Hume and Practical Rationality: Is There Any Connection Between Morality and Reason?

Episode 46 of the On The Very Idea - A Philosophy Podcast podcast, hosted by Tony Bologna, titled "Hume and Practical Rationality: Is There Any Connection Between Morality and Reason?" was published on January 6, 2022 and runs 21 minutes.

January 6, 2022 ·21m · On The Very Idea - A Philosophy Podcast

0:00 / 0:00

Summary

In this first episode of a two part installment, I look at the work of David Hume and his ideas that justify that famous quote of his “Reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions.” This quote has always troubled me. As politico-moral beings, many don't want to classify a horrific act as merely bad. There is also an urge to classify that horrific act as irrational. Does reason really tell us nothing about morality? Is reason just a way of determining efficient means to an end? Was Hitler evil and rational, or, just evil? What work can a concept of rationality do to condemn an evil act? In this episode, I look at the work of Peter Railton, a Hume scholar, who argues that people often interpret Hume's quote incorrectly. According to Railton, Hume believed that rationality does have a robust role to play in determining which acts are moral or immoral. Hume's point was rather that rationality in isolation could not tell us much about morality but working in conjunction with our sentiments, rationality could help determine for us which acts are moral or immoral. 

Episode Description

In this first episode of a two part installment, I look at the work of David Hume and his ideas that justify that famous quote of his “Reason is, and ought only to be the slave of the passions.” This quote has always troubled me. As politico-moral beings, many don't want to classify a horrific act as merely bad. There is also an urge to classify that horrific act as irrational. Does reason really tell us nothing about morality? Is reason just a way of determining efficient means to an end? Was Hitler evil and rational, or, just evil? What work can a concept of rationality do to condemn an evil act? In this episode, I look at the work of Peter Railton, a Hume scholar, who argues that people often interpret Hume's quote incorrectly. According to Railton, Hume believed that rationality does have a robust role to play in determining which acts are moral or immoral. Hume's point was rather that rationality in isolation could not tell us much about morality but working in conjunction with our sentiments, rationality could help determine for us which acts are moral or immoral.

Share this episode

Similar Episodes

Jan 2, 2026 ·10m

Jan 2, 2026 ·13m

Descriptive Outline of the Pampas

Jan 1, 2026 ·21m

Jan 1, 2026 ·18m

Dec 31, 2025 ·24m

Dec 31, 2025 ·15m

Similar Podcasts

Rough Notes Taken During Some Rapid Journeys Across the Pampas and Among the Andes by Francis Bond Head Loyal Books “Galloped on with no stopping, but merely to change horses until five o’clock in the evening—very tired indeed, but . . . saw fresh horses in the corral, and resolved to push on. At half-past seven, after having galloped a hundred and fifty-three miles, and been fourteen hours and a half on horseback got to the post—quite exhausted—I could scarcely speak . . . an hour before daylight was awakened by the Gaucho, got up, had some mate, mounted my horse, and as I galloped along felt pleased that the sun should find me at my work. . .”Later in life nicknamed “Galloping Head,” for his exploits on the Argentine pampas, Sir Frances Head Bond, went to the Argentine in 1825 as mining supervisor for the Rio Plata Mining Association, a group of English speculators whose ill-planed and financially disastrous idea it was to send Cornish miners to re-open old gold and silver mines in the former Spanish colonies. His “Rough Notes,” often written in a staccato style that is surprisingly fresh, show The Book of Huey The Book of Huey Huey has the dopest, funniest, most inciteful conversations with his friends. Within all the shenanigans and jokes, there are frequent profound moments and lots of quotable gems. With the idea that other folks could benefit from, or at the very least, be highly amused by listening in on these convos, he created a safe, judgment-free space to discuss love, sex, life, dating, relationships, fuckery, and advice with raw honesty and humor.Explicit Content Wanted: A Husband Samuel Hopkins Adams This serious, yet witty and hilarious, romantic comedy by Samuel Hopkins Adams is a must read/listen! From the very beginning it intrigues you with the troubles and feminine woes of young Miss Darcy Cole. Being a dowdy, unkempt fledgling lady, she finds herself in a mirthful fix after telling a whopper to her room-mates in order to save face from her severely lacking personal life. Resentful and jealous of most all other women, and contemplating suicide, she turns to actress Gloria Greene for guidance on how to become more attractive. Miss Cole had no idea what she was getting herself in to! Was it even possible to make herself over? How on Earth would she get through the lie of being engaged to a “titled” man, no less! She had never even met Sir Montrose Veyze, let alone be engaged to him! And then there is the charming Jack Remsen, who seems to be in a pickle himself. Darcy knows he would never fall for someone like her; in fact, no man even looks at her! But perhaps he might be coer World That Couldn't Be (Version 2) by Clifford D. Simak Loyal Books The planet where his new plantation was established was very strange, with a complete lack of sex; all of his workers and all the animals and plants had no sex at all; they were all 'its'. But like every farmer on every planet, Duncan had to hunt down anything that damaged his crops—and whatever animal ate his vua plants was going to die. Of course he had no idea what this one looked like or what it was like, but whatever it was, he would track it and his rifle would bring it down. It was a very interesting hunt with a very interesting ending. Simak has written another delightful story that will keep you listening and wondering to the very end. With maybe a chuckle and guffaw on top. Listen and find out why.

URL copied to clipboard!