A Reel Pain podcast artwork

PODCAST · tv

A Reel Pain

A Millennial and Gen Zer clash over what makes their movies a classic. A Reel Pain is a movie debate podcast hosted by John Choate and Matthew Pursell, where generational nostalgia meets fresh perspective—and not everyone leaves happy. John, a millennial with a deep love for iconic ’80s and ’90s films, introduces Matthew to the movies he grew up believing were untouchable classics. Matthew, a Gen Z movie fan shaped by more modern cinema, returns the favor by bringing films John somehow missed along the way.This is a debate that you don't want to miss! Subscribe today!

  1. 15

    Is This Cult Classic Actually Good? | Millennial vs Gen Z

    Is Mortal Kombat actually a legit cult classic… or just a nostalgia-fueled fever dream? In this episode of A Reel Pain, John (Millennial) revisits a childhood favorite, while Matthew (Gen Z) steps into the tournament with fresh eyes—and zero attachment. What follows is a chaotic, hilarious breakdown of one of the most iconic video game adaptations ever made.From the instantly recognizable theme song to the over-the-top fight scenes, the guys dive into what still works, what absolutely doesn’t, and whether this movie earns its legacy or just survives on vibes. They unpack the strange storytelling choices, questionable CGI (looking at you, Reptile), surprisingly solid practical effects, and the undeniable camp factor that somehow makes it all… work. Along the way, they debate if this is a “so bad it’s good” situation or if there’s actually something more here beneath the surface.By the end, the ratings might surprise you—and raise the bigger question: are we judging this movie fairly, or are we all just victims of the Mortal Kombat theme song hypnosis?🎧 Watch, then decide for yourself… is this a flawless victory or a total fatality?

  2. 14

    The Devil Wears Prada — Who’s the Real Villain? | Millennial vs Gen Z

    A millennial and two Gen Z voices take on The Devil Wears Prada—and what starts as a nostalgic rewatch quickly turns into a full-on debate about career ambition, toxic workplaces, and whether this iconic fashion film still hits the same in 2026.In this episode of A Reel Pain, Matthew and John are joined by Rachel Pursell (Gen Z) and Naomi Winder (Millennial) to break down a movie that defined an era—but lands very differently depending on when you first saw it. From Meryl Streep’s chilling performance as Miranda Priestly to the fashion montages, quotable one-liners, and surprisingly dark character dynamics, the group dives into what holds up—and what absolutely doesn’t.They unpack the generational divide behind the film’s message, including whether Andy’s transformation is empowering or concerning, why her friends might actually be worse than her boss, and if Nate is secretly the real villain of the story. The conversation also explores early 2000s culture, shifting workplace expectations, and how differently this story would be told today.By the end, the group has to decide: is The Devil Wears Prada still a classic… or just a relic of its time?🎬 Watch, debate, and decide for yourself—and don’t forget to subscribe for new episodes every week.#TheDevilWearsPrada #MoviePodcast #MillennialVsGenZ #AnneHathaway #MerylStreep #MovieDebate #FilmDiscussion #AReelPain

  3. 13

    Does This Jim Carrey Film Still Hold Up? | Millennial vs Gen Z

    In this episode of A Reel Pain, John brings one of his all-time favorites to the table: Liar Liar—the 1997 comedy starring Jim Carrey at the height of his powers. What follows is a generational clash over one big question: does this iconic comedy still hit today, or is it carried by nostalgia?Matthew goes in completely blind, never having even heard of the movie before—while John remembers theaters full of people laughing uncontrollably. As they break down the film, they dive into Jim Carrey’s over-the-top performance, the surprisingly emotional father-son story, and whether this brand of comedy still works for a Gen Z audience.From unforgettable scenes like the courtroom chaos and bathroom meltdown to the deeper themes of honesty, fatherhood, and personal growth, the conversation goes beyond just laughs. They also debate whether this was peak Jim Carrey, how the movie compares to his other classics, and if comedy like this could even be made today.By the end, both hosts find themselves asking the same question: is Liar Liar just a funny ‘90s movie… or is it actually a timeless classic?🎬 Watch the full episode and decide for yourself.If you enjoy the episode, make sure to like, subscribe, and turn on notifications—we’re dropping new episodes every week.#LiarLiar #JimCarrey #MovieReview #MillennialVsGenZ #90sMovies #ComedyMovies #FilmPodcast #MovieDebate #ClassicOrNot #AReelPain

