Skip to content
058 - Pontius Pilate episode artwork

May 13, 2019 1 hr 33 min

058 - Pontius Pilate

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: HELLOFRESH For $80 off your first month of HelloFresh, visit hellofresh.com/ndq80 and enter ndq80 at checkout. Discuss the Episode by Clicking Here STUFF IN THIS EPISODE: TMBH - Who Was Pontius Pilate? The Catch (Willie Mays) Army-McCarthy Hearings Veritasium - How Was Video Invented Grammy Award North Dakota Bison USS Cairo South Dakota State University Apostles' Creed Aramaic Language Tiberius Julius Caesar Triumvirate Augustus The Julio-Claudian Dynasty Sejanus Capri Roman Procurator Coinage Byzantine Empire Charlemagne Denarius Hippodrome Caligula The Antiquities of the Jews The Jewish War Flavius Josephus Philo of Alexandria Eusebius Gospel of Matthew Gospel of Mark Gospel of Luke Gospel of John The Pilate Stone Pilate's Ring 13 Alabama Ghosts and Jeffrey Cry Baby Holler CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

058 - Pontius Pilate

0:00 1:33:27
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

So sometimes on this podcast, we've done a debrief of a Smarter Every Day episode, like how I arrived at my conclusions and things like that. But I'll be honest with you, I think the ratio of people in the third chair here is probably 50-50 religious, not religious. Yeah, that's about how I read it. Let's be serious, dude.

I mean, you're doing Bible on the internet. I mean, that's not the most popular topic. But we see often enough in the feedback, people are saying, well, hey, I'm not scared of learning about this stuff. Just talk about it.

So I can learn about it. I think this topic today is interesting because you learned about this guy from the Bible in a really interesting way. And so would you do me the honor of just explaining here in a few minutes why you decided to study this topic that you did on 10 Minute Bible Hour, Pontius Pilate? Yeah, and I'm honored that you're interested in that you want to compare notes and what our process has even looked like, history is a different animal.

So yeah, I talk about pilot and we'll talk about how you do the work and learn stuff about it. It'll be fun. Let's do it. This is more of a meat and potatoes kind of episode, isn't it?

Yeah, there's a lot to it. So I don't know how we can frame it any other way, but it's well-prepared meat and potatoes I'd like to think. Let's go. This episode's sponsored by a little fresh.

See what we did? That's not what we did. Have you ever done Pilates? No, absolutely not.

I don't even really know what those are. You? Never. Okay, moving on to number two.

What about Pilates? You know what I think about that? Oh yeah, I've learned a lot of things about Pilates. You mean Pontius Pilate, the Roman procurator who was responsible for the execution of Jesus of Nazareth around 30 AD?

Oh, let me just check notes. Yeah, that's what my notes say. Yeah, yeah, I know some stuff about that. You want to talk about it?

Yeah, let's do it. Because that's the video that you did recently, right? Yeah, that is the hardest I've ever worked on a video in terms of sheer time and research. It was a beast, man.

So I think the thing that's most interesting about it is I was talking to you as you were working on this and you put in as much research into this as I would expect a graduate level person to put in some kind of paper they were publishing. This was serious. This was serious work that you did. This was more work than either of my graduate theses.

Really? Yeah, dang. Well, and here's here's part of the difference. When I produced those capstone projects for my post college degrees, I had to defend that in front of two or maybe three people and they were smart and nice, but they only sort of cared because deep down they knew no one was ever going to read those works ever.

They were going to get published and bound up and put in the library and no one would ever, ever look. So they were peer reviewed, but not at the level I knew this ponches pilot thing was going to get peer reviewed. Does that make sense? Meaning thousands upon thousands of people would be watching the video and they would be looking for holes in your research just to execute you publicly.

Right. When I did a project on the advent of television in the 1950s and the Midwest and how that changed culture and connectedness in rural Nebraska and made them feel more like a part of a larger thing that was going on. What was that for? Was that for your master thesis?

That was for, yeah, my second round of grad school. Just to be clear, in what school and what program were you in? That was UNK, a University of Nebraska at Carney. And that was a project I did as a part of my degree in history of the West and Western thought.

Okay. And what was the official title of the thesis? Oh, I think I remember. I think it was powering up the antenna on the Great Plains and then colon and the whole bunch of words that sound official, but I can't remember the second part of the title.

It was cool. I went and did all this original research. The all of the people who worked on bringing television to Nebraska had either recently died or were getting close to dying. And I went and found all of these people.

I found the on-air personalities from 1954. I went and found people who bought television sets as soon as they came out and interviewed them to hear their recollection of what it was like to see the, you know, the, the TD crate getting off loaded from the train and then then buying it and setting it up in their house and all of their neighbors gathering around every night until finally they had to tell them to back off and all of these cool little anecdotes about watching the clumsiness of trying to handle these live broadcasts and queuing up the tape and all of this stuff. I got stories about people seeing the, the Willy May's catch. You remember the Willy May's catch?

