Skip to content
055 - Internet Manipulation and Countermeasures episode artwork

Mar 17, 2019 1 hr 28 min

055 - Internet Manipulation and Countermeasures

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: HELLOFRESH For $80 off your first month of HelloFresh, go to https://HelloFresh.com/ndq80 and enter ndq80. Discuss this episode here STUFF IN THIS EPISODE: Tarzan - You'll Be In My Heart by Phil Collins Spiderman - "Go Get 'em, Tiger" Alita Battle Angel Trailer Man in the High Castle Trailer Smarter Every Day - The Future of War, and How it Affects YOU (Multi-Domain Operations) Physics Girl - Dianna Cowern RIMPAC Ken Burns Effect Wochit.com Exclusive poll: Americans want economic reform in 2020 Fait Accompli Americans' Trust in Government to Handle Problems at New Low 1984 by George Orwell Resistance by Muse Panopticon Jeremy Bentham John Stuart Mill Jeremy Bentham's skeleton on display CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

055 - Internet Manipulation and Countermeasures

0:00 1:28:37
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I just cried in another movie, dude. What movie? Before I tell you, I know how this goes, but I want you to hear me out because I think it's a good reason to cry in a movie. It was the first five minutes of Disney's Tarzan just now before I came out here.

Hang it. Okay. No, just get out of your system. Are you?

All right. The first five minutes. It's powerful. Did you watch the first five minutes of up?

Sometimes the first five minutes will do things to a person. No, but I'm just sitting here thinking about like a meeting room and they're like, okay, Bob, what do we do? We got to grab them really fast, right? So you're going to have these guys in here and it's for the kids, right?

But there's going to be these old guys that bring their kids in. We got to figure out how to just like punch them right in the gut. Is it a good meeting? Yeah.

What did they do to you? What did this room full of emotional terrorists do to you? Oh my goodness. Well, these geniuses in the first five minutes of Disney's Tarzan, have you seen this movie?

No. Well, in the first five minutes, they get the main character to where they need to be in order to be in a Disney movie, which is the parents need to be dead. Right. So they accomplish this in a Greek leopard attack.

So these poor people survive this horrible 19th century shipwreck, presumably off the coast of Africa. And then they come to shore and everything's okay because they saved their baby. And dudes beard is immaculate and they make this amazing Swiss family Robinson style treehouse. And looks like everything's going to be good and then a leopard just comes in and kills him.

Yeah. All while Phil Collins is singing with his dreamy ethereal voice. You know what else happened? What?

Some poor mom gorilla has her little baby gorilla fall behind the caravan a little bit. And the same stupid leopard eats her baby gorilla right in front of her face. Oh, so the leopard kills both the moma gorilla and the parents? No.

The leopard kills the baby gorilla in front of moma gorilla's face. Yeah. And then as if that wasn't enough, the leopard client lines up into the treehouse and murders the mom and dad who survived the shipwreck, but doesn't notice there was a baby in there. Oh, so the parallel is people are just like a realist.

I don't know if there's any point. Well, actually, I think maybe I sort of do know the point they were going for with literature at that point. But this is not what we're talking about. None of that made me cry.

You know what made me cry? False. Phil Collins is singing along and everything. And it's all about like strength of heart and not giving up.

And the dad is like trying to provide for his family. And so he's taking the mast from the shipwreck ship and he's got it on his shoulders. He's trying to hoist it up by himself, but he can't quite provide for his family by himself. Because it's the mast of a ship.

Yeah, because he is wife runs over and puts her shoulders into it with him. And they make this moment of eye contact like we got this together and they lift it and I teared up. Why are you laughing? I really thought that I really thought you'd apologize at that point.

You know what? No, I just think it's funny that you cry when females do things that are powerful. I just think that's funny. That's what it is, man.

I don't know. I like girls. I like it when they do cool stuff and I like my wife and I like my daughters. And because I've got these three women in my life will two or still little girls.

I just get real squishy in my heart about it. You want to know something else maybe crying a movie? What's that? Too bad.

I'm telling you. I'm talking about the movie Maguire Spider-Man when finally Kirsten Dunce and Toby Maguire have a minute to themselves and their sirens or something. He looks out the window like I'm supposed to go and do brave things and she's like go get them, Tiger. Yeah.

That was awesome. And that's what I'm married to. It made me feel things inside but you keep laughing at me. No, I'm not laughing at you.

Yeah, I totally laughing at you. I'm totally laughing at you. Yeah, because I hear it because of how we're on the phone together. No, the funny part is that you have a weakness.

