Skip to content
075 - Why Do People Make Huge Statues? episode artwork

Jan 17, 2020 1 hr 39 min

075 - Why Do People Make Huge Statues?

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: HELLOFRESH STUFF FROM THIS EPISODE Vulcan Park, Birmingham, AL Christ the Redeemer statue, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil Statue of Liberty, New York, NY African Renaissance Monument, Dakar, Senegal Mount Rushmore, South Dakota Crazy Horse Monument, South Dakota Stone Mountain, Georgia Yogi Bear Gutzon Borglum NPS Junior Ranger John D. Rockefeller, Jr. Memorial Parkway North by Northwest Yellowstone National Park Crazy Horse Sitting Bull Battle of the Little Big Horn Sand Creek Massacre Fort Robinson State Park Archimedes Wind River Indian Reservation The Punisher Korczak Ziolkowski Ellis Island Frédéric Auguste Bartholdi Richard Morris Hunt 3D Printing Nerd Restoration of The Statue of Liberty Edward Wightman Colossus of Rhodes Titan of Braavos Eagle Bronze Foundry Genghis Khan Equestrian Statue The Mausoleum of Hadrian Mausoleum of Augustus James Webb Space Telescope Sculpture, Fallen Astronaut Reformation Wall China's AI News Anchors Cincinnatus Galvanic Action Tsunami Stones Stonehenge Georgia Guidestones CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

075 - Why Do People Make Huge Statues?

0:00 1:39:56
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

So it's just a lady named Karina, and she comes over and she helps do the floors every so often. Okay. And you know what I mean, like the deep clean in the house, because it's a... Yeah, right on.

Yeah, it's something you can't really keep up with if you have children on that. So Karina comes over and she's in the other room and right before we record, I was going to talk to her and be like, Hey, I'm going to record in the other room. So can you please quit vacuuming? It's kind of what I was getting at.

There's a lady that works with her that doesn't speak a lot of English. And I said, uh... I said, Como c'est en espeñol esto. And I pointed to the vacuum cleaner, I said, Es vacuón?

And she said, No, espero de dor? Is that right? Espero de dor? I think.

Espero dor? Anyway, so she's like, No, that's how you say it. Okay, cool. It's like, In Áthro caie, I said, What?

I told him to vacuum some other street? No, no, no, no. I screwed all this up. And that's why it's funny.

I said, Áthro caie, I said, Requar dómi boca. What? And she's like, No. So, so to be clear, you said vacuum on some other road.

Remember my mouth. Exactly. She left at me. She's like, No, you're grab a door.

Grab a bar. How do you say record? Grab a bar. Grab a bar.

Grab a bar to a vos, no boca. So she's like, You're going to record your voice, not your mouth. And she's like, You know, Gave me the little mental like headpad. Like, it's okay.

You know what I mean? So it was pretty cute. I enjoyed it. So welcome back to Notum Questions where I, Destin, Sandlin talked to my friend Matt Whitman about all the things that are important in life at any given moment.

And like this, like butchering the Spanish language together. Yeah, in front of other people. Yep. So Destin, I saw two gigantic sculptures this week and they affected me.

And I want to talk to you about them. You were like, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, Stop talking because I saw giant sculptures too. I know. We talked about giant sculptures.

Yes, we can. We did that thing where we paused the conversation because it's so good. We're like, let's just turn on the mics, right? Because I hate it's so unnatural.

I bet I like giant sculptures for different reasons than you do. But I bet some of the reasons I like them are the same is why you like them, if I had to guess. Yeah, you're setting the Venn diagram hook there. All right.

Challenge accepted. Yes, I am sure there are different reasons. So you contacted me about these two sculptures that you saw. I was just coming off of a trip where I saw a giant one.

But I've seen many, many more in my lifetime. I've seen many of them make for various reasons. And I've thought about giant statues that were made in antiquity as well. So how would you like to do this?

Okay. So to be clear, we're not talking about the art of sculpting in general. We're talking about like monuments, big giant stand the test of time, mega-lithic monuments, right? Yeah.

Do you want me to just tell you a couple right now that they're in my head? Yes. And then I'll tell you a couple that are in my head. Okay.

In Birmingham, Alabama, there is a giant sculpture called Vulcan. It is the largest iron sculpture in the world. And overlooks the entire city of Birmingham when it was in Brazil, in Rio de Janeiro, there's of course Christ the Redeemer. I was there last year.

I haven't seen that. Yeah. But I've heard of Christ. Yeah, there's that and Brazil.

And I was at the Statue of Liberty just the other day. Have you been to Senegal? No, never touched down in Senegal. There's a giant statue in the car.

It's a huge statue of a family. It's a really interesting one. And then there's other ones that I've thought about. I mean, these are the types of grand statues I'm thinking about.

And the two that you contacted me about were incredible. Yeah. Mount Rushmore and the Crazy Horse Monument. One of them's done.

One of them's got a long ways to go. Yeah. Have you seen either of those? I have not.

