Caught Stealing (2025): Cats, Crimes, and Chaos

In this episode of Reel It In, Will and Tucker head to 90s New York for Darren Aronofsky’s Caught Stealing. Based on the cult novel, the film follows Hank Thompson (Austin Butler) whose life spirals out of control after he agrees to watch his neighbor’s cat.We dig into the film’s gritty setting, Aronofsky’s bold directorial choices, and how the tone swings between dark comedy and brutal violence—drawing comparisons to Tarantino and the Coen Brothers. From Butler’s lead performance to Zoe Kravitz and the standout supporting cast, we break down the film’s character work and cinematic style.Plus: our predictions for how Caught Stealing will be received, the moments that stuck with us most, and a quick look at upcoming releases we’re excited about.Instagram: @reelitinpodTikTok: @reelitinpod