That's the funny part. Why is that funny? Why is that funny? It's funny.

It's good to have that, right? Yeah, it's definitely good. It is crazy though. I know we've made a joke out of it these last few years like the little girls running and doing brave stuff but it is every stinking time.

We went and saw Alita, Battle Angel and Puerto Rico which was not special at all but it's a girl cyborg and she fights bravely against things that are bigger. Yeah, it can be the crappiest movie in the world and I'm still just like go get them girl. Nice job. I feel things.

I don't consume as much media as you do. I think that's what it is. It's very difficult for me to get lost in a movie. When's the last time it happened?

Um, I'm trying to think. Wow. Yeah, I don't know when the last time I sat down and watched a thing on, you know, I'm watching the man in the high castle with Tara. We watch like one every week maybe like one episode of weeks.

That's incredible restraint. There's just a lot going on. Thing is though for me and what I do, story and writing and structure and character kind of is my job too. It makes me better at what I do.

I don't know. You're not sure you believe me. No, no, I believe that that's true for you. I'm just trying to think about how I create stories and things of that nature.

I guess if you think about what I'm doing lately, it's more nonfiction and you're doing nonfiction as well but I think allegory and metaphor is more important in your work. I think so because I deal in abstraction. Like this last video you did, that was pretty tangible. Uh, yeah.

You blew crap up. Well, I didn't. I just monitored the crap that was blowing up and you opened the video with four straight clips of you shooting things or blowing things up and it was awesome. Yeah.

Okay. Yeah, I did blow stuff up. So there we go. For the third chair.

So I made a video with a four star general about the future of warfare. It's all this four star general's idea, general Brown, US Army Pacific. So the way it went down is as we may have mentioned before, he contacted me and he was like, Hey, would you like to record your last mission and then interview me and then we'll have a discussion about the future of what's called multi-domain operations and then you can put it on your little YouTubes there, you know? That's adorable.

Yeah. He didn't say that but that's the, you know, I'm doing the hand waving this, you know, that's kind of the impression. He's like, I know four star general, he worries about bigger things. Exactly.

And he's like, I know you do the internet stuff. Why don't you just, I'll give you some information and you can put it out there so people can consume it. I'm like, yeah, sure. And I interviewed the guy and it's just fascinating.

Like, I feel like I've been a pawn on a 3D chessboard for 15 years and I don't really understand my role. You know, to me it's a really big deal. I understand we have to know exactly what the bad guy's doing right here and blah, blah, but he is the mastermind or one of the masterminds behind the bigger picture. Diana Cowar and she's physics girl online.

She was explaining to me the concept of 4D chess and the way 4D chess is played to hear her describe it is there's several 3D chessboards. You've seen like the multi-layered chessboards like a wedding kit kind of thing. Sure. So imagine three of those side by side.

And so you're playing 3D chess on one of the boards but you can make the move across any of the chessboards that are side by side. So they call that 4D chess. So Brown's role is to play one of the 3D chessboards and then he reports back to an overall commander that ties in all these different theaters of operations. So he is controlling a very complicated sphere of influence but that ties into a bigger picture as well.

I'm a little bit of you pawn somewhere on the board. And so just to be able to have the opportunity to sit down with a person that strategizes at that level and have a conversation and furthermore realize that the conversation itself is part of the strategy like that was fascinating. And so I made up my mind once I understood what was going on. I was like, you know, I'm just going to ask him because I spoke to this guy, Lieutenant Colonel Davis at the Eastern Master Warfare group at Trade-Off training doctrine command and he explained multi-domain operations to me.

And he explained that the way multi-domain operations work in the future of war is you have several domains of military operation. And that's land, sea, air, space, and cyber. And so he also argued that there may be a kind of funny because cyber sort of is heart. It is.

But he said there is the sixth domain potentially that's the human domain, which is basically what people are thinking and feeling. Okay, that's heart. And so I realized pretty quick, I'm about to go talk to Brown. He wants me to make this video so that it's out there on the internet.

Like he's trying to put a message out there in the cyber domain to potentially affect things that happen and see and land and things of that nature. I was like, holy crap, this video is a weapon. And so I made my mind out that I was going to ask him. And to my surprise, when I said, is this video a weapon, I hit him with it cold, I was expecting to knock him off his feet, right?

And he said, absolutely. And I was like, it was a really reasonable expectation that you would knock a four star general office fee and then he'd run out of the room crying like the atheist professor and all those Christian email. No, the jock didn't break. Yeah, I get it.

