just now

More than Meets the Eye: The Murder of Barbara Stoppel

Barbara Gayle Stoppel, a 16-year-old waitress, was tragically murdered on December 23, 1981, in the women's washroom of Ideal Donut Shop in Winnipeg, Manitoba. She was strangled with a twine, and despite being found alive, she succumbed to her injuries after six days on life support. The murder case quickly became notorious not only due to its brutal nature but also because of the wrongful conviction of Thomas Sophonow, who was initially accused of the crime. Sophonow underwent three separate trials: the first ended with a hung jury, and the second and third led to convictions ultimately overturned by the Manitoba Court of Appeal. The Supreme Court of Canada refused to hear a Crown appeal, leading to Sophonow's final acquittal. This case is frequently cited as a significant example of a miscarriage of justice involving flawed eyewitness identifications and police misconduct during the interrogation process. Despite Sophonow's exoneration, the actual perpetrator remained at large until a re-investigation of the case pointed to another suspect, Terry Arnold, who was already known to police for similar offences, having left a trail of depravity, sexual assaults and suspected murder in his wake. This revelation came too late to be pursued thoroughly, as Arnold died by suicide in 2005. The impact of this case has been profound, leading to public scrutiny over police procedures and the reliability of eyewitness testimony. It has also been the subject of several books and a public inquiry which sought to prevent such injustices in the future.

First published

04/29/2024

Genres:

history

culture

documentary

true crime

Summary

Episode 315: Barbara Gayle Stoppel, a 16-year-old waitress, was tragically murdered on December 23, 1981, in the women's washroom of Ideal Donut Shop in Winnipeg, Manitoba. She was strangled with a twine, and despite being found alive, she succumbed to her injuries after six days on life support. The murder case quickly became notorious not only due to its brutal nature but also because of the wrongful conviction of Thomas Sophonow, who was initially accused of the crime. Sophonow underwent three separate trials: the first ended with a hung jury, and the second and third led to convictions ultimately overturned by the Manitoba Court of Appeal. The Supreme Court of Canada refused to hear a Crown appeal, leading to Sophonow's final acquittal. This case is frequently cited as a significant example of a miscarriage of justice involving flawed eyewitness identifications and police misconduct during the interrogation process. Despite Sophonow's exoneration, the actual perpetrator remained at large until a re-investigation of the case pointed to another suspect, Terry Arnold, who was already known to police for similar offences, having left a trail of depravity, sexual assaults and suspected murder in his wake. This revelation came too late to be pursued thoroughly, as Arnold died by suicide in 2005. The impact of this case has been profound, leading to public scrutiny over police procedures and the reliability of eyewitness testimony. It has also been the subject of several books and a public inquiry which sought to prevent such injustices in the future. Sources: barbstoppel.com Thomas Sophonow | Innocence Canada City of Winnipeg 1984 CanLII 2912 (MB CA) | R. v. Sophonow | CanLII 1984 CanLII 3811 (MB CA) | R. v. Sophonow (No.1) | CanLII 1986 CanLII 104 (MB CA) | R. v. Sophonow (No.2) | CanLII 1999 CanLII 6576 (BC SC) | R. v. Arnold | CanLII 2001 BCCA 374 (CanLII) | R. v. Arnold | CanLII 2005 BCCA 611 (CanLII) | R. v. Arnold | CanLII Body of suspect in Winnipeg killing found in Victoria Drifter Thomas Sophonow Inquiry Letter of Apology to Tom Sophonow 1bpm85fqb_903420 Stoppel Exclusive: Thirty years later, survivor details encounter with serial killer Terry Arnold Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Duration

Parent Podcast

Dark Poutine - True Crime and Dark History

View Podcast

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

    HEX - File 0053 - Mike Browne, Master of Madness and Mayhem

    Release Date: 11/26/2021

    Description: Our hosts chat with very special guest, Mike Browne host and creator of Dark Poutine, a podcast about Canadian true crime and dark history, as well as host on Supernatural Circumstances and now author of Murder, Madness and Mayhem

    Explicit: Yes

    Bonus Episode: Travel Update & Jack Luna of Dark Topic Interview (MB)

    Release Date: 08/24/2018

    Description: As we aren't talking about a full case we're calling this Bonus Episode 1. Mike and Scott chat about Mike's recent cross country trip and Mike gives the Dark Poutine related details of his journey. The last half of the episode is Mike speaking with Jack Luna of Dark Topic about his show, podcasting, true crime and some tough life experiences. We'll be back next week with our regular fare.Shout outs to:https://darktopicpodcast.com/https://www.nighttimepodcast.com/https://canadiantruecrime.ca/http://trailwentcold.com/http://www.insightpod.com/https://mindsofmadnesspodcast.com/https://www.truecrimegarage.com/http://www.alreadygonepodcast.com/https://36times.podbean.com/http://leftbehind.blubrry.net/https://thespoopfiles.podbean.com/http://themarblegarden.libsyn.com/http://thesaltycanadian.libsyn.com/https://crime709.podbean.com/ Support the show: https://www.patreon.com/darkpoutine Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Explicit: Yes

    Introducing Dead On: A True Crime Podcast

    Release Date: 10/29/2020

    Description: Do you love unravelling a good old fashioned whodunnit? Oh, honey. Me too. I’m Elisha, armchair detective and host of Dead On: A True Crime Podcast. Join me every Friday. We’ll dive into a case that scratches your itch for true crime, dark history, and mystery. Streaming now, everywhere you love to listen.Support the Show.

