Okay, buddy, this is a conversation I've been looking forward to. As always, when we read a book together or consume an audiobook together, we avoid discussing it and this book has been very hard not to discuss because this book was very powerful. And I'm talking about The Sun Does Shine by Anthony Ray Hinton, which he recommended to me. Yes.
First of all, thank you for this recommendation. Thanks for listening to it. Appreciate it. This was a powerful experience.
We can talk more about exactly how it was a powerful experience in a bit. But I guess before I ask you a question here, for the third chair, if someone has not listened to The Sun Does Shine by Anthony Ray Hinton, you should. But you don't have to do that to appreciate what this conversation is going to be about. Okay.
Why did you recommend this book to me? Well, it changed my life for many different reasons. I think the best way to start here is just to try to explain what happened to Anthony Ray Hinton and how he dealt with that. And then we can kind of unpack it.
Does that work for you? Yeah. And I want to put a disclaimer out with you, my friend. This book tripped my fury over injustice trigger like few things ever had.
And so I'm going to try to be composed and dignified and stuff during this conversation because I think that's important. But so much of the power of this book was the anger that he evoked in me. And I cried through a quarter of this book with my goofy Princess Leia headphones on, working in the yard, just bawling constantly. It wasn't the kind of crying where, oh, that's so beautiful and tender.
It's the kind of crying where I was just broken down by the cruelty and at a loss with anger at what happened to him. And so I'm going to do my best, man. But this book moved me in a lot of ways. And I'm still not quite sure what I'm doing with it emotionally.
Fair enough. Yeah, that's fair enough. I think you got to be careful with those emotions because I think a big part of like if Anthony Ray Hinton was sitting in front of you right now, I don't think he would want you to feel that way. You remember an Inters game where there's the hot anger and the cold anger?
Yeah. The hot anger, you're upset and you just like do stupid stuff, but the cold anger, you're cold and calculating and you figure out ways to fix things? Yeah. I think Anthony Ray Hinton would be more interested in creating that type of cold anger in you so that you strategize and figure out how to make things better.
And that is why I recommended the book. Neither of the things I feel fall into the category of cold or hot anger. It was a category of anger I don't know that I've ever felt before. And so it'll be fun to process this out with you in that regard because this is more than a book.
This is more than a book. This stuff happened. It's real. Yes, there's a story and the story is absolutely fascinating to consume, but this has implications.
And so you're trying to answer a question I already asked you. I'm going to bounce it your way again. Why did you recommend the book? Because it changed me.
It took me from like, oh, well racism might be a thing to hot dang. It's real and it manifests itself in these ways in our society. And these are things I can do to try to change them. And internally, it has set up like long term plans in my mind for things I want to do to affect these things.
Like I've actually started putting things in motion slowly. And those are those are for destined from 10 years from now to sort out whether or not I was able to accomplish those things. It's pretty serious in how it's affected me. So I just want to briefly explain what happened to Anthony Ray Hinton for the third chair and then we can get into it.
So whether or not you listen to the book or whatever, essentially what happened is Anthony Ray Hinton was wrongly convicted for murder. There was someone that was killed at a Quincy's restaurant. And I know it sounds silly, but even that mattered to me because I can remember eating at a Quincy's restaurant when I was younger. Really?
What were they like? They were kind of, you know, Ryan's steak houses. Have you ever eaten one of those or is that a original thing? Probably it's a middle class steakhouse that they had a salad bar.
I remember the salad bar and you know, after you ate, you could get some ice cream from the little ice cream machine. So it was somewhere in between a buffet, but they didn't have a buffet. They would bring you your entree, whether it was like chicken or a steak, but you got to go get a salad bar and that was just magical to me. And then there was like a family steakhouse that was not too expensive.
And they were all over the south. Okay. I can picture those. Yeah.
And they were not anymore. No, no, they're not anymore. I mean, they're the kind of place like you would order your steak and you'd get it medium-rare and they would bring you these little plastic pick things that were marked that your steak was cooked a certain way. So it was like a fancy meal for my family.
We were, you know, my parents were auto workers and they worked really hard to provide for our family. And so going to Quincy's was a big deal in our minds. We would do it like in holidays and stuff like that. Anyway, so this was how it went down.
Someone was murdered at a Quincy's restaurant. They were forced into the freezer, shot, robbed. And for some reason, Anthony Ray Hinton was convicted of this. He was at the wrong place at the wrong time.
And he had essentially angered a person that acted as a false witness against him. Yeah. A guy who didn't like the way Hinton conducted his business with a lady. Exactly.
But like Hinton, what was it that he dated as a sister? And along those lines. Yeah. And I mean, as a kid and this guy held a grudge and was basically willing to implicate him in the crime, even though the crime made absolutely no sense.
And this is when I started getting mad. More than that, Matt, it's not that it didn't make sense. He was across town. That's part of what I mean by doesn't make sense.
He was physically too far away to have committed the crime. And it wouldn't even have taken forensic analysis to figure that out. A calculator in 30 seconds was enough time to figure out. It was a physical impossibility.
Right. And so they decided that he fit the part. They decided to charge him with the murder. And his trial was awful.
Like during his trial, the prosecuting attorney basically had just decided that he wanted to kill Anthony Ray Hinton. He's really, that's the way we do need to be, I don't know, I don't want to say fair because we are fair, but because, you know, the all this is documented. But we need to try to figure out what you're saying here. Trying to retract the emotional energy when I say the following.
It seems as if the prosecuting attorney had decided that he had already wanted to convict Anthony Ray Hinton and he not only wanted to convict him, but he wanted him to die. How about this? Yeah. Emotionally restrained.
And then I'll just take another run at that my way. Okay. Cool. Go for it.
Okay. Here's what happened. The dude had no money. He made a really significant mistake.
He stole a car as a young man. And I get how that's going to be a blemish on somebody's reputation. You shouldn't steal cars from other people. That said, he owned it.
He did what he needed to do to square accounts and the way society works both legally and it should be personally is that after you've squared accounts, you've squared accounts. So he made the thing right, settled up. And for the most part, other than that, by his own admission, he's a dude who liked the ladies, but no account of him ever, you know, appropriately liking the ladies. That's what he described as like his one weakness, right?
He used that language. Yep. But not like any kind of creeper way. He's just a guy who liked to go out and try to connect with women.
That sounds like, I don't know, a lot of humans. That's it. Otherwise, there's really nothing to even look at to criticize him for. And so the idea that this guy is some hardened violent criminal is completely unfounded by the time this thing gets toward trial.
And then what made me furious from the get go is from the arrest to the initial incarceration to the initial hearing, the obvious data that anybody who's ever watched even a half an hour of a cop show on TV would know to go and collect was not only not collected, it was willfully ignored. You've got dust in the barrel of the gun that his mom owned. I mean, there's visible dust. And yet they're saying this is the weapon that was just discharged to kill a man.
That's insane. I mean, that is enough to not only acquit, but to just not even arrest the guy in the first place right there. You have the fact that he was checked in to his job, which was cleaning and working at a secure facility where he has to be checked in and checked out. And there's written record and witnesses that he was there, not at this Quincy's restaurant.
Nobody even bothers to check. And he's telling them, I was at work, you can talk to these people, you'll find out. And so the whole time, Hinton is acting like what mom, I'm going to be out of here in like 10 minutes, there's absolutely nothing. And then with each day that goes by, it becomes more and more evident that this is not about data.
This is not about the facts. And then he quotes some of the people involved in his incarceration on stuff that they said that makes it clear that they just picked somebody that was going to go down for this thing. The folks were scared because this was, there'd been a series of fast food, mid-range restaurant type robberies and they needed to make the public feel better and was going to pick this guy. And then on top of that, you know what?
