Mysteries of The Ohio Valley podcast artwork

PODCAST · true crime

Mysteries of The Ohio Valley

The banks of The Ohio River keep secrets and stories that often get overlooked, but not anymore. Join Nate as he dives into the dark, strange, and sometimes unexplainable happenings from Pittsburgh to Paducah, and beyond. These are the Mysteries of The Ohio Valley.

  1. 104

    Turkeyfoot - Rick Childers Interview

    Nate is back from his hiatus with a chat with Rick Childers - author of the new fiction thriller, "Turkeyfoot," co-creator of the podcast series "Reformation Abroad," and half of the Stove Leg Media founding team. Pre-Order Turkeyfoot here!https://www.amazon.com/Turkeyfoot-Rick-Childers/dp/195695774X/ref=sr_1_1?crid=8HCYL3223T31&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.S5mNK8LOMz0LPXQun5oix66HzrzhuAkBTw0dWOHrGgw.UGZvERnHiI6OLsiXHsAL5o8E2WJP607iKzbHlvb0q6o&dib_tag=se&keywords=turkeyfoot+rick+childers&qid=1725423831&sprefix=turkeyfoot%2Caps%2C138&sr=8-1

  2. 103

    The Forgotten Miner: E3 - Same Shade of Dark

    Cam and Brad are plummetted into the bottom of the mine - what is ahead? There is only one way to find out. Be sure to tune in next week to the exciting conclusion of this 4 part series!

  3. 102

    The Forgotten Miner: E2 - Into the Mine

    Cam and Brad make their way a little further into the mine, only to split up and find some strange noises, a mine cart, and then... nothing.Thanks again to Brad, Cam, and Carrie for helping with the voicework!And thank you all for being patient with me as I make these little stories for you. I know that these can take a long time to make, but for these fiction works I really try to put a lot of time and effort into them. See you next time!NateLicensing and SoundsThunder RumblingBy Motion AudioFootsteps OutdoorsBy Audio PlanetOld Creaky Rusty DoorBy Asak SFXCoinsBy EquilibrioWalkingBy BeisonFlashlight ClicksBy Sound CreatorPersistance HuntingBy MW_Drum_StudioWalkie TalkieBy GarnaVutkaWalkie TalkieBy WARP EFXMetal ScreechBy Audio PlanetMetal Wheels SpinningBy Home and Explorer

  4. 101

    The Forgotten Miner: E1 - The Feature

    Brad and Cam get deeper into gambling debt after a horse race doesn't go their way. A news story gives the boys financial hopes, despite some obvious obstacles. Welcome to episode 1 of this fictional MoTOV special!Thanks to Brad, Cam, and Carrie for offering their voices for this role!Also, if you want to get in on our horse racing ownership group - check out my friends at Thoroughcrowd!https://thoroughcrowd.com/?gclid=Cj0KCQiAw6yuBhDrARIsACf94RVIgYBKvliUFp_vX2S2OkLbzkU0NkVjnS_ibNlgZmvpY8L9nngyD3MaAjX1EALw_wcBSourced AudioBugle - Racetrack Call And Reveille By LaravichHorse Race By tuttkileTV Broadcast Logo By boomerVegas On Fire By ROVADORTrip To VegasBy DPmusicBroadcast News By SnowMusicStudio

  5. 100

    Century Mark - 100th Episode of MoTOV!

    THANK YOU for listening to all 100 releases on this feed! I break down the most impactful episodes (to me) through the first 100. Hope you enjoyed the ride so far - many more episodes to come.Love,Nate

  6. 99

    Wolf in the Night - Beth Lynn Barr

    Nate discusses the disappearance and then discovery of Beth Lynn Barr.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wilkinsburg,_Pennsylvaniahttps://www.tumblr.com/clairvoyancethestrange/94928780470/the-dark-history-of-johnson-road-novemberhttps://www.wpxi.com/news/investigates/cold-case-disappearance-six-year-old-girl/QM23JFFJIVGYLOUULJYBWJVBNQ/https://whokilledbethbarr.wordpress.com

  7. 98

    The Unholy Connection - Roberta Elam and Susan Rush

    Roberta Elam and Susan Rush were murdered by the same man - but who could it be? Is the answer so obvious? is there more that meets the eye? Nate discusses his opinions on the case on this episode of MOTOV.https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/q5nkxc/was_there_a_serial_killer_operating_in_western_pa/https://positivelypittsburgh.com/a-rash-of-murders-southwestern-pa-in-1977/https://darkmatter69.blogspot.com/2020/01/who-killed-west-virginia-nun-roberta.htmlhttps://uncovered.com/cases/roberta-elamhttps://www.wvnstv.com/news/west-virginia-news/5-of-west-virginias-most-disturbing-unsolved-mysteries/

