Skip to content
023 - Tackling Tragedy (And NetNeutrality) episode artwork

Jan 10, 2018 1 hr 12 min

023 - Tackling Tragedy (And NetNeutrality)

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: THIS EPISODE ALSO BROUGHT TO YOU BY: The Fifty-Fifty! (horrifying details below) STUFF FROM THIS EPISODE: Onion News Network - Apple's Computer with no Keyboard (Mild Offensiveness Warning) Google Search of The "Slow iPhone Phenomenon" What is Net Neutrality? Vote No on 2B - Fort Collins, CO "I Milk The Monster" Clip from the NDQ 022 - Star Wars Episode CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

023 - Tackling Tragedy (And NetNeutrality)

0:00 1:12:46
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Daniel, what's up? I'm on my way home from work. Can't get Matt. I love your edit as long as you make it sound smarter than we are.

But I think the way it starts is a little jarring, because Matt sounds like he ate a box of rocks for breakfast. And unless you know the context of me calling and just wanting to process tragedy with my buddy, unless you understand that, it kind of leaves you wondering, like, what the heck's wrong with Matt? So I think Matt's playing basketball. I'm on my way to a family thing.

And as you know, that's really important right now. If you could call Matt and get him to flip on a microphone and record some kind of intro explaining why he sounds sick because he was. And I think then people will be more forgiving to us. So if you don't mind calling that and I do that, I think it's good.

It's good to go. I think he wants to publish tomorrow. So thank you. Appreciate you.

Bye. So I'm in a meeting with two guys in somebody text me and said pick up the phone or whatever. And then my sister tries to call me. And I have this thing where I can, you know, everybody has an automated text message that you reply.

Yours are pretty good. Yours are really good. I think my favorite is pooping. I'll return your call in seven hours.

I think that's my favorite. I'm pooping right now. I'll return your call in seven hours. That's a good one.

And I always do. There's this one that I have. It's it just says yellow. You get that one sometimes, right?

Yeah, you don't abuse it. But yes, I get yellow, which I assume. Well, I think we've agreed means if you really need me, I could answer, but please don't really need me. Exactly.

That's what it means. I'm in the middle of something that requires my full attention. Unless it's urgent, I'm going to stay doing what I'm doing. Okay.

So my sister calls me. I respond text yellow. You know, if it's urgent, let me know. She replies immediately urgent pick up.

I was like, oh, wow. Nobody ever does that. Okay. Must actually be urgent.

So I walk outside, take the call. I apologize to people in the room. I say, hey, is this actually urgent? I'm kind of in the middle of something.

She said, yes. And I'm not going to say their name. And uncle have been in a wreck. We don't know anything other than we're on the way.

And I was like, where did it happen? They're like about 50 miles south on the interstate. Okay. What do we know?

Nothing other than they're on the side of the road right now. Okay. Keep me updated. Tell me where they're going blah, blah, blah.

I'm going to walk back in this meeting, wrap up. And then we'll see what happens. I said, okay. Well, the next text I get says they're medfliding our uncle to the hospital and he's complaining about his back.

And I was like, oh, that's good. He's complaining. Yeah. That means there's feeling there, no problems, but they're medfliding.

That is a problem. And so I actually had an appointment at the same hospital. And so I got out and figured out what was going down. They were taking my aunt to one hospital down south and they were flying him up to Huntsville.

So I head up there and I asked my dad, who's on the way as well. I said, dad, I'm going to disappointment. Tell me what I need to do. Tell me if I need to break loose at this appointment.

Where do I need to go? What happens? And this is your dad's brother? No, it's my dad's sister.

It's her husband. Long story short, dad texts me. I mean, this doctor's appointment. I didn't know if I needed to go down there or what.

Blah, blah, blah. I basically wanted to let him handle it. He said, broken back. And I was like, that doesn't sound good.

That doesn't sound good at all. I hope they stabilized him. And I go down there and I walk in the emergency room. And it's my dad and my other uncle and me and my uncle's laying there on the table.

And he's clearly been banged up. And dad's talking to anesthesiologist. My other uncle's talking to the radiologist. My uncle's there and I walk up to him.