No. I mean, but the difference in those, and the ones I'm talking about, are like created out of nothing and put on a pedestal. Correct. But you're talking about ones that are carved in rock.

Now, there's Stone Mountain, Georgia. There's a big relief that I've seen in Stone Mountain. It's a Confederate general monument there. Memorial, I guess it was.

I always thought it was General Sherman. Um, shut up. It took me a second. I was like, no, it's done on Jackson and then Robert.

Oh, idiot. History or something. No, I doubt they would make a monument to Sherman in Atlanta since he burned the whole place down in the American Civil War. That was taken as an affront at the time.

Yeah. Yeah. I've seen Stone Mountain. So I guess it would call Stone Mountain a relief, right?

Because it's not a full sculpture. It's like a carving that just barely comes out from the rock. Is that a fair way to describe it? Yeah.

I think so. And that's what you started describing some of the stuff in Rushmore and Crazy Horse that I never thought about. And that's why I was so interested in this topic. And I was like, please quit talking so we can turn mics on.

So can you, in my mind, Mount Rushmore, I've never been, but it's like in the middle of this wide open plain. I'm assuming South Dakota, you live there now. I'm assuming it's a big plain. There's nothing interesting in South Dakota, right?

Except Mount Rushmore. Right. Except Mount Rushmore. It's interesting stuff.

We'll talk about that. Continue with your theory. So in my mind, you drive up over this long flat area like Kansas or something like that. I don't know what I'm talking about.

No, Black Hills. So maybe it's rolling hills. But you come up on this area and you see it off in the distance and you get closer and closer. There's a bunch of trees and Yogi the Bears hanging out.

And it's just like this really old, I don't know, like Jelly Stone National Park. Yes, ish. Okay. Most of South Dakota is high plains.

It's the transition place between the Midwest, highly agricultural and the West, ranching and then up into the high country. So your last batch of mountains from the Rocky Mountain range is this weird little island. The mountains called the Black Hills. That's where I live.

The northern end of the Black Hills are the result of just a geologic uplift and volcanic activity. So they're just, I mean, they're mountains. I had 7,000 some feet in elevation. It's like a 5,000 foot rise from the flat stuff below.

So it's pretty legitimate mountains. I mean, it's not like Rocky Mountain National Park or the Tetons, but it sure feels like mountains when you're in here. And the central and southern part of the Black Hills are more like those kind of bulbous granite formations. That's obviously bulbous is not a technical word.

Can you picture what I'm describing? Yeah. Like a zit ready to pop on the topography. It's like this big rock sticking out of nowhere.

Yes. And nothing grows out of it. It's just a big naked chunk of granite, but they're not, they're not like jagged and mean looking like something from like some sort of evil overlords hideout. They're rounded from time.

And it's like looking at clouds. When you look at those kind of rock formations, you see stuff in them, you know, squirrels or people's faces or I don't know, like when you like when you look at clouds and you can see an alligator in there and umbrella or whatever, it's like that. But it's a whole chunk of land that's that way. And so I can totally see how back in the day somebody would come along in these hills and be, you know, going around bends and through little canyons and passes and see these rocks and be picturing stuff up there.

And this guy, I think his name was Gutsim Borglum. I'm trying to say his name fast. So you can't tell that I don't actually know what all the consonants are. He worked out some kind of deal.

He's like, I want to put some presidency United States up in this one particular set of rocks that looks like it would handle four portraits really nicely. So see like an artist or sculptor? What was his deal? Well, sculptor is definitely the profession that would be attached to him, but I don't know, master of logistics, mountain climber, businessman.

I mean, really, what would it take to buy a mountain and then mobilize enough people to carve four giant heads into it? That's a lot of talent. It's a lot of overlapping skills. Remember the four presidents who were on there, right?

Yeah, it'd be Washington, Jefferson, Abe Lincoln, and Teddy Roosevelt. Yes, the first Roosevelt. Yeah. So Roosevelt doesn't really stand in with the rest because you got like Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln.

They're like guys in the 1800s that did huge things, right? But Teddy Roosevelt's got Washington's earlier. Yeah, I'm sorry. Yeah, you're right.

But Teddy Roosevelt, is he there because of all he did to preserve the National Park? Is that why he is there? You know, I don't know, but I sat there and wondered that myself. When you go to Mount Rushmore and they give you the little information book later, my kids do the Junior Ranger program at any National Park, any National Monument.

Did you know that exists, by the way? Yeah, Emily Grassley talks about it quite often. Like if she finds a fossil in a National Park, she'll go report it to a Ranger and they give her a badge. It's really cute.

Okay. Yeah, well my kids do that too. You can fill out this little thing and you answer questions and then they swear you in. They're like, I'll take care of the National Parks and be responsible and respectful.

And my kids love it. They've got a stack of badges from all of these different places. Well, while the kids were filling that out, all the questions that were asked about Washington, Jefferson, and Lincoln were very obvious. Like, oh, he's up there because he liberated the slaves and won the Civil War and preserved the Union.

