Skip to content
0008 - Illustrating Ainulindalë (Evan Palmer Interview) episode artwork

Feb 26, 2015 1 hr 10 min

0008 - Illustrating Ainulindalë (Evan Palmer Interview)

from The Tolkien Road Hosted by The Tolkien Road

https://www.evanpalmercomics.com/#/ainulindale/ How do you draw music—especially when that music is creating the universe? In Episode 8 of Talking Tolkien, John and Greta talk with artist Evan Palmer about his graphic adaptation of the Ainulindalë. Evan explains how he turned Tolkien’s abstract creation story into visual art through watercolor, ink, explosive color, and striking interpretations of Ilúvatar, Melkor, the Ainur, and the Valar. ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ CHAPTERS 00:00 — Tolkien’s Overture 01:17 — Introducing Evan Palmer 02:59 — Tolkien and the Creativity of Other Minds 04:33 — Comic or Graphic Novella? 05:25 — Evan’s First Attempt at The Silmarillion 07:13 — Giving It Another Try 07:50 — Translating Mental Images into Art 08:04 — The Fantasia Connection 08:43 — Melkor and Night on Bald Mountain 09:39 — Creating the Comic in Two and a Half Weeks 10:43 — Evan’s Artistic Influences 11:44 — Watercolor, Ink, and Acrylic 13:27 — How Do You Draw Music? 13:45 — Condensing the Ainulindalë 15:02 — Planning vs. Painting 16:19 — Illustrating the Whole Silmarillion? 20:23 — Letting Tolkien Supply the Images 21:02 — Turning Sound into Visual Art 23:01 — The World Before the World 24:07 — Music as Northern Lights 25:13 — The Halls of Ilúvatar 26:01 — Why the Ainur Are Orbs 27:05 — Visualizing Ilúvatar 28:14 — A Work of Love 29:47 — Art as Sharing 32:07 — Identifying the Ainur 33:01 — Before the Ainur Become Distinct 34:11 — Break 35:13 — Back with Evan 41:13 — Did the Music Form a Tree? 42:35 — Greta’s Favorite Sequence 43:32 — Why Creation Needed Explosive Color 44:53 — Designing Melkor 46:02 — Melkor’s Blackness 47:35 — Geometry and Discord 48:32 — Does Melkor Add Something Necessary? 49:17 — Why the Valar Look Like Children 52:38 — The “Otherness” of the Valar 53:38 — The Valar Enter the World 54:31 — Melkor the Pouty Kid 55:57 — Melkor Becomes Beastly 58:00 — The White Ship 1:00:10 — “The Earth as a Garden” 1:01:23 — Could We Do a Part Two? 1:02:22 — Leaf by Niggle 1:03:23 — A Gateway into The Silmarillion 1:04:41 — Foreshadowing and Easter Eggs 1:05:35 — The Lamps and Two Trees 1:07:45 — Evan’s Other Projects 1:09:32 — Where to Find Evan 1:09:47 — Final Thoughts ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ HOW DO YOU DRAW MUSIC? The Ainulindalë presents an unusual artistic problem. Its central action is music taking place before the physical world exists. Evan uses movement, abstract forms, watercolor, and color to suggest rhythm and melody. It becomes a second translation: Tolkien turns music into words. Evan turns Tolkien’s words into images. ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ MELKOR AND THE DARKNESS Against the flowing colors of the Music, Melkor introduces blackness, geometry, straight lines, and confinement. His discord seems not merely to add another color, but to suppress the colors already there. The imagery raises one of Tolkien’s great questions: Is evil something truly creative, or does it survive by corrupting what is already good? ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ THE CHILDLIKE VALAR Evan intentionally depicts the Valar as almost childlike when they first enter the world. They are powerful—but inexperienced. As they grow into their responsibilities, their appearances mature as well. Their bodies are not fixed physical forms, so appearance can reflect personality, emotion, and spiritual development. ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ ART AS GRATITUDE When John thanks Evan for creating the comic, Evan explains that the project itself was his way of thanking Tolkien. He loved The Silmarillion and wanted to respond by making something. That captures one of Tolkien’s great ideas about sub-creation: Creativity inspires more creativity. ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ A GATEWAY INTO THE SILMARILLION The Ainulindalë can be intimidating because it is so abstract. Evan wanted the comic to give readers a visual foothold. It does not replace Tolkien’s story. It helps readers imagine it—and perhaps gives someone who stopped after the first few pages a reason to try again. ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ THE BIG TAKEAWAY Evan Palmer’s Ainulindalë is more than an illustration. It is an interpretation. Music becomes color. Discord becomes darkness and geometry. Spiritual beings take physical form. And Tolkien’s creation myth becomes something readers can almost watch unfolding. One act of creation inspires another. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/the-tolkien-road--5222755/support.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

0008 - Illustrating Ainulindalë (Evan Palmer Interview)

0:00 1:10:51

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Tolkien Road?

This episode is 1 hour and 10 minutes long.

When was this The Tolkien Road episode published?

This episode was published on February 26, 2015.

Can I download this The Tolkien Road episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.