The catch. Yes. Yeah. People saw that on TV.

I got stories a little bit later, but people saw that on TV. People watched one of the first things that happened on television after it came to Central Nebraska was the McCarthy trials. Remember what those are about? Yes, I do.

And so it was really interesting to talk to all of these old-timers who were remembering what it was like to first be connected on the national level and the very first thing they get is just miserable divisiveness. People cannibalizing each other in Washington and so it kind of had a repulsive effect to a lot of the people I spoke to because they're like, why would I want to use my TV for this? Well, what year was this? I mean, we're talking 50s, 40s?

1954. 1954. And so that was black and white TV. The television screens were circular at that time, if I recall.

Color TV was just starting to happen, but that was a luxury few could afford when all of this started getting fired up. Did you see Derek from Veritasium's video on the history of video? My goodness, that was excellent. It was an excellent video, man.

I mean, he talked about the Emacon tube was where the, was the Emacon? No, Emacon is a super high-speed framing camera. What's it called? It was a tube, but anyway, the any is a, it's a, I don't know what you call it, it's a derivative of the term for this tube.

I want to say Emacon tube, I may be wrong about that. But anyway, so any awards come from that particular cathode ray tube design. And I did not know that until I watched that video. That was great.

Those are the kind of things that you do kind of pick up along the way. Like, you know where a Grammy gets its nickname? You've picked up that data along the way. The gramophone?

Yeah, it's gramophone. And that's why they hand them gramophones. I saw a picture of a weird owl throwing like five of them in the trash to make room for the new one that he got this time around. Was he just being sarcastic?

Just being funny? Oh, I'm sure weird owl didn't throw those away. They're hard to get. Yeah, he was goofing.

Okay. But Emi, I just never thought about where that name came from. And then I watched that video. And I thought, Hey, Derek, I'm learning things.

Thank you. You're making my life better. This is what I want from educational programming on YouTube. Yeah, I'm looking up here.

Orthicon tube was the original one. Ah, man, it's not in the video description notes on there. But anyway, yeah, great video. Totally should go see that.

I'll put a link down in the notes or actually Tina will I want to do it. Thanks Tina. Thanks Tina. I'm looking up finger to put that in your dirty notes.

Tina is just better than me. She's a better person. I mean, well, go on. Yeah, it's true.

So yeah, this was a really fun project, right? And I went and did a ton of original research. Nobody had told this story. The TV station that was the first one to come to Nebraska.

It's still in existence. And I have a good buddy, Steve White, who worked for that station forever. He and I worked the church together and traveled all around the world with kids. And we just done some really cool stuff together.

He's very good at his job. You know how a lot of times you get, I don't know, local reporters, they're kind of rookies and it doesn't always go the best. But you can tell they're kind of learning on the job. And it's kind of like the minor leagues.

Yeah, that is not the case with Steve. Oh, he just knows what's up. He's good. He knows.

Oh, he's really sharp guy. And he's just decided, I'm going to be a central Nebraska. I'm going to plug in with this community. I'm going to like it.

I'm going to raise my family here. I'm going to know the politicians and the he's just he's like an old timey journalist who does it right. God does it at a relatively small station in a town. I crave that.

Yeah. It's trusted guy in your hometown that's going to get it right. You know, that's just brilliant. When I met him, I think he's a bison.

I think he went to North Dakota, North Dakota State. Think it was North Dakota. How do you say that? No, no, no, no.

He's not a bison. He's a South Dakota guy. No, no, no, no. Go back to that word.

How do you say that word? Oh, you caught that. Yeah. If you talk with people from North Dakota and you pronounce their bison as the bison, you are wrong.

It's the bison as though there's a Z in it. But there's not a Z. There's an S. Yeah, it's an S.

Yeah. So why do you pronounce it like there's a Z in it? I don't know. Why do people pronounce things the way they pronounce things all around the country?

It's all weird. That's interesting. Speaking of Nebraska, they have a town in Nebraska that is spelled C-A-I-R-O. How would you pronounce that?

Cairo. Yeah, that's correct, but you're wrong. It's Cairo. Really?

Yeah. Do you know why? No, I don't. Me neither.

I have no idea. That's just what they do. The USS Cairo was an ironclad ship that was sunk in near Vicksburg and they brought it up. The USS Cairo?

Yeah. Actually. What's interesting is the crane ship that actually pulled it up out of the bottom of the river was also named the Cairo. Really?

Yeah, it was interesting. I have no idea why I know this. That's pretty good. Yeah.

