EPISODE · Jun 5, 2026 · 35 MIN
Quadruple Homicide - The Pelley Murders
from Doubt in the details · host Fowsia
In April 1989, the small community of Lakeville, Indiana woke to a crime that shattered its sense of safety. Inside the Pelley family home, four people were found dead. The murders would become one of the most debated cases in the Indiana’s history. Detectives took immediate interest in Jeff, the son. “Jeff was the only one unaccounted for. That made him our starting point.” Cold case investigator Martin Ryans explained. But a starting point is not evidence. And in this case, the gap between suspicion and proof would become the center of a debate that continues to this day.Music by: Ashot Danielyan Tiktok: @doubtinthedetails
What this episode covers
In April 1989, the small community of Lakeville, Indiana woke to a crime that shattered its sense of safety. Inside the Pelley family home, four people were found dead. The murders would become one of the most debated cases in the Indiana’s history. Detectives took immediate interest in Jeff, the son. “Jeff was the only one unaccounted for. That made him our starting point.” Cold case investigator Martin Ryans explained. But a starting point is not evidence. And in this case, the gap be...
NOW PLAYING
Quadruple Homicide - The Pelley Murders
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.