I said, hey, that is an elaborate way to get a helicopter ride, young man, or something like that. Good job. Yeah, and he laughs at me. And I forget what I said.

Something like it was a big pop. He said it was quite a lick. It was quite a lick. And he's talking.

He's coherent. He's looking at me. I'm like, man, he's here. And then he communicates through dad or however it was.

I don't know, long story short, we figured out, but his spine is damaged. And they said, sir, we have to x-ray. You're back. We gotta figure out how we're going to do this surgery.

They go to x-ray, x-ray. And they pull the sheet up and they kind of pick him up. And they put the x-ray, he said under his back. And they lower him back down.

And it's clear he's an agony because he's moaning. He goes, oh, oh, oh, oh, oh. And then I'll never forget this. He said, please sir, remove it.

It hurts very badly. Oh my goodness. What would you have said? A lot of words, man.

And so not that. But I thought it was pretty powerful, a pretty powerful statement because he was being very kind to everyone in the room. And he was keeping his composure and he was being kind. Yeah.

That blew my mind. He could be that strong and that composed in that situation. And then we go out in the hall and the doctor comes out. He's a very competent, capable doctor.

So the doctor looks at us and tells us the reality of the situation and what he's about to do. And he turns around and he goes into the room. And what do you say in that situation? When you get super, super heavy news about the reality of the situation, what do you say?

I still don't know. And I have more practice than most people. I don't know. I've been in that spot with family members, but you know, I end up in that spot professionally a lot.

I don't know. I say what comes to mind. I try to reassure people. But the bottom line is there isn't a right thing to say.

There are wrong things to say, but there isn't some genius thing that makes it better. It's supposed to be weird and it's supposed to hurt. So I don't use profanity. I mean, you know me well, not to know that, you know, words that are on the edge.

Yeah, I'm working on you. You're working on me. I chose to, I didn't know what to say. It wasn't anger.

It wasn't fear. It wasn't anything. The only thing I could think of to say, to sum up what we were all thinking was one very specific, clear, profane word. I just said it.

It wasn't the up bomb. Never said that one. Said one clear word to express what we just heard and just, you know, right there in front of my dad. This is well, crap.

That was it. And he just kind of went, mm-hmm. And we walked to the other room and we started working on stuff, started trying to figure out all the rest of the things we had to do. And it was just an interesting situation, you know?

It was a very heavy moment. And it's why people like you keep those words in reserve so that you have something that means what you mean when something like that happens. Yeah, I don't remember the last time I said that word. So anyway, the good news is he's got use of his arms.

He's very, very clear with his thinking right now. And his vitals seem to be getting better. Really? Yeah, that's where we're at right now.

I'm really happy to hear that. I'm really, really proud of my family. Everybody's doing a different thing. Like, you know, one of my aunts is trying to coordinate this aspect of it.

Because my other aunt, I mean, my aunt was in the car with him. And she has broken bones and she's hurting as well. I mean, she got back with it hard. And everybody's just coming together in a really cool way.

So everybody has something to do. Yeah, even my sister who lives out of country. My sister lives out of country. And so I'll call her and I'll update her.

I'll be like, OK, here's what went down today. And these are some decisions that we need to do coming up. If you could go ahead and as the unbiased person that's not emotionally in the middle of the situation, obviously you're emotionally involved, but you're not right here in the middle of it, you're probably thinking more clearly. So these are our options.

Go research it. Figure it out. Come back with what you think the best answer is. And often it's not the answer that I expect or want, but it's the best answer.

And so it's really cool. Everybody's doing something. So I like that. Yeah, and you need that.

Yeah, I found it in those times. If you've got a couple of people who don't have anything to do, they'll find ways to do weird things. People need to feel like they're doing something. What does everybody say when something goes wrong?

If there's anything, anything, anything at all that we can do. Yeah. How often have you taken somebody up on that? Not that much.

I mean, either. Because I don't know what's really needed in those times is for people outside the situation to be creative and just find a way to insert themselves and be helpful and then get right back out until they can think of something else. But I mean, it's nice to express if there's anything we can do. But the reason we say that to each other is because we care, but the world is hard and bad things happen and some of them are way beyond our control.

