This message comes from Viking, committed to exploring the world in comfort. Journey to the heart of Europe on an elegant Viking longship with thoughtful service, destination-focused dining, and cultural enrichment on board and on shore. And every Viking voyage is all-inclusive with no children and no casinos. Discover more at viking.com.
Looking for something meaningful to listen to? Visit podcastlibrary.org. A growing home for timeless audiobooks, classic radio dramas, educational talks, history, philosophy, and thousands of hours of spoken word audio, all free to stream. Whether you want to relax, learn something new, or rediscover voices from the past, podcast library makes it easy to find something worth hearing.
Start listening today at p-o-d-c-a-s-t-l-i-b-r-a-r-y.org. Looking for something meaningful to listen to? Visit podcastlibrary.org, a growing home for timeless audiobooks, classic radio dramas, educational talks, history, philosophy, and thousands of hours of spoken word audio, all free to stream. Whether you want to relax, learn something new, or rediscover voices from the past, podcast library makes it easy to find something worth hearing.
Start listening today at p-o-d-c-a-s-t-l-i-b-r-a-r-y.org. All that you have said may be true, say some. Anarchy may be a perfect form of social life, but we have no desire to take a leap in the dark. Therefore, tell us how your society will be organized.
Then follows a long string of questions which would be very interesting if it were our business to study the problems that might arise in emancipated society, but of which it is useless and absurd to imagine that we could now offer a definite solution. According to what method will children be taught? How will production and distribution be organized? Will there still be large cities, or will people spread equally over all the surface of the earth?
Will all the inhabitants of Siberia winter at Nice? Will everyone dine on partridges and drink champagne? Who will be the miners and sailors? Who will clear the drains?
Will the sick be nursed at home or in hospitals? Who will arrange the railway timetable? What will happen if the engine driver falls ill while the train is on its way? And so on without end, as the wicked prophecy all the knowledge and experience of the future time are could, in the name of anarchy, prescribe for the coming man what time he should go to bed and what days he should cut his nails.
Indeed, if our readers expect from us an answer to these questions, or even to those among them really serious and important, which cannot be anything more than our own private opinion at this present hour, we must have succeeded badly in our endeavor to explain what anarchy is. We are no more prophets than other men, and should we pretend to give an official solution to all the problems that will arise in the life of the future society, we should have indeed a curious idea of the abolition of government. We should then be describing a government dictating like the clergy a universal code for the present and all future time. Seeing that we have neither police nor prisons to enforce our doctrine, humanity might laugh with impunity at us and our pretensions.
Nevertheless, we consider seriously all the problems of social life which now suggest themselves on account of their scientific interest, and because, hoping to see anarchy realized, we wish to help towards the organization of a new society, we have therefore our own ideas on these subjects, ideas which are to our minds likely to be permanent or transitory, according to the respective cases. And if space permit, we might add somewhat more on these points. But the fact that we today think in a certain way on a given question is no proof that such will be the mode of procedure in the future. Who can foresee the activities which may develop in humanity when it is emancipated from misery and oppression, when all have the means of instruction and self-development, when the strife between men with the hatred and rancor it breeds will be no longer a necessary condition of existence?
Who can foresee the progress of science, the new sources of production, means of communication, etc.? The one essential is that a society be constituted in which the exploitation and domination of man by man are impossible. That the society, in other words, be such that the means of existence and development of labor be free and open to everyone, and all be able to cooperate according to their wishes and their knowledge in the organization of social life. Under such conditions, everything will necessarily be performed in compliance with the needs of all, according to the knowledge and possibilities of the moment, and everything will improve with the increase of knowledge and power.
In fact, a program which would touch the basis of a new social constitution could not do more, after all, than indicate a method. And method, more than anything else, defines parties and determines their importance in history. Method apart, everyone says he wishes for the good of mankind, and many do truly wish for it. As parties disappear, every organized action directed to a definite end disappears likewise.
It is therefore necessary to consider anarchy as, above all, a method. There are two methods by which the different parties, not anarchistic, expect, or say they expect, to bring about the greatest good of each and all. These are the authoritarian or state socialist and the individualist methods. The former entrusts the direction of social life to a few, and it would result in the exploitation and oppression of the masses by that few.
