Skip to content
033: The audience experience, with superfan Roderick Branch episode artwork

Oct 27, 2019 56 min

033: The audience experience, with superfan Roderick Branch

from Stand Partners for Life

Chicago Symphony cellist Brant Taylor may have been our very first special guest here at the Stand Partners, but so far we've been missing the perspective of his partner Roderick Branch. Roderick is a musician, though his day job (and sometimes into the night job) is as a partner at a giant law firm. Roderick is what you'd call an extremely savvy listener, otherwise known as a superfan. So today Akiko, Brant, and I talk with Roderick, to remember just who it is we're playing for. Roderick elaborates on the dynamics between orchestra and audience in the context of different halls around the world. We speak about the room for error in a magical rendition, the performer as an audience member, and how the level of familiarity with an orchestra affects our experience of it. We also get into the pros and cons of designs, histories, and acoustics of different halls. Next, we share many stories about what made a particular concert life-changing, and then weigh up the various traits of our favorite conductors. Finally, our pet peeves about off-putting audience or performer behavior take center stage. Key Points From This Episode Performers and audience members might feel differently about the quality of a symphony. The distance of a performer or observer from the orchestra changes how it sounds. Minor mistakes are less meaningful when there is great spirit in a performance. The mood of an audience member might change their experience of a performance. Live symphonies sound different to recorded and mastered ones. The way a musician reacts to something unexpected is an indicator of how prepared they are. Experiencing different hall acoustics is neither good or bad but special. Sometimes one has to try to be less critical to have a good time. Knowing the orchestra might change the experience of watching them for better or worse. Knowing who is playing could change whether Roderick goes to a concert or not. Disney Hall’s modernity compared to the sense of history of Symphony Center. The acoustics of Disney hall are like a soft focus lens, while Chicago Hall is less forgiving. Less forgiving acoustics can be liberating because it allows for powerful playing. Hearing the same orchestra playing in different halls is a good way of seeing their difference. Great conductors bring out aspects in a symphony not heard before. The respect the orchestra has for a good conductor is palpable in their body language. It is difficult to be fully present as a musician in every performance. Several stories of the most life-changing performances the group have ever seen. Barenboim, Boulez, Haitink and Muti compared by Roderick. Off-putting performer behavior: not looking engaged and talking during the applause. Off-putting audience behavior: humming, cellphones, leaving too early, coughing. Links Brant Taylor Roderick Branch Chicago Symphony Orchestra Bartok Concerto For Orchestra LA Philharmonic Disney Concert Hall Symphony Center Orchestra Hall Daniel Burnham The Burnham Plan of Chicago Barbara Walter Milli-Vanilli Musikverein Carnegie Hall Concertgebouw Severance Hall Riccardo Muti Krassimira Stoyanova Pierre Boulez Ben Molar Daniel Barenboim Ma Vlast The Moldau Bernard Haitink Shakespeare Beethoven 9 Verdi: Requiem The Hollywood Bowl Jumbotron Anne-Sophie Mutter “If you’re performing a string quartet or a solo piece, the way you react to things that don’t go totally as planned is the biggest indicator of how well prepared something is.” — @ Akiko Tarumoto [0:12:07] “If you listen to the concert with your music critic hat on, that detracts from the enjoyment of the experience.” — @ Roderick Branch [0:18:10] “It’s actually an interesting hobby to hear an orchestra you know well, play in different halls. It’s the best way to figure out exactly how much difference the hall can make for, better or worse, in the way that something sounds.” — @ Brant Taylor [0:24:54] “I think I was probably looking down at the stage just taking in and basking in the glory of this beautiful sound in the context of the piece being heard for the first time, and at one point, I looked up at Mr. Boulez, and tears were streaming down his face.” – @ Brant Taylor [0:35:15] “I mean if I pay to go to a concert I want to stay to the bitter end.” — @natesviolin [0:50:26] Transcript EPISODE 33 [INTRO] [0:00:00.0] NC: Hello and welcome back to Stand Partners for Life. I am Nathan Cole. [0:00:04.7] AT: I am Akiko Tarumoto. [0:00:20.0] NC: Today we are thrilled to be here with our good friends and actually the first repeat podcast guest here on Stand Partners. Brant Taylor, cellist in the Chicago symphony. [0:00:29.2] BT: Thank you, it’s nice to be here. [0:00:31.5] NC: And now Brant’s partner Roderick Branch who is a musician but these days, primarily an attorney and in the context of today’s episode, a super fan because we’re going to get that audience perspective today and that’s what it’s going to be about from someone who comes to all sorts of