Skip to content
00 - Introduction Part 1 - The Republic - Plato episode artwork

May 20, 2024 18 min

00 - Introduction Part 1 - The Republic - Plato

from The Daily Logic Library Hosted by solgoodmedia.com

https://www.solgoodmedia.com Listen to hundreds of audiobooks, thousands of short stories, and ambient sounds all ad free! "The Daily Logic Library" is a sanctuary of reason, where daily discussions delve into the rules of logic and the structure of arguments. Perfect for anyone looking to sharpen their reasoning skills and understand the building blocks of effective communication. This episode includes AI-generated content.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

00 - Introduction Part 1 - The Republic - Plato

0:00 18:49
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Looking for something meaningful to listen to. Visit PodcastLibrary.org. A growing home for timeless audio books, classic radio dramas, educational talks, history, philosophy, and thousands of hours of spoken word audio, all free to stream. Whether you want to relax, learn something new, or rediscover voices from the past, Podcast Library makes it easy to find something worth hearing.

Start listening today at P-O-D-C-A-S-T-L-I-D-R-A-R-Y.org. Part 1 of the introduction to Play is a production of the virtual world of the world as many as possible. Whether you want to provide access to the world of service, visit PodcastLibrary.org. A growing home for timeless audio books, classic radio dramas, educational talks, history, philosophy, and thousands of hours of spoken word audio, all free to stream.

Whether you want to relax, learn something new, or rediscover voices from the past, Podcast Library makes it easy to find something worth hearing. Start listening today at Part 1 of the introduction to Plato's Republic, translated by Benjamin Jowet. The Republic of Plato is the longest of his works with the exception of the laws, and is certainly the greatest of them. There are nearer approaches to modern metaphysics in the syllabus and in the selfist.

The politicus or statesmen is more ideal. The form and institutions of the state are more clearly drawn out in the laws. As works of art, the symposium and the protagonists are of higher excellence. But no other dialogue of Plato has the same largeness of you and the same perfection of style.

While other shows an equal knowledge of the world, or contains, more of those thoughts which are new as well as old, and not of one age only, but of all. Nowhere in Plato is there a deeper irony, or a greater wealth of humor or imagery or more dramatic power. Nor in any other of his writings is the attempt made to interweave life and speculation, or to connect politics with philosophy. The Republic is the center around which the other dialogues may be grouped.

Here philosophy reaches the highest point, to which ancient thinkers ever attained. Plato among the Greeks, like Bacon among the Moderns, was the first to conceive the method of knowledge, although neither of them distinguished, the bare outline, or form, from the substance of truth, and both of them had to be content with an abstraction of science which was not yet realized. He was the greatest metaphysical genius who in the world has ever seen, and in him, more than in any other ancient thinker, the germs of future knowledge are contained. The sciences of logic and psychology, which have supplied so many instruments of thought to after ages, are based upon the analyses of Socrates and Plato.

The principles of definition, the law of contradiction, the fallacy of arguing in a circle, the distinction between essence and accidents of a thing or notion, between means and ends, between causes and conditions, also the division of the mind into the rational, concommission, and irascible elements, or of pleasures and desires, into necessary and unnecessary. These and other great forms of thought are all of them to be found in the Republic, and were probably first invented by Plato. The greatest of all logical truths, and the one of which writers on philosophy are most apt to lose sight, the difference between words and things, has been most strenuously insisted on by him, although he has not always avoided the confusion of them in his own writings. But he does not bind up truth in logical formulae.

Logic is still veiled in metaphysics, and the science which he imagines to, contemplate all truth and all existence, is very unlike the doctrine of the syllogism which Aristotle claims to have discovered. Neither must we forget that the Republic is but the third part of a still larger design, which was to have included an ideal history of Athens, as well as a political and physical philosophy. The fragment of the Kritius has given birth to a world-famous fiction, second only in importance to the tale of Troy, in the legend of Arthur, and is said as a fact to have inspired some of the early navigators of the sixteenth century. This mythical tale, of which the subject was a history of the wars of the Athenians against the island of Atlantis, is supposed to be founded upon an unfinished poem of Solon, to which it would have stood in the same relation as the writings of the logographers to the poems of Homer.

It would have told of a struggle for liberty intended to represent the conflict of Persia and Helles. We may judge from the noble commencement of the Timnius from the fragment of the Kritius itself, and from the third book of the laws, in which manner Plato would have treated this high argument. We can only guess why the great design was abandoned, perhaps because Plato became sensible of some incongruity in a fictitious history, or because he had lost his interest in it, or because advancing years forbade the completion of it. We may please ourselves with the fancy that, had this imaginative narrative ever been finished, we would have found Plato himself sympathizing with the struggle for Hellenic independence, singing a hymn of triumph over marathon and celamis, perhaps making the reflection of Herodotus where he contemplates the growth of the Athenian Empire.

