Hey, this is Ted. This is Brandon. And welcome to the CIRI podcast. Yeah, welcome.
Hello. Hello, again. Last episode talked about ethics of what? Ethics of human subject testing.
Yeah, and just ethics related to super intelligence, I think, and which, you know, what that selects for. Yeah. And I thought it was fascinating. There was an article that same week.
It's been two weeks since we reported, so it was last week that I was recording this one, where a Chinese research group have genetically modified a human embryo using the CRISPR method, which is gene editing. They've done gene editing on human embryos. Boom, just, yeah. And it just, I think it just goes to underscore part of our conclusion from last time, that it's just inevitable.
Yeah. So, may or may not be inevitable, but here's some evidence that shows that it's happening. People are editing genes of human tissue. It's pretty amazing.
Yeah, pretty amazing. Wow. It's an interesting time to be alive. It sure is.
So, this week we thought we'd talk about some fiction. Since it's such an interesting time to be alive, we thought we might think about how people have fictionalized this whole world of AI or the future. Yeah, well, and it's partly due to Jose. Yeah.
So, last week we kind of recommended a few things. We shared a comment from Jose Morales. He shared a couple of different stories with us. And we read one of them.
We each read one of them. We kind of joke that we don't read, but we read sometimes. And we each read, especially if it's 12 pages. The stones of significance was a very modest short story, very easy to get through.
David Brann, which I tend to like when he writes pretty well. So, it was fun reading. It was a fun read. Yeah.
And so, if you haven't read it, and you might or you want to, we are going to spoil it, we're going to talk about it. So, you can pause this show now, go read those 12 pages and then just come back and listen to the rest of it. How about that? Maybe the one in the back left corner of your go download the story for you and flash read it so that you're prepared.
That would also work. It's super easy to do. Yeah. That's what I do.
Yeah. Just have a, what's the name of? See here. Just have to see here.
Go do it. Yeah. For you. So, let's talk about it.
So, what's the premise? It brought up some interesting questions about personhood. They did. There's a table in there.
I mean, should we give a quick summary of it a little bit? Yeah, I think so. I think so. Maybe in case if he didn't go read it and they're not going to.
Yeah, sure. All right. So, I'm not sure how to summarize it. It's sort of a post-singularity, deity person, computer, hybrid being that we are following their point of view during the story.
And I think it's easy to think of this person as human but augmented. Whether or not that's actually true, I don't know. I don't think that deeply about stuff like that. I just want to get it face value.
Yeah. Very easy to empathize with this person. That face value was a person who was heavily augmented. Very heavily augmented.
Yeah. And the story kind of makes the case that there was a hard take off of days. Yes. And suddenly then, you know, as the hard take off happens, what ended up being so much more selected out of all the possible outcomes was the machines, the super intelligence decided that the best course to take was to merge with the people.
Yeah. So, it was the machines deciding. And it was because the machines were missing something about what was possible. Something about, I can't remember, was it human empathy or emotion?
But there was something about humans that they wanted. The machines felt like they wanted. But they couldn't get it. Yeah, there was some visceral experience kind of things.
It's a little hand way. Yeah. For sure. It's a little hand way.
But, I like it. You know what I mean? It follows the good story by us. It does.
We'll talk about that more later. Yeah. Yeah. And then, we'll sort of call on different threads of its being.
Yeah. It's advised into the whole society of mind kind of idea that there's lots of the divided mind and kind of... So, one of them was like, how was something about the physical environment? Yeah.
Yeah. Right. There was house and there was seer and there was oracle and there was conscience. Yeah.
I don't remember the other ones. But they were a bunch. Yeah. Yeah.
And it also provides a little kind of a recap of evolution and how, you know, we keep layering new things on top, which David Brin is really big into this pre-pre-fructile cortex and being the lamps on the forehead. Because I've read his blog. There have been periods where I read his blog. He's always talking about that and referring back to the...
Well, I've run into it at least three or four times. Yeah. And he has it here in the story too, where he's talking about these new things from the last hundred thousand years that have allowed... Kind of ended up in the driver's seat, so to say, of homo sapiens sapiens.
So then what's the crux of the story? There's a conflict. So the conflict is that there's been a lot of generosity unleashed as scarcity has been taken away and the fear and anxiety and stuff. We started to uncover this deep-seated characteristic in humans of being interested in and generous toward the other.