So no, he was made of sternr stuff, huh? It was impressive. Like he just owned it. He's like, absolutely.

This is a cyber weapon. And I hope it works. I hope it's a countermeasure to anybody that thinks they can blah, blah, blah. And I was like, whoa.

So the difference in the cyber operations that's happening from all these rogue nations that are funding this stuff is that general Brown's doing it in the open. He's just walking out onto the battlefield and the cyber domain and he's like, Hey, all of you. I'm calling you out. It's been a few episodes since this topic came up and I know you've been working on this for whatever what months.

Forever. Yeah. And you did a like a 30 tweet Twitter thread. And I don't know, last month, month before, whatever.

And it, I guess if a tweet can go viral, that's kind of what it did. What's been the response for people? What is come out of this? Are people getting what you're saying?

Here's the upshot. So after I went out and did impact, which was the rem of the Pacific exercise in the Pacific. And for the third chair, essentially, I was filming missiles striking a ship and torpedoes striking a ship in the Pacific Ocean that were being fired from shore. A Norwegian missile was used and also the Japanese fired a ship, a surface to ship missile.

And so my job was to film that to understand warhead effects on target. So engagement position, things of that nature, other things I wanted to know that I helped them get. I think General Brown's idea was to put it out there so everybody could see it. Now thinking about all that and then learning about multi-domain operations in this cyber warfare component, I didn't really understand what he was saying at the time to be completely honest.

I come back home and I'm working on the video and I'm having to get like the, all the military footage I used had to be approved. So I'm waiting on all that junk and I'm trying to formulate my message and all that. So in the beginning of February, I see this video in my YouTube subscription feed or my suggested videos or however it works. And it says something about Trump and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

Oh, yeah. And I look at it and I was like, oh, wow, that's, I'm not a Republican. I'm not a Democrat. I'm just right down the middle right now at this point in my life.

So this seems like an important political moment though. And, and I look down and it's got like 135,000 views and it was uploaded yesterday. I was like, whoa, that looks like real news. Like that looks important.

So open it up. And I can't you not, is a robotic voice? Someone had programmed a robot to read a script and they had automatically put video over the top of this script and it was upvoted like thousands of times and there were hundreds of comments on this thing. And all the comments were like extremely political.

And I'm aware of the other. And a little bit incoherent. Yeah. Exactly.

I mean, I have not seen the video. I haven't seen the comments, but I know the kind you're talking about. Yeah. And they're all like, oh, you know, RBG is dead.

They're just propping her up and whatever. All this weird stuff. I'm sitting there trying to digest it. And I was like, this isn't real.

Like none of this is real. But it's sitting here on YouTube and it's got 135,000 views, which is an incredible amount of views. For example, your Greek Orthodox video, it's done. It's done that, right?

It's doing great. Yeah, it's done that. That's a big deal, right? That's a big deal for me.

And you've worked for years and years and years as a human, like intentionally creating content, right? Engaging with people, trying very hard. This just seemingly happened overnight out of nowhere. And so I was like, okay, something's up.

I understand YouTube. I understand countermeasures in the military sense. I'm going to start looking at this. I'm going to start figuring this out because General Brown told me about multi-domain operations.

He told me about the cyber warfare. I'm not an idiot. And I know just enough about all these things to try to piece a story together here. But I just spent an afternoon researching this thing.

So your first clues are that's a lot of views in a hurry for something of incredibly low quality. Yes. I mean, obviously this is one of those ridiculous, awful robot voice things. And the comments seem super inflammatory and grammatically problematic.

And the thumbs up to thumbs down ratio on this video was super high positive, super high on an obviously awful video. Yes. I was like, there is no human that would click thumbs up on this, like knowingly. Right.

Did the video provide any value to you as a viewer whatsoever? No, it did not. Okay. So I'm like, um, you know what?

I can just get the voice here. Let me just drop in a little bit of this here. So this is how the video starts. It has like this fake newsy look to it.

And you know, it's got like a globe spinning and all this like, you know, all this music like you would see on the old breaking news things. Yeah. Like you paid 50 bucks on pond five for some stock footage of news. Yeah.

And then it rolls in with this audio. Listen to this. This is awful animation. You see how bad that is?

It's terrible. It's slow. Why would anyone even keep watching at this point? Listen to the voice.

I'm not even to the voice yet. Oh. Okay. After Trump sends message to RBG, he breaks silence on big plans for Supreme Court.

President Donald Trump spoke about Supreme Court, Justice Ruth Batter Ginsburg's, ailing how throwers gave and reveals his terror. This is terrible. This is terrible. During an interview with the Daily Caller.