  4. 12

    A Jim Carrey Fever Dream… | Millennial vs Gen Z

    A childhood favorite meets a fresh set of eyes as we break down A Series of Unfortunate Events—and things get surprisingly complicated. Matthew grew up with the books, John didn’t… so does this gloomy, chaotic adaptation actually hold up, or is it just nostalgia doing the heavy lifting?From the moment the Baudelaire children lose everything, this movie leans into its dark tone—but balances it with some seriously unexpected humor. We dive into whether that tonal mix works, how Jim Carrey absolutely steals the show as Count Olaf, and if cramming multiple books into one film helps or hurts the story. There’s also a deeper conversation around whether this should’ve been a movie at all… or if it was always meant to be a series.Plus, we get into favorite scenes, underrated moments, and the surprisingly emotional beats that caught us off guard. And somehow… we BOTH landed on the same rating.Is this a misunderstood classic… or just a weird relic of early 2000s filmmaking?Watch now and decide for yourself.#AReelPain #SeriesOfUnfortunateEvents #JimCarrey #MoviePodcast #MillennialVsGenZ #MovieReview #FilmDiscussion

  5. 11

    Is True Lies Still a Classic? | Gen Z vs Millennial

    A Millennial favorite steps into the ring as John defends True Lies, a high-octane action-comedy starring Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jamie Lee Curtis—but does it actually hold up, or is it coasting on nostalgia?In this episode of A Reel Pain, John brings one of his all-time favorites to the table, while Gen Z co-host Matthew experiences the chaos for the first time. What starts as an explosive, confident spy thriller quickly turns into something… very different. From unforgettable action sequences and iconic one-liners to a wildly controversial middle act that completely divides the room, this episode captures the full spectrum of what makes True Lies both beloved and baffling.As the debate unfolds, the guys dig into whether this movie knows what it wants to be, how its tone shifts impact the experience, and if nostalgia is doing some heavy lifting for Millennial audiences. Does the action outweigh the awkward? Does the comedy still land? And most importantly—does True Lies earn its “classic” status, or is it a relic of its time?Watch now, pick a side, and let us know: is True Lies a certified classic… or a movie that just doesn’t age as well as we remember? 🎬

  6. 10

    Mamma Mia! Was This Musical Ever Good? | Rachel Pursell & Taylor Petersen Bring the Heat

    A millennial and Gen Z perspective collide in this episode of A Reel Pain as the crew dives into the chaotic, colorful world of Mamma Mia!—but this time, it’s not just a debate… it’s a full-blown takeover. With Rachel Pursell and Taylor Petersen stepping in, the energy shifts fast as nostalgia, musical love, and brutally honest critiques all hit at once.From the iconic ABBA soundtrack to the over-the-top performances, this episode explores whether Mamma Mia! is a feel-good classic or a wildly overrated singalong. Rachel and Taylor come ready to defend the movie they grew up loving, while the guys try to make sense of the plot, the performances, and yes… Pierce Brosnan’s singing.As the conversation unfolds, things get personal—favorite scenes, unexpected emotional moments, and the undeniable pull of a movie that feels more like a comfort watch than a cinematic masterpiece. But the real question remains: does nostalgia carry this movie, or does it actually deserve the love it gets?Tune in for one of the most fun, chaotic, and laugh-filled episodes yet—where friendships are tested, ratings get questioned, and Mamma Mia! becomes the ultimate battleground.🎬 Watch now, join the debate, and let us know—classic or cringe?#MammaMia #AReelPain #MoviePodcast #ABBA #FilmDebate #MovieReview #MillennialVsGenZ #PodcastClips

  7. 9

    Unforgiven Revisited with Phil O’Brien | A Western That Changed Everything?

