EPISODE · May 8, 2026 · 36 MIN
To Buy or Lease a Car | EP069
from Playbook of the Wealthy · host Playbook of the Wealthy
The buy vs. lease debate is older than the cars themselves, and most people pick wrong because they never run the math. The right answer depends on the brand, the miles, and what you actually do with the car when the term ends.In this Playbook of the Wealthy episode, financial advisors Heather Townsend of Townsend Financial and Dave Grant of Retirement Matters break down when leasing wins, when buying wins, and the exact framework Heather uses with clients. Heather walks through a real lease vs. buy comparison on a $100K Porsche Macan, the 6,000-lb SUV depreciation play for business owners, and the BMW maintenance trap that turned her from a lifelong leaser into a buyer. Dave shares the frugal-to-Tesla journey, why he gave his 16-year-old the family Chevy Malibu, and how a switch in insurance brokers cut his auto premium in half.▶ Listen on Apple, Spotify, or visit https://playbookotw.com★ WHAT YOU'LL LEARN ★▸ The mileage cap question that kills most leases before the conversation even starts▸ Why a BMW out of warranty is the most expensive "deal" in the driveway▸ How leasing actually works as a rental, including what's covered, what's not, and what you owe at turn-in▸ Why customizing a leased car (tints, body kits) almost never pays you back▸ Why Porsches are the rare luxury car that can make more sense to buy than lease▸ The 6,000-lb SUV bonus depreciation play for business owners driving 50%+ for work▸ The buy-vs-lease math on a $100K Macan over six years▸ Why "leasing all four cars" with four drivers in the house is almost always the wrong answer▸ How adding a teen driver impacts insurance, and what a good broker can do about it▸ The decision framework Heather uses with clients: mileage, then brand, then math★ CHAPTERS ★00:00 Cold open: a $17,000 BMW maintenance bill and the question that won't go away01:09 Welcome: the buy vs. lease debate that never dies01:54 Why this question comes up so much (and why Heather is "the car girl")03:05 Lease basics: it's a rental, not ownership03:58 The mileage cap that kills most leases before they start05:36 Maintenance under warranty: lease's quietly biggest value06:57 Customizing a leased car (and the body kit you'll never see again)08:16 The pros and cons of leasing, summarized08:33 Why getting out of a lease is harder than getting out of a marriage09:27 Heather's lease story: $5K, age 16, and a "Beemer Check" plate13:06 Business owners: the 6,000-lb SUV depreciation play14:43 The pros and cons of buying outright16:48 Longer payment terms and the trade-in trap18:42 You buy it, you own it, you fix it18:53 Buy vs. lease math on a $100K Porsche Macan21:25 Dave's frugal years: used cars until kids forced new23:40 Trump, EV credits, and the day after the Tesla call25:03 The decision framework: mileage, then brand, then math26:18 Q&A: $120K sports car, lease or buy?27:34 Q&A: 4 drivers, 4 cars, should I lease them all?31:14 Highlights: the day Eli got his license (and our insurance bill)33:09 Highlights: a one-car household and the tariff that killed the GT 6336:07 Wrap up★ LISTEN ON ANY PLATFORM ★Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/playbook-of-the-wealthy/id1787630097Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/21LrI3IB2wMsOOJLiGsRJKWebsite: https://playbookotw.com★ WATCH NEXT ★The 5 DIY Money Mistakes That Quietly Cost You Years | EP065: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s4zprAatOtoDividends Are Lying To You: The Outdated Retirement Income Strategy | EP066: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3B5rw6VPSU★ CONNECT ★Submit a question for a future episode: https://playbookotw.comEmail: [email protected] Grant on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davegrant82Heather Townsend on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/heather.townsend.financial#BuyVsLease #CarBuying #PlaybookOfTheWealthy
What this episode covers
The buy vs. lease debate is older than the cars themselves, and most people pick wrong because they never run the math. The right answer depends on the brand, the miles, and what you actually do with the car when the term ends.In this Playbook of the Wealthy episode, financial advisors Heather Townsend of Townsend Financial and Dave Grant of Retirement Matters break down when leasing wins, when buying wins, and the exact framework Heather uses with clients. Heather walks through a real lease vs. buy comparison on a $100K Porsche Macan, the 6,000-lb SUV depreciation play for business owners, and the BMW maintenance trap that turned her from a lifelong leaser into a buyer. Dave shares the frugal-to-Tesla journey, why he gave his 16-year-old the family Chevy Malibu, and how a switch in insurance brokers cut his auto premium in half.▶ Listen on Apple, Spotify, or visit https://playbookotw.com★ WHAT YOU'LL LEARN ★▸ The mileage cap question that kills most leases before the conversation even starts▸ Why a BMW out of warranty is the most expensive "deal" in the driveway▸ How leasing actually works as a rental, including what's covered, what's not, and what you owe at turn-in▸ Why customizing a leased car (tints, body kits) almost never pays you back▸ Why Porsches are the rare luxury car that can make more sense to buy than lease▸ The 6,000-lb SUV bonus depreciation play for business owners driving 50%+ for work▸ The buy-vs-lease math on a $100K Macan over six years▸ Why "leasing all four cars" with four drivers in the house is almost always the wrong answer▸ How adding a teen driver impacts insurance, and what a good broker can do about it▸ The decision framework Heather uses with clients: mileage, then brand, then math★ CHAPTERS ★00:00 Cold open: a $17,000 BMW maintenance bill and the question that won't go away01:09 Welcome: the buy vs. lease debate that never dies01:54 Why this question comes up so much (and why Heather is "the car girl")03:05 Lease basics: it's a rental, not ownership03:58 The mileage cap that kills most leases before they start05:36 Maintenance under warranty: lease's quietly biggest value06:57 Customizing a leased car (and the body kit you'll never see again)08:16 The pros and cons of leasing, summarized08:33 Why getting out of a lease is harder than getting out of a marriage09:27 Heather's lease story: $5K, age 16, and a "Beemer Check" plate13:06 Business owners: the 6,000-lb SUV depreciation play14:43 The pros and cons of buying outright16:48 Longer payment terms and the trade-in trap18:42 You buy it, you own it, you fix it18:53 Buy vs. lease math on a $100K Porsche Macan21:25 Dave's frugal years: used cars until kids forced new23:40 Trump, EV credits, and the day after the Tesla call25:03 The decision framework: mileage, then brand, then math26:18 Q&A: $120K sports car, lease or buy?27:34 Q&A: 4 drivers, 4 cars, should I lease them all?31:14 Highlights: the day Eli got his license (and our insurance bill)33:09 Highlights: a one-car household and the tariff that killed the GT 6336:07 Wrap up★ LISTEN ON ANY PLATFORM ★Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/playbook-of-the-wealthy/id1787630097Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/21LrI3IB2wMsOOJLiGsRJKWebsite: https://playbookotw.com★ WATCH NEXT ★The 5 DIY Money Mistakes That Quietly Cost You Years | EP065: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s4zprAatOtoDividends Are Lying To You: The Outdated Retirement Income Strategy | EP066: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3B5rw6VPSU★ CONNECT ★Submit a question for a future episode: https://playbookotw.comEmail: [email protected] Grant on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davegrant82Heather Townsend on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/heather.townsend.financial#BuyVsLease #CarBuying #PlaybookOfTheWealthy
NOW PLAYING
To Buy or Lease a Car | EP069
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
No similar episodes found.
Similar Podcasts
No similar podcasts found.