Hobreba Thing is freedom of speech which has made the Athenians so far exceed every other state of Helles in greatness. Or more probably, attributing the victory to the ancient good order of Athens and to the favor of Apollo and Athena. Again Plato may be regarded as the captain, or leader of a goodly band of followers, for in the Republic is to be found the original of Cicero's de Republica, of St. Augustine's city of God, of the utopia of Sir Thomas More, and of the numerous other imaginary states which are framed upon the same model.

The extent to which Aristotle or the Aristotlian school were indebted to him in the politics has been little recognized, and the recognition is the more necessary because it is not made by Aristotle himself. The two philosophers had more in common than they were conscious of, and probably some elements of Plato remain still undetected in Aristotle. In English philosophy too, many affinities may be traced, not only in the works of the Cambridge Platonists, but in the great original writers like Berkeley or Coleridge, to Plato and his ideas. That there is a truth higher than experience, of which the mind bears witness to herself, is a conviction which in our generation has been enthusiastically asserted, and is perhaps gaining ground.

Of the Greek authors who, at the Renaissance, brought a new life into the world, Plato has had the greatest influence. The Republic of Plato is also the first treatise upon education, of which the writings of Milton and Locke, Rousseau, Jean-Paul, and Gautre are the legitimate descendants. Like Dante or Bunyan, he has a revelation of another life. Like Bacon, he is profoundly impressed with the unity of knowledge.

In the early church he exercised a real influence on theology, and at the revival of literature on politics. Even the fragments of his words when, repeated at second hand, have in all ages ravished the hearts of men who have seen reflected in them their own higher nature. He is the father of idealism in philosophy, in politics, in literature, in many of the latest conceptions of modern thinkers and statesmen, such as the unity of knowledge, the reign of law and the equality of the sexes have been anticipated in a dream by him. The argument of the Republic is the search after justice, the nature of which is first hinted at by Cephalus, the just and blameless old man, then discussed on the basis of proverbial morality by Socrates and Polymarkis, then caricatured by Thrasimakis, and partially explained by Socrates, reduced to an abstraction by Glaucon and Adei Montes, and, having become invisible in the individual, reappears at length in the ideal state which is constructed by Socrates.

The first care of the rulers is to be education, of which an outline is drawn after the old Hellenic model, providing only for an improved religion and morality, and more simplicity in music and gymnastic, a manlier strain of poetry, in greater harmony of the individual in the state. We are thus led on to the conception of a higher state, in which no man calls anything his own, and in which there is neither marrying nor giving in marriage, and kings are philosophers, and philosophers are kings. And there is another, and higher education, intellectual as well as moral and religious, of science as well as of art, and not only of youth, but of the whole life. Such a state is hardly to be realized in this world and quickly degenerates, to the perfect ideal succeeds the government of the soldier and the lover of honor, this again declining into democracy and democracy into tyranny, into an imaginary but regular order, having not much resemblance to the actual facts.

When the wheel has come full circle, we do not begin again with a new period of human life, but we have passed from the best to the worst, and there we end. The subject is then changed, in the old quarrel of poetry and philosophy, which has now been more lightly treated in the earlier books of the Republic, is now resumed and fought out to a conclusion. Poetry is discovered to be an invitation thrice removed from the truth, and Homer, as well as the dramatic poets, having been condemned as an imitator, is sent into banishment along with them, in the idea of the state is supplemented by the revelation of a future life. The division into books, like all similar divisions, is probably later than the age of Plato.

The natural divisions are five in number, book one and the first half of book two down to the paragraph beginning, I had always admired the genius of Glaucon and Ade Mantis, which is introductory. The first book, containing a refutation of the popular and sophistical notions of justice, including like some of the earlier dialogues without arriving at any definite result. To this is appended a restatement of the nature of justice according to common opinion, and an answer is demanded to the question, what is justice stripped of appearances? The second division, two, includes the remainder of the second and the whole of the third and fourth books, which are mainly occupied with the construction of the first state and the first education.

The third division, three, consists in the fifth, sixth, and seventh books, in which philosophy, rather than justice, is the subject of inquiry, and the second state is constructed on principles of communism and ruled by philosophers, and the contemplation of the idea of good takes the place of the social and political virtues. In the eighth and ninth books, four, the perversions of states and of the individuals who correspond to them are reviewed in secession, and the nature of pleasure and the principle of tyranny are further analyzed in the individual man. The tenth book, five, is the conclusion of the whole, in which the relations of philosophy to poetry are finally determined, and the happiness of the citizens in this life, which has now been assured, is crowned by the vision of another. Or a more general division into two parts may be adopted, the first, books one through four, containing the description of a state framed generally in accordance with Hellenic notions of religion and morality, while in the second the Hellenic state is transformed into an ideal kingdom of philosophy, of which all other governments are the perversions.

