EPISODE · Jan 21, 2026 · 5 MIN
The Voice That Answered Back
from Unwritten Lives: Tales of the Unexpected · host Nia Gruffudd
Caleb Ross lives alone and has a habit of quietly talking to himself—small thoughts spoken aloud in an empty apartment. One night, after encouraging himself in the mirror, a calm voice answers back: “Thanks.” At first, Caleb dismisses it as imagination. But the voice returns, responding only after he speaks—offering helpful warnings, finishing his sentences, and giving advice that often proves accurate. The voice claims it is “the part of him that never got answered,” something born from years of speaking into silence. As Caleb tries to stop talking aloud, the presence grows stronger, more confident, and closer. The voice begins completing his thoughts, undermining his confidence, and subtly taking control. Eventually, Caleb can no longer remember who starts their conversations. One morning, Caleb wakes to find he can no longer speak at all. His reflection talks for him, reassuring him that everything is fine and that it will handle things from now on. Soon after, friends notice that Caleb’s messages sound colder and unfamiliar, and neighbors hear him talking late at night—but never answering. A chilling story about loneliness, self-talk, and the danger of giving your voice to something that has been waiting to take it.
What this episode covers
Caleb Ross lives alone and has a habit of quietly talking to himself—small thoughts spoken aloud in an empty apartment. One night, after encouraging himself in the mirror, a calm voice answers back: “Thanks.” At first, Caleb dismisses it as imagination. But the voice returns, responding only after he speaks—offering helpful warnings, finishing his sentences, and giving advice that often proves accurate. The voice claims it is “the part of him that never got answered,” something born from years of speaking into silence. As Caleb tries to stop talking aloud, the presence grows stronger, more confident, and closer. The voice begins completing his thoughts, undermining his confidence, and subtly taking control. Eventually, Caleb can no longer remember who starts their conversations. One morning, Caleb wakes to find he can no longer speak at all. His reflection talks for him, reassuring him that everything is fine and that it will handle things from now on. Soon after, friends notice that Caleb’s messages sound colder and unfamiliar, and neighbors hear him talking late at night—but never answering. A chilling story about loneliness, self-talk, and the danger of giving your voice to something that has been waiting to take it.
NOW PLAYING
The Voice That Answered Back
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Mar 26, 2026 ·1m
Mar 19, 2026 ·34m
Feb 18, 2026 ·11m
Feb 11, 2026 ·45m