Hey, Dustin Sandlin, this is a special episode. Do you know why? It's a book review episode and it's your book. It would have been really weird if you'd said like, no, I don't know why.
Because we need to talk about my book and I'm hoping you'd prepare it. Have you prepared? I have, yeah. I'm gonna sit in here.
I want to talk about the book itself first though, but I don't think people have to listen to this book in order for them to enjoy this episode. Would you agree? Yeah, okay. The book is How to Think, A Survival Guide for a World at Odds by Alan Jacobs.
And obviously, since I picked the book, I like the book, but why do you think people don't need to listen to it? This is a deep, thinky book, obviously, but the principles we're going to talk about, they're pretty, I don't know, it's not like a plot line. You don't have to listen to an entire book to get the story arc and stuff like that. And I'm gonna tell you more about my thoughts on this book in particular in a second, but first, I think we need to address something.
This is written by a human Alan Jacobs and in the book, he mentions other podcasts that he's listened to, right? So I mean, yeah, he lives in our world a little bit, I think. I think it's possible he may stumble upon this episode and listen to this episode. So we need to address that.
How do we address that? I would like to introduce you to Alan Jacobs because I don't think, I don't know, he probably has no idea who we are. So can I do that real quick? Okay.
I accept. All right, Mr. Jacobs, here's the deal. We normally pull a third chair up to the table every once in a while, and we talk to people.
So we're talking specifically to you. I think this is the only time we ever talked to one human, but Alan, this is my buddy Matt. Matt is a hyper-intelligent individual. He lives in Landar, Wyoming.
He's a pastor. He's got multiple degrees. Matt, I think it's history. There's some military tactics in there.
There's some theology, and then there's, what's the other one? There's another one. Oh, Western thought, this is right up his alley. But on top of all that, Matt is probably one of the most hyper-competent, socially intelligent people I know, which is why I asked him to be my friend a while back.
So anyway, he cares about the Bible and the internet. He has a thing called Tim and the Bible Hour, where he talks through the hard stuff in the Bible. It's interesting, dude. And he recommended this book to the entire internet.
So I think you should, I don't know, maybe give him a tweet at Matt, wait, man, TMBH. Is that too strong? I went too strong. I'm sorry.
That was a certain. Yeah. I was almost uncomfortable. Yeah.
So Mr. Jacobs, this is my friend, Destin Sandlin. He lives in Northern Alabama, and he is an engineer by trade rocket scientist. He doesn't claim that because it makes him sound fancy, and his mom told him not to get all fancy sounding just because he was a rocket scientist.
Literally, she told him that on the day he got his degree. But he worked at the Redstone Test Center forever and made rockets and did tests, and it's been really fascinating to follow his journey in that regard. But at the same time that he's been doing that, he's also been doing this internet thing, especially with his YouTube channel Smarter Every Day, where he does educational stuff, largely about science, but nothing's off limits. And part of the reason that I think he and I are friends is because I think even though he is a hard sciences engineering guy, I think he's wired more like you, in that he thinks really hard about thinking.
He thinks about the social dance of thinking. He thinks about the big meta picture of thinking. And he likes to understand it. And so your book is like a more complex version of the conversations that we have as we think about the same kind of stuff.
And so I really wanted him to read this thing because I thought it would supercharge our discussions and move the whole thing forward. And then it ended up just becoming a part of the podcast. So thanks for writing it. And if you are listening, I hope we don't completely disappoint you.
But we'll try and give real honest feedback about what we thought. What do you think? Is that another chair? I think so.
Am I clear to push Mr. Jacobs away from the table? Like literally I have a chair. I can push it away.
Gentle. Yeah. Here we go. Yeah.
Listen to this chair. I think it's leaving. Bye. Bye, Alan.
You seemed great. Okay. So now we're going to be honest. Why the heck did you pick another book that's like hardcore, thinky?
And there's like no stories and stuff. I had people text me and tell me, like Matt's not allowed to pick stories anymore or pick books anymore because this is so hard to listen to. Was it the old man? How many people texted you?
40? 60? Go 100? Just one.
So it was one. So person would have another word you could use to describe how many people it was. That's true. But it's a one person one person text to me.
But they have a point. So here's the deal when I pick books, I usually pick books that are fun because people only have a certain amount of time to listen to stuff. And they want to pick stuff that's interesting and entertaining and things like that. And so I pick books like Inters game and just you know, really which was fun.
Yeah, it's fun. But you pick books like make me explore the inner depths of my soul and like try to make me have an existential crisis while I'm writing the book. What's the deal? Good literature does that to you, whether it's fiction or otherwise, right?
But okay, first of all, I'm not going to defend myself on this at the expense of the books you've picked. Inters game was wonderful. I didn't think it necessarily would be, but it really worked for me and it made me think about stuff and it affected my life. Ready Player One was silly, a little more lightweight.
It did not change my life, but I really had fun with it. And there were a few themes that were enjoyable to explore. So I liked the books that you have picked. But taking Inters game as an example, it was subversive.