And he just listens up there because he's like this great mind that figured out Western liberalism and how to do freedom and democratic republic and Washington's up there because he resisted the impulse toward political parties and power and they wanted to make him a king and he wouldn't do it and he was a great general. But then Roosevelt's a little bit trickier. It's kind of all over. It sort of depends on who you talk to.

He was the trust buster. He's the guy who used the power of the state to fight back against oppressive monopolies. Well, it's not that interesting to a kid who wants a badge but it's part of his legacy. He's the guy who charged San Juan Hill and fought in the Caribbean.

He's the guy who speaks awfully and carry a big stick. He had a whole bunch of very formative foreign policy stuff. He's the guy that didn't shoot a bear out of a tree. Yeah, and he's the guy who had the idea to preserve all this land in the West.

So I think your guess is good. Which is the best idea America has ever had, by the way. It's an incredible idea. Why would you say that?

Because, I mean, the idea of, well, we have all these resources. Let's just take the land and rape it and do whatever we can with it right now and use this land for whatever we want immediately. The idea of preserving something to cast forward to future generations, I mean, that's selfless but it's also beautiful and it creates a better world in the long term. Like a capacitor, it's like moving some of the energy that we have now and preserving it for future generations.

I mean, it's kind of upside down for what you would think capitalism would want to do. And I just think it's beautiful. It's just such a great idea. Yeah, did you know that basically Grand Teton National Park and a big junkie Yellowstone were just donated by a super rich guy?

Really? Yeah, Rockefeller. When you go to the Teton's or Yellowstone, you drive on the Rockefeller Parkway. That's the road.

I did not realize that. John D. But I don't know for sure that that's the member of the family. Yeah.

So I agree. I think it's a brilliant idea. You know, got on there. Maybe he was just there at the right time.

The other three stand out as more remarkable presidents to me than Roosevelt, but I'm not criticizing Roosevelt. It's any Roosevelt fans out there. I googled Rushmore to see what it looked like. And something that never occurred to me is I found a wide shot.

And at the bottom of the mountain there or the side of the hill or whatever that is, I don't really have a sense of scale. At the bottom of it, there's just a big pile of rocks. Yeah. And it never occurred to me what happened to the rocks as they chip them off of the mountain to make these statues or make these portraits.

I guess they just left them at the bottom of the mountain. Is that what happened? Sure what it looks like to me. Yeah, there's just a big rubble pile down there.

But it's interesting rock because it's all honey combed. You can see where they used the pneumatic drills to punch into the rock and then dynamite it. So it's all got this cool pattern to it that you'd never see in nature, obviously. Really?

Yeah. You mean like the rubble has that pattern? Right. Yeah.

Every single rock, well, not every single rock, but tons of those rocks. I mean, you can see where the blasting occurred and the drilling occurred to put the charges in there in what's left over. Oh, that's cool. Something I'm concerned about is when you start carving into a material, like woodworkers would know this just naturally by feel or tile.

Like as you cut tile, you know, you've like tile floors and stuff, right? I have. So as you cut a tile, you know that if there's an imperfection on the inside of that tile, you always risk as you're making the cut just the whole tile breaking in half. Yes.

So something that's always scared me about stone statues and things like that is when you're chiseling, maybe there's a fissure that you can't see and all of a sudden like half the, you know, Washington's nose breaks off or something, something you're not expecting. Right. Like, did they talk about that at all? At the exhibits?

Okay, they didn't. But there's another giant sculpture I want to tell you about. So I'll tie a bow on Mount Rushmore and then I'll answer that question. It's amazing that you bring that up.

I mean, that's enormously intuitive. Did you ever see North by Northwest with Cary Grant? Nope. That's worth your time.

Third chair. That's worth your time. That is a neat old adventure, high stakes, like almost it's not a spy adventure, but it has that feel to it. It ends up at Mount Rushmore and it ends up at Mount Rushmore in the old days of Mount Rushmore when it was all outfitted to look like kind of old faithful.

Have you been to Yellowstone yet? I still haven't, man. I feel shame in that, but no, I haven't. Man, I mean, you got out to the West to see me one time, but it literally required alignment to force celestial bodies to make that happen.

I mean, that's more than it took for the wise men to go see B.P. Cheese says, we got to get you out here dude. We need to tour the West. I know.

How do you picture old faithful, like architecturally? Old faithful in my head is just like maybe some hills around the outside, like a bowl kind of thing. And then down in the bottom, there's just like this flat area and a geyser that you can just walk up and maybe there's like a little rope around it with some, like, or maybe a chain that keeps you from getting into the little geyser pool. That's in my head.

That's what it looks like. Okay. Yeah. Yeah.

You're in the zip code. It is kind of a basin. And all the architecture there is this 19th century gigantic log timber construction. It's just gorgeous breathtaking.

Mount Rushmore used to look like it was at woodsy, timbery, piney, mountain goats wandering around kind of construction. It was very homey and folksy and it kind of accentuated the idea that these guys are citizen presidents and they're not, you know, professional dictators or something. They did their little term and they were done. And I really liked the way it worked.

