Capitol Police / Jaylen Lewis Manslaughter Trial Update W/ Scott Gilbert episode artwork

EPISODE · Mar 23, 2026 · 5 MIN

Capitol Police / Jaylen Lewis Manslaughter Trial Update W/ Scott Gilbert

from The Clay Edwards Show · host Clay Edwards

In this timely trial update from The Clay Edwards Show, defense attorney Scott Gilbert — who just secured Ted DiBiase Jr.’s acquittal — sits down with Clay to break down the latest in the high-profile Capitol Police manslaughter case involving officer Michael Rhinewalt and Jalen Lewis.   Gilbert reveals the cases have now been consolidated and are set for trial in May. Without discussing specific evidence, he explains the unusual charging theory in the indictment: the officers reasonably believed they were in imminent danger when Lewis drove his vehicle toward them, yet prosecutors argue that belief was unreasonable — a rare legal concept called “imperfect self-defense” normally used only as a jury instruction to reduce murder to manslaughter.   He walks through key use-of-force principles: how a vehicle can legally be treated as a deadly weapon, why officers (or any citizen) don’t have to wait until they’re physically struck to defend themselves, and why this indictment is so uncommon. Clay shares his strong view that the officers were fully justified, drawing parallels to similar vehicle attacks nationwide.   A clear, no-spin look at self-defense law, vehicle-as-weapon cases, and one of Mississippi’s most watched police incidents heading into trial. Essential listening for anyone interested in law enforcement accountability, use-of-force rulings, or criminal justice in the state.  

In this timely trial update from The Clay Edwards Show, defense attorney Scott Gilbert — who just secured Ted DiBiase Jr.’s acquittal — sits down with Clay to break down the latest in the high-profile Capitol Police manslaughter case involving officer Michael Rhinewalt and Jalen Lewis.   Gilbert reveals the cases have now been consolidated and are set for trial in May. Without discussing specific evidence, he explains the unusual charging theory in the indictment: the officers reasonably believed they were in imminent danger when Lewis drove his vehicle toward them, yet prosecutors argue that belief was unreasonable — a rare legal concept called “imperfect self-defense” normally used only as a jury instruction to reduce murder to manslaughter.   He walks through key use-of-force principles: how a vehicle can legally be treated as a deadly weapon, why officers (or any citizen) don’t have to wait until they’re physically struck to defend themselves, and why this indictment is so uncommon. Clay shares his strong view that the officers were fully justified, drawing parallels to similar vehicle attacks nationwide.   A clear, no-spin look at self-defense law, vehicle-as-weapon cases, and one of Mississippi’s most watched police incidents heading into trial. Essential listening for anyone interested in law enforcement accountability, use-of-force rulings, or criminal justice in the state.

NOW PLAYING

Capitol Police / Jaylen Lewis Manslaughter Trial Update W/ Scott Gilbert

0:00 5:06

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of The Clay Edwards Show?

This episode is 5 minutes long.

When was this The Clay Edwards Show episode published?

This episode was published on March 23, 2026.

What is this episode about?

In this timely trial update from The Clay Edwards Show, defense attorney Scott Gilbert — who just secured Ted DiBiase Jr.’s acquittal — sits down with Clay to break down the latest in the high-profile Capitol Police manslaughter case involving...

Can I download this The Clay Edwards Show episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!