And there's nothing we can do to help yet in those moments. You really want to do something. And so if you guys have got a situation where everybody has a role, yeah, that's that's pretty unique. That's pretty good.

What's the coolest thing somebody's ever done for you in a really bad situation like that? When my brother died, people did so much stuff. I don't even remember it all because we were in a haze. But I remember people showing up in ways that made sense.

I remember people getting out of the way in ways that made sense. And you know something I really appreciated when we were going through that tragedy? What? Was everyone was emotionally healthy enough not to make it about themselves?

Explain that. What you notice when I'm around tragedy is you'll always have those one or two people who are like, oh, I had lunch with him two days ago. So who cares? Like what you're doing right now is prioritizing your processing.

You're trying to put yourself in proximity of the lost so that this can be about sympathy for you when there are people who knew him on a little closer basis than had lunch recently. There's always that comment about just some people come out of nowhere to grieve because they're emotionally needy in this way. And people spared us that when my brother died. I really appreciate it.

What do you mean? They spared you. I mean, that person didn't show up. We didn't have the person who's addicted to grief and attention show up and try to attention whore while people were trying to legitimately grieve a tragic loss.

That's cool. Yeah, it was cool. It was really nice because I see it so much and the one time in our lives when we really needed to not deal with it, it wasn't there. So that was cool.

And if people are doing stuff like what you're going on here, I don't hear any talk of victim hood or what was us just you have a good family and you guys get after stuff together. It's pretty cool. It's pretty cool. Let me tell you what the latest thing is that we're trying to figure out.

So all right. When we go into the room, they're trying to get his vitals under control and blood pressure and all that. And he's doing a good job of breathing the right amount. There was an issue with O2 exchange the other day and he had to calm down and breathe better and he was able to do it.

But the problem is there's something he wants to tell us, but he's got a tube down his throat to help him breathe. That makes it harder. And he can't say what it is he wants to say. And he can't write.

And he can't write. So because of that, he tries to say it. And it's very, very important. Whatever this is, it's super important.

Yeah. So we're trying to, and the reason he can't write is because his arms are held in position because it's a reflex to pull the tube out of your throat, right? Well, you just get the alphabet tablet, man. That's what we're going to try to figure out.

We've been like, OK, don't try to talk to us because you just get agitated and worked up and your breathing goes, we're like, the tubes come out soon enough. We'll wait and we'll communicate. And tonight, he looked at me and I walked in the room and his eyes snapped to me instantly. It's like, finally, you know, you were able to come back because of his thing hours on that junk.

He looked at me and it's like, OK, game on, I have to communicate this thing. And he tried to tell me. And I could not read lips. And that was the moment where I was like, OK, I'm angry enough now to have an inert to figure out exactly what this word is that we're trying to say, you know what I mean?

Angry problem solving destined is effective. Yeah, you know what I mean? I don't actually. I've never seen you angry problem solving good.

I believe it's effective. Yeah. It felt like the thing to say. I got angry.

I was like, I'm angry because you're frustrated. I'm frustrated. We both love each other and we want to communicate and we're going to make this happen. And so that's going down tomorrow.

I've decided. So I'm going to figure out how to do that. A lot of people are telling me about adaptive technologies. There's a thing on your iPhone or your, uh, your Android called scanning.

Have you ever heard of this? I've heard of scanning as like a word. So how do you mean? Basically it scans the letter, scans through the letters on your phone and then you click with whatever input you can do, whether that squeeze something or click something or whatever input method you're capable of.

You click when you get to the letter you want and then it will reduce the number of letters based on the words in the English language. Oh, so it's like the predictive text like we used to do with the, uh, the old flip phones. You do like, what was it? T9?

Yeah, exactly. And then you know, using rows and letters and stuff like that. That's what that's what people are saying is the thing to do. And so I'm just working on trying to get an input and then I just called a buddy of mine, Ryan, his daughter has had accessibility issues in the past.

And so I called him. I was like, Hey, I need your brain right now. And he's super, super smart. He's actually a test pilot.

And so he knows about input to machines. He gave me some links and some of that check them out. Makes stuff happen. I know this is a super serious topic, but did you ever, did you ever see the onion news network video about the Mac wheel?

