Well hello everybody, this is Brandon. Yeah, this is Ted. And that's so backwards, we never do it that way. Welcome to AI Concerning.
Ah, it's clever, I like that. This is the show where we have two questions. Yeah, we do. Two questions, one, should we be concerned?
Yes, we should. About the future of AI and humanity. The second question, what do we do about it? And that is the topic of today's show, kind of indirectly, I guess, right?
Yeah, I think there's a lot of reasons why we find it difficult to effectively point ourselves at this problem. Yeah, so Ted posted a link to 80,000 hours and precipitated a crisis in my mind, because I read it and I thought about it. And I reached out for some career coaching from the 80,000 folks, even though I'm pretty confident I'm not there. They're real target, demographic.
But so Ted put that out there and he has not had any impact on it because I don't think you've read it, right? That's right, I haven't even read it. I thought it was cool, the idea of it. I saw it on Twitter.
I can't remember if Elon Musk tweeted it or Tim Urban tweeted it, but either way both of them were connected to it somehow. And I thought, well, I'm a fanboy of both of them, so it must be good and maybe other people would like to read it. Yeah, so here's the gist of the whole 80,000 hours website and organization. I guess it's a nonprofit.
So yeah, the whole 80,000 hours nonprofit. And you have about 80,000 hours in your career. How do you choose what to do with those 80,000 hours? And they offer guidance on how to select a career that's going to be rewarding for you and effective at shaping the world in a direction that's positive that you're excited about.
So both of those think excited about and effective at shaping the world in a positive direction. One of their core areas that they think is both important, really important, and under resourced, I guess, with creative minds and hearts pointed at it, is AI safety. So I did a little kind of look at it and reading. And I noticed that they have a service that they provide, which is career coaching for people who are interested in going into one of the fields that they target.
So AI safety being one of those, which is a very prominent one for them. So I filled out their questionnaire to solicit career coaching from them. And I was struck by how I'm not the target demographic. It seems like they're pointing at people who are straight out of school more.
And I found myself depressed. Well, I think it's fascinating that when we're not straight out of school, the set of issues that we're dealing with are different or nuanced or more complex or something. It's a different situation. Yeah, my blessings are my curse.
Yeah, what do you mean by that? Well, I have a very stable job that earns really well. And given that up, would be very disruptive to my family. Risky?
Very risky. Yeah. And I also have, so that's one part, that I have a very stable and lucrative job as an engineer. And I also have a track record of having risks sort of blow up on me.
Not having to work out well when I go out on a limb and do a startup or something like that. So I put those together. And what I need coaching with is how do I still earn a lot of money while I work with Switch careers. And I feel so I have such a dissonance when I encounter that question because it feels like it's, I guess it's maybe what hippies felt when they, similar to what hippies felt when they stopped being hippies and started having families and careers and started earning money and had to decide between letting, you know, between their idealism and the pragmatic life of consumption.
This brings to mind the commencement address when I graduated from college. Tell me about that. The speaker was Gary Trudeau, the guy that wrote the Dunesbury cartoons. Yeah.
And this was, well, let's say a couple of decades ago, shall we? Sure. It's been a while. And I don't remember, of course, the words you used.
But the gist of it was, you today are full of idealism. You're graduating from college. You're going out there in the world. You've got hopes.
You've got dreams. And what most of you are likely to do is to say, once I get a great job, then I'll work on those hopes and those dreams. And after you get a great job, then you're likely to say, once I get a great spouse, I will get those hopes and dreams out and I'll work on them. And then once you're partnered up, then you're saying, once we have kids and things are settled down, you end up putting those hopes and dreams in a box.
And you put them on the top shelf in the back of your closet. And once the kids are out of school, once the kids are graduating from college, or they're graduating from high school, and they're gone, you can see the progression here. You just kick that can down the road. And that's why we have this phenomenon of people living their work life for retirement, hoping they're going to have a great life when they retire.
And I'm not even talking about a life of necessarily a great impact in the world. But just like, what do we want to do in life periods? Enjoying things. Put it off.
Put it off. Put it off. Put it off. So maybe we should start an organization, because we still have half of our careers, at least, to go around, probably.
Maybe we should start 40,000 hours. Well, it's really, it's OK. So here's the thing about the number of hours. I think on last show I mentioned this book I'm reading, which I couldn't remember the name of.
It's called Radical Evolution. It was written in 2005. And a lot of the issues that are prominent today, sort of even in popular culture, the AI revolution, the nanotech revolution, the genetic engineering revolution, all of that stuff was predictive. It's been pretty good by Kurzweil longer than that.