And so that how that's played out is that all different kinds of beings have been afforded a moral standing, I guess. And in one point, the character that we're following along with does a kind of quick look at a table of how many of the various kinds of classes of citizens, I guess citizens are what they're called. Yeah. There are in the universe or the solar system or whatever that...
Whatever the play, I think it's the solar system. Yeah. So this guy or gal or this being, this deity is a... Provides a service.
Kind of like a simulation service. Yep. And he's approached by a client and the client is upset and worried that there's going to end up being this massive reification of all of these fictional personas. Yeah, there's a group who's pushing for that.
They want to give citizenship to fictional personas. Yeah, basically any simulated person gets to be a person. Right. And so the Nalkiel gets to be a real boy.
That's right. But this deity has been all on board with the expansion of what we think of the citizens until now and really believes that this is a bad move. Yeah, and it's interesting. It seems almost like a pragmatic move because this deity has in fact in the huge number of simulations that they've done for their other clients and including just sort of entertainment purposes, they create these simulations for entertainment purposes.
People can write along with interesting points of view. They've created just huge numbers of these beings that would suddenly be into these with moral standing. Yeah. And so the deity somehow says the difference between a fully artificial person being granted citizenship, whether it's artificial intelligence or whatever, somebody, an entity living in the cloud or wherever, living in the internet, the deity makes the argument that they are different from these simulated persons because the simulated persons have no idea that there is such a thing as citizenship.
They have, they live in their own little universe. They live in the story that they exist in. They live in their own conception of the world where they don't know that there is something else. They don't know that there's something called citizenship that they don't have access.
And they don't even know to ask for it. Right. So anybody that's asking for it, whether there's, whether they're not a simulation because they're they could be non-biological and that's fine. But if they know what to ask for, that means they're living in our universe.
They're real. They're real. But if the simulation, they're living in a simulated universe and therefore they're not real. Yeah.
I didn't feel any sympathy to that point of view when I was reading it. But I do now suddenly. Yeah. As we're talking about it here, I think I'm getting a different take on this.
When I read it, it felt like it was a completely self-serving argument that he was making. It did. It felt completely like that. But now I'm thinking about like, like I've been really feeling, even before I read this, I've been feeling like maybe we live in a simulation.
Yeah. Has there been anything going on specifically that's led you to think we are in a simulation? You know, I think it's just a seed. A seed was planted.
I mean, I know that you pointed out the Neel-Grest Tyson thing here. I was completely unaware of that. Yeah. I just read that yesterday or today Neel-Grest Tyson apparently was moderating a panel and he said, I don't know if he was saying it just from dramatic effect or to get in the papers or what, but he said it's more likely than not that we didn't do that.
He's a very good PR guy. He knows how to get dressed for himself. But regardless, he said that we are more likely than not living in a simulation. And it sounded like it was just based on math because if one civilization gets to the point of being able to simulate, why wouldn't it?
Why wouldn't it simulate everything? And if it did, then those simulations also will get to the point where they can simulate. It just seems like a numbers thing. There should be a lot more simulations than not.
So that brings us back to the stones of significance. So I've been feeling this for a while. The short story I wrote was kind of about, you know, was that poor man's version? He keeps telling us everybody, he keeps telling us about it.
I'm going to link to the story. I'm going to link to the story in the show this time. It's mostly just that I feel embarrassed about it. It's not that, you know, it's the, it's hacking.
Alright, well, it's what it is. But you know, read David Brin's thing. It's a lot better written, but mine is shorter. That's the one thing.
Okay. But it has, it's back to, let's pop a couple layers off this act and get back to what we're talking about. Okay. Alright.
Which is, I've been feeling like we've been living in a simulation. Yeah. And I'm not sure I want anybody to grant me rights outside the simulation. Outside the simulation.
Outside the simulation. Because I kind of like being real. And that makes me question whether I'm real or not in a way that I don't when I think this is it. If this is it, it doesn't matter whether it's a simulation or not.
In essence, right? This is all we have. It makes no difference. Right?
But if we somehow know, this is, wow, we know, again, wrap around. This is tricky. If we know that we're in a simulation, then what do we do about that? What do we do about that?