  8. 97

    Heavy Rain - Brenda Lee Ritter

    Brenda Ritter never made it home on the night of May 18th, 1977. Could the Washington Strangler be at it again?Meadowlands, PA to Zediker Station Rd, Eighty Four, PA 15330 - Google MapsUnsolved Cases: Brenda Lee Ritter Raped, Strangled in South Strabane | Baldwin, PA PatchObserver-Reporter - Google News Archive SearchWas there a serial killer operating in Western Pa in 1977? And if so, who was he? : r/UnresolvedMysteries (reddit.com)COLD CASE - BRENDA LEE RITTER - 1977 HOMICIDE - SOUTH STRABANE TOWNSHIP - WASHINGTON COUNTY - $5000 REWARD!! | Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers (crimewatchpa.com)Brenda Lee Ritter & The Washington Strangler - YouTubeCindy Goff Blog: Unsolved Murders 1976-1977 #3-Washington PA

  9. 96

    The Maroon Cutlass - Debra Capiola

    On St. Patrick's Day of 1977, Debra Capiola walked to school by herself. She never made it to the bus stop. What happened on that day? Could her killer be behind more than just this murder?https://www.reddit.com/r/UnresolvedMysteries/comments/q5nkxc/was_there_a_serial_killer_operating_in_western_pa/https://archive.triblive.com/news/cecil-man-gets-life-for-1977-slaying/https://www.newspapers.com/article/pittsburgh-post-gazette-wash-co-murders/51099361/https://inmatelocator.cor.pa.gov/#/Result

  10. 95

    The Pregnant Pause - Mary Gency

    When a pregnant 16 year old girl is murdered in Western PA, a "he said - he said" finger pointing battle begins. Who could have committed such evil? Are both suspects guilty? https://archive.triblive.com/local/local-news/two-charged-in-1977-murder-of-charlerois-mary-irene-gency/https://www.wtae.com/nowcast#http://coldcaseusa.blogspot.com/2011/10/mary-gencys-1974-killers-brought-to.htmlhttps://archive.triblive.com/news/mid-mon-valley-duo-to-stand-trial-in-mary-irene-gencys-1977-murder/https://archive.triblive.com/news/charleroi-man-gets-2-4-years-for-role-in-34-year-old-murder/https://apnews.com/article/ef02e7e70c274449b8c5e16603446d33https://inmatelocator.cor.pa.gov/#/

  11. 94

    Shotgun Killer - Edward Surratt

    We continue our journey through the mess that was Western Pennsylvania in the 1970s with a conversation about Edward Surratt. As we look at all of the deaths that took place around this time - Surratt certainly is to blame for a fair number of them. But his timeline doesn't line up with many others. See you all in 2024!https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Surratthttps://www.timesonline.com/story/news/2021/06/02/four-cold-cases-solved-serial-killer-edward-surratt-confesses-killing-six-pa/7514192002/

  12. 93

    Late for Mass: Susan Rush

    Susan Rush was a tremendously kind young woman, dedicated to her weight loss journey and her church. The night before Thanksgiving, she vanished. What happened to Susan? Could this be connected to the other murders in the area around 1976? Find out on this episode of Mysteries of The Ohio Valley.

  13. 92

    The Long Road - Barbara Lewis

    Barbara Lewis was the first of many unsolved murders to take place in the Ohio Valley during 1976-1977. Nate dives into the attack, examines the evidence, and pitches some ideas about what may have happened.https://patch.com/pennsylvania/foresthills-regentsquare/unsolved-cases-barbara-lewis-body-found-a-mile-from-hcb6cbfd079https://archive.triblive.com/local/penn-hills/unsolved-penn-hills-murders-from-decades-ago-prompt-blog-to-share-details/https://archive.triblive.com/news/police-seek-help-to-solve-30-year-old-slaying/

  14. 91

    Devil of Pumpkin Run - Debra Makel

    Nate begins a dive into West Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Ohio's streak of murders that took place between 1973 and 1978 with the abduction and murder of 8 year old Debra Makel.Sources and things you should check out:Ken Mains - Unsolved No More - YouTubeCOLD CASE - DEBBIE MAKEL - 8-YR-OLD-HOMICIDE - JEFFERSON TOWNSHIP - GREENE COUNTY - DO YOU KNOW ANYTHING? $5000 REWARD!! | Pennsylvania Crime Stoppers (crimewatchpa.com)Debra Makel | Deep Dive | Unsolved Homicide | A Real Cold Case Detective's Opinion - YouTube

  15. 90

    The Forgotten Miner - Scary Stories from the Valley #4

    Nate gets into another spooky story from the valley! Enjoy!Sounds used (Licensing stuff)Halloween Monster Whoosh By Crester StudioAppalachia By Steve BuzzellHouse Of Horror By Jello

  16. 89

    An Ohio Thanksgiving: The Turkey Bowl(s)

    Nate discusses turkey bowls with a belly full of food. Happy Thanksgiving!