And you feel like you're getting a book here about kid stuff that's kind of cute and harmless and then it kind of amps up in terms of intensity. And by the end, you're thinking about like life and death and you know, really effectively you get to the end, you're thinking about the repugnant cultural other. You're thinking about that dangerous distant other that you don't know what to do with. Well, holy tell, that was where this book takes you.
Whitman, that was masterful. That was really good. I mean, yeah, dude, that was good. You around the thought for me, you're tracking?
I didn't see that coming. But so you're saying, oh wait, I'm about to do the thing where I say so you're saying, which is what this book told me not to give you question. So it's cool. Okay, so what you're saying is that Inters game does similar things to what this book does only subversively because it makes you think about people that are different from you and eventually get to the point where you can try to empathize with them.
Roger that my friend. Dang, that was good. Yeah. Okay.
And so one does it artfully through great storytelling and you experiencing those things to wrestle with vicariously through a character with whom you share some traits and some not traits. The other kind of kicks down the front door burst through the brick wall like a gooleve man is like, Hey, let's think about who we are inside and how we talk with other people, but they both push us and I want to get pushed figuratively. Okay, so that being said, sometimes books like this, the way they're packaged, they're less palatable. They're just harder to consume.
But I'm not saying I didn't enjoy it because holy cow, dude, at the end of this book, I feel, you know, one of the things he talks about at the end of the book is, you know, be careful with your metaphors, but I just want to try one. Okay. Every interaction that I have on social media with people that I don't agree with, it feels like this dance. It feels like we're too fencers and we're like going at it and we're trying to score points against each other or something like that, or maybe, well, I mean, to use the illustration that he used because he says we shouldn't think this way.
And I did like a battlefield, right? And so I'm up against this other person and I'm trying to strategically win the argument or win the battle. Reading this book feels like you're on that battlefield, but you have this third perspective. It's like if one side during the Civil War had instantly had satellite imagery that they could use so they could see from above how the battle was playing out and they could just watch the points that each other were making and say, Oh, look, oh, he's doing this there.
Oh, he's building the straw man so that he can, you know, or does that make any sense? Yeah, it really does. And it's not that it's not that you use that that perspective to more decisively kill your enemy. It's that you want to understand the battle in general.
And I think this book has helped me do that in a way that I wasn't really prepared for. And since reading it, there's a couple things that particularly from the checklist at the end that I think about before I tweet something or before I respond on the internet. So thank you for suggesting the book. It is cool.
It is vegetables or making vegetables. This is like meat potatoes, right? I mean, this is hardcore stuff. So yeah, this is definitely not cotton candy like some of them that I suggest.
And I'm glad for that. I want to be changed by the things that I invest in reading. And thank you for suggesting Enders game as our last one because I got to the end. And I realized that, wow, you know, the other is not necessarily my enemy.
And there's a quest to be embarked on like ender to go and understand the enemy that I just got done eradicating. And so when I came to this book, if I'm to be totally truthful, my pride brain was relabeling this book, how to win? How to win or how to be reaffirmed that you already think right? And I think that's honestly what I was hoping the book would do when I downloaded it and turned it on and started listening to it in the car.
I wanted it. I was hoping that I would go through and everything would be like, oh, I already do that. I already do that too. I'm already a great thinker.
And it didn't do that. It pushed back on me and made me feel weird. Why did you download this book? Like you didn't just find it.
Somebody told you about it, obviously. Who told you about it? And why did you read it? Yeah, my friend Mark, who is a journalism professor, I think I mentioned him too before.
He's the one who recommended it to me. This guy, Alan Jacobs, I believe was at the same undergraduate college where Mark went. I think they were both at Wheaton in Wheaton, Illinois at the same time. And so I think that's what caused Mark to read the book.
And Mark, well, about four years ago, now, four years ago, spend 10, 12 years ago now, I gathered the people who I respected the most at that time in terms of sort of academic-y thinkers, a guy named Matt Osterkamp, my friend Aaron Utect, and my friend Mark Cottington. I was like, hey, we're all guys who right now are using too much of our intellectual energy to complain about things we don't like, about the world, about religion. What if we put our heads together on a couple of long writing retreats and tried to make a book of constructive proposals for how to make it better? And so these guys were on that kind of Mount Rushmore of peers who I hyper respect.
And Mark has always been a dude who's a very, very honest thinker. He doesn't need to win at stuff. He's very secure in his own skin. So when he recommended the book, I was like, this will make me better.
I need to read it. And then I read it. And I was like, this will also make Destin better. I want him to read it too.
And then I want to use it to sharpen each other. So that's how it happened. Cool. Well, thanks for sharing it with me.
I appreciate it. And right now, after talking about all that, there's two things I'm thinking about. Okay. If I had a Mount Rushmore friends who would be on it, and what would satellite imagery do to the Civil War?
Those sound like really good episodes. They really do. Okay, cool. So we jump right into it?
Yeah. And you know what? There's about the kind of people I left off my list of super smart people who I don't want to feel bad that they weren't on that Mount Rushmore list. So everybody else, you're real smart too?
