Hello, this is Brandon. Yeah, this is Ted. This is the concerning AI podcast. And tonight I'm driving, so watch out.
And it's interesting that I'm driving because it feels a little like I'm just out there on the roads going crazy with nobody in the front seat. Check it up on me. That sounds like a segue. Man, it's like softball time, right?
So we kind of have a couple of things to talk about. And this one, the Waymo shedding the safety driver that's been a kind of a story that's been developed. So I want to come back to that one in a minute. Or we get to that point.
I just had a laugh out loud moment from the Facebook group. And I wanted to thank Daniel, I think. Yes, Daniel, for posting the All Your Bays or V Long to Us. I've never encountered that before.
And there's t-shirts and all that kind of stuff. But I just laughed and laughed when I heard that. So thank you for bringing a little joy to my life. That is some total yank humor, nerd humor that I just love.
I may have to get one of those t-shirts. My birthday is coming up. I don't have that. Do you have that?
Can you just say, oh, that may make a good birthday present. It shows up on your list. That would be awesome. Yeah, get to it, gentle listener.
That's a great business idea. In fact, that's kind of like the one in Rob's book with Flutter. Not with Flutter, but where their company got it started. Oh, yeah.
That's a good gifting kind of thing. Yeah. Like gif matching, like a dating book for gifts. Yeah.
Yeah. Okay. So we are zipping through the topics here. Maybe faster on the streets.
I just can't keep beating this. I can't keep beating this. I can't keep beating this. I can't keep beating this.
I can't keep beating this. It's like the safety driver thing too much. So let's just get that one out of the way. So first of all, Waymo, the name threw me out a little bit because this is a company that Google bought and Google isn't even Google anymore.
And so Waymo is an alphabet company. So the thing that we used to call the Google self-driving project, the Google self-driving car project is now called Waymo. Is that right? I think so.
And does that mean that that's their W slot and that there's nothing else in the W slot. After, do you mean in the alphabet? Yeah. Yeah.
I mean, so. Do you think they use that to prioritize a little bit like their priority queue? You don't make it to the top 26. To the top 26.
And, and yeah. You have to sort of use a J or something like yeah, anyway So Waymo has in October I guess started driving without a safety driver in the front to grab the wheel and part of the news around this is that Land corporation and some others have argued that we should not let perfectly the enemy of good And that there are a lot of lives to be saved by just having a slightly better than human driver record So now that they're on the road we are I think is exciting reason I think this is because now that they're on the road we are getting close to the test case that will tell us a lot about The future of autonomous vehicles and that's when Ted When when I don't know when what I missed it. Okay. Uh-huh.
Yeah, this is hard. I don't know how you do it So it's when the self driving car kills somebody. Oh, yeah. Yeah, we've had some fatalities already with self driving cars But it's been user error It's been user error and it's also been in the mode where you know that the responsibility is still with the human Yeah, for sure very clearly and you know, it's very clearly in the regime of the responsibility rest with the human I think you know nobody that's a hard one to go crazy over.
Yeah, you know for a punter to take off on so the way Mo cars the way this test is gonna work is if there's a geofence around Chandler, Arizona, which is near Phoenix It's a hundred miles and it's inside that geofence and I guess they're gonna be providing rides to people through an app or something like a over style yeah I think they're targeting that pretty soon right like the next Month or two it sounded like it's me. Yeah, and they're gonna have a Google engineer still in the car But sitting behind the driver seat nobody sitting in the driver seat. Yeah, the way my engineer. Sorry.
I keep saying Google Yeah, and so it seems like it's likely there will be a fatality at some point it does seem likely that there will be a fatality At some point I guess the longer it goes without one, you know, like the more that might Shape public opinion about it right like if it's if it turns out to be 30% safer than human drivers or 50% safer Or even 70 you know like there's a point at which I think people will be will be swayed But yeah, so this test case I think is gonna is we're now finally teeed up for it to happen Okay, no wait a minute for a second I'm a believer that in general that people are bad at math and so I'm worried that public opinion if we have a fatality will go Against the idea of self-driving cars because we feel like well, I'm a responsible driver I know Why would we give over control of that? But now I want to argue on the other side of that for a minute We don't ban toasters because somebody makes toast in the bathtub and they get electrocuted and they die Yeah, but somebody who makes toast in the back in the bathtub is not the same as somebody who gets run over by a car So when it kills when it kills the toddler that's gonna be a different case well We have faulty products all the time when people end up dying. Why is this different? That's a good question.
