Anxious At Bedtime

In the very first Ask Cash episode, nothing is off limits. Are you planning a proposal? A demon summoning? Adopting a new pet? Join us as Cash weighs in on it all, in his own way.   Expect honesty, chaos, unexpected wisdom, and at least one moment where we both question why we thought this was a good idea.    It's funny. It's unfiltered. It's slightly concerning. And it's officially the start of Ask Cash. We're probably fine.   If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

What happens after an encounter like that? In the final part of our Betty and Barney Hill series, we follow the story beyond the night on the road and into the years that came after. As the Hills tried to move forward, new questions began to take shape. Strange illnesses. Lingering fear. Additional sightings that made it harder and harder to dismiss what they experienced.  We explore the physical and emotional toll the encounter may have taken, including Barney's declining health and death, and the life Betty continued to live in the shadow of that night.  We also take a closer look at Betty's now famous star map, the growing attention surrounding their story, and how their private experience became one of the most widely known and debated abduction cases in history.  Because for the Hills, the story didn't end when they got home. And it didn't end when the memories came back. In many ways, it never ended at all.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]. 

In Part 2 of our Betty and Barney Hill series, we dive into the hypnosis sessions that uncovered the missing hours from that strange night in 1961. From the dinner party where the Hills first shared their story to the investigators who began asking questions, this is the chapter where they mystery deepens and the details of the encounter finally begin to emerge.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the pod, please email to [email protected]

We're back.  After some time away, we're returning to the microphones with one of the most famous and unsettling stories in paranormal history. But before the lights in the sky, before the missing time, and before the hypnosis, there were just two people.  Betty and Barney Hill. In part 1 of this two parter, we're going back to the beginning. We explore who Betty and Barney were, how they met, and the romantic road trip that would unknowingly cement them in paranormal history forever.     If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

This Halloween, we're diving deep into one of the world's eeriest legends, black-eyed children. From chilling 1980s sightings to theories linking the phenomenon to tragic murders of the 1960s, these pale, black-eyed visitors have haunted the woods and internet forums alike for decades. Join Monica and Cash as they unravel real reports, folklore roots, and paranormal theories behind this haunting mystery. Why do so many witnesses describe the same thing? And why do the stories always begin with a knock at the door? It's our Halloween special, and yes, we're in costume for this one! You can watch the full video episode on YouTube to see our spooky fits and all the eerie expressions that didn't make it into the audio version.  YouTube version here: https://youtu.be/4m_GjUftczU?si=BZjiIbPxxeqbkCoQ If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

This Halloween season, we're tucking you in with true tales that'll make you sleep with one eye open. From a ghost that steals cabled and remotes to a mimic pretending to be someone's mom, these stories are the perfect mix of eerie, intimate, and unexplainable.  You'll hear from Nova, one of the original co-creators, about the night she saw a woman drenched in blood, and a listener whose wife somehow knew what happened in his recurring nightmares, but won't say how. Plus, a husband's chilling encounter on a dark rural road that might not have been entirely human and a ghost that seemingly enjoys a good rocking chair.  So grab a blanket and settle in, it's our October Listener Story special.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

This week, Monica and Cash tumble down the haunted rabbit hole of online listings for cursed and possessed objects, but things get weird fast. One listing vanished right in the middle of recording. One bear named Fanny just wants to play video games. A clown doll refuses to reveal the spirit inside it. And one mysterious doll has Monica eerily close to clicking "Buy Now."   Join us as we explore the scary, the absurd, and the possibly possessed corners of the internet, where every "pre-loved" item might just love you back a little too much.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

This week, we take you to one of Idaho's most haunted historic sites, Stricker Ranch. Once a lonely stop on the Oregon Trail and now home to more than just memories. Armed with our mics, curiosity, and the Ghost Tube app, we revisit our past ghost hunts at the ranch. What started as a calm history chat turned into something else entirely... Let's just say, by the end, we didn't end the episode, the ghosts did. And Monica almost peed her pants.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

From the deserts of Arizona to the jungles of Papua New Guinea, reports of giant winged creatures refuse to die. Are modern pterodactyls gliding through our skies, or are these sightings just misidentified birds and folklore reborn? We dive into the legends, pterosaur eyewitness accounts, and mysteries that keep the skies alive with speculation.  If you or somebody you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

