Gunsmoke: Old West Stories

Originally Aired: July 24, 1960 Gunsmoke #433, "The Imposter," begins with a weary Chester struggling to keep up with Marshal Matt Dillon on a simple trip to the telegraph office. When they stop to help Sarah Curtin load her wagon, they encounter her husband Rob, who seems strangely uninvolved. The encounter takes on new significance when Matt receives a confusing telegram from Sheriff Ab Stringer of Miami, Texas, announcing he's bringing in a prisoner and needs help. However, when Stringer arrives on the afternoon stage, he's alone. The affable lawman explains the telegram was garbled, but his mission is deadly serious: he's tracking Sam Fraser, a bank robber and murderer he believes is hiding somewhere in Dodge under an assumed name. The challenge facing Matt and Stringer is formidable. Fraser is a sandy-haired man around thirty years old, a description that fits half the men in Dodge. With no wanted poster to aid their search and Fraser's talent for deception, identifying the killer becomes a game of observation and instinct. As Stringer mingles with locals at the Long Branch, Matt begins to wonder if the manhunt might be closer to home than anyone suspects.

Originally Aired: July 17, 1960 Gunsmoke #432, "Busted-Up Guns," Matt Dillon and Chester head north to the Sioux reservation for a friendly visit with Indian Agent Whip and his wife Gladys, expecting a peaceful hunting trip and warm welcome. Instead, they're met on the trail by Big Feather and his braves, who conduct a suspicious search of their gear and cryptically direct all questions to the white agent. When they arrive at the agency, they find the once-thriving settlement eerily deserted, with lodges falling into disrepair and residents hiding inside. Inside the locked agency house, they discover a drastically changed Whip, armed with a shotgun, drinking heavily, and consumed by paranoia. He has confiscated all the Indians' weapons and keeps them locked in the storeroom under constant guard, forcing Gladys to stand watch when he cannot. Whip bitterly claims the Sioux are no longer human and cannot be trusted, while a distraught Gladys confides that her husband has become a stranger to her. As mysterious explosions like dynamite echo across the reservation, Matt and Chester realize something has gone terribly wrong on the agency.

Originally Aired: July 10, 1960 Gunsmoke #431, "Reluctant Violence," presents a thought-provoking conflict when an elderly pacifist named Homer Lidley arrives in Dodge City on a dangerous mission. Homer travels from town to town advocating for citizens to voluntarily give up their guns, believing that mankind must abandon violence or face destruction. His passionate street preaching quickly provokes trouble when angry cowboys knock him down and kick him, outraged by his radical ideas. Marshal Matt Dillon intervenes and takes Homer to Doc Adams for treatment of his injuries. Despite his injuries and Matt's warnings, Homer remains committed to his cause, explaining he witnessed the horrors of the Siege of Atlanta and believes guns offer no real protection. Matt sympathizes with Homer's idealism but insists the frontier is still too raw and lawless for such ideas to take hold. Meanwhile, two suspicious men named Lou and Hare begin asking Chester questions about Homer's whereabouts, claiming to be friends wanting to visit him. Their interest in locating the pacifist and his sack of gold suggests Homer may face an even greater threat than simple frontier hostility.

Originally Aired: July 3, 1960 Gunsmoke #430, "Little Girl," Matt Dillon and Chester respond to a prairie fire and discover a grim scene at an isolated homestead. Inside the burned cabin, they find a man who died in the blaze, seemingly drunk and alone. As they investigate the desolate property with its starving horses and neglected buildings, a young girl emerges from the creek bed. Ten-year-old Charity Gill explains that the dead man was her stepfather, and she tried to pull him from the fire but couldn't move him. She matter-of-factly tells Matt she didn't like her stepfather and has been living in neglect since her mother's death three years ago. Doc examines Charity and finds her physically healthy but disturbingly mature for her age, shaped by years of isolation and hardship. As Matt tries to find proper placement for the orphaned girl, Charity insists she wants to live with him, putting the marshal in an uncomfortable position. The investigation raises unsettling questions about the fire and the little girl's peculiar detachment from the tragedy that has left her alone in the world.

Originally Aired: June 26, 1960 Gunsmoke #429, "Line Trouble," begins when Jasper Foss reports to Marshal Matt Dillon that the new telegraph line west of Dodge has been cut. Matt and Chester investigate and discover Army soldiers repairing the damage and holding a Kiowa man named Smallhawk under guard. The Indian admits to cutting the wire, believing it to be bad magic that carries evil sounds across his people's land. Matt, who knows Smallhawk as no troublemaker, convinces Colonel Hooper to release the prisoner into his custody, promising to take responsibility and show Smallhawk that the telegraph can be good magic instead of bad. To prove his point, Matt takes Smallhawk to the telegraph office and sends a message to the Indian encampment, instructing Smallhawk's son Brown Wing to bring a horse to meet his father outside town. The demonstration aims to change Smallhawk's fear of the wire and prevent future trouble. Meanwhile, the bitter Jasper Foss, recently fired from his job for being too old, lurks in the background with cryptic warnings about Matt needing to watch out and do a good job.

Originally Aired: June 12, 1960 Gunsmoke #427, "Kitty Accused," finds Kitty Russell facing an unwelcome complication on what should be a simple stagecoach trip to Fort Learned. After a late night at the Long Branch, Kitty prepares to visit her friend Sally, who has just had a baby. Marshal Matt Dillon sees her off, but the journey takes a troubling turn when Arnie Grimes and his bitter wife Hattie board the same stage. Arnie has been making persistent unwanted advances toward Kitty around Dodge City, much to his wife's fury, and Hattie makes no secret of her resentment toward the saloon owner she sees as a threat to her marriage. As the uncomfortable journey progresses, tensions mount inside the cramped stagecoach. Arnie continues his inappropriate attention despite Kitty's clear rejections and Hattie's sharp rebukes. The situation grows increasingly volatile as Hattie's jealousy and Arnie's obsession collide, trapping Kitty in the middle of a dangerous domestic conflict with nowhere to escape on the long road to Fort Learned.

