EPISODE · May 12, 2026 · 7 MIN
The Grey Door at Cedar Hollow Motel
from Rooms We Don't Open — Fexingo Horror · host Fexingo
In the summer of 2007, I stayed at the Cedar Hollow Motel off Route 9 in upstate New York — a place that should have been forgotten decades ago. The lock on door 11 didn't work, so they moved me to room 14. That's where I met the man in the grey coat. He wasn't a guest, and he wasn't staff. He told me about the door at the end of the east wing — the one painted a different colour. The one that didn't lead to a room. I didn't open it, not that night. But I watched, and I listened, and I learned why the motel's vacancy sign never blinks after midnight. This is a story about a hallway that shouldn't exist, a door that leads nowhere, and the sound of a key turning in a lock that has no keyhole. It's about what happens when you check in but can never check out. And it's about the grey man who sits in the office, waiting for someone to ask the wrong question. #CedarHollowMotel #Route9 #UpstateNewYork #GreyDoor #Room14 #MotelHorror #Summer2007 #Midnight #VacancySign #GreyCoat #KeyInLock #DoorThatShouldntExist #Luna #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #RoomsWeDontOpen #AnthologyHorror #SlowBurnHorror #HouseHorror #DoorwayHorror Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
What this episode covers
In the summer of 2007, I stayed at the Cedar Hollow Motel off Route 9 in upstate New York — a place that should have been forgotten decades ago. The lock on door 11 didn't work, so they moved me to room 14. That's where I met the man in the grey coat. He wasn't a guest, and he wasn't staff. He told me about the door at the end of the east wing — the one painted a different colour. The one that didn't lead to a room. I didn't open it, not that night. But I watched, and I listened, and I learned why the motel's vacancy sign never blinks after midnight. This is a story about a hallway that shouldn't exist, a door that leads nowhere, and the sound of a key turning in a lock that has no keyhole. It's about what happens when you check in but can never check out. And it's about the grey man who sits in the office, waiting for someone to ask the wrong question. #CedarHollowMotel #Route9 #UpstateNewYork #GreyDoor #Room14 #MotelHorror #Summer2007 #Midnight #VacancySign #GreyCoat #KeyInLock #DoorThatShouldntExist #Luna #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #RoomsWeDontOpen #AnthologyHorror #SlowBurnHorror #HouseHorror #DoorwayHorror Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
NOW PLAYING
The Grey Door at Cedar Hollow Motel
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.