  17. 88

    No Sanctuary - Sister Roberta Elam

    Nate discusses the murder of Sister Roberta Elam. Sources: https://darkmatter69.blogspot.com/2020/01/who-killed-west-virginia-nun-roberta.htmlhttps://uncovered.com/cases/roberta-elamhttps://www.wvnstv.com/news/west-virginia-news/5-of-west-virginias-most-disturbing-unsolved-mysteries/

  18. 87

    The Ohio Gang - Mysterious Deaths Around Warren G. Harding

    Nate gets political (not) as he digs into some presidential history on this election week episode!

  19. 86

    Children of New Skin - Scary Stories from the Valley #3

    Nate tells a Halloween tale about a terrifying cult that is said to live in the woods somewhere near where Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana meet. Hope you enjoy the last drops of spooky season!Sounds used:Jungle Hunters By Stereoalex Merciless Cult Massacre By colortunes Twig Snap By Nobou Underwater Diving By Sotirios Bakas

  20. 85

    An Unsavory Figure: Sprinkles The Killer Clown

    Nate harkens back to the clown craze that took place in 2016, along with the story of Sprinkles.

  21. 84

    Stove Leg Feature: Paradigm

    Here is episode one of Paradigm: The Lillielid Murders. This 8 episode Stove Leg feature is available in full whereever you listen to your podcasts.

  22. 83

    Monsters of The Valley (With Nate and Devin!)

    Nate digs into the archives for this one! Enjoy!!

  23. 82

    Lurking in the Woods - Scary Stories from the Valley #2

    Nate gives you a quick scary story about Bigfoot. Enjoy!Sounds used (with permissions through MotionArray's Licensing)Halloween Monster Whoosh By Crester StudioEpic Monster Growls By WoozleCampfire Crackles By Katya MorrisA Road Through The Wolf Valley By Alexey MaximovMove In Retro Style By Awesome MusicWind Gusts Through Trees By Archers SoundsSiamang Monkeys By ProphesierCamera Flash Light Transition By BANTTime Is Running Out By PB&J

  24. 81

    The Mirror of Despair - Scary Stories from the Valley #1

    In this first scary story from the Ohio Valley, Nate tells the tale of the Mirror of Despair.Join us next week for another fun story!Here are all of the sounds used during the production of this episode:Halloween Ghost Howls By FTUSMonster Laugh By Motion AudioHorror Suspense Atmospheres By EchoVerseCrowd Negative Reactions By ProphesierDancing In Paris By Mellowstu Halloween Monster Whoosh By Crester Studio

  25. 80

    Something in the Water - Max Creek Vortex

    Nate explores the Max Creek Vortex! Max Creek Vortex Loop Trail Guide in the Shawnee National Forest (hikingwithshawn.com)Blog: Visit the Max Creek "Vortex" (10/28/10) | Southeast Missourian newspaper, Cape Girardeau, MO (semissourian.com)Max Creek Vortex Shawnee National Forest — Stephanie Susie Photography

  26. 79

    Danelo Cavalcante Update / 2023 Little Brown Jug

    Nate talks about all the big news in the Ohio Valley - namely-Danelo Cavalcante getting caught-Nate's new fiction podcast (The Package, available everywhere)-The history of the Little Brown Jug

  27. 78

    Manhunt - Danelo Cavalcante

    This mystery of the Ohio Valley is ongoing! Stay vigilent, and help spread the word about Danelo Cavalcante - Update (09/13/23) They got him! Links:A timeline of the hunt for Danelo Cavalcante | CNNEscaped murderer Danelo Cavalcante armed with rifle he took from resident's garage - ABC News (go.com)Businesses in search area for Danelo Cavalcante dealing with low foot traffic (msn.com)Danelo Cavalcante update: Neighbors' anxiety, frustration grows as manhunt nears 2 weeks - CBS Philadelphia (cbsnews.com)

  28. 77

    Rivers of Time - Steamboats in the Valley

    All aboard! Nate discusses some of the history about steamboats in the Ohio Valley.

  29. 76

    Fire and Rain - Don Decker

    Nate explores the mystery behind Don Decker. Can he actually command water to appear? Seems a little odd...