These two points of view are really opposed, and the opposition is only veiled by the genius of Plato. The republic, like the Phidris, is an imperfect whole, the higher light the philosophy breaks through the regularity of the Hellenic temple, which elast fades away into the heavens. Whether this imperfection of structure arises from an enlargement of the plan, or from the imperfect reconcilment in the writer's own mind of the struggling elements of thought which are now first brought together by him, or perhaps, from the composition of the work at different times are questions, like the similar question about the Iliad and the Odyssey, which are worth asking, but which cannot have a distinct answer. In the age of Plato there was no regular mode of publication, and an author would have less groupal and altering or adding to a work which was known only to a few of his friends.

There is no absurdity in supposing that he might have laid his labors aside for a time, or returned from one work to another, and such interruptions would be more likely to occur in the case of a long than of a short writing. In all attempts to determine the chronological order of the Platonic writings on internal evidence, this uncertainty about any single dialogue being composed at any one time is a disturbing element, which must be admitted to affect longer works, such as the republic and the laws, more than the shorter ones. But on the other hand, the seeming discrepancies of the republic may only arise out of the discordant elements which the philosopher has attempted to unite in a single whole, perhaps without being himself able to recognize the inconsistency which is obvious to us. For there is a judgment of after-ages which few great writers have ever been able to anticipate for themselves.

They do not receive the want of connection in their own writings, or the gaps in their own systems, which are visible enough to those who come after them. In the beginnings of literature and philosophy, amid the first efforts of thought and language, more inconsistencies occur than now, when the paths of speculation are well worn in the meaning of words precisely defined. For consistency, too, is the growth of time, and some of the greatest creations of the human mind have been wanting only in unity. Tried by this test, several other Platonic dialogues, according to our modern ideas, appear to be defective, but the deficiency is no proof that they were composed at different times, or by different hands, in the supposition that the republic was written, uninterruptedly, and by continuous effort, is in some degrees confirmed by the numerous references from one part of the work to another.

The second title, Concerning Justice, is not the one by which the republic is quoted, either by Aristotle or generally in antiquity, and, like the other second titles of the Platonic dialogues, may therefore be assumed to be of later date. Morgenstern and others have asked whether the definition of justice, which is the professed aim or the construction of the state, is the principle argument of the work. The answer is that the two blend in one, and are two faces of the same truth, for justice is the order of the state, and the state is the visible embodiment of justice, under the conditions of human society. One is the soul, and the other is the body, and the Greek ideal of the state, as of the individual is a fair mind and a fair body.

In Hegelian phraseology, the state is the reality of which justice is the idea. Or described in Christian language the kingdom of God is within, yet develops in a church, or external kingdom. The house, not made with hands, internal in the heavens, is reduced to the proportions of an earthly building. Or, to use a Platonic image, justice and the state are the warp, and the wolf, which run through the whole texture.

And when the constitution of the state is completed, the conception of justice is not dismissed, but he appears under the same or different names throughout the work. Both is the inner law of the individual soul, and finally is the principle of rewards and punishments in another life. The virtues are based on justice, of which common honesty, in buying and selling, is the shadow, and justice is based on the idea of good, which is the harmony of the world, and is reflected both in the institutions of states, in the motions of the heavenly bodies. The Timois, which takes up the political rather than the ethical side of the republic, is chiefly occupied with hypotheses concerning the outward world.

Yet contains many indications that the same law is supposed to reign over the state, over nature, and over man. Too much, however, has been made of this question, both in ancient and modern times. There is a stage of criticism in which all works, whether of nature or of art, are referred to design. Now, in ancient writings, and indeed in literature generally, there remains often a large element which was not comprehended in the original design, for the plan grows under the author's hand.

New thoughts occur to him in the act of writing. He has not worked out the argument to the end before he begins. The reader who seeks to find one idea under which the whole may be conceived must necessarily seized on the vagus in most general. Thus, Stalbaum, who is dissatisfied with the ordinary explanations of the argument of the republic, imagines himself to have found the true argument in the representation of human life in a state perfected by justice, and governed according to the idea of good.

There may be some use in such general descriptions, but they can hardly be said to express the design of the writer. The truth is that we may as well speak of many designs as of one, nor need anything be excluded from the plan of a great work to which the mind is naturally led by the association of ideas, and which does not interfere with the general purpose. What kind, or degree of unity, is to be sought after in a building, in the plastic arts, in poetry, in prose, is a problem which has to be determined relatively to the subject matter. To Plato himself the inquiry, what was the intention of the writer, or what was the principal argument of the republic, would have been hardly intelligible, and therefore had better be at once dismissed.

End of introduction, part one.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Logic Library?

This episode is 18 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Logic Library episode published?

This episode was published on May 20, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this The Daily Logic Library episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.