How Plato's Atlantis Became a Modern Myth: The Real Story Behind the Legend episode artwork

EPISODE · Jul 3, 2026 · 16 MIN

How Plato's Atlantis Became a Modern Myth: The Real Story Behind the Legend

from Elsewhere · host Tyler Cooper

Think Atlantis is just ancient mythology? Think again. In this episode, Tyla Cooper reveals how a 2,400-year-old philosophical tale transformed into the 19th century's most profitable pseudoscience, complete with bestselling books, psychic channeling, and maps drawn by wishful thinking. 🎯 What You'll Learn: • Why Ignatius Donnelly's 1882 book sold over 50 editions by convincing Americans that Atlantis explained everything from pyramids to Native American civilizations • How Heinrich Schliemann's real discovery of Troy in the 1870s accidentally launched a treasure hunting craze for "lost" civilizations • The surprising connection between the Theosophical Society's psychic leaders and modern Atlantis mythology (spoiler: they claimed to channel Atlantean wisdom directly) • Why those Victorian-era Atlantis maps were completely wrong, based on outdated ocean measurements and a hefty dose of confirmation bias 👤 Perfect for: anyone who's ever wondered how ancient philosophy becomes modern conspiracy theory, and history buffs curious about how legitimate archaeology gets twisted into profitable fiction. 📍 Chapters: [00:00] Tyla Cooper introduces Plato's original Atlantis story [01:45] How the discovery of Troy changed everything [03:30] Ignatius Donnelly turns mythology into bestselling "science" [06:15] The Theosophical Society's psychic Atlantis claims [08:00] Why Victorian maps got the Atlantic Ocean completely wrong [10:30] How ancient wisdom became modern wishful thinking 🔔 Never miss an episode: Follow Elsewhere on Spotify or Apple Podcasts and turn on notifications. New episodes drop daily, your next favorite insight is one tap away. 🔍 Topics: Atlantis mythology, Plato philosophy, Victorian pseudoscience, Heinrich Schliemann Troy, Theosophical Society ------ Keywords: international stories, news breakdown, world news, current events, current affairs, global affairs, global perspective, international conflicts Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Think Atlantis is just ancient mythology? Think again. In this episode, Tyla Cooper reveals how a 2,400-year-old philosophical tale transformed into the 19th century's most profitable pseudoscience, complete with bestselling books, psychic channeling, and maps drawn by wishful thinking. 🎯 What You'll Learn: • Why Ignatius Donnelly's 1882 book sold over 50 editions by convincing Americans that Atlantis explained everything from pyramids to Native American civilizations • How Heinrich Schliemann's real discovery of Troy in the 1870s accidentally launched a treasure hunting craze for "lost" civilizations • The surprising connection between the Theosophical Society's psychic leaders and modern Atlantis mythology (spoiler: they claimed to channel Atlantean wisdom directly) • Why those Victorian-era Atlantis maps were completely wrong, based on outdated ocean measurements and a hefty dose of confirmation bias 👤 Perfect for: anyone who's ever wondered how ancient philosophy becomes modern conspiracy theory, and history buffs curious about how legitimate archaeology gets twisted into profitable fiction. 📍 Chapters: [00:00] Tyla Cooper introduces Plato's original Atlantis story [01:45] How the discovery of Troy changed everything [03:30] Ignatius Donnelly turns mythology into bestselling "science" [06:15] The Theosophical Society's psychic Atlantis claims [08:00] Why Victorian maps got the Atlantic Ocean completely wrong [10:30] How ancient wisdom became modern wishful thinking 🔔 Never miss an episode: Follow Elsewhere on Spotify or Apple Podcasts and turn on notifications. New episodes drop daily, your next favorite insight is one tap away. 🔍 Topics: Atlantis mythology, Plato philosophy, Victorian pseudoscience, Heinrich Schliemann Troy, Theosophical Society ------ Keywords: international stories, news breakdown, world news, current events, current affairs, global affairs, global perspective, international conflicts Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

NOW PLAYING

How Plato's Atlantis Became a Modern Myth: The Real Story Behind the Legend

0:00 16:54

No transcript for this episode yet

We transcribe on demand. Request one and we'll notify you when it's ready — usually under 10 minutes.

No similar episodes found.

No similar podcasts found.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is this episode of Elsewhere?

This episode is 16 minutes long.

When was this Elsewhere episode published?

This episode was published on July 3, 2026.

What is this episode about?

Think Atlantis is just ancient mythology? Think again. In this episode, Tyla Cooper reveals how a 2,400-year-old philosophical tale transformed into the 19th century's most profitable pseudoscience, complete with bestselling books, psychic...

Can I download this Elsewhere episode?

Yes, you can download this episode by clicking the download button on the episode player, or subscribe to the podcast in your preferred podcast app for automatic downloads.
URL copied to clipboard!