Crime City Colorado: A True Crime Podcast

Send us Fan MailRosa Arguello was 29 years old when her body was found in a ditch in Thornton. She was stabbed several times. A year later another body was found in Westminster. The woman was also stabbed several times. A man was arrested for this Murder who happens to be the ex-boyfriend of Rosa. Could he have killed both women?Support the show

Send us Fan MailAriana moved to Denver with her little boy to enjoy the mountains, rivers and all of the festivals that Colorado has to offer. She would end up being murdered the same way her grandmother was. Think they are connected?Support the show

Send us Fan MailOn September 27, 2006, Duane Morrison walked into Platte Canyon High School and changed the lives of everyone at the school, but especially for six young girls. Learn what happened at the first school shooting in Colorado after the Columbine shooting, the one that most people have forgotten about.Support the show

Send us Fan MailIt is 7am in November 2017. Who is driving under the influence at that time? You would be shocked at how many people get arrested for DUI from 7am to 11am, and Mr. Cumsille is another one. But unfortunately, he did not just get pulled over for driving like an asshole. He did something unforgivable. Support the show

Send us Fan MailRichard Henne wanted to be famous so bad! So he signed up for a tv show. He thought by being on the show everyone would see how awesome his family was and would offer them a reality show. Well, that didn't work. And they were on the show twice. So, they had to do something big to get the attention of the media, then the TV networks would definitely want to give them a show! Or would they?Support the show

Send us Fan MailWhen Rita Gutierrez-Garcia went missing after going out with some friends, it was not long before police had a person of interest. But it would take a long time before any questions would be answered, and longer before Rita would be brought home. This guy sucks, big time!Support the show

Send us Fan MailWhile there are bad apples in every profession, the ones in charge of our children are the ones that need to be held the most accountable! Here are four of our worst "educators". Let's hope they really enjoy their time in the Department of Corrections. Maybe they can teach other inmates how not to be POS!Support the show

Send us Fan MailNow you know we are a Law Enforcement Family, but when an Officer does some stupid shit, like SA's someone, they are considered a POS and they get to be mentioned on our Podcast!! So buckle up for a ride on this one!!!Support the show

Send us Fan MailRule #1, do not google things about the way you plan on murdering someone. Rule #2, Don't murder people. You will ger caught! Let's talk about Alan.Support the show

Send us Fan MailHAPPY NEW YEAR!!! We have not changed a bit, we are still the little ray of sunshine's you have all come to love, or hate HA HA!! Bringing in the new year with the case of a POS who stole a car and then tried to sell it. It did not go well....Support the show

Send us Fan MailWho finds a trash bag buried in a crawl space, that smells horrendous, and thinks it's trash? Not me! But maybe that is because I am morbid! Contractors replacing a sump pump find a trash bag in the crawl space and think just that. But get curious. Guess what? It is not trash....It is human remains. Let's start the shenanigans.Support the show

Send us Fan MailWhen Winston Sr and Charlotte were found murdered in their Alabama mansion, it was not long before Alabama Detectives were coming to Colorado looking for their suspect! How? That's 1400 miles away! Well, we will tell you! And also fill you in on our shenanigans as of recently!Support the show

Send us Fan MailWhen you put Paw Paw in assisted living, do you take away his weapons? Did you ever think about if he still had weapons?? You may want to check his belongings! Papa may be packing heat!!!Support the show

Send us Fan MailAwhile back we did an episode on some prison escapes, this episode goes into detail on one of those people and the crazy things that went down on his farm. I still want to know where you get Uranium!!! Support the show

Send us Fan MailWE ARE BACK!! Cami is back from her birthday trip to Hawaii! The last episode we recorded did not save! DANG IT! But we are bringing you Anthony, a massive POS that should have never been  allowed to see his child, let alone have 50% custody! This does not play out well!!Support the show

Send us Fan MailI have gotten so many things on Craigslist! Cars, baby items, I even adopted Bear the massive Chocolate Lab from Craigslist! You can also apparently hire Hitmen on there! Now, obviously they are not very good, but you should probably ask for references!!! Just saying!!Support the show

Send us Fan MailIn February 2024, two young adults were killed at University of Colorado Colorado Springs in the dorms. When the motive was revealed, everyone was shocked. A room mate dispute over what? Then it goes to trial and the suspect wants to use the self defense method....Umm what now??Support the show

Send us Fan MailWhen you hear of a fool proof way of breaking out of prison, you have to give it a shot right? I mean, the last people who tried this exact method were caught, but these guys are way smarter so they could definitely pull it off! Yea Right! Thanks Jo for letting us know about this one!!Support the show