That's good stuff to know. You never know when you need to know this stuff. Yeah, pick up all these little trivia bits. So, no, Steve went to, he went to South Dakota State and same place that Adam Vinotary, the kicker, went to.

That's how I remember we went to school. And so when I met Steve, he was fresh out of college, journalist, babyface and all of this stuff. And he's still there. He's getting a few little flecks of gray in the hair and in the beard.

And that's a gift to a community when you have trusted local news who don't do sensationalist stuff, but they do legitimate research and homework. And it's been fun to see him succeed and to see him as a journalist serve a community for a big chunk of time. And so, what was fun about this graduate work that I did is that it was with his station. So, I was able to give them at the end like, hey, here's a history of your station.

You didn't know you had. And it's all bundled up. And there it is. So, a few people actually read it.

And I think appreciated it because it told a story that would have been lost if we'd waited even another year or two to try to tell it. We wouldn't have been able to get all that information rounded up. So, it's fun. Nice.

Sweet. But nothing like Pilot. Pilot was a monster. Yeah, that was a lot to say you worked hard on a video.

Yeah, that was fun. We got to talk about it. Yeah, that was fun. Yeah, of course.

Yeah, of course. It's worth it. So, here's the deal with Pilot. Being your buddy and just externally observing your life, I would call you and be like, hey, what's up?

Oh, man. I just like recently discovered that Pilot's wife used this brand of pantyhose and direct quotes, which is interesting because, you know, it was before they came in the little plastic eggs. And I didn't realize that. You know, every time I would call, you would be like this mad man who was having some deep philosophical connection with this historical character in a way that, you know, is interesting, but nobody really is sound like, no seriously, like there was this painting in Switzerland, right?

And something about a fountain and he washes his hands as a ghost. I was like, Matt, what are you smoking, dude? No, it was very interesting. That's an actual story.

That's an actual local legend. We're going to get to that. We're going to get to the ghost thing. Okay.

All right, cool. So, let me just ask some questions. So, Pontius Pilot is this dude in the Bible. And I think he's kind of getting a bad rap, personally.

I kind of empathize with the guy because Jesus has put on trial. It's a mock trial. The Israelites that are in, I don't know if they're technically Israelites at the time. They're just this religious group, the Jews at this point in time.

They want to crucify Jesus for blasphemy and Pilots like, I've interviewed this guy and he seems pretty cool. And maybe not cool. Maybe he's just a little crazy, but there's a little over statement, but indifference, maybe. In difference.

Okay. So, I've interviewed this guy and I don't think he's guilty. How about that? And they're like, well, we want to kill him.

And Pilot comes up with this plan. He's like, well, okay, clearly these people are just bloodthirsty at this point in time. Maybe if I do this little tradition that they do and I offer up this other dude, Barabbas. Maybe they'll take Barabbas because traditionally we let one person off the hook.

So, maybe if I put Jesus and Barabbas up here, they'll just select Barabbas and this Jesus guy won't get crucified and it'll be done. And they pick Jesus, right? No, we want to kill Jesus. Right.

And then Pilot does something that's fascinating to me. He gets a bowl of water. And he's like, hey, I'm going to wash my hands. This guy's blood is on you.

And to me, that's interesting. And I'm reading the story in the Bible and I'm like, okay, cool. Pilot gets it. And he's saying this guy's not guilty of the crimes that they're accusing him of.

But then here we are thousands of years later. And in the Apostles Creed, Pilot's name is mentioned. Can you quote the Apostles Creed? Mostly, but I'm not going to try it because I'm going to embarrass myself.

Apostles, I'm going to look it up. Yeah, I always read the lyrics when we do it in church. I do, too. I act like I know, but I'm secretly peeking.

Yeah, I'm secretly peeking as well. Okay, so let's, let's, I'm just going to pull up the Apostles Creed. Oh, it's in Latin. Now we're not going to do this.

Okay. This is... I've even got the Father Almighty creator of Heaven and Earth and Jesus Christ. God's only Son, our Lord.

Did you find it? I did. I found it. Okay, go ahead.

Who's conceived by the Holy Spirit, born of the Virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate, who by the way, in the Apostles Creed, Wikipedia article is the only person that has a link. Suffered under Pontius Pilate was crucified, died, and was buried. He descended to the dead. This is a little different in the way we say it in church.

On the third day he rose again, he ascended into heaven. He is seated at the right hand of the Father. He will come again to judge the living and the dead. I believe in the Holy Spirit, the Holy Catholic Church.

In our church, we say the Holy Christian Church, the communion of the saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body, and the life everlasting Amen. And so this Apostles Creed, I'm sure there's a historical genesis of this Apostles Creed, but pretty much anybody that says that you agree to most of the tenets of the Christian faith, you would be able to recite the Apostles Creed in good faith. Yeah, with only maybe slight nuance or characterization, like what does Catholic mean? Is that an acknowledgement of Roman authority, or do we use that in the sense of the word universal?

