just now

[Linkpost] “Practically A Book Review: Appendix to ‘Nonlinear’s Evidence: Debunking False and Misleading Claims’” by Rafael Harth

Listen to this episode

0:00 / 0:00

Summary

First published

01/03/2024

Genres

business

Duration

51 minutes

Parent Podcast

Effective Altruism Forum Podcast

View Podcast

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

  • Effective altruism in a nutshell

    04/12/2021

    The 80000 Hours team

    'Effective Altruism: An Introduction' is a collection of ten top episodes of The 80,000 Hours Podcast specifically selected to help listeners quickly get up to speed on the school of thought known as effective altruism.Here the host of the show — Rob Wiblin — briefly explains what effective altruism is all about, and what to expect from the rest of this series.

    Clean
  • Effective altruism in a nutshell

    10/04/2021

    80000 Hours

    Effective Altruism: Ten Global Problems is a collection of ten top episodes of the 80,000 Hours Podcast, designed to bring you up to speed on ten pressing issues the effective altruism community is working to solve.Here the host of the show — Rob Wiblin — briefly explains what effective altruism is all about, and what to expect from the rest of this series.

    Clean
  • Effective Altruism

    11/14/2023

    In this episode, we consider Effective Altruism, the cool younger brother of Utilitarianism. Effective Altruism provides another lens through which to consider what health equity demands of us, and leads to some interesting conclusions when thinking about American inequities in a global context. This episode features interviews with Dr. Brian Berkey of the University of Pennsylvania, and Jack Lewars of OneForTheWorld.

    Clean
  • Ten: Benjamin Todd on the core of effective altruism and how to argue for it

    04/12/2021

    The 80000 Hours team

    Is effective altruism just about donating money to fight poverty? Does it include a moral obligation to give? How do you talk about it to people who've never heard of it? In this conversation from 2020, Arden Koehler and 80,000 Hours CEO Ben Todd cover a bunch of topics related to effective altruism. We also have an article on misconceptions about effective altruism – based on Will MacAskill’s paper The Definition of Effective Altruism – and this episode can act as a companion piece.Full transcript, related links, and summary of this interviewThis episode first broadcast on the regular 80,000 Hours Podcast feed on September 21, 2020. Some related episodes include:• #75 – Michelle Hutchinson on what people most often ask 80,000 Hours• Benjamin Todd on varieties of longtermism and things 80,000 Hours might be getting wrong (80k team chat #2)• Benjamin Todd on what the effective altruism community most needs (80k team chat #4)Series produced by Keiran Harris.

    Clean

Similar Podcasts

  • Podmax Podcast: Let's Talk About Movies

    08/15/2020

    Podmax Podcast

    A podcast dedicated to the love of movies, the good and bad.

    Clean
  • Nonprofit Leadership Podcast

    08/12/2020

    Rob Harter

    The Nonprofit Leadership Podcast: Making Your World Better features discussions covering the most critical issues, trends and opportunities facing nonprofit leaders and those engaged in social innovation. Hosted by Dr. Rob Harter, in this podcast you will hear real stories from experienced leaders about what strategies and practices have made them successful. It is our hope that through this audio series, people can learn not only what it takes to be an effective non-profit leader but to hear inspiring stories about people and organizations that are successfully making a positive impact in their communities. Enjoy the show!

    Clean
  • Cedar Valley Young Adults Podcast

    08/11/2020

    CVC Young Adults Podcast

    Cedar Valley Church's Young Adult Ministry Podcast, in Bloomington, MN

    Clean
  • One Piece Podcast

    08/11/2020

    No es otro estúpido podcast

    El único podcast de One Piece en castellano.Entra, escúchanos y diviértete con este programa dedicado exclusivamente a la maravillosa serie de One Piece. Una maravillosa aventura de piratas y corsarios que no te dejará indiferente.Teorías locas, curiosidades, resúmenes y monográficos es lo que os encontrareis en este canal.¡Suscríbete y recomiéndanos a tus amigos!Blog:https://podcastonepiece.wordpress.comTwitter: https://twitter.com/PodcastOnePieceFacebook:https://www.facebook.com/podcastonepiece

