So you and I make YouTube videos and I don't want to feel too self-important by talking about the YouTube thing, but I think there are huge implications for the future of society based on these algorithmic changes. Would you agree with that? I absolutely agree. And I don't think that's an understatement at all.
We have seen seismic shifts in the history of culture and thought based on a new mechanism coming into play or a new use for that mechanism. So no, I don't think it's self-important to talk about the medium because I think the medium is really affecting things. Yeah. And when you said that, were you thinking about the printing press?
Well, yeah, that's one of many. Sure. Okay. I could go clear down the rabbit hole with you on how that changed things in more subtle ways than you usually talk about.
But I think you get it. Yeah. But YouTube is different. I think YouTube is very different because when YouTube itself came to the scene, you had or social media in general, really, you had this way that you could communicate with people.
It was like a new printing press. But the thing that's different about this than, you know, back in the day, Gutenberg and everybody is that the distribution of all this information is throttled by someone and that someone is the person that owns the company or the people that own the company that controls that social media platform. Whereas in the past, it was throttled by the amount of paper you could get, how quickly you could disseminate that paper, how far the distribution reach could be, and a little bit what the owner of the printing press was willing to allow to, you know, to put ink to paper on. Right.
And so the algorithm that you hear everybody talk about or the way in which a piece of content that someone makes for the internet is distributed to people who have elected or not elected to see that content made by that particular content creator, that is becoming a more and more important thing in today's society. It's influencing the political landscape. It's influencing how people think. It's influencing how people, you know, fix things.
It's a big deal. People who do what you and I do in private conversation speak about the algorithm in the same reverent hushed tones that people use to talk about God. They do. They actually do.
People pray to the algorithm. People theorize as to what the algorithm might want, want to sacrifice what thumbnail, what click through rate does the algorithm need to be pleased? How does the algorithm show its favor to you? It's getting weird.
But you know, it's interesting. Have you ever heard of that experiment? Derek mentioned it in his video. And this is something that a lot of us have been talking about.
Derek from Veritasium. Yeah, Derek from Veritasium. He made a really good video that unveils how he feels like the algorithm is working. And I think more than anyone, he is testing ways to be effective using the algorithm, you know, to his advantage.
And one of the things he talked about in this video was the result of a conversation that he and I had had and he and I and other people have had in the past about this pigeon experiment. Have you ever heard about this pigeon experiment? Help me out. So basically you have these pigeons in a box and you have this button in the box or something like that.
If the pigeon hits a button and out pops a little bit of food and the pigeon gets food, right? So they would then imprint on the button, right? And they're like, oh, okay, I want food. I hit the button.
Got it. Understand it. But there was this other experiment that was performed where they had the button in the box and they would randomly put food into the box with a pigeon. And depending on what that pigeon was doing at the time and the box randomly, like if he was walking across the button or if he was turning around in a circle in the corner or if he was bobbing his head a certain way, whatever the pigeon was doing as this random input or stimulus via food came into the box, they tried to replicate the behavior they were doing in order to win the favor of this magic food God that would give him food.
Yes. Yeah. Okay. I have heard about this and wow.
That has implications, right? Well, yeah. And the place where I've seen that play out and I won't go far down this road, but it's in your swing in baseball. Baseball is such a superstitious game.
Like don't rub somebody else's jersey when they're on a history. Don't talk this on one if they're throwing a no hitter. Like what exactly did I do when I stepped into the box? No, Mark Arcy Apara has to adjust his batting gloves the exact same way every time.
And of course it's nonsense. But on that 1% chance that it's not nonsense, the human brain will say repeat it. And if you didn't, it's easy to blame not repeating the silly thing for being a part of the game. So it's not just pigeon brains.
This is us too. Well, it goes further than that. Like during World War II, the Army or whatever the armed forces component that flew airplanes at the time was as they flew over islands in the Pacific, they build these big runways and they would land and all this stuff would come in. And you know, you had these, these different things on the airstrip.
And I've read stories and heard from people of some Marines in Hawaii specifically talk about in some of these places that they go, the indigenous people would build airstrips or things that look like airstrips like wind socks and things like that. They saw airstrips because at some point in time, airplanes were landing and bringing precious cargo and new things that they hadn't seen before. And so they thought, well, obviously the airstrip had to be here in order for the airplane to land. So let's just build an airstrip and more of these magic aircraft will show up with goods that we want.
If this than that. Yeah, exactly. So anyway, all this to all this to say, I feel like at times as a content creator on the internet, I can be a bit like the pigeon and I can start to try to figure out, you know, what's going on in order to please the algorithm. And we had to debate the other day and you were included in that discussion.
And I just want to, I want to turn over cards here and just let everybody know it wasn't a crisis moment, but it was an important moment. I created this video with Trent about grain bins and over the course of a year, we went out to this farm in this remote city in Alabama and we would record the process of building a grain bin and then the farmer harvesting the soybeans in this case, filling the grain bin and then selling them at a certain elevated price based on the basis price at the time. Which should have been relentlessly boring. Yeah.
