Peculiar Tales

A ventriloquist dummy that felt a little too real…Strange stories. Unsettling rumors and a legend that refuses to die.This week on Peculiar Tales with Dawn & Kristy, we dig into the eerie myths surrounding Charlie McCarthy and the truth behind them.Was it all just an act… or something more? Support the show

Amelia Earhart’s final words were clear—but what followed was silence.In this episode of Peculiar Tales, we trace Amelia’s rise as a pioneering aviator and unravel the chilling mystery of her 1937 disappearance. From her final flight toward Howland Island to the decades of theories that followed, one question remains:What really happened to Amelia Earhart?Support the show

In 1878, a quiet home in Amherst, Nova Scotia became the center of one of Canada’s most chilling mysteries.In this episode of Peculiar Tales, we explore the story of Esther Cox and the strange events that surrounded her — violent knocking, moving objects, unexplained fires, and messages appearing without explanation. With dozens of witnesses claiming to see the disturbances firsthand, the case quickly became one of the most well-documented paranormal stories of its time.Was it a poltergeist? A response to trauma? Or something else entirely?More than a century later, the mystery still remains unsolved.Support the show

Easter is meant to be a time of light and renewal… but some stories suggest something darker lingers beneath the surface.In this episode of Peculiar Tales, we explore creepy, supposedly true Easter stories from the dead seen at their own graves to strange traditions rooted in fear and unexplained encounters.What if Easter isn’t just about what rises… but what never left?Support the show

In February of 1978, five men left Northern California to attend a basketball game and never made it home. Days later, their car was found abandoned deep in the Plumas National Forest, miles in the wrong direction and surrounded by snow.The Yuba County Five case is filled with unanswered questions. Why did they drive so far off course? Why leave a working car? And what happened to Gary Mathias, whose remains were never found?In this episode of Peculiar Tales, we explore who these men were, the night they vanished, and why, decades later none of it still makes sense.Support the show

Maps showed it to be a place to go to, west of Ireland, an islandthat could vanish and reappear at will every 7 years. Then asquick as it made its way on maps it was excluded after time, afterthe stories, after the expeditions. Is the Island out there? Is theland simply a myth? In this episode we are following the mapsthrough time to try to find answers to these questions., maybesome places are not lost, perhaps they are hidden.Support the show

A family massacred while they slept. A village with it’s secrets and anger, a court determined to convict quickly, and an innocent man’s name that would take136 years to clear. This story is about, a heinous crime and the injustices that followed, and remained a stain on Irish history, this story isn’t just aboutviolence, it is also about innocence and ignorance.Support the show

Okanagan lake is deep and calm, maybe too calm. Whispershave been heard of a shadow beneath the water, a shadow thatcomes to the surface long enough to remind us that the lake hassecrets, and by some accounts the whispers are nothing less thenterrifying.Support the show: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2515241/supportSupport the show

On February 14th, 1929, seven men were lined up against a brick wall inside a Chicago garage and executed in broad daylight.No arrests. No convictions. No justice.In this episode of Peculiar Tales, we dive into the chilling story of the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre one of the most infamous crimes of the Prohibition era. Fuelled by gang rivalry, carried out by men disguised as police officers, and soaked in the violence of 1920s Chicago, this brutal act shocked the nation and changed how America viewed organized crime forever.At the centre of it all: Al Capone, Bugs Moran, and a city ruled by bootlegging, corruption, and fear.Dark. Bold. Unforgettable.This is the crime that made the country stop and look.Support the show

Some stories don’t end—they echo.Peg Entwistle was a promising young actress chasing success from Broadway to Hollywood. But behind the dream were heartbreak, rejection, and a future that never arrived. Her tragic death tied her forever to the Hollywood sign… and to a legend that refuses to fade.In this episode of Peculiar Tales, Dawn and Kristy explore Peg’s rise, her struggles, and the night that made her infamous. Then, decades later, the chilling reports begin—ghostly figures, whispered voices, and the scent of gardenias drifting through the hills.Some stories end. Others echo.Support the show

When actor Charles Coghlan died, in 1899 his coffin was lost at sea- only to resurface years later in Prince Edward Island. Was this coincidence or maybe something else? Support the show

Between the fine line of history and folklore, are threads of truth intertwined with fiction. There were warnings and there were deaths, and there was always the greed! Join us while we dive into the tale that has baffled many people for 155 plus years.....a story of gold.Support the show