    Clean
  • STAR WARS The Vintage Rebellion Podcast

    08/11/2020

    The Star Wars Vintage Rebellion Podcast - SWTVR - Podcast Team

    The Star Wars Vintage Rebellion Podcast is brought to you by five vintage Star Wars Toy collectors. The team discuss vintage star wars collectibles, recent threads and stories from across social media and forums, the current vintage market, oddball items, as well as covering stories that have been rocking the vintage collecting community. There are also interviews with all types of collector as well as an events section where you can discover Star Wars events in your area. All this plus much much more, so download this podcast now!

    Clean
  • PeloTonOfFun

    08/17/2020

    PeloTonOfFun Podcast

    A pro cycling podcast by American husband and wife super fans Ryland & Emily Lu Aldrich.

    Clean
  • AMERICA OUT LOUD PODCAST NETWORK

    08/12/2020

    AMERICA OUT LOUD PODCAST NETWORK

    Your Source for Free Speech, Talk Radio, Podcasts, and News - America Out Loud is home to expert columnists, talk show hosts, and national commentators - Here we take on the challenges of our generation so that we can preserve future generations.

    Clean
  • Podcast – Teenager Lesben-Podcast

    08/15/2020

    Hey Ihr da draussen,dies ist ein Podcast für schwule und lesbische Teenager.

    Clean
  • CriticaAme Podcast

    08/15/2020

    Crítica Americanista

    Podcast by Crítica Americanista

    Clean
  • MSPoweruser Podcast

    08/16/2020

    MSPoweruser

    Welcome to the MSPoweruser podcast! This is THE podcast for the Microsoft enthusiast and power user. We discuss the latest news about Microsoft, Windows 10, Windows Phone, Xbox and everything Microsoft!

    Clean
  • HeBrews Podcast

    08/11/2020

    A podcast from HeBrews Fort Wayne covering music, faith, and culture.

    Clean
  • NFgametime's Podcast

    08/11/2020

    NFgametime

    Gametime med Nikko och Fernan är en Podcast där vi spelar tv-spel och pratar om allt som faller oss in. Vi är en blandning av humor, nörderi och galenskap.http://www.nfgametime.blogg.se/

    Clean

Episode Description

A summary of the Nonlinear situation from a third-person perspective, by Ozy Brennan. I find it to be thoughtful, well-written, and well-researched enough to be part of the conversation. It was also posted on LessWrong.

Edit: full text included below (with permission from the author). I had to reformat a lot so assume all formatting errors are done by me.

About a week ago, I became one of a small, elite group—people who have read every single goddamn word of Nonlinear's Evidence: Debunking False and Misleading Claims. I read the appendix. I read the appendixes to the appendix. I have spent more time thinking about whether a complete stranger got a vegan burger than any person should.

If you just want to make up your own mind, I suggest reading The General Situation and referring to Dramatis Personae when you get confused who is who. If you like drama [...]

---

Outline:

(02:00) How We Got Here

(03:46) Dramatis Personae

(05:20) Ben's Credibility

(07:39) Kat Woods's Credibility

(11:30) The General Situation

(12:59) Enmeshment

(17:44) Finances

(23:22) Isolation

(25:17) The Drug Situation

(27:34) Specific Situations

(27:37) The Vegan Burger Situation

(29:21) The Driving Situation

(31:21) Speculation About Drugs

(32:42) Alice's Credibility

(36:09) The Saga of Alice's Incubated Organization

(41:58) The Saga of Emerson Spartz's Previous Business Life

(45:14) Could Nonlinear Employ People?

(48:50) Takeaways

The original text contained 16 footnotes which were omitted from this narration.

---

First published:
January 3rd, 2024

Source:
https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/RdiQ3n8cFJBxHRnwu/practically-a-book-review-appendix-to-nonlinear-s-evidence-1

Linkpost URL:
https://thingofthings.substack.com/p/practically-a-book-review-appendix

---

Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO.

Discussion (0)

Be respectful and constructive in your comments

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts about this episode!