EPISODE · Jun 4, 2026 · 6 MIN
The Swimming Hole at the End of Old Mill Road
from Cul-de-Sac — Fexingo Horror · host Fexingo
It was July of 1999 when my friend Danny and I found the swimming hole. Not the one everyone knew about, but another one—hidden off Old Mill Road, past the no-trespassing signs, through a break in the fence that someone had cut. The water was darker than it should have been, and the trees leaned in too close. Danny said it was perfect. He went in first. I sat on the bank and watched him disappear under the surface. He came back up smiling, but something about the way the water rippled behind him didn't feel right. For a week we kept going back. And every time, the hole felt deeper. The air felt colder. The silence between words stretched longer. This is the story of what lived at the bottom of that swimming hole, and what it cost us to find out. #SwimmingHole #OldMillRoad #Danny #1999 #Summer #SomethingInTheWater #HiddenPlace #FenceCut #DarkWater #Submerged #Pull #SmallTown #Indiana #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #CulDeSac #Episode31 #Anthology Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
What this episode covers
It was July of 1999 when my friend Danny and I found the swimming hole. Not the one everyone knew about, but another one—hidden off Old Mill Road, past the no-trespassing signs, through a break in the fence that someone had cut. The water was darker than it should have been, and the trees leaned in too close. Danny said it was perfect. He went in first. I sat on the bank and watched him disappear under the surface. He came back up smiling, but something about the way the water rippled behind him didn't feel right. For a week we kept going back. And every time, the hole felt deeper. The air felt colder. The silence between words stretched longer. This is the story of what lived at the bottom of that swimming hole, and what it cost us to find out. #SwimmingHole #OldMillRoad #Danny #1999 #Summer #SomethingInTheWater #HiddenPlace #FenceCut #DarkWater #Submerged #Pull #SmallTown #Indiana #FexingoHorror #HorrorPodcast #CulDeSac #Episode31 #Anthology Keep every episode free: buymeacoffee.com/fexingo
NOW PLAYING
The Swimming Hole at the End of Old Mill Road
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.