    What happens when a legendary Western isn’t what you remember it to be? In this episode of A Reel Pain, the generational debate takes a new turn as the crew is joined by special guest Phil O’Brien—bringing a Gen X perspective into the mix—to revisit Unforgiven, the Clint Eastwood classic that helped redefine the Western genre.From the jump, this conversation digs into more than just nostalgia. Phil shares what it was like seeing Unforgiven in theaters back in the early ’90s, while the Millennial and Gen Z perspectives challenge whether the film still holds up in today’s cinematic landscape. As the discussion unfolds, the group wrestles with the film’s moral ambiguity, its rejection of traditional “hero vs villain” storytelling, and the haunting reality behind violence that the movie refuses to glamorize.But this isn’t just a film breakdown—it’s a full-on evolution of opinion. Scores shift, perspectives change, and what starts as a straightforward review turns into a deeper conversation about legacy, storytelling, and what makes a movie truly timeless. By the end, the question isn’t just whether Unforgiven is good—it’s whether we ever understood it correctly in the first place.🎧 Watch, listen, and decide for yourself—then join the debate.#AReelPain #Unforgiven #ClintEastwood #MovieReview #FilmPodcast #WesternMovies #MovieDebate #FilmAnalysis #PodcastClips #MovieFans

  8. 8

    Is There Will Be Blood a Masterpiece? | Gen Z Makes a Millennial Watch

    In this episode of A Reel Pain, Matthew (Gen Z) forces a long-overdue first watch: There Will Be Blood. A slow-burn epic about ambition, isolation, faith, and oil — lots of oil. For years, this one sat in the “overhyped classic” category for John. But after finally sitting down with it, the reaction might surprise you.From the silent, tension-filled opening sequence to the explosive final “milkshake” confrontation, this episode dives deep into Daniel Plainview’s descent into obsession. Is this simply a story about capitalism and corruption? Or is it a character study about a man who cannot coexist with other human beings?The generational dynamic flips here. Gen Z defends it as a near-perfect film. The Millennial wrestles with its heaviness, its discomfort, and its emotional weight — but can’t deny its brilliance. The performances are dissected, especially the towering presence of Daniel Day-Lewis and the unsettling rivalry with Paul Dano’s Eli Sunday.This isn’t a flashy movie. It’s not built for quick clips or algorithm moments. It’s patient. It’s intense. It lingers. And by the end, the debate becomes less about whether it’s “good” and more about whether it’s great.Is There Will Be Blood a masterpiece that demands multiple rewatches… or a perfectly crafted film you only need to experience once?🎧 Subscribe and join the generational movie debate every week on A Reel Pain.

  9. 7

    Is The Boondock Saints Really A Cult Classic? | Gen Z vs Millennial

    In this episode of A Reel Pain, the Millennial makes his case for one of the most quoted, dorm-room-DVD, late-’90s cult classics of all time: The Boondock Saints. A movie built on vigilante justice, Irish Catholic swagger, and pure “there was a firefight!” energy — but does it actually hold up in 2026?John revisits a film he once considered untouchable. The black coats. The slow-motion gunfights. The brotherly bond. The courtroom monologue. For a certain generation, this movie wasn’t just entertainment — it was identity. But when Gen Z watches it through a modern lens, the flaws start to surface fast.The conversation quickly shifts from nostalgia to morality. Is this a bold anti-hero story… or a revenge fantasy dressed up as divine purpose? Does the message collapse under scrutiny? And does the ending justify everything that came before it?One thing everyone agrees on: Willem Dafoe absolutely steals the movie. But is one legendary performance enough to carry the rest?Final scores reveal a generational gap that might be wider than expected — and the debate gets real.Is The Boondock Saints a misunderstood cult classic… or proof that some movies are better left in your high school memory?🎧 Subscribe and join the generational movie debate every week on A Reel Pain.

