Skip to content
Kissing Books Critique podcast artwork

Kissing Books Critique

by Jenna McCall, Vicki Hilton, Heather Ryder

Your place for step-by-step editing of our work, line by line in some cases, big picture in others. We talk about what works and what doesn't, from adverbs and passive voice to deep POV and character motivation, we cover it all, in context, in action. Hosts: Vicki Hilton, Heather Ryder and Jenna McCall

From the show's RSS feed, refreshed Apr 19, 2026. Source feed.

Subscribe Bookmark

Episodes

  1. Getting Wet for the Wrong Reasons (A Positioning Problem)

    Vicki's brought us a deliciously wet romance meet-cute that's got positioning issues—and we're not talking about the steamy kind. Between crystal-clear Mediterranean waters and one mysterious Frenchman who's definitely giving Aquaman vibes, we're drowning in "eyes running over" problems and…

    more
  2. Rough Hands and Slippery Decks

    Romance writing craft meets underwater chaos in this manuscript critique session for indie authors and aspiring romance writers. Vicki's chapter delivers a delicious meet-cute scene, but we're diving deep into writing craft fundamentals: scene logistics, character movement, dialogue formatting…

    more
  3. Hockey Romance Breakthroughs

    We're deep in hockey romance territory this week as the group tackles a submission featuring contract clauses, curse words in French Canadian, and one very good dog named Clyde who's clearly the real star of this critique session. From the mysterious "Clause 53B" (which we're definitely stealing...

  4. Hampus Gets Called to the Principal's Office

    This week, the team dives into Jenna's hockey romance featuring Hampus, a troubled player facing ultimatums from team management. Listen as three romance authors dissect a tense office scene, debate whether dogs can "chuff" (spoiler: they can), and provide 742 comments on character development,...

  5. Resting Brood Face Syndrome

    We're deep in Resting Brood Face territory this week as Vicki's Catching Trouble continues with Maxime's chapter two, where our grumpy hero discovers that scowling at customers might not be the best business strategy. From "wild, untamed Poseidon king" energy (our first yellow highlight!) to the...

  6. Stop Harassing My Wife (and Other Logistics Fails)

    We’re deep in scene logistics, missing windows, and rogue dental appointments this week as Heather's submission hits the group chat. From personified smiles to hallway entrances that don’t quite make sense, we’re unpacking character movement, setting gaps, and what it really means to widen your...

  7. Mistakes Were Made. Horses Were Spotted.

    In this episode of Kissing Books Critique, we dive headfirst into Vicki’s brand-new first chapter, an angsty, small-town cowboy romance inspired by a classic '90s country hit. From navigating car logistics (who’s driving again?) to unpacking the emotional weight of fictional towns and old flames,...

  8. Critique and Ice Cream Cliffs: Chloe’s Chapter Takes the Stage

    We’re back in action, and this time it’s Vicki’s turn in the hot seat! Join us as we dive into the second half of Chapter One from the final book in her globe-trotting, language-blending trilogy. This one stars Chloe. Former sidekick, current leading lady, and the kind of character we all want to...

  9. French Kisses, Freckles, and First Chapters

    This week on Kissing Books Critique, it's Vicki's turn in the hot seat as we dive into the sparkling first chapter of her upcoming (and final!) book in the French Kisses trilogy. We talk freckle problems, seaside settings, and what exactly comes to mind when someone says "French kiss" (spoiler:...

  10. That Scene Where He Takes His Shirt Off (Sorta)

    This week on Kissing Books Critique, the spotlight turns to Jenna’s upcoming romance Unleashed—and things heat up fast (literally). Heather and Vicki dive into a rain-soaked, tension-filled chapter where sparks fly and shirts come off. We critique everything from setting clarity and physical...

  11. Starting Off Wobbly: Why First Chapters Are So Hard

    We’re back—and just a little too excited about it. In this giddy return to the pod, Jenna reads the first chapter of Heather's current WIP, featuring Mason and Ronnie, two characters with too much communication and a whole lot of tension. Vicky brings the critique, and together we dive into why...