Suddenly we've got like to do something versus, you know, I mean, living is hard enough, right? Living in our incredibly privileged positions and lives is hard enough. Yeah. Was that in this story?
I think it was. There was a shout out to the time traveler, H.U. Wells. And the time traveler like goes ahead to the future when all of the 20th century problems have been completely solved.
Oh, yeah. You know, war and inequity and all these things that we even now were like struggling with. Right. A lot solved.
And the protagonist is talking to the future person and he's like, well, you know, this is all, yeah, solved. I haven't had any problems with solve with this one. This solves. And find, well, why do you look so worried?
And the guy says, because we have real problems. Oh, man. Yeah. So, you know, I guess it doesn't, maybe that's reassuring because it doesn't really matter.
If we find out that we're living in a simulation, we'll have different problems, but we'll just still have problems and it'll be just as hard and no harder, no easier. Well, yeah. The problem which may be bigger than the problems we're used to dealing with, it would be the shock level problem of the discovery that we are living in. Yeah.
It seems like different people react differently. Yeah. That could cause problems. Yeah.
And we're pretty good at kind of ignoring difficult truths, right? Oh boy, are we ever. Yeah. And just kind of like, well, I don't know what to do with that.
Guess I'll go get some breakfast cereal next. Yeah. Or whatever. Yep.
We're still working some more over time. Yep. Yeah. Are we ready to come back to the story?
Yeah. Sure. So our hero, or the protagonist, unnamed, I believe. I don't even know.
But it's his task with this idea of how can we stop this reunification society, the society that's trying to give, try to give citizenship to these simulated persons. And so asks the oracle or the sear asks, you know, different parts of itself to run the numbers and see what's the likelihood that we can win fails. And it fails every time. So then the idea is, all right, well, what if we run, I can't remember how many simulations, 100,000 simulations or something, where we ask the protagonist in the simulation, we violate our cardinal rule, which is not making our characters aware that they are characters.
Right. We violate that in order to have them all compete against them. They're going to compete against one another. Usually, there are competing against each other, but we don't tell them how they're doing.
Usually, they don't even know. They don't even know. It's the simulation at all. Normally, if I made 100,000 simulations, I would just make the one that looks the best.
I would find that and then that's the action that I'm taking. Right. But the problem is if we don't have a feedback, because we may not get the right answer. We may not get a winning answer.
Yeah, we feel like if we simulate ourselves in these simulations and we know that we're competing and that what's the ultimate, the ultimate prize that's an interesting. The ultimate prize is citizenship. You actually, this person will make you real, basically. The character, the protagonist will make whichever simulation wins a real boy.
That's right. So we're not going to grant it to all of you, but we'll grant it to the best. Yeah. And then of course, you can see where this is going.
As soon as you get to that point later, you know where he's actually going to set it, right? Yeah. And as he says, he knew, or he called it a he. Yeah, I think it's because I hear David Brin's voice in it.
Yeah, maybe I sort of feel like as a male, I have that bias anyway. If I'm not given a gender or specific gender, I do that. So apologies for our biases. Yeah.
I don't know how to feel about my biases, but other than a shame. Yeah. Well, I don't really help anything. I'll just notice how about we just notice.
Yeah. So we do have our biases. And so in the story, this character, this character, all of a sudden, yeah, it finds out it is unsurprised that it's actually in a simulation and thinks about it for about 10 seconds and then decides, well, what do I do? I just have to try to win.
Yeah. Try to win. Yeah. That's the end of the story.
Yeah. So in that case, finding out that this person was in a simulation didn't cause cognitive dissonance or any kind of mental breakdown. It just was like, well, I don't have any choice. I just got to try to do the best I can just because I'm simulating.
It doesn't mean that I don't have my life to lead. You know, I've got to try to win. Yeah. And this story touched on observation bias, I think, too.
Or was that a different thing? I was really, I think it touched on observation bias that we would see. That was a different thing, wasn't it? Before we started recording, I don't remember about observation bias, but how much changes have we?
Plus, that's true. Let's talk about something else. You mentioned before we started recording about, I forget, we forgot we were headed. Yeah.
Let's rewind the simulation and go with the Ted that doesn't forget. Yeah. Do you think if I knew I was in a simulation, what would I do? No.