  10. 6

    Over the Hedge: Most Underrated Animated Movie? | Gen Z vs Millennial

    In this episode of A Reel Pain, the generational debate heads into animated territory as Gen Z picks Over the Hedge—and the millennial host watches it for the very first time.Originally released in 2006, Over the Hedge blends fast-paced animation with surprisingly sharp commentary on consumerism, suburbia, and family dynamics. What started as a “kids movie” quickly turns into a deeper discussion about whether this DreamWorks film is smarter—and more relevant—than it ever got credit for.The hosts break down:Whether Over the Hedge works as a Gen Z childhood classic or just a time capsule of the mid-2000sThe surprisingly stacked voice cast, including Bruce Willis, Steve Carell, and Allison JanneyHow the film handles themes like consumerism, conformity, and family without dumbing things downStandout scenes, underrated jokes, and the infamous HOA villainFinal ratings… and the big question: Does Over the Hedge deserve “classic” status?A millennial nostalgia skeptic meets a Gen Z defender in one of the show’s most unexpected debates yet.🎧 Subscribe for weekly Gen Z vs Millennial movie debates, and let us know in the comments: Was Over the Hedge underrated… or just overhyped?

  11. 5

    Is The Rock An Overrated Action Movie? | Gen Z vs Millennial

    A millennial picks a ’90s action juggernaut—and a Gen Z host puts it on trial.In this episode of A Reel Pain, John selects The Rock, the 1996 Michael Bay action thriller starring Nicolas Cage, Sean Connery, and Ed Harris. What follows is a generational debate over whether The Rock still holds up—or if nostalgia is doing most of the heavy lifting.John revisits the film as a longtime fan, praising its practical effects, iconic performances, and peak-era action filmmaking. Matthew watches with a modern lens, questioning the runtime, character choices, and late-film pacing that feel very “of their time.”The conversation dives into:Sean Connery’s scene-stealing performance and Bond-theory rumorsNicolas Cage’s unconventional action-hero arcMichael Bay’s early directing style and hyper-kinetic editingWhether the film’s final act earns its extended runtimeBy the end, final scores are revealed—and the generational gap is on full display.🎥 New episodes every week.👍 Like, subscribe, and tell us in the comments: Is The Rock a timeless action classic—or a nostalgia trap?

  12. 4

    Is Bottoms Already a Comedy Classic? | Millennial vs Gen Z

    A Gen Z pick puts millennial nostalgia to the test.In this episode of A Reel Pain, Matthew (Gen Z) brings Bottoms (2023) to the table — a chaotic, over-the-top high school comedy that John (millennial) somehow missed when it first hit theaters. Going in blind, John reacts in real time to a movie that thrives on satire, absurdity, and jokes that refuse to play it safe.The conversation breaks down whether Bottoms is a modern comedy classic or just pure Gen Z chaos, touching on its exaggerated take on high school tropes, unapologetic humor, and why it feels more like an early-2000s parody than a traditional coming-of-age film.Along the way, they discuss:Why Bottoms feels intentionally ridiculous — and why that mattersThe generational humor gap between Gen Z and millennialsStandout performances, including Marshawn Lynch and Ayo EdebiriWhether “you couldn’t make this movie today” is actually trueFinal ratings — and if the millennial’s score changes by the endIf you enjoy movie debates, Gen Z vs millennial culture clashes, or comedy films that swing for the fences, this episode is a must-watch.🎬 Watch the full episode, then let us know: Is Bottoms brilliant satire or absolute madness?👍 Like, subscribe, and join the argument — new episodes every week.