So a Roman Catholic will capitalize the letter C. A non-Roman Catholic might make that lower case, meaning as so as to indicate this is just a universal expression of Christianity. But yeah, it's pretty dang tight, and it's kind of the boundary markers for what is and isn't or the non-Christian Christianity. Okay, so looking at this Apostles Creed, there are, let's see, we're just going to look at humans in the Apostles Creed.

We've got Jesus Christ, that one makes sense. We have Mary to be expected, and we have Pontius Pilate and record scratch. Yeah, to me, that's weird, because Pilate got out of bowl of water and he was like, I'm going to wash my hands of this moment. This is on you, but here in the Apostles Creed, now we're very firmly pinning this on him, which is interesting to me.

So, Matt, you have spent weeks and weeks and weeks researching Nate, months researching Pontius Pilate. So, yeah, if I may kind of frame my job in this discussion, you're very, very close to the trees. You're in the forest. You were like, okay, you were living in the woods.

Kind of like where you were with Facebook, Bernie Sanders hair, lab coat, yes, dry eyes bubbling in the background. Yeah, so my job in this discussion is I'm going to try to pull you out of the deep places and give me more of a top level view and help me understand who Pontius Pilate is. So, Matt, who is Pontius Pilate? I can do this.

Okay, Pontius Pilate is a guy from Samnia, which is a region just east of Rome. He's from an ancient family that had been a nuisance to the Romans for centuries prior to the first century when we get to Jesus. And he's a guy with a really underwhelming resume who probably all things equal would not have received his appointment as governor of Judea if it weren't for some sweetheart connections in Rome or maybe a shared agenda with some people in Rome. And so, he comes from total obscurity in the lower ranking upper classes, like a knight, to ascend to this position.

He follows a guy named Gradus who had been there for 10 years, which is really good for a governor. Okay, I'm going to pause in this difficult spot. I'm coming out of the trees. I'm just going to pause you real quick.

So, first of all, Rome at the time is a government. Yes, it is. No, I mean, you're laughing at me. I'm being serious.

I'm backing up. So, Rome is a government. Yeah. And there are states in Rome or there are city states or what are the divisions of government in Rome at that point in time, geographically speaking?

That's a dang good question. City states are more associated with Greece, like Athens was a city state. Sparta, a lot of happened between then and the classic Roman Empire. So, what we talk about now would be client-king states.

In other words, Rome goes out to conquer somebody, but it's really tough, learning lessons from history, to send out your army and Roman governors to take over and completely occupy these people with an entirely foreign government. What they figured out is it is way easier to collect taxes and keep peace if you have a partnership government, where the Roman representative is there, but also there's an indigenous representative who understands local customs and law and religion and things like that. And they kind of work in partnership with the Roman governor being the more authoritative of the two of push comes to shove. So, this is called a client king state and both Judea and Galilee at different times were client-king states of Rome.

So, fully under the banner of the Roman Empire, kind of like we have states in the United States, I guess, but whereas in the United States, theoretically, the governors are legitimate powers, there the indigenous governors would be more of a concession to keep the peace. Does that make sense? So, this is like Puerto Rico. Hmm.

This is Roman Puerto Rico's where we're at. Sure. Language is a little bit different. Uh-huh.

There's a governor, but they don't have like, do they have the full rights of Roman citizenship? If you're a Roman citizen, you do. But to become a Roman citizen, it's not like you pass a 400 question test and go to a few classes. It was a pretty special title to achieve.

That's why most of the Jewish characters that we encounter in the New Testament are not Roman citizens with one really obvious exception. So, Pilots' role, if I understand you correctly, is he is in this extended area of the Roman Empire and he's the governor over these people who aren't necessarily walking around speaking Latin. Oh, no, definitely not walking around speaking Latin. Some people, I guess, would have a sense of that for legal or trade purposes.

But in the Eastern Mediterranean, the Langua Franca was Greek. But even in Judea, Greek would have been a secondary language. Aramaic is what most people would have been functioning in. So, for the most part, he is at this extended place and he's trying to keep the peace.

Keep the peace and collect taxes. That's his job. This episode of Noto Questions is sponsored by Hello Fresh, which is a meal kit delivery service that helps you cook, eat, enjoy. By sending you pre-packaged ingredients, everything you need to make an incredible meal all by yourself right there at the kitchen.

You get to cook. Yeah, my two favorite things about this is that I get to participate in making the meal and therefore I learn things and I feel ownership of this. And the other thing is that it tastes very good, which as I mentioned before, is very important to me when it comes to food. What I like about it is they have a simple instruction sheet that comes with every package.