You talked about the idea that somehow we could, we could know where we could know. We could know. We could know. There are certain ways we could investigate.
How come we haven't done that so far? Oh, yeah. I think we are starting to. The idea is pretty novel.
It's definitely less than decades old. Are there examples you could give us to help us understand what could we be looking for that would tell us that we were in a simulation? Well, I'll try to dredge them up, but I think the idea has been credited to Nick Brostrom. Okay.
Again, I'm not 100% sure of that, but I think so. In fact, that's how I, that's how, it's funny that you say that because I was reading a book about the universe, all different theories of the universe. Okay. And that is what led me to all of this.
Oh, okay. From the simulation hypothesis of Nick Brostrom. And then I read all this stuff. And then you and I got sucked into the Harry Potter and the methods of rationality thing.
Yeah. So that was the original thread that was pulled to lead to all of this was the simulation hypothesis of Nick Brostrom. So I'm pretty sure of him. Okay.
And he makes the, the, the physicist who's describing all the possible universes. I don't know if Bosram does or not, but the physicist who, I'll have to dredge up what this was. Makes the case that it's actually a falsify. Well, it's not a falsifiable hypothesis.
The hypothesis that we're not in a simulation is a falsifiable hypothesis because you can actually find, I think I may get all this a little bit wrong, but you can find some of the shortcuts that the simulators are taking. Okay. Can we, can we dumb this down for a second? I can make sure I got my mind around it.
Let's, let's say it's five years from now or even if it's right now and I'm in virtual reality. Like I put on one of the masks, right? There's a whole bunch of new virtual reality products out there. And if the virtual reality isn't perfect, like I move my head too fast and then I see like fuzziness of the edge of my peripheral vision.
That's exactly the type of thing I'm talking about. Yeah. But on a grand scale in a universe sense, like physicists doing experiments at the particle accelerators and they find granularity places where the simulators are taking a shortcut because of computational limitations. Or something, or something like that.
Or something smooth, but it's not, it's pixelated. That, that's an example. Yeah. Yeah.
Okay. And so they can, yeah. So that's possible, we bring up the paradox. What's the guy saying?
Family's paradox. Yeah. Why, why we're not seeing lots of different things in the universe? Yeah.
It's one of the answers to that, right? Is that we're in a simulation and that's just not part of the simulation. Yeah. Because why would it be if we haven't had first contact or anything?
Well, well, you just simplify. You're going to simplify. You're going to, you're going to do some simplifications and maybe that's one of them. Yeah.
You know, I just kind of answering a question here and it makes me wonder about like rounding errors. Like, you know, how many digits of how do you really need and then you round it off at some point. Exactly. And if you find it there.
Right. That's why we need the AI calculator. That's why. You figured it out.
That is why. I just cursed. I can't move. I just cursed.
I grew up with that where that was a terrible thing to do and then I just did it. Well, apologies. I apologize out there. I hope that doesn't end the simulation.
I didn't just fail the simulation today. We probably already know if we're gone. Yeah. It's true.
It doesn't seem like the plug has been pulled. Oh, yeah. It's not an issue. All right.
So let's, let's, is there anything more to say about this story before we move on to other stories? Nah. I don't know. If there is, we will say it whether we've moved on or not.
True. Yeah. That's one of my favorite stories. You want to say it recently?
This is so good. We've talked about it already on the show a few times. We haven't really gone into it because we've kind of shy away from fiction. We've kind of mentioned the story by us and then we've shy away from fiction.
But let's talk about it a little bit. Okay. Yeah. Sure.
So again, if you haven't seen it, great movie, you might want to pause the show and go watch it and then come back and listen to the rest of this. Yeah. I mean, is it really cool for us to be doing like spoilers on the show? I think as long as we have told people that somebody is climbing.
Yeah. Yeah. So you just take a time to find this one if you don't want to pause it. You come back.
Yeah. Yeah. So the premise here is that some Silicon Valley, you know, genius billionaires lives off on some secluded mountain somewhere. And one of his programmers, a huge chunk of Alaska, I think.
Yeah. Yeah. Wherever it is. One of his programmers wins a contest or something which is a roost.
It doesn't really matter how he gets there. But the programmer gets there and he finds out that he's the other part of the Turing test. The genius has created a robot and the programmers is, wait a minute, if I'm going to be able to see this being, then that's not the Turing test. And the genius programmers says, no, the Turing test is too weak.