No, this sounds amazing. It's, it's this next generation Mac computer where they eliminate the keyboard entirely for simplicity and sleekness. And all it is is one giant old old school iPad wheel with a giant button in the, oh my gosh, I'm full enough on the machine. You just have to scroll through endlessly.

It's like literally anything you want to do on your computer is just a few hundred mouse clips away. It's funny. That sounds like the way Mac's going, by the way. Yeah.

I think, I think Apple has full on loss their way. No doubt. Yeah. I think we've gone to crazyville as well.

The, the Galaxy S8 is out, but supposedly the S9 is coming out soon. So I'm in that weird place between waiting for the next version and getting this one. So I think I'm going to wait another month and a half or so and get the S9. Which means I'm only awesome and up to date for a couple more months.

Yeah. How about Apple? Are you okay with me complaining about phones for me? I feel like I just totally hijacked this.

Yeah. Yeah. We need to do this. How about Apple intentionally sabotaging their own product to get people to buy newer versions of the same product?

That is total horse crap, man. But here's the deal. Here's the deal. I have one comment about this.

I have a comment about the iPhone. Does it involve causation and correlation? No, it's not normalized. So does that graph like people just searching iPhone?

Obviously that would correspond to the release of the iPhone. But I don't think that graph that you showed me is an accurate data set because I think it's naturally skewed because people were searching for iPhones anyway at that point in time. Yeah. I think that's a fair point.

I also think though, that those people are searching for iPhones anyway. I think that's a fair point. I think that's a fair point. I think that's a fair point.

I also think though, that those spikes are so exaggerated that even if you do somehow normalize that or consider a different data set, it looks like there's still some correlation. Well, I don't. Okay. For example, let's say pick something out about you.

So let's go with ruggedly handsome. Okay. So attractive beard. Attractive beard.

Let's do that. Strong shoulder muscles. That's far better than what I was going to do. Okay.

So let's say you have a video that goes viral. Okay. I like that. That's good.

Yeah. Because videos about people explaining text criticism of the Greek manuscript evidence supporting the New Testament, that stuff is flaming hot. I'm really liking your delivery lately, by the way. You're hitting the groove.

I like what you're doing it. Anyway, so let's say that you did a Matt Whitman ruggedly handsome search, right? Yeah. Let's say that.

I don't do that regularly, but let's say that could happen. It would spike every time one of your viral videos spiked, right? Because people are trying to find out who you are, who's this Matt Whitman character that's so ruggedly handsome. I like that.

I mean, I don't necessarily believe that that particular graph you sent me is fair. However, the fact that they were doing that and not being 100% open and honest about it from the beginning, that right there is shifty. But you know what else is shifty? Vermaliers.

Verizon. I believe that Verizon is limiting the speed of videos being downloaded on my phone specifically with Snapchat. Really? Used to.

I could just blaze through the Snapchat feed that my family was sending me that you were sending now anytime I tried to load it is so incredibly slow, but it's only with Snapchat. I get on Wi-Fi. Really? It blazes.

How long has this been a deal? It's been a deal for several months. So pre net neutrality changes. I don't know.

Because everybody's brain is going right now. Yeah. All I know is that I tweeted some I was like, hey, so I get the deal that Apple is slowing down people's phones. I understand that.

We all need that for a long time now. Is anybody noticing that their Verizon service is slower? And people are responding and you know, most people, but two, there's people said yes. And so I don't know if it's true or not.

So I'm not accusing Verizon of anything. I'm asking questions. I'm on Verizon as well. And when I'm in Wyoming, it's like my home internet, which is blazing, by the way, because I assume my 4G network, my LTE network is being shared by like nine other Wyomingites and a bear.

No one's using it so it's fast. But when I go to four columns, which is in Colorado about five hours south, it is unbelievably slow. It won't play YouTube videos at times. I mean, it will be going to load it.

Like load it. It's 2018. We don't load things anymore. Okay.

This is direct. What I said, the iPhone slowdown was obvious. If you're a Verizon customer, have you also noticed throttling of data speeds? My point was 2017 LTE doesn't seem to be equal to 2015 LTE, because it's telling you how much service you have supposedly, right?