Nope, this is going to be the last thing I'm going to say, I'm going to dial it down for a second. Because he doesn't have any money, they assign him this hack public defender who is, to me, the most frustrating character in the entire story. And the guy just won't do anything. Well, the quote that the defender, like Anthony Ray Hinton said, I was calling Anthony from here on, he said he heard him say under his breath, like, okay, well, you're going to defend this guy, you'll be awarded $1,000 by the court in order to do this.
And he said, I eat $1,000 for breakfast. I went and found Sheldon Perhax. He is scrubbed from almost everything in this story. Really?
Almost everything. This is all a matter of public record. He did these things. He is the guy.
He still practices law in Alabama. Does he really? Yeah. And you know what?
I hope this dude has come around. My life has been changed. I'm really glad I'm not who I was in younger years. So who knows how this guy has changed.
But what I do know is that the top review of his law practice is from some lady who says I eat $1,000 for breakfast once. No, it's not. It sure is, buddy. 16 equals.
Yeah, you'll notice it's a one out of five. I think if there was a zero out of five, 16 reviews Sheldon Perhax. And honestly, some people might be like, whoa, take it easy. Honestly, this guy right here had a man's life in his hands and stole whatever it came out to be 30 plus years of life from Anthony Ray Hinton by being complicit.
Not negligent, isn't even strong enough word. Complicit in what happened to him. And again, so I'm looking to the guys now. I hope he's changed.
But man, I do not like who he was back then. This is interesting. So I'm looking at all these reviews on him, on Google. And it's all these avatars of these smiling soccer moms.
I mean, it's out there on the internet. So Blair says, this man allowed an innocent man to go to jail. Aaron says, $1,000 for breakfast, zero stars. It's like these soccer moms are just like that one.
We're going to kill him. So what I'm saying is I don't know that Anthony would want that. I don't know that he would want it either. But I don't know that he wouldn't.
If the harshest penalty that Sheldon Perhax has to pay for what he did is some moms, 16 of them in total, said some mean things about him on the internet, I think he got the good end of that deal. Yeah, but I'm not going to go write a review. I'm not going to go pile on. Like I said, I hope he changes.
But that's what's so weird about this book is these aren't characters in a book. This all happened. I'm not going to say you're missing the point, Matt, but I think you're missing a thing that Anthony Ray Hinton is really trying to get across here. Like to me, the fact that this injustice happened is awful.
Okay. And we need to tell the rest of the story here in a second. But I want to remind you that part of his major message, Anthony's major message and he gets to he gets to say what he wants to say. He lived this.
Yeah, it is. I agree. One of the major things he's trying to teach me in the way that he's writing these words is to forgive people. Right.
Like he's trying to teach me the way that he's writing these words is to forgive people. But he's trying to teach me that. And so I agree. I think it's important to hear him when he says that.
I agree. And what I'm saying is in the whole story, which is about a miscarriage of justice and a warning to not miscarry justice in the future, the public defender system was the greatest failure. I agree. I don't think that in the name of forgiveness, I did not get the impression from the book that Anthony wanted people to overlook the realities of what went wrong.
Yes, I have some background information as well. I talked to somebody from the book, but I need to tell the rest of the story real quick so that third shares up speed. So he's convicted wrongly. He sent to jail.
There were appeals. Things didn't work out. He was up on death row. And that's a lot of years in between those two steps.
If I'm, how long does it take between the first conviction and he actually goes to home in prison in South Alabama? I don't remember the exact timeline, but he was on death row for 28 years. So yeah, it couldn't have been too long. When he's there in death row, he's meeting people and there's not a lot of capital punishment being carried through.
I mean, people, they're not in Anthony's words. They're not murdering people. The state is not murdering people early when he's there, but then it just really picks up. At some point, they just start executing people and these people that he knows.
Thank you for using that word, by the way. I like that he used that word and I like that you repeated it. It's his word. It's his word.
It's his word. It's not. I don't want to say that word, but it's his story. So I'm using his language.
What do you call it when you knowingly kill somebody under cover of a lie? Oh, yeah, that's murder. Yeah. They're trying to murder him.
Yeah. But the point here is some people in the story, I wouldn't say everybody was murdering in the story. There are people involved that certainly were trying to execute murder. Anyway, long story short, Anthony himself says, you can believe in the death penalty and agree that we should not do it because the state does not have the ability to 100% guarantee that a person is guilty.
He says that his words not mine. You know what I think about that. I do know what you think about that. Long story short, he's on death row for 28 years.
Somewhere along the way, this lawyer named Brian Stevenson gets involved and he takes on the case. He has an outfit called the Equal Justice Initiative here in Alabama. And basically, they have decided to defend people that everyone else has turned their backs on. If you are on death row, we are going to jump in and we are going to do our best to try to defend you.
Why? Because it's the right thing to do. And we think everyone should have access to justice. Brian Stevenson has another book called Jess Mercy that I highly recommend listening to your reading as well.
He actually voices himself, the audio version. So I would recommend that. It's many more stories. It's hard to imagine.
But this one case of Anthony Rehan here is just one of many cases that Brian Stevenson has handled throughout his career. That is staggering. It is. And every one of these has just crazy emotional things involved and it's worth listening to.
Anyway, that's what happened. He eventually got him exonerated, I believe is the word, of this conviction. They overturn some evidence in the case. And evidence that should have been sorted out before charges were even brought.
I mean, the most elementary level evidence. Is it seems along the way as if the judge is trying to suppress evidence from being brought to the light? And so it's generous of you to say seems there's no reason. I mean, here's the thing.
If you're going to kill somebody, you would want to consider every ounce of data up to the very last second that you kill somebody in any circumstances, legal proceedings, heat of the moment, anything. You want to gather every bit of data possible because you are going to kill somebody and it's very, very hard to unkill somebody and someone would argue it's impossible to unkill somebody. And so to me, that was another one of the real hot button moments in this is what are you people doing? Like, look, maybe he's guilty.
I disagree with the death penalty. Maybe this is something the state feels they need to do. I'm not in charge. I'm not in a position to stop you, but I need to at least believe that you look at everything to the final second to make absolutely sure you get this right.
When there was just stonewalling an obfuscation for years in considering new evidence that should have been considered at the very beginning. It looks like you're trying to murder somebody. It looks like you're trying to murder somebody when you do that. So one of the turning points in Anthony's case was this forensics expert that they had, this firearm expert, the first one.
Yes, the first one. They called him to the stand and this guy did not know how to work the microscope and the prosecuting attorney just destroyed him on the stand. He couldn't see well. He was a half blind expert.
Anthony got called him. Yeah, he had one functional eye. Yeah, it was awful. I actually called one of the experts in the later part of the book.
When Brian Stevenson got involved, I called, I forget the guy's name. I don't want to say it. There were several people involved. I found this one expert that used to work for the FBI.
He's retired now and I contacted him and I had a really cordial nice conversation with him. He did not want to be connected to anything publicly at all. And I just asked him about the case and I was like, Hey, would you be willing to, you know, I want to do a video on smarter every day about how forensics works? I want to talk about the gun.
I want to talk about this case. I want to see how this stuff works. He was like, well, no, not going to do that. However, what do you want to know?
As we talked, I said, what did you make of the state's like the state of Alabama, they have a forensics office, I guess it was a lab said based on what you know as an expert, what do you make of the case that was made in the early days of the Anthony Ray Hinton trial? And this guy was like the most professional person I've ever spoken to. He was like, well, he said, I will say this. I arrived at very, very different conclusions than what they came up with.