And sometimes like if the kids go over to my mom's house or something like that, we'll send a Hello Fresh meal over there and you know the instructions and everything. But it's just very simple, easy to follow instructions and then you can make an incredible meal all by yourself. I love it. Yeah, it's paint by number E's with, for me at least, the gourmet level of deliciousness.

That is far better than anything else that I prepare myself. Pushes my limits a little bit. I get flavors I would never, I just wouldn't think to try the things that Hello Fresh sends me. And then I love literally every single meal I've had from them.

I've absolutely loved. Oh yeah. But half an hour for you? Is that your time frame on this?

Yeah, half an hour, depending on the recipe. Some of them you can cook everything in one pan. Others maybe take two pans or maybe if you got to put some tortillas in the oven or something like that. For the most part, it's easy cleanup as well.

So you should give a shot. For 80 bucks off your first month of Hello Fresh, go to hellofresh.com slash in DQ80 and end of the code in DQ80 at checkout. I've been getting some feedback from people who have ordered steak-based Hello Fresh recipes knowing that that is my favorite thing that they do. Everything I've had that involves beef really stands out for me.

I'm kind of a kind of sewer kind of into it. And I'm kind of a snob about beef because I live in Wyoming and it's in a ranch central and so I get this stuff really fresh. And it is spectacular. It's great meat.

So if you're a meat-of-or-like me, this is going to work for you. But it also works for people who are not meat-of-or-like me. They're veggie heavy options and even vegetarian options that you can go for. But obviously I enjoy talking steak.

I just realized that the meat is not frozen when it shows up at the house. Is it? It's just refrigerated. And you know how when you get meat out of the package and you know like this is exactly ready to cook?

Yeah. You just picture it working. That's how it comes every time. They've really got the how to get this from their facility to your door thing.

Dialed. So again, for 80 bucks off your first month of Hello Fresh, go to hellofresh.com slash Ndq80 and enter Ndq80 and try something with steak. It's a well I don't know man. The chicken and pork is pretty good too.

I enjoy it. You're making great points. You're not going to go wrong with anything. Hellofresh.com slash in DQ80, in DQ80 at checkout.

Thank you to everyone who supports the sponsors because when you do that, you're also supporting us and you help us make this podcast. Thank you so much. DQ80, is it okay if we get back to me uncomfortably obsessing about an obscure character from the first century AD? It is kind of cute the way you do this.

You're in the zone. It's good. It's really good. I enjoy it.

I like this song. I like that you get into things just like I get into things. Yeah. Offaly different things.

You're being a good sport. Thank you. Thanks to Hello Fresh for sponsoring the show. More punches, pilot.

So I guess that means that pilot is extended in this Puerto Rico area of Rome. People are speaking a different language, but he's still trying to make people in Rome happy. Like he's trying to make the government back home happy, correct? Yeah.

And we could say that for sure just because you know by merit of him being a Roman governor, but there's this little bit of political intrigue that I don't think gets us too far into the forest that is really crucial information that doesn't come up unless you look close and it has to do with the reign of the emperor Tiberius. You remember the name of the first emperor of Rome? Julius Caesar? Nope.

Julius Caesar was not an emperor of Rome. He was a part of a leadership group called the Triumvirate along with the very famous Pompeii, but all those guys died that destabilized things and there's a big civil war scramble for power that happens in the late first century BC and the guy who comes out winning is Julius Caesar's godson Octavian and he takes the name Caesar Augustus. Okay. And so that is effectively when we flip from the Roman Republic overwhelmingly governed by a Senate and laws to a Roman Empire, which is effectively a dictatorship that sings or swims based on the quality of its leader.

Got it. Okay. So Tiberius is the second emperor of Rome. So this is all kind of a new experiment for Rome.

How do we transition power? Who succeeds who right now? We're all a part of this dynasty called the Giulio Claudian dynasty and these people are going to rule for about a hundred years and Tiberius is the second in this line. So we're thinking we're going to go with pre-migene sure.

Whoever is first born to Tiberius gets to be emperor when it's over, but Tiberius has this advisor named alias Sejanus. Sejanus, Sejanus, you'll hear both ways. And this Sejanus guy is very, very clever in terms of political maneuvering and he is easily the second most powerful person in Rome, maybe for a while the most powerful person. Spell his name?

Sejanus. S-E-J-A and U.S. Sejanus. Okay.

So we've got an emperor who is trying to hold together the power in Rome. We've got a super-duper advisor here, Sejanus, and go. So what happens is Sejanus gradually takes control of the day-to-day operations of the empire and Tiberius, who is kind of over it anyway, pseudo-retires to the island of Capri off the coast of Naples. And do you have Isle of Capri casinos where you live?