Sorry. No, you know, you've jettled it and it's down, man. It's a bigger Mount Rushmore. It's a future one that includes all the presidents.
So no one has to feel bad. It's a very big mountain. Huge thanks to Audible for sponsoring this episode. You can get a free audiobook by going to audible.com slash in DQ.
Obviously, this is a book review episode. We love this. We love like everybody listening to the book on their own. And then we come together and we talk about it.
This was Matt. So I'm going to pick the next one. It's a blast. But the important thing here is they sponsor the episode.
So you can get your own audiobook, whatever the heck you want, by going to audible.com slash in DQ. Matt, what's the other way they can book? You can text and DQ to 500 500. Then you get the whole same deal set up on your phone that way.
Yeah. And you actually own the books. You can send them to people. So we're actually in the middle of a book review.
So I don't think we have to belabor this. You obviously know what's going on here. Get it. Audible.com slash in DQ or text in DQ to 500 500.
Thanks Audible for sporting. Thanks Audible. Oh, everybody. One of the things that a couple of professors told me in grad school was, Hey, I know you got a lot of books to read here.
Grad school is a little bit different animal. I do need you to understand all of these books. But here's a pro tip. If you really want to understand a book about ideas, read the introduction again and again until you could repeat the author's argument without even having read the rest of the book and you will get the book and you'll power through it fast.
The introduction is the book in a good book. So I spent a lot of time on this introduction. I think I've been through it half a dozen times easily. And I've got a bunch of stuff that stood out to me.
But I'm guessing some stuff stood out to you here. So I'm going to bounce it to you first. What jumped off the page for you in the introduction? Um, I didn't, I didn't take notes like that.
I took bigger overarching notes. Like for example, my first question for you is, is this book in like totality, is it a full on response to Twitter? And what's happening on Twitter? That's a really good question.
Well, I think he turns over his hand later on and acknowledges that at least a percent of this is motivated by responding to Twitter. When I read the book, every interaction that, you know, all these hypothetical interactions that are on the internet that you're having with people, I'm just sitting there thinking about my Twitter account. Your Twitter account is nice. What are you talking about?
Yeah, I know, because I, there's a lot of things I don't want to respond to and I just don't. I don't. But I don't know. Just, I see people interact on Twitter in different ways.
Like I have, I have been tempted to do things like if I had a bad customer service experience just to like blow people up on Twitter about it. I've been tempted to do things like that and I try really hard not to not to do that. Do you give it five minutes when you want to? I give it infinity minutes.
So that's even more minutes. That's more minutes. So I don't know, just in general, how much do you think this book is a response to Twitter? I think this is a bigger picture response to a meltdown, a breakdown in our ability to communicate, especially with people we disagree with.
I think Twitter is one of the vehicles that gets us there because those repugnant cultural others, and we'll get into that more in a minute, used to be a very foreign group of people. You just didn't interact with them. They didn't affect your world. They never made it onto your lawn.
But now with social media, you have to account for those people. They will see what you wrote and they will reply and it will get weird. And it feels like, like we're at in the evolution of our social brain, we just weren't quite ready for that leap into having the repugnant cultural other right on top of us all the time. And that's why I think the bold language of a survival guide is appropriate.
I feel like he's really trying to equip us to do something that we are ill-equipped to do. In the introduction, he references this guy, Kahneman Daniel Kahneman. I think that's right. And he's this guy who has argued that human thought gets divided up into system one thought and system two thought and that system one thought is the intuition, the visceral reaction to stuff and that system two thought where we really break things down and think hard is much more rare.
And a lot of times, if I'm reading it right, that system two thought just deteriorates into using our cold reasoning skills to justify our initial system one reaction. And so Jacob's in the introduction, he interacts with some of these other sociologists, Jonathan Heit is another one that he touches on a little bit. That's the guy who had the elephant and the writer metaphor. And then he says that maybe the problem with some of those models is that we're focusing too much on the science of thinking and forgetting that there's an art to thinking as well.
Well, I think one part that resonated with me is he said, well, when we start to think of the brain as a computer, we're screwing up because it's way more complicated than that. There's a lot that goes into it that's not just ones and zeros coming in and coming out. I mean, there's a lot of subtlety and emotions playing in. There's chemical things that happen that are external to the brain that probably affect how your brain works.
I mean, there's a lot to it. And so I think that's one problem with the science of thinking is we'd like to see a flow chart of how things work. And I don't think it's always that simple. I think there's a lot more nuance into why people make what decisions they do.
I've seen super smart people arrive at the wrong conclusion because they've rationalized themselves into that hole. I can think of a ton of examples. I mean, the most notable that I always reference because it's like this, you know, I put this on a shelf so I can look at it, but it's that time I bought that car that I shouldn't have bought. Yeah, the Supra.
I like to think about that because it's like, oh, wow, I can make really big mistakes by not thinking correctly. Yeah, I should have bought the Corolla that the engineer had all the oil change receipts for for the past 10 years, but instead I bought the stick shift Supra that somebody had bought the word turbo and like stuck it on the side that counts. Yeah, I think back to that time because that was a moment in time where my thinking was corrupted and it ended up costing me dearly. And so sometimes my goal at this point, what I'm thinking is to minimize pain for future destiny.