concerts, not only in Chicago but around the world and we want to know what you see that we miss when we’re on stage. [0:00:58.5] BT: I know there’s lots of musicians that probably say, “I could never be married to another musician,” or some people that say, you know, “I could only be married to another musician.” [0:01:07.8] AT: I think there’s a lot of envy with people who actually managed to get out of our little tiny group of people and meet somebody who does something else and can sort of, add that diversity to your life. [0:01:22.3] RB: I mean I dunno if I would say that applies to us because when we met, I was still playing the Cello but at least, what I ended up doing – Yes, it’s definitely outside the field of music although I do tend to spend a lot of time around musicians and at concerts simply because of well, it’s something I like to do and it’s also related to the way that our schedules work. Brant’s working times are Thursday nights, Friday nights and Saturday nights which, for somebody who has got an office job like me or generally the times that we have off. I spend a lot of those times going to concerts, otherwise we’d be passing ships I think. [0:02:02.1] BT: Yeah, probably. [0:02:03.6] NC: Well, we’ll call that a partial escape for you Brant. You managed too sort of get out of the musician pairing here. [0:02:11.5] AT: But I mean, Roderick, can you tell us what brought you to your current career, what is that that you’re doing now? [0:02:17.8] RB: Sure, I was in – well I’m a lawyer now, I practice capital markets transactions at a large law firm and what brought me to my career was probably ending up with a degree in English literature, French literature, and music right out of undergrad and quickly deciding that I had nothing else to do but apply for law school. [0:02:35.4] NC: This sounds familiar. [0:02:36.8] AT: I think I’ve said that exact thing so I didn’t get into law school so that fixed it for me. [0:02:43.8] NC: Are you also on the board of the Chicago Symphony or one of the governing – I forget what it’s called. [0:02:51.8] RB: I’m what’s called a governing member which is kind of like the junior board and the governing members vote to elect members of the board of trustees. [0:03:02.3] NC: How many concerts would you say you go to or how many programs do you think you see of the CSO every season? [0:03:08.1] RB: Yeah, that’s a good question. The CSO probably plays 48 weeks a year, is that right Brant? I don’t go every single week but I would say that I would go most weeks. [0:03:19.4] NC: That’s been now for how many years would you say? [0:03:22.6] RB: Well, I guess I started actively listening to the CSO, when I was in live performance anyway, when I was in law school. Brant and I met right around the time that I was graduating as an undergrad. We were friends for the next four years or so. The CSO would come on tour to Boston where I was going to law school or New York where I first started my first job and I would usually go hear the concerts either at Symphony hall or at Carnegie hall. That would be going back to probably 2000, 2001. Call it over 20 years at this point. [0:03:58.6] NC: Well, let’s get right to it because I’m really interested to hear what you see and hear, Roderick, that we miss even though we think we’re right in the middle of the action. We can do the math, I mean, you’ve been coming to concerts for 20 years and however many – 20 Or 30 programs a year, so that’s a significant amount of performing that you have seen and you guys have – you get something that we don’t. We play the same concert and then we ride home in the car together and record a podcast about our thoughts but we were both on stage. Whereas you, you know – Brant will be performing in concert, Roderick, you’re out there in the house and so your perspective is going to be different. We were saying before we turned on the mics that there were probably a lot of weeks where Brant, you’ll feel like things was just terrible and you weren’t having any kind of a good time on stage and then Roderick, you might say it was an amazing life changing performance, does that happen? [0:04:56.3] BT: That happens sometimes. I’d say, more often, it happens that the way that I felt the concert went on stage, turns out to be, you know, similar to the impression that you had from the audience. [0:05:07.3] RB: That’s usually true, I will say that I’m a harsh critic of most concerts and I usually will be very honest with what I think I heard, when I talk to Brant about things. You know, I definitely have opinions about repertoire, conductors, the particular people who may be playing particular parts on the stage which can make a big difference bu

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

033: The audience experience, with superfan Roderick Branch

0:00 56:18

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Stand Partners for Life?

This episode is 56 minutes long.

When was this Stand Partners for Life episode published?

This episode was published on October 27, 2019.

Can I download this Stand Partners for Life episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.