The second party trusts to the free initiative of individuals, and proclaims, if not the abolition, the reduction of government. However, as it respects private property, and is founded on the principle of each for himself, and therefore on competition, its liberty is only the liberty of the strong, the license of those who have, to oppress and exploit the weak who have nothing. Far from producing harmony, it would tend always to augment the distance between the rich and the poor, and end also through exploitation and domination in authority. This second method, individualism, is in theory a kind of anarchy without socialism.
It is therefore no better than a lie, because liberty is not possible without equality, and true anarchy cannot be without solidarity, without socialism. The criticism which individualists pass on government is merely the wish to deprive of certain functions, to virtually hand them over to the capitalist. But it cannot attack those repressive functions which form the essence of government, for without an armed force the proprietary system could not be upheld. Nay, even more, under individualism, the repressive power of government must always increase, in proportion to the increase, by means of free competition, of the want of equality and harmony.
Anarchists present a new method, the free initiative of all and free agreement. Then, after the revolutionary abolition of private property, everyone will have equal power to dispose of social wealth. This method, not admitting the re-establishment of private property, must lead, by means of free association, to the complete triumph of the principles of solidarity. Thus we see that all the problems put forward to combat the anarchistic idea are, on the contrary, arguments in favour of anarchy.
Because it alone indicates the way in which, by experience, those solutions which correspond to the dicta of science, and to the needs and wishes of all, can best be found. How will children be educated? We do not know. What then?
The parents, teachers, and all who are interested in the progress of the rising generation will meet, discuss, agree, and differ, and then divide according to their various opinions, putting into practice the methods which they respectively hold to be best. That method which, when tried, produces the best results, will triumph in the end. And so for all the problems that may arise. According to what we have so far said, it is evident that anarchy, as the anarchists conceive it, and as alone it can be comprehended, is based on socialism.
Furthermore, were it not for that school of socialists who artificially divide the natural unity of the social question, considering only some detached points, and were it not also for the equivocations with which they strive to hinder the social revolution, we might say right away that anarchy is synonymous with socialism, because both signify the abolition of exploitation and of the domination of man over man, whether maintained by the force of arms or by the monopolization of the means of life. Anarchy, like socialism, has for its basis and necessary point of departure equality of conditions. Its aim is solidarity, and its method liberty. It is not perfection, nor is it the absolute ideal, which, like the horizon, always recedes as we advance towards it.
But it is the open road to all progress and to all improvement, made in the interest of all humanity. There are authoritarians who grant that anarchy is the mode of social life which alone opens the way to the attainment of the highest possible good for mankind, because it alone can put an end to every class interested in keeping the masses oppressed and miserable. They also grant that anarchy is possible, because it does nothing more than release humanity from obstacle, government, against which it has always had to fight its painful way to its progress. Nevertheless, these authoritarians, reinforced by many warm lovers of liberty and justice in theory, retire until our last entrenchments, because they are afraid of liberty, and cannot be persuaded that mankind could live and prosper without teachers and pastors.
Still, hard-pressed by the truth, they pitifully demand to have the reign of liberty put off for a while, indeed for as long as possible. Such is the substance of the arguments that meet us at this stage. A society without a government which would act by free, voluntary cooperation, trusting entirely the spontaneous action of those interested, and founded altogether on solidarity and sympathy, is certainly, they say, a very beautiful ideal, but, like all ideals, it is a castle in the air. We find ourselves placed in a human society which has always been divided into oppressors and oppressed, and if the former are full of the spirit of domination, and have all the vices of tyrants, the latter are corrupted by servility, and have those still worse vices which are the result of enslavement.
The sentiment of solidarity is far from being dominant in man at the present day, and if it is true that different classes of men are becoming more and more unanimous among themselves, it is nonetheless true that that which is most conspicuous and impresses itself most on human character today is the struggle for existence. It is a fact that each fights daily against everyone else, and competition presses upon all, workmen and masters, causing every man to become a wolf towards every other man. How can these men, educated in a society based upon antagonism between individuals as well as classes, be transformed in a moment, and become capable of living in a society in which each shall do as he likes, and as he should, without external coercion, caring for the good of others, simply by the impulse of their own nature? And with what heart, or what common sense, can you trust to a revolution on the part of an ignorant, turbulent mass, weakened by misery, stupefied by priestcraft, who are today blithely centenary, and tomorrow will let themselves be humbucked by any knave who dares to call themselves their master?