In this episode we step into the shadow of the holiday season. Wherethe beautiful lights and the holiday songs are not enough to chaseaway the darkness of what some call an ancient creature. This is notthe usual Christmas tale that you might remember, this is a walkthrough the dark side of the holiday. From the Alpine region villagesto North America, we will uncover the fear and festivities ofKrampus and why some never want to hear the chains clanking in thecold of December.Some traditions were never meant to bring joy…This is The December Devil. Support the show

Before the bestselling novel. Before the blockbuster film. There was a real woman whose disappearance shocked the public.In this episode of Peculiar Tales, we explore the chilling true case often called the original “Gone Girl.” What began as an ordinary relationship quickly unraveled into a mystery filled with contradictions, unsettling clues, and lingering doubt. Was she truly a victim, or was everything part of a carefully constructed lie?Join us as we peel back the layers of this haunting story. A real-life mystery that feels as though it belongs in an Agatha Christie novel, except this time, the crime was real. This is The original “Gone Girl.” Support the show

Hooves, Hides and Hidden Creatures Winter legends of Wales and Iceland. Let’s go to worlds where winter nights echo with ancient footsteps, ritual songs, and creatures older than folklore itself. In This episode we are diving into uncanny holiday traditions from the snow and windswept edges of Europe. Support the show

On Christmas Day 1929, the Lawson family of rural North Carolina became the center of one of America’s most haunting tragedies. In this episode, Dawn and Kristy uncover the chilling story of Charlie Lawson a father who murdered his wife and six children before taking his own life and the lingering mystery of why it happened. From the eerie family portrait to decades of rumors, folklore, and unanswered questions, we explore the facts behind a Christmas crime that shook the nation and still unsettles us nearly a century later.This is the The Lawson Family MurdersListener discretion advised.Support the show

In the dim corners of every town lurks tales that come out in the dark, some swear that the tales are true, while others say the tales are nothing more then folklore. Some tales will tell of an axe murderer,or a hook handed man out for revenge, or even a headless man who rides in the fog every fall.Join us in this episode  while we challenge what you think you know. Listen as we blur the lines between fact and fiction. We will give you a few tales and you can guess which one in grounded in fact.Dare to decide true tale or Urban legends?Support the show

Across the landscapes of Ontario are the remains of19 th century military forts, they are solemn witnessesto what was a turbulent past. The barracks nowcarefully preserved once echoed with the sounds ofthunderous cannons, and the clatter of muskets andsoldiers shouting are now much quieter. If you listencarefully, well maybe you can hear the wind carryingthe sounds that no living person was supposed tohear. Fragments of the past now caught betweenthis world and the next.Support the show

In this episode we tell the story of Mary Celeste a ship found drifting at sea her sails torn and tattered, no crew on board, no signs of struggle. What happened to the crew of the Mary Celeste? This question has puzzled and fascinated people for generations.Join us as we tell her story and discuss what could have happened. This is The Ghost Ship Mary CelesteSupport the show

In this eerie and chilling episode, we explore 2 cemeteries that have dark history and local legends.  Graves, ghosts & grim tales is what  make up these haunted cemeteries that awaits on  this Halloween.  Support the show

This Devil’s Night, we’re diving into where it all began. Before the fires and fear, there was Gate Night a night of harmless pranks that slowly transformed into something much darker. We talk about the legends behind Devil’s Night, how Detroit became ground zero for the chaos, and the stories that still haunt the city today. From folklore to firestorms, this episode sheds light on one of Halloween’s most infamous traditions.This is Tales Of Devil's NightSupport the show

In this chilling episode, we dive deep into one of the most infamous cases of alleged demonic possession in American history the exorcism of Roland Doe. Known as the real-life inspiration behind The Exorcist, Roland’s story involves mysterious scratches, flying objects, guttural voices, and a series of dramatic exorcisms performed by Catholic priests.Who was Roland Doe? What really happened in that Maryland home? Was it truly a case of possession, or a misunderstood medical or psychological condition? Join us as we explore and examine the cultural impact of a case that continues to haunt and fascinate decades later.This is The Exorcist Of Roland Doe Support the show