But instead, it's one of the most fascinating videos you've ever done. I mean, if that thing were airing on PBS, you'd win an Emmy for it. It's excellent. Thanks, dude.
Appreciate that. We worked really, really hard on it. We worked with us, digested all these mounds of mounds of footage that we went through Trent and I. It's been a lot of time going back and forth.
Long story short, we worked really, really hard on it. And so we finally got to the point where we were going to upload the video to the internet and we had two questions that we have to ask. What do we name this video and what thumbnail do we create? And the reason this is so important is because we've spent a year working on this, not like 100% of the time of year, but you get the idea.
Sure, sure. A lot of brain space and everyone into this. Clearly. But you have to boil all that down into one thumbnail and one title.
And so we're talking about it and we said, oh, you know what YouTube likes? What if we were to lay down in grain and just have our face exposed? It would be really interesting because it would be a human face in this grain and you wouldn't know what's going on and it would look like, you know, we could call it something like, how do you store seven billion beans, which is how many soybeans this thing can hold? Yeah, we can do it.
But you know what I didn't like that thumbnail. Yeah, you didn't like that thumbnail. When I first asked the farmer if I could take a picture like that, he was like, that's a bad idea. I was like, why?
He was, well, people dying grain dens all the time by getting suffocated by the grain. That's just not a good idea. And I'm thinking to myself, well, you know, you're right, farmer, but at the same time, we want people to understand how important your job is. And I'm wondering a little bit, we were, I'll just call it a moment of weakness.
We're like, maybe we should bow to the magic algorithm and we should do this clickmate thumbnail. And immediately as the video is processing, Derek from Veritasium uploads his new video, Can You Swim in Shade Balls, which is a very interesting video. Yeah. You know, it asks a lot of questions and it's a follow on to his other video, you know, why are there shade balls on this, on this reservoir?
And what do you think the thumbnail was? Did you say the original thumbnail you had up? It was him laying in a gigantic floating pile of shade balls with just his face exposed. Right.
Yep. And then we had a discussion and then immediately his thumbnail pops up and it's we instantly saw, oh my gosh, it already has 600,000 views in like an hour. This is going to the moon, right? The algorithm has chosen that this is the video.
It's just going to go crazy. And we're like, we can replicate that thumbnail and we know how to. And so we talked ourselves out of it and you were in the room and we said, well, I mean, we could do it. And you heard all the discussions.
How do you want to describe it? I'm trying to. Well, you put all this work into this video. You want people to see it.
You want people to appreciate what farmers do. And yet you are enormously conscious in your videos and everything you do on the internet about how you present things and not wanting to put stuff out there that someone could watch in part and get a bad idea and go do something and hurt themselves or someone else. So the way I would read it is you were in a catch 22 having lived in Nebraska for a long time. My role in the room was to play games on iPhone and pound the table for don't do it, dude.
You're trying to make a video that's a love letter to farmers about how awesome they are. And if the thumbnail is a picture of something that will make them all cringe, it kind of defeats the purpose. Right. But I can only mention it was interesting for you just to watch all that because you were kind of external.
You hadn't put the time into the video. Right. You knew the fact that farmers die in Greyman's all the time, but you also saw the struggle and what's interesting is you actually understood it because you also create content for the internet and also spend the vast majority of time trying to figure out thumbnails and titles like the videos, the easy part anymore. How do I get these two microscopic little things?
It's dumb little picture and a few words worth the title. And that's my chance to get somebody to watch it. The algorithm will offer it up. They've right up the bat.
People aren't into it. Then this really important thing that I think is really important. And in my case could bridge the gap between people who don't like each other and be a step toward peace and better understanding and redemptive stuff. And so what do I do?
Do I go clickbaity and do things that are kind of ridiculous and over the top with the title and the thumbnail, maybe even a tiny bit deceptive to get people in the door. It would be very easy to justify that in my brain in order to say, well, if I don't get them in the door, they won't encounter this redemptive message. It'll be good for people who believe all kinds of different things. But at the same time, I don't really want to make a disingenuous title or thumbnail.
And so I don't do you want to be effective or not? How far are you willing to go in order to be effective? Yeah, I wrestle with it all the time. So you saw it play out and you saw the very intense conversation that happened and you saw that we ultimately decided to go with just me and a grain ban throwing grain in the air.
Which I liked. That was a nice picture, not as effective for clicks but a nice picture. Yeah. So we did it.
These are the thoughts we're having. The video performed well. It's got over 2 million views, which is good for me. That's cool.
Yeah, that's good. Immediately after that happened, I called Derek and said, Derek, we're struggling with all this stuff. And I don't like the brain space that I'm in. I feel like these same competitive pressures are why peacocks have bright feathers.
I mean, I feel like this is why some people feel like they need to surgically augment their bodies. I mean, this is a weird brain space that I don't do in any other aspect of my life, but I'm doing it now. And Derek, you're playing the game really well. And we all know that.
Would you mind coming on Node-Am questions and talking to Matt and I about it? And thankfully, he said yes. I think the cool thing about it is that all this happened while you were in the room. And so you and I were physically co-located for this episode.