And I'm very interested to know how they concluded what they concluded. And so what he didn't do is he didn't throw another professional under the bus. He did not say that's BS and they did XYZ. And it's pretty clear that they're trying to cover somebody up.
He just walked in the room and he's like, I'm an expert. This is the way the things are. I'm not going to speak to that person's work. I'm just going to tell you what the truth is.
And that's the air of the conversation. What he didn't say and what I read in between all of the words was it was a bunch of BS, man. It was this way. And it was very clear and a child could have figured this out.
If they knew the state of the art and they understood the science behind it, like he didn't say any of that stuff and can't attribute any of that. But like, it was pretty clear. You know how it is if you're an expert in the field, you're like, yeah, I mean, it's pretty obvious. Yeah.
I mean, I'm not going to be in my field. There's just stuff that you recognize. Yeah. It's not tough if you've been around it for any period of time.
Yeah. So using the social spidey sense and listening to the things that weren't said, it was pretty clear that he was like, man, this was missed in a really big way. I don't know how, I don't know why, not attributing anything to anyone. But I do know that these are the facts.
And that's not what was said in court. I don't know, man. That was a frustrating phone call. Wait, why was it frustrating?
I mean, it was just just sad, just sad, the injustice of it all. Yeah. You actually have to fake science in order to arrive at the conclusion that was reached. You have to, like there has to be an element of deception in order to believe that he killed these people.
At some point, you have to cross this threshold and move from, oh, well, it could have been this to actively wanting it to be that. Yeah. And there's such a difference between, well, there could be different opinions on this. I don't like it when people say you're being intellectually dishonest to someone else when no, it's perfectly valid for someone to read that data this way or this way or this way.
On the other hand, intellectual dishonesty when it's real is one of the most obnoxious things ever. Have you ever been legitimately accused of something you didn't do? Um, I know I have because I felt that emotion, but nothing is coming to the surface right now. I know what's happened, but in the context of this book, no, no, no, no, well, sure.
I've got one that doesn't rise to this. Can I tell you about it? Please. When I was in, I would say fifth grade, I had back to back incidents.
It was kind of like that third crow of the rooster kind of situation for me. A very pivotal pair of incidents incident number one. I was at my grandparents place up in Wyoming. We lived in Colorado at the time and they went to a church and I kind of, you know, what vacation friends are like.
You meet some of the kids in the neighborhood. You don't know them real well. You see them when you're in town and there was a kid at their church and we hung out a little bit and it was all right or whatever. We were real poor.
We didn't have a lot of toys. We went down to the Ben Franklin there in town and we were looking at GI Joe guys and there was a couple that I really wanted, but whatever. We just, that's just not something that we bought and it was like four bucks or whatever. That's how much GI Joe guys cost back then.
So we talked about it some more and I was well trained by good parents to not grub for money or, you know, beg somebody to buy me that thing or whatever. So I just, I mean, I liked it. He could tell I like it, but that was it. There was no angling at all.
Well, he kind of did this thing where he took out all this money when we got back to his place and threw it out across the bed to be like, look how rich I am in fifth grade. Yep. And I was like, whoa, you could get a ton of GI Joe guys. He's like, yep.
I was like, cool. I got to be like a paper route or something. I don't remember. I was talking about how I was going to earn money and I was going to get some GI Joe guys too.
And he takes a five dollar bill off the bed and he's like, you know what? Go buy yourself one. And I knew what my parents would say about that. And I was like, nope, nope, nope, can't do that.
He took the bill and he folded it up and he pushed it into my pocket. And I took it out. I was like, I can't take five bucks. I'd have to ask my parents.
They took it and like wrestled me and was trying to like shove it physically in my mouth. Not kidding. That happened. That made sense in fifth grade, I guess.
And at that point, I was like, well, you're trying to put it into an open orifice. I guess you really want me to take your five bucks. So I took the five bucks. I told my parents, he gave me five bucks.
They said, well, you know, okay, if he gave it to you, I was like, yeah, he definitely gave it to me. He had, you know, all this money and he gave me five dollars to buy a GI Joe guy. I went and bought the GI Joe guy. It was Beachhead who hails from Auburn, Alabama.
Now, what a weird power thing for another kid to do to another kid. It's one of the most memorable events of my childhood. That's like Caesar stuff. It's weird.
You're wearing me the peasants so I can throw money at him. It's weird. Yeah. Yeah.
It was weird. And can we just agree that stuff like this happens when you're a kid matters? Like this is important. Yes, this shapes me.
This matters. I can definitely agree. Definitely. Okay.
It's so weird because there's some stuff that happened when I was a little kid. It seems like it was five lifetimes ago. This feels like last week. So we go home.
I've got my little GI Joe guy, you know, who cares, whatever. And get a phone call. You know, a day after we get home. I was this young man's parents and they need to talk to my parents about the money I stole from their son.
And I went from zero to a hundred. I wasn't out of control, but it's the most insistent. I think I think it's the most assertive I had ever been in my life up until that point. I was in the room.
I was like, put him on the phone. Tell them to put him on the phone and they put him on the phone and I grabbed the phone. And I was like, Hey, you did this. Then you did this.
Then you did this. And I did this. This was yesterday. You know exactly what happened and you know you're lying.
You have to tell the truth because you're making it sound like I stole. He's like, well, you did steal. I mean, he doubled down on this thing. And even to this day, you know, with all of the lifetime of slights or offendedness, that is maybe top three things that I forgive you because that's something I'm supposed to do.
But man, it makes me angry when I think about it. Wasn't resolved. His parents insisted that I was a thief and that we owed them money. The kid doubled and tripled down on it.
My parents knew better and we gave them $5. Whoa. My parents stuck up for me. But what I wish they would have done is told them that they could roll up another $5 bill and find a warm home for it.
I wish they would have gone to bat even harder for me. I appreciate that they. I appreciate that they believe me. You're telling me your adult parents in order to placate this other family mailed them $5?
Oh, no. I earned $5 and mailed it to them to placate this family. I'm angry. I'm angry.
But I did not steal that $5. That's not I have stolen things. There was a transformers. If you rub it, it turns colors Autobot sticker that was in a pile of trash that was swept up in the floor on a target.
I saw it in there. I knew it had value. I took it with me and put it in my pocket. I definitely stole that transformer sticker.
It was not mine. I took a CD from somebody one time in high school and gave it back the next day because I knew it was wrong. So I have stolen things. Dang.
I definitely stole those two things. So I'm not saying that I couldn't have done something like that, but I didn't. I didn't do that. And it made me so angry.
Now get ready for the right just indignation to flip. That year, my parents got me an Iowa Hawkeyes sweatshirt. I love the Iowa Hawkeyes. That was my team when I was a little kid.
And they gave us magnifying glasses at school and they showed us how to burn paper. I'd never seen that before. So I'm just out on recess with a magnifying glass goofing around, burning stuff. I'm like, well, I wonder if it works on fabric.
And I burned a couple of holes in the sleeve of my shirt. I thought, oh, that was dumb. And I stopped. Rather than being honest about it, I went home.
My mom found it. She's like, what happened? And I made up a complete crap story about a couple of boys who had been mean to me, roughing me up and holding me down and doing that total fabrication. Not a word of it was true.
They knew it wasn't true. I knew it wasn't true. They gave me chances to come clean and I did not take the off ramps. I knew exactly what I was doing.
And I remember it like it was yesterday. My fifth grade teacher Ralph Ravenschlaug pulls me aside. The next little Ralph. Good old Ralph.
He was awesome. Oh, good man. Great teacher. Pulls me aside.