Yeah. So out of the people that responded over double the amount said yes, it is slower. Yeah. It doesn't surprise me at all.

And Verizon said, we always want you to receive the best service possible. Please go ahead and test your speed and tell us what speed you're getting. And they provided a speed test for me to do speedtest.net. My response is, but it seems like you're throttling for the video.

Of course, the speed test is going to be fast. Oh, you know, thank you for offering a solution that in no way addresses the concerns I clearly articulated. Let's do an ad first and then I'll talk net neutrality. What do you say?

Okay, I'm fine. Yeah, sure. Let's add it up. All right, here we go.

This episode of No Dumb Questions is brought to you by HelloFresh. HelloFresh is a meal kit delivery service that shops, plans, and delivers your favorite step by step recipes and pre-measured ingredients so you can just cook, eat, and enjoy. Those are their words and I agree with them. Here are my words, which is a sloppier way of saying the same thing.

HelloFresh is making me better at food. There's no way around it. Every time we do this, I learn something both about how to appreciate food that is outside of my normal sphere of foods I would consider. And also each time we do this, I learn something about how to be better in the kitchen.

I learned to identify foods that I didn't know what they were. I learn how to cook things the right way at the right time and it's not intimidating. I can improve this neglected skill set that I have while not risking wrecking a meal because the instructions are so easy to follow. And so far, every time I've cooked or helped cook, everybody's liked what I did.

So it makes me feel like I'm actually useful in the kitchen as well. The cool thing about this is that even if you're a person who travels a lot or has a weird schedule, it's super flexible. You can initiate and suspend deliveries at a pace that makes sense for you. And it shows up on time.

It shows up the right way. The packaging is brilliant. It's recyclable. You're not wasting stuff.

So the convenience of the thing really is part of the appeal. But once again, the biggest part of the appeal for me is just that it tastes good. And I'm getting to a place in life where I'm more and more tired of junk and I notice it more and more when I eat bad stuff. I just don't feel good.

I feel good after I eat this. And that matters to me. It makes the rest of the day better. It makes the next day better.

So I look forward to these meals. I've got really smart people who work on this to review the recipes to make sure they are what they need to be. So you can eat with confidence knowing that you're putting stuff in your body. You ought to be putting in your body.

So it's a great way to grow. It's a great way to eat something good. And it's flexible. And the kind of thing where you can make it fit to your lifestyle.

So I'm really positive about all that stuff. If you haven't tried this yet, I hope you'll give it a shot. We've been getting a lot of good feedback on this. It seems that it's pretty much unanimous that listeners who've given this a try have been really happy that they did and I think you'll feel the same way.

So anyway, the deal is that you can get 30 bucks off your first week of HelloFresh by going to HelloFresh.com slash NDQ and entering the promo code NDQ. Again, that gets you 30 bucks off your first week of HelloFresh. We really appreciate your support in general of this program. And if you want to support us, this is a really beneficial to you way to do that.

All right. Thanks so much. Let's go back to the conversation. Okay.

Net neutrality. Let's do this. Here we go. Cool.

Because you want the internet to hate you. To hate me or wait, do you have the right opinion? Do you have the approved opinion? That's the way this goes down, isn't it?

It is. You have to have the approved opinion or this doesn't work. Okay. So this is not a discussion.

This is how the things are and it's final. Oh, man. This is great because I know you're probably going to have the wrong opinion compared to the internet and your voice sounds like. I'm not going to have either of the opinions and it's going to irritate people.

So here's where I'm at. Here's where I'm at. I think because internet is pretty much I'm not going to say it's a right like Icelander whoever. No, it's not a right.

Internet is really, really important. It is the great equal. Totally agree. It is access.

You know what is the right? Hold on a sec. We can't get past this. What?

You know what is the right? Who is obstructing you from making a deal with somebody to go and get internet is wrong in you. Okay. You have that right for sure.

But to say that internet is a right means that someone must provide it. No matter what, it must happen. And that's called a positive right. Negative rights are those things that you have by virtue of existing positive rights or when you get into tricky territory.

