All Episodes
Very Special Episodes — 73 episodes
Dock Ellis: High and Outside
The Family Who Vanished Into Siberia for Over 40 Years
A Very Special Mini-Mailbag
Marilyn, Hamilton + John Wilkes Booth's Statue: NYC History Hiding in Plain Sight
The Unintended Insanity of the 1994 Caribbean Cup (w/John Green and Daniel Alarcón of The Away End)
Bar Trivia: How a Staten Island Pub Made College Hoops History
Richard Nixon and the Magic Suitcase
10 Minutes to Live: Hawaii's Text Message Fiasco of 2018
Zero Gravity: The Zambian Space Program
Movie Mystery: The 2000 Oscars Heist
The Galápagos Murders
Taking On Water
The Olympic Prison
Breaking the Olympics
Meet the Steagles
JFK's Forgotten Summer [Best of 2025]
Big in Japan: Kentucky Fried Christmas
The Cabbage Patch Crisis
Skylab Is Falling
The Fundamental Magical Element
A Very Special Thanksgiving Mailbag
The Dogs of Chernobyl
The Grocery Store That Killed Communism
The Arctic Balloon
Being Joe Isuzu
A High School Brawl in the Panama Canal Zone
Introducing: Hoax! with Dana Schwartz and Lizzie Logan
The 1932 Crime That Birthed Superman
Hush! The Battle Over 'Goodnight Moon'
Who Really Wrote the Pledge of Allegiance? [Re-Release]
JFK's Forgotten Summer in Journalism (with Rob Reiner)
Richard Nixon's Alien Adventure
Hemidemisemiquaver: A Modern Quiz Show Scandal
Big Bird Goes to China
How a Three-Point Shot Saved Thousands of Lives [Re-Release]
David Chase's Wonder Years
The Night the Harlem Globetrotters Finally Lost
Operation Lunar Eclipse [Re-Release]
The Popsicle Kings of Mexico
North by North Korea
Spies and Dolls
The Pizza Funeral
How Gatsby Went From Total Flop to Great American Novel
The Mysterious Death of Andy, the Sneaker-Wearing Goose
Night of a Thousand Weddings
Live From New York, It's Your Grandmother
Super Streaker
Hot Wheels of Fortune
An Artificial Christmas
The Spider-Man Wedding
The Landfill
The Joyride: Amelia and Eleanor's Excellent Adventure
The Case of the Missing Novelist
Eugene Bullard: Freedom in the Skies
The Amazing Journey of the Three Kichis
The Furby Files
The Legend of SwordQuest
Art of Gold: The Olympic Art Competitions
Famous Dumpster Fires in History: The 1904 Olympic Marathon
The Shot: A Buzzer-Beater That Saved Lives
The Affair of the Diamond Necklace
The Buffet Table
Signs of Life: Revisiting Martha's Vineyard Sign Language
On the Hunt for Math's Most Mysterious Number
Westward Hoax: The Secret History of Palisade, Nevada
EThe Worldwide Sensation That Started as an April Fools' Joke
Seed Wars: History's Deadliest Botany Rivalry
Spider-Man's Surreal Adventures on Broadway
Happy Leap Day
The Pledge: Who Really Wrote the Pledge of Allegiance?
Old Man on Campus
Boat Trip: The Attempted Sinking of Titanic
Introducing: Very Special Episodes