5 True Crime Cases Still Unsolved in 2025 #406

Episode 406 of the Southern Girl Crime Stories podcast, hosted by by Southern Girl, titled "5 True Crime Cases Still Unsolved in 2025 #406" was published on August 6, 2025 and runs 32 minutes.

August 6, 2025 ·32m · Southern Girl Crime Stories

0:00 / 0:00

Summary

Step into the chilling world of unresolved mysteries with "5 True Crime Cases Still Unsolved in 2025." These five haunting stories remain clouded in uncertainty, leaving families and communities yearning for answers and justice. 🕒 Case Lineup 🔹 Deborah Jean McKneely - A 39-year-old Georgia mother of two vanished in 1991 on the very day she was set to finalize her divorce. Blood evidence, a broken door, and cut phone lines pointed to foul play, but despite suspicion surrounding her estranged husband, Deborah has never been found and the case remains unsolved. 🔹 Nicole Marcum - At 23, Nicole disappeared under highly suspicious circumstances in Baytown, Texas, in 2019. Her abandoned car was found on a bridge, but no body, no surveillance, and no credible investigation followed. Family believes foul play was involved, especially pointing to her ex-boyfriend’s behavior. She remains missing. 🔹 Shelva Rafte (Shelly) - A mother of four, Shelva vanished after attending her daughter’s graduation party in Pennsylvania in 2006. Seen arguing with her boyfriend, her family doubted she’d walk home alone in the dark. Despite searches by authorities and the FBI, no trace of her has ever been found. 🔹 Stephanie Casberg - Stephanie’s brutal murder in Wisconsin in 1969 shocked the community. At 17, her dismembered body was found scattered near the Root River. Despite suspects ranging from coworkers to gang associations, her killer has never been caught, and her case remains unsolved over 50 years later. 🔹 Theodoric Elton Hunter Sr. (Theo) - A devoted father from Virginia, Theo disappeared in 2019 after visiting his estranged wife's home. His car was last spotted by a license plate reader at 3 a.m., and has never been found. Despite family-led searches and no financial activity since, his case remains a mystery. 📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/cd03aa8e upport the show Subscribe:✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories☕ Buy Me a Coffeehttps://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8👕 BUY Merchandise:https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrFGMkHpKdyIEPscm4YS_0g/store🎁 Donations:🅿️ PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=XENJPDT5MREMCⓂ️🅾️ Venmo: www.venmo.com/u/southerngirlcrimestories

Episode Description

🕒 Case Lineup

🔹 Deborah Jean McKneely - A 39-year-old Georgia mother of two vanished in 1991 on the very day she was set to finalize her divorce. Blood evidence, a broken door, and cut phone lines pointed to foul play, but despite suspicion surrounding her estranged husband, Deborah has never been found and the case remains unsolved.

🔹 Nicole Marcum - At 23, Nicole disappeared under highly suspicious circumstances in Baytown, Texas, in 2019. Her abandoned car was found on a bridge, but no body, no surveillance, and no credible investigation followed. Family believes foul play was involved, especially pointing to her ex-boyfriend’s behavior. She remains missing.

🔹 Shelva Rafte (Shelly) - A mother of four, Shelva vanished after attending her daughter’s graduation party in Pennsylvania in 2006. Seen arguing with her boyfriend, her family doubted she’d walk home alone in the dark. Despite searches by authorities and the FBI, no trace of her has ever been found.

🔹 Stephanie Casberg - Stephanie’s brutal murder in Wisconsin in 1969 shocked the community. At 17, her dismembered body was found scattered near the Root River. Despite suspects ranging from coworkers to gang associations, her killer has never been caught, and her case remains unsolved over 50 years later.

🔹 Theodoric Elton Hunter Sr. (Theo) - A devoted father from Virginia, Theo disappeared in 2019 after visiting his estranged wife's home. His car was last spotted by a license plate reader at 3 a.m., and has never been found. Despite family-led searches and no financial activity since, his case remains a mystery.

📚 Sources: https://controlc.com/cd03aa8e

upport the show

Subscribe: ✅ https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGirlCrimeStories?sub_confirmation=1 🅿🅰🆃🆁🅴🅾🅽 https://patreon.com/southerngirlcrimestories ☕ Buy Me a Coffee https://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8 👕 BUY Merchandise: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrFGMkHpKdyIEPscm4YS_0g/store 🎁 Donations: 🅿️ PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted_button_id=XENJPDT5MREMC Ⓜ️🅾️ Venmo: www.venmo.com/u/southerngirlcrimestories