Yeah, which is always a bit of a trip when we get started. But what can you do? Yeah. And to be clear, we are recording this episode that you're about to listen to with new equipment that we hadn't quite figured out.
Road gave us a new recording device called a roadcaster. And this is us working through the quirks of trying to figure it out. We actually love it. But at this point, we like their products in general.
I mean, that's what we use for our both e-mics on top of cameras. And it's what we record the podcast on all the time with their USB mics. Yeah. So this is us trying to figure it out so any bad things that happen are us not knowing how to use it.
Yeah, it's not a reflection on the equipment because I think we've got that dialed now. But anyway, let's go talk to Derek from Veritasium and a big thanks to Derek for jumping on the channel with us. Yeah, interesting subject. Let's get after it.
Okay. This is a very special episode of Notum Questions. We're physically in the same place. I don't know what to do with my face.
Yeah. So what do we do? Do I look at you? What do I do?
I kind of want to go across here at this angle and I know that's not right. We are not professionals. We don't know what we're doing. Okay.
So for the first time ever, we're actually going to record this video and put it up on YouTube. Yeah. And so the YouTube channel, YouTube.com slash Notum queues, I think it is. Yeah, high risk, low reward.
There you go. Good idea. But more importantly, we have who I'm going to call the king of YouTube at least right now. That just gets, yeah, today.
Derek Mueller from the YouTube channel Veritasium or as, how do we say it? Are we actually going to do this? Are we actually going to talk about what I don't, I think it's very fascinating. I think I've already, yeah, I think I've always identified that properly and there's nothing to discuss.
How's it going, Derek? It is going very well. Thank you for having me. I'm sorry I called you Dirk from Bad to Tubbly.
I'm in the first episode of this podcast. Yeah, that's all right. I'm going to be in time in my life and something's happened. I'm not proud of it.
I'm over it. I'm good. So Derek, what's been going on? We, full disclosure, we have no idea how to do a podcast.
We're in the same room together. So we're really trying to do this. And it's not working out well so far. I'm excited to witness this.
This is a historic moment and I'm delighted to be your remote guest for this special episode. So there's a couple things I'd like to talk to you about. We've been wanting to talk to you for quite a while. Number one, you have been doing a lot of research on YouTube lately.
And number two, I just want to throw the ball around about being dads at some point. Because I've witnessed an amazing transformation in your life over the last couple of years. And I've really enjoyed it. So what do you want to hit first, man?
I'll take anything you got. Yeah. You said doing a lot of research on YouTube. What's the direct object there?
Because I think everybody presents their research on YouTube. But Derek's been actually doing research on the subject of YouTube. Right. Which was enormously helpful.
How's that video done? The one with the flippy cards? Yeah, the flip chart video about how to go viral or why my video went viral. It did pretty well.
It did surprisingly well. Because I didn't know that you didn't know that you didn't know that many people. Yes, behind me there was a flip chart that I actually hired someone to make because I'm in no way an artist. So if I tried to make that, it would be totally illegible.
So I worked with an artist animator for four days to actually make the whole flip chart. So that was an experience. But yeah, I think the video has been well received. And I've definitely got a lot more people getting in contact with me over this video.
You can have a video that does 10 million or 30 million views when people don't necessarily reach out to connect. So many people have been reaching out to say how much this meant to them and that it resonated with them. And particularly a lot of YouTubers are saying that. So I guess that's nice to hear that we're all sort of going through the same thing.
That was really what I was trying to do there was put my experience down in some way that made sense. Well, I guess to frame it, the whole idea here is you made a video to try to explain the YouTube algorithm and how it works and how we as consumers of the algorithm interact with it and we as creators of content interact with it. Is that how you interpret the video? Yeah.
I'm not charged with the video though. Is that how you interpret the video? For sure. I mean, I think we live kind of within the medium of YouTube, which makes the idea of how does YouTube work and how did those workings affect the platform?
I think that makes them like central everyday parts of your life. There was this phrase, the medium is the message, which goes back to a Canadian professor in the 1970s. And I feel like I always kind of studied that and never understood it. Really like, what does that mean?
What is he talking about? But now that I'm a YouTuber and I've spent like nine years making YouTube videos, I feel like I've got a whole different appreciation for what does that mean? The medium is the message. And I guess the bottom line for me is that the way it seems is that the fundamental machinations of YouTube, like the algorithm, determine what content is on the platform and what audiences watch it.
And like, what is the character of YouTube? What is the soul of YouTube? That's actually not determined. I would argue by the audiences or the creators.
It's determined by the platform itself, which I think is a really crazy idea and something not a lot of other people acknowledge, which is why I wanted to make that video and sort of highlight these things that have kind of been driving me crazy and see if anyone else agrees, I guess, with how I see it. Marshall McLuhan. That's the guy, right? Marshall McLuhan.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
The extensions of man, I think. Ooh. Fine work. Yeah.
So once you see that, you start seeing everything through those lenses. And so you start thinking, okay, television requires X number of ad breaks. Clearly they figured out where the two curves align for maximum amount of ads that can be present for maximum revenue. If you're talking like, you're watching ALF in 1985.