I thought, there's no way he would have just noticed that. But I'm already in this thing. I got a stick with the lie and I stuck with the lie. He took me into the little like the little bonus office over recess and he was composed.
But his eyes were glassy. He's like, what are you doing, Matt? We both know that's not true. Both know that's not true.
And you told your parents that and now you're telling me that. What's about to happen is that I'm about to go out and get those two boys and they're about to be in trouble for this. And it's going to be your word against theirs. Do you want to do that?
And then the rooster crowed for the third time. And I was like, oh, I am what I hate. Oh, no, I am accusing people of something they definitely didn't do to cover my own butt. And I know how it feels to get accused of something to cover your own butt.
And I just bald and I came clean about everything. I went home and I came clean about everything. And those back to back incidents were very formative because I got to feel the injustice of false accusation from both sides. And I remember it vividly.
Dang. No, I never had anything like that. That injustice that you feel is real. And I want my kids to feel that way.
I want them to feel that horrible. If any injustice happens anywhere to anybody, but imagine it's you and you're sitting in a jail cell every day for 28 years and you know every single day for 28 years that is not true. So just the fact that you're there, that's awful, right? But also know that they're systematically killing the people in the cells around you one at a time.
And someday they're going to call your number and do the same to you for that injustice. I cannot begin to understand what he felt. What do you think that would turn you into? It would destroy me, man.
Like it would make me angry. It would make me bitter. It would make me realize that I'm the only person looking out for me. I really think in this story, the two people that kept him sane were Lester, his best friend.
To me, Lester is the hero of the story. Oh, he's Sam on steroids and either Sam because all the good characters and stories are named Sam. You're talking about Sam Wise from, from Lawrence? Sam, Tarly.
Yeah. No, I think Lester is the hero of the story because he came and he visited Anthony and he was there. And he was just like, Hey, dude, this is the way it is. You didn't do it.
You know what? Just having that external anchor to keep your brain steady. Yes. I mean, that had to admit the world to him.
Yes. If Lester doesn't exist, Anthony Ray Hinton is dead right now and you and I have never heard of him. I think so. I think so.
So yeah, I was just blown away by Lester's loyalty and I liked Anthony talking about how when they were younger, they would like hide in the ditch, you know, walking down the road and they jumped the ditch to hide from cars and stuff like that. I did that. I did that growing up. Yeah.
Everybody did that. So Lester really meant a lot to me in the story. Of course, his mother come to visit. Imagine, imagine being in that situation and just knowing that injustice happened and there's no way to talk to you, man.
Callie, I just don't get it. I don't. I can say with certainty when processing out how I would respond versus observing how Anthony responded with certainty and not some attempt at weird false humility or thing that just people say, he is a better man than me. Same.
He's native snurner stuff. He's better than me. And everyone who encounters this story, the very notion of justice is benefited because it was him who ended up there and not someone like me. Hey, Dustin, this episode of Notable Questions is brought to everybody by HelloFresh, which is America's number one meal kit delivery system.
You get easy seasonal recipes and pre-measured ingredients delivered right to your door. And all you have to do, as we said before, is cook and enjoy. What are you HelloFreshing right now? We've got one called Beef Tenderloin and Bismamic State Sauce.
So we had three different meals that came in. We had pork chops. We had quesadillas and we had this one. And do you do the thing that I do?
You save the one that you're most excited about to last or do you eat it first? How do you do it first? Oh, no, I do it first. No, I'm really.
I'm grubby and demanding. Yeah. I mean, I like them all. I haven't had it yet.
What? I'm looking at the picture. Chipotle steak. Is this a new one?
Yeah, I think it maybe is. I don't know. I haven't seen it before. It's got a little spice to it.
It says, and you know how you get normal corn that's like yellow, but then you get south west corn that's yellow, but it's got that little bit of like spicy paprika kind of coloration to it, like to been seared a little bit. It looks like that except it's run over the top of steak. Really? Yeah.
I'm going to buy it. I'm going to use the card to learn how to do it and then I'm going to put it in my face hole. What does the recipe look like? I haven't seen that one.
Okay. You've seen the recipe cards. You kind of know the drill here. Yeah.
I've got the beef tinderloin, the psalmic steak in front of me right now. What's that one? I've got a different card here. This is the, oh, I can't say this word.
I've never been able to. This is the chimichurri steak. That was actually pretty close. I feel better about that than I thought I would.
And so it's divided up. It's like an eight and a half by eleven card stock glossy card with crystal clear pictures in six steps. Boom, boom, boom. You prep the thing.
You roast the veggies. You make the sauce. You cook the steak. You make the veggie jumble and then you finish and you serve.
The first thing that I've learned is the sauce. It's like every single meal comes with some clever flavor blast that I never, ever, ever would have thought of. Also like the fact that the way it's timed out on the card, when you get done and you take everything off the eye, it's like all of the different items finish at almost the same time. I don't know how they do that, but it's magic.
Yeah. It's like everybody and everything rendezing properly. Send me a picture of that recipe card so I can make sure that I can remember to make a mistake. But what is the offer code?
Like how do we get HelloFresh in front of the face holes of the people that are listening to this right now? Because that's ultimately what we've got to do, right? Yes, it is. People should do it.
So if you're off your first month of HelloFresh, you go to hellofresh.com slash NDQ80 and then you enter NDQ80 and check out and it all goes to plan. That's awesome. So it's that simple. HelloFresh.com slash NDQ80 and enter the promo code NDQ80 at checkout and $80 off is a significant amount of money.
That's a lot of money. Yeah. This is an actual promotion where it actually makes your life better and actually saves you a bunch of cash and did you see that they now offer sides as well? Garlic bread and cookie dough?
What? No. Yeah, it's a thing. So you can just have that delivered to your house.
Is this like an upgrade or something? How does that work? It's like completely intuitive. You'll have no trouble figuring it out.
Awesome. I'm on it. HelloFresh.com slash NDQ80. NDQ80 at checkout.
It's delicious. You will love it. Your kids can learn how to cook too. That's a good thing as well.
Yep. They're with us every single time. Thank you HelloFresh for supporting the program. Thank you to everybody who listens for supporting the sponsors.
You would not believe how far that goes. All right. Let's get back to talking about some pretty heavy stuff here. Yeah.
So I watched a video on YouTube recently that I think applies and I think it's worth mentioning here. Have you ever seen this video by Regent University School of Law? This was uploaded to YouTube in 2012. This guy named James Duane, he's a law professor.
He gives his talk called Don't Talk to the Police. Have you ever seen this? I have not seen the video, but I think I've heard the content of it. I'm just going to let you hear him talk for just a second.
I'm going to play a little bit of it. Okay. So you can get the feel here. Listen to this.
I was invited to give you a taste of a typical law school classroom experience here today. And I thought I would take advantage of this opportunity to do something I'd spend on my mind for a while. Just stand up and probably say God bless America. God bless the Bill of Rights and thank God for the Fifth Amendment.
I'm not ashamed to say I'm proud of the Fifth Amendment. And I'm proud to admit, I'm Cameron. I'm the internet that I will never talk to any police officer under any circumstances with all due respect, sir. I'm doing something really extraordinary here today.
Something I'll almost never see another law professor do as long as you live. I'm really putting myself on the spot here. This was my idea. By my invitation, I've given up half of my time approximately.
I'm giving equal time and the last word to an expert who really knows something about what I'll be talking about. So what Professor Duane does here is he explains for approximately 20 minutes how your words can be used against you in a court of law. And you'll notice you've heard of your Miranda rights or it's actually not for Miranda rights. He explains that it's the Miranda warning.
You have the right to remain silent. Your words can't and will be used against you in court law. That's better language. Yeah.