*Contains spoilers for the movie Clown in a Cornfield In this episode we're diving into one of the creepiest pieces of American folklore: the phantom clown sightings. From the terrifying reports of clowns trying to lure kids into vans in 1981, to the strange echoes in 1991, these eerie encounters blur the line between urban legend, mass hysteria, and something much stranger lurking just out of sight.  We'll unpack the history of clown panics, explore how these sightings connect to the mysterious "phantom clown" phenomenon, and even draw some chilling parallels with Clowns in a Cornfield. (Yes, we finally got to talk about it, technical issues be damned.) Are these just trick of fear and imagination, or do phantom clowns belong alongside cryptids and ghosts in the catalog of things that go bump in the night? If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

This episode is truly for mature audiences only! We finally visited Zak Bagans' Haunted Museum in Las Vegas, and we have thoughts. In this episode, we break down our entire experience, from the objects and atmosphere to the ghostly encounter (just one!) and whether it lived up to the hype. We share the good, the bad, and the repulsive. We're being brutally honest about it all. Haunted or hype? Let's talk about it.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

The ash has barely settled from Part 1's dive into the 1980 eruption of Mount St. Helens, but the story isn't finished yet. Because some people believe the mountain didn't just unleash fire and destruction... it unleashed something alive.  In this episode, we meet the legendary Batsquatch, a winged cryptid with glowing red eyes, blue fur, and a knack for terrifying unlucky hikers and pilots. We'll dig into reported sightings, the bizarre details that don't quite add up, and how this monster managed to flap its way into modern pop culture with a hazy IPA brewed in its honor.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

On May 18, 1980, Mount St. Helens unleashed the most catastrophic volcanic eruption in U.S. history. In this first part of our two-part series, we explore the mountain's eerie lore, the warning signs no one could ignore, and the morning when an entire face of the volcano collapsed in the largest landslide ever recorded. We'll take you inside the chaos, destruction, and four tragic deaths that became part of the mountain's story. Next week, we'll trade geology for the bizarre as we dive into a cryptid that was came from the eruption.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

This week's episode is a little chaotic, but hopefully in the best way. From floaty horrors to forest hauntings and glowstick fueled terror, we're diving into four brand new Summerween themed horror stories to cool you off with chills.  It's also a special one: Cash reads a story on air for the very first time!  Stories in this episode: The Last Float- A foggy lake, a missing friend, and a haunting that wants to be remembered. Camp Hollow Eyes- A throwback costume party at an abandoned summer camp turns terrifying.  The Melting Man- A heatwave urban legend proves all too real. Glowstick Hollow- A secret rave in the woods is not what it seems... and leaving might not be an option.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

First of all,  Baddies > Haggies. In this chilling installment of listener stories, we bring you five true tales from people just like you, who encountered the paranormal and lived to tell the tale about it (barely).  First, a mysterious voice calls out at just the right moment, saving one listener from what could've been a deadly fall. Then, an intimate evening is rudely interrupted by an uninvited chaperone...who doesn't take the hint and follows the author home. We also hear from a renter who unknowingly moved into a house haunted by the dark aftermath of a Ouija session gone wrong.  A parent shares the story of their child, who seems to have a rare and eerie gift: the ability to see other people's trauma in a ghostly form. And finally, a woman's terrifying sleep paralysis experience leaves us wondering if what happened in the night was truly just a dream... or something far more real.  Turn out the lights, grab a blanket, and remember, we're probably fine.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]  

What do you get when you mix a robotic hamster-owl, a made-up language, and a government ban? A Furby. In this episode, Monica and Cash dig into the bizarre and unsettling history of everyone's favorite cursed childhood toy. From real life horror stories and tech conspiracy theories to the NSA's paranoia and a possible paranormal connection, we ask: were Furbys haunted...or something worse? If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

In this killer-good episode of Anxious At Bedtime, Monica and Cash dive into the 1997 teen slasher classic I Know What You Did Last Summer. Monica gives a dramatic (and slightly unhinged) retelling of the plot while Cash adds his signature commentary and deep sighs.  We break down everything from the iconic killer's rain slicker to the movie's biggest scares, and of course, rate it on our Anxious Scale, from "We're Fine" to "Turn The Fucking Lights On" (1 to 10 lights, naturally).  You'll also hear some behind-the-scenes fun facts and our personal survival kits- three things we'd take into the movie world if we had to face off with a hook-wielding murderer.  Lock your doors, dim the lights (or don't), and press play, because someone knows what you did last summer.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