You're going to see 22 minutes of ALF and you're going to see eight minutes of advertisement spread over what, four breaks and then one on each end. And so then you go back and you watch reruns of, I don't know if you can actually, I don't know if ALF is actually out there, but I should have picked something more accessible. You go back and watch that and you understand that the storytelling is stunted and abbreviated and even the jokes are crafted around that economic reality of just how money worked on TV in the 1980s. And I guess I just hadn't thought about that to that McLuhan level that you brought me to in the video about YouTube.
But what's weird is as you pointed out in the video, they keep changing it. And you know, maybe we get why that happens. We can talk about that more. But you get us all to a place where we're thinking about we were crafting our media or our message around the constraints of a certain type of media.
You change those ground rules. We find out about that. It's almost like it rewires our brains every time the algorithm changes. Is that an overstatement?
I don't know that it rewires our brains, but it definitely shifts, I think, how we make content. And maybe that is, you know, in the long term leads to rewiring. You know, I think one of the things that drove me nuts was this idea that videos that get a lot of views are better videos because that's the public perception, right? When I had this video that did 30 million views, I had people emailing me to be like, Whoa, Derek, you know, great video.
You really nailed it. And it's not that I didn't think my video was good because I think it was. I think it was a good video. But I don't think like the views were proportionate to the quality.
You know, and I think about other really good videos that don't blow up. And I guess, you know, it's easy when you have like a bad video to say, well, the algorithm sucks. It should have done like this video should have done better. But I think we have a video that blows up.
Like that's that's the time to say this algorithm is a bit weird, you know, it's working wrong. We actually had a conversation about you today, Derek. We, um, yeah. So Trent and another guy we we work on videos together and we were making this video about green bins.
And right before we clicked upload, we're sitting there struggling about what thumbnail to put on the video. And we're also thinking about what title and all these things. And right before we clicked upload, your thumbnail pops up. The latest video, can you swim in shade balls?
Is this the name of the, is this the name of the video? That is the title of the video. Yes, sir. Okay.
So, so here's the deal. We watched that video and you have to understand to make this grain bin video over the course of literally a year, we went out to my buddy's farm about an hour away. We worked on a crew for a week to build this grain bin, went out there, filmed the harvest, loading the grain bin, unloading grain bins, a lot of work. And when we watched your video, which was excellent, let's admit it was excellent, um, it was interesting because I could tell you were doing things because I know you're a freaking genius.
For example, did the video need to be 10 minutes and 34 seconds long or whatever it was? That's a good question. I was sort of torn about how long to make it, but I don't know. It didn't need to be that long.
You tell me. I mean, my last two videos before this have been like 12 minutes and frankly, if I could have made this one 12, I would have done it. I had some other footage, but I was just like, you know, it doesn't frankly, so I feel like I was pretty judicious with like 1040 was basically where it came out. And I was like, you know what?
That's okay. Can you explain to me the thought process because you did something I did not do for the video I made. I didn't think about how long the video should be. I was just like, this is how much content I have and I threw it out there.
What is yours coming out? 17, but I had an ad in mind and you didn't, right? And you're so abrupt. Yeah.
It was over and then it was a Patreon. So thank you by the way. So genius, by the way, you're going to sign these shade balls and you're going to support veritasium on Patreon, everyone. I mean, that is a killer smart move, man.
I mean, we people support, no questions on Patreon. It's a huge, it's huge to not have to be tied to that revenue like that. So congratulations on doing that. Thank you.
I got to say, I guess this is sort of, there's a strategic approach that I'm taking right now towards trying to insulate veritasium from shocks of whatever sort of changes in the algorithm or changes in my life or whatever. So I'm trying to make it so that if I want to keep making videos, I can keep making videos and they'll financially make sense. And if there's no sponsors or whatever, everything continues to make sense. So that's what a lot of these steps sort of play into.
And I wonder if this idea came to my head because of a conversation I had with you when I was talking about doing this viral video with you before I did it. And you were like, well, you got to talk about Patreon and push that because that could be a serious buffer for you if times get tough with the ad sense or whatever and allow you to keep making videos. And I was like, I feel like it's too much messaging for this one video. But then after my shade balls video blew up and people were asking, can you swim in them, I was like, oh, man, that's ridiculous.
But then I thought about it harder. And I was like, I'm in a position now where I can actually buy shade balls and they cost like $3,000. But I can do that. It's not crazy.
It's not financially ruinous for me. And then I was like, what do I do with the shade balls once I'm done? And I was just kind of stuck on that one night and the thought just popped into my head. Mail him to your Patreon supporters.
Sign him and mail him out. And I was like, I know that would be crazy. But if it drives a few more people to Patreon, like totally worth it. And hopefully those people stick around for the long run.
And so this is like, yeah, it's a big effort that I got to make right now. But sort of an investment in the long term. And it's also one of those things where I'm kind of paying it forward because you could pledge one dollar today. I'll still send you a shade ball.
But hopefully you stick around long enough to pay for the shipping. So that's sort of the hope. So Derek's a genius. Yes he is.
