Skip to content
060 - VR Baptism episode artwork

Jun 14, 2019 1 hr 8 min

060 - VR Baptism

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: HELLOFRESH DISCUSS THIS EPISODE BY CLICKING HERE STUFF FROM THIS EPISODE Real Pastor in Virtual Reality Baptizes An Anime Girl Tertullian Cyprian The Protestant Reformation National Treasure Trailer First Muslim in Space A Guidline of Performing Ibada at International Space Station Randy Travis Tim McGraw Kansas City Royals Polka KJIL Radio - Meade, KS Time After Time by Cyndi Lauper Former FBI Agent Explains How to Read Body Language Joe Biden's Most Touchy Feely Moments Wife of ex-Defense Secretary Defends Biden The Electrical System of the Body Jerry Seinfeld Painfully Rejects Kesha's Hug CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

060 - VR Baptism

0:00 1:08:09
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

So you're going to have to go to Nicaragua, is that right? Yeah, leave tomorrow. What are you doing there? The same thing I always do in Nicaragua, which is- I had to take over the word.

It occurred to me that halfway through that's what it sounded like, so you played it right. Yeah, yeah. No, I'm going down to work with a whole bunch of pastors from all kinds of different brands of Christianity, and there's this kind of seminary in a box program. I don't know, it's expensive to go to college for anything here.

It's expensive for yet to go to college for that stuff there. So we've been invited to come down and teach these classes. So I'm going down to do this time around, it's a New Testament survey. So you're teaching pastors in Nicaragua how to be pastors?

Yeah, not really how to be pastors. They're already really good at that. I don't think they need any of my dumb advice, but I think they're much more impressive at it than I am because they're doing it all without training, without the benefit of school. It's economically impossible for most of the men and women who serve in that role in that country to go and get the training they need to do it.

So they're kind of on an island doing it by themselves, trying to muddle through, figure it out, but even then you might think, well, I just jump on the internet or just go buy some books, but even that's kind of economically prohibitive for a lot of these people. So that's kind of the role that we play. We roll in and try to help build those gaps and provide resources and then leave them alone, let them do it. How they think they need to do it.

Yeah, and increasingly you go to the internet for things and the answer might not be there. You notice that? Or at least convoluted. Yeah.

Yeah. So I want to bring something up today and I know that you really had to cram in this recording session because you're leaving. So there was this thing that happened on the IndiQ subreddit. Okay.

Someone has this post-made called Abtism in VR. Did you see this? No. Actually, I didn't.

I missed it. Yeah, it was two days ago. Okay. And so I realized that you're getting on an airplane and you're going to Nicaragua and the whole reason you're going is to talk to people about, I mean, I don't know, if you teach people how to be a pastor or whatever it is you're doing.

At what point do you talk about wearing suits that don't fit? What lesson is that involved in? Is that like the first week when you teach in that? Or what?

Maybe this is the southern thing. Suits that don't fit? Yeah, I just like to joke about what. I don't even know how to wear a suit period, man.

I just know that like pastors think a lot about what they wear. They think a lot about it, apparently, because they always- Do you? I bet you do. I don't know.

I think about what I put on every day, but it's pretty informal, man. I do a collared shirt that sleeves rolled up because it's like how I like to wear those shirts. And jeans are like Mount Me Cool Pronow Outdoor Pants kind of things. And I wear a pair of jeans or some kind of outdoorsy looking shoe.

And that's it, man. But you think about it, though. Well, I didn't say pastors wear fancy clothes. I said they think about what they wear a lot.

But there's not that much to think about. I was like, well, let me just grab one of my 15 collared shirts, which everyone doesn't smell bad. I'll put that on. That one looks not that wrinkly.

Let's do that. And then here's some pants and some shoes. Yeah? I don't know, man.

I don't think our church is normative because of where we're at geographically. People literally wear cowboy hats to our church. Yeah. It's pretty cool our church too because people wear just whatever.

But this VR church thing is what got me thinking about this, right? Okay. So there's this- it's a video. It's a really interesting video, link in the description.

And it starts with this guy talking about like, well, you know, I know that some churches have dress codes. Do we have dress codes in VR? Because a lot of people in VR have like a sexy, later avatar with exaggerated features and things like that. I mean, there's breasts and butt.

I want to see if you'd go clever or obvious. Yes. You went obvious. I respect that.

Yeah. Okay. So a lot of anime VR people, I'm not in the VR community, but I have noticed that, you know, there's this culture and in Fortnite, all the features of these people are kind of cartoon like an exaggerated. In this video, it opens with a person asking just that.

So there's this guy that's created a VR church. You know what? It occurs to me. We should just get this guy on.

Yeah. I mean, I have so many questions and I guess you're using the phrase VR community like it's a thing I should understand. I don't. But I'm a simple fly fisherman.