    Explicit: Yes

    Update: Stanley Park’s Babes in the Woods Identified

    Release Date: 01/22/2024

    Description: Episode 301: In episode thirteen of Dark Poutine, we covered the Babes in the Woods case, a tragic and long-unsolved mystery from Vancouver. In 1953, the skeletal remains of two children were discovered in Stanley Park, one of Vancouver's largest urban parks. What made this case, particularly haunting was that the children were found with a hatchet that appeared to have been used to end their lives. The identities of the two children remained unknown for almost 70 years until, in 2022, using DNA genealogy, the Vancouver Police were able to identify the boys believed to have died sometime in 1947. They were seven-year-old Derek and six-year-old David D'Alton. Their mother, Eileen Bousquet, who died in 1996, told relatives at the time that social services had taken the boys as she was unable to care for them. No one knows for sure what happened leading up to their deaths, and as so much time has passed, it is doubtful we ever will. At least they have their names back. Sources: Stanley Park — City of Vancouver Murder, Mystery and Intrigue in Review: Babes in the Woods 166: Hate Crime: The Murder of Aaron Webster – Dark Poutine – True Crime & Dark History Six Officers Plead Guilty To Stanley Park Beatings 2004 BCPC 1 (CanLII) | R. v. Cronmiller | CanLII Unsolved Stanley Park ‘Babes in the Woods’ case still haunts a city Interview with Brian Honeybourn 69UMBC — The Doe Network 68UMBC — The Doe Network VPD hopes genealogical testing can help solve cold case - Vancouver Police Department VPD identifies child victims in historic cold case murder - Vancouver Police Department Babes in the Woods: Vancouver police release identities, details about historic murders - VIA Identities of Stanley Park Babes in the Woods revealed almost 70 years later Who were the Babes in the Woods? Eileen Bousquet Archives — evelazarus.com Cold Case BC by Eve Lazarus Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    Explicit: Yes

Similar Podcasts

    Killer Occult

    Release Date: 12/22/2021

    Authors: Adam Dawson

    Description: Podcast covering true crime and dark history as well as cryptids, UFOlogy and anything dark, disturbing or just plain weird.

    Explicit: Yes

    The Dark Chronicles Podcast

    Release Date: 03/05/2021

    Authors: Ojani Cabrera & Michelle Esquivel

    Description: Your weekly fix of dark topics such as true crime, the supernatural, and history.

    Explicit: Yes

    Mad Hatters Club

    Release Date: 01/01/2022

    Authors: Mad Hatters Club Pod

    Description: Two girls talking about whatever strange, dark history and true crime topics they find interesting.

    Explicit: Yes

    Monday Mornings with Maddy and Morgan

    Release Date: 04/28/2021

    Authors: Monday Mornings with Maddy and Morgan

    Description: A podcast bringing you dark history, true crime, spooky facts, & plenty of laughs, every Monday morning!

    Explicit: Yes

    Freaky AF

    Release Date: 09/27/2021

    Authors: Syrai Fernando

    Description: FREAKY AF is a casual, spooky podcast that covers topics ranging from true crime, dark history, conspiracy theories, etc...

    Explicit: Yes

    Dead Headspace

    Release Date: 09/08/2020

    Authors: Patrick R. McDonough

    Description: A podcast highlighting the best content by writers, reviewers, and creators in the Horror, Dark Fantasy,Dark Scifi, & True Crime genres.

    Explicit: Yes

    Batas Akhir

    Release Date: 08/12/2020

    Authors: Eguh

    Description: Professional Crime • Harmony in Technology • Romantic Thriller • Dark History

    Explicit: Yes

    Happy Hour Gets Weird

    Release Date: 08/17/2020

    Authors: Cassie and Tiffany

    Description: Cassie and Tiffany get together and talk true crime, paranormal stories, and weird history while sipping craft cocktails. NSFW! Sometimes dark, sometimes funny - always weird! 21+CHEERS!

    Explicit: Yes

    What The Fear Podcast

    Release Date: 08/06/2020

    Authors: What the Fear Podcast

    Description: A Podcast about all things dark: true crime, paranormal, and oddities! Hosted by Inkie & Gwyn

    Explicit: Yes

    Violent Ends

    Release Date: 08/23/2020

    Authors: Violent Ends

    Description: Unique tales of true crime, dark history, and the paranormal. Host Jenn Carpenter takes the cases she covers seriously. Herself? Not so much. (Formerly known as So Dead.)

    Explicit: Yes

    Death Dames Podcast

    Release Date: 08/17/2020

    Authors: Death Dames

    Description: Each week, we cover your favorite dark and creepy stories, and pick apart the weird science and history behind them. True Crime/Science/History/Comedy Podcast. Hosted by Kimberly Baker, Lila Dunk, and Allyson Nemec.

    Explicit: Yes