That's a very noble high functioning goal of thought, isn't it? I mean, nothing wrong with that. There's a guy that I respect, Steve, you know, Steve, Steve, babe, and I respect him too. There's two main reasons why people do things.
One is the anticipation of pain. So they try to avoid it or the anticipation of a pleasure. And those are some really big thoughts that go into people's decision making process. And so I think sometimes you can make a decision knowing it will cause you pain, especially in the short term, but hopefully it'll help the overall grand scheme, whatever you're trying to do with the world in the long run.
Anyway, science and art of thinking. Okay, two thoughts on that. One, the first time I read this book, and I mean, it's got to be like in the first four or five pages, he uses the analogy of your system one thought and your system two thought when buying a car. And I laughed out loud thinking of your experience with the toy of Supra, knowing that I was going to have you read this book that he used an example directly ripped from the pages of your life, maybe chuckle, but two.
So Steve makes that point about anticipation of pleasure or avoidance of pain as being prime motivators in our thinking. How do you think that figures into disagreeing or getting into it with people on the internet? Do we get into it with people on the internet in weird ways because we want pleasure or because we're avoiding pain or is it something else? Oh, I think I think he picked an excellent example when he went with Megan Phelps-Roper when he started talking about, you know, she had the she grew up in this certain environment for people that hadn't read the book.
You know, she was part of the Westboro Baptist Church movement. And if you don't know what that is, well, do you want to explain that briefly? You probably have a better handle on the yeah, Westboro Baptist Church is somewhere in Kansas. It's a church that is mostly made up of the relatives and descendants of a guy named Fred Phelps.
I know you call him a fundamentalist. That might be meaningless. The medalist. This is a dude who just got to a place where his read on the Bible was so bizarrely obsessed with particularly sex and not just sex, but gay sex like that for whatever reason of all the things in the Bible.
That is the one that jumped off the page and was like, nope, not that one, which is weird because like on a list of things that come up, it's way, way down there in terms of frequency of mention. But for whatever reason, he felt like this is what is wrecking society and there would have been some other probably theological assumptions about how this was undercutting God's plan for America. I don't know. The dude turned nasty and he's brilliant.
I think he was a former lawyer or something brilliant, strategic dude. And with this tiny little church he managed to go around and pick fights with basically everyone in the name of their church being the only one that's right. And I had a couple of personal experiences with this church. I don't think you and I will discuss this before.
Have we? You've had personal experiences with Westboro Baptist Church? Yeah. Hold on.
Let me get some popcorn here. Go. What happened? I worked at a church in Nebraska.
Big church. I was like the 15th guy on the totem pole. I was not important there. There was a church that was really thriving when I was there and there was a death in the church of a guy who was a very dear friend of mine.
Wonderful dude. But he was a guy who liked to write his motorcycle and he was a part of something that I think they called the Patriot Guard. And what this Patriot Guard would do? Oh yeah.
Oh you've heard of this? Yeah. So when these Westboro Baptist Church people will go and protest the funeral, the Patriot Guard will ride and they will stand in between the family who's mourning and these every word I want to say, I'm not going to say, these people that do things at these funerals. And so they try to stand in the gap there.
They kind of form a human shield to protect those who are mourning. Exactly. So this guy was one of those dudes? Yes.
So Fred Phelps, you know, Westboro goes around. They do protest funerals or they did. I don't know what they do now. And part of that was like they somehow in their brain correlated soldiers dying to some sort of divine retribution for people of the same gender having relationships.
I don't get it. That doesn't sound like the mind of God from the Bible, but whatever. And so these Patriot Guard would do what you said. And my buddy was a part of that group.
Well, they kept a list of people who were a part of that Patriot Guard group. And then when they would die, they'd go protest the Patriot Guardsmen's funerals. I was co- I don't know what you call it, officiating this funeral. And we started driving up and we'd heard that Westboro was going to be there.
We knew what corner they were going to be on in town. We knew what signs they were going to be holding. And sure enough, there they were. But all of these other gruff biker types turned out and completely boxed them in.
They didn't lay hands on them. They don't do physical confrontation. And so it was pretty cool to see all of these friends of my buddy stand up to the Westboro, bully jerks. But the signs they were holding were just a level of shocking cruelty.
That is one thing to hear about in a news story. It's another thing to be going to mourn the loss of your dear friend and see some clown holding that crap on a street corner. It's a nasty group. It's the point.
It really does hurt me that they do it. And they do it supposedly in the name of God. That really hurts me. But whatever.
So what I thought was interesting in the choice of Megan Phelps Roper, by the way, excellent story. Oh, yeah. That's cool. Did not know that.
Oh, the story I was telling. Thank you. Yeah, interesting stuff I thought. I thought the choice of using Megan Phelps Roper in this book and showing that she turned as a result of an interaction on Twitter that was charitable where someone just interacted with her.