The way he handed out the shade balls at the end of that video to his patrons, genius. Yep. And just all of them. You and I both know that the balance of how we get funding here on the questions, the line share comes from the sponsors.
And so are we just going to blatantly steal his idea? I think we do it. We're not going to be not blatantly steal a brilliant idea. But here's the thing.
He sent out shade balls. You know what those are good for? Shading reservoirs. And you know how many it takes?
More than one. So here's what we could do that I think might have a little stronger application. We had talked about this enamel pin idea a while back. I think we just pulled the trigger and we designed and print up a crap ton of those winged hissar enamel pins.
Like the kind that you can poke through something like pulling your backpack or something. Yes. And you send them to literally everybody. So if you're a patron of the podcast, you get one.
That's how it works. Well, that was easy. Yeah. That was easy to deal.
I'm not going to address entered into patreon so that we know where to send it. But if that's the case, you get one. Yeah, this makes a little sense. And the way it works is we call everyone that listens to the podcast or the third chair and the patrons.
They're the people that have arrived in our time of need. And that is the winged hasars. So yeah, if you would like to arrive as a winged hasar, now is your chance. There's a link below.
You can go because it's a desperate race against the mind and race against time. Just pick random one person and send them a dollop of warm mayonnaise instead, just like an envelope like a standard mailing envelope, but like one spoonful of warm mayonnaise and then just look it and seal it and send it just one person. No. And I think he might have detracted from everything we just tried to do.
It's so fine. No mayonnaise only pins. Ignore what Mad just said. Everyone who signs up will get an enamel winged hasar pin.
Have you thought about how we're going to mail these out? Have you thought about that? No, we'll figure all of that out later. That's what that's how responsibility works.
There is a logistics nightmare that's going to happen after this. Yes, there is. It's going to be horrible. No, you're out.
It's going to be awesome. Everybody's going to be officially if you want to officially be a winged to start this out of doing it. So go to patreon if you have signed up, be sure to get an address in there that we can get in the system because we're going to have to do some kind of mail merge thing to put addresses on envelopes or something. Oh, dude.
Then you'll be able to identify other people by the pin they have on their backpack. You will make random friends. And I'm not kidding, man. That happens.
Really? Yeah, that kind of stuff happens. I mean, two times last week I had somebody who made the connection. Yeah, and I'm telling you, it just comes up from time to time.
There are other asars out there. You will figure out who they are now. It's an identifying mark. Let's do it.
Thank you so much, all patrons for supporting in all seriousness. This is an attempt to just straight through the front door balance out how we financially pull the podcast off and we're trying to, I don't know, get eggs in multiple baskets so that we at any point in time are not subject to something not being put on the schedule, like a sponsorship, not hitting a certain month or something like that. This is an attempt to diversify. Yeah, it just keeps the energy and momentum rolling to hit a certain publication schedule and keep getting something done because I think it's a lot of fun.
I like doing it. And the weakest are thrived. I also think we should send a few people the pin and also like an empty manneh pack in a separate envelope. Like we should just do that.
You got the manneh's. I don't think this is going to work, man. I mean, the stars are going to arrive at the manneh's thing. Really?
I just want people to open that envelope and be like, I got my pin. It's just warm. It's just warm manneh's. Can I just say that for the last year, consistently your content has been my favorite content on the internet.
It started with the salt lamp video. He says that when you're not around. Well, thank you for saying because this is the utmost praise, you know. It is.
I'm such a fan of everything that you do, Dustin, that when it's not just, you know, it's one thing for, you know, a random stranger to say, I love what you do. It's another thing for you to say, you know, I love what you've been making. It means a lot to me. Or bros.
Yeah. So the thing I like about this relationship with Matt is, you know, it's rare for somebody to get in the inner circle and be able to like look you in the eyes and tell you that you suck at something or that you mess something up. Try to say nice with that. But so like Matt will give me very honest negative feedback and it's hugely important to me and you do the same with me.
And that's, I think having people that will give you that negative feedback is, that's a big deal. I think so. And so thank you for giving me all the feedback over the years. But I'm going to tell you something about me.
It's just bad, which I don't feel like I'm done. No, you don't. But you're willing to do it. Like you're honest and you're a man of integrity.
It's his barometer of friendship. It's like some kind of masochistic thing. It doesn't make sense for most people. But I want to tell, I want to tell you, well, so you guys are more similar than you know.
You're very, very different people, by the way. Like I'm kind of like in the middle of this friendship. I'm friends with you, but so you both think very differently about a lot of things in the world. But one thing that you're very similar on is this video you did recently, Derek, about film or video, I guess you could say.
And Derek has a PhD in teaching people with medium media. Didn't know that. Congrats. That's a lot of work.
And you did a master's degree on public broadcast. Who was it? Yeah, my first, wait, no, my second master's thesis was on the beginning of television in rural Nebraska. Wow.
1954. That is a topic. That is cool. Everybody was still alive.
Almost everybody was still alive. So I got all these old folks from nursing homes and stuff talking about the hijinks of being on air for the first time. And it was fascinating. Original research.
But yeah, no, I wasn't really going to go to that. They're still alive. That's awesome. It was fun to bounce it back and share it.
