ScareSquad Podcast

On April 18, 1998, 32-year old Peggy Carr went to run a few errands in the coastal town of Wilmington, North Carolina. As fate would have it, two thugs up to no good spotted her walking to her car, kidnapped her, and eventually murdered her. This is the tragic case of Peggy Carr.

In one of the most bizarre stories of 2026, we talk about Dayton Webber, the quadro amputee, professional cornhole player, who snorts cocaine upside down and then shoots semi-automatic rifles. This guy just shot and killed one of his good friends while driving a car and then dumping the body out of his car. Doing all of this with no arms or legs.

Today we are talking about one of the most notorious serial killers in the history of the United States and we bet you've never heard of him. Samuel Little claims to have killed upwards of 100 women in his life and we dive into what we learned about this awful human being.

In this episode we talk about the Utah mother of 3, Kouri Richins, who was just convicted of poisoning and killing her husband, Eric Richins, in March of 2022 and then writing a children's book about it.

Join Mollie and Billy as they discuss the ScareNetwork's newest original paranormal series 'Thomas House.' Located in Red Boiling Springs, Tennessee this hotel has been ranked as high as Number 2 on CNN's list of most haunted locations in the United States.

Friday the 13th has long been a notorious date on the calendar way before Jason Voorhies stepped on the scene. Take a listen as we explore the history of this date and why it is so superstitous.

On December 30, 2025 Spencer and Monique Tepe were brutally shot in their bedroom as their two small children slept right down the hallway. Ten days later the authorities made a shocking arrest, Monique's ex-husband.

The Flatwoods Monster is a famous 1952 West Virginia cryptid sighting involving a reported 10-to-12-foot-tall, spade-headed, green-clothed alien creature with glowing red eyes that floated towards witnesses.

Velma Barfield was the first woman in the United States to be labeled a 'serial killer'. She was also the first woman to ever die by lethal injection in the US after she admitted to killing at least 5 people throughout the 1970's.

In the first ever episode of the ScareSquad Podcast Billy and Mollie talk about the heartbreaking kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie, the daughter of NBC's Today Show Host Savannah Guthrie. They go through the Timelines, the evidence and dive into some theories of what happened in this tragic story.