Originally Aired: June 5, 1960 Gunsmoke #426, "Fabulous Silver Extender," finds Chester holding down the fort while Matt Dillon transports a prisoner to Have City. Into the marshal's absence walks the nervous Professor Albert Cramston, a self-proclaimed metallurgical researcher who claims the San Francisco silver syndicate has put a price on his head. Eight hired killers are supposedly tracking him down for ten thousand dollars, though he can't identify any of them. Chester promises to keep watch, but the real mystery begins when local shopkeepers Wilbert and Durgum notice the peculiar professor borrowing dimes at the Long Branch saloon, then mysteriously returning with silver dollars to repay them. Following Cramston to Wilbert's recently sold shop, the curious pair discovers him working with strange machinery by lantern light. When they attempt to apprehend him as suspicious, Chester intervenes, forcing an uneasy introduction between the frightened professor and the would-be captors. Cramston, satisfied they aren't foreign agents or syndicate killers, prepares to reveal his closely guarded secret to the three men, provided they're willing to die to protect it for the good of their country.

Originally Aired: May 29, 1960 Gunsmoke #425, "Bad Seed," finds Marshal Matt Dillon on his way back to Dodge from Fort Larnard when an unexpected visitor enters his camp. A young woman named Trudy Trent, claiming to be starving and desperate, begs the marshal not to send her back to her father. She paints a dark picture of life with her Pa, describing him as a violent drunk who mistreats her terribly. Despite her pleas and increasingly inappropriate advances, Matt insists on taking her home the next morning. When they arrive at the ramshackle Trent farm, Matt meets Asa Trent, a slovenly drunk who alternates between professing affection for his daughter and threatening the marshal. The tension at supper is thick as Trudy recounts disturbing incidents from her past, including a Christmas when her drunken father accidentally set her on fire. Convinced that the girl's situation is genuinely dire, Matt agrees to take Trudy back to Dodge with him despite Asa's threats and warnings. But as Matt settles into the barn loft for the night, he senses something isn't quite right about the whole situation.

Originally Aired: May 22, 1960 Gunsmoke #424, "Marryin Bertha," Marshal Matt Dillon finds himself dealing with an unusual problem when his deputy Chester Proudfoot confesses to a reckless mistake. Suffering from spring fever and feeling romantic, Chester has been writing letters to lonely women advertising in St. Louis newspapers, stretching the truth about himself and even sending one woman Matt's photograph instead of his own. Now a widow named Corinne Gatesley has arrived in Dodge expecting to marry Chester, and the panicked deputy begs Matt to impersonate him and send her away. When Matt meets the imposing Mrs. Gatesley, a woman taller than Chester and built like the Marshal himself, he discovers Chester's letters promised her he had money coming his way. The situation turns dangerous when Doc Adams recognizes Matt's description of the woman. She may actually be Bertha Hoskowitz, a woman once suspected of marrying and murdering several men for their money in St. Louis, though authorities could never prove it. With Chester having foolishly promised wealth he doesn't have, Matt realizes the deputy may have made himself the target of a cold-blooded killer.

Originally Aired: May 15, 1960 Gunsmoke #423, "Tall Trapper," presents Marshal Matt Dillon with a puzzling murder case when Doc Adams discovers a woman beaten to death in a covered wagon east of Dodge. The victim, Cassie Riley, had been traveling west with her husband Riley in hopes the dry climate would improve her failing health. When Doc arrives to treat her, he finds she's already dead from a brutal beating. Riley tells Doc and Matt about a mysterious trapper who shared their camp for two nights, eyeing Cassie the whole time, making him the obvious suspect. The case takes an unusual turn when Matt and Chester ride out to the murder scene and discover the body has been moved to a Pawnee burial platform high on wooden poles. There they encounter Ben, a laconic trapper raised by the Pawnees who admits to burying Cassie in the traditional elevated grave. Though Ben denies killing her and could have easily shot Matt and Chester before they drew on him, the evidence looks damning. As Matt brings Ben to jail and confronts the grieving Riley with his wife's suspected killer, the truth behind Cassie's death remains murky.

Originally Aired: May 8, 1960 Gunsmoke #422, "Wrong Man different story from #135," Marshal Matt Dillon receives a warning from lawman Blair about a dangerous killer named Jim Waddell who may be passing through Dodge City. Waddell is described as a smooth-talking, well-dressed man who never carries a gun but prefers to kill with a knife. Meanwhile, a charming stranger calling himself Jack Norman arrives in town and makes an immediate impression on Kitty Russell with his cultured manners and polite behavior, a refreshing change from the rough cowboys she usually encounters. When Norman gets into a poker dispute and pulls a knife to defend himself against accusations of cheating, Matt becomes suspicious and decides to hold him in jail. The situation grows more complicated as Matt notices the striking similarities between Norman and Blair's description of the wanted killer Waddell. Both men are refined, well-mannered, knife-carrying Texans who avoid firearms. Despite Kitty's protests that Jack couldn't be a murderer and Norman's own insistence that Matt is making a grave mistake, the marshal keeps him locked up while waiting to hear back from Blair about the suspect's true identity.

Originally Aired: May 1, 1960 Gunsmoke #421, "Nettie Sitton," Marshal Matt Dillon and Chester find themselves in desperate circumstances after a renegade Ute ambush leaves Matt badly wounded with a bullet in his leg. Fevered and unable to ride, Matt must be dragged through the wilderness by Chester toward what appears to be an abandoned cabin. However, the cabin is anything but abandoned. They're met by Nettie Sitton, a hardened frontier woman wielding a shotgun, who immediately demands their money and guns in exchange for shelter. Nettie is no ordinary settler. She's a woman who's buried four husbands and twenty children, and she makes it clear that a couple of strangers don't faze her one bit. Despite her rough exterior and mercenary demands, she removes the bullet from Matt's leg and allows them to recover in her cabin. As Matt fights fever and Chester stands exhausted watch, the threat of the renegade Utes lingers nearby, and the marshal and his deputy must rely on this formidable woman's grudging hospitality to survive.

Originally Aired: April 24, 1960 Gunsmoke #420, "Stage Snatch," finds Marshal Matt Dillon delivering a dangerous prisoner named Rouse to Hayes City for trial when their stagecoach is stopped by Bigfoot, a Native American leader, and his son Younghawk. Rouse murdered Bigfoot's father, and the grieving son believes the killer's life belongs to him, not to white man's justice. Despite Dillon's assurances that Rouse will likely hang after trial, Bigfoot refuses to let the law handle the matter and takes both the marshal and his prisoner captive. As they're forced to march across the prairie toward the tribal encampment, the situation grows increasingly tense. Rouse, roped to a horse and struggling with the brutal trek, whines and complains while Dillon maintains his composure despite having his hands tied. Though Dillon has always been friends with Bigfoot and promises him justice through the legal system, the Native American leader remains determined to hold his own council trial, creating a dangerous standoff between frontier justice and tribal honor.