In this special tribute episode, Monica and Cash celebrate the legendary Dan Meers, aka KC Wolf, with a series of funny, fictional ghost stories set in Arrowhead Stadium. From haunted hallways to cursed tailgates, Dan Meers takes on paranormal chaos with heart, humor, and a foam finger.  Whether you're a Chiefs fan, a ghost story lover, or just here for the BBQ references, join us as we honor one of Kansas City's greatest with this lighthearted paranormal love letter.  Thank you, Dan Meers for being a wonderful human. And if by some chance you ever listen to this, sorry for the cursing. GO CHIEFS!! If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected] Books referenced: Wolves Can't Fly and Mascot on a Mission

Nestled deep in the woods of Connecticut lies the ghost town of Dudleytown, a place so steeped in darkness that it's been erased from maps and sealed off from the public. Was it doomed by a centuries-old curse, plagued by madness and death, or simply swallowed by the forest itself?  It it all just legend? Or is something truly watching from the trees? If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

In one of the most delightfully unhinged chapters of American wildlife history, Idaho once parachuted live beavers into the wilderness. Yes, actual beavers. With parachutes.  In this mini episode, we dive into the true story of how post-WWII suburbia clashed with beaver behavior, the legend of Elmo Heter (Idaho Fish and Game's most chaotic genius), and how one brave rodent named Geronimo became the world's first skydiving beaver.  We laugh a lot, because it's truly absurd, but we also unpack the ecological brilliance behind these fluffy little ecosystem engineers and why we should all respect the beaver hustle.  Disclaimer: No, we don't condone throwing animals out of planes, parachute or not. This was a real program in the 1940s, and thankfully, wildlife relocation has come a long way since then.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

This week we dive headfirst into the haunted corners of eBay to uncover some of the creepiest, weirdest, and most haunted objects currently up for sale. From cursed dolls to ghost-infested keys, we explore the bizarre listings, read chilling item descriptions, and share our takes on whether we'd dare bring any of these spooky treasures home.  Listener discretion advised: We're not responsible if you invite a ghost into your house.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

We're back! This special mini episode marks our return, and though it's shorter than usual, it's filled with something we all need right now: hope. Join us as we explore the mysterious and miraculous stories of the Butterfly People, angelic figures reported by survivors of the devastating Joplin tornado. Whether you believe in miracles or just need a reason to look for light in the rubble, this one's for you.  This episode is lovingly dedicated to Katt Morris, Cash's mom. May she rest gently and be forever remembered.  We would also like to make a correction. In the episode, Monica says the tornado was an E5. It was an EF5. 

We're heartbroken to share that Cash's mom is missing. She left her home around 1am without her phone, wallet, medications, or cane, and hasn't been seen since. We've shared all the missing person information on our social medias. If you're able to share or keep an eye out, it means the world.  Thank you for understanding. We love you. We'll be back when we can. 

Is it just a game... or a gateway? In this episode of Anxious At Bedtime, we had our ChatGPT conjure eight terrifying tales of Ouija board encounters - each one darker, stranger, and more unsettling than the last. From cursed packages to whispering walls, nothing is off-limits once the planchette starts to move. So, light a candle, hold your breath, and don't forget to say goodbye. Because you never know who's listening.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

In this chilling episode of our Ouija series, we're diving into the real stories - the ones that kept people awake at night long after the board was packed away. These aren't urban legends. These are firsthand accounts of Ouija board sessions that went way too far, encounters with entities that didn't leave when the game ended, and the lingering effects that followed.  From shadowy figures to ominous messages that came true, these tales might make you think twice before asking, "Is anyone there?" Spoiler alert, someone usually is.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Think you're ready to play with a Ouija board? In Part 2 of our deep dive, we're talking rules of the game, both the well-known ones and the ones whispered about in paranormal circles. We'll walk you through how to mentally and energetically protect yourself, and cleanse your space (and the board), and the worse places to break out the planchette. Plus, we get into the fascinating, and slightly chaotic, Blindfold Theory - is your subconscious the one spelling out messages, or is something else moving the planchette? Light a candle (or don't, idk), don't forget to say goodbye, and remember... we're probably fine.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the pod, please email it to [email protected]