Oh, this is clumsy. Yeah. So, all right. I'm uncomfortable watching it.

After I identified this behavior, they YouTube started shutting it down because I made it popular in this Twitter thread, but I was able to save a couple of them beforehand because I knew it was going to be weird. So those things had hundreds of thousands of views. It had a huge like to dislike ratio. So where did your brain go?

Obviously this is in all things. Obvious fraud. Yeah. But how do you amass hundreds of thousands of views?

And so I was like, what up? So I wrote a script out. I listened to the words that they were saying and I typed all of them out in a notepad file. Yeah, I called you when you were in the middle of that.

It's about the hardest you've gone. Can't talk brain engaged by in a really long time. I did do that. I'm sorry.

It was like it was full Heisman stiff arm. It was worth it though. Genius at work. Excuse me, please.

This episode of Notum Questions is sponsored by HelloFresh, a meal kit delivery service that brings food to your house. It's like mailing you tasty yummies. Do you get tasty yummies mailed to your house, Matt? Yes, you know dang well that I do and you know dang well that I like it.

I know dang well. I've gushed about this before, but I'm a sucker for good branding and clear, simple communication. I'm one of those guys unpacking Walmart furniture and I opened it up as a bookshelf and I was like, oh no, six pages of instructions with drawings. I don't know if I can, and I can always figure it out.

But HelloFresh, I open the package. I take out the card and I immediately feel like I can do this. Exactly what to do. So well presented.

Oh yeah. They have to have some type of psychological people and staff that help make these, and graphic designers that make these recipe cards because they're amazing. To me they're like how I felt about getting baseball cards that I prized when I was a kid. I love my HelloFresh recipe collection.

It's like a wall of fame of all of the stuff that I learned how to cook it. Right there at the front is Steak and SaaS. That's where like your Wade Boggs, no, no, you weren't Wade Boggs, you were George Braggs. Thank you.

You know what? We're good friends. Thank you for saying that. Thank you for listening.

Cal Ripken Jr. So yeah, I'm panicking too. Yeah, I'd frame that and get it signed. Like if Steak and SaaS was doing an event, like at a local mall or something, I would definitely go over and have Steak and SaaS just dribble a signature all over my card.

Absolutely. Alright, so let's tell people what they can do. So the point is YouTube can have HelloFresh. You can go to hellofresh.com slash ndq80 and enter the promo code NDQ80 at checkout.

That gets you $80 off your first month. And that is like $20 off the first four boxes. So it's like getting eight meals for free and you get to go to the website and pick out what kind of meal you want. It's kind of a thing.

We go through and we look at all the meals together every once in a while and we'll pick them. The grocery store overwhelms me. Yeah. I go, I love my wife, I want to be supportive and helpful, but it's kind of like how I feel about the instructions for the bookcase, just a little too much.

I can't picture everything I'm gonna need or how it's all gonna go together, but I like the idea of going on the internet and looking at beautiful pictures of food that I want to eat, I mean, I want that. I want that, I don't know how to get it or what, but I want it in my face. So just send that to me and then I'm going to make it and eat it. And so it's like cool, complicated, good food is now possible for me and I get to participate.

I would kind of disagree with the complicated part. It is complicated in that when you get done, you're like, I have no right to make something that's awesome because I just made a sauce and I'm not far enough to do that, but it's not complicated to actually do it. No, by complicated, I mean the taste. Oh, okay.

You know how fancy like Somali wine people, I was like, move, I don't know what they're talking about, it just tastes like wine to me, but the food, I get it. I understand with the first bite, this is different than like there are more flavors happening here than what I would do left to my own ends. And I like that I'm trying to sort through all of the things that make it delicious. No, it's ridiculously easy, which is my point about the instructions, to get something that is so complex, that's the term complex.

Complex, yeah. In taste without being complicated, that's kind of the sweet spot. That sounded good. Complex and taste.

Yeah, you should tell them that. Okay, so here, let me just do the promo code one more time just so people get it. So $80 off your first month by going to hellofresh.com slash indiku80 and enter indiku80 at checkout. Again, that's like getting eight meals for free, that's 20 bucks off your first four boxes.

You're gonna dig it. Absolutely. Thanks again to hellofresh for being a part of Notum Questions and thanks again to hellofresh for being a part of Dinner at the Whitman household. And the Sanlon household as well, rock and roll.

I think it was important. I think it's gonna be very important. It was important. And so I typed all that stuff out and then I went to Google and I would enter different sections of the text.