You notice it doesn't say your words can be used for you in a court of law. Did you notice that? I sure did. Okay.
So what he explains in this talk is that when you communicate with the police, your words will be used against you. If you say something to try to talk yourself out of the situation, it's not going to work. Like you're not going to say something to the police and they're going to be like, oh, okay, you know what? You're innocent.
And oh, by the way, we're totally going to tell everybody that thing you said to like bolster your case. We're going to say that in court. You know, no, they don't do that. He explains that if you said something when you were arrested and you try to bring that up in court, they can have it thrown out as hearsay.
No, objection. That's hearsay. And the court will agree with them. Only the things that you say that can be used against you will be used in court.
I didn't know this. Did you know this? I remember that from my constitutional law class, my junior year of college, when I was starting to get into the pre law aspect of what I was studying and I was mortified when we worked our way through Miranda rights and the relationship between the police and the courts. And I was probably a pretty pivotal step on my journey toward a liberty and mentality, a liberty and philosophy.
He goes on to give several examples of things that you would say that wouldn't hurt you at all. Like there's no way this could basically convict you. Here's an example. Okay.
It wasn't me. In fact, thank you very much, Officer, but no thanks. How about this one? Here we go.
Now here's the most surprising of all. I say the most surprising one for the last. Let's suppose you've got the following scenario. You're clang to think about talking to the police.
He says, I've got nothing to hide. They think that I killed somebody in Virginia Beach last night. Well, and this is what your client tells you in confidence. I don't know who Rob that's door.
It wasn't me. In fact, I've got a pretty good elbow. I wasn't even in Virginia Beach that night last night. I was four hours away visiting my mother in the Outer Banks.
Unfortunately, no, I did not pay for gas with a credit card. I used cash and so I've got no witnesses that can prove I was there except my word. And of course, mama, for what that's worth, which is nothing. So your client says, so the police want to talk to me and I want to see cooperatives.
So what I'll do is I'll tell them that I was in the Outer Banks last night. Now, there's nothing on his face incriminating about anything. Let's assume, by the way, that you will believe with all your doubt. You've given your client a polygraph exam.
You've known him for years. You've been going to the same, bibles like for 30 years. No, but you was there. How on earth could this come back to haunt us?
How on earth could this come back to be used against us? Be honest, raise your hand if you really think the Antubatic questions. I can't, I can't see how it could possibly be used against me. I can't.
You're afraid I'll call on you, right? I won't call on you. You're wrong, you're dead, wrong, you're wrong. Everything you say.
Every time you talk to the police, you will regret it. You see, the problem is here it is. This is the last point. I think as almost as well.
Even if your client is innocent. And only tells the truth and doesn't tell the police anything incriminating, and the entire interview questions and answers are fake, you're even his truthful answers can be helped to use crucified even in innocent man if the police do no fault of bears and in the possession of any evidence even mistaken unreliable evidence that anything your client told them was false even if in fact it was true again going back to this example from a moment ago let's suppose I tell I go ahead and I'm even the police I think I got nothing to hide I tell them I was in the outer banks last night officer how can they be used to convict me by itself they cannot help it all by itself but what if I later find out to my horror after I put my cards on the table that they've got a witness a girl that I went to high school with and on the peachable witness we've never been enemies she had no reason to lie she swear she's she saw me in Virginia Beach last night a couple of blocks away from that store about an hour before it was robbed now her testimony by itself isn't going off the prosecutor if she's all they've got I'll get this case to run out of work trial but if like an idiot I talked to the police and I told them the truth I told them I was in the outer banks and now alone but whole tragically it turns out they've got a witness a false mistake and confused but sincere incredible witness who could testify that I was here in Virginia Beach now they're likely to get a conviction because what they'll do I've just turned this cop and this woman into the government star witness they'll put her help out officer procon to testify about how my client lied to him about being in the other banks and then they'll put on this girl this girl who would have not even helped her case at all who will testify no that's not true that was a lie I saw Mr. Gwynne's client here in Virginia an hour before the robbery not so far from the store by herself she would not help the government anything significant way but what I have just done you see is given the other part of the puzzle and now I'm doomed and that interesting wow yeah so watching this video is this guy is amazing I highly recommend everyone watch this video at the end of the video he invites an investigator for the Commonwealth of Virginia up on to the stage and he said okay sir here's what I'm gonna do I just told this entire classroom of law students to never talk to never let their clients talk to police under any circumstances your turn tell them I'm wrong tell them what I got all this stuff because this guy has interviewed people for years like thousands of people this is the first thing he says when he walks on stage not even interview I'm gonna take the podium here because I took notes on some of the things you said and everything he said was true okay and it was right and it was correct and I'm just gonna give you a few ideas I'm gonna tell you a few examples but first I'm gonna give you a little information as was said earlier I've interviewed thousands of people I've interviewed people with foreign police departments when I was in the Navy I was in law enforcement and I was a criminal investigator thank God we're in the United States because most interviews in Italy Spain and so forth start out physically okay there's no police abuse over there they can do pretty much what they want anytime they want any how they want so just be aware that be thankful for you biggest question I was asked when I first I am a 3L and there's someone classmates in here best days coming up May 10th when we get to leave so those of you that are applying and I told a couple people that you think it's hard getting into law school try to get a second it's coming okay a couple things I was asked how do I quit from getting speech it's very easy question quit speed okay but something Professor Duane brought up are any of you guilty of anything how many of you drove here today anybody go above 55 on the interstate anybody drive at home and go above 55 on the interstate because if you if you stay once I it's almost a and there you go and people are inherently honest and that's their biggest downfall okay they really are or they want to tell their story and if you drive 55 on the interstate where it's 55 the only thing you're gonna do is meet the person behind you because they're gonna rear you let's read this second man okay so that's a fact but everybody does something that they can get in trouble for I can follow as a police officer my uniform I can follow a car however long I need it to and eventually they're gonna do something illegal and I can pull them over and justify illegal pull them up so just be aware of that don't don't think you're so innocent in such a thing when you get stopped for a traffic ticket everyone likes to be somewhat honest and what's the first thing the police officer ask you you know how fast you're going but the speed line is 35 you'll say oh 38 40 because you want to be kind honest even though you're doing 50 you just said 38 40 you just admitted to breaking the law you just confessed so they can go to court with that with a confession that you were exceeding the speed line okay so then you need to think about those things and when you do become defense attorneys which my point is these government officials that are trying to get a conviction know exactly what to do to get a conviction it's like he goes on to explain it's like me having never boxed before getting into the ring with a heavyweight champion this investigator that's gonna walk into the interrogation he knows exactly what to do in order to get a conviction it's just a matter of time they can wear you down he goes on to explain in this video how he can say something like this hey you know the people that you did this to they're really upset and it can help you if we write an apology to them so that blah blah blah and he goes on to explain that he's convicted dozens of people with a written apology the apology being the confession they know all the techniques in order to do this and they just employed whatever one is required once the state has decided you're guilty it's not really an essential proven guilty it's almost the other way it's almost guilty until proven innocent what you're saying to me is it's fascinating we put that lecture is fascinating and if you're troubled by it that should help you understand why I see the world the way I do yeah I mean obviously I think we're on the same way we're not on different sides of the coin you're on the same team here buddy okay well you know what I mean a lot of people would say would listen to me talking to you hate cops what no no I'm I'm troubled by whoever has the monopoly on force in the situation that's who I've got my eye on remember we agreed to use the term legal monopoly on force we agreed that yeah sure yeah well the legal monopoly on forces the only one that effectively matters for this conversation because there is not mob justice it isn't how we do it we do it this way and when it's a a proper carrying out of justice you're good if somebody did something horrible to some kid or really victimized somebody I'm glad we tricked him with getting him to write that apology because I want that person to own it there needs to be justice when a victim has been truly wrong and it needs to be just justice wherein the person who did the bad thing is the one who answers for doing the bad thing but the system is designed to incentivize