I forget the guy's name. Was it Devin or someone? He said the problem with Twitter is that people talk back. And so she was tweeting and then this guy responded to her and he was charitable.
Nice. And you know, hey, he may be wrong, but you know, he seems nice. And that's hard. And that kind of melted her brain a little bit.
And that kind of eventually turned her and she stopped by making one decision. I thought this was very interesting. And the decision was to not hold one of the particular signs at the by the way, did you find it shocking that he just wrote all the words in the book? I'm so grateful that he didn't need to quit being afraid of words.
We do. I'm cool that you and I are trying to do something that people can listen with kids that anybody gets to down with their kids and listen to. But if you're talking to adults, we need to quit being afraid of words. Things need to be said, so we know what we're talking about.
I thought it was so cool. They used all the words. Anyway, so yeah, it takes their power away. Use them.
So she had a sign that said, you know, three words, God hates and then slur for these people. I think it's slur. I don't know how it works. And she made a decision.
No, no, something about people dying. I forget what it was. But she made this decision to quit holding the sign. And it was an internal decision that she didn't talk about with people in the group.
But she goes, you know what? That's just a little line too far. I'm going to take one step back from holding that particular sign. And that was the beginning of the shift in thought.
And even if that's all she did, even if she stopped, just quit, you know, I'm not going to hold that sign anymore. That just seems mean. That's interesting because the question that Devin asked her was, well, how can these people ever be saved if you kill them? And there's another response to that.
So she's like, okay, well, that's a logical I'm going to stop doing promoting that. So I just think it's fascinating. It's a good response. And it's one of those rare times where a good response actually gets through the armor.
Yeah, but it starts with one decision, right? She made a decision to not do one of these things that she was doing. And she didn't tell anybody because maybe she was ashamed that other people in her group might not, you know, appreciate her decision. So that tells you there was some fear there.
So let me ask you this, Matt, is there ever been a moment in your life where you've made this internal decision and you didn't want to tell people around you because it wasn't, you know, in Vogue or whatever? But have you ever done that? Have you ever seen something going on? You know what?
I'm not going to do that anymore. Or I'm not going to laugh at that joke anymore or these types of things. I need permission to nuance. It's going to take just a second to settle, okay?
Sure. Yeah. Because you're asking about something that's pretty important to me. Well, there are two things you don't have to get very deeply.
You don't have to get too personal if you don't want it. That's okay. I mean, I can't answer the question without going here, but I'm cool with going here. Okay.
There were two things as a young man that I thought very, very deeply. I literally wore a hat that said GOP to college. Like the same way I wear a Wyoming hat all the time now, that was my go-to hat. You did?
I did. Matt Whitman wore a hat that said GOP. Yeah, I just, I just was sure that I was sure that that was the right team in all situations as a kid. Depictures, white, absolutes, pictures exist.
I mean, just for reference, I mean, I would never use this. Yes, they do. I would never use this only internet like in mass. Okay.
It's possible. I can't accommodate that. You know what? You'll see underneath that GOP hat?
Long flowing golden hair. So this was a long time ago. So nobody brainwashed me into being a loyalist to one political party. And this is where I want to nuance.
I'm not saying this to pick a fight with people who really do like that political party, whatever. I know there's comfort in latching onto a group that has a set of ideas politically. And sometimes they might have good points and maybe sometimes they don't. It just it doesn't matter.
It's irrelevant. I'm talking about a shift for me. And what to be clear, the reason it's so shocking to me is you pride yourself on not being a team picker. Yep.
And so the thought of you wearing a hat saying, I'm I'm for this side. That's just mind-blowing to me. Well, you get it. But anyway, for me, it's not a rejection of all of my friends who like the grand old party.
It's not a rejection of Republican ideas. I think some of the stuff that they think I suppose. It's a rejection of team picking. It's a rejection of thinking that there is hope and answers in political parties.
And that shift was stunning for me as that started to happen in my 20s. I was sure that hope for humankind would come from my slightly fundamentalist brand of Christianity in a spiritual sense and eternal sense and that hope for the world and getting society straightened out would come through my political party. In both situations, my exclusive team would be what fixed it. And so I used my words and my brain to out argue people, most of whom didn't even want to have an argument, to demonstrate the superiority of my team's ideas.
And I needed that more for me than I did for other people. And so where the change happened was I started to lose confidence in that. And there was a moment and this is what you were asking me for. There was a moment where it occurred to me, I might just be a partisan hack.
And I can tell you exactly when it was. It was when it was when Bill Clinton got impeached. I really wanted that to happen. I really needed that to happen because I thought he was a bad guy and a bad man.
And maybe he's not a big fan of presidents or politicians in general. But I needed the wrong of Bill Clinton being elected to be undone and for my team to win that battle. It came very late in the game and it felt like it would be so satisfying for that to be straightened out. And then it happened and it was the first time the Pandora's box principle had ever occurred to me in my entire life.
And I was like, wait, no, the fact that if they do that, if I do this to their team, when my people aren't in power, they're just going to do it to me. Why wouldn't they do it back? Yeah. And you know what happened two years later?