And so there's this thing on a YouTube video where they have an automated captions service and those captions are inserted in the metadata for each YouTube video. Okay. And so you can search for words on Google and that will roll it into the YouTube search. Am I making any sense?

I'm not using the words correctly. I'm gonna go with Yesish. So if I search for words that are typed in a script, it will search the automated caption files for each YouTube video. Right, yeah, I'm tracking.

Okay, so I just did that. I found dozens of videos of this exact script, which if you think about it, the script is the hard part to write. Dozens of videos of this exact script, but the things were different in the video. For example, the automated voice was different.

Really? The images on the screen were different. What's it called? The Carl Burns effect?

Is that what that's called? Ken Burns. Ken Burns, the Ken Burns effect was used, but it was used from different starting point keyframes. So you're keyframing from a different anchor point?

Exactly. So all these things were happening. And the reason they did that is because the way the YouTube content ID algorithm works is you hash an image. So every frame on a video is hashed.

They take all the pixels and they add them up and they come up with a number. And that number is how they compare content ID. It's a really complicated thing, but if you change the footage enough, you can get around the hash function, content ID system on YouTube. So it's counter-mesh.

That's why a lot of videos you see where people are scamming someone else's content. They'll goof with the aspect ratio, they'll stretch the image, they'll crop it awkwardly, goofy stuff like that. Like any of the channels that just harvests stuff from cable news and it's show cable news segments, they all use that trick. And if you think about it, that's a legit counter-measure, right?

Yeah, it's a legit counter-measure because some stuff is fair use. But it's more than that. So these people know they're stealing something. And so YouTube has developed a counter-measure to fix that and that is content ID system.

Well, then these people go one step further and they take these digital stretch mechanisms or whatever and they create a counter-measure. And so I'm thinking about all this stuff. I'm like, this is war is what this is. This is just the escalation of how these things work.

And at what point will YouTube update their counter-counter-counter-measures to run that hash over everything, but to run it in different aspect ratios and to compress it and stretch it to try to catch any of those tricks. Exactly. So they'll figure it out. I decided to get on a plane and go to YouTube.

But before I did that, let me explain some of the other things they were doing. My assumption is that they were creating dozens of these videos. And the idea is they would go in with these sleeper login accounts and they would upvote these videos and create inauthentic behavior on the videos to make them look like they were good and make them rise up in the YouTube algorithm. But more importantly, if you do this and people start clicking on these things, it'll start suggesting similar content.

So in my mind, what they're doing is they're creating dozens of videos that look like the same thing that they artificially inflate them using their sleeper accounts or whatever they're doing and have those videos recommend similar videos. And if you do that enough, eventually one of these videos will rise up out of the algorithm as the most suggested video because all these other ones will funnel into it. This algorithmic momentum will be channeled into one of these videos and it'll rise up above the noise floor of the YouTube algorithm. And suddenly, real human eyeballs will start to see it.

Does that make sense? It all makes sense. I'm tracking with what you're arguing in terms of how it happened. That squares with my experiences and observations on YouTube.

OK. But the billion dollar question, who did it and what are they trying to accomplish? OK, so my next theory was because this is political in nature. I'm sorry.

I didn't mean to jump ahead. No, no, you're perfect. That's perfect. No, it's OK.

I mean, you're a guy who can literally just jump on a plane and go to YouTube. I didn't want to derail you. What do you mean? I'm going to go.

You're like, well, so I had a question. So I decided to just jump on a plane and go to YouTube. Well, sometimes I have questions. But I rarely jump on a plane and go to YouTube to ask.

Well, I'm glad you're on a first name basis with them. Well, this is kind of how it went down. I did this big Twitter thing. I just basically outed that the behavior was happening.

I was like, I think people are manipulating the algorithm. My gut reaction wasn't YouTube bad. Let's all hate YouTube because that's what the world does right now. And we like YouTube.

Yeah. They're a good partner. So I'm like, this is a legitimate attack. And I think this is an engineering problem.

So my assumption was this was an external party because I had listened to General Brown, right? So I'm like, somebody's trying to make a space off at each other. So I'm just going to go figure this out because all these companies, YouTube, Twitter, Facebook, some other companies, they all contacted me because of the tweet storm. Yeah.

To some extent, people at each of these companies, not the companies themselves, but people at these companies in their own way, they reached out and they were like, yeah, so this thing you're talking about, it's totally real. And we lose sleep over this. And we try really hard. And this is difficult.

Were they defensive? Did they feel like you were criticizing them? No. They felt like, finally, somebody gets it.