Kurzweil features heavily in this book. It's not one of his books. And the Radical Life Extension features in this book. And I don't know yet in 2017 whether we've actually seen the data of life being extended.
Are we seeing? I know that life expectancy in the developed world is going up every year that you stay alive. It's not yet going up a year for every year. So we haven't gotten to that point of infinite life extension.
Escape velocity. Escape velocity. Yeah, I've been thinking about how much time do we have? We just suffered a death in my family.
And I wonder, for all of human history, this has been what we deal with. We deal with death, all of us. And is that always going to be the case? Am I alive at a time when we could surpass that?
And what difference would that make? That might make a difference in my own career. If we could radically extend my career, wow. Does that change how I deal with today?
Yeah, well, does it? I mean, how would it change it? I'm curious. In your particular case, let's skip the rhetorical for a moment and get down to the nitty gritty.
Well, I would have to. You feel to know that. Let's say I tell you, Ted, you've got 2,000 years starting today. And then you get killed in an accident that shocks and horrifies the world.
Yeah. Well, I feel like, for me, I'm not in the situation yet where I have a higher paying job that's relatively steady that I have a big risk of leaving. Although, I have a consulting career which has a high potential for income. That I feel there's a risk in leaving.
And you've invested a lot into the momentum. I have invested a lot of time and energy a lot of years into this. And I'm awfully good at it. It hasn't really paid off.
That investment hasn't necessarily paid off, except in time. I have a lot of time to spend on things I want to, which, for me, is mostly family. It's not AI research. That's not where I'm pouring my heart and soul day to day.
I'm pouring it into my kids and relationships and community and extended family and that kind of thing. So I feel like I'm living my values in that sense. And so when we think about, well, what if my career was much longer? Well, on one hand, it gives me, if we take away the existential threat from AI, the philosophy on a deadline, the need to go fast right now, it gives me actually a lot of relaxation.
Like, I don't need to hurry because I may have many more than 40,000 hours left. And I'll make my contribution in the larger world, if there is such a thing for me, when I can. It's not so urgent. Right, so it makes the kick the can down the road strategy seem less foolish.
Less foolish and sad. Yeah, it feels like living my values of being a family right now actually lines up pretty well. And that's just fine. But the problem is that ignores the threat from AI.
Like this may be the moment when the most leverage of any moment from now to that take off. Yeah, but am I actually living my life as if that statement were true, as if this is the high leverage time? I mean, other than having this podcast, which I'm not sure that we're getting much, I don't know, what listeners you'll be like judge of that because you're the ones maybe taking more action than we are. I mean, if that's our leverage, then you all need to get to work.
Yeah. But I don't see myself, you know, I'm not pouring hours every week into AI safety. So where's the disconnect? Is there a human frailty that comes to play?
Or am I personally just weak? Is this a personal thing or is this a systemic thing? Yeah, well, it seems like there are people who have overcome that for sure. We can list off folks who are, I mean, so in AI safety, in AI research period, but in AI safety, there are several different kinds of people, I would say.
There are those who have kind of fallen into it via interest and opportunity, which is how I came into AI in the first place. It just happened that way, the dynamics of the world pushed me in that direction. I didn't seek it out. And then there are others who have changed their lives in order to work on these things.
They've made a plan and they've organized themselves. They've moved from one part of the country to another. They joined one part of the world. Or even one part of the world to a whole other part of the world.
Yeah. Yes. All right. So they've moved from one part of the world to another.
And those are separate, you know, they kind of feel different. And the reason they feel different to me, I think, is because I'm not going to fall into it. I feel pretty confident of that again. I'm not going to fall into it again.
Like the dynamics and the opportunities that seem to be presenting themselves, it feels unlikely. That's because of your current stability? Because of my current stability. Yeah, I made a local optima that's got strong attractor one second.
See, I mean, it's funny. I just went away, right? And this is an illustration of the values thing. I love the podcast briefly here.
Because my wife, Shelley, is out riding her bike with her friend Heather. And they are going on a really long ride because that's part of their happy in the sun. And so I have the kids. And I've stuck them in front of a screen so that I can do this podcast with you.
And that's an unusual thing. That doesn't really line up with the values of my family very much. Screen time is minimized. Not because, you know, it's funny.
I feel like I have to defend that choice. In the tech world, you feel like it? Well, it's just because so many other people make a different choice in it. The dynamics of that choice and the conversation that comes up are very odd.