Originally Aired: April 17, 1960 Gunsmoke #419, "Solomon River," presents Marshal Matt Dillon and Chester with a grim discovery along the riverbank while transporting prisoner Ben Crown to Dodge. The lawmen encounter Letty Thatcher, a woman nearly dead from exhaustion, desperately trying to dig a grave for her husband Luther in the punishing prairie heat. Inside her isolated cabin, they find Luther's body has been lying dead for days while Letty, too weak to bury him, has slowly been starving. Despite Dillon's urging to come with them to Dodge City where he can help her start over, Letty refuses to leave. She reveals the heartbreaking reason for her stubborn determination: buried near Luther's fresh grave are five small mounds, the graves of her babies who died during their years of hardship on the desolate prairie. The lawmen reluctantly continue their journey with Crown, leaving Letty alone at her homestead. Chester remains troubled by her situation, leading him to seek Doc's help in obtaining a tonic, though the deputy's awkward attempts to keep Letty's identity secret frustrate the physician.

Originally Aired: April 10, 1960 Gunsmoke #418, "Daves Lesson," Marshal Matt Dillon takes on an unexpected responsibility when his old friend Joe Barrett and Joe's wife Lydia die suddenly from fever, leaving their teenage son Dave orphaned. At the request of Joe's brother Will, Matt agrees to take fifteen or sixteen-year-old Dave under his wing for the summer, giving the boy a chance to get away and heal. When Kitty Russell teases Matt about finally becoming a family man, he brushes off her comments, insisting it's just what the boy needs. However, when Dave arrives on the Dodge City stage, Matt quickly discovers this won't be as simple as he thought. Dave Barrett proves to be a headstrong young man determined to prove himself as tough and capable with guns. He boasts about his shooting skills, insists he doesn't need anyone watching over him, and clearly idolizes gunfighters who wear two pistols. Left in Chester's care while Matt rides to Hays City, Dave bristles at doing mundane tasks and keeps insisting that a real lawman's deputy should be wearing a gun and ready for action. Chester struggles to manage the cocky teenager, and it becomes clear that Dave needs to learn some hard lessons about what it really means to be a man.

Originally Aired: April 3, 1960 Gunsmoke #417, "Greater Love," finds Marshal Matt Dillon investigating a deadly stagecoach robbery that leaves a shotgun guard dead and two bandits wounded. The trail leads to the homestead of Howard Brandt and his wife, where Matt discovers that the gentle, easy-going young settler he once met has turned outlaw. One of the wounded bandits left for dead at his own doorstep, Howard clings to life while his wife tries desperately to protect him from Matt's questions. She reluctantly reveals that Jeb Butler and a man named Blake lured her husband into the holdup, and that the gang rode off after dumping the dying Howard in the dirt. When Doc Adams mysteriously disappears after being summoned on an emergency call, Kitty becomes alarmed. Days pass with no word, and Matt fears the worst. His suspicions are confirmed when Mrs. Brandt returns to town with her husband's body, her face bruised and battered. She brings devastating news: Jeb Butler has Doc tied up and held captive, and the situation grows more dangerous by the hour as Matt races to find his friend before it's too late.

Originally Aired: March 27, 1960 Gunsmoke #416, "Indian Baby," finds Marshal Dillon investigating a troubling situation when Doc Adams and Kitty discover a nearly unconscious white woman lying on the prairie, clutching an infant. The woman, later identified as Dory, is suffering from severe exhaustion and exposure, but what makes the case peculiar is that she's a white woman holding an Indian baby. When Matt questions her, Dory insists the child is hers and speaks frantically about savages killing her baby and her missing husband Joe. Doc believes she may have kidnapped the infant. Matt and Chester ride out to a nearby Indian camp to get answers, where they meet with Hawkwing, who reveals the truth behind the tragedy. The old chief explains that Dory's own baby died of fever, and his people buried the child while trying to help the grieving mother. In her confused state of grief, Dory wandered into the night and took one of their babies. Now the young braves are out hunting, and Hawkwing warns there will be trouble if the child isn't returned before they come back. Matt must somehow help Dory face the painful reality of her loss before the situation escalates into violence.

Originally Aired: March 20, 1960 Gunsmoke #415, "The Constable," finds Marshal Dillon in a difficult position after cracking down on unruly cowboys from a trail drive. When trail boss Rance threatens to boycott Dodge City after five of his men are buffaloed and jailed, the town's businessmen panic. Led by Mr. Green, they pressure Dillon to ease up on enforcement, prioritizing commerce over law and order. The marshal, employed by the federal government rather than the town, refuses to compromise but agrees to stop making arrests in Dodge until the townspeople ask for his help. To handle local disturbances, the businessmen hire a replacement: Dillard Band, a broke, overweight former cowboy who doesn't even carry a gun and hopes to talk troublemakers into behaving. As new cattle herds arrive and chaos erupts in the streets, Dillon and Chester wait in the marshal's office while the inexperienced, unarmed constable faces increasingly violent cowboys. When Doc Adams bursts in reporting deaths and injuries throughout town, the situation reaches a crisis point, forcing everyone to confront the consequences of choosing profit over proper law enforcement.

Originally Aired: March 13, 1960 Gunsmoke #414, "Unloaded Gun," finds Marshal Matt Dillon returning to Dodge City exhausted and feverish after a four-day manhunt. During the chase, Matt killed Red Lyme following a holdup, though the details of exactly what happened remain unclear. When Matt arrives back in town, he barely acknowledges Kitty and Doc Adams, stumbling straight to his office where he collapses without even removing his muddy boots. Doc diagnoses a fever and gives him sleeping powder, while his deputy Chester notices Matt's gun belt has been carelessly dropped in the corner, covered in mud—highly unusual for the normally meticulous marshal. As Matt sleeps off his fever, word reaches the Long Branch Saloon that Joe Lyme, Red's brother, has returned to Dodge City with vengeance on his mind. Joe is openly declaring his intention to kill Marshal Dillon for his brother's death. Meanwhile, Chester begins cleaning Matt's neglected gun, and a boy arrives claiming Doc needs Chester's help holding down an injured man. The stage is set for a deadly confrontation, but Matt remains unconscious in his office, unaware of the threat gathering against him.