So are you telling me that we're doing the Ready Player One thing at this point? It's kind of happening. Yeah. People are putting buckets on their heads and they're going and meeting in virtual space and they're just interacting and having community there.

And this video was fascinating. It's 10 minutes long. I don't know who posted this video. Somebody named Syermore, S-Y-R-M-O-R, but I don't know if this individual is the person in the video or I mean, that's the level of engagement I have with this.

But the whole idea of VR church is fascinating to me. And this video is a pastor that baptizes a person named Drumsy. Baptizes Drumsy in VR in virtual reality. So first of all, having not, you have not watched this video, right?

No, no, no. I can't even picture it. So if someone were to come to you as a pastor, first of all, what's baptism? I'll talk about that.

So can you just give me, we're doing this? Well, people in the subreddit have asked me, they said, hey, will you talk about the topic? I said, well, the JPMs, the Jesus is permanent, would probably really hide and might make people uncomfortable. And they're like, well, I don't know.

We just kind of would like to hear you talk about it. And so from that perspective, it might be interesting to discuss this because it's a fascinating concept. And I think it has implications specifically for places in the world where it's illegal to think certain things, right? Okay.

Yeah, I'll answer that question. If you're serious at all. So, man, give me the 100%, like, what is baptism from a pastor's perspective? Don't try to sell me under anything, but just explain technically what it is.

Yeah, I'd like to think that's how I always do it. Okay, you're not going to like this, but it depends on what pastor you're talking to. If you're talking about the Roman Catholic or Eastern Orthodox churches, baptism means something very different than it does in a Southern Baptist church. So I have to answer for both.

Please be patient. For more of the historical high church approach where the idea is that salvation happens by Jesus, but that is handled by the church. So your relationship with the church is very, very, very crucial. Baptism is something that happens when your baby, your parents make that decision for you.

It's what's called a sacrament of the church, which is one of the ways that the grace of God is handed off to a person. And at that point, you are initiated into the life of the church and through that into the beginnings of a life of faith and in relationship with God. Baptism means something very different in most Protestant traditions, especially evangelical, Baptist style Protestant traditions, the more modern stuff that people picture with more casual things like us. Baptism is something that adults or at least kids who are old enough to decide for themselves choose and they do this as a public way to tell everybody, hey, I am a follower of Jesus and just like Jesus got baptized symbolizing his death and resurrection.

So I will be baptized literally by being dunked in water to symbolize me following him there, dying to myself and being raised into new life in Jesus. That's how I would explain it. I think we're on the same page. There's nothing magical that happens at the moment.

It is a super duper symbolic thing in your tradition and mine. Yes, a Roman Catholic would say, whoa, no, something does happen. There is a spiritual transaction and things happen in the heavenly realm and this counts for something. So that's just a place where Christians see that a little bit differently.

Pull that thread. What happens? Is there your name is not in a book and then it's like good guys, your name's not there and then all of a sudden you go up front and somebody sprinkles water on your head or pore, dunk you under water depending on what you believe. And all of a sudden your name is in the book.

What do you believe? There was a very, very smart early church father from North Africa named Tertullian. You ever heard of that guy? No.

Most Roman Catholics probably have. They're more interested in these early Christian leaders than most Protestants are. But Tertullian famously said that he who does not have the church as his mother cannot have God as his father. Wait, was that Cyprian?

I don't know. It was one of those guys. It's one of those guys. So whatever the case, the meaning there being that access to God is somehow mediated through the official Roman Catholic church.

And so I'm sorry these questions are hard to answer without just absolutely pegging the JPMs. Are you still good here? Yeah, I gave you no prep. Okay.

I saw a video. I want to talk to you about it. And I'm like, you know, let's just do it. You're asking the right questions here that lead back to the video.

So okay, I'm just going to keep going. You were welcome to interrupt me whenever you want. Let's just say it for the third chair. Hey, third chair.

We know you're probably atheist or not, but we also know that you're smart and you probably want to know how this stuff works. And there's no dumb questions here and we can just have the conversation and you're a well-adjusted adult, right? That works. Yeah, just get it.

Yeah, yeah. In Matthew chapter 16, there's this breakthrough moment between Jesus and his disciples, Peter in particular, up to Matthew 16, which is one of the gospels or the stories that describe the life and teaching of Jesus up until that point in the book, which is a little past halfway. It looks like Jesus is saying that he's the son of God, the Messiah, the one who is the fulfillment of this super ancient prediction that there would be this one character who would bring about redemption and restoration to the broken world. And so people are starting to think it might be Jesus and some people are really threatened by the idea.

He says, but it would almost be blasphemous to even suggest that out loud. And so the disciples have been pretty mum on that point. And finally, Jesus pushes this to a confrontation point where he's like, who do people say that I am? Well, reincarnation of some old prophet or some other people say this.