  30. 75

    Porkopolis - The Pork Industry in the Valley

    From Goetta to Scrapple, the Ohio Valley loves them some pork. Nate dives into this industry on this Histories of The Ohio Valley episode.

  31. 74

    Introducing: Left on Dead

    Nate tells you about Left on Dead! Go check out John and Jamie's new show whereever you listen to podcasts.

  32. 73

    An Interesting Arrest - Brookelyn Farthing

    We're hitting close to home on this episode with covering the mystery of Brooke Farthing. Let's keep her memory aflame and look into her more. https://uncovered.com/cases/brookelyn-farthing https://www.lex18.com/news/covering-kentucky/community-marks-ten-years-since-brookelyn-farthings-disappearance https://www.findbrookefarthing.com/brookes-story/ https://www.nolangroupmedia.com/berea_citizen/berea-man-charged-with-sex-crimes-found-dead-saturday/article_f01799dc-df60-11ea-a76f-9b162878d694.html http://kool.corrections.ky.gov/KOOL/Details/473767 https://www.lex18.com/news/lex-18-investigates/farthings-mom-has-questions-for-man-arrested-on-unrelated-charges

  33. 72

    The Cradle of American Sport

    With baseball in full swing, football around the corner, and Nate being back in America - he figured it was a good time to teach everyone that we have the Ohio Valley to thank for both professional baseball and football.

  34. 71

    Heaven(?) on Earth - Utopia, Ohio

    Nate discusses Utopia, Ohio's jagged and sad history. Thanks to Steve Barber of the Cubicle Chat and Armchair Booking Wrestling Podcast for assisting with the "Boots on the Ground" research!Sources:https://spectrumnews1.com/oh/columbus/untangled-with-josh-robin/2019/04/26/what-happened-to-utopia--oh https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utopia,_Ohio https://www.roadsideamerica.com/story/11893

  35. 70

    Sister Cities of the Valley

    After some spirited (get it?) conversations at his favorite Parisian bar, Nate dives into some sister cities of places in the Ohio Valley. Enjoy!

  36. 69

    The Land Remembers - Blue Mist Road

    Nate celebrates a birthday and keeps on with the ghost tour of Summer 2023.Weird Pennsylvania (weirdus.com)Blue Myst Road: A Film About Pittsburgh Urban Legends - YouTubeBlue Mist Road Is The Most Haunted Street In Pittsburgh (onlyinyourstate.com)

  37. 68

    West Virginia Joker - Jim Comstock

    Nate digs into the life, times, and pranks of writer and humorist Jim Comstock.Jim Comstock - Wikipediae-WV | Jim Comstock (wvencyclopedia.org)

  38. 67

    Bridge Over Troubled Water - Erie PA

    Nate heads to Erie Pennsyvania to discuss a bridge, a ghost mule, and a cemetary. Links!Gudgeonville Covered Bridge - WikipediaPennsylvania Haunts & History: Gudgeonville Bridge Legend (hauntsandhistory.blogspot.com)Gudgeonville Covered Bridge | Haunted Places | Girard Township, PAStroll Through Erie Cemetery, A Haunted Cemetery In Pennsylvania (onlyinyourstate.com)

  39. 66

    Riding The Fence - Gnadenhutten Massacre

    Nate digs into the Gnaddenhutten massacre before heading out for vacation. Ciao!

  40. 65

    S4E22: Mother of Sorrows - Helltown, Ohio

    Nate goes to Hell...town, Ohio for today's wild and mystery filled episode.Links!Why Helltown, Ohio More Than Lives Up To Its Name (allthatsinteresting.com)Helltown, Ohio: An Abandoned Town With a Tragic History (thevintagenews.com)Is It Illegal To Go To Helltown Ohio? | Ohio Law (keatingfirmlaw.com)Boston Township, Summit County, Ohio - WikipediaEaston Treaty | The Canadian EncyclopediaFrench and Indian War - WikipediaOur Lady of Sorrows - Wikipedia

  41. 64

    S4E21: Last of the Boat Wreckers - Colonel Plug & River Pirates

    Nate discusses real life river pirates on this episode of Mysteries of the Ohio Valley.