Originally Aired: March 6, 1960 Gunsmoke #413, "Blood Money," finds Marshal Matt Dillon and Chester searching for water on the prairie when they encounter a wary stranger named Joe Harp holding them at gunpoint. Harp's suspicion quickly fades when he realizes he needs their help. He's discovered an injured man named Harry Spiner, whose horse has thrown him and broken his leg. Despite Spiner's ungrateful and surly attitude, Harp has dragged him to shade and stayed to help. Matt and Chester transport both men back to Dodge, where Doc tends to Spiner's injury. Over the following weeks, Harp lingers in town gambling but causing no trouble, while the recovered Spiner proves himself thoroughly unlikable to everyone he meets. When a wanted poster arrives identifying Joe Harp as a bank robber and murderer with a $500 reward, Matt reluctantly prepares to arrest the man who seemed decent enough. But Chester accidentally reveals the news to Spiner, who rushes off to warn Harp. What follows forces Matt to confront the ugly truth about gratitude, betrayal, and the real meaning of blood money when one man sees an opportunity to profit from another's kindness.

Originally Aired: February 28, 1960 Gunsmoke #412, "Prescribed Killing," presents a chilling domestic drama on the Kansas prairie. Myra Kirby arrives in Dodge City with a disturbing message for Marshal Matt Dillon: her husband Luke is going to kill her. Living in isolation on their horse ranch, Myra has grown bitter and resentful of Luke's devotion to his horses and his visits to the Widow Holland, a neighbor woman whose husband recently died. The tension between the couple has escalated to the point where Myra tells Matt she simply wanted him to know what's coming, so he'll know what to do afterwards. Luke confirms the marital strife when Matt confronts him, cryptically saying his wife is living with devils and there's nobody who can help except him. The situation grows more ominous when Luke warns the Marshal that no one can stop what's happening, and that only he can deal with it. Just as Matt finishes speaking with Luke, Doc Adams arrives with grave news: he's already been out to the Kirby place that morning, and Myra has been badly hurt. The stage is set for Matt to uncover the dark truth behind this troubled marriage.

Originally Aired: February 21, 1960 Gunsmoke #411, "Mr.and Mrs Amber," When Marshal Matt Dillon catches Neil Amber stealing seeds from Jonas' store, he takes pity on the desperate sodbuster and pays for the supplies himself. Amber and his wife are struggling to survive on their small patch of land near Pawnee Wells, plagued by one disaster after another. However, Dillon's mercy becomes complicated when cattleman Pete Fletcher arrives at the marshal's office demanding justice. Fletcher's rider has discovered a stolen, slaughtered calf in the Ambers' shed, killed while Neil was in town. Fletcher wants Mrs. Amber arrested immediately. When Dillon investigates, he finds Mrs. Amber distraught at being accused of theft, claiming she only discovered the calf in her shed by accident. Despite Fletcher's insistence and his rider Baird's testimony, Dillon refuses to make an arrest, citing insufficient evidence. Fletcher leaves with an ominous warning that next time, he and his men will handle the matter themselves without involving the law, leaving the marshal to worry about the escalating tension between the struggling homesteaders and the powerful cattleman.

Originally Aired: February 14, 1960 Gunsmoke #410, "Distant Drummer," features Raffi, a simple-minded Civil War veteran who wears his drum proudly around his neck, a gift from his captain at Antietam. When Raffi seeks refuge in the Long Branch from taunting townspeople, Miss Kitty shows him compassion and kindness, offering him work chopping wood while she watches over his precious drum. Doc Adams suggests that perhaps the drum is the last thing Raffi was ever proud of, though it makes him a constant target for the town's cruelty. When a concerned citizen named Dobie urges Marshal Dillon to take action against Raffi as a potential troublemaker, Matt refuses, pointing out that any trouble would come from those tormenting the harmless veteran. The situation escalates when Chester alerts Matt that some men have treed Raffi at the livery stable, dangling his beloved drum from a branch and forcing him to crawl out for it. Raffi falls and is injured, prompting Doc to treat him while Matt confronts the tormentors. As Raffi recovers, he speaks ominously about folks needing to learn different, leaving Matt concerned about what the traumatized drummer might do next.

Originally Aired: February 7, 1960 Gunsmoke #409, "Delias Father," Marshal Matt Dillon seeks shelter at a remote ranch during a storm while transporting prisoner Keel and dealing with a lame horse. He's surprised to find the ranch now occupied by Delia Robbins, daughter of his old friend Ben. Delia welcomes Matt warmly, remembering how highly her father spoke of him. When she offers to guide Deputy Chester Festus to town so he can telegraph the judge about their delay, telegraph operator Mr. Weems drops a bombshell: the whole town knows that Matt Dillon killed Ben Robbins. Delia is stunned by this revelation about the man she just welcomed into her home. The storm has trapped Matt at the ranch with the shocked young woman and his dangerous prisoner. As the truth about Ben Robbins' death begins to surface, Matt must confront a painful chapter from his past while maintaining control of a volatile situation. The marshal's friendship with Ben and the circumstances of his death promise to create an explosive confrontation.

Originally Aired: January 31, 1960 Gunsmoke #408, "Chester's Dilemma," Chester finds himself the object of affection from Edna, a young store clerk working for Mr. Jonas who transforms from a wilted shopgirl into a radiant companion each afternoon at closing time. The pretty but mysterious woman, who Jonas suspects is hiding something about her farm upbringing in Ohio, begins accompanying Chester on his daily mail runs from the depot. She clings to his arm, flatters his bravery, and shows unusual interest in the marshal's correspondence, particularly the wanted circulars and official letters. Meanwhile, Doc McGee diagnoses Chester with a different ailment: he's become listless and distracted, neglecting his duties at the marshal's office. Doc suggests to Matt Dillon that Chester feels unappreciated, but the real cause of Chester's preoccupation becomes clear when Edna kisses him on Front Street and takes a particular interest in a letter from Ohio. As Chester struggles between his duties and this new romance, Edna's secretive behavior and her focus on the marshal's mail hint at complications ahead for Dodge City's lovesick deputy.