Of course, lots of people think I'm an idiot about that, but it's in my opinion. I didn't want to engage on that because I didn't really understand it. But I think I'm not playing the ignorant guy here. I actually am the ignorant guy.

So a positive right means you get to do something. A positive right means a thing that someone must provide to you. So for example, people feel like a clean water is a right. And while I agree that everyone should get clean water, right is the wrong word because that means that if you're somewhere in the middle of nowhere, someone else must be conscripted to fly you in clean water.

Should that person have clean water? Yes, but you're not born with clean water. Whereas negative rights are those things assured in our founding documents. Like you have the right to life, liberty, pursuit of happiness because you don't need anybody else for that.

You have the right to speech or to assemble if you can get somebody who wants to assemble with you. Some of us have more trouble with that than others, but you get the point. So positive rights is just a thing where people are using the word right a lot to mean people really should have access to this. And they're right.

People should have access to this stuff. But to use the term right is just the wrong word. I can see where you're going already, man. Can you?

Your position is going to be. We're doing this 40% of the time. You know what I'm thinking. I'm going to do the mind reading thing.

That you're very good at it. 40% of the time. So your position is going to be that the internet companies should be able to do whatever the heck they want and you can either choose to sign up with them or not. Is that your position?

In a perfect world. Yes. In this world, my position is a little different than that. Okay.

I can't even finish this. I'm in a gag. I'm so sorry. I'll joke lighter in the future.

Go ahead. Go ahead with the stormtroopers. There's no stormtroopers in my actual opinion of your opinion. No.

I don't want to know what you think I think. I think we're going to end up in a very similar spot here. I think we both think that the goal should be that no one serves as the gatekeeper of the internet and that everyone has affordable access to a completely free and open internet where I think we might disagree is what the best way is to achieve that. Hmm.

So do you think that the government should provide roads? I think that the government is one way to make roads happen. Okay. And I'm totally cool with that being a way to do it.

Okay. Let's do that again. This time answer my question. Do you think the government should make roads?

Okay. I'm going to go and answer your question again. I think that's one great way to make roads happen. Okay.

I am totally cool with the level of overwhelming consensus we have to say government, you can collect money from us to make roads. We're cool with that as a solution to our road question right now. There might be a few people who are grouchy about that, but I think most of us are cool with kicking it on roads, right? Yeah.

Yeah. I think so. So there's the usual libertarian hang up about the roads. I mean, this is, you're not going to believe this is not the first time I've been presented with this question, but my not radical response is if there's overwhelming consensus, sure, tax stuff and we'll build it together through government.

But if that could happen through government, there's also a way for it to happen without government if we built it that way. It's not like people wouldn't want roads anymore. If there was no government, we just find some other way to do it. But I like the way we do it.

It's fine. So do you think government should connect people to the internet? No. Not at all?

No, no, not in an ideal world. What if there's overwhelming consensus? Yeah, that's a fair point. Overwhelming consensus, I think really does affect things.

I also think people should be able to opt out of that. And that's my weirdest view is I think more things should be opt in and more things should have an option to opt out so that you don't inflict the will of a majority on the will of the minority at every turn. Okay. So in the case of a major infrastructure element in society, such as roads, suits, and roads, sewer, things like that, trash removal, you kind of need government.

And in order to get a piece of glass from the center of the city all the way to my house, that's not really something I can pay for myself. It would be tricky. It would be tricky. Yeah, a lot of easements, a lot of work.

And somebody did the work to get all those easements and to make it happen, right? And that was a company, right? It was a company with the help of government. Okay.

So this is where my position becomes nuanced. Gotcha. I want the internet to be the Wild West. The best idea wins.

Everybody can say whatever they want and think whatever they want. It means a bunch of stupid stuff is going to end up on the internet. I don't care. Wild West, no victim, no crime.

If there is a victim, it is a crime, whether it's a virtual or not. So I want the freest, most unregulated speech ever right up to the point of victimizing people. But the problem with this and the problem that I have with my libertarian friends who are like on the other side of the net neutrality argument is that there's an infrastructure that we all kicked in on whether we wanted to or not. Whether you voted for it or not, the government collected money that you earned and then used it to build an infrastructure.