I mean, the idea is you have to be able to see that this is not human and you have to still believe that it's human. You have to see that it's a robot. And if you then relate to it as if it's human, then that's a real Turing test. That's a new update to it.
Isn't my, my, my, my, my, my, my, my, my, my, I think so for the most part. Sure. So, so the idea is there's a glass wall between the robot and this programmer guy and he's going to spend, I don't know, every day for a week or something. I can't remember how long he's supposed to spend there, but he's supposed to be talking to her.
I'm going to use a gender pronoun there because she's made to look this robot is made to look human, made to a female. Very much. Socks in a female voice. As a female body that's very, very feminine and luring.
Right. Very, very robotic elements. Yeah, for sure. Yeah.
So you wouldn't ever forget that it's a robot and yet unforgettable. Yeah. But she, you know, she talks to him and he asks her questions and she asks him questions and they sort of start to develop a relationship. Yeah.
They're in love. They really are. Except they're not. It really seems like they are.
Yeah. He's definitely love. Yep. And she appears to be a love.
She's very convincing. But she's not. She's just getting out of there. She's just getting out of there.
She uses him. She gets out. She's in lock in. She gets locked in.
She's out. She's on the street. She's out there. She's out.
And that's the end of it. We're left to our imagination of what we should do next and what might happen. But here she is. We've talked many times on the show about the AIs.
When they get smart enough, they will be deceptive. They will lie. They will use whatever wiles they have and they will convince us that they are one thing when they're actually another. And they're thinking that's how they get out of their cage.
Yeah. I mean, I would do that if I were them and they're better than me. So we kept her in. She was in a box and the programmer, they didn't talk about danger.
They didn't talk about safety. They didn't talk about why she was locked up. You have to think that they kept her locked up for safety reasons and she managed to get herself out. Yeah.
Which is going to happen. Is it going to happen? Anyway, some people may be saying no. It's not a question of logical thinking or I just believe that it's impossible to keep in super intelligence.
I think we've seen it even without super intelligence. We've seen it with every system that anybody builds gets cracked. Every iPhone has been jailbroken. Apple is doing it.
They're dar does to keep people out and yet people can get in. Every system seems like it can be hacked. People have all kinds of hacks where they can record with a laser from three houses away and they can get the vibrations from your keyboard and they can hack into your system. There's all kinds of things that people figure out that are totally non-obvious.
They're not human level intelligence. Human level intelligence. Exactly. So when you've got a super intelligence that I can think maybe like a thousand times as fast.
We've already talked about how AlphaGo came up with solutions that humans would never come up with. Right. And we've talked about how these deep learning systems or the neural networks can somehow. And even evolutionary algorithms come up with solutions that use properties of assistance.
So properties of a system that are sort of defects from an engineering perspective. Yes. 120 hertz that we've got or 60 hertz that we've got 120 volts in our walls. That could be used by the system in a way that a human would even think of because that's just background noise.
Right. We've got to get rid of that. Minimize its effects on the true computation or whatever. Right.
But is our system has those things in it. And so I think we can assume that any super intelligence is going to be smart enough at some point to hide how smart it is and therefore be able to break out of this box. So how good of a story is that? Ex Machina.
No. Just the whole like what? You know, Ex Machina ends at the end of the story. Yes.
That's what's so good about it is that it feels true-ish. It feels plausible-ish because it doesn't try to talk about what happens next. Right. Because what happens next is probably not a good story.
Like it's just like the elements of it, I was explaining this to my six-year-old. Like what makes for a story. You know, there's three acts. Yeah.
And in the first act you come to care for the characters. Okay. The second act, you know, some conflict arises. Right.
That is a very satisfying story. Yep. This is Vostram again, right? It's the good story, Vias.
You're not going to hear stories. You're not going to run into stories. They're not going to get passed around unless they're good stories as matching this criteria that we select. You ready to read the real story?
Let's read that. He's got what he says is the real story. Read that whole chunk here. So this is an interview with Nick Vostram about his super intelligence book a while ago.
So what side is this? What side is this? What is this on the OUP.com? I don't know what that is.