And then at some point they bulldozed all of that. They came in and they put up polished granite, Greek God pantheon marble stuff and it doesn't resonate as well with me now. But just down the street, there's another monument just down the street, like 30 miles, a little further south than the black hills to the Native American leader, Crazy Horse. Have you ever heard of him?

Yeah, I mean, there's these Native American leaders or Indian leaders that hear about all the time, Crazy Horse sitting bull, people like that. But I don't really know what they did. I mean, I don't know what he's known for and obviously he's a hero of some type. But I don't know what he did other than he's just this big figure in history in the back of my mind.

But please tell me what he did. Yeah, and that's reasonable because I think this is the kind of thing that is going to be taught more in schools if you kind of live out in this neck of the woods the same way when I go to Alabama, I'm learning a zillion things about local history that I've never heard about here. That's pretty common knowledge to you guys having grown up there. So no shame on not having the Crazy Horse details.

I don't have them all either. Was Crazy Horse at the Battle of Wounded Knee? A little big horn. Little big horn.

A little famous battle he was at. Okay, gotcha. So the Battle of Little Big Horn, that is 1876. Yeah, very good.

George Armstrong Custer was the guy who fought there. And what's so remarkable about that battle is that it was a crushing defeat for the American cavalry and essentially a complete and total victory and annihilation victory for the Lakota, the Sioux, the Cheyenne, the Arapaho, I think that's right. But the Lakota Sioux for sure. Crazy Horse was the guy who was like, hey, enough of this crap.

I can see the writing on the wall. This is never going to end. The whites, the Americans are going to continue to push west and eventually everything about us. It just doesn't jive with the future of where all this is headed.

So after the Sand Creek Massacre, which happened in Colorado in the 1860s where some Jack Wagon military commander just went off on his own as his captains didn't even want to go along with it. They didn't fire. But this one dude, Shivington was his name just murdered like 600 and some women and children and a few dudes were there to change the 1864 Sand Creek Massacre. Have you heard of that before?

No, I haven't. I'm telling you that Sand Creek Massacre doesn't happen and maybe this whole story plays out differently. It was so pivotal because the people who got killed at Sand Creek were overwhelmingly sympathetic to working out some kind of long term mega plan that could make this whole thing work in the western half of the United States. Like obviously it was never going to go back to the have roaming tribes covering huge swaths of land.

But the plans that were cropping up and that there was some momentum for, they would have worked a lot better than what ended up happening. And this bloodthirsty shittington guy who unfortunately was a Christian minister, he ignored the advice of his subordinates. He can't fire on them. This isn't a war party that we're not here to fight.

And he sent his men in and they just, the accounts are horrifying of what happened there. Is it congressional hearings? Shivington was utterly condemned for his behavior and all of this goes on record. And so the whole crazy horse thing is like a 10 year long retribution for what broke down and fell apart after the Sand Creek Massacre.

So crazy horse then, he's kind of like this embodiment of the spirit of the Native American West and being like, look, we were willing to play ball but not like this and we're just not going down without a fight. And boy, did he go down with a fight, just an incredible warrior by all accounts from both sides of the conflict. And he died in a cowardly way. He was arrested and I guess was going to be tried at Fort Robinson in Western Nebraska.

And people claimed that he tried to escape but basically he just got bayoneted in the back by some guy. So crazy horse is a pretty, a pretty deer figure to the Native Americans of the West. Wait, wait, wait, who killed crazy horse? Some guy, some low ranking dude who was doing a prisoner transfer at Fort Robinson in Western Nebraska near Scott's bluff.

And that's kind of it. Yeah, I mean, I'm silent because I'm like, why, why did he, why did he kill him? This sounds kind of like when Archimedes was killed in Syracuse, just like some soldier walks in and he's an idiot and you know, Archimedes is like, don't disturb my circles. And he just gets speared.

You remember that story? No, I've never heard that story. Archimedes, he's just working. Yeah, yeah, they were, they were being invaded by the Romans, I believe.

And he's in his house chilling, I guess. And he's working on some math and Archimedes math was incredible. I found a book of it the other day and I looked at it and I was like, whoa, whoa, whoa. I thought he just like tied some strings around trees and then approximated pie but this choker was doing like a hardcore geometry.

And so this Roman soldier walks in and Archimedes is like riding stuff on the ground. He says, don't disturb my circles. That's the famous quote. I'm googling it my circles.

I believe that's it. Yeah. No Lee to her barre circulars meos. I don't know what that means.

According to, that was the phrase uttered by the ancient Greek mathematician and astronomer Archimedes when Romans conquered the city and they killed him. Anyway, that sounds like just some soldier that doesn't know the gravity of the situation, just killed crazy horse without really understanding what he was doing. Is that the way it fell apart in your mind? That's the way the story has always felt to me.