a certain number of convictions for the processes to work a certain way anytime that much power is consolidated anywhere you might have 99 very honorable people handled that power properly but there's gonna be one who doesn't and that one can do a tremendous amount of damage what you're using present tense verbs and I think what's so interesting about the story is Anthony lived in the past or you know this moment happened in the past and these people had a secondary agenda that appears to be racist very much so yeah it was important that this killer was black it was important at that moment in history for this particular set of prosecutors or whoever was involved in this and Anthony even said that they said as much and even if he's innocent he's gonna take one for the team here yeah that was the thing for me that yes I knew the story before I read the book and I knew this was going to be this expansion of this unjust story but what I wasn't really prepared for was that my Alabama that I know and love and I spent an awful lot of time in my life trying to make Alabama not 50th on every list right I want people to know that there's good people here we love it people are kind and way right they're kind in ways that they're not kind other places this book was directly attacking what I know and love in a way that it should have been attacked okay and so after reading this book I started just reading I just started reading things about laws in Alabama and I discovered that I already knew that Alabama had the longest constitution in the world you know that only because you've told me the constitution of the state of Alabama is the longest English constitution in the world what I learned is it was written by people who wanted to suppress African Americans in the state like it was written with a racist agenda it was written in 1901 there've been many attempts to try to change it and all have been unsuccessful so I think it's important at some point that these injustices of the past are reversed and something more equitable is put in place I'll say that agreed and I want to figure out how I can help do that and this book really sparked that in my mind it wasn't until I was confronted with the fact that something this egregious could happen here not 30 years ago that it made me realize holy cow we are not far removed from total injustice and the people in power that serve their control over other people and it just made me realize that we need to put checks and balances in place to keep that from happening in the future or just reduce power yeah that's true too or just have less power if there's less power there's less chance to abuse power and that's the thing where I know I'm an outsider to the current political discourse but the one thing that I see that I would push back on right and left politics at this point in history is look you all want solutions but all your solutions involve more power and all the problems you're trying to solve are a result of there being too much power at some point you got a dial it back we learned that the hard way coming out of the age of absolute monarchs that was just too much power and eventually some really smart people realized it's not that we need to get that power into the hands of the right person it's there just needs to be less and so I love that the thing that runs the red flag up for you is the idea that the Alabama Constitution has too many words what a great place to start there's power in all of those words there's opportunity no it's not damage to exploit no that's that's not at all with so the reason it has too many words is because the Constitution of the state of Alabama centralizes the power within Montgomery we don't have what's called home rule like for example if we want to buy a mosquito truck in Madison County Alabama not an exaggeration that might have to go to a constitutional amendment in order to get that done they have consolidated the power centrally in Montgomery so that they can have control over these poorer counties that you know are predominantly African-American it's really strange man I'm trying to understand how we're disagreeing here though what I just said is where there are lots of words that is a demonstration of inappropriate power and then you just describe a situation where there's a whole bunch of words and the explanation is consolidation of too much power okay you're right I retract it I don't need to retract it I think we're saying the same thing so to round out that last thought you know we hear from the professor on the video that you played we hear from the investigator on the video you just played we hear you talk about the Alabama state Constitution and my Bible brain kicks in in Proverbs 1019 you'll remember it when I say it where there are many words transgression is unavoidable but he who restrains his lips is wise this is not a new problem this is a reality tons of words equals the consolidation of power because within all of those words are a whole bunch of traps so apparently this is something that dates to at least 3,000 years as a human phenomenon and here we are in the early part of the 21st century figuring out how people like you or me could push back on it again so we don't see more of this kind of injustice so how do we figure something out that people keep getting wrong that we've got wrong yeah you have to take steps backwards you have to give back that power and that's not something that powerful people like to do no powerful people like to manipulate not powerful people into participating in their power scheme right and anybody anybody in the third chair who's listening and it's like yeah the other team is like that I'm sorry it's you to and any libertarian who's listening like go champion Matt you're right it's everybody else honestly we like power to and the renunciation of our imagined right to control other people is where we start to fix these things I found it interesting that Anthony was able to connect with people in the jail like he was able to connect with guards he was able to connect with the other inmates and out of everyone that was there he was the person that was there under the most raw deal that we know of yeah that we know the people he described had come in they done horrible horrible things I still wouldn't kill him I'm against all killing but they've done really bad things are you gonna stop killing that I'm against all killing all killing yes in principle I'm against all killing I've never been under that kind of duress where I'd have to face that decision in the heat of the moment but yeah I'm against killing old people young people foreign people criminals everybody I think taking a life is an enormous thing and when you outsource that on your behalf to the government wow that that moral buffer that you're putting between that action and yourself is a dangerous thing it greases the skids toward devaluing life and taking lives from people we may find undesirable I think once you open the Pandora's box of killing the whole lot flows out of that you don't like and it's gonna boomerang on people you love is a better not to kill people so what what you're saying is great and wonderful and I agree killing bad oh my goodness hand wave no go ahead no I'm serious and everyone would agree with you with the way you say it like that right but there are people that agree in the death penalty hey if you do certain things to children you should be killed you know there should be some consequence there are people that believe that and to some extent I don't know where I'm at on that specific thing you know but I do know this the way Anthony articulates it triggered something in my mind that had never been triggered before he said you you can believe in the death penalty and agree that we shouldn't do it yeah there's a ton of values I hold just like that you know me well how many things you know that I would say I'm totally against this and it should be completely legal and protected yeah got it but my point is not that the point is the way he's communicating with people this is what I learned from Anthony Ray Hinton the way you articulate a point can be very effective in getting others to receive your message so he starts by saying hey you can be right but let's agree that the state doesn't always get it right and to unjustly kill one individual makes all of this awful and unjust and we shouldn't do it I agree the big thing I learned from him is he starts a statement with that olive branch more than anybody on the planet he has earned the right to say hey the death penalty is awful my friends have died I've heard them die I've seen the lights flicker from the generators you do not want the death penalty you have smelled them die yeah he says all those things and he had or he could say all those things he could more than anybody ever he could say those things and he chooses not to he says listen I acknowledge that you can believe that we should have a death penalty you can believe that but let's also agree that maybe we shouldn't so just that little thing that he does just it's like a magic trick man he has all of that authority all of the moral high ground and he chooses not to use it I think the word for that is meekness when you have incredible power and you restrain it and don't use it yeah so the way he articulates his point it's split my heart wide open like a sledgehammer driving like a railroad spike straight through the middle it was like holy cow man like the way he said that changed everything about what I think about the death penalty to the point where like if I'm ever governor of Alabama what you do day one you pick up the phone you call Brian Stevenson you're like hey what are the cases on the books right now that are most unjust let's let's start talking you know what I mean well if I'm governor Alabama I commute every death sentence immediately life in prison fine if you have I mean there's a there's a legal system for that as somebody who generally doesn't like to harvest other people's money and use it for my purposes I think we can agree that having law and justice in society is absolutely vital and I'm more than happy to pay to keep someone alive who maybe deserves to be dead but we're not gonna kill somebody in response to killing at far rather than I would commute every death sentence day one what's interesting is I find myself holding back saying things because I know that Anthony Ray Hinton's a real man and he might listen to this and I don't want to say something that's contrary to what he might feel because I don't want to offend him I know that Brian Stevenson might listen to this I know that the mother of a slain child that you know the person has been convicted is on death row I know that that person might listen to