Originally Aired: January 24, 1960 Gunsmoke #407, "Bless Me Till I Die," Matt Dillon and Chester encounter Cole and Beth Ann Treadwell on the trail to Dodge City when the couple's wagon breaks down. Cole is a traveling preacher—though not ordained or properly schooled—and the Treadwells are wandering from town to town looking for the right place to settle. Matt suggests Dodge could use a parson, and soon the couple is holding prayer meetings in the town schoolhouse, quickly becoming beloved members of the community. Chester grows particularly attached to the Treadwells, escorting Beth Ann to services and losing checker games to Cole. However, trouble arrives in the form of Nate Bush, a troublemaker with a grudge against Chester for getting him thrown in jail. When Nate confronts Chester while he's escorting Beth Ann to a prayer meeting, the situation grows tense. Beth Ann tries to defuse the conflict, urging Chester not to fight, but Nate's drunken bullying continues. The confrontation escalates when Nate corners Beth Ann alone at the general store, creating a dangerous situation that threatens the peaceful atmosphere the Treadwells have brought to Dodge.

Originally Aired: January 17, 1960 Gunsmoke #406, "Fiery Arrest," finds Matt Dillon and Chester caught in a violent rainstorm and taking shelter in an abandoned shack. Their refuge turns dangerous when two armed men, Hod Mueller and Mosley, get the drop on them. The suspicious Hod is convinced that someone tipped off the law about his whereabouts, and when a woman named Millie arrives with supplies, he's certain she's the one who betrayed him. Despite her desperate denials, Hod viciously beats her while a helpless Matt can only watch. The outlaws tie up Matt, Chester, and Millie before riding out to rob a stagecoach, leaving their captives to struggle free. Once loose, Matt sends Chester back to Dodge with the badly injured Millie while he pursues the outlaws alone through the storm. The confrontation in the rocks plays out with deadly consequences, and Matt returns to town to check on Millie's recovery. Under Doc Adams and Kitty's care, the battered woman begins a long healing process, but the physical wounds may prove easier to mend than the deeper scars left by Hod Mueller's brutal treatment.

Originally Aired: January 10, 1960 Gunsmoke #405, "Lukes Law," presents a clash between frontier justice and modern law enforcement. When old-timer Luke Burris is beaten and left bloody by Smed Moley following a public confrontation in Dodge City, his son Jess comes to Marshal Matt Dillon seeking help. Luke refuses to press charges, insisting he's always handled his own troubles without the law and isn't about to start now. Despite Matt's warnings that times have changed, the stubborn pioneer remains determined to settle the score himself, leaving the Marshal powerless to intervene without a willing witness. The situation escalates when Smed Moley, emboldened by Luke's refusal to involve the law, begins bragging around town about the beating. Matt confronts Moley at the Long Branch and warns him to stay away from the Burris place, but the damage is done. When Moley rides out to the Burris homestead looking for more trouble, young Jess faces an impossible choice between his father's fierce independence and the deadly consequences of frontier justice. The episode explores the tensions between the old ways of the West and the rule of law that Marshal Dillon represents.

Originally Aired: January 3, 1960 Gunsmoke #404, "Trojan War," finds Marshal Matt Dillon confronting the notorious Pueblo gang when they arrive in Dodge City. The trio of outlaws, Ed and Rio Parks and Chuck Evans, have a fearsome reputation for stage robberies throughout the western territories, and Dillon wastes no time warning them to keep their noses clean in his town. When the gold dust shipment stage from Buckeye fails to arrive on schedule, the marshal's suspicions are confirmed. He and Chester discover the robbed stagecoach with the driver and guard shot dead, the strongbox emptied, and a woman's carpetbag inside with no sign of its owner. Following the killers' trail through the darkening wilderness, Matt and Chester track the gang to an abandoned campsite where they make a grim discovery. They find Helen Ford, a female passenger from the stage, shot and left for dead by the fleeing outlaws. As the dying woman struggles to identify her attackers, Dillon faces the challenge of bringing the ruthless Pueblo gang to justice for robbery and murder.

Originally Aired: December 27, 1959 Gunsmoke #403, "Puckets New Year," Marshal Matt Dillon and Chester are returning to Dodge City after a brutal blizzard when they discover an abandoned buffalo hunter's camp. They find an elderly hunter named Ira Puckett hiding in a wagon, badly injured and half-frozen after being abandoned by his skinner, Jed Larner, who rode off when the storm approached rather than help his crippled partner. Puckett threatens Matt and Chester at gunpoint, desperate not to be left behind again, but the marshal brings him safely to town where Doc Adams must amputate part of his frozen foot. The operation saves Puckett's life but ends his buffalo hunting days, leaving the proud old man bitter and consumed with thoughts of vengeance against Larner. Despite Matt's warnings and attempts to help him adjust to town life, Puckett refuses to let go of his rage. When the marshal finally spots a scarred man matching Larner's description in the Long Branch saloon weeks later, the situation threatens to explode into deadly confrontation as Puckett's thirst for revenge collides with Matt's duty to prevent murder.

Originally Aired: December 20, 1959 Gunsmoke #402, "Beekers Barn," finds Marshal Matt Dillon facing a tense family conflict on a bitter cold Christmas Eve. When rancher Jethro Beeker storms into the marshal's office demanding that trespassers be thrown off his property, Matt discovers the "criminals" are Will Ross and Harmony, Jethro's own daughter whom he disowned two years earlier when she married Will. The young couple, caught in a snowstorm while traveling, sought shelter in Beeker's barn out of desperation. When Matt and Chester arrive at the ranch, they find Will armed and defensive, protecting Harmony in the tack room where he's made her a bed of straw and blankets. The situation grows more urgent when Matt discovers why the couple so desperately needs shelter: Harmony is about to give birth. As Doc Adams is summoned through the snowstorm and the stubborn Jethro refuses to acknowledge his daughter's plight, the marshal must navigate between an unforgiving father and a frightened young couple facing the arrival of their child on one of the coldest nights of the year.