Would it not be more prudent to advance gradually towards the anarchistic ideal, passing through republican, democratic, and socialistic stages? Will not an educative government, composed of the best man, be necessary to prepare the advancing generations for their future destiny? These objections also ought not to appear valid, if we have succeeded in making our readers understand what we have already said, and in convincing them of it. But, in any case, even at the risk of repetition, it may be as well to answer them.
We find ourselves continually met by the false notion that government is in itself a new force, sprung up one knows not whence, which of itself adds something to the sum of the force and capability of the... Hey Ontario, come on down to Bed-MGM Casino and check out our newest exclusive, The Price is Right Fortune Pick. Don't miss out. Play exciting casino games based on the iconic game show.
Only at Bed-MGM. Access to The Price is Right Fortune Pick is only available at Bed-MGM Casino. Bed-MGM and game sets remind you to play responsibly. 19 plus a major Ontario only.
Please play responsibly. If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you, please contact CONNECTS-ONTARIO at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge. Bed-MGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with I-Gaming Ontario. ...of those whom it is composed of, and of those who obey it.
While on the contrary, all that is done is done by individual men. The government, as a government, adds nothing save the tendency to monopolize for the advantage of certain parties or classes, and to repress all initiative from beyond its own circle. To abolish authority or government does not mean to destroy the individual or collective forces which are at work in society, nor the influence men exert over one another. That would be to reduce humanity to an aggregate of inert and separate atoms, an impossibility which, if it could be performed, would be the destruction of any society, the death blow to mankind.
To abolish authority means to abolish the monopoly of force and of influence. It means to abolish that state of things by which social force, that is, the collective force of all in a society, is made the instrument of the thought, will, and interests of a small number of individuals. These, by means of the collective force, suppress the liberty of everyone else to the advantage of their own ideas. In other words, it means to destroy a mode of organization by means of which the future is exploited, between one revolution and another, to the profit of those who have been the victors of the moment.
Michal Bakunin, in an article published in 1872, asserts that the great means of action of the international, with the propagating of their ideas, and the organization of the spontaneous action of its members in regard to the masses. He then adds, quote, To whoever might pretend that action so organized would be an outrage on the liberty of the masses, or an attempt to create a new authoritative power, we would reply that he is a sophist and a fool. So much the worse for those who ignore the natural social law of human solidarity, to the extent of imagining that an absolute mutual independence of individuals and of masses is a possible or even desirable thing. To desire it would be to wish for the destruction of society, for all social life is nothing else than this mutual and incessant interdependence among individuals and masses.
All individuals, even the most gifted and strongest, indeed, most of all the most gifted and strongest, are at every moment of their lives, at the same time, producers and products. Equal liberty for every individual is only the resultant, continually reproduced, of this mass of material, intellectual and moral influence exercised on him by all the individuals around him, belonging to the society in which he was born, has developed and dies. To wish to escape this influence in the name of a transcendental liberty, divine, absolutely egoistic and sufficient to itself, is a tendency to annihilation. To refrain from influencing others would mean to refrain from all social action, indeed, to abstain from all expression of one's thoughts and sentiments, and simply to become non-existent.
This independence, so much extolled by idealists and metaphysicians, individual liberty conceived in this sense, would amount to self-annihilation. In nature, as in human society, which is also a part of this same nature, all that exists lives only by complying with the supreme conditions of interaction, which is more or less positive and potent with regard to the lives of other beings, according to the nature of the individual. And when we vindicate the liberty of the masses, we do not pretend to abolish anything of the natural influences that individuals or groups of individuals exert upon one another. What we wish for is the abolition of artificial influences, which are privileged, legal and official.
End quote. Certainly, in the present state of mankind, oppressed by misery, stupefied by superstition, and sunk in degradation, the human lot depends upon a relatively small number of individuals. Of course, all men will not be able to rise in a moment to the height of perceiving their duty, or even the enjoyment of so regulating their own action, that others also will derive the greatest possible benefit from it. But because nowadays the thoughtful and guiding forces at work in society are few, that is no reason for paralyzing them still more, and for the subjection of many individuals to the direction of a few.