In this chilling episode, we delve into one of the most infamous cases in American history — the brutal double murder that shook Fall River, Massachusetts in 1892. Andrew and Abby Borden were found hacked to death in their own home, and soon suspicion turned toward Andrew’s daughter, Lizzie.Was she a cold-blooded killer driven by greed, jealousy, and resentment — or an innocent woman caught in a storm of class prejudice and sensational headlines? Dawn and Kristy uncover the tangled web of social status, scandal, and suspicion that surrounded Lizzie Borden’s life, trial, and mysterious acquittal.Join us as we revisit the crime scene, sift through the evidence, and explore the haunting legacy that still lingers inside the infamous Borden house — now a bed-and-breakfast said to be haunted by its past.This is The legend of Lizzie Borden Support the show

Step into one of Canada’s most chilling legends—the Baldoon Mystery. This haunting tale from early 19th-century Ontario begins with the McDonald family, whose peaceful farmstead was shaken by a relentless series of bizarre and terrifying events.Fires erupted without cause, bullets and rocks pelting their home from unseen forces, and poltergeist activity. Was it the curse of a witch, or something even more sinister that no priest, neighbour, or man of faith could drive away?Join us as we uncover the documented accounts, eerie witness testimonies, and the strange “solution” said to have finally ended the torment. The Baldoon Mystery has endured for generations, not just as a ghost story, but as a chilling reminder of how fear, folklore, and reality can intertwine.This is The Baldoon Mystery.Support the show

A time remembered for its elegance but also steeped in darkness & dread. Behind the lace curtains & polished manners lay obsession with death & the macabre.From mourning rituals to bizarre medical cures that promised health while flirting with danger the Victorians lived in a world where superstition and science often collided. This is the Victorian era.Support the show

A socialite of her time, in the roaring 20's she was known for being a wife to her husband but she has her own ambitions of setting out and making a name for herself. However her tale has sadness, excitement and tragedy woven together like a spiderweb of emotions and resilience. Join us while we tell you of Zelda Fitzgerald.   Support the show

In this special edition of Peculiar Tales, hosts Dawn and Kristy launch the first episode of what we hope becomes a recurring series: Legend or Tale?We’ve gathered four mysterious stories, three are urban legends passed down through the shadows, and one is entirely true. Can you figure out which one it is?Listen closely, question everything, and put your instincts to the test. Will you spot the truth hidden among the peculiar tales?This is Legend or Tale?Support the show

Trains carry more than just passengers — sometimes, they carry the echoes of the past. In this episode, we explore four haunted train stations where whispers of tragedy, loss, and the unexplained still linger on the platforms.From ghostly apparitions, terrifying sounds and even animal ghosts.Why do these places seem frozen in time? And what is it about train stations that draws spirits to linger long after their final departure?Whether you're a believer or a skeptic, these stories may have you thinking twice next time you hear a distant whistle in the night. This is Haunted Train Stations.Support the show

In this chilling episode, we tell the story of the mysterious and haunting case of Emma Keyse, a woman whose brutal murder sent shock waves through a quiet community, and led to one of the most baffling attempted executions in British history. At the centre of it all stands a man whose execution defied death itself, earning him the eerie nickname: The Man They Could Not Hang.What really happened on that fateful night? And how did a failed hanging turn into a legend that still echoes today?This is The Case Of Emma Keyse & The Man They Could Not Hang⚠️ Trigger Warning: This episode contains discussions of hanging, execution, and graphic details related to violent crime and murder. Listener discretion is advised.Support the show

In an isolated corner of Canada, there is place wrapped in mystery of the complete unknown, a story that tells of the disappearance of an entire tribe of Inuit, as well as a twist with possible supernatural and a splash of outer limits.join us while we dig into the secrets, of one of Canada's unsolved Mysteries. That include a famous author of the time and a journalist who broke the story to the world. This is a Nunavut MysterySupport the show

Welcome to our very first episode! In this chilling debut, we dive into the twisted corridors and haunted halls of the Winchester Mystery House a sprawling, bizarre mansion said to be built under the guidance of restless spirits.Was Sarah Winchester driven by grief, madness, or something much darker? Join us as we explore the strange history behind one of America’s most mysterious homes, where staircases lead to nowhere, doors open into walls, and the line between legend and reality is as crooked as the house itself.We’ll unpack the personal tragedy that haunted Sarah, the spiritual warnings that may have inspired the endless construction, and the legacy of a home shrouded in superstition and sorrow. This is The House That Spirits Built.Support the show