And I've been to all of these places. I've been to Little Big Horn on more than one occasion. I've been to Fort Robinson. This is like my story.

This is what I grew up around. And frankly, I don't know, you've been to the wind Indian reservation with me. That is where we watched the eclipse happen. We were on the reservation and that is in a Rapa Ho and Shoshone reservation.

So the story overlaps with you too, even in how it played out that we had to make the clever maneuvers we made to get on the land to watch the eclipse. Wow. Okay. So yeah, I think there was a way better way this could have played out and it played out very ugly and continues, I think, to be just difficult and hurtful and tough.

But crazy horse is cool. He fought back other people, you know, it's kind of like a Xavier and Magneto. Other people took the Xavier approach and we're like, now we have to negotiate and work this out. And he's like, after Tancree, screw it, I'm going full Magneto approach.

And so he fought and I can't blame him for fighting. So crazy horse did. My place I'd fight back to. Yeah.

Yeah, crazy horse. If you ever thought about that, like all of the energy of your mind, like in the peaceful tendencies that you have and the desire for peace and all that, have you ever thought what would happen if just everything breaks and you were to apply your whole force of being for not evil, but like military strength? Have you ever thought about that? I think that's the premise of the Punisher, right?

Frank Castle, like he loses everything and he applies all of his skills in mind. I'm not talking about moving. I'm talking about you. Have you ever thought about that?

Well, yeah, and I'm saying I have when I watched the Punisher, like that made me think about it. Like what if you had nothing, but you were still alive and you put all your mind toward violence or revenge or straightening out some kind of wrong, I tend to think of it when I'm not watching the Punisher. I tend to gain that out more in the post-apocalyptic, what if everything broke and I loved everybody, I lost everybody I loved. What would I do?

How would I survive? Where do you go? Who do you associate with? I don't know.

It sounds like I haven't gained it out as much as maybe you have, but yeah, it's across my mind. What do you think about it? Yeah, I've gained it out. I've gained it out.

I want to be in. Yeah, you know, if, for example, when you think about all these past wars in the past and you think about obviously the past wars in the past, but you think about these people that were put in impossible situations and they were like, well, we're going to do this to all of your family and I guess you could fight if you want to, but there's no way you're going to win. And like what you would do as a person to figure out how to survive and how to, you know, just think about World War II and the French people that were, you know, the nation surrendered very quickly, but you had all these people that were sabotaging things and it's just, I don't know, this, I hope I'm never put in a situation like that ever, but I've, I can imagine how a person like Crazy Horse would try to work things out correctly, you know, with honor and then realize at some point, oh, it's not going to work. We've got to play by their rules and I'm going to be better at them at their game.

That's, that's kind of the impression I get. Yeah, if they speak violence, I'll speak violence. That seems to be his response, right, which I'm not a fan of, but it's really hard for me to condemn his actions. Why not fight back?

It's the situation where you sit there and do nothing, like watching my team down nine points with five and a half minutes to go in the fourth quarter of a football game and it's fourth and four from the 50 yard line and they punt. It's like, oh, you just decided to lose him for third chair members who don't speak football. That's just the equivalent of rolling over going down without a fight. And I don't think I'd want to do that.

I mean, this guy was smart. He could read the writing on the wall and he knew it was going to go down probably one way or the other. So he chose to go down with a fight and I respect it. And this guy who carved this crazy horse monument, no, carved isn't the right word, man, because crazy horse isn't done.

Had you heard that there was a monument to him that was going up in the black hills? Yes, I have. And I heard it was huge. Huge brother.

Like I've heard that Mount Rushmore could fit in his armpit. Wow. So the sculpture itself is a general likeness of crazy horse. Nobody is really sure what he looked like.

Some of the pictures that it's claimed are crazy horse or disputed. So it's kind of this image of the determination of the Native American resistance in the West that that's the expression they put on his face and only his face is done. But what it's going to be is this Native American leader on horseback pointing forward and like his hair and the horse's mane and all of that is getting carved in this mountain. And again, Mount Rushmore fits in the armpit.

It's nuts. So do you have to pay a mark there? You ask the right questions. No, you pay for admission.

So you can see the thing dang well from the road, but you pay to go in. We paid 30 bucks to take my family of five. And the reason I didn't care one bit is because it's totally privately funded. This guy, his name is Korshak Zolkowski.

Maybe it's his last name. I feel like I put your last name. That's Korshak is his first name though. He's the dude who decided to carve the thing and the government came along and was like, here's 10 million to help make that happen.

And maybe they were there with the right motives. I don't know. But he's like, no, no, I'm not taking 10 million dollars of money from the government who did this to commemorate what that government did. No, it's going to be funded privately.

And so he's never taken a penny of any kind of state funding at all to make this monument. So for me, paying 30 bucks to go in there and park and walk around. It's like, I don't feel bad about that at all. I helped build that thing by paying my 30 bucks.

You know, so you're saying that, well, first of all, how long is it taking to do this? Like how long has this thing been going? Yeah. About that.