Originally Aired: December 13, 1959 Gunsmoke #401, "Don Mateo," Matt Dillon's past comes calling when Don Esteban, an old friend from his days riding the Mexican border, arrives in Dodge City looking for him. The reunion at the Long Branch starts with warmth and nostalgia as the two men reminisce about their dangerous adventures together, hunting outlaws in territory where they made their own law. But Esteban hasn't come just to visit. He's tracking a man named Rallo who has wronged his Maria, and he wants Matt to ride with him like the old days. Matt faces an impossible choice between loyalty to his friend and his duty as a U.S. Marshal. When he refuses to join the hunt and warns Esteban that he'll have to come after him if he kills Rallo, the Mexican sadly observes that his old partner no longer has "the enjoyment." The tension escalates when Chester brings word that Doc is treating a wounded dirt farmer, shot by a rider in Mexican outfit. Matt must now confront whether his old friend has crossed the line from the borderlands justice they once shared to cold-blooded murder.

Originally Aired: December 6, 1959 Gunsmoke #400, "Big Chugg Wilson," a seemingly innocent flirtation between saloon girl Lori and a rough buffalo hunter spirals into violence and obsession. When the unwashed and lonely Chugg Wilson rides into Dodge City to sell his hides, Lori playfully teases him at the Long Branch, much to the concern of Roque, a ranch hand who has feelings for her. Kitty Russell warns Lori that she might be attracting more attention than she intends, but Lori dismisses the danger, insisting she's just having fun. She promises Chugg a drink later, not realizing how seriously he takes her casual attention. When Chugg returns that evening expecting Lori to keep her promise, the situation turns dark. Lori tries to brush him off, explaining she was only teasing, but Chugg refuses to accept her rejection. When Roque attempts to defend Lori and escort her home, the massive buffalo hunter becomes violent, leaving Roque badly hurt and claiming Lori for himself. What began as playful banter transforms into a dangerous confrontation that threatens everyone involved.

Originally Aired: November 29, 1959 In Gunsmoke #399, "Hard Lesson," a desperate young man named Joe Belvin faces an impossible choice when his outlaw brother Pete comes home mortally wounded from a bank robbery. Pete has returned seeking their mother's healing touch, only to learn she died a year ago. With Pete bleeding badly and refusing a doctor for fear of the law, Joe rides into Dodge City to strike a deal with Marshal Matt Dillon. The naive farm boy believes that returning the stolen money will square everything with the law and save his brother, but he receives a hard lesson when Matt tells him Pete would still have to stand trial regardless. Frustrated and angry that the law won't help his dying brother, Joe returns home and hides Pete before Doc Adams arrives. When Matt and Chester ride out to investigate, they find blood but no patient, as Joe stubbornly refuses any assistance that might bring the law down on Pete. The young man is determined to protect his brother at any cost, even as Pete grows weaker and mentions his outlaw partners, Lo and Raleigh, who aren't far away. Joe must now decide whether his misguided loyalty will lead to more tragedy or whether he'll accept the hard truth about justice and the law.

Originally Aired: November 22, 1959 Gunsmoke #398, "Paid Killer," finds Marshal Matt Dillon facing a deadly threat when old Billy overhears a sinister conversation in the livery stable. Two men discuss a contract killing—one offering a thousand dollars in gold to have Dillon murdered, and the other accepting the job. Though Billy couldn't identify the voices in the darkness, Matt and Chester soon trace the money to Lawson Hale, a businessman whose schemes Matt has repeatedly thwarted. Now Hale has hired an unknown gunman, and the killer could be anyone among the strangers in Dodge. For two tense days, Matt refuses to hide, walking the moonlit streets despite Chester's protests and his own admission that waiting for an unseen assassin frays the nerves. When Matt confronts Hale at the Long Branch saloon and tries to goad him into making his own play, the cowardly schemer refuses to take the bait. That night, a muzzle flash from the shadows finally announces the killer's presence, but after one shot, the gunman vanishes into the darkness, leaving Matt to wonder when and where he'll strike next.

Originally Aired: November 15, 1959 Gunsmoke #397, "The Square Triangle," presents a tale of deadly temptation when Marshal Matt Dillon warns Red Lawson about the dangerous allure of Ava Morley, a married woman whose past admirers ended up in a fatal gunfight. Lawson dismisses the warning, insisting he's no fool like the others. When Matt encounters Ava prowling Front Street after midnight looking for Lawson, he sends her home and fears the worst. His concerns prove justified when Jesse Wells, a young bartender, arrives at Matt's door with grim news: Al Morley has been knifed in the back at their cattle-buying camp near Buffalo Fletch, and Red Lawson has fled with ten thousand dollars. Matt and Chester pursue Lawson, tracking him to a water stop where the fugitive waits to board the eastbound train. When Matt confronts him, Lawson refuses to surrender, forcing a gunfight that leaves him mortally wounded. As Doc Adams examines the dying man, Matt reflects grimly on how Lawson became just another fool destroyed by his attraction to Ava Morley, despite the marshal's warnings about the mournful nature of certain kinds of love.

Originally Aired: November 8, 1959 Gunsmoke #396, "Cavalcade," presents Marshal Matt Dillon with an agonizing dilemma when Deputy Sheriff Ed Hunter arrives from Richmond, Virginia, carrying murder warrants for two fugitives. Hunter has tracked one suspect, Calvin Moore, for nineteen years following the shooting death of Roger Beauregard. When Hunter shows Dillon a photograph, the marshal recognizes the face as someone he knows well in Dodge City: Doc Adams. The evidence is unmistakable, despite the passage of time. Doc explains his side of the story to Matt, revealing that young Jim Beauregard challenged him to a duel over a southern girl they both courted. With no witnesses to prove self-defense and facing certain conviction as a Yankee outsider in Virginia, Doc fled west and eventually settled in Dodge. Now Matt faces an impossible choice between his duty as a lawman and his loyalty to a friend. Doc makes his position clear: he won't go back to Virginia and face prison for defending himself. The marshal must decide whether honest law means betraying a good man, while Dodge City waits to see what their marshal will do.

Originally Aired: November 1, 1959 Gunsmoke #395, "Westbound," finds Matt Dillon and Chester traveling to Abilene on what should be a routine prisoner pickup. While Doc grumbles back in Dodge about Chester's easy assignment, the deputy himself feels uneasy about the trip. Their mission is to arrest Jack Daggett, a killer who fled to his hometown after a shooting in Dodge. The arrest goes smoothly at the Last Chance Saloon, but trouble quickly surfaces when the local constable, Roar, proves unhelpful and warns that Daggett's older brothers won't take kindly to the situation. With Wild Bill Hickok away in Topeka, Matt finds himself without local support and denied use of the jail. With four hours to wait until the westbound train departs for Dodge, Matt and Chester hole up in a hotel room with their handcuffed prisoner. The hotel keeper reluctantly accepts their business but demands payment in advance, fearing the bloody confrontation that may come when the Daggett brothers learn their younger sibling is under arrest. As the minutes crawl by and tension mounts, Chester's earlier hunch about this assignment seems increasingly justified.