Send us Fan MailKristil was married with three children, and had a beautiful house in Broomfield, Colorado. Then an ex-boyfriend from 20 years ago starts to text her. And not like a "Hey how are you" type of text, like "I know your license plates are expired" and "here is a photo of your husband getting out of his car at work" type of texts. The kind of texts and emails that would make you want to join the witness protection program. But why would an ex that Kristil has not seen in 20 years want to harass her and scare her so badly? What would he gain from any of this? We will see!Support the show

Send us Fan MailIn 1998, Matthew Shephard was going to College in Wyoming. He went to bar one night and never came home. His death would make news worldwide and change legislation to make it Hate Crime to target someone based on their Sexuality. This is a very sad and tragic case.Support the show

Send us Fan MailTom and Beth Engel adopted two kids from the Philippines. One attempted to stab Beth, the other actually did stab her. And did some other stuff too. And this kid was only 14 years old!! John Engel is quite the bad son! Sorry for the delay, we blame Kylie and Xfinity! Support the show

Send us Fan MailThis one is Simple, Short and Sweet. This is what happens when little juveniles are out at 1 and 4 in the morning with no parental guidance and have respect for human life. Sadly a mother and her ten year old daughter lost their lives due to these two juveniles.Support the show

Send us Fan MailDid you know that Neveah spelled backwards is Heaven? And that is where this little 3-year-old ended up because her mother decided to date and live with a man who was a registered sex offender and had been convicted of child abuse. This mother is just as guilty as this POS!Support the show

Send us Fan MailBrandy Duvall was a  14 year old who loved Michael Jordan and loved wearing his jersey. Should not have been an issue. But in Denver in 1997, the gangs in the area were massive and wearing that jersey could be trouble. And it was. This is probably one of the most brutal cases we have covered. Trigger warning for everything that is messed up in this world. Support the show

Send us Fan MailWhen you are a massive control freak, and want to control everything, including your wife, you do not take it well when that control starts slipping away. But murder is never the answer, and what he did to his daughter's is unforgivable! This guy is a massive POS and a sorry excuse for a soldier. He does not deserve to wear a uniform. Support the show

Send us Fan MailIn 1991 there were a rash of bombings in Grand Junction, Colorado. When they made an arrest, the case was pretty weak, in my eyes anyways. Can you really convict someone based on how some wire cutters leave marks?? Maybe....Support the show

Send us Fan MailWelcome to Granby, Colorado, where you can hike, boat, paddleboard, or even have to outrun a psychopath in a modified Bulldozer with a grudge against everyone in the town! Some people say he is a hero, what do you think?Support the show

Send us Fan MailWe are bringing you three cases today. These are three funeral homes in Colorado that royally screwed over families and really caused a scandal. All three of them were thankfully caught and closed down! But it makes you think, how many others are doing shady shit?Support the show

Send us Fan MailI said I would never cover Columbine as it was way over done, but several people has asked for it, so ill just do it a little differently. We will go over the myths and rumors regarding Columbine. And unfortunately the number of victims went up to 14. Support the show

Send us Fan MailI have never been to Aspen because I am poor. But this lady was I guess a prominent member of the Aspen Community. She ended up dead in her closet. Three people were arrested for her murder, but only one would be convicted! Support the show

Send us Fan MailStill not super happy with the sound, but working on it as we go. Here is the case of Harvey Gaffney, a case suggested by a listener. Wait until you hear how this guy loses his virginity! Ew!Support the show

Send us Fan MailWe are finally back! I am not totally happy with the sound yet, still playing with the new equipment. But GUESS WHAT?? THIS IS OUR 100TH EPISODE!! OMG!! THANK YOU EVERYONE WHO CONTINUED TO SUPPORT US ALONG THE WAY! We Appreciate every single one of you! And today we are bringing you the case of Alfred Packer, who lied about being a mountain guide and took five guys into the mountains on what was supposed to be a seven-day trip. Twenty days later Alfred shows up alone. You won't believe what actually happened in those mountains!Support the show

Send us Fan MailApologize for the sound quality. New equipment and need to get the bugs out. Randy dropped dead and at first it was thought that his heart finally gave out, he had a bad heart after all. But then the autopsy revealed he had been shot. Twice. How did you miss this at the scene. But you you are not going to believe who was all arrested for this murder. Oh and Kylie has the flu. If only there was a vaccine to prevent this ha ha.Support the show

Send us Fan MailWho doesn't love a little puppy? Who wants a $4,000 puppy? That is how much money you would need to buy a European Doberman from this breeder in Colorado. But Sergio Ferrer was like, NOPE! Ill take all of them and then screw everything up when I am questioned. And also, Happy Holidays!Support the show

Send us Fan MailSo, there are so many people to blame in this case! Jessica left an abusive husband with her four children and was able to get a restraining order. Did that stop her ex? NOPE! Did the Police help her? Nope? Did someone end up paying the ultimate price? YUP!!!Support the show

