Comfort TV, Real Stakes

Peter and Aubrey each share their five all-time favorite TV shows — and discover an accidental through line. Three of Peter's five were created by Mike Schur, and nearly every pick on both lists is about people helping each other become better. They talk about why "prestige TV" doesn't appeal to them (too stressful), why comedy doesn't have to be mindless to be meaningful, and how these shows reflect a belief that community — not individualism — is what makes us human.Show NotesAubrey's #1 — Friends: Classic background show; jokes that didn't age well somehow got funnier for it. Peter's counterpoint: "Why are you all such dill holes to each other?" Friends on MaxPeter's #1 — Avatar: The Last Airbender: The show that started his thematic through line — a group helping Aang defeat the Fire Lord without killing him, centered on Zuko's redemption. "If you won't watch it because it's a cartoon, get over yourself." ATLA on NetflixThe Good Place (both ranked it #2): Aubrey lost her mind at the season 1 twist. Peter notes the real thesis — not just that people can improve, but that people help each other improve — and that Mike Schur consulted T.M. Scanlon's What We Owe to Each Other and real ethicists to build the premise. The Good Place on NetflixAubrey's #3 — New Girl: Quotable Schmidt, secondhand embarrassment from the awkward humor. Peter couldn't get into it — "I don't have ADHD, but watching it I feel like I have ADHD." New Girl on HuluPeter's #3 — Ted Lasso: Season 1 is the comfort-food classic, but Peter defends seasons 2-3 as necessary for the arcs — Ted, Roy, Jamie, Rebecca — to land. The scene where Rebecca confesses why she hired Ted gets called one of the most powerful moments in television. Ted Lasso on Apple TV+Aubrey's #4 — WandaVision: Rewatched during night shifts as a nurse. Loves the hidden details that pop on rewatch (Vision noting no children in Westview, children everywhere next episode). Still the strongest Marvel Disney+ series in her book. WandaVision on Disney+Peter's #4 — Brooklyn 99: Captain Raymond Holt (the late André Braugher) is the greatest TV character ever created. Peter defends the controversial final season — "I respect it more because it had the nerve to go there" — and cites the Terry Jeffords racial profiling episode as something the show had to address. Brooklyn 99 on PeacockAubrey's #5 — Game of Thrones: Love-hate. Loves fantasy and high stakes, hates that it's "bummer after bummer." The Red Wedding broke her. She has exactly one character she still considers morally good. GoT on MaxPeter's #5 — A Man on the Inside: The third Mike Schur pick. Ted Danson plays a retired professor who goes undercover in a retirement community and reconnects with his daughter and with life after his wife's death. Season 2 deepens the same theme: connection is the antidote to isolation. A Man on the Inside on NetflixWhy No "Prestige TV": Peter avoids Breaking Bad, The Wire, Sopranos — "bad people being bad" is too stressful when your day job already is. Aubrey agrees and distinguishes high-stakes fantasy from realistic misery.Community Over Individualism: Aubrey rants about transactional culture (friends expecting Venmo for airport pickups). Peter counters with a real story — his work team showed up by the dozens to pack up a nurse's house during a crisis, no questions asked, no expectations. That's the world these shows are pointing at.