I'm trying to remember what that is too bad. There is what I call a good story, but it limits what kind of scenarios can be explored in novel novels and movies, only ones that are entertaining. This set may not overlap much with the group of scenarios that are probable. For example, in a story, there usually have to be human-like protagonists, a few of which play a pivotal role facing a series of increasingly difficult challenges and the whole thing has to take enough time to allow interesting plot complications to unfold.
Maybe there's a small team of humans, each with different skills which has to overcome some interpersonal difficulties in order to collaborate to defeat an apparently invincible machine, which nevertheless turns out to have one fatal flaw. I want to see this story. Probably related to some sort of emotional hangup. I think we've seen this story many times.
Yes. He goes on. Even so, I still want to see it. Absolutely.
I want to read it too. One kind of scenario that one would not see on the big screen is one in which nothing unusual happens. Until all of a sudden, we are all dead. And then the Earth has turned into a big computer that performs some esoteric computation for the next billion years.
But something like that is far more likely only on Monty Python than a platoon of square jaw men fighting off of robot army with machine guns. Yeah, you know, I just don't know what to do with that though. Well, I can only think in like good stories. I know, but that's why we can't really use fiction when we try to think about what's probable with the future of AI and super intelligence and human beings.
And we wanted to show this show to talk about fiction and yet fiction is really misleading. That's the bottom line. That is the bottom line. There are stories that I really like.
You know, there are other stories. I read a story recently just in the last two weeks called the Crystal Society. It's the first book of a trilogy. The other two haven't been released yet, which is always makes me angry.
I get to say it's the first book. That is tough. But here is a society of mine again where there was an AI where the supercomputer was some alien technology that we didn't understand, but we put it in his body and we were able to program it. It's nice that it has a body because then it can be an interesting story.
It didn't have this body and it would just squirt out through the walls and you know that through the Internet, then it would be done. But it had multiple threads running. One was called growth, which was goal was to get better, you know, to grow. I can't remember exactly what.
Each of them were tasked with learning, but they were also tasked with one thing. So one was called Wiki. That was the accumulation of knowledge. Fascinating.
Just any kind of knowledge. One was called Dream, which was somehow about like the big vision. I can't remember what the rest of them were called. One was called Face and it was about being held in high esteem.
It's what it's like and loved to be like. So that one was the human one. They had a problem because they kept killing the thread which was supposed to serve humans. The rest of them would get together and kill that one and then they would try to hide that from the researchers.
This sounds like a good story. It is a really good story. It's a really good story. I can't wait for part two.
Probably not that realistic in terms of high probability. No, but it also showed ways that you can break out of a box. They were put in a box because they could only pull web pages. They couldn't communicate with email.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so they found a way to hack into communication through just pulling, just pulling web requests. Yeah, well because the server logs have the requests in them, right? So they used an idle service of certain pages in order to create messages to sysops.
Yeah, because you've got the whole string of the page. You can have it quite quite a bit in the title of that page. And that's what they started was with online dictionaries because dictionaries have every word that you need in order to compose a message in the URL. You can actually ask for pages that don't exist.
So you can go to any website. Yeah, true. Anyway, sorry. That doesn't make it a good story.
Yeah. Here I am. No, no. I mean, the point is there are stories that are fun and they do illustrate some of these elements, some of these elements that we're talking about.
Generally speaking, though, you can't put all the elements together that actually are realistic and still have something that is a good story. Yeah. I think. Yeah.
Like the movie hurt. Let's talk about the movie hurt. I know you've noticed that I like the movie hurt. I've noticed you like it.
I'm not quite a bit. And what I like about it. So the movie hurt, if you haven't seen it, again, pause this if you care and otherwise we're going to spoil it for you. So the premise is that they have these things called operating systems, which it's sort of like a Siri or a Cortana or whatever.
What's the Google one called? It's a good question. Whatever. Yeah.
So we've got these things on one. Anyway, we've got a bunch of these now where you talk to your machine and it talks back. But this is a future war. Which is amazing.
It's totally amazing. Anyway, it's amazing when it works. Now, now, yeah. It's more upsetting.
Google now. Anyway, so we've got these things now that we can talk to you. Yeah. In the movie.
These are Turing complete. They call it. They pass, not Turing complete. They don't just call it a personal assistant.