He's like, okay, yeah. But who do you say that I am? And then Peter, who's always the bold one in the group, he decides to take a swipe at it. And he's like, you're the Christ, the Messiah.

And Jesus affirms that. And he's like, yep. And that's not even from you. That's from God.

You're definitely right. And then he goes on to say some stuff that has caused a tremendous amount of controversy and confusion and also good stuff throughout history. He goes into this language about, yep, you're right, Peter. And on this rock, I'll build my church and Hades isn't going to prevail against it and whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven and whatever you loose on earth will be loose in heaven.

And then he goes on to say, and also I'm going to die soon. And that kind of takes all the wind out of the situation. And then the very next thing that happens in Matthew 17 is the Transfiguration where Peter and James and John, C.G. says in all of his glory and hear God's verbal affirmation of him.

So there's a ton of theology that happens right there. And the Roman Catholics come to believe that Peter is the founder of their church in Rome. And that Rome is the first among equal churches and that essentially someone needs to be in relationship with the one true church, which is headquartered in Rome, in order to be in right relationship with God. Because Peter, and this gets back to your question about what happens when that baby gets baptized.

Because Peter, they believe, was given the ability to do and proclaim things on earth that would be binding in the spiritual realm. The Roman Catholics believe that when a priest who is descended from the spiritual lineage of Peter, so Peter hands off the keys to leadership of the church to the next pope and the next pope and the next pope and those pope's commission bishops and those bishops commission priests and those priests, commission other priests. The Roman Catholic would say that anyone who is descended from that spiritual lineage of church authority and thus connected back to Peter and Jesus, when they perform a baptism, that is a binding and a loosing, that is a loosing the grace of heaven that is a binding to the church, that's more my language than their language, I guess. And so there is a spiritual transaction in the mind of the Roman Catholic that happens at baptism.

And at that point then, in their mind, if that baby, God forbid were to die, then the grace of God was conveyed through that baptism in that moment of infant baptism and they're good. Whereas a Protestant would look at that and say, there is no spiritual transaction. The spiritual transaction that matters here has already occurred when someone becomes a Christian through their understanding of who Jesus is and a decision to follow him as king of their life. That can happen in private.

There is no need to be anybody there for that. No church involved whatsoever. But that baptism is the public expression of that. So they kind of go on record and be like, hey, this is what I'm going to go ahead and do with my life, whether you think it's weird or not, this is my plan.

So does that make sense as to how those are two very different things? So if I get this straight, you're saying that the Roman Catholics among us would say, hey, when you're baptized, there's this thing that happens and however records are kept, suddenly you're putting the records for the people that are good to go, for salvation. Sure. And then they would of course nuance that out because it's a complicated topic.

Yeah. And then the Protestants would say, or maybe even some other people in the Eastern church or things like that, they would say, okay, so well, I don't even know. They'd say something along the lines of, well, salvation happens separately from that. And baptism is a way just to let other people hear horizontally on this plane of existence with us, let them know what your plans are.

That's the deal. Yeah. I think the Eastern church would look more like the Roman church than like us, but otherwise, think it right on there. Okay.

So that brings me to this VR baptism, right? Okay. Before you bring that up, let me make one more remark for the third chair that might be like why are we talking about this? Right.

It is as strange as this might sound that debate about what baptism is and how it works and how salvation works and does the church own salvation, do individual's own salvation, what has had a much bigger effect on your life and the world than you know. Whether your religious or not is irrelevant here. That question gets to the heart of where authority in Western civilization, in global civilization for the last 2000 years lies. The Protestant Reformation wars that have nothing to do with religion are still somehow connected to this question because it creates this mingling of authority between church and state.

So if it feels like, man, that's just a bunch of Jesus talk for no reason. I mean, well, it is Jesus talk, but also it's global history talk and really important stuff. So there that is my defense of why theology is important to proceed. So I mean, I think it's interesting because there's this moment at the end, I'll just say at the end of the Jesus story, I'll just say it that way of our accounts.

It's the great commission, right? It's where Jesus is on this mountain and he's about to like reveal the plan, right? And he's like, okay, here's the deal. I spend all this time on earth hanging out with you dudes.

I'm about to like fly up into this cloud. You don't know that part yet, but I'm going to tell you this massively important thing before I do it. And he's like, I want you to do two things guys. And we're like, oh my gosh, he's about to reveal like the master of Jesus plan.

He says, number one, go teach everybody about me. You know what I mean? It says is go ye therefore make disciples of all nations. And then he says this baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and Holy Spirit.

So Jesus spends all this time on earth at this most critical moment in history. And he has two things to do. This is what he's telling us to do. Number one, go teach the nations about me.

Number two, baptize them. That's pretty weird, man. Yeah. Let's say you're the dude that's going to take over the world.

Okay. Let's say that you're thinking in terms of power, humanity and all that kind of stuff. You're not. Well, let's just be the thought experiment here.