But they did so by making deals with certain companies, which means those companies have sweetheart deals that they bought from the government because they're definitely kickbacks for those companies to be the winners. So now you got other companies that could get in to make competition happen to drive costs down, but they can't get in because they didn't pay the upfront fee to put in the infrastructure, meaning you don't have legitimate competition, meaning you don't have the ability to drive prices down like you normally would. So it's this fun little challenge to the normal libertarian structure because you've got a physical monopoly that was built by past decision making. How do you unbuild the infrastructure?

How do you unbuild the monopoly? Right. One solution is just have the government. Yeah, regulate.

I mean, not regulate it. So how do people get into the game if the government regulates it? Bukus of money. Uh-huh.

That's the only way to do it. So one of the big bugs of the Obama era net neutrality as well, this allows competition. But does it really? How are you going to buy your way into a local market under the Obama era rules or under the new rules?

How can competition happen here? The only solution is infinite money. And that's the only solution, which is why Google's doing it. Or here's another solution, technological progress.

Find another way to move data in high volumes that doesn't involve digging up trenches and laying down cable. Wireless. Sure. It's interesting you bring that up because in developing nations like in South America and specifically in Africa, the cell phone technology boomed long before it did in the US because we had better infrastructure, better wired infrastructure, which I found fascinating.

Yeah, me too, when I first went to Africa in 2005 and because of my Western prejudices, I just expected, well, I got a lot of what I expected. I mean, I got a guy wearing a hollowed out dead monkey backpack. That's awesome. With the broken arms and legs tied together to form the back.

Are you serious? I got stuff like that. That's amazing. You had fruit in there.

Kind of ironic since there was probably fruit in there before too. Good for you, monkey. You live on even after. I mean, there was crazy backwards jungle stuff that I saw, but also I was like, how come?

How come everyone's phone is nicer than mine? Can I see that? Can I look at your phone? I had huge phone in me.

So yeah, you're right. I can attest. So you don't think that if I pay for internet, I should be able to get all of the internet. I do think that absolutely.

And that is the contract I want to make with whoever is selling internet. I want access to the whole thing. I don't really want the deal to change at all. I like the deal.

I liked the deal before the net neutrality regulations and I like the deal with the net neutrality regulations. But if you're a user, it's worked fine for me. Really? Well, yeah, I've had full access to the internet for the entire life of the internet, right?

The same bandwidth? Well, it's grown consistently. The longer I mean, I live in a place where the internet keeps getting faster. I know other people complain of the opposite.

I don't have that. I don't have that luxury. I live somewhere where I can get eight megabytes down. That's where I live.

Goodness. I know, dude. That's like my church internet. It's awful at work, but at home, it's multiple times that it's messed up, man.

It's really, really slow. I think I can get eight up at times, man. So when I get a Trent's house, he's got no joke. That has gigabit.

And so I go from eight megabytes down to like, hey, Trent, can I come sit in your driveway? He's like, deal junior and I go over there and boom gigabit. It's like, I can feel the Wi-Fi portion of my computer, wherever that is, just catching on fire. It's like a flamethrower.

It's amazing. Beautiful. Anyway, moving big files and stuff like that. Do you ever notice your internet being throttled?

Like do you notice? No, I never have. It's interesting that you bring up that you think technology should move forward because I'm experiencing the problems on Verizon. That's where I'm experiencing problems.

I think I'm not accusing them of anything. Well, why is Verizon incentivized right now to do a better job? Why would they introduce new technology to do a better job? It's their competition.

Who are they trying to beat? And I would argue they have no incentive. Right now, this moment, things are fine for them. Yeah.

Yeah. Why would charter or I'm sorry, no, you guys, Comcast, why would Comcast innovate or for that matter provide quality customer service? They don't have to. They bought the regulations.

They bought market victory all over the country from politicians who were delighted to get money for their reelection or chest. And so they provide crappy service and don't innovate and everyone hates them. Almost as much as EA. It's always one of those two companies.

It's the most despised, right? Have you seen the commercial they put up in Fort Collins right there near you? No, I know my buddy Adam in Fort Collins has a lot of opinions about this, but no, I haven't seen the commercial. Okay.