The hanging Chad election. And I mean, maybe if there's no impeachment, maybe people are more reasonable about that. But instead, to be clear for the younger listeners, so that's when Al Gore and George W. Bush were running for president against each other.
And it came down to Florida. And in that election, there was some question about particular ballots in the state of Florida. And they had this special voting system where you'd punch a hole in paper. And if it didn't punch it all the way through, this Chad is what the word was for the little hole that leaves the paper that was hanging in there.
And so there was some question about those votes and it went all the way to the top. Oh, it went nuts. People were election officials were trying to gauge how seriously people meant to vote for one candidate or another based on how hard the paper looked like it had been punch. It was like a forensic analysis of a handful of ballots in two Broward and Dade County.
Crazy. So the other time in our history where we had a deeply disputed election was 1876 between Hilden, Hilden, Tilden, and Hayes. And what do you know, that's right in proximity with the Civil War, another very divided time. And so for me, I was very troubled when I realized that I had been one of the cheering voices in the gallery to open this Pandora's box.
And as soon as it was open, I wanted it back closed and realized this is bad. This is going to hurt everyone. The hope is not in one of these two teams. The hope is in somehow working beyond these two teams on a certain agreed upon set of principles.
And so for me, I can point right to when I shifted from strongly partisan to kind of rejecting the whole idea of partisanship being the way that we solve things. And can I give you a more trivial, yet equally personal moment for me? That's what we're doing, please. So, you know, I'm all about, I'm all about preserving the earth.
I mean, I don't have a recycling bit at my house because I don't offer that in my county. But if there's an option, I always go out of my way to do it, right? Okay. Another thing I like are straws.
I really, really like straws a lot. Okay. This sounds dumb. This sounds dumb.
There's a role with me here. I'm rolling. I like the straws because I can put my finger over the top of it and pull the liquid up and I can remove my thumb and I can watch the liquid go down and back up and I get to think about the oscillation frequency of the liquid and the momentum. The thing called Bernoulli's equation that I get to do in my head.
I can't do it in my head, but I get to think about it in my head. I heard that one. You already did that? Yeah.
You pulled it's different than what you think. It's the momentum equation, but you kind of let the liquid out of the straw and it goes down into the bottom of your drink. And then it goes beyond the surface of the liquid and then it bounces back up and it oscillates until it dithers out until it's even. Anyway, I took a lot of classes on fluid dynamics and I love playing with straws.
I saw a video on the internet of a sea turtle. Have you seen this video? I've not. They have the sea turtle.
It's some conservation wildlife type folks, wildlife conservationists. I don't know what they call themselves, but they have the sea turtle and they're holding down and like he's hurting. There's something wrong. And then they go up and somebody has a pair of pliers and they reach into his nose and they pull out the straw from the sea turtle's nose.
The whole thing, it comes out lengthwise. You can't see the straw and then the whole thing comes out and this turtle sneezes or something. I forget what it was. And I was like, holy crap.
Why am I using single use plastic? Why am I doing that? Where does it go? And I started thinking about it.
I was like, this is bizarre. Why? Like right now on the desk that I'm at, I have two literal glasses. Those are glass.
Yeah. But down here below, I've got a plastic. Where's that? Yeah.
You got this plastic bottle of water. And this wasn't the first time that it occurred to me that my use of plastic could be harmful. I was in Honduras a long time ago and we were on top of this mountain in this village and they didn't have power or anything. And this guy looks at me and says, hey, you see that kid right there?
He's asking you if you want to go see his water source. I was like, yeah, yeah, I'd love to. And so this kid, we start running through the woods and about like a quarter of a mile later, we're at this spring that's coming out of the side of the mountain. And he has this bottle, this two liter bottle that he's clearly used to get water out of the spring, you know, hundreds of times.
I was like, holy cow, I throw that bottle away every time I use it. And he has used that same bottle hundreds of times. And he's providing water for his family with it. What am I doing?
I don't know. So internally, my mind is shifting on this topic. And I can feel every time I use a single use plastic device, I feel this tension happening. And I don't know why.
I mean, I do know why because it's dumb for me to get a plastic back at the grocery store and ultimately my kids are going to have to deal with that. You know, that's that's the way my brain is shifting that I said it's dumb. And what I'm trying to articulate here is I'm starting to feel like it's dumb. Repugnant cultural other.
Do you have one? Yeah, probably. I don't I mean, you want to not say I want to not say I do. Okay, I get lured into a lot of fights.
People want to I don't know, I will say this. It was very interesting for me. So I've had the opportunity, as you know, to speak to face face with both President Obama and Ivanka Trump. And yeah, I'm a pretty in the middle of the road kind of person.
And the way each of those sides reacted to me doing that, for example, when I spoke to Obama, I got a lot of noise from the right when I spoke to Ivanka Trump, I got a lot of noise from the left. The way that went down was very different. And it was not the same type of conversation in both directions. It was, I don't know, one of them, what do you mean?