Well, that's one of the ways that this trial in the court of public opinion could come out I mean it could come out that I mean so okay, so what are the options? So one of the options is overwhelming overwhelming shame and apologies from waymo and pushing everything out by a Decade or more because it's just so obvious that the outrage from the public is there So that's at one end of the spectrum right like we screwed up. We never should have done this. We're sorry We thought it was a good idea and it does make sense that we can tell that that really you know any fatalities that are all They're just not acceptable, you know, they just have to do that because of the public perception Yeah, that just seems to be ought to me.
It seems wrong to be you know from a from a utility maximizing utility where utility is people living and if you're if you're actually Have a better safety record than you know you save a lot more lives by having them out there than not having them out there Right, so you know from them the math I think is clear either either it's safer It's fine, but that doesn't that's not what he's gonna win the day or probably right so so that's one in the spectrum The other end of the spectrum is is that it's a non like it's just hardly a news event Like people just don't care. Yeah, I think I don't I can't see people you know going out and making impassioned cries to the public to get everybody Riled up about how everybody should be driving in the driverless car I just don't see that I just can't imagine a dynamic it would get us there So it seems like that the furthest into the spectrum of people just don't like it well Yeah, I mean people have died from airbags and cars and yet we don't ban airbags people die airbags even after a recall is it is this different? Well, I I Worry that it's different, but I don't see how it is like from a logic standpoint of this is a product This is a commercial product that people are bringing to market and sometimes there are fatalities from products You know the airbag I think they should hire you when it's happened. They should hire you as their publicist Airbag is a fantastic Anality yeah, it's it's a safety device and self-driving cars really are a safety device.
Oh, yeah See they need to get out ahead of this I think with it You know get the story all ready to run get ready to syndicate to the AP if they were smart They already haven't done we don't even know that right because it wouldn't be public until it happens Yeah, yeah, it'll be it'll be an interesting thing to see to right how slick are they like how well prepared are they for this? Or are they just clueless type ease? Yeah? That'll be fun.
Well, I can I say fun? I don't think I can say fun I take back fun. I was you can't say fun around Yeah, they fun around something, you know where there's an accident and it's bad one of the Star Trek actors died when his jeep Cherokee rolled over After he exited the vehicle of pin him against the fence so his vehicle was subject to a recall and he ended up dying Yeah, he didn't it just started rolling forward and it ended me. Oh no over I thought roll over sideways Yeah, why would he just roll down the driveway and switched in between it and wall?
Yeah, right? So I mean that's a oh, it was the recall was because the shift lever is confusing So it could absolutely be because of that same the same problem. That's why he don't die. Mm-hmm, right?
So so that one didn't play out that way didn't play out in the court of public opinion where G for somebody got the Skatego and had to had to do something Alright, so let's get our minds of the our psyches like the psyche of a human being. Why would there be outrage? Why is this different? I think this is some volition of the other there's some So this may be actually a place where the hype actually helps what do you mean?
Wow, you know I think people are primed because of how good computers are at math and how good computers are at chess and these other games that we Associate with tremendous human intelligence to believe that the computers are more powerful and smarter and better than they are Hmm. So when somebody says there's a safety device and gonna have a few strange failures that maybe a human wouldn't but in general It's gonna be it's just a lot safer than people are you know that may be credible because of that that bias right that could happen It could it could in general people don't understand their technology. They know their technology helps them in their day-to-day life They like their smartphone. They like their smart TV.
Maybe that's enough. Maybe it's okay to let's look in value to its thing Yeah, interesting. All right, well, so we'll have to see how this plays out All right anything more you want to say about we were we move on? No, I've got way more to say, but that's a different time You've been having an AI right here It's so fast.
It just came out so quick. Yeah, yeah, because you know all your babies are be long. Oh, that's right. That's right So you've been reading something I've been reading where is everybody yeah the full title is if the universe is teeming with aliens Where is everybody and it's a 75 solutions to the Fermi pair other Fermi paradox and the problem of extraterrestrial life by Stephen Webb We talked about this with Rob Reed when we had him on the show he mentioned this book and I got it at the Download the PDF off the web.
It's so good. Think about 75 different solutions to the Fermi paradox I mean I think if we batted around before I read this book we probably would come up with I don't know three or four Maybe ten between the two of us maybe fifteen if we really I was gonna give us a couple dozen Yeah, if we really went after it but so far out of the first 19 none of them I don't think I would have come up with well Maybe a couple of my money come up with but none of them make sense to me in terms of like an answer and only one of them No out of the first 19 actually feels like well, there's something there. There's something really interesting there's a math there That could they could help us, but I think it's really interesting there are three major categories one is well They are here. We just haven't seen them yet And the second major category is they are here.