this and so I'm sitting there thinking about all these things that would be easy and I could score some quick points if I said I'm into a microphone right now but I find myself not because I don't feel like I've earned the right to say those things you've been very consistent in the entire time I've known you in avoiding piling on the obvious opinion to say stuff that will score you points because we're all just supposed to signal what we think right now this is a time for healing and all signaling that we think the right stuff you don't you don't do it I respect it so I get where you're coming from at the same time get a little pissed man I think it's okay and if the head frustration with this isn't targeted just right and somebody at 30 years of their life stolen it's maddening and yeah I want to be sane and level-headed and I want to game it out but I can't I can't hide the fact that no it makes me mad and I'm okay with people knowing that it makes me mad if it makes me somebody who is virtue signaling I don't know I'd like to pass this time around please because this is the height of injustice to me are you implying that I'm not pissed no I'm not I'm saying maybe when I maybe when I'm pissed it looks a little different than when you're pissed that's very fair like right now for example yeah that's very fair yeah yeah so what I don't even say that stuff to push back on you I say that stuff to defend myself being frustrated yeah we know each other very well we know the dance steps right now but I do want to ask you a question all right about this about this the things that make you angry right Brian Stevenson saw these things happening and he got very angry and he decided to move to Alabama and start fighting it with that cold logic like I'm going to get into the system and I'm gonna fight it he talks about going to certain people's offices and we'll show up and they find out that he's African American they'll give some snide remark about how he talks eloquently or something and it's obviously a big it's a racist comment and he talks about those things happening how he lets it roll off his back and he doesn't he doesn't just fire back immediately right yeah stick up for himself use that to stick up for other people well I wouldn't say he doesn't stick up for himself he's he's just very strategic with how he does it okay I'll give you an example I used to work with this guy and he was very very rude very rude and he would say things you know he's like cussing you out don't you get over there stand over there I'm gonna you know because he was a safety officer and he made you do certain things love the guy he kept me safe he kept me alive many times but he was very confrontational in his style and I was very cool calm and collected that was my that's my style playing around with everybody real goofy but when it came time to communicate I was very clear you knew exactly where I stood on any individual topic so one day he's just going off like that and it was just enough it crossed the line it was time for me to communicate to him that I was done with it so I said it's time for you to go stand right over there just calmly pointed over there because you're being a dickhead right now and I need you to go walk over there and shut your mouth and do your job that's all I said I didn't raise my voice it was very calm earlier that day he had said things about my mother you know been just yelling all kinds of fanities you know it's just his style later in the day we executed the test he walks over he goes hey man we need to talk it's like okay bring it what's up I didn't appreciate what you said earlier and I said yeah yeah what about it did you not like he goes you called me a dickhead and I was like I did and I said what about that did you not like because if you recall you called me XYZ you know I just listed off all the things he called me and my mother and all this if you recall you've said these things for the past week and I just said that one thing so what is it about what I said that bothered you and he said well you meant it I said I did mean it and he said well I didn't appreciate it I said okay think about that and that's where we left it I did ask for forgiveness but it was very clear that my words had incredible power compared to his words which were cheap I didn't intend on learning that lesson I wasn't trying to teach somebody lesson but it was something that I certainly learned in the moment for myself so this is my question for you okay fast forward to social media today something happens you disagree with it you get on the internet and you just light up social media about the injustices or maybe you do the echo chamber thing and you are using the royal you or do you mean me the royal you okay and you don't do this obviously you don't do this online but like yeah forgive me let me be more clear a lot of individuals I see on social media they get very angry and they are very vocal about how they feel about certain things this is my strategy my strategy is don't do that and don't feel like I have to comment about everything so when I do it means more and usually when I do it I want it to be in the form of a long-form video where everything's well thought out and articulated so that's my strategy right now I think it's a good strategy and I wasn't trying to call you out on that strategy I'm trying to justify my frustration let me around the corner here I'll let you Anthony says when he's in Holman prison and his friends are getting executed every time that happened he beat on the bars right right and at the end of the end of the book he does this kind call to get you to beat on the bars for those who are wrongly executed right so what does that look like today how do you voice dissatisfaction with an injustice in the world without becoming an additional voice that's angered over trivial things because I see people tweeting with the same tone about you know you didn't use this particular word for this whatever did you understand the question I'm not doing a very good job of articulating it but you understand the question there's a line there's a line like I want my words to have meaning so when I do step up to the plate and grab a microphone or whatever and say this is wrong I want that to be heard by people and I don't want to just use my words when I think social justice is incredibly important and if I'm not fighting for social justice because I'm wanting to reserve all my words for the right moment and I never end up using them that's bad on me right yeah especially if I'm giving a if I'm given a platform to do that but I have people in my Twitter feed all the time oh yeah I know what you're gonna say yeah oh destined if you don't comment about that you clearly agree with it or you have a platform use it for my thing which is obviously an arguably morally right exactly mm-hmm yeah I'm not a fan of that approach I get that too even though my platform is smaller here's the thing then Anthony Ray Hinton was not banging on the bars because he wanted to be the guy at the lever he was banging at the bars because it was wrong he was banging at the bars out of support and respect for somebody no matter how much they screwed up who was about to get killed willfully and intentionally and when people bang at the bars on Twitter it's not hard to read the comment and understand the talking points which have been regurgitated a billion times and understand that they're not banging the bars just because things need to be better it's banging the bars because things need to be better and my team should be controlling the lever and that's what discredits it to me is I don't like the way this power is being used my team should have the power instead I'm sorry that just invalidates everything not impressed that element right there undermines just about every noble cause from every place on the political spectrum right now and what's shameful about it is it's a trick we've learned from politicians that the other team is bad they're using power wrong give me power and I'll definitely use it right well that's what it was ten years ago now it's increasingly becoming the other team was wrong they used the power wrong give me the power and I'll use it to punish them and reward you that's dangerous dangerous stuff and so every one of these causes many of which I might happen to really agree with from all parts of the political spectrum lose their punch when the only solution to this problem I just urgently presented you with is to give me and people like me all the power no one's ever saying we should reduce how much power there is out there so no one could do anything like this to anyone don't hear that but that I think is a noble way to frame it so my way of bringing these things up is to start a podcast with my friend and convince thousands of people to spend eight hours heavily invested in thoughts around the story of a guy named Anthony Ray Hinton and to think at the heart level about what he experienced and what he went through because he has the right to speak about these things in a way that I do not nor I to those people that may or may not listen to this that have been angry that I don't scream out in public about certain things that you feel it's because I don't have the right to speak in a way that Anthony does and so this podcast itself is the way I bring awareness to those types of topics is that an acceptable answer it's a very acceptable answer and you know online and offline I highly respect you for it when we agree on a cause and when we disagree on a cause I respect you either way cool so this is a little different we're cramming a break in right here because we're talking about this thing that is one of those faceless institutional problems that makes you feel impotent to change the world but you want to see the world change and we were talking off mics for a minute about what we do to just mobilize people towards something that is productive and I don't know what you have in mind the other day I went up to the jail I had to get some fingerprints for this form I was filling out and while I was in the jail I just started interacting with the people in there there were people in stripes and people and wearing badges and I realized all these people are people I thought it would be interesting if just you sitting there listening just pick the thing a pick a way to make a positive impact in your community wherever you're at it could be whatever but it's the kind of thing where if nobody ever suggests something like this maybe you never think about it but perhaps the call to action here is just to think about the possibility of maybe volunteering in a way to help people like that in your community maybe I don't know teach GED or just look up somebody who sits