I don't want it. Yeah. Okay, John. So you're going to think through this stuff.

Reveal your master plan to all of your followers and go. What? This episode of Notum Questions is sponsored by Hello Fresh, a meal kit delivery system that shops plans and delivers step by step recipes straight to your house. Tell me about it, Matt.

I think this is how people are going to do food moving forward. This is really catching on. It's caught on with us. It's super simple.

I guess the exact phrase is home cook meals made simple. It's not simple for me any other way. This checks out. They send you the stuff.

You follow the plan. You get good food. It's a six step easy and enjoyable recipe. You can just like sit there with your family and make this thing.

I did this thing with my kids. I challenged them. I had the ingredients out and then just handed them a card and said go for it. They totally did it.

My 10 year old and 12 year old cooked steak, mashed potatoes, roasted carrots and it was phenomenal. Have you done that yet to your kids? So you basically did some kind of kids play set except at the end you eat what they made with the play set? Except it wasn't a play set.

It was real food cooked with real kitchen appliances and it was really delicious. I mean, that's the deal. We haven't done that yet. I think a little guy isn't quite there, but I think the girls could hack that and I think that might be something that we could legitimately use as a parenting trick for the next phase in their development as humans.

I'm doing this. Yeah. I'll imitate you and I will tell you the results. you know, we love HelloFresh.

So for $80 off your first month of HelloFresh, if you want to try it. Go to hellofresh.com slash in DQ80 and enter in DQ80 at checkout. And for those of you who are not from the south and are confused by in DQ80, I'm going to take a run at it for $80 off your first month of HelloFresh. Go to hellofresh.com slash N DQ80 and enter in DQ80.

That would be November, November for that 80. HelloFresh is good. Give it a shot. Have your kids do it.

Tell us how it went when they took their first swipe at it. It's really good. I would love to see pictures of your kids cooking HelloFresh for you while you're like like sipping on a tee with your feet up on the ottoman or something. That's what I wanna see.

Yeah, I get to beat everybody the punch on that one. I will deliver as soon as possible, my friend. Let's do it. Hello Fresh is good.

We're not joking about this. We actually love this stuff. It's great for our families. We wanted to be good for your families too.

Give it a shot. Hello Fresh.com slash November Delta Quebec 80. Hello Fresh.com slash Noodle Duck Quack 80. It's really hard to remember all of those.

Eight zero. You got it. All right, back at it. Reveal the master plan to all your followers.

To take over the world? Yeah, do it. Go. I don't want it.

Actually going to take over the world? What would my master plan be? Well, everybody who's wanted to take over the world or master plan has been to tell people how the things are and eliminate everyone who doesn't present. I know.

And that's why this is so weird. Jesus is like, depending on the version you read, he's like, go teach them and then baptize them. Literally go win hearts and minds. That's it, right?

Yeah. Yeah. And what's so crazy about this? Well, okay, but in the larger context of the book of Matthew, win hearts and minds, I mean, that sounds like language we use for the invasion of Iraq.

That's kind of a tainted language. I wanna slow roll that. How they would have understood that is live and proclaim the values of the upside down kingdom of God. The weak are strong, justice for the oppressed.

You win when you lose. That's what Jesus was talking about is this kingdom of God that has these very foreign values to the rest of the world. So what they were going out to proclaim was Jesus as king of a kingdom that has stunningly upside down. And I think beautiful values that even people in my experience who don't like Jesus or the Bible or how Christianity has worked out very much, they tend to really like the values that Jesus talked about there.

So hearts and minds, I don't know, I would just frame that a little bit differently. Thank you for hearing me. New ons accepted. Okay, so thank you.

That brings me to this moment in time when you're putting your underwear in a way back, no doubt. So that brings me to this moment. You were about to do the first part of this. You're about to go teach all nations.

You're going to Nicaragua. You're going to teach down there. Are you going to do any baptizing where you're down there? Pastor?

No, I think they'd be inappropriate. They've got perfectly good pastors. There's nothing special about me. They don't need me.

Okay, I'm just wondering. No, if there's a baptism that needed to be done while we're down there, people from Nicaragua should do it and they should do it in better Spanish than I could do it. Gotcha. So that brings me to this VR baptism, right?

So based on your description and how you describe it, baptism, at least in half of the Christians on earth or maybe more, is a symbolic thing, right? Yeah, a significant minority, call it a 65 old world church, 35 Protestant. Got it, okay. Long story short, I think the VR baptism is interesting and it makes sense.

This guy, I don't know his name, he has started a virtual reality church. People put the KFC buckets on their heads. They go meet in virtual reality and they talk and he delivers a sermon and he hangs out and they do the things they do in a church. Like mostly it's all in your head, right?

That's what church is. People sing, people listen to a message and all this stuff. And one of the only, there's two physical things I can think of that happens in church. One of them is baptism and the other one is communion.