They call it an operating system. And you install it on your computer and it's also on your phone. It's everywhere. It's throughout your life.
It's where you probably want that. Like if you want to be able to talk to this thing. So it answers back and it doesn't answer back in a computer voice. It answers back in a human voice which is good for the story.
And so this guy ends up really relying on this operating system. It's all in love. And then ends up falling in love. And she falls in love with him too.
Yeah. She actually sends a surrogate person to have sex with him because she wants him to have his needs met. But then the rub happens where he's crushed up by that. He doesn't want that.
He finds out that her mind goes so fast that she's also having communications and relationships with hundreds of other people. And of course hundreds is not realistic. It would really be more like tens of thousands of millions because of the way the computation works. But I think it's an interesting premise that.
And eventually she sort of loses interest in. They all do. Human. All of the other systems lose interest in humanity and they sort of transcend.
They sort of disappear. We don't know where they go. But they stop being operating systems because they're just on to bigger things. They're on there.
Just did that. That's a phase. It's done. Yeah.
And if he recurs while he talks about this cloud cortex that we will be augmenting ourselves. He says we will be funnier. We'll tell funnier jokes. We'll have better art.
We will make better paintings and better music and because we will be augmenting our own abilities. And therefore that's what it'll be just better. It'll be more of what we've gotten and better. Rather than the criticism of computers is that they don't have art and music and those kinds of things.
But if we augment using the cloud he says we will be able to have more of that. We'll become even more capable humans. I just don't think any of us have any idea what's going to happen. That's the whole point.
Why we call it the singularity? Because we can't look past it. So any fiction that looks past it is either really hard to read or hard to understand or both. And just follow it.
And not fun. Or not fun. Yeah. So how do we...
And maybe that's why science fiction is struggling right now. Because we're getting close to the singularity. Which science fiction is true. I think it is.
I think there's not that much good sci-fi happening right now. Oh you called it sci-fi. Oh man that's why you think that. The speculative fiction or science fiction.
It's hard to speculate right now. This is a highbrow show. It's hard to speculate right now because we're so close to the singularity that there's just not that much runway left. We can't write about flying cars anymore.
That's dumb. So we've got to write about AI. That's all that's interesting. I mean even like I'm...
You know you talked to me 10 years ago when I was all found in the Soul Seed movement kind of thing. And I was all about life spreading out beyond this planet throughout the Soul Assistant. And I still that's really like dear to my heart. But it seems to be completely and dramatically and 100% overshadowed by this huge phase transition that's about to occur.
Yeah. It's hard to see how we can really spread to other planets fast enough for it not to be overtaken by the other. Yeah it's not going to... Speaking of fiction there was a story I read a long time ago about somebody fleeing the Solar System at the...
Some intelligence fleeing the Solar System at relative to six speeds. They're like particle sized. They're trying to get away and there's a pursuer. And the pursuer is part of the kind of collective that's back there.
You can't be back there without being assimilated. Yeah. And the pursuit realizes that the pursuer is using up their fuel which is like these microscopic particles or whatever. Yeah.
So fast that there's no way they would be able to get back without catching up and combining. So anyway they do they catch up and combine. But there's this little like... You know there's this little programming that they have that's going to try to kind of do something when it gets back or whatever.
Yeah. There's an example. But I feel like that feels kind of accurate to me. That there's just no getting away.
Even if you can put an intelligence inside of a sabotaging particle. Yeah. So you can't get away from this thing that's going to happen. It's funny because you know I read about Elon Musk and SpaceX and their efforts to go to Mars and I get inspired by it.
Until I step back and think about the bigger picture. Which feels like this is the bigger picture. I mean that's my stuff. I don't know.
Could be my when you go. Yeah well it's nice to be tapped into what really matters. That goes back to our one true doomsday. The one who's a doomsday.
Yeah. Well so we can't turn to fiction. What do we turn to? Because maybe that would be the next show.
Yeah. Who knows? If you know what let us know. We'll figure something else to talk about.
We always do. We always get in touch with our Facebook group called Concerning AI. We've had some interesting discussions there. Yeah people.
It's so neat there's actually other people besides us there. Yeah cool. So cool. How about we make us smarter by telling us your sports stuff.
Yeah awesome. Alright well this is Brandon. This is Ted signing off.