No, we don't. Okay. That's a thing here. The reason that the Isle of Capri is this idealized lavish place that you would name a casino after is because of all the rumors of licentiousness regarding Tiberius' semi-retirement.

It was like a hot tub video. It was just constant porn for Tiberius while he was on this island, indulging in everything. That's the perception at least. Sejanus is all business.

And we know that Tiberius' pseudo-retirement happened before Panchus Pilate was appointed governor of Judea. How can an emperor retire? Well, how can an emperor do anything? We don't really know what emperors do yet because it's a new empire.

Do they have to be there to run things? Could they take an early retirement? I don't know. You can do whatever you want.

You're an emperor, right? I mean, he's feeling it out. We don't know how this works yet. And he's got a guy who he trusts to handle business.

So timeline wise, we can say pretty surely Sejanus appointed Panchus Pilate. Now, there are all these rumors later in this game. Hold on, wait. So, yeah, I need to draw a line here.

So you're speaking as fact, but you said we can say pretty surely, sir, very clearly. So is this something that you figured out or is this something that's documented? No, lots of other people agree with me who studied this stuff. It's really a question of timeline.

I mean, it's possible that Tiberius knew who Pilate was and really liked him and in the middle of being fed grapes and being fanned and having other things done to him as well. That he's like, you know, who I want to be governor of Judea is Pilate, but he wasn't really giving any other orders at the time. So it seems really weird that he just would have given that one order. It's far more likely that his bureaucracy handled that and Sejanus was ahead of that bureaucracy.

Okay. Yeah, it's a little bit speculative, but it's overwhelmingly likely it wasn't Tiberius who made this call. I guess this is why I'm saying this in like the hard sciences, if I say the acceleration due to gravity is 9.81 meters per second square. Sure.

If I say that, then that is a fact, you know, as best we can tell. Or if I say like, protons and electrons repel each other, whatever I say, it's based on fact. But you're sitting here talking about history and it's different because you're going on some things were written down over here. But how do we know what was written down was true?

You know, a lot of people say that the whole, that's the reason they're, they don't agree with Christianity in general's because it was written down and they don't believe the integrity of the documents, all these types of things. So I guess when you're telling me this stuff, will you just make it clear for me? Yes, we know this because of this or we don't know this because of that. We just tell me these things.

Yeah, sure. How do we know anything? Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I know.

I mean, unless it's repeatable, we don't know know know it, but we do know it. I mean, it all comes down to the threshold of belief. Was Pontius Pilate a person? Well, I mean, we got coins that say he was, we got a rock with his name on it that says he was.

Tell everybody about the coin. All kinds of documentation. Sure. Yeah, I just went and bought a coin because I became curious about these physical proofs of who Pilate was and when he was in charge.

This is when Google it. I can afford that. And I just literally bought a coin minted probably during the first three years of Pilate's reign, maybe as much as in the later for five or six years of his reign. How much was it?

It's less than 200 bucks. Yeah, it comes in this neat little tidy packaging and there's a whole organization that rates the quality of these coins and that vouches for their validity. I mean, it's not a coin that's really worth enough to make it profitable to fake it anyway. What's it made out of?

But, yeah, I don't know. It's either a copper or a bronze, but I guess I don't know. So what is on the coin? You know, the way it's the little patina on it would tell me that it's a copper.

Okay. There's a stave on one side, like a shepherd's staff kind of thing. And the backside is harder to make out. I guess I'm looking at here.

I can't really say exactly what I'm looking at. Sorry to tell what this is. Like maybe stocks of wheat. You have it right now?

You have it in your hand? Yeah. So I remember when you got this coin for the third chair, I'll let you know. So, so Matt's doing all this research about Pontius Pilate and then he tells me like, dude, I bought a coin.

I was like, oh, that's great, Matt. You bought a coin. That's neat. What is on the coin?

And you're like, well, it was minted by Pontius Pilate. And you're, I'm kind of surprised to hear you downplay it right now that now that Mike's are on because this was like a big deal to you. Like this wasn't, this wasn't like, oh, I bought a coin. This was kind of ramping up.

Well, I have just say it. I mean, if you like the coin, tell people about the coin, dude, because this was like a borderline religious experience for you. Borderline, I think it was more of a historical experience connected to religious stuff. But yeah, when I got the coin, I was excited about it because it's history and I like history.

But it occurred to me at some point. This is the only physical artifact from this era that I've spent my life studying harder than any other era I've looked at that I've actually held in my hand. This is it. I've actually touched it and I like that.

I actually own it. That is my coin. And Pontius Pilate, who was listed in the Apostle's Creed, he made this coin. He struck this.

Dang. And then I got to thinking further and I've told you this as well. It's about, well, I don't know what the odds are, but I'd say they're pretty good that somebody I've heard of from that era of history had this jingling around in their pocket at some point. And who knows, maybe somebody really famous that I've heard of from that era had this jingling around in their pocket.