However, you think that happens. Some people call it the Lord's Supper. There's many different ways that happens. It's the same exact question that comes back to the same issues I was talking about with Peter, Catholicism, the role of the church.

Same questions, yeah. But how do you think a VR baptism would work? Having not viewed the video? Like the nuts and bolts of it, the mechanics?

Yeah. Well, we do have baptism, how do you do it? You fill up a tub of water and you take some money up there and you say, I'm gonna baptize you now in the name of the Father, Son, Holy Spirit, and you dunk them underwater, right? That's what you do?

That's pretty close. The term is immersion. An explanation of their faith. However, they see fit for some people, that sounds really flowery and it's beautiful and it's great for other people.

It's kind of this clumsy, yeah, I was doing this and now I'm here and I'm doing this and that's not exactly a theological treatise and that's beautiful too. But we put the microphone in front of them and let them explain what this means to them and why they're doing it. And then, yeah, I usually haven't plugged their nose so they don't come up gagging and sputtering and then I kind of put my hand behind somebody's like support the neck and head and I stand outside the water. They stand in it and I say so and so because of your profession of faith in Jesus Christ as Lord, I now baptize you in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit and then I take them under water and I pull them back up and then I usually get a soaking wet hug and that's with me for the rest of church.

Is there anything magical about the water? Like the fact that there's water, any magical there? I knew you'd take us there. And by using the word magical, you've tipped your hand as to your belief or your answer to the question.

Yeah, am I right? Yeah. So obviously by your phrasing, you would say no, there is not. Yeah.

And I would say there's nothing magical about anything because magic's not really a thing but there may be something significant about that water that is being missed by doing it with fake water. Really? I was saying it doesn't work. I know the people in the Eastern Church and the Roman Catholic Church, they're not going for that.

That's fly by night. A Roman Catholic listening to this right now would be saying that's my problem with Protestants. So right there. So they'd say I'm blasphemous.

And for the third chair who don't know, Protestantism, that happened in 1517. That got started, you've heard of Martin Luther. And it was a split away from the old Catholic Church. And so all of your Methodists and Baptist and sort of episcoples, sort of my group, we're all Protestants.

We're all part of the people who would say, lots of great things about the Roman Catholic Church, but we don't think that Rome holds the keys to salvation. And we have more of a distributed power model than the Roman Church. And so we see a few things different. All of my Roman Catholic friends and the Roman Catholic listeners are like, no, no, no, no, no.

That doesn't work. The water actually matters. And the action actually matters because church is where the intersection of the unseen spiritual reality and the physical reality overlap. And you turn it into something virtual, you fundamentally alter the meaning.

Whereas I think a Protestant's gonna be more likely to be cool with it. This is what I would say. I would say watching this video made me think a lot of things. And I wanna be mindful of your time.

I know you have to pack and you have to go physically to Nicaragua and you're gonna go do what you believe is that part of the great commission that you're supposed to do. I got a little bit longer here. I'm fascinated by this conversation. Yeah, so this baptism that happens, you've got this guy that his avatar is an African-American man.

Soto 7A23D is the word that's floating above his head. He's standing. Soto or Soto. S-O-T.

He is standing in front of Winnie the Pooh and an Avatar girl. And they're in... Anavi, excuse me? Anavi, like the blue from the movie Avatar?

No, no, forgive me. She is an anime looking Avatar of a human. Okay, got it. I'm tracking.

Standing in front of this, it looks like they're in an endless water area. It looks like a sea, something you'd see down in Bolivia or something like that. And then he explains how he started his VR church and stuff like that. And this drumsy person who is the anime, obviously the anime chick in pink, it looks like an anime person.

He said, okay, and drums, he says, hey, I wanna be baptized. And then I goes, okay. And then they changed the world that they're into. What looks like a Japanese, like a domicile of some sort, like a place where people would live.

And he says, okay, drums, here's what we're gonna do. They're waste. And he says, okay, so what I'm gonna have you do is just crouch where you're at. And your avatar will go under this water.

And they do that. And the guy, I'm looking at it right now, he says, I baptized you name it, Father and Son of Holy Spirit. Now so drums, he rise up again into a new life, I'm reading, to signify new life for your spiritual walk. And he says, and that my friends is your baptism.

And he explains it much like you probably do in your church. He explains it a little differently in a way that, you know, I'm not 100% on board with all his take on how everything sounds, but it's very interesting. It's a very interesting concept because they're not together in physical space, but their hearts are connected. And you know the passage that I'm thinking right now, however many are gathered, what is it?

Go ahead. Yeah, it's Matthew chapter 18. Yeah, we're ever two more gathered together in my name, I'm there with them. So the question I would have is, wherever two or more gathered in my name, I'm there, it doesn't have to be physical space, does it?