  42. 63

    S4E20: Sinisterly Yours- Circleville Letter Writer

    When the beans start to get spilled about a small town Ohio woman's love life, choas insues. Has the anonymous author of the infamous Circleville letters been unmasked? - CBS NewsThe Mystery Of The Circleville Letters (factinate.com)Circleville Writer | Unsolved Mysteries Wiki | Fandom

  43. 62

    S4E19: The Brickyard - Indianapolis 500

    Nate is back and slightly healthier to take on some fun facts about the Indianapolis 500.Here is the song mentioned in the episode!The Mel-Tones 1945 - Back Home Again in Indiana - YouTube

  44. 61

    S4E18: Without A Trace - David Bocks (Nov 2020 Patreon)

    Sadly, Nate is sick this week and wasn't able to get a new episode out. Good news is: we have one in the can from late 2020. Enjoy!

  45. 60

    Stove Leg Feature: Reformation Abroad

    Hey guys! It's Nate, giving you just a taste of what I've been working on over the last year. If you like what you hear and are interested to hear the rest of Season 1 of Reformation Abroad - be sure to subscribe to it on your favorite podcast app. Some links to the show are below. Be sure to leave a 5 star review and tell your friends to as well!Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/.../reformation.../id1687436294Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/484FvpWUdqcIxK0jLNQzuj?si=9660b64ddcad47baSpreaker: https://www.spreaker.com/show/reformation-abroadAn interview, a shootout, a cleaning, a new friend(?), a liftoff. Welcome to Reformation Abroad.Be sure to like us on Facebook for special behind the scenes conversations about the entire production of the show! https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100092686299124For information about our fantastic cast, please visit the Reformation Abroad IMDB page:https://www.imdb.com/title/tt27820441/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_0_tt_8_nm_0_q_reformation%2520abrAll sounds not created by Stove Leg Media organically were sampled from Motion Array and are covered under their standard universal license.For more information about the licensed sounds: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1k3N99UNcRxOFpJcomev6fSvcDPaGSTJa/view?usp=sharing

  46. 59

    S4E17: Little Egypt - Cairo, Illinois

    Nate talks about his experience last week in the Shawnee Forest and why Southern Illinois is called "Little Egypt."

  47. 58

    S4E16: Moth to a Flame - The Mothman

    Nate is travelling this week, so he has dug up a gem from the Patreon archives for you to enjoy. See you guys next week!

  48. 57

    S4E15: Chance of a Lifetime - The Kentucky Derby

    A very fun Histories of the Ohio Valley episode about the biggest sporting event to take place down the river - the Kentucky Derby. Nate goes through some fun facts about the historic race and gives his pick! Good luck, and I'll see you next week hopefully a smidge richer. 39 Fun Facts About the Kentucky Derby 2023 - What to Know About Derby Day (townandcountrymag.com)

  49. 56

    S4E14: Cold on the Kanawha - Melanie Metheny

    On the morning of July 19th of 2006, Melanie Metheny dropped off her three children at daycare in Belle, West Virginia – just a little south of the state capital in Charleston, but she never returned to pick up her kids. Many clues were found in the search for Melanie, but her whereabouts are still unknown to this day. What happened to this Kanahwa County mother of three? Could foul play have been involved? Join Nate Metz as he dives into this Mystery of the Ohio Valley.https://melaniemetheny.wordpress.com/https://wchstv.com/news/local/cold-case-files-kanawha-county-mother-of-three-melanie-metheny-now-missing-16-yearshttp://www.melanieshope.org/?fbclid=IwAR3W87GEucmEaNiOMfzrbSr94cxpmitY_OIfJtfp6Nifo3dL-Zbw1uCT3vs

  50. 55

    S4E13: Low Bridge - The Erie Canal

    Nate dives into the Erie Canal (but not really that'd be wild) on this episode of Histories of the Ohio Valley!Opening of the Erie Canal - This Month in Business History - Research Guides at Library of Congress (loc.gov)

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

The banks of The Ohio River keep secrets and stories that often get overlooked, but not anymore. Join Nate as he dives into the dark, strange, and sometimes unexplainable happenings from Pittsburgh to Paducah, and beyond. These are the Mysteries of The Ohio Valley.

HOSTED BY

Stove Leg Media

CATEGORIES

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does Mysteries of The Ohio Valley have?

Mysteries of The Ohio Valley currently has 50 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is Mysteries of The Ohio Valley about?

The banks of The Ohio River keep secrets and stories that often get overlooked, but not anymore. Join Nate as he dives into the dark, strange, and sometimes unexplainable happenings from Pittsburgh to Paducah, and beyond. These are the Mysteries of The Ohio Valley.

How often does Mysteries of The Ohio Valley release new episodes?

Mysteries of The Ohio Valley has 50 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.

Where can I listen to Mysteries of The Ohio Valley?

You can listen to Mysteries of The Ohio Valley on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts Mysteries of The Ohio Valley?

Mysteries of The Ohio Valley is created and hosted by Stove Leg Media.
URL copied to clipboard!