In this first installment of our Ouija board series, we dive into the eerie history of the infamous sleepover seance tool. Learn how the board named itself, why the U.S. Patent Office believed it could talk, and how it sparked not one, but two intense family feuds. We'll tell you how the mysterious death of Ouija board mogul William Fuld was blamed on the board itself - and how its co-creator, Helen Peters Nosworthy went from being one of the board's biggest supporters to warning people of its powers. Grab your favorite blanket, light a candle, and remember: we're probably fine.  If you or someone you know has ever had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

In this chaotic episode, we put on our tin foil hats and speculate on the ultimate ghost hangouts. From amusement parks to shopping malls, we dive into the weird and wonderful places that would make perfect haunts. Which locations offer the best entertainment for the restless dead? Tune in as we debate and theorize the most unexpected paranormal playgrounds.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Surprise, surprise, we talk about poop and butts again.  Step back into the unsettling world of historical medicine, where doctors prescribed tobacco smoke enemas for drowning victims, miracle weight loss pills packed a deadly punch, and teething babies endured the horrors of teeth lancing. But for all the bizarre and horrifying treatments, some medical experts of the past were surprisingly close to real breakthroughs, despite having no idea how things actually worked. Were they just lucky, or was there something eerily intuitive about their methods? Join us as we explore the fine line between medical madness and accidental genius.  If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Forget everything you think you know about leprechauns. In this episode of Anxious At Bedtime, we're diving deep into the mischievous world of Ireland's most famous fairy folk. We'll explore the original color associated with them, how the King of Ulster fits into their legend, and dig into three documented sightings that'll make you wonder what's really hiding at the end of the rainbow. Grab a lucky charm or two and get cozy - but remember; we're probably fine.   If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

We let AI take the weel - metaphorically, of course - and had ChatGPT write us some original scary stories, and wow, did it deliver. This episode is packed with eerie and hilarious tales, including a ghostly football fan that refuses to leave the game, a poor crunchwrap that witnesses things it never should have seen, and a do-good haunted llama. Buckle up, because this is going to be a weird one.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Off the coast of Venice lies Poveglia, an island so haunted that even the Italian government refuses to use it. Once a mass grave for plague victims and later home to a nightmarish insane asylum, Poveglia is steeped in centuries of tragedy and terror. From eerie whispers and shadowy figures to the legend of a mad doctor who met a gruesome fate, the island's spirits refuse to rest. Join us as we uncover the dark history and terrifying hauntings of Italy's most forbidden island.    Sorry for the technical difficulties. This should be the whole episode.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Looking for love in all the haunted places? In this episode, we're diving into the dating profiles of your favorite cryptids and paranormal entities! Get ready for monstrous pickup lines, eerie romantic confessions, and a whole lot of supernatural seduction. Who would you date, ghost, or run screaming from? Tune in and find out! This is for entertainment purposes only. Please do not use any part of this episode as dating advice. We know literally nothing about dating paranormal creatures.  If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Deep in the heart of New Orleans' French Quarter stands the Pharmacy Museum, a place filled with eerie relics of early medicine - but also something far more sinister. Allegedly. Legend has it that a doctor once practiced and murdered within these walls, leaving behind a chilling legacy of suffering. Now, his ghost is said to haunt the museum, a spectral reminder of his dark deeds. Join us as we uncover the twisted history, ghostly encounters, and spine-tingling lore of one of the city's most infamous haunts. We're probably fine..right?   If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the pod, please email it to [email protected]

! We are doing a giveaway that ends February 1st. If you want to enter, email us for more information or find details on our Instagram or Tiktok !   What if a simple painting could bring disaster into your home? Since the 1980s, tales of the Crying Boy paintings have spread fear across the UK. Are they cursed? Is it a coincidence? Or is something more sinister at play? Monica and Cash dig into the eerie history, the skeptics' take, and whether you should think twice before hanging art on your wall. Don't worry - we're probably fine.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Step into the Wild West as we explore the history of the Fort Worth Stockyards, a once-thriving hub of cattle drivers and saloon doors swinging open. But not all the echoes of the past have faded. Join us as we uncover the eerie tales and numerous reported hauntings of Miss Molly's Hotel, a historic landmark said to be home to restless spirits. From phantom shit talking to full body apparitions, this episode is a journey through time and the paranormal.  If you or someone you know has experienced something paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