And it was also fun to hear all the things they asked me not to put in the document. Like what? Obviously, like what? You're not writing a document.
Ten years. I think that's fair game. They're probably dead. I think you automatically go to prison for a lot of the things that they said.
Oh, 2019. But back then, apparently it was okay. One of the things that they would do is there were three of the guys who were real Lucy Goosey and one of the guys who was real uptight and trying to imitate New York news media. And so these three guys would, they'd get all set up behind the desk from time to time.
And then Fancy Man would come in and he'd look over behind the desk on air and realize that the other guys were wearing literally nothing below the jacket. They were just naked. Yeah. And then this old guy describing whatever term they used to describe that state of being.
To be clear, Derek, I'm wearing pants. To be clear, I am not. Thank you for showing me that. Show me the correct.
It's like, why did I agree to be here? And then the Fancy Guy was getting all uptight on air. And so one of the guys I interviewed went over and just cut his tie right here. And I think somebody got fired over it.
It was a parting of ways kind of relationship thing. But it'd be like Mad Men just telling the story of this news channel in whatever hold region of Nebraska in the 1950s and all that went on. It was pretty fun. I was making some bigger important Fancy Sounding defensible thought that seemed academic.
But mostly I just like the stories about the male nudity behind the desk. But Derek, your PhD was on using video as a way to educate? Yeah. So it was really a way to try to merge what I wanted to do, be making videos or films or whatever, and science, which I was good at.
So I had this PhD that was, how can we use films to teach physics? So I spent three years essentially making films and testing them on students and seeing what worked better. What was your matrix for that? How did you know if it worked?
Well, we tested them before and after with these standardized tests. And try to look for gains. Did they improve their scores? So what worked best?
So the thing that I found worked best was explicitly discussing misconceptions. In the sciences and physics, misconceptions are a really prominent area of research. Because in your data experience in the world, you experience things like friction. And that kind of masks a lot of the fundamental physics that's going on there and the way inertia works and things like that.
So when you just ask about intuitive things, a lot of people get it wrong because they have these ideas about you need a force to keep something moving, for example. That's kind of intuitive. But that's only because friction's there. So if you look at friction of the equation, then of course an object in motion stays in motion.
So it's fine to, like we can learn to memorize those things. But it's very hard to change the fundamental conception of the universe to really take on a Newtonian view. So I tried out these videos where we'd explain it as clearly as we could. We'd use textbook explanations.
We would use animations. We'd use real world examples. We'd go through all this stuff like basically the best lecture we could give with all these multimedia. And then we'd test kids afterwards.
And we'd find that they were more confident in their answers. They would say, yeah, I think I learned something from that video. I really enjoyed it. And I'm more confident in my answers now.
If we looked at pre-to-post test, there was no movement. That they didn't actually gain any more correct answers on the post test than they did on the pre. Whereas a separate treatment we did where we pointed out, it's a misconception to think that when you throw an object in the air, there's a force in that ball that keeps it going against gravity. And then eventually it dies away and gravity balances it at the top and then gravity wins and the ball accelerates downwards.
We'd go through stuff like that and we would illustrate it without saying this is wrong necessarily. But then gradually we'd come around to the right idea and then we'd test the kids again. So we definitely had the possibility of really confusing these kids because instead of just seeing the right answer, they were seeing the wrong answer and then the right answer. And sometimes it was in a dialogue format was one of the things I tried where we didn't really say that this guy's always wrong and this person's right, but they kind of figured it out because the dialogue was reasonably natural.
And for novices, their score is almost doubled going to the post test. Now by no means do I think they're Newtonian reasoners now, but I do think that we've moved them somewhere down the path, which we definitely didn't do by giving them a really clear lecture-like presentation. So I'd say that was a big finding for my PhD. Do I understand correctly that you're saying you have to deconstruct what someone understands first before you can then relay the foundation of truth?
Is that what you're saying? It's interesting to put it that way because when I talk to a lot of teachers, they're saying to me, okay, Derek, so we need to blow up these misconceptions. And what I say to them is actually the misconceptions are so strongly ingrained that you'll probably never get rid of them. The best you can hope to do is actually use them as a foothold.
I kind of imagine it like scaling a wall or climbing a mountain or something. And it's like this misconception is just a place that is a really great hold. It's a place that people will want to come back to over and over and over. They'll always go there.
So instead of trying to get rid of that, just embrace it and sort of understand why it is. You think that you have to maintain a constant force to keep something moving at a constant speed because there are frictional forces opposing you. So you've got to learn that those forces are really equal and that's why you've got to keep applying that force. But if we were in space, then you could remove.
But basically, so you want to build the context around it. So I almost think of it like as planting a flag in those things as saying, you know what, you're going to come back to this. But remember, it's flagged to say like, this is a misconception because of how friction makes the world appear. And if we were in a friction-free environment, you would see something quite different.
So I always think about building around it, like build scaffolding around it that sort of honors these ways of seeing the world, which make a lot of sense and there's reasons why we think that way. But to go to a sort of a more foundational perspective, we need to build out these structures from there and sort of understand why that isn't and go from there. Does that make sense? Yeah, I'm tracking.