  13. 3

    Does 10 Things I Hate About You Still Hold Up? | Gen Z vs Millennial

    A millennial picks Ten Things I Hate About You (1999) — and a Gen Z co-host watches it with fresh eyes.In this Valentine’s Day episode of A Reel Pain, John and Matthew revisit one of the most iconic teen rom-coms of the late ’90s to answer the ultimate question: does this movie still hold up, or is it riding purely on nostalgia? From Heath Ledger’s legendary musical moment to the poetry scene that defined a generation, the hosts break down what still works, what feels dated, and why this film continues to spark debate across generations.They dive into the soundtrack, the performances, the humor, and the emotional beats — plus whether this might actually be one of the most timeless rom-coms ever made. Scores are revealed, minds are challenged, and nostalgia is put on trial.If you love classic movies, modern takes, or watching generations clash over pop culture, this episode is for you.🎧 New episodes weekly — like, subscribe, and join the debate.

  14. 2

    This Movie Is Wild… and No One’s Talking About It | Millennial vs Gen Z

    In this episode of A Reel Pain, the generational tables turn. A Gen Z pick forces a millennial first-time watch as the crew dives into Death of a Unicorn—a dark, uncomfortable, and wildly polarizing film that sparks instant debate.What starts as a fresh Gen Z recommendation quickly becomes a clash of expectations, nostalgia, and modern filmmaking sensibilities. From brutal tonal shifts and uncomfortable themes to standout performances and frustrating character choices, the hosts break down what worked, what didn’t, and whether this movie actually earns its reputation.As always, initial ratings are locked in early, favorite and least favorite scenes are dissected, and no one pulls punches trying to defend their take. Does Death of a Unicorn reward its ambition, or does it collapse under it? And more importantly—does this Gen Z pick hold up for a millennial watching it for the very first time?🎬 A Reel Pain is the movie debate podcast where generational nostalgia meets fresh perspective—and not everyone leaves happy.

  15. 1

    Is Lethal Weapon Actually Good? | Gen Z vs Millennial

    A millennial and a Gen Zer clash over whether Lethal Weapon still deserves its “classic” status.In this episode of A Reel Pain, John brings one of his most nostalgic picks to the table, while Matthew watches Lethal Weapon for the very first time — completely blind. What starts as a confident defense of an 80s action staple quickly turns into a much messier conversation about aging movies, character arcs that don’t quite land, and moments that feel increasingly uncomfortable through a modern lens.As the discussion unfolds, nostalgia gets challenged, plot holes pile up, and the infamous final act sparks genuine frustration. By the end of the episode, ratings shift in real time, and no one walks away with quite the score they expected.Final Ratings:🎬 John (Millennial): 7.5 / 10🎬 Matthew (Gen Z): 5.25 / 10Is Lethal Weapon still lethal… or has time finally caught up with it?💬 Drop your rating in the comments🎥 Subscribe for more millennial vs Gen Z movie debates

  16. 0

    Is The Hobbit Overhated? | Gen Z vs Millennial

    In this episode of A Reel Pain, Matthew (Gen-Z) finally convinces John (Millennial) to watch The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey for the first time — and the results are surprisingly wholesome.Together they debate whether Peter Jackson’s 2012 Tolkien return deserves more credit than it got at release. From Martin Freeman’s Bilbo to Gollum’s riddle scene to the controversy around stretching a children’s book into three movies, the hosts break down what works, what doesn’t, and why the internet got so weird about it.Topics in this episode:• Why Gen-Z defends The Hobbit• Why Millennials mostly skipped it• Book vs film adaptation differences• Does it hold up in 2026?• Fanbase expectations & backlash• Funniest and best scenes• Final ratingsFinal Scores:★ Matthew (Gen-Z): 9/10★ John (Millennial): 8.5/10🎧 New episodes every Friday — subscribe to join the generational movie wars.