It's not about whether or not that happened. It's about holding something where there's even a possibility that I got it. I would say Jesus of Nazareth had this or that it was on a table that Jesus of Nazareth flipped over and went scattering and clinking across the floor of the temple courtyard. This is all these stories that involve coinage and you're actually holding one that could be one of those coins.

It's just, yeah, it's a pretty neat connection. And for you, if you go and do a video about the energy transfer down a whip as it is cracked and how that all breaks down, you can just get the whip back and do it again because your discipline is repeatable. My discipline is not repeatable. And so you always have hands on access or almost always to the things that are enriching your life and that you're thinking about and trying to really understand and then explain to other people.

I don't. Ideal with memory, ideal with what was written down, ideal with probability. And a lot of the stuff that I study is so far removed from now that the idea of ever touching any of it is just, I mean, it's, you don't even think of it. It's not even an option.

And then it occurred to me for a couple hundred bucks. I could touch some of it. I could actually hold it. So in that respect, this is a place where our disciplines overlap.

I am actually tangibly physically interacting with hard data from the era in question that I study as you physically interact with hard data from the stuff that you study. So yeah, this is pretty exciting to me. That's cool, dude. That's really cool.

It's 2000 years old. Isn't that nuts? I wonder where that coin was. Like, how did it make the geric?

Okay, got it. Jesus may have gone down to the local wood store and bought some lumber with it to make a desk or something. I got it. But what happened to that coin in the meantime?

Well, there's been, well, I'm sorry. I mean, thousands of years in between there and here, what happened to it? Almost 2000 years were closing in. I can give you some hits.

What I know is this, when you look at a timeline that has neat little colored bars for like Rome, the Middle Ages, the modern age, that is an approximation. It is way blurrier than those timelines make it look. The reality is that Rome never really fell. It just adapted and evolved and became other things.

It moved east and it's still the Roman Empire, but now it's in Constantinople and we call it the Byzantine Empire and gradually the West gets absorbed into the church and local Italian kingdoms and stuff like that. Well, eventually some of those kingdoms congeal enough to have a guy feel justified in calling himself an emperor in Charlemagne, his crown emperor of the Holy Roman Empire by, I think, Leo III on Christmas Day 800 AD. And Charlemagne now is an emperor over a Holy Roman Empire. So it's still, I mean, kind of Rome.

Geographically, it's not the same. But Rome casts this long shadow over the Middle Ages and Rome represents order and value and predictability. But the Middle Ages in Europe represents chaos and scatteredness. And instead of this big imperial idea, you've got this little local ideal.

So who prints coins in the Middle Ages? Well, some kings were powerful enough to do that. But one of the major currencies that held value all the way through the Middle Ages, this simply Roman currency. In fact, I believe I've heard it said that Roman currency carried value and was still exchanged up into the Napoleonic era in the way of the century in Europe.

It's my understanding. I mean, that coin minted by the people under Pilate. That was just for Puerto Rico of Rome. That was over there in the corner, right?

I mean, that's not like, doesn't have Tiberius's face on it. No, he wouldn't have wanted to do that. He made some mistakes in putting Tiberius's face on things and it bit him in the butt. Pilate made mistakes.

Yeah, he did. We'll get to that in a minute. But no, I mean, presumably, coins from the later empire are the ones that you still saw in circulation all the way to Napoleon. But historically, I think it's really well demonstrated that Rome was sort of this ideal of order and yesteryear and sanity that everyone was constantly trying to point back to or cling to.

I mean, why do you have, why do you have Zars in Russia? I mean, Zars is Caesar. They're trying to claim ownership to the legacy of Rome. That they're in the 20th century.

Yeah. Well, okay, you see, right, where I was going. I mean, the Germans tried to claim connectedness with Rome. Why did the Nazis have an eagle in that posture as their sigil?

Speaking of which, I was in a meeting in Germany one time and we were looking up an old standard, an old test standard. And the German went to the back room and got it and he came out and he said, oh, I found it. It's pretty old. Like, it's old enough to have an eagle on it.

Oh, he was joking. But he was, he was joking and he laughed and we looked around the room and we're like, is are we allowed to laugh at that? Yeah. Okay.

That's funny. We can laugh. Okay. I'm glad we're there.

Yeah. It was pretty funny. Another thing I used to do, speaking of money and currency, people that would come visit Alabama and they'd come to the range for some of the testing that we did, they would say something like, well, what do we need to do when we we head over there? Like, they were getting their travel packet together.

I was like, oh, it's just, it's just like anywhere else, except if you have any Confederate bills, go ahead and bring those. They still work in the vending machines. And dude, dude, you could learn pretty quickly where people thought you were. Like, they, they would say, if they said, oh, you're funny or they're like, oh, yeah, I got to stack.