It's going to take a minute. I think he started in the 1940s. He courtys, yeah, courtys was. So he's dead.

He's dead. He died in 1982. Okay. And he was from maybe Boston, Connecticut, something like that, and met some Native American leaders and they were like, we would like you to make a monument to the Native American West.

And he's a great sculptor as a kid. Great sculptor, man. He did. I'm talking a lot of it.

Are you still like, is it cool if I tell you a little bit more about this guy or am I getting into it? Yeah, go ahead. I mean, I would like more specifics. You're kind of, I can feel the emotion, but I'm not, I'm not learning an incredible amount because I just want to know more about like the specifics of it.

If that makes any sense. Sure. I'll tell you the specifics about the guy. Hey, this episode of No Dumb Questions is brought to you by Hello Fresh and get mouth watering seasonal recipes and pre-measured ingredients delivered right to your door with Hello Fresh.

America's number one meal kit. Hello Fresh makes cooking at home fun, easy and affordable. What's the cool stuff about Hello Fresh buddy? Well, it's delicious.

Did I tell you I have a new Hello Fresh meal that is now my favorite? No. Yeah, I do and you need to try it. It's called Tuscan, sausage and pepper spaghetti.

I don't know how you are on spicy stuff, but this isn't spicy. It's like right at the edge of spicy, but not actually spicy, but I cook this thing and I hoarded the leftovers so that only I could eat it because it was that good. This Tuscan sausage spaghetti might take over the steak and sass. It might.

It's pretty impressive. Okay. Okay. I don't want to ask you to settle down because I'm really glad you're excited about it.

But that steak and sass is pretty special. I know what I said. What I like about the thing is that it's quick. I'm reading a statistic here that the average time to go to the grocery store.

There's an instant a group called the time institute. They measure these things. 41 minutes to go to the grocery store for normal person, which is like 35 hours a year, I'm told. And this just shows up at my place and then I cook it 30 minutes.

I have to think. I don't have to know what kind of ingredients to get or shop through those. And it simplifies life enormously. That's probably the thing that has helped my family the most about this is it makes the chaos go away.

Here's some other data that I have. Okay. There's finally been a study done by the University of Michigan and turns out it is basically more sustainable to use HelloFresh. They said that your carbon footprint is 25% lower than store bought grocery meals.

Plus you don't waste as much food. I thought that was awesome. It's actually more sustainable to use HelloFresh. Yeah.

I certainly don't waste as much food when I cook with the pre-measured ingredients. That's for sure. Well, and the other thing that's efficient is the flexibility factor just not having to be locked into a thing forever, but instead having the ability to get it when you want it and when you're traveling, like I'm going to be here coming up for a little bit. You come to visit.

Turn the thing off. You come to visit. I am awesome. I'm absolutely coming down to visit.

Pause that HelloFresh and come visit my friend. That's going to be awesome. I will pause the HelloFresh. I will come visit and we will play basketball and racquetball.

Yeah, racquetball. We got to play racquetball. We need to go to like an inner city league. Heck yeah.

Let's do it. Let's totally do that. That's going to be fun. Yeah.

I don't know, man. I like your chances at the racquetball because it's all angles and I feel like of the two of us, you think more of those categories than me. I'm going to level with you. I can make the ball go into the corner and come out if there were no spin on the ball, but because it's so sticky and it changes direction when it bounces.

I can't figure it out. Okay. If you want to try HelloFresh because it's amazing and you should and it's good for everything. You can do this by going to hellofresh.com and use the code indikute10 during HelloFresh's new year sale for 10 free meals including free shipping.

Again, that's HelloFresh.com and it's awesome. You should totally do this. It seems like they keep making it better, man. They do.

It's only 566 per serving now. It's like they're honing the craft of getting delicious meals to your house. Anyway, give it a shot. That supports the podcast.

It supports us and we appreciate it. Again, that's HelloFresh.com slash ndq10 for 10 free meals including free shipping. Thanks, HelloFresh for supporting us. Thanks everybody who buys HelloFresh and indirectly supports podcast through that.

Tusken sausage pepper spaghetti. That's the one. So, of course, Jack, he became a sculptor. He was a very young man.

He was just gifted for it and he liked to carve things out of things as opposed to, you know, like use clay to build things out of nothing, the contrast we were discussing. It's additive, like additive sculpture instead of attractive. Yeah. Yeah.

And his studio and housed in it still in his original log studio from the 1940s are a bunch of things that he sculpted along the way. And one of them is made out of driftwood from Boston Harbor and it's called like Old Pagan or something like that. And it's a super old dude. This thing must have been sculpted around the World War II, something like that.

And it's this shirtless sailor who apparently eccentrically memorized all of Shakespeare and then famously would just quote entire plays at sea as he sailed in and out of Boston Harbor in the 1800s and early 1900s. And right at the end of his life, Courshack went and met this guy and sculpted him and it was so moving. It was like a connection over time between me and this dude. I'll never meet because we weren't even close to living at the same time.