I can't remember what the second category is the third category is they're just not here They were alone. Yeah, I've got to those yet But it's really it's really fascinating like the first one was kind of it was kind of a joke They are here and they're hungarians and that's a joke in the early days of Before we had nuclear fission I guess they a lot of the Hungarian physicists were the ones that seem to be smarter than everybody else in the US And so that's kind of a joke the second one is something like they are here and their politicians because politicians are so weird And so they get more serious, you know after that they get into more math and they get into you know Reasons why we might not be able to see them or reasons why they don't want to be seen like the zoo hypothesis where we are kind of We are living in a national park basically. Oh and so like Star Trek Prime Directive kind of thing Exactly exactly and it's our track you really don't have a good plot unless you break the prime directive all the time Right, right, but that's again the story bias. Yeah, you assume that on most of the worlds where the Federation is capped out They don't break it so there's no story there exactly exactly so the zoo hypothesis is interesting the simulation one They don't call it that but it's but it is basically you know, that's that's in there too.
Mm-hmm. So it's interesting And so it's not entirely clear to me how this connects to AI I mean we've talked about it on the show before but the idea that If Earth is not unique if we're not alone in the universe then presumably super super no no we can't say super human AGI let's say AGI the singularity would have happened in those other places first and then maybe that's you know where the simulations come from or who knows who knows what happens after that yeah, so there's a couple of connections, right? There's the simulation, you know that simulate awareness emulation. Yeah, and that's the answer and therefore, you know It's coming from tremendous computational power.
Mm-hmm another one is a great filter that you know the potential for AI to be a great filter Yeah, we have a cross the great filter yet in the book So I think that's you know, it's interesting one that we'll probably will talk about later assuming that's in the book Mm-hmm one of the other interesting things that was in the book that I read so far was the idea that other civilizations might have sent out spores and we could be aliens Mm-hmm. Maybe we didn't come from here. No, I don't know what that does for you exactly. Other than what you want.
Yeah, yeah Yeah, and I think that's interesting I mean we don't actually know how life came into being on Earth and knowing that it came from someplace else just shifts that inquiry to Another location in the universe doesn't actually solve anything, but it would certainly be remarkable We want to know about that if that were true mm-hmm. Yeah, well it did happen pretty quickly Yeah, after the after the planet sort of became nice. Yeah Tropical pleasant. Yeah, okay any any you have any call to action on that is there you want other people to read it?
I would love other people to read it. So yeah, I think yeah the book Steven Webb is the author if the universe is Teaming with aliens where is everybody? So I'll put a link to that in the show notes and if you'd like to read along and you know put some comments in the Facebook group or better yet Send us a voice memo usually we ask you to send us voice memos after you've heard something on the show and you want to talk about that In this case we haven't really talked about it yet So we'd like we'd like your initial thoughts it when you read the book give us a little bit of a one-minute all-in-show It's like it. Yeah, it's like first time listener longtime caller that kind of thing.
Yeah So send us a link the other way around first. Oh, yeah, it could be send it to concerning ai at gmail.com I think if you condition the probability all our bait all your base are these long Okay, cool. That's yeah, I think that's our chauffeur for this time That's how that's how I roll when Ted is not in the safety seat. Okay.
Very good. Come see us in the Facebook group Oh, he's in the safety he's taken over again I forgot I was about to run over somebody. Yeah, let me see if I can take back over you push the button Can you push the button that lets me have control again? Okay, all right back in control I don't want to collect my emotions.
Yeah, find us in the Facebook group That's where people are smart and say interesting things that you know, maybe more so than what we do even here But there's a lot of people there and it's it's really fun All our base all your bays are be long to us Little nuggets in the Facebook group recently. Yeah, and if you want to say this a voice now But not a voice now a one minute or so we memo pull out your phone It's probably got one of those apps and you can just click share and send it to concerning ai at gmail.com Go people and I'll give us some to pick from we don't always play all of them But we do like to put together a show every now and we pick out a few and let you guys be the driver So thank you for joining us today and this is Brandon I'm not in the safety seat Well, I'm worried I'm not sure I should say all right, so this is Brandon this is tip and keep your up. Yeah Bumbling I think I think that's what I'm counting on cuz yeah sure a lot. Yeah, that's good