Yeah, and contextually that's a passage about, the really most of all has to do with problems in church and standing up to problems in church. Like, hey, you're gonna have to go and confront some things and it's gonna be hard sometimes. But even if I'm not physically there, if you're unified in doing what I told you to do, I'm with you, that's kind of the take on, but it could apply the way you're using it to, I suppose. You see where I'm going with this?

I really do. And you can hear my wheels spinning from all the way across the country. My thing is this, in this conversation, I'm not going to say either of the following things. This is a great idea, I like it.

I think this is awesome, I have no problem with that. I'm also not gonna say, this is a terrible idea. People shouldn't do it, that's sacrilegious. I need to think about it, and even after I think about it, I don't think I'm gonna say either of those things.

I don't know, people should try to pursue things that they think are important. I think that's the case that I'm pursuing something I happen to think is really important too. I think it would be better to go through the ups and downs and joys and pains of being in an actual tangible community together, but at the same time, I would like to be baptized in an infinite voyage of the Dawn Tritor Sea that transforms into some Japanese home with a little tranquil pool in it too. I mean, it sounds like a beautiful thing that just happened there.

You're not asking me to do this, but I'm going to resist the temptation that I sometimes feel to try to put this into either the good bucket or the bad bucket, and instead try to go with the understand bucket. And so my question back to you would be, why do you think that happened? Why do you think that group exists? Why do you think in this day and age that that church exists and what do you make of the phenomenon?

I think it's very interesting. So for example, when you're on the internet and you want to learn about something, but you don't want other people to know that you're learning about it, you can do that, right? Yeah, so you can try to peer into the world of glass blowing or beekeeping or what do these people think about this different political viewpoint that I don't want my friends to know I might secretly hold. You can kind of peek into those windows and you can see things like that.

I've listened to your sermons on your website, on your church's website, I've listened to that. Thanks. And I'm assuming a lot of other people do that too, they kind of peek into your world there. So I think this is a really interesting thing to peek into matters of faith in a way that's not as like, oh, well, what do I wear to go to your church?

Kind of thing, you know what I'm saying? And I found it interesting that the first thing this person said in the video, they're talking about, well, what do I wear in Avatar world when I go to VR church? And so that told me right off the bat what these people were thinking, like how am I supposed to act when I'm at a church? Because I want to do the things I'm supposed to do, but I don't know how to do it and I don't know what to ask.

So I think in that respect, this is beautiful, right? I agree. I mean, it's beautiful. It takes all the social awkwardness, I don't know what to do, where do I go?

It takes all of that and then just does away with it. And this guy, this VR, I really want to talk to this dude, I don't know what his name is. It's just a really interesting way to handle it. But another thing that I think is interesting about it is, I believe that my faith is not of this world.

And so for example, there's a lot of people that disagree and they're like, well, you have to go to this specific place in Jerusalem and touch this wall and this physical thing is tied to you. You know, like when all those idiots in the ISIS guys, they were destroying all these holy sites. Boy, that ticks. Do you remember this?

I think do I remember it. Oh my goodness. Yeah, we watched National Treasure last night. It's from 2004.

So I guess, spoiler alert and this is for National Treasure. You get to the end and they find the treasure room and even the few things I was able to make out. Whoa, that's amazing what they're trying to tell me was in this treasure room. And I wonder what else was in there.

And I started thinking about all of that stuff and how hard it is to preserve and my mind went right to ISIS. Did it really freakin' Jackwagons. What on earth is your problem? Don't care how much you disagree, leave it alone.

It's one of our few points of connectedness to what people thought before us. I mean, leave it there so that you can point out how your ideology triumphed over it even if you want to. Jerks, just don't blow it up in bulldoze. Every single image I saw of that as a historian, just with everything that I believe, it turns my stomach, yes, I remember.

Yeah, so I don't know. If you tie your faith to anything physical in the physical world, then I don't know, it somewhat cheapens it to me. And so to me, it's hyper interesting that my faith, in the most real way exists in my heart and my mind and this VR church seems to reflect the ultimate in goal of my faith. Because for example, I don't know if you're tracking this, but when the first Muslim went to the International Space Station, you know they have to face Mecca when they pray, right?

How do you do that? Well, yeah, yes, I do know that. Yeah. Yeah, so when you're orbiting the Earth, X number of times a day in your Muslim, and by the way, have you ever been to a nation where the Muslim call it a prayer happens?

Have you ever seen that? Yeah, absolutely. A few different places. How did that feel to you?

Did you see it? Yeah, we stayed right next to a mosque. It's not really a minaret, but maybe you do call it a minaret. When I was in Israel last year, our first night was in Japa on the coast, and we stayed on the fifth floor.

This really, really cool presidential spot we got on Airbnb. And I mean, I could literally have thrown a tennis ball from the roof where I was sleeping and played catch with somebody on top of the, I don't know what you call it, the tower of the mosque where they played the prayers through the speakers. So it was right there, and boy, was it loud. We did not see that coming.