  17. -1

    The Terminator Changed Everything… But Is It Still Good? | Millennial vs Gen Z

    A millennial and a Gen-Z movie fan clash over James Cameron’s The Terminator (1984) — and not everyone makes it out alive.In the debut episode of A Reel Pain, John (millennial) introduces Matthew (Gen-Z) to one of the most iconic sci-fi action films ever made. Together they break down whether the movie still holds up in 2026 — from Arnold’s robotic acting and time-travel plot twists to claymation endoskeletons, questionable prosthetics, and the legendary “I’ll be back” scene.Does Gen-Z think The Terminator is a masterpiece… or just mid?🎬 What We Talk About in This Episode:• Movie nostalgia vs first-time reactions• 80s sci-fi vs modern filmmaking expectations• Practical effects, stop-motion, and VFX aging• Time-travel plot logic & Easter eggs• Iconic Arnold Schwarzenegger moments• Kyle Reese thirst, police shootouts & questionable love scenes• Original ratings vs post-debate ratings⭐ Final ScoresJohn (Millennial): 7.5/10Matthew (Gen-Z): 6/10🔔 Watch NextEpisode 2 → The Hobbit (2012) + showdown continues🎧 Follow A Reel PainPodcast feeds coming soon — subscribe for weekly episodes!#TheTerminator #MovieReview #MoviePodcast #GenZvsMillennial #ArnoldSchwarzenegger #JamesCameron #SciFiMovies #FilmDiscussion #FirstTimeWatching #PodcastClips #MovieDebate #NostalgiaFilms #AReelPain

  18. -2

    Announcement Trailer

    A Millennial and Gen Zer clash over what makes their movies a classic. A Reel Pain is a movie debate podcast hosted by John Choate and Matthew Pursell, where generational nostalgia meets fresh perspective—and not everyone leaves happy. John, a millennial with a deep love for iconic ’80s and ’90s films, introduces Matthew to the movies he grew up believing were untouchable classics. Matthew, a Gen Z movie fan shaped by more modern cinema, returns the favor by bringing films John somehow missed along the way.This is a debate that you don't want to miss! Subscribe today!

Type above to search every episode's transcript for a word or phrase. Matches are scoped to this podcast.

Searching…

We're indexing this podcast's transcripts for the first time — this can take a minute or two. We'll show results as soon as they're ready.

No matches for "" in this podcast's transcripts.

Showing of matches

No topics indexed yet for this podcast.

Loading reviews...

ABOUT THIS SHOW

A Millennial and Gen Zer clash over what makes their movies a classic. A Reel Pain is a movie debate podcast hosted by John Choate and Matthew Pursell, where generational nostalgia meets fresh perspective—and not everyone leaves happy. John, a millennial with a deep love for iconic ’80s and ’90s films, introduces Matthew to the movies he grew up believing were untouchable classics. Matthew, a Gen Z movie fan shaped by more modern cinema, returns the favor by bringing films John somehow missed along the way.This is a debate that you don't want to miss! Subscribe today!

HOSTED BY

A Reel Pain

CATEGORIES

Frequently Asked Questions

How many episodes does A Reel Pain have?

A Reel Pain currently has 18 episodes available on PodParley. New episodes are automatically indexed when they're published to the podcast feed.

What is A Reel Pain about?

A Millennial and Gen Zer clash over what makes their movies a classic. A Reel Pain is a movie debate podcast hosted by John Choate and Matthew Pursell, where generational nostalgia meets fresh perspective—and not everyone leaves happy. John, a millennial with a deep love for iconic ’80s and ’90s...

How often does A Reel Pain release new episodes?

A Reel Pain has 18 episodes. Check the episode list to see recent publication dates and frequency.

Where can I listen to A Reel Pain?

You can listen to A Reel Pain on PodParley by clicking any episode. We provide an embedded audio player for direct listening, and you can also subscribe via your preferred podcast app using the RSS feed.

Who hosts A Reel Pain?

A Reel Pain is created and hosted by A Reel Pain.
URL copied to clipboard!