Like one of the groups who was saying when one group took their turn being angry at you, it had a different flavor than when the opposite group took their turn being angry? It was personal. Yeah, it was personal. And they they're like, Oh, wow, I didn't want to have to crucify Dustin, but I guess we need to.
Where's the hammer and nails? I was like, Oh my gosh, that's amazing. And so I just kind of took it on the chin and kept going. But it was it was interesting and bizarre.
And so I think in general, the people that I would say are the repugnant cultural others are the ones that just don't have good will towards other people on the internet. I try to think about how I'm serving other people. I try to do that and people that don't do that. And they seem very, very self centered.
And I'm going to yell really loudly at everybody right now. That's I do not like that. What is so tricky is that it feels like that is a valid repugnant cultural other because of how demonstrably damaging that behavior is. But we can't have peace on the internet without those people.
What do you mean? What do you mean? I mean, we need them. I mean, you got to fight with somebody at your job, you got to fight with somebody at your church.
And you want things to be better, you need your enemy. They hold the keys, or at least half of the keys to peace. And so it's become, I think it's very natural for me to want to do the thing where I just wash my hands of people who I think are really mean spirited. But at the same time, how much better would stuff be if if goodwill wins out over me when I'm fussy and difficult on the internet or over those who make a habit of being fussy and difficult on the internet.
So this whole proposition of surviving a world at odds or maybe even helping a world at odds be a little less at odds, it doesn't involve the eradication of the repugnant cultural other. It involves somehow understanding and things getting better between us and our repugnant cultural other. So I'm calling the bullcrap flag on you here because in the book, he talks about the fact that if he said something that people disagreed with and they tried to just freak out on him, he said he admitted to starting a personal Twitter account and having only about 100 people go following him there so that he could interact in a productive way. And so what you're saying, what you're saying and what he's saying is very different.
I think it's not. I think we're talking about two different levels of zoom. I'm not saying don't mute people. I'm saying ultimately, if we want this thing to be better, that huge percentage of people in society who like to push the nuclear option whenever they can and just melt down emotionally over disagreement in front of people, like, yeah, we need that to change.
I mean, you can't kill him and you don't want to, you can't send him away and you shouldn't want to. Like what you want is a better relationship. And so if we want this thing to be better, we have to find a way to break through to each other and to our repugnant cultural others on some level. Now, I think what Jacob's is talking about is not quite so macro as this save the world, make everything better, you know, maybe overly dramatic system that I'm engaging in right now.
I think what he's talking about is himself and surviving in a world of gods. And what he figured out is that that behavior was drawing crap out of him. Remember, he talked about like his hand shaking and being unable to type because he was so angry about what people said over this or that issue on the interweb. Can I say something?
I think what he's talking about is insulating himself. You can say lots of something. So if let's just think about that. He's talking about his hands shaking over the keyboard.
I thought when he said that, it kind of struck home a little bit because he was talking about reading someone else's article and the things they were saying were just angry and evil or whatever. Maybe those aren't his words. I just made something up, but you know what I'm trying to say. Just what you do and what I do, very, very different.
You turn a camera on your face, you record your face saying things with your mouth hole and then you think through things and you try really hard to be graceful and respectful and then you upload those to the internet. And then thousands of people watch that and they scroll down two swipes on their touchpad and they get to the comment section and then they either say, hey, good job or who are the people that are most motivated to leave comments typically? The ones that want to rip you a new one, man. And so not really with your crowd on Timet Bible Hour, people are very graceful there.
But it's a good group. I mean, on Smarter Every Day, dude, I get systematically destroyed often. And so when he was sitting there talking about his hands shivering above the keyboard because he was angry and that's when he starts talking about take the five minutes. Dude, that's my life.
And you almost take the five minutes. You call me sometimes and I am the five minutes. Well, I don't I just don't engage. Sometimes I hurt you not engage.
Sometimes it hurts you to the point where we get on the phone and we game it out. But usually it doesn't. Like what? When does it hurt me that I've gained it out with you?
Okay, I'll throw this out here and we want to redact it later. We can. The one that really stands out to me was someone talking about a personal interaction they had with you where they describe you as just basically being a jerk to him, not like evil to them, just mean and dismissive and you know, oh, never know. It was kind of thing.
And there was no data and it hurt. Yeah, we spent a long time gaming that out. I do remember that because I'm like 99% sure it did not happen. But they threw it out there on the internet for the world to see and I'm like, what the heck?
What do you do? Yeah, I remember that now that you say that. Thank you for bringing it up. And so I mean, I can remember another time where one of my children, they were in public and this person comes up and introduces himself and then one of my kids had this major health issue happen immediately and it had to be addressed immediately.
And you know, the person has their hand out to shake it and I just had to be like, I'm so sorry, I have to be a dad, I have to go now. And I remember that happening. I remember thinking that person probably thinks I'm whatever. But it is important to me that that I'm at peace with everyone.
But yeah, you're right. I remember that. And yeah, that one hurt because I think it was a lie. Yeah, my point is what we're doing is very, very different than what Jacob's doing here, I think, because we very much put ourselves on the internet.