on the fringes of society take a little bit of time talk see what happens yeah just be cool to people that normally are just kind of cast aside yeah and here's the thing if under normal circumstances if you go and do something and then you trot right over to the internet and you're like oh I like to talk to somebody I'm important it just doesn't come off well so here's the deal I would like to hear from you I know you wouldn't tell me otherwise but I'd like to put a thread in our slash NDQ and I would like to hear what people thought of or what happened or what we could do better and who knows maybe we inspire each other a little bit so I'll make some kind of thread that's like went and did something after the Sunday Shine episode and we'll compare notes it doesn't have to be in a jail it doesn't have to be anything weird I mean it could be helping out at a homeless shelter it could be whatever but I have found in my life every time I've done something like that it is always ended up making a huge impact in my life you know you kind of enter into the thing thinking oh well I'm gonna go help someone else but nine times out of ten I walked away having my life being improved by the experience and I know you've got the same way Matt from some stuff you've told me about so as a community we're gonna see what it looks like for us to pick something redemptive even if it's a one-off redemptive thing you don't have to commit till the end of time but pick something redemptive and do it and then if you feel like it someone is asking so you're not being arrogant it'd be awesome to compare notes a little bit I think that's our thing yeah that's it that's simple cool all right let's get back at it let's do it and I would frame it a tiny bit differently to restate what I just said I would say the same to all of those things but if you want to know what my solution is it's at some point we have to dial back the mechanisms and allow things that we think are bad to happen not just recituate who's at the lever and I think that's what Brian Stevenson is working to achieve I think so too yeah he has an organization called the equal justice initiative yes I follow Brian Stevenson's work there at EJI the equal justice initiative and you can donate to them there are 501c3 my understanding they're just at EJI.org I just wanted to let people know that it exists it would be inappropriate for us to mob you know that attorneys Google by the way makes it not do that I would love it at that state at 16 reviews we don't need to make our voices heard that way it would be inappropriate to go and mob the people who did screwed up things in this story unfortunately it would also be inappropriate for me to find Brian Stevenson on the street somewhere and hug him but that's what I wanted to do when I listen to the story just I know this is socially inappropriate and you just can't do it but I just want to hug that man and then I put both hands on his shoulders as we push away and look him deeply in the eye and say thank you I respect you and then I could leave him alone but I'd understand if there need to be a restraining order yeah one thing I think he probably deals with a lot is people who read this story and they get very emotional like like we have and you want to do something like you want to participate in a way I don't know that this is what they experience but I bet they have a lot of people that just kind of sweep in and just want to have a conversation and do one or two things and then kind of back away but leave them there doing the everyday dirty business that is this but I do think that donating to the equal justice initiative might be a good way to help them I think that'd be good anyway how's the book changed you man anytime I encounter a story like that it holds up a mirror to me it was like reliving those twin incidents of false accusation from my youth you start the book on your my moral high horse and then your own failures occur to you part way through and you come crashing down off of that moral high horse I'm not better than the people who got this wrong so it may be super super mad it may be cry a whole bunch it made me reflect on my own failures I just don't have a spotless record on this and I know it made me want to help do what I can I know this sounds like a ridiculous connection but me doubling and tripling down on this little project where I try to talk with people I don't agree with and make videos about it it's fueled by this book in part I read the book I was like all right you know what can I actually do and that's the sector of the world that I understand a little bit about and I really do want to try to help and maybe even kind of atone for stuff I've got wrong that's how it affected me you it took things from a oh well the system is a little bit corrupt and blah blah you know just being a white man in Alabama it kind of took it from oh yeah everybody says this about us to a very personal deep place and it took me from yeah well I know that might be true but I kind of avoid talking about that because I don't I don't want to pretend that that's real to a place where okay this happens it's real how can I strategize to fight it in a very clever way that will affect real change how can I do that that's what it did to me it changed the way I think about my involvement in my community change the way I think about my skin color it changed the way I think about the justice system and it certainly changed the way I think about the death penalty it hardened me up and made me feel mad and then it softened me his ability to forgive does not make sense it doesn't make sense I have to do better yeah I do as well as a Christian it's it's easy for me to talk about forgiveness to see the way he did it actually did it and does it I would say it's probably a present tense thing for him it's very sobering obviously the story of the Sun does shine is Anthony Ray Hinton's and not mine but what I really enjoyed about this conversation is comparing notes on how a story that he put out there because he clearly wants people like you and me to think about how this affects us and what we're doing with our lives and it was really meaningful to give each other permission to not just reflect on his story but to reflect on how his story affects us and what we want to do different because of it so thank you for comparing notes on that yeah and I just appreciate you being the kind of friend that I can just call and be like hey we should read this story together it had a big influence on me and I think it'll do the same for you and so thank you for doing that first of all and I agree I think at times in this conversation we kind of made the stories about us a little bit and I just want people to know that it's because we know each other so well that we weren't making about us we were just comparing notes on injustices and things like that so this is very much about Anthony Ray Hinton and the things that he went through so I don't know if that can cross well at all but I think you know I'm tracking with you I'm tracking with you I appreciate your sensitivity to that I'm sorry I allowed it to sound like I was getting after you a little bit there in the in the middle that wasn't my intent but I don't like the way it came off oh whatever dude you know I fired back no that's the give and take man cool I'm good with that I did not take it bad at all you were just trying to give me permission to avoid my opinions that's what you were doing and I totally I totally got that 100% so thank you okay yeah I can do it better but what you heard on my side was frustration because a lot of times I pull my punches and when I speak and how I speak sure and it's not because I don't want to speak I'll say that it's because I think there may be a more calculating way to do it what I'm struggling with myself right now is when to speak and is it always a good idea to be quiet Anthony would tell me no and so the thing that I haven't figured out as an adult is when to speak and when to when to not speak so I'm working on that myself I think there's one other injustice that Anthony Ray Henton has to live with even now and that's the fact that there's never been any formal compensation that's occurred that I'm aware of I mean there's no amount of money they can give him to make this right the state screwed up specific individuals in the state perhaps did it maliciously but this man has been wronged and I know of nothing that the state of Alabama has done to try to make it right other than set him free which is not anything really so are you kidding me nothing has been done I don't know is I didn't even think to ask I just assumed there was some automatic civil suit filed against the state and that the state cut some gigantic check to make up for what it did I don't know the answer to that wow I want to know let's look into that let's look into that so let's let's not say that nothing hasn't been done but I do know some people that I want to talk to that surely we can get something done where we can we can at least get a formal apology surely that's been done at minimum an apology seemed so obvious to me that it didn't even cross my mind to ask but yeah I'd really like to know yeah so I'll be following up with that I'll go investigate that and maybe in an upcoming episode I'll update you on what the status of that is yeah but I really I really want to do that but you wanted to close out this episode by hearing from the man himself and I think that's appropriate so so what do you think we should do here that speech that he gave and I don't know how much of it was extemporaneous but that he gave when he walked out the doors from his time on death row I think is very powerful I just say we give mr. hit in the last word let's do that prosecution seemed deemed to take my life from me they just didn't take me from my family they had every kitchen they executed me for something I didn't do but for all y'all that's happening to cameras I want you to know there is a god you see how but he looks like he will destroy but yet he will defend me and he defend me and I just want to think I'm not ashamed to let you know that he sent me not just a lawyer but the best law and I couldn't have made it that then and I want to say to the victim family I will continue to pray for you just about half the 30 years a miscarriage of justice not only to me but to the victim family for all of us that say that we believe in justice this is the case to start showing because I shouldn't sit on death row 30 years all they had to do was test the gun but when you think you hide and mighty and you're above the law you don't have to answer to nobody but I got news for everybody that played a part and sent him in the death row you will answer the guard