So apparently there's a city there. It might actually be Fort Collins, but the local government has decided they're going to create their own internet network right there. Yeah, I think that's Fort Collins. And they're like, everyone gets a flamethrower.

It's like everyone gets all the internet, all the speeds, everything. And they created an ad. This is clearly created by the cable companies that says the local government wants to give you internet. Shouldn't they be working on roads?

Oh, you're kidding. No, I'm not joking. This is their argument. Oh my goodness.

And so they're like 150 million dollars. And it's like, but traffic and it is the worst attempt at propaganda I've ever seen in my entire life. What about, yeah, one one fun thing about the commercial is everyone in the commercial is driving, but none of them are looking at the road. This is the fun thing.

Yeah, that's a nonsense argument. And here's the thing in Fort Collins, they're going to have overwhelming consensus. And you know what? If somebody doesn't want to buy internet from the government, they should be allowed to not buy internet from the government and not have to pay for it.

If you have overwhelming consensus, do it. If you've got light consensus and you're going to make everybody else do internet your way because you got to 51%, I think it's a jerk move. So my hope would be that however it ends up, that they get really good internet because that not scoring political points for your team is the stated objective and I happen to agree with the stated objective. We use the internet for everything.

It should be fast and it should be free and you should be able to do whatever you want short of hurting somebody. If some company comes along and like, oh, well, we can get into the market now and we can win, then everybody should probably make a contract with them until somebody can come up with a better deal and then they should make a contract with them. And if the government can do it the best, make a contract with the government brilliant. If Obamacare is the best way to get healthcare, buy Obamacare.

If something else is the best way, do that. That is how prices go down and innovation happens. Do you know anybody who doesn't want internet? I think there's some politicians in the UK who made some statements recently that makes me wonder if they prefer if the internet just went away.

Really? But now everybody wants internet except powerful people who know they can't control it. The internet's dangerous, man, like North Korea. North Korea.

And don't you think there's some political overtones of wanting to control the internet that have been involved in this whole conversation? Everybody wants to own it. Yeah. It's gold mine, man.

Silk Road, figuratively. Okay, I just sent you the video. Watch it. Alright, I'm on it.

Oh boy. It's already stupid looking. I love Fort Collins and things are really moving. Usually means traffic isn't.

Oh my goodness. Look at the road. I mean, you're not allowed to drive in text or talk on the phone in Fort Collins. Surely you can't record an ad while driving.

That is the stupidest ad I've maybe ever seen in my life. Did you notice not a single individual in the entire video that was driving was looking at the road? No, not at all. Which is that actually is illegal and has victims.

You don't want to look at roads. Their comments are disabled for the video and they even disabled the like dislike bar. You can do that. Yeah.

I should consider that. I didn't know that was an option. Boy, that Ghostbusters trailer they would have loved to have known that was a possibility. Yeah, I know.

What is so stupid about this is that people can't tell what's going on. You have two entities that should not partner up ever. You have business and the state. They should not engage in the same activity.

The state should regulate and ref business so that they don't cheat and swindle and injure or use violence to get ahead and win. They should do business and neither is really that dangerous without the other. The state can't do a lot of hurting people if they don't have any money provided by business and business can't do anything to people if the state is regulating the heck out of them and saying you can't do awful things to people. It's not that tough.

It used to be where we had this confusion was on the issue of church and state. And after the 30 years war in the 1600s and 600,000 people in Europe got killed over doctrinal disagreements that people started to think, you know, maybe we shouldn't have government and church interacting in this way so much. The church shouldn't be able to buy the government and then use the government's ability to use force to make church things happen. And then we had our liberal revolutions in America and France and Latin America and everywhere, right?

We're doing the same exact thing now with business, but we just haven't quite figured it out yet. People on the right are like government bad business good. People on the left are like business bad government good. And both are half right.

It's when you put them together that they wield actual dangerous power. You don't want Comcast having the authority of government. That is bad news. And you don't want the government operating on behalf of Comcast because Comcast bought laws.

Do you want the government in Fort Collins to create an internet infrastructure? Sure. I think it's a great idea. And if it's a terrible idea and it fails, I hope they let it fail.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 12 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on January 10, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.