But I did overlap lifetime wise with course check. And I guess what I'm saying is his sculpture was powerful enough to make me feel things in an image, to make me think about time and my life and the timelessness of art. And so to take something like that and to try to blow it up to a scale that's maybe the biggest carved monument on earth, I would have to think it is, is an enormous undertaking, but it's working, dude. Crazy horse.

His face is done. And the expression is already emotionally powerful. So whatever the case, course, I worked on that face for ages and brought his family on board and it's gone slow because they're not, they're not taking public money, but they think maybe another generation or two is what it's going to take, maybe a hundred, 150 year sculpture processes, what they're looking at. That's amazing.

Were they actively like, ting, ting, ting, were they sculpting the day you were there? Yeah. Yeah. People were working.

I mean, it was a cold day. It was middle of winter. But you remember you asked about fissures or faults within, within whatever you're carving and how do you account for that? We were talking about Rushmore.

So joining the pin in that, that was one of the things they were talking about as they were carving. They're like, right now we're trying to take account of what's going on. Inside the rock here on the arm and we're using this technology and that technology and it wasn't explained in detail to detect where weaknesses or problem spots might be. So we don't break something we can't ever fix.

So somehow they are accounting for that. That's cool. That's really cool. Yeah.

And you kind of picture like people with chisels, right? But you look up on his arm and there's like gigantic bulldozers and excavators. You can play football on his arm. I think if you wanted to, it's just like an aircraft carrier deck.

Maybe land a small plane on his outstretched arm. It's incredible. Yeah. I'm looking at the, I've got some dimensions here.

It looks like the arm is 263 feet long. That's nuts. Almost football. Yeah.

That's crazy. So this is a feather. So there's a feather going to go in his head. Is that going to be made out of like, what does that mean?

Yeah, I can't tell if it's a feather or if it's like his hair in like kind of thick locks flowing backwards. Yeah. I don't know for sure. But here's what's amazing, man.

They're going to put this plaque that's going to be like the size of your house flipped on its side and stuck on the side of a mountain. They're carving this out of the side of the mountain and the plaque or some words that Courshack wrote something like, you say we're without land, but my land is wherever my people died, wherever my people are buried. So with that plastered on the side of the mountain and crazy horse pointing off into the distance, my lands are where my dead library. That's a line.

That's it's powerful. Essentially, this whole statue or monument is just a big middle finger to the United States. What do you say? Maybe in a good way.

There's a ton of things I love about the United States. But yeah, I think I think what it's trying to say is we aren't conquered because we can't be conquered because our lands are where our dead library. Got you. It's a memorial in the truest sense of the word.

It's a, you know, it's it's something that will go forward to future generations and like, whoa, who would carve such a crazy thing? Yeah. And is that what you think when you see a school? I mean, how quickly does your brain go to?

Wow, that's really pretty. And then skip forward to why would somebody do that? What must have been the circumstances that would make someone invest this in this? So we recently went to New York and my daughter wanted to go to Ellis Island because she has read, she's read books about Ellis Island about immigration and all these types of things.

And it was just very interesting to her. So before we went to Ellis Island, we would start to go to the Statue of Liberty, which is on an adjacent island. It's called Liberty Island. And just the whole idea of, you know what, we're going to take a lot of money and we're going to create this huge statue.

Just that in itself is fascinating. That's interesting because that as a whole culture, you have to come together and be like, you know what, we could buy corn or wheat or make machines or airplanes with this, but we're going to set it aside and we're going to make a thing that outlives us. That in itself takes a certain amount of forethought cooperation. It takes a lot.

And what's so interesting about the Statue of Liberty is that it was done by the French. The French did it for America. Yeah, it was the present, right? Yes, it was a gift.

The way they did it was really interesting. They created the statue in France. There's this guy, Frederick Bartoli. He created this thing and he just, he was his idea.

He really wanted to make this huge thing. It's called officially Liberty and Lightning the World, which most people call it. That's the name of it. Yeah, it's called Liberty and Lightning the World.

It's not the Statue of Liberty. I know, yeah. That's the title of it. But you're telling me that it was not made by Gustav Eiffel.

I was the Eiffel Tower guy, it's the one who did the Statue of Liberty. No, no, no, Bartoli was the guy. Like he was the guy that designed it. He came up with it, but he reached out to the Eiffel guy for the structural engineering on the inside.

He was like, Hey, I need help. I'm really good at this. You're really good at that. Let's work together.

Like the base of the Statue of Liberty, that was made by America. There was a famous architect. Let me find out who knew it. This is funny as you're looking it up because again, it was a gift from France.

I knew Eiffel was involved somehow, but it's almost so iconic that I've never actually thought about the thing about the Statue of Liberty. I was said it was on Ellis Island. I didn't even have that right. Morris Hunt is the guy that designed the pedestal for the Statue of Liberty.