Send us Fan MailWho loves hiking? I know I do! Kylie, not so much. Harold loved it, so for his 12th wedding anniversary he took his wife, Toni. And she "Fell". Weird, his 1st wife died in a tragic "accident" too. Maybe someone should look into that.Support the show

Send us Fan MailCU Boulder in 1966 became the scene of a gruesome murder in one of the most popular buildings on campus. Now, it is apparently haunted.... Sleepover time! Who is coming? Let me tell you the reason it is haunted. And my co-host has returned, about damn time!Support the show

Send us Fan MailDude starts off getting out of prison and going into the Witness Protection Program. Sounds great! Get's to start over with no criminal history, a new name and new life! Then his wife ends up dead. The local police want more info on this dude, but the feds are not playing nice. Well, they should have. Because then all hell broke loose!! This is why we can't have nice things! Also, email us your address and we will mail you a Christmas Card <3Support the show

Send us Fan MailAfter Nothing Worked Yesterday, we tried again today and had success. When a man and woman meet and fall in love and get married, it is not always forever. Chris and Amara split up and Amara and her 6 year old moved in with Chris's sister. Long story short, there was a restraining order placed, and ignored and Chris went to jail a few times. Then the last time he was arrested, a Ninja broke into Amara's house and all hell broke loose. Tune in!Support the show

Send us Fan MailTrigger warning for the migraine about to ensue! This dude used so many different names there is no possible way he kept them straight. I know I couldn't. This dude is known as the Chameleon Killer. Try to keep up with all the name changes! Kylie could not! And Special Guest Appearance: CudaSupport the show

Send us Fan MailOctober is Domestic Violence Awareness Month, as well as Breast Cancer Awareness month (CHECK THOSE FUN BAGS!!). Amber tried everything she thought of to get away from her abusive, piece of shit ex boyfriend. But even moving out of state did not work, he followed her. And then one night, he followed her too closely. And her new boyfriend, probably heard her die. Don't fight DV alone, get help and always keep your guard up. Support the show

Send us Fan MailAnd we are back with yet ANOTHER mass shooting in Colorado. We used to be known for our mountains, our wildlife, skiing, fishing, etc. Now we are known for the shit ton of Mass Shootings we have. This is NOT something that should be happening, anywhere. But, let's talk about this piece of crap, James Holmes. And Kylie will educate you on the ingredients in a Pumpkin Spice Latte, and you will not be happy about that either.Support the show

Send us Fan MailWhen Scott Sessions did not show up to play trumpet for the Elvis Experience, people knew something was wrong. Maybe the new girlfriend, Heather, can answer some questions. Or maybe her psycho ex can explain? Love triangles never work out in the end.Support the show

Send us Fan MailSo, people are very opinionated on certain topics, which is fine. People are entitled to their opinions. When you decide to do a mass shooting over your opinions, that is a complete BS. That is what happened with the case of this asshole. Robert Dear, Jr. took his political beliefs to an entire new level and tried to start a war. Thankfully he did not get very far. But there were some fatalities and for that, he deserves to pay.Support the show

Send us Fan MailWe all love our men and women in Blue, but the ones who abuse their power and take advantage of someone need to be prosecuted and called out. So, here we are, calling them out and telling everyone what big pieces of shit they are. Buckle up buttercup, you are in for quite a ride! Support the show

Send us Fan MailWe are bringing you a short episode this week, the case of Lily Silva-Lopez and holy shit. This one is going to piss you off. I may have went on a rant on this one ha ha, but I think you will all agree with me on this one. Buckle Up Buttercup, you are in for a ride.Support the show

Send us Fan MailSo, a kid is being abused for 14 years and no one says a damn thing. Then a murder happens and everyone is like, oh yea that kid suffered for years....Cool, and no one said a word. This kids mother failed him, every one around him failed him and the system failed him. I for one am not shocked something like this happened. But it should not have happened. Support the show

Send us Fan MailFirst of all, there are way too many "Falls" in the family. SUSPICIOUS! But there was also a kidnapping and murder near Turkey Creek in Morrison, Colorado and Adolph Coors III was involved! SCANDALOUS! But they are still a pretty popular beer! And someone did go to jail. Not for long, but still.Support the show

Send us Fan MailIn 2021, Old Town Arvada was mortified when an Officer was gunned down for no reason, other than he was an Arvada Police Officer. Then there was the man who took down the shooter, and then the hero was taken out tragically. This is the horrible case of the Arvada shooting, where so many others would have died, if it wasn't for Johnny Hurley.Support the show

Send us Fan MailI understand that choosing a religion can be daunting, but joining several at one time, plus some Cults for good measure seems like a bad idea! Matthew Murray had been raised in a strict Christian household. He then decided, Christianity was not for him. Which is fine, you have the freedom to choose your religion. But you do not get to go shoot up the two places that you were raised in because you changed faiths. Matthew Murray believes he can, and he did.Support the show