He's done a very good job of isolating himself, which is why he isn't or one of the reasons why he isn't on this program with us right now. You know, I was going to look him up and ask him to just jump on, make a few connections and like the thing that he has up right now is, Hey, if you want me to be on your podcast or your thing, look me back up in 18 more months. My family has asked me to shut it down for a while. So so I never asked out of respect to that request.
But yeah, we're doing slightly different things than him. His is maybe a little more deliberate. It's just a different medium, right? He's maybe not making a video, but he wrote this book we're discussing.
It has a pretty big reach. My point is I know what it's like to feel like you've been personally attacked and just take it. I know that's like, yeah, and people don't people don't think about the asymmetry of the social media world. No, I'm not saying YouTube.
I'm just saying the social media world in general. Like if you can rally a bunch of people around an idea that you don't like, then you I mean, suddenly you can have tens of thousands of voices screaming at an individual that was just going about their life doing something. You know, it's interesting how the gain to use electric circuit terminology, the game can be amplified very, very quickly. I think everybody who does what we do is a little bit concerned that someday those cross-airs are going to be studied on us.
Whether it's justified or not, it's just such a yucky thing to imagine going through. It is. It is. And I try to be squeaky clean in both my personal life and my public life.
Well, and honestly, it's a little easier for you because you're a decent dude. That helps. You don't have to do a lot of faking and a lot of acting. And the times when I see you maybe be a little bit more difficult than others, it's fairly trivial.
Can I ask you an unrelated question from the centro? Do you have a refutation mode? Do you feel like there's a switch in your brain that goes from conversation to refute, like what Jacob's was describing? I don't know that I do.
I maybe have it mentally, but I usually don't outwardly. No, no, this is all wrong. I do. I totally do.
I don't know. It's just not combative, I don't think. I don't know. You've got me thinking.
I'm doing that thing where I caught my head to the side and I'm looking off in the corner of the room. Oh, yeah. I'm not accusing or suggesting you do. I was.
I wanted to ask you a question without any prompting because I really want to know what you think. I try very, very hard to see all sides of the argument. And often when I'm having a discussion with someone, I'm honestly trying to see it from their side. And sometimes I fight with you a lot.
And we kind of do the Kabuki theater thing where we try to get on opposite sides of an argument just to help each other understand the argument. Like the synthesizer versus guitar thing? Oh, dude, the internet did not understand that. So that's what it was, right?
Yeah, it was trying to be engaging with you and debating with you. Well, in the last, okay, in the last episode, I asked you why guitar still existed. I thought it was clear what I was doing, but apparently it wasn't. So I don't know.
I can say it. People won't believe it. What I was trying to do is I was trying to put you in the position because I know you love guitar. I was trying to tell you that all the guitar does is make music that we can replicate with other devices.
But we all know it's more than that. And so what I did is I built up this question in terms of saying why do guitars still exist? I can do all this information with just by understanding engineering and science. I can plug a string and all this stuff.
So why does a physical half to still exist? And what I was trying to do, poorly, I assume, is get you to describe those things about a guitar that you can't see and you can't feel. But you know, it's the art and it's the human element and all that stuff. So by putting you in the position where you had to defend that, it would help you articulate the argument better.
And it would ultimately help us all get to the heart of why guitars are important. What the internet heard is Desens, a robot engineer who hates music. Would you agree with that? And then we went on to talk about a bunch of different music that you like with banjo, Appalachian stings in between.
Did you read the comments though? Oh yeah, I read it and everything. Well, I mean, for crying out loud, there was a possum loose in your house and the subreddit was dominated by the guitar conversation. It's got to be something really salacious to not talk about that possum.
So I think that's a humeroid. Did you see the church choir lady that said she got so mad she had to walk away from the podcast? Did you see that one? Yeah, I don't remember her name.
I interact with her a lot on Twitter. And she's a really nice, really nice level headed lady who says smart things on Twitter. So I was like, Whoa, I've never seen that side from her. I think, I think you push by your sandlin.
That's when you picked up the phone and you're like, we got to fix this. The thing about it is, okay, you didn't brief me. You said I'm going to hit you with something cold as part of this episode and everything else we briefed each other on before we had a purpose. That was the only thing I didn't prepare you on.
And you understand why I didn't prepare you on that, right? Well, and I maybe you got the reaction you wanted. Maybe you didn't. But I didn't know.
I didn't know what you were doing. I caught on about halfway through. And I know your dance steps really well in terms of the way we jab each other and rib at each other. And so you threw that out and I listened and I internalized and I was like, what the heck?
You know, dang, what? You know, dang, well, what is this? And then I went, this is where it all ties back. I flipped into reputation mode.
And I know that tone. And there's like this same level headed, let me flesh out this argument tone that I take that I think is effective. I think it's decent. It could improve, but it's decent.
And then there's this other one that I get into where I'm a little tiny bit miffed and I'm not joking. And so that clumsy apology that you got at the end of all of that discussion about guitar in the last episode was not that I was upset for disagreeing with you. I wasn't upset at all. What I was disappointed in myself for was how quickly I hit the reputation mode switch.