I'll bring them. You're like, okay, they're like, okay, they're with it. They know that we're like humans. But if they said something like, really?

Like, how does that work? Like, they said, they said it seriously. You're like, okay, cool. These people have very strong stereotypes and they think we're all inbred.

Is one of their stereotypes that they think vending machines were invented in the 1860s? I mean, I'm just telling you that joke fell flat sometimes and when it did, I knew what kind of person I was dealing with. So yeah, man, just to bring your Confederate bills, I work in vending machines. That's funny.

Anyway, okay, getting back. You may be thinking one more thing. I'm sorry. I'm gonna do one more rabbit trail.

Okay. Now, before you do that rabbit trail, can I tell you about the equivalent for that here? Yeah. Here, we literally still kind of have the Cowboys and Indians thing.

We live right next to the Wind River Indian reservation. The people who live there are citizens of our community and people who live in town do business interact with folks on the reservation. I mean, it really is this vestige of the old West, right? And some folks are still pretty upset about how all that played out.

Some folks are in a place where, well, you know, we all share a community. Let's just be a community. And I was in McDonald's maybe a year after I moved here. So I'm really not used to this social dynamic yet.

Don't really know how to play it. And there's a group of four Native American teenagers sitting back in the play area. Our kids are playing and goofing around. And Camilla and I are sitting there eating some food.

And there's a guy who comes in, no kids, but he sits down and he starts giving the Native American kids kind of a hard time. It wasn't really a racist hard time. It was more like old guy toward teenagers hard time. Yeah.

But it was sort of weird and kind of insensitive and we felt uncomfortable and we're quite sure what to do with it. And these kids were awesome. They rolled with it and get all indignant. They kind of jabbed back at the guy, sort of wore him down and he was a little softer by the time he got up and left.

But it was awkward and really uncomfortable. And as soon as a guy left, I congratulated the kids. Like, hey, you guys handled that really well. I was much respect.

And the one looks at me like, it's fine. We're going to burn his wagon later. I was like, you are awesome. That is amazing.

I got out of my chair and high five to all four kids. That is amazing. That is like, that is the appropriate, you know, the appropriate amount of embracing stereotypes and being able to joke about them. That's great.

I loved it. And we'll see if Tina does as to whether or not that makes it into the edit. That's hilarious. You were asking me something about Rome, though.

What were we talking about? It doesn't matter. What I was going to say is, as people think these currencies are strong and they're going to live forever, it made me think about, you know, a day when you would have a Bitcoin being compared in terms of value of Roman, whatever it would be, a draw from, or whatever. I don't know.

What is a Roman currency? I don't know. Sure. That sounds good.

Whatever. Daenerys is what you usually hear. Okay. Cool.

Anyway, long story short, you got a coin and you love it and it makes you think about history and it makes you connect and it makes you a little squishy. It just does. More squishy than you're letting on right now. So, you know what?

Can we just admit that things make me squishy? Yeah, things make me squishy too. Yeah. Yeah.

I get it with that. What can you do? That coin, you have, do you carry it in your pocket? Yeah.

You know what? I do. And not for religious reasons. I just kind of like it.

And I like showing it to people. It's a cool conversation piece. And yeah, so the whole time I was working on that video, I carried it around in my pocket. And when we, when we did Palm Sunday and I talked about Pontius Pilate in church and the nice full room and everything, I sent it around the whole church.

I started in the front like show and telling kindergarten. Like, I just love show and tell. Well, how can you not? Yeah, I know that nap time.

Do you remember a particular like, particular show and tell moment that you did kindergarten? Not that I did, but I remember one that somebody else did. They brought in a skull of some animal. What?

And I'd never, I'd never been exposed to that. Yeah, it was like a, what do they call the kind of taxidermy amount that isn't made to look like it's just the skull. What do they call that? European.

Okay. Cool. Yeah. I'll tell you who would be able to tell us more about that.

Emily would have answered that question confidently and with details. She would. Yes. So yeah, it was just something like that.

It was a European mountain. I'd never seen a dead thing skull before. So that kind of weirded me out. But I remember it distinctly.

You? I just remember I had one, I don't know if I had transformers. I had one transformer dinosaur, but I had a box. No, I didn't have a small remember.

I had. Okay. Yeah. I don't know the names.

I just know how to transform on. That's all I knew. But yeah, I remember taking a transformer one day. That was cool.

This is fun and all, but if we're going to get to all the Pilates or Pilates in this episode, we're going to have to get back to Pilates. So let's go. Go back. Okay.

Okay. Okay. So pilot. What about what do you need to know?

Is that just carte blanche? Is that just mean go? Yeah, go. And go.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 33 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on May 13, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.