That's the tone. I just reached out to them. I was like, can I come hang out with you and ask you questions and get to the bottom of this? And they're like, yeah, we have to work it.

They're all these official channels. But please come out. We want you to understand because we know you're going to do the smarter everyday thing. But we want you to understand so you can do it right.

I was like, thank you. And so I did that. I got on a plane, went out there and I talked to people. And I've got an upcoming series on that.

We're going to talk about everything that happened there because you have an upcoming series on that. Yeah. I mean, I think I'd like to hold some punches back. But the upshot is, this is what I learned.

This is going to be the punchline in the videos. This is a complex engineering problem. They are literally under attack every single day. And for us to sit back and think that it's a bunch of humans at YouTube that have malicious intent that just are lazy and not doing anything or these humans at Twitter, these humans at Facebook, oh, yeah, they just don't get it.

They're just letting all this bad stuff happen. That is a naive, self-centered, childish look at how these things work. Wow. Because however complicated you think this stuff is, it is orders of magnitude more complicated than that.

OK, but all right. I hear you on that. But how on earth does it help someone's cause to make an awful news video? I mean, from what I saw, there was no real opinion or angle in the video.

It was just kind of a lazy repetition of some bizarre comments the president made. Like, you don't need Russian bots to attack YouTube in order to feel like from time to time the president makes goofy comments. I mean, whether you find that endearing or not is another question. But I just I don't see what the upside is of that particular example.

OK, let's just go into this. So my assumption was that this was an ideological attack where these people wanted us to hate each other. So they're going to get to the most divisive issue possible at the time, which is politics. And if you listen to the text of what that bot is talking about, it's like taking a very Democrat's think this.

Aren't they bad kind of approach? Oh, OK. So I turned it off too soon. So my assumption was they're trying to get Republicans and Democrats to hate each other.

OK. So I went out there to YouTube. And I even alluded to that in my little Twitter storm there. I went out there and they're like, no, that's not what this is.

I was like, what do you mean? It works like this. The goal for people in developing nations is to make money. And if they can figure out a way to make money from a computer farm, they're going to do it.

And so these attacks are motivated for two different reasons primarily. Number one is financial. If they can figure out a way to create incentivized content and the incentive is getting money from advertisements, they're going to do it. And I asked them, I was like, how much money do you think they're putting behind making this kind of content?

They're like millions of dollars. I was like, what? I was like, yeah, think about it. If they can figure out a way to make money on our system, they're going to do it.

And they're going to play within the rules. This is the thing. All this junk is within the rules. They're going to make this content and try to gain the system in any way possible in order to send money to themselves.

And so that's why you slowly are seeing the bar being raised on these platforms. You hear people complain now, well, I can't become a YouTube partner because I don't have X,000 subscribers. And the reason is because if they kept the bar low, then all these machines could jump over the bar. You see what I'm saying?

I do. The thing that's interesting, though, is at least in the example you're giving me, the thing that whoever this is from wherever they are believes that can get our attention and earn clicks is divisive stuff. Yeah, exactly. They're smart enough to know that's what works.

Yeah. And I'm smart enough to know that's what works. Even when it's tongue in cheek. If I make a video that's right through the front door, like, here's some stuff about some things from the Bible.

I've got a good subscriber base, and they will watch that, and will engage. And it's a good experience. But if I make stuff that is pushing back on fringe bizarro ideas, I'll get double the views on that kind of video, just because there's tension and disagreement built into the premise of the video. I'm about to blow your mind, dude.

What I'm about to show you you have not thought about yet, because I had not thought about it a week ago. And I'm needing to do stuff. No, you hadn't thought of it, then I definitely haven't. Because of how our brains both are.

My point is, I'm needing to be said. It needed to be said. It needed to be said. I apologize.

OK, this is going to blow your mind. I'm so OK. All right, blow my mind. OK, go to watchit.com.

W-O-C-H-I-T dot com. Right now? Yes. OK, watchit.com.

All right, I'm there. OK, for the third chair, explain exactly what you see. Exactly what I see. OK, it looks like the kind of thing that you can log into.

So this is some kind of personalized thing. We love video. So we built the predictive video creation platform that you'll love to create impactful videos now. OK, OK, watch this.

This is absolutely mind-blowing. I want you to think about you being YouTube, right? OK. You create this platform, YouTube.

And the idea is all these people are going to make videos about things they love and they're going to upload it. And then you're going to create these artificial intelligence ways to go through all these videos and make sure there's no violence or gore or nudity or things like that, right? Yeah, mostly works. Yep.