Anyway, I'm not going to defend it now that I noticed that I'm in that mode. That's a choice we've made is to limit screen time and try to engage with slower gratification, more creative activities. But I am violating that value in order to do this podcast. I'm sacrificing it.
I'm making a trade-off. Yeah. So in a small way, you're putting AI safety ahead of that stability that you've got there. Yes.
Well, I'm putting it ahead of the value of not being passive consumers in the world. And actual dissonance over that. I feel bad. That's definitely a very strong value for our family.
And yet, I'm giving that up in order to do this. So to do more feels like it would be leading our family even more in that direction. And so I feel like the other values would have to go. And that it would affect our stability quite a bit too.
So it feels like the health of my family is the thing that is to be traded against. And there are people, I know there are whole movements focused on, you can have it all, right? That you can have all the things. And it isn't about trade-offs.
It's not actually trade-offs. Yeah. Yeah, I think that we could have a conversation that would help create a different set of trade-off conversation. I think that it's occurring today in this conversation right now as if stability is the trade-off versus energy into AI safety, as if that's an either or.
And I'm sure that there's other ways to have the conversation where other things would be traded off. And you could have both of those. I don't believe it's possible to have it all. But what else could be traded off if we were to have a different conversation?
I think that's where you get the genius of the end. That could be. No, I mean, it's not obvious to me what that would be. Or if the stability of your family would still look the same, or if the potential work on AI safety would look the same.
I've got something to bring up here. All right. So several years ago, while I was building with this consulting business that I've talked about, I decided I needed to find more of my own voice. And so I started a podcast.
And no, it wasn't concerning AI. This was before that. It was called a purpose podcast, which you can do. Why did you form the purpose podcast?
Because what I do in my business consulting is I help individuals and businesses live out their purpose. And I believe that if you're really clear on your purpose and then you take aligned actions, then that's how you create impact in the world. And so that's why I created the purpose podcast, in order to encourage people to do that, to tell inspiring stories, to interview inspiring people, and to get that idea out into the world more, that when we live according to our purpose, everybody's better off. And you still believe that?
I do, OK? I think I believe that too. Yeah. I'm willing to take that as a given.
I think that's an assumption that we both share. Yeah. So one of the results of doing the purpose podcast is that several years ago, I actually stopped reading business books. A lot of my colleagues who do what I do all around the world, they read a lot of business books.
And they're constantly looking for either validation of things they already know, or they're looking for new knowledge to be able to help their clients, or to be able to help grow their own business. I just found that those books were not feeding me. And so I gave myself permission to stop reading those books, and I started reading other kinds of things. I started reading more fiction of all kinds.
I'm not reading a lot right now, but in general, I like to read all kinds of things. And that's one of the reasons why I gave myself permission to start concerning an eye with you, Brandon, was that I wanted more friend time. I looked at the constellation of my life, the web of all the things that I'm engaged in, and I wanted more friend time. And AI is one of the things that you and I are both interested in.
And concerning AI made sense because our families are going to be affected. Our kids or our kids are going to be affected, if the singularity actually happens, and if there is a threat, much more likely to impact them than us. So it all made sense. It was not a business decision.
I actually, when I started the purpose podcast, I thought it might help my business. I did not think that starting concerning AI would have any impact on my business. And I was wrong about that, I think. It's fascinating.
We've been at this for a couple of years now. And I find that the fact that I have such a strong passion outside of my work makes me a more interesting person. It gives me something more interesting to talk about in small talk. It also helps me think about the trends that my business clients are going to have to deal with in the next three, five, 10 years.
Not that I am a futurist, but because I'm reading all this stuff, I'm helping ask the right kinds of questions, helping them, really think about the future. So I think it actually is helping me in business. And I didn't need that argument that it would help me in business in order to do it. But it's just a good thing.
It's a good thing to pursue your passions, whatever they are. So bring it in full circle. Nice. I like that tie in at the end.
I'll talk tight. Yeah. So it feels like this may be a slow take off for my action in the AI safety world. You like that?
You say the term? Yeah, I dig it. You know? It's like threads in a tapestry coming together from a pre-picture.
Use the terms. Own the terms. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. I like that. Yeah. So you know, that's so what?
OK. So you have done the Purpose Podcast. You are a stand for the idea that we should be in touch with our purpose in the world and take actions that are aligned with our inspiration and be fully self-expressed in the world. Yeah.
All right. So what is your response to somebody like me who says, I have dissonance? I think we all have dissonance is my response. I think that when I read biography of people that have been really influential in politics or in technology or whatever, sometimes those people express regret about what happened, what it was like with their families.