Originally Aired: October 25, 1959 Gunsmoke #394, "Old Gunfighter," centers on Charlie, an elderly man who spends his days sitting in front of the Dodge House, regaling anyone who'll listen with stories of the legendary gunfighter Rio Joe and the old days. When Chester intervenes to protect Charlie from a couple of young toughs who are tired of his constant talking, he ends up with a black eye for his trouble. Charlie insists he's trying to help these young men by teaching them proper gunfighting technique, warning that their clumsy methods will get them killed, but nobody wants to listen to an old-timer's advice anymore. As Charlie continues sharing tales of Rio Joe's exploits with a young boy, spinning yarns about facing down three men in border country, the townspeople grow increasingly skeptical. The young toughs mock Charlie as a blowhard who never actually knew any real gunfighters. When challenged to prove his stories are true, Charlie finds himself unable to offer evidence, leaving doubt hanging over whether he's a genuine old gunfighter sharing hard-earned wisdom or just a lonely man seeking attention with tall tales.

Originally Aired: October 18, 1959 Gunsmoke #393, "The Mortgage," presents Marshal Matt Dillon with a moral dilemma that strikes at the heart of frontier justice. Wealthy landowner Caleb Andrews arrives at the marshal's office demanding that Dillon serve an order of foreclosure and eviction on Ed Blake, a hardworking farmer who owes $420 on his mortgage. The debt came due just three days ago, but Andrews refuses to wait, despite Ed's legitimate hardships—a broken leg from a horse accident and his family's struggle to bring in a crop. When Dillon tries to reason with the callous creditor, pointing out that Andrews already owns half of Ford County and doesn't need the money, Andrews dismisses his concerns and insists the papers be served immediately. Dillon reluctantly carries out his duty, delivering the devastating news to Ed's wife Martha at their well-tended farm. With only five days to vacate, the Blake family faces complete ruin. The situation weighs heavily on Dillon's conscience, leading him to question the nature of right and wrong in his profession. When Andrews pushes too far with an insult at the Long Branch Saloon, tensions escalate, and Dillon takes desperate action to try to help the Blakes before time runs out.

Originally Aired: October 11, 1959 In Gunsmoke #392, "Kitty's Quandary," a drifter named Shave Murdoch has been spending considerable time at the Long Branch, and he's set his sights on Kitty Russell. While Shave smoothly courts Kitty with compliments and attention, he shows particular interest in Marshal Dillon's whereabouts and routines. When Matt arrives to take Kitty to supper, tension crackles between the two men. Shave claims he's in Dodge on business and will be heading to Texas soon, but his questions become more pointed when Kitty mentions that Doc Adams will be pulling Matt's bad tooth that night. As Doc prepares for the painful procedure, he plans to get Matt heavily liquored up first, which means the marshal will be incapacitated well into the next morning. When Shave learns this detail from Kitty, his reaction suggests more than casual interest. With Chester left in charge of a groggy, whiskey-soaked marshal and a quiet town, the stage is set for trouble. Shave's mysterious "business" in Dodge and his careful timing raise questions about his true intentions.

Originally Aired: October 4, 1959 Gunsmoke #391, "Hinka-Do," begins when Matt Dillon discovers that the Lady Gay Saloon has suddenly come under new management. A formidable woman named Mamie, lately of Kansas City and St. Louis, announces she's taking over the establishment with a new policy. The peculiar part is that former owner Herman Bleaker, a vain little man known for showing off his fancy vests around town, has vanished without a word to anyone. Mamie claims he sold her the saloon and left for St. Louis, but Matt grows suspicious when he learns Bleeker's horse remains at the livery stable and no one saw him leave on the train or stage. At the Lady Gay's grand opening, Mamie proves herself a force to be reckoned with, laying down strict rules for her patrons and demonstrating her lightning-fast draw by shooting an ace of spades off the back wall. While Doc Adams, Chester, and the townspeople marvel at this imposing newcomer, Matt quietly investigates Bleeker's disappearance. When Manuel reports seeing Mamie in the arroyo behind the saloon before dawn carrying a shovel, Matt and his companions head out with a lantern to investigate what might be buried there.

Originally Aired: September 27, 1959 In Gunsmoke #390, "Personal Justice," Matt Dillon brings a prisoner named Reed Morley to Wichita to stand trial for the murder of a woman. Before Matt can even get a hot bath after the dusty journey from Dodge, he's confronted by Clayt Morley, Reed's older brother, who insists that no one with the Morley name could commit such a crime. Clayt makes his position chillingly clear: if Reed isn't acquitted and walks out of the courthouse a free man, Matt won't live to see him hang. Despite calling it an appeal to Matt's sense of justice and honor, the threat is unmistakable. Throughout their stay in Wichita, Clayt shadows Matt and Chester, repeatedly reminding the marshal of his "continued interest" in Matt's health and welfare. When the trial concludes, Matt faces a troubling situation where the verdict may not align with justice, and Clayt Morley's dangerous obsession with family honor threatens to exact a terrible price. Matt must navigate between doing his duty as a lawman and surviving a man who believes personal justice supersedes the law.

Originally Aired: September 20, 1959 Gunsmoke #389, "Gentlemens Disagreement," opens with a desperate Jeannie Wells bursting into Matt Dillon's office with alarming news: Ed Baudre has arrived in Dodge City on the morning train, and she's certain he's come to kill her husband Bert. Four years earlier, Jeannie had been involved with Baudre back in Louisville before choosing to marry Bert instead, and Baudre swore revenge. Despite Jeannie's pleas for help based on their old friendship, Matt explains he can't interfere in personal quarrels, though he reluctantly agrees to talk to Baudre. When Matt confronts the vengeful man at the Long Branch Saloon, tensions escalate into a physical altercation, and Baudre issues an ultimatum to Bert: face him in a gunfight by sundown. Bert Wells, now a peaceful blacksmith who hasn't worn a gun in two years, refuses Matt's suggestion to hide out on the prairie while the marshal finds a way to run Baudre out of town. Citing honor and manhood, Bert insists on facing his adversary despite having little chance against the experienced gunfighter. However, before sundown arrives, someone strikes Baudre from behind in an alley with a hammer. When Matt and Chester arrive at the Wells home to investigate, they find Bert armed and waiting in the darkness, and Matt must make an arrest for murder.