I think it's ludicrously insightful and surprisingly well aligned with what I do. I find what you guys do fascinating. I like to swim in those waters. What you guys do is my favorite subject is a high school kid.
But I went to college to play baseball and major in baseball and they didn't really do science, so I did history and philosophy. But the structure is, and I keep trying to convince Destin of this. The structures are not that different. Now you're talking about someone becoming a gifted Newtonian reasoning.
What is Newtonian reasoning? It's just the natural sciences of the classical world and the early modern age put into a more structured, more repeatable format so that you're putting some actual flesh and substance observations and assumptions that you're making from abstract reason about what you see. And so what's interesting about what you're saying to me though is that we kind of fall in love with those misconceptions. They provide us in some order.
They make us feel good. They make us feel like we understand the world around us and what happens when we do things. That's your phone. I'm going to drop it.
Yeah, yeah. Just leave my phone down there. But you get the point as to what happens when I drop my phone. But what's interesting is that is to hear you coming from a hard sciences perspective telling me that misconceptions is hurdle number one to learning because that's absolutely been my experience in dealing overwhelmingly in the realm of the abstract with theology, philosophy, history.
And I don't know. Do people get defensive when you push back on deeply ingrained misconceptions about the physical world? I think less so. I think when people have misconceptions about other things that they're deeply invested in or then they'll push back.
But when it's about the physical world, I feel like there's less vested interest or something. There's less of self invested in these things. And I think generally people are amazed and kind of excited when they learn the truth about the physical world. I've seen that so many times when I go out in my early videos a lot of what I did was talking to people on the street and just taking these things to them and showing them to scrap in events and then showing a way to resolve them.
So that was kind of one of the things that I love doing. A lot of people want me to keep doing it. There's only so many of those things that I could do. So I kind of run out of a lot.
But I think people do really enjoy it. Do you feel like a prop's more toward wonder than irritation? In other words, you're a deer in yourself to people when you push back on those misconceptions. I hope so.
And it also depends on how you do it. The place that I come from is not this place of I know everything and you're an idiot. The place I come from is most of the world doesn't know this but isn't it fascinating? And I love it so much that I hope that some of that love is communicated to them when I explain it or show it or do a demonstration with them.
I used to teach for about seven years at a tutoring company in Sydney. And some of my favorite moments, I would get chills down my spine when I was teaching. If I taught. Really?
Yeah. If I would get literal chills down my spine, one of the greatest moments when I could do this was when I showed that De Broly's wave assumption about electrons yielded mathematically through the equations, a divorce assumption that angular momentum of these orbits was quantized. So bores came from this totally. I'm a level leader guy.
I have no idea what you said. I almost feel like pulling out the equations right here. What were those words again? I really want to know what they are.
When I was teaching this, I used to give me chills to teach about bore basically coming in and saying the reason an atom doesn't just collapse into itself, the electrons don't just spiral into the nucleus is because maybe for some random reason their angular momentum is quantized. And quantized just means comes in multiples of a smallest chunk. Destiny, give me a funny face. So I'm going to say like money is quantized.
It comes in multiples of pennies. Every amount of money is in multiple pennies. So bore was just saying every amount of angular momentum is a multiple of the smallest amount of angular momentum, a quantum of angular momentum. And he was coming to that from this just like maybe this is the way it is.
He just like he was like ad hoc proposition. And then de Broglie came along years later and said maybe the electron is both particle and wave and it's wave length is given by this relation. And what's amazing is that if you look at the two equations you can rearrange one, I'm getting the chills. You can rearrange the de Broglie equation to look exactly like the bore equation.
So a result of having a wave like electron and wrapping it around to form orbits gives you the exact same equation as angular momentum is quantized. The fundamental gives you this physical interpretation for why angular momentum is quantized. It's because the electron fundamentally is a wave phenomenon. So they were both right.
Yes. They were seeing the same truth from a different perspective. Absolutely. I mean, De Broglie's was almost you could argue more complete because he had a physical picture of what was going on and he had this intuition into the nature of matter that no one had ever had.
And once he had that it all clicked, you know, it all fit. But again, we're back to that evolution from the natural sciences, which used to be, we call it philosophy, into the natural sciences as we think of it. Now where you actually have hard data in front of you have something to look at and work at and shoulders to stand upon. I mean, that's, it's not just Boer fellow.
What was he doing business? 1913 was the, was his model of the atom. Okay. Yeah.
I feel affinity with the kind of the abstract natural science minded people because when we do this, when we do this whole thing and you want to talk physics with me, it's really fun for me to try to guess how it works. But I don't have anything to draw on other than I've seen things happen and I'm trying to get it somewhere in the zip code of truth and reality. And then you give, you fill in the gaps with actual truth and reality because this is what you do and it clicks and it makes sense. But it would have taken me decades of study to be conversant in the physical realities we're dealing with.
But even an idiot like me can look at those basic phenomenon and kind of wrap my brain up. That's exactly what I was going to say. Yeah. So I don't know.