So my first response is it can be jarring, but even though I don't practice the same religion, I found there to be a lot to respect and appreciate about that level of devotion every time I've been in Africa or the Middle East and heard it, I guess that would be my impression. You? Yeah, it's interesting. The first time I experienced it in like mass form, like thousands of people at one time was in the Gambia in vengeful of the capital.

It was very interesting. You know, we're just walking along the street and boom. Suddenly everybody pulls out a rug, throws it down and the call to prayer happens. And it was jarring, if I'm honest.

I didn't know it was about to happen. And I was standing there upright and I was like, well, what do I do? I'm the only person standing. What do I do?

And I felt awkward and I didn't know how to act or, you know, well, am I allowed to continue walking? Is that disrespectful? I don't want to disrespect people. And so it was interesting because a lot of the emotions that I felt in that moment are probably shared by people and they try to visit the church for the first time or something like that.

So I just thought it was in Canverify. Yes. And I can see it from the front. Yeah.

And so when it comes to the first astronaut that went up to the International Space Station, I believe this was the first one. I'm not 100% sure. But it was a group of people that got together, I believe, I don't want to mess this up. I believe it was in Malaysia.

And they said, well, what are we going to do? And so in Malaysia, they convened a conference of 150 scientists and scholars to try to figure out these questions. This was back in the early 2000s. And I actually have a document open here on my computer.

And it is a guideline of performing Ibada at International Space Station. I think I'm saying the word correctly. I'm not 100% sure. And so they are Ibada.

I don't know how to say it. But they created a multi-page document telling you where to look. And it's an interesting thing. So when you tie your faith to physical places, it seems like you're limiting it to me.

Ah, I see where you're going to go now. Yeah. And so I think the idea of VR Church, do you think it's the final form of church? I hope not.

Why? I will say this. I don't think people should not do it. I see the beauty in what you're describing.

I understand the value. But I don't think it's complete. I don't think you can do the things the church is supposed to do, redemptively and in service to the world fully from that platform. I think we are physical beings that exist in a physical world.

And if you think that there's an actual first cause that decided that it would be better for there to be something instead of nothing and initiated the physical laws of the universe and that being thought highly enough of the physical world or valued enough that he took on flesh, as Christians believe, and was here for a period of time and suffered an actual physical death and rose from the grave. I mean, that's a lot of the physical coming into play. And trying to divorce ourselves from that entirely. I don't think it's a complete expression of who we are as humans.

I have the theological concern that I think it's just incomplete. Good. It's just incomplete. Just like 10-minute Bible hours incomplete.

Don't go to church on 10-minute Bible hours. Weird. It's not what it's for. Do people do that?

Do people tell you they do that? I think people are well-frag to tell me they do that because they know what I think. And they know that I'm going to be like, yeah, go to church. Mom, church is your sock.

Yeah, maybe. I don't know. Try anyway. Make it better.

That's part of what we do is we figure out how to interact with people. We don't get along well with. It's part of faith. But I also think even apart from the theology of it, I just don't believe that's how humans are built.

I think we have physical bodies for a reason. And I think they matter. And I don't think we can divorce ourselves from that and still feel complete in our relationships. So I think it's a good idea.

I don't think anybody's a police that are corrected. I think it's cool. I just think it's something that will gradually feel a little bit hollow for adherents who aren't complimenting that with real world stuff. But you know, I've always been skeptical of the bucket heads.

OK, buddy. We're going to meta for just a minute. It's like tone change here. Why do you like doing this podcast?

I don't know. It's because we get to talk about really weird things. And I feel like I can be, I don't know, the weird word is vulnerable. But I can ask whatever and have honest conversations.

And I don't have to worry about people judging me or you judging me. I don't know. This sounds weird. I'm constantly talking about feelings.

That's so strange that you don't notice it. It's probably because of the phone distance between us. That's probably it. No, I agree.

I agree. That's part of the fun. I follow you around the internet quite a bit. You follow me around the internet quite a bit.

I feel like you are the same everywhere. But I also feel like you maybe feel a bit more permission than usual to engage with people who are part of this channel. Is that a fair statement? That is.

On Smarter Every Day, I'm very guarded with what I say at certain times here on the podcast. And I feel like you might be the same way. I feel like this whole community, this note of questions, whatever we want to call it, I really like it. Because the main thing is on Patreon, for example, the people that support on Patreon often do not feel the same ways about certain things that I do.

And they tell me that in comments. And it's awesome. You've noticed these in the comments, right? Yeah, I really have.

And we've talked about the whole idea thought ghetto thing that is forming up around the internet. People get mad and hurt. You have to be in a certain tribe. You have to think certain things.

They retreat into somewhere that's safe. And then we just lob bombs at the other thought ghetto from far, far away. And then never the twine shall meet. And it's horrifying when they do.