Originally Aired: September 13, 1959 In Gunsmoke #388, "Johnny Red," a stranger arrives in Dodge claiming to be Billy Crail, the long-lost son of elderly rancher Mrs. Crail who ran away seventeen years ago. The reunion seems heartwarming at first, as the lonely widow welcomes her boy home with open arms. However, Matt Dillon knows a dark truth: the real Billy Crail died at the Battle of Shiloh during the war. The marshal recognizes the imposter as Johnny Red, a wanted bank robber and cattle thief from Lubbock with a criminal record stretching back years. Matt faces an impossible dilemma when he visits the Crail ranch with Chester. Mrs. Crail is happier than she's been in years, her failing health miraculously improved by her son's return. She's been going downhill since her husband John died, but now has a reason to live again. When Matt confronts Johnny Red with the truth, the cunning outlaw uses the old woman's joy as a shield, daring the marshal to break her heart by exposing him. Matt must decide whether to arrest the criminal and destroy Mrs. Crail's newfound happiness, or let a dangerous con man prey on a vulnerable widow.

Originally Aired: September 6, 1959 In Gunsmoke #387, "Matts Decision," Marshal Matt Dillon faces mounting frustration from nearly everyone in Dodge City. The episode begins with Chester complaining about rowdy prisoners who've made a mess of the jail, and matters only get worse from there. Doc Adams storms into the Marshal's office angry about a drunk who stole and wrecked his buggy, demanding Matt do something about the lawless drovers. Hotel owner Mr. Dobey wants Matt to act as doorman and keep loafers out of his chairs, while Miss Bagley represents a group of town ladies concerned about bottles in the streets and general disorder when the Texas herds arrive. Matt finds himself caught between impossible expectations and the reality of frontier law enforcement. As complaints pile up and tempers flare, even Chester manages to destroy the Marshal's hat while cleaning up after prisoners. The mounting pressure from all sides forces Matt to examine his role as lawkeeper and consider what he can realistically accomplish in a rowdy cattle town where drovers and townspeople constantly clash.

Originally Aired: August 30, 1959 Gunsmoke #386, "Shooting Stopover," finds Marshal Matt Dillon transporting a dangerous prisoner named Gurney to Wichita to face murder charges. Accompanied by his deputy Chester, Dillon boards the afternoon stage carrying not only the shackled killer but also a strongbox of gold, a schoolmarm passenger, and a reverend. When they stop at Hat Creek Station to change horses, tensions run high. The schoolmarm protests Dillon's treatment of Gurney, insisting he be shown human dignity despite his crimes, while Chester remains convinced the prisoner deserves no such consideration. The routine stopover turns deadly when the station keeper mysteriously disappears and the replacement horses are nowhere to be found. Suddenly gunfire erupts as outlaws launch an attack, targeting the gold shipment and scattering the stage horses. As bullets fly and the stage driver Jim rushes into danger, Dillon must protect his passengers, secure the gold, and prevent Gurney from escaping—all while pinned down by hidden gunmen in the rocks. The marshal faces a difficult choice about whether to leave the murderer chained helplessly to the stagecoach wheel or risk freeing him in the chaos.

Originally Aired: August 23, 1959 Gunsmoke #385, "The Reed Survives," finds Matt Dillon confronting a volatile domestic situation that threatens to turn deadly. Lucy Hunt, who left her dance hall life six months ago to marry the scripture-quoting Ephraim Hunt for his 800 acres of rangeland, comes to Matt in desperation. She claims her husband, who once studied to be a preacher, has grown cruel and suspicious, accusing her of terrible things and threatening to kill her. When Matt refuses to act without evidence, Lucy warns him he'll eventually have to intervene—but by then, it will be for murder. The situation grows more complicated when Doc and Kitty reveal that a young drifter named Bruce Ryder works at the Hunt place, and Kitty hints at Lucy's possible involvement with him. Matt confronts Bruce, suggesting he move on, but the young man refuses to leave his comfortable position. When Chester reports that Ephraim has purchased his first gun ever and is drinking in the barn, the stage is set for a deadly confrontation between the three, with Matt racing against time to prevent bloodshed.

Originally Aired: August 16, 1959 Gunsmoke #384, "Pokey Pete," Dodge City's curious recluse becomes the target of taunting youngsters and dangerous drifters alike. Chester catches young Ted harassing the elderly, silent Pete, who shambles through town wearing boxes on his feet during his monthly visits for supplies. While Chester tries to teach the boy respect by taking him fishing and spinning yarns about Pete's supposed pirate treasure hidden somewhere outside town, his stories may do more harm than good. Meanwhile, Marshal Matt Dillon and Doc discuss the mysterious old man who's been coming to town for as long as anyone can remember, never speaking a word and paying in gold coins. The tension escalates when Pete makes his regular stop at the Long Branch Saloon for his customary three drinks. A couple of rowdy troublemakers take exception to the strange old man's presence at the bar, demanding he move and answer them. When Pete remains silent, the confrontation threatens to turn ugly, forcing both Matt and Kitty to intervene before the situation explodes into violence against the defenseless drifter.

Originally Aired: August 9, 1959 Gunsmoke #383, "Mavis McCloud," a mysterious telegram arrives in Dodge City announcing that someone is coming to get married and requesting Marshal Matt Dillon meet the noon train. When young Mavis McCloud steps off that train, she surprises everyone by explaining she doesn't know whom she'll marry yet—she's simply come west looking for a husband, and believes the marshal should help her find the right man. Matt and Kitty are bemused by the unconventional arrangement, but within days Mavis meets and marries Barney Wales, a hardworking young cowboy with his own spread near Dodge. The newlyweds' happiness is threatened when a dangerous man named Lou Staley arrives from St. Louis, tracking Mavis down and vowing to kill her husband. Matt learns that Mavis has been hiding secrets about her past, including her real name and her connection to the menacing Staley. When Barney refuses to run from the threat, insisting he'll stand his ground despite Mavis's pleas, Matt faces the challenge of protecting the young couple while unraveling the mystery of why Staley is so determined to destroy Mavis's new life.