Cole Payton Draft Evaluation | Athletic FCS QB

We’re breaking down North Dakota State quarterback Cole Payton, one of the most intriguing dual-threat quarterbacks in the 2026 NFL Draft class. After spending multiple seasons in a versatile, Taysom Hill–style role, Payton took over as a full-time starter in 2025 and delivered an efficient, explosive season.This film study covers Payton’s deep-ball accuracy, touch and ball placement, timing versus defensive leverage, off-script creativity, athleticism as a runner, and areas that could limit his projection at the next level. We finish with strengths, weaknesses, and a final draft grade based on his 2025 tape.Let us know your thoughts on Cole Payton as an NFL prospect in the comments.Chapters:Touch & Ball PlacementTiming & AnticipationOff-Script AbilityAthleticism & QB Run GameThrowing Motion EvaluationFinal NFL Draft Grade