This week we explore the tale of the Greenbrier Ghost, the only case in U.S. history where a ghost's testimony helped solve a murder. Discover the haunting story of Zona Heaster Shue, whose restless spirit revealed the truth about her untimely death to her mother, leading to the conviction of her murderer.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the pod, please email it to [email protected]

In this episode, we explore the time-honored tradition of telling ghost stories during the holiday season. First, we unravel the eerie legend of the haunted Christmas tree, where festive lights conceal a sinister secret. Then, we delve into the tragic tale of the Mistletoe Bride, a ghostly bride whose search for love ended in a chilling disappearance. Snuggle up but keep the lights on.    As we ring in the New Year, we wanted to let you know that Anxious At Bedtime will be taking a short break next week to recharge and prepare for an exciting year ahead. This means there won't be a new episode, but we'll be back the following week with more spine-tingling stories and paranormal fun.   If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal and would like to have that story read on the pod, please email it [email protected]

Dive into the dark and fascinating origins of Yule traditions! From Odin, the god of death, to the evolution of Santa Claus, and the terrifying legend of Krampus, we uncover the eerie roots of the holiday season. Also, did they find Santa Claus's body? Tune in with your best spooky friends to hear all about it!   If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal and would like to have your story read on the pod, please email it to [email protected] Happy Holidays!

In this chilling episode, we trek deep into the snowy peaks of folklore and mystery to explore the legend of the Yeti. From ancient tales to more modern-day expeditions, we unravel the origins of this elusive cryptid and examine the evidence behind its existence. Has the Yeti not been found because he's busy scoring touchdowns on the field? Join us as we uncover the truth - and decide if we really are probably fine.    If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal and would like to have your story read on the pod, please email to [email protected]  

Monica and Cash dive headfirst into the weird and wild this week, unpacking a few juicy conspiracies, UAP sightings, and ghostly topics. Was there really an intergalactic throwdown scheduled for December 3rd, or was it just internet hype? Tune in for playful banter, hilarious theories, and a few spooky chills along the way. You're going to want to grab your tinfoil hat for this one!

We wrap up our discussion of Lake Superior with how the Edmund Fitgerald was doomed from the start, the harrowing story of Charlie and Angelique Mott, and everything we know about Mishipeshu.    If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal that you would like to have read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Your favorite trio talks aliens, probing, and eventually Lake Superior.    If you or someone you know has had a brush with the paranormal and you would like to share that story with the pod, please email it to [email protected]

In what is quite possibly our most chaotic episode yet, the gang talks (mostly) about Halloween, its traditions, and how it came to be the holiday we know and love.    If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal and would like to have your story read on the pod, please email it to [email protected]

Monica, who is very sick and apologizes for her scratchy voice, tells us a true story about thievery, possible mistaken identity, a potential curse, misfortune, heartache, and a very haunted house.    If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal and would like to have your story read on the pod, please email it [email protected]

It's a Nova episode! If you or someone you know has experienced the paranormal and would like to share that story, please email it to [email protected]

Monica teaches us about two infamous ghost ships. One, named the Princess Augusta and nicknamed the Palatine Light, is an actual ghost of a ship with a dark past. The other, named the Lyubov Orlova, has a more glitz and glam past life, with an even scarier retirement.  If you or someone you know has experienced something paranormal and would like to have that story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Nova shares about Banshees, why they wail, and what their favorite object is.    If you or somebody you know has had an experience with the paranormal and would like to have your story read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Monica, Cash, and Nova read personal paranormal accounts from listeners!    If you or someone you know has had an experience with the paranormal that you would like to have read on the podcast, please email it to [email protected]

Nova explains to us the mysterious circumstances around two separate disappearances. Brandon Swanson went missing on May 14, 2008 in Minnesota. Maura Murray went missing on February 9, 2004 in New Hampshire. Both disappeared while driving alone and neither have been seen or heard from since. The cases are not related, but both are shrouded in mystery and the unknown.    If you or someone you know has any information on the whereabouts of either person or any information that could assist in the search for these individuals, please contact the appropriate authorities.  For Brandon Swanson:  The Lincoln County Sherriff's Office 1-507-694-1664 FBI ViCap 1-800-634-4097 or you can email [email protected]  For Maura Murray: New Hampshire State Police Cold Case Unity 603-223-3860 or email [email protected]  The family's website is https://www.mauramurraymissing.org  Julie Murray's podcast is "Media Pressure"