  12. Enemies, Tension, and a Slow Burn Done Right

    In this episode of Kissing Books Critique, we dive into the art of the slow burn—how to build tension, keep characters at odds, and make every stolen glance count. We tackle passive voice, repetition, and the sneaky ways setting (or lack of it) can impact a scene. Plus, a broody hero fights his...

  13. Revisions, Rainstorms, and One Charismatic Critiquer

    Deadlines are closing in, but that doesn’t stop us from diving deep into revisions, refining character depth, and debating the logistics of stormy bar scenes. In this episode of Kissing Books Critique, we analyze pacing, emotional resonance, and the fine line between evocative and overwrought...

  14. Love Scenes SOS

    Too many hands, too many mouths, and one big stylistic leap—welcome to the final episode of our Valentine's love scene critique special! This week, we’re unraveling the mysteries of rogue body parts, refining intimacy on the page, and celebrating Heather’s bold new writing style. Can we keep…

    more
  15. The Butterflies and the bees and the... logistics

    Love scenes: the good, the bad, and the logistically impossible. In this episode of Kissing Books Critique, we’re diving deeper into what makes a love scene work—breaking down sensuality, pacing, and those little details that can make or break the moment. From crafting multi-sensory experiences…

    more
  16. The Smutty Bits

    We’re back, just in time for Valentine’s Day—and things are heating up! Love them, hate them, or struggle to write them, love scenes are the heart (and heat) of romance, and for the next three episodes, we’re pulling back the covers to critique what makes them sizzle—or fizzle. As Pink would say,...

  17. Avoid White Room Syndrome

    Beats v. stage direction. Setting, setting, setting! Goals, motivation and emotions. Texts being an awesome narrative tool. We made a couple of references to books this episode. The first was Dwight V. Swain's Techniques of the Selling Author. Mr. Swain discusses scene-sequel and...

  18. Details, Details, Details

    Setting matters. Romance and smells. Logistics and towels! NOTED!

  19. Do You Have Enough Internal Dialogue?

    Size doesn't matter, and neither does quiche. Parkling Spink anyone? Moving with the social times in our writing. Heather takes us to school on attention to detail. Vicki's still living in the nineties. Internal thoughts help drive a narrative.

  20. Valentine's Day Special, Part 3

    The last of our naughty adventures in crafting a fun love scene. Join us for our tipsy foray as we help our characters get all the right moves.

  21. Valentine's Day Special, Part 2

    Drinking Games and Sexcapades

  22. Valentine's Day Special, Part 1

    It's all hands and panting - Potato lovers of the world unite - We love a man who comes undone

  23. Show Don't Tell or Showing vs Telling

    Nailing the opening of a book is hard. We continue work on Heather's opening chapter of her new book. When real life invades our stories and Heather learns texting laws.

  24. Who's Your Target Audience?

    Openings are hard. We all struggle to nail the right tone, present the characters the way we see them in our head, and do all the things. But openings are hard.

  25. Introducing Kissing Books Critique

    In this episode, we each introduce ourselves. Share a little about where we are in out book-writing adventures and give you a small taste of what you can expect in the coming year.

About this show

Your place for step-by-step editing of our work, line by line in some cases, big picture in others. We talk about what works and what doesn't, from adverbs and passive voice to deep POV and character motivation, we cover it all, in context, in action.

Hosts: Vicki Hilton, Heather Ryder and Jenna McCall

Hosted by

Jenna McCall, Vicki Hilton, Heather Ryder

Frequently asked questions

How many episodes does Kissing Books Critique have?

Kissing Books Critique has 25 episodes on PodParley. The most recent episode was published on October 30, 2025.

What is Kissing Books Critique about?

Your place for step-by-step editing of our work, line by line in some cases, big picture in others. We talk about what works and what doesn't, from adverbs and passive voice to deep POV and character motivation, we cover it all, in context, in action. Hosts: Vicki Hilton, Heather Ryder and Jenna...

How often does Kissing Books Critique release new episodes?

Kissing Books Critique publishes monthly, based on its 25 episodes since December 2023.

Who hosts Kissing Books Critique?

Kissing Books Critique is created and hosted by Jenna McCall, Vicki Hilton, Heather Ryder.
Link copied