I didn't know this about you. I didn't know that, I didn't know that teaching gave you chills. I didn't know, I kind of thought that it was a secondary thing to your passion that was making video. It's really tough.
I mean, I didn't understand what he said earlier. Like all those words he said, like they were, I don't know physics like he does. I want to draw you some pictures, man. I don't know engineering like you do.
We all have like places that we spend a lot of time. I spent how many hours, how many times did I teach that lesson? 50 times maybe. It wouldn't have been crazy to teach that lesson 50 times.
I would frequently, because we had these really intense holiday periods where I would teach the same class three times a day and it ran for three hours. So I was teaching for nine hours a day. And I guess what excited me about doing that was like, yeah, the same thing, three hours, three hours, three hours. And every class would be another chance for me to hone that joke or get the from the class when they got that.
It was like a performance. So I loved acting. I did drama projects and teaching was like an extension of that for me. It's about communicating and presenting and inspiring and like all those things.
I want to form excitement in my audience. And in a way, YouTube is like an extension on that. So here's a question. So I've noticed, let me frame it this way.
You now just talk to me about how much you love to teach using YouTube and all this good stuff. But fundamentally, it's the teaching and the knowledge going from your brain to someone else's brain that really makes the chills happen for you. But I've noticed that you're starting to weaponize YouTube to great effect, right? After you and I were in New York and we were hanging out with Mr.
Beast at the creator summit, the gold jacket club, monocle club, gold jacket, monocle, blue pin club. That's right. Well, we were there. You and I had a conversation with Jimmy and we started talking about the stuff and we arrived at the CTR, the click through ratio, it gets above a certain percentage and you can get a view time of at least what is it, seven minutes, then you get a banger, right?
And so then it's going to go to more people. So the question is, how much do you change your content in order to get it to more people? I mean, this is something I can really see you struggling with right now and you're doing it very well. I appreciate you saying that.
I think that is the fundamental question is how much do you change to fit what's going to work for the system? You change too much and then what's the point in doing it in the first place? That's not what you signed up for. But you don't change it at all.
You stay small. You know, I think the biggest reason people don't watch, you know, certain channels is not because that channel's videos are not good or they wouldn't be interested in them, but because they just don't know about them. So I would argue that the number one problem we have is just exposure to audience. And that's where I think that you need to have some viral videos to crack that, you know, to expose yourself to a few more people who then will come along for the journey.
And that's what you need. Because what I do see is that channels that focus just on, this is what I want to do and I'm just going to keep doing exactly this again and again and again. They shrink over time. And that's not a position that I want to put myself in.
At the same time, I don't want to totally abandon my mission. So for me, okay, there's a great talk by Jack Conti called Adjust Your Packaging, which is essentially about deciding what is inside your box that you really care about and like these are the things that are essential to you and what is outside your box and is sort of the wrapping on it and the things that like I don't care about frankly, like, you know, we could change a lot of stuff and I still don't mind. One of those things for me is actually the particular pieces of science that I take on. So if taking on the science of shape balls is way more attractive to people than the science of say, salt lamps, then I'm okay with doing the shape balls, you know, like I find so much in this universe fascinating that I feel like if it's about what content that I choose to do, like I'm happy to make some different choices if I feel like that could yield a 10 just return in terms of, you know, who sees it or what new audience I could discover what I'm doing.
What I think is core, what I think is inside the box is that fundamentally this is good science, it is the truth as best as I can discern it and I'm communicating it in a way that I feel like is honest and good and can help people understand it. So I feel like those sorts of things like the way I do it are inside the box but sort of like what topic I'm doing, what the thumbnail looks like, I'm willing to negotiate on those things because like I'm not wedded to it. I don't know. So that's where I'm hoping to go.
At the same time, I think everyone has to realize that YouTube does change you a bit. And the way YouTube works does change the content. Like it does. Maybe it makes it better.
I don't know. What are your thoughts? So for the sake of our audience, for the sake of the third chair, this is Jack Conti, the founder of Patreon. Correct.
And more importantly, the electric keyboardist for Pomp and moves, correct? That's correct. And for the sake of Derek here, I just want to let you know a little bit about Matt. So Matt has a YouTube channel.
It's called the Ten Minute Bible Hour. I've seen it. I've seen it. I've seen you talking near a volcano.
Yeah, that happened once. Yeah. Okay. I believe it was inclement weather.
What's the inclement that you were there? Was it cladding? It absolutely was. And this I watched like I think well over a year ago, because I was, you know, whenever you guys started the podcast, I started looking into who is this Matt character.
You know, I've got to make sure my buddy has been hanging out with like, you know, good folk. Yeah. You've been doing that. Look at that form.
Yeah. So one thing about Matt's channel is it's a very, it's a very well produced channel. But one thing I noticed early on when we first became friends was he kind of made his bed and he was going to, he was going to lie in it. He's like, I'm going to make content like this.
And it was clear to me like, okay, this content will not by definition get massive engagement. You ain't joking. It's just not going to happen. Like doing Christianity on the internet is like suicide for trying to get engagement.
I just be suicide. Don't sugar go. Yeah. Well, first of all, it's not a fun topic to talk about on the internet.