It is no reason for constituting society in such a manner that the most active forces, the highest capacities, are in the end found outside the government, and almost deprived of influence on social life. All this now happens owing to the inertia that secured positions foster, to heredity, to protectionism, to party spirit, and all the mechanisms of government. For those in government office taken out of their former social position, primarily concerned in retaining power, lose all power to act spontaneously, and become only an obstacle to the free action of others. With the abolition of this negative potency constituting government, society will become that which it can be, with the given forces and capabilities at the moment.
If there are educated men desires of spreading education, they will not be able to do it. they will organize the schools and will be constrained to make the use and enjoyment to be derived from education felt and if there are no such man or only a few of them a government cannot create them all it can do as in fact it does nowadays is to take these few away from practical fruitful work in the sphere of education and put them to direct from above what has to be imposed by the help of a police system so they make out of intelligent and passionate teachers mere politicians who become useless parasites entirely absorbed in imposing their own hobbies and in maintaining themselves in power if there are doctors and teachers of hygiene they will organize themselves for the service of health and if there are none a government cannot create them all that can do is to discredit them in the eyes of the people who are inclined to entertain suspicions sometimes only too well founded with regard to everything which is imposed upon them if there are engineers and mechanics they will organize the railways etc and if there are none a government cannot create them the revolution by abolishing government and private property will not create force which does not exist but it will leave a free field for the exercise of all available force and of all existent capacity while it will destroy every class interested in keeping the masses degraded it will act in such a way that everyone will be free to work and make his influence felt in proportion to his own capacity and conformity with his sentiments and interests and it is only thus that the elevation of the masses is possible for it is only with liberty that one can learn to be free as it is only by working that one can learn to work the government even had no other advantages must always have that of habituating the governed to subjection and must also tend to become more oppressive and more necessary in proportion as its subjects are more obedient and docile let's suppose government with a direction of affairs by the best people who are the best and how shall we recognize their superiority the majority are generally attached to all prejudices and have ideas and instincts already outgrown by the more favored minority but of the various minorities who all believe themselves in the right as no doubt many of them are in part which shall be chosen to rule and by whom and by what criterion seeing that the future alone can prove which among them is the most superior if you choose a hundred partisans of dictatorship you'll discover that each one of the hundred believes himself capable of being if not sole dictator at least of assisting very materially in the dictatorial government the dictators will be those who by one means or another succeeded in imposing themselves on society and in course of time all their energy would inevitably be employed in defending themselves against the attacks of their adversaries totally oblivious of their desire if ever they had had it to be merely an educated power should government be on the other hand elected by universal suffrage and so be the emanation more or less sincere of the wish of the majority but if you consider these worthy electors as incapable of providing for their own interests how can they ever be capable of themselves choosing their actors to guide them wisely how solve this problem of social alchemy to elect a government of geniuses by the votes of a mass of fools and what will be the lot of the minority who are the most intelligent most active and most advanced in society to solve the social problem to the advantage of all there is only one way to expel the government by revolutionary means to expropriate the holders of social wealth putting everything at the disposition of all and to leave all existing force capacity and goodwill among men free to provide for the needs of all we fight for anarchy and for socialism because we believe that anarchy and socialism ought to be brought into operation as soon as possible which means that the revolution must drive away the government abolish private property and entrust all public service which will then embrace all social life to the spontaneous free unofficial and unauthorized operation of all those interested at all those willing volunteers there will certainly be difficulties and inconveniences but the people will be resolute and they alone can solve all difficulties anarchically that is by direct action of those interested and by free agreement we cannot say whether anarchy and socialism will triumph after the next revolutionary attempt but this is certain that if any of the so-called transition programs triumph it will be because we've been temporarily beaten and never because we have thought it wise to leave in existence any one part of that evil system under which humanity groans whatever happens we shall have some influence on events by our numbers our energy our intelligence and our steadfastness also even if we are now conquered our work will not have been in vain for the more decided we shall have been in aiming at the realization of all our demands the less there will be of government and of private property in a new society and we shall have done a great work for human progress is measured by the degree in which government and private property are administered if today we fall without lowering our colors our cause is certain of victory tomorrow end of section five end of anarchy by ericomala testa