That Scared the Crap Out of Me

Hey hey, we are back with a new episode just in time for the holidays! On this episode, we are sharing some of our most interesting holiday celebration stories, along with our favorite Christmas movies, songs, and memories.Happy holidays to everyone! See you in 2026.

WE ARE BACK...This week we are circling back around to past episodes that have updates, including : Amy Bradly, Madeline Soto, and The 7M TikTok cult.

This week, we are asking each other a series of questions that are either funny, informative, and some even a bit emotional.Listen along, and share your answers with us on our Instagram or TikTok (@thatscaredmepod)!

We returned for another ghost hunt at Rolling Hills Asylum...Listen to our thoughts on our experience this time around. We finish the episode off with some evidence we found - give a listen and tell us what you hear/think.

We continue the Love Canal story this week, along with two other WNY tragedies.Stories covered: Love Canal, Loretta Gates & Terri Bills, and Leichia Reilly.

We get back to it with some local tragedies that shook our community and had us reflecting about whether you truly know someone or not.The stories we cover: The Bike Path Killer, The Wendy's Homicide, and Love Canal (finished on volume 2).

**NOTE** Kristie meant to say that Heather O’Rourke became ill in 1987 - not passed away in 1987 🤦🏻‍♀️!!This week, we are chatting about Hollywood paranormal movies that have been "loosely" based on true stories, and the theories surrounding them.

This week, we decided to come back with part two of Get Your Popcorn Ready - where we each share what we are watching (shows, movies, documentaries), reading (books...), and listening (podcasts, audiobooks, music) to - and we think you should check them out too!

This week, we discuss the tragic story of vlogger, Gabby Petito.If you, or someone you know needs help regarding domestic abuse, please call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at (800)799-7233 or text BEGIN to 88788.https://gabbypetitofoundation.org/https://www.thehotline.org/

This week, we are chatting about the Hulu documentary and details regarding the vlogger Ruby Franke.Next week, we will continue our vlogger episode when we talk about Gabby Petito.

Hi - welcome back!We are so excited to be back, and we hope y'all are too!This week, we discuss any updates we have from our previous episodes, and we chat about two hot topics flooding the media right now: airplanes and the Blake & Justin drama.

Hey everyone! It's been a hot minute, but we just wanted to grace you all with our beautiful voices to share with you that we are coming back! We may not have an episode weekly, but we are going to try for bi-weekly. Thank you for your patience, and we can't wait to connect again!!!!

Hello again! We are back with an all new episode & season, and we are starting it off with a BANG! On this weeks episode, we share our thoughts and evidence from our investigation of Rolling Hills Asylum. Grab some headphones and listen closely to our EVPs - and head over to our instagram (@thatscaredmepod) for more photos and a video clip of the "whistle" we caught.

*TRIGGER WARNING* This episode is graphic. We are back! This week we are discussing historical cold cases. The cases are: The Chicago Tylenol Murders, Jack the Ripper, and The Black Dahlia.

*Trigger Warning* On this week's episode, we each discuss a current case that has taken the media by storm, and has left everyone wondering what actually happened??? The cases are: Noah Presgrove Doug Benefield (The Black Swan Trial) John O'Keefe (Karen Read)

We are back with a new episode! This week we are chatting about our biggest fears, along with real-life stories that have happened to solidify our fears...and provide us with more anxiety (awesome - good times!).

*Trigger Warning: This episode contains graphic details* This week, we are reviewing the unsolved cases of Caylee Anthony, Madeleine McCann, and JonBenet Ramsey. We are chatting about the case details, conspiracy theories behind them, and what our theories are.

Hey hey heyyyy, we are back! This week we lay out all of our favorite book, movie, and show recommendations for the following categories: Please be advised, some of the following have trigger warnings and SPOILERS! -Psychological Thrillers -Supernatural -Horror -Scary Dramas -Scary Campy

This episode we discuss the unusual and unexpected deaths of Marilyn Monroe, Brittany Murphy and Naya Rivera.

This week we decided to share some of our weird, scary and random neighbor encounters and stories.

This week we dive deep into the scary and strange world of different cults!

This week we share chilling urban legends that are some of our favorites from over the years!

On this week's episode we dive deep, spitting facts and feelings regarding a scandal that rocked millions of marriages across the world -- the 2015 hack of Ashleymadison.com.

On this weeks episode, we discuss the horrific and puzzling homicides of four college students attending the University of Idaho -- some will know this case as "The Idaho 4". Join us, as we talk about the timeline of events, and speculate about what we think took place that night.

Let's get back to it! On this weeks episode we break-down all of the HOT celebrity happenings that are swirling around social media right now. Diddy, Drake vs. Kendrick, the Met Gala...we chat about all of it!!!

LISTEN TO THE END FOR DETAILS REGARDING OUR GIVEAWAY!!! This weeks episode is a recap on season 1! We are reflecting upon each episode, along with any updates we may have for the news/true crime stories we spoke about, or mistakes that we need to correct. *We will be taking a short break, and will be returning for season 2 in May!!!!*

In Part 2 of A Family Haunting, we are joined by our mom and our brother Michael, as we share our story about a night that shook us ALL to our cores...we will never know exactly what we saw, but we've all agreed that we are OK with never knowing.

This week (and next), we are reminiscing about one of our childhood homes that changed our lives forever. In part 1, we chat about the history of Grand Island, NY, and the history of the home...along with the reoccurring themes for the families who lived in the home.

This week, we decided to keep our Freaky Friday (if you follow us on Insta and/or TikTok you will know what we are talking about) theme going by taking turns, chatting about current events that scare us, freak us out, or leave us wondering "what the heck is going on?!".

WE'RE ON A BOAT! This weeks episode was recorded in our mini-suite, on the Sky Princess Cruise Ship! We discuss the mysterious disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley, and the events/people/things, etc. that scared the crap out of us (and the things that excited us) on our Western Caribbean cruise. So, come aboard the ~loooooveeeeee boooaattttt~ with us :)

This week we share the most memorable spiritual encounters we've had in our lives - outside of a childhood home we grew up in, but that's for another episode to come! Spirits have always been around us, but some encounters leave lasting impressions...

This episode is a bit different from the others we have done, as we decided to take a bit of a more serious tone, discussing the cases of Elisa Lam and Kenneka Jenkins. Two, young girls who tragically lost their lives at such young ages. For some reason, their stories have stuck with us, so much so, that we felt the need to openly talk about them.

In honor of Valentine's Day, we talk about a student-teacher romance gone bad, and the personal connection it has to Kristie & Michelle. We also spill the tea with our own NSFW bad romance stories that scared the crap out of us (and had us running for the hills!). WARNING: This episode contains sexual & adult content.

This week we chat about movies and games that have left a lasting impression on us...but first, we dive into a terrifying encounter the three of us experienced at a movie theatre. If you have had any scary movie theatre experiences or would like to recommend your favorite (or frightening) movies and games -- pop over to TikTok and/or Instagram to let us know, or email us at [email protected]

This week we chat about our (and others) spooky stays at the Holiday Inn on Grand Island, NY -- and the stories surrounding Tanya (the ghost) rumored to haunt the 4th floor. Be sure to head over to our Instagram (@thatscaredmepod) or TikTok (@thatscaredmepod) for photos of the hotel, and a hair-raising photo of "Tanya".

What the heck is this podcast about??? Give the trailer a quick listen to find out what we have in store for - That Scared the Crap Out of Me.