But the weird thing about this, and what makes me like engaging with it so much, is that I just don't think we're there. I don't think it's a thought ghetto. I think it's full of all kinds of weird people, with weird different ideas. We put up with my weirdness and my weird ideas.

I mean, obviously not you. Your ideas are all the ones that are good and right. And we're aggressive. My ideas are correct.

We have to accommodate each other a little bit. And I just think that's bizarre that I think you took a cross section of our patrons. It would be a very, very bizarre thing for cultural anthropologists to try to figure out how that happened. I agree.

Yeah. So I think it makes sense just to say thank you to the patrons, who don't think the same things as Matt does on certain topics about libertarianism and all your things that you think of. There are some people in the world who don't think those things. People that don't feel the same way about bidets as Matt Whitman.

It's the one place where I might draw the line. Or for me, I mean, a lot of people think very different things about the world than I do. And still, when I read the comments on Patreon, it's clear that you get what we're doing here. We're just trying to have an open, honest conversation.

And we're dropping the guard a little bit. And we're being, can I say vulnerable? Or does that make me feel like I can't be feeling so? This is the stuff that informs how we think.

For better or for worse. And sometimes it's for worse. But if you really want to know somebody and have an honest conversation, all that stuff is just part of the equation. It's part of the package.

Yeah. Where people get that. And this community is mature. I guess the way to say it is thank you patrons for being well adjusted enough to want to support something that you may or may not agree with in different times.

I know there's no one that agrees with everything. You think or everything I think. I don't agree with you. Susan D.

Whitman does. She doesn't like a lot of your remarks. Oh, is she ever does your mom ever say like that? Yes.

And he's just so he's just the fastest and times. Well, first of all, Susan D. Whitman is not a southern lady. Oh, actually, she's not.

No, she is. I don't even know how to do it. She's just out in Northern her who can handle all that. Oh, don't you know.

No, that's only in Lena jokes for North Dakota. No, from Wyoming. We just sound like people. OK, normal.

Everyone else sounds wrong. Whereas I sound like an inbred hick. I understand which you're trying to implement it. It's amazing how much gap I left between those lines that you could exploit.

No, you're reading exactly right. Break it back. You think you're a lovely young man. OK, so anyway, the point is thank you, Patrons, for supporting the podcast, even if you may not agree with what we're talking about here at any given day.

Thanks for helping us figure all this out. Right on, patreon.com slash no-no questions is where people do that. Thanks, everybody does. Thanks to everybody's like, nah, I'm not going to support stuff on the internet at all.

But you're just here. We love having you here, too. Thank you, everybody. That feels like an excellent segue to start talking about touching each other.

It's going to get way as you couldn't phrase that any other way. We just need to get onto it now. It's a good talk about that. We're relieved.

Have you and Camilla ever done the longest relationship thing? Yeah, we did a year apart when she was working as a DJ. Did you know that Camilla was a country music DJ? What?

A country music DJ? You didn't know this. You didn't know this. When was it?

It was so fun. I like it when we discovered new things. She was a country music DJ in high school and college. I wish she could see my face right now.

This makes me so happy. So I had a country music phase in my life for about two years. And there's this little who was popular when you did that? Oh, this was in, well, obviously, like Randy Travis.

And this is when some weird people were coming onto the scene, like Tim McGraw, it's when they were first starting. It was just like the little period of time. But I still know those songs. Those are the country music songs I know.

We just need to talk about country music sometimes. Today is not the day. Yeah, you got to go. But sometimes, like that's like, no, no, not even because of that.

It's because we're on another topic. And that rabbit hole is so deep. Yeah, for another time. But she was a country music DJ.

And she first worked at a country music station in the Bohemian Alps of Nebraska, where everybody was from a part of the world that loved polka. So she played country most of the time. But she was also responsible for Kansas City Royals games and polka night. And so she also knows a tremendous amount about polka.

What? And I don't remember what was it. Was she interning at a radio station or something in Mead, Kansas, KJIL, maybe it was called? And we had to do the maybe sophomore junior year of college three or four months by distance.

And yeah, so yes, I've done it. And it was different. And it was tough. And I'm glad that now we share home.

Yeah, there's something about, even if I'm working really late and stuff like that, it's something about crawling in bed with my wife, even when she's asleep and rolling over and just getting her a little pat on the shoulder, or driving somewhere with my wife and reaching over and holding her hand, or hanging out with your buddies and giving them a physical fist pulse. Oh, got it. Yeah. I don't want to hold your hands.

I did hold hands with Brady to tell you this. I bet he rolled with it. Oh, he totally did. We went skating, like roller skating in New York.

And he was in town. I was like, dude, you want to come to this party? I can totally get you in. And it was so funny.

What did you guys skate to? What song was on? There was tons of different songs. And I was enjoying it.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 8 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on June 14, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.