OK, so along comes things like, watchit. Scroll down. OK. So just describe what you see here.

What does this service appear to be? OK, it looks like video editing software. That's what I'm seeing next. Primitive video editing software.

It's not good stuff. 108 million licensed assets. OK, now stop right there. You see, 108 million editorial and creative licensed assets.

So they gather up all these images and they do things like that. Scroll down in the next line of stats. This is what I want you to stop and think and listen to your brain and what it's telling you about these numbers that you see. Scroll, read videos trending now.

What do you see? Whoa. Wow. That's the third chair here, Matt.

You got to explain what you're saying, man. Yeah, well, I'm drinking it in, buddy. It's kind of a lot. You came to this prepared holy cow.

OK, so what they're saying is in the last month, they have mushed together a collection of 108 different editorial and creatively licensed clips or images. 108 million. How did 8 million numbers matter right now? Yep.

1.6 million videos in the last month. OK, how many videos did it say they created today? 59,000. Wrap your brain around that.

I'm trying. I scrolled through my YouTube channel, taking stock of where things were at. I don't know if you days ago. I was like, wow, look at this.

I covered this entire book of the Bible. I covered this whole series of topics, all this history stuff. It's like 250, 260 videos. And I think about how much time and care and individual writing went into each of those.

And that's like 250. This is 59,000 videos created today. Yeah. And they're like Taco Bell menu videos, where you just take the same handful of ingredients and just mush them together in slightly different ways and try to pass it off as something original.

So this does several things. So this is the weaponization. I'm going to use the term weaponization loosely here. This is the weaponization of content creation.

So if you can create 59,000 videos today on whatever topic your people are paying you to do, because you're using these artificial intelligence engines to create these things, you enter a script, you enter a digital content asset library. So let's say we're going to mix in some videos about Trump and Ruth Bader Ginsburg and the Supreme Court from the outside in the White House. And then we're going to shake it all up. And we're going to pour out the yachty dice.

And we're going to see what video we get. And we're going to do that 2,000 times today. And we're going to have these machines make us 2,000 videos. And we're just going to slam them on the internet.

And we're going to try to saturate what's going on. Something will hit with that, Minnie. Yeah. That's the idea, because it's only sort of merit-based.

But look at this. It's ready to publish. Customize your daily video creations into your own fresh branded story. That'll take one minute.

Yep. What? Yeah. Can you imagine making a YouTube video for your channel in one minute that would provide value to a viewer?

Right. Exactly. That's impossible. But here's the thing.

OK. This is the brain melting part. So are you beginning to wrap your brain around the scale of using artificial intelligence to create online video content? And this is only one service.

This is one service that's above board. This is a for-profit, non-state-funded service that is doing it in the open. How on earth can YouTube stay ahead of this? Imagine what's happening.

I can't imagine. OK. Here's another thing, dude. I think about stuff from my genre.

I know you pay more attention to things from the genre in which you work, right? You're comparing notes, seeing what's working, what other people are doing, celebrating successes of others, maybe rolling your eyes at silly stuff from time to time. I do the same in my genre. And my genre, unlike yours, just sucks.

It's rough. There's not good content. It's combative. It's weird.

Really just content on the internet is not usually very fun. It's really cool when you run into something that's great. One thing that blows my mind is when I go to get started on writing my next video or whatever. And I just go to check out what's already out there.

And I will always find four or five complete trash videos. Nobody on screen, stock footage garbage, and a script that was written almost like was written in another language and then run through a translator bot. And I will see these from time to time. Be wildly successful.

And so part of what's blowing my mind right now is I'm finally understanding how that can happen. And honestly, that's a little bit less discouraging. So there's some upside to this. The story I want to tell is you, YouTube person, that's angry because YouTube did something wrong, do not understand the engineering problem that these people are trying to solve.

This is an impossible thing to say head up. Can you imagine what it would take? How much money and manpower and man hours it would take to go through and manually delete just the 1.6 million videos that were shared from watchit.com alone last month? It's impossible.

It's impossible. So they create these artificial intelligence countermeasures, right? They have to. So YouTube creates a platform, watch it webinizes AI for content creation.

YouTube creates AI countermeasures. And by the way, the watchit AI has countermeasures built into it to get around the YouTube terms of service stuff, right? So of course, YouTube has to create AI with counter countermeasures to sniff all this stuff out. And then at that point, we've got bots fighting each other.

And so YouTube is trying to stay ahead of this. But think about this, Matt. If you were to take 1.6 million, 1.2, 3, 0, 1.6 million, if you were to take 1.6 million videos, and you were to develop AI that could take out 99.9 of these, right? So we're going to let 0.01 slip through the crack.