And so I do not think there's any easy answers here. I think that what we're grappling with is the question. Is it enough to just start a podcast? I mean, most people don't start podcasts, Brandon.
And here we are on this show. And lots of people have expressed to us that they enjoy it. And so there's something different about us that we took this step. There's more steps that we could take.
But what is the trade off? And where is the genius of the end? I just think what we're grappling with is not something that has an answer. It's that we need to grapple with the question in order to take whatever smaller big steps we're going to take tomorrow or next year.
We have to take whatever steps we see as doable in the constellation of our life as it exists today. And if the stability that you're feeling feels like a trap, well, it doesn't. That's the thing. I mean, if it felt like a trap, I would feel a lot better about blowing it up.
But you don't want to blow it up. There's a lot of great things about it. And so you don't want to give it up, or why should you? So then what do we do?
It feels really selfish, though. I feel like my life is selfish. Like it's not selfish in the context of how I am with my family. But it's kind of like the circles of care.
My selfish circle of care goes beyond just the brand and skin bag. But it does encompass my family. It doesn't go very much further beyond that. And that is what I feel bad about.
I think is that I'm super privileged. I am super lucky to be born at this time in this place with all of the resources that I have. And I feel like I'm kind of just enjoying that privilege, rather than using it to make a difference. I guess.
That's what the real dissonance is. It's not that I feel trapped or sad. I feel trapped. Yeah, it's my blessings that are causing this sense of dissonance.
And my tendency is just not want to give up any of us. Yeah. Are you familiar with the book Crush It by Gary Vaynerchuk? Yeah, I don't know that I've ever read it.
But I know Gary V and I've heard people talk about it. I don't think I've ever read it. But I heard him talk about it. Yeah.
I listened to the audiobook probably 10 years ago. And some of the things that he said really stuck with me. He said, if there's something that you care about, and it's different from what you're doing, if you're making a good living as an engineer, but your passion is actually baseball cards, then take action now on baseball cards. That doesn't mean you have to leave your engineering job.
You've got hours after the kids go to bed before you have to go to bed, or you've got hours in the morning depending on your bio rhythms. You've got time when you could be working on a baseball card blog. And you could put an hour a day into that. And you don't even have to be a business person.
You know how it's going to monetize at some point. Just create great content, build an audience. And eventually, you'll figure it out. Some marketer will come to you and they'll have a great offer.
And you'll too will partner up. And you'll leave that engineering job, because now you've got a great business that you've created for yourself. So the theory there is take action on the things you're passionate about, even if it doesn't mean blowing up your whole life. So we're sitting with that.
Yeah. And we don't have to answer it now. But that's something we could look at. Starting a podcast was a marginal effort.
It was something we weren't doing. It was literally time where we're sitting and talking with one another. There's editing time. There's money we're putting into hosting.
And we interact with people on the internet. We wouldn't otherwise. So there's time that we're both choosing to put into this thing. Well, what's the next marginal place that we're choosing to put energy?
And where can we take that energy from that doesn't adversely affect the other things that we care about most? That reminds me, like you said that, and I just wanted to sit here and bask in it for a moment. And it reminds me of a quote from one of my all-time favorite books, Happiness Hypothesis by Jonathan Heit. And in the forward, it's called introduction to much wisdom.
I just happen to have the book sitting right here. So I can read the book. He says, in a mix of this in introduction, too much wisdom. He says, we might already have encountered the greatest idea, the insight that would have transformed us, had we savored it, taken it to heart, and worked it into our lives.
And I want to savor this. I feel like there's an insight here. And the sort of suffering that I've been doing over not doing more is maybe wasted effort. So you point out that we have started this podcast.
We are in action. And action grows on itself. And allies emerge. And it's true.
And maybe the answer is not to blow up my life and move to a different part of the world. And maybe the answer is to feed the passion, feed the activity that is providing some value that is happening regularly, just a little, even, and let the dynamics of positive feedback work. Feels like a good place to leave it. I can dig it.
Thank you, Ted. You're welcome. You're welcome. And thank you listeners for being here.
It's really great to hear from you when we do. If you'd like to be a voice on the show when we do listener feedback, you can email us a voice memo, record a voice memo on your phone, and MP3, and send it to concerningai at gmail.com. And if you'd like to be involved in any of the discussions that happen between the shows, we meet at Facebook. The group is called Concerning AI.
So anything else? Yeah, I'm just sitting here, sitting here with that. Just feels important. Thank you.
All right. Well, we're going to sit with that and listen as you can sit with that, if you like. And until next time, keep your waffy up. Keep your waffy up.