How many is that? Like 1,000? Yeah. You're still getting all this stuff through.

So let's imagine the bad guys want. Is it 1,000? I didn't have it up with that much. I think so.

Hold on. 0, 0, 0, 0. Times 0.001 is what you want. Times 0.001 equal 1,600.

Yeah, 1,600 videos would still get through. OK, but here's the other question. Yeah. In getting that whittled down to 1,600 videos, and we really should have been able to do that in our heads.

Oh, yeah. Now you've run the math on it. I'm feeling pretty embarrassed. Yeah.

Did you know that we do base 10 here with our numbers? No, I didn't know that. No. Yeah.

There's a lot of really convenient metrics that you can use because of that. It's crazy. 10 fingers is amazing. You do professional math, right?

And engineering for really? Move on to your point, Matt. OK, I was just checking. That wasn't absolutely for sure.

So just think about, in an effort to purge 99.9, whatever percent of that, how much collateral damage is there going to be as well? Exactly. Not just here's how much gets through. Here's how much good stuff gets caught in the filter.

And this gets me to connecting some dots here. I'm going to ask the third chair to be patient here, because I know that people from a whole variety of points of view, listen, and I appreciate that. There has been a lot of talk lately, whether fair or not, that social media seems to be more interested in pushing back on fringe stuff that tends right than pushing back on fringe stuff that tends left politically. Fair or not, that's the accusation.

That's the observation. I have a new theory on this. But go ahead. See if you're right at the same theory.

That's where I'm headed right here. And I will go only so far as to say, though I am not a right Ist, I see some evidence to support that assertion. I see sometimes that it seems exaggerated. But what about this?

What if people overseas who either one, want to spread division or two just want to make a book by monetizing division, what if they've figured out that the way the left responds to crazy right stuff is more likely to draw numbers than the way the right responds to crazy left stuff. And as a result, they do a whole lot more crazy right stuff because for whatever reason financially, that's more beneficial. And as a result, groups like YouTube create their countermeasures. And so more stuff that looks to you and me like it leans right gets caught in those countermeasures.

And maybe there's not a grand conspiracy. Am I crazy? You're not. Let me say it a different way.

OK, so you're saying maybe it's intentional that attacks are happening on the right more? No. Well, maybe it's intentional from the malicious actors that we imagine are overseas. That's what I'm saying.

I'm going to speak in stereotypes. Always dangerous, but is a young person or an older person more likely to be on the left? I just thought about this. The only age group where a slight majority favors socialism as an economic system is like the 18 to 22 window.

So yeah, younger equals more left historically. And so older would be more right, correct? Yes. OK, that's correct.

Oh, I see what you're doing. Yeah. Who did telemarketers target? I just watched two videos today of IRS, scammers, calling people, intelligent people who caught it.

But I know people who've been suckered by it. And they're not young. Right. So if you're going to spend time making videos to try to sucker people, who are you going to go, Golly?

Yeah, you're going to attack the older generation. The older generation tends to be more to the right. Therefore, this is the transit of property of destined hand-waving YouTube data. Therefore, they are more likely to create inauthentic behavior on the right.

Because of the people who tend right. Therefore, YouTube's algorithms are going to have to be applied across the board to the right more. And then you have collateral damage. And when you have collateral damage, you get one YouTuber with a voice making a video saying how they're being suppressed.

You see what's happening here. OK, all right. But hold on. Let's also be honest, the different parts of the country lean very heavily in certain directions.

I remember when I lived on the north side of Chicago in 2004, when Barack Obama was running for Senate, there were like eight votes in that entire district that weren't for Barack Obama. There are parts of the country that lean dramatically right and dramatically left. And come on, the Bay Area is as left as the country can be. It's not the craziest thing to suggest that most people working on social media companies in the Bay Area are going to have preferences that lean left, right?

I shouldn't have said left, right. But you know what I mean. I'm waiting for your point. OK, so my point is, if I'm Joe Blow on the internet and I hear what you and I are saying, I'm thinking, huh, those seem like credible theories.

OK, so we're all victims of our biases. And I suppose it could be possible that people in social media might have biases and they might try to inflict that on the algorithm. OK, it took me a second to figure out what was going on. I thought you were presenting this as a logical truth.

But I realize now you were presenting what a person may think about the truth. Because I know you're a well-adjusted human man. And you know that people have their own ideas. You're less likely to stereotype employees of it.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 28 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on March 17, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.