And what was so fascinating is they were in correspondence together. So there were there were drawings that went back and forth between the US and France. And they, you know, he was like, I don't know, that pedestal looks okay, but that one's not, I don't know about that. And so finally, the challenge was you had to make a pedestal that was really good looking, if you will, but didn't eclipse the statue itself.

You wanted it to compliment the statue, but not overpower it. And I think I think Hunt did a great job with that. Anyway, the Statue of Liberty is fascinating. It was done with copper and the process was fascinating.

So they created a small statue and then they set up a trust structure around it. Like when I say small statue, like very tiny, you know, something that you and I could approach and like hold a ruler up to and start looking at and things like that. But they like life size or smaller. Right.

But what they did is they created these boards. Like if you can imagine boards above the statue and you could take like a level across those boards and then drop a plumbop down from the top of that board and you could measure the length of the string and you could measure over this much. And so what they would do is they would extrapolate the small dimensions from the statue to the larger dimensions. Have you ever done 3D printing?

Have you ever done any type of additive manufacturing at all? Have you ever done anything like that? No, I've watched Joel's channel a little bit 3D printing nerd, but I'm not done it myself. Yeah, there's so many neat things about 3D printing.

But one thing that just the simple geometry of it's interesting. You have XYZ coordinates and you can you can scale it up and scale it down, things of that nature. So just the process of seeing the small statue and how they made these dimensions and then they just scaled it up. They literally multiplied by a scalar and then they had to create these forms.

And so for example, the toenail for the Statue of Liberty, you have to make a reverse toe out of wood and then you take these copper sheets and you hammer these these copper sheets into that reverse toe made out of wood. That's how you do it. And then you go on the inside and you create what they did originally is they had these iron straps that they would put in there and these iron straps they would bolt to the copper. It's fascinating.

But if you think about the shape of the inside of a statue like that, it's not like a cylinder. So you can't just, you know, radially bolt a strap, whatever it is, 10 meters in diameter. You can't radially pull things and strap it. You have to make each individual piece custom because the statue is so complicated.

You with me? OK, I was with you to the last phrase. You have to make each individual piece custom. Are you saying that the statue itself is made of several pieces later assembled?

Yes, exactly. Each individual piece. OK, all right, I'm tracking them. Yes, but so there's two components to it.

There's the outside structure that's made out of copper. That's the outer shell. And then there's the internal structure. I've all made that, but you have to connect those two together.

So you get the trust work on the inside. You have the special outside, but you have to have a physical, like material interface between the copper and that inner, the inner truss structure. And so those are straps that they would create and they would bolt them in place. Or in some cases, they're still there.

Yeah, in the 80s, they redid it. They're like, Oh, we've got all this iron on the inside here, but, you know, it's not, it's not watertight. So the inside of the statue leaks. So they went back in the 80s and they completely redid the inner workings of that.

With stainless steel that had to have been hundreds of dollars. Yeah, I mean, yeah, dozens, dozens of dollars, but what was really cool about it is they again, right there, but again, right there, somebody made a cultural decision to spend unfathomable amounts of money on a statue. And we got to come back to why because that was a great question. You asked, sorry, continue.

Yeah, what's really interesting is when they did that, though, they got French craftsmen to come over and do it because it was originally a gift from the French. And when they went back on the inside and they redid the internal workings, that the French did that as well, which is awesome. Isn't that cool? I didn't know.

I was going to say I'm embarrassed. I'm not embarrassed. It's okay to not know things. It's okay to not know things that are in plain sight.

I just didn't know any of that. And it's a healthy reminder for how many gaps I have, what I know about even my own country's past, but no, that's fascinating. I mean, now you mentioned it. I do remember kind of, was there an unveiling ceremony or something in the late 80s or maybe early 90s when they finished all of that restoration stuff?

I think I remember seeing all the scaffolding and everything as a kid, but I've never been to the island itself. I've only seen it from a ways away. Did you guys go to the island itself? Yeah, we went to the island itself.

I've never been up in the statue. This is the second time I've been to the island. And I think I appreciated it a lot more this time because I had a little bit more engineering knowledge this time than when I went the first time. I think I went when I was in college then, but I've taken a lot of a lot of classes and grad school since then about stresses and things of that nature.

So I really appreciated it for what it was this time, a whole lot more, but it's one thing to appreciate the mechanical design and just the grand scale of something like this and just the social willpower it takes and the political willpower it takes to make something like this. Like it, if I understand correctly, he sold bonds to do it, I may be getting that wrong, but it's just fascinating the way it all went down. But I really find it fascinating for what it represents. Like just across the water there at Ellis Island, you had people that were waiting in line just this grand hall in Ellis Island where people were like literally waiting in queues to be registered as immigrants.

And you could see our last name has probably changed there. They're really well, I mean, maybe yours, maybe mine. I don't know when the sandlands made it to this continent, but when the Whitman's left England, at least some of them, their last name was our last name was white man, W. I G H T M A N.

But as I told you before, my family had a run in religiously and politically with the crown and gradually we relocated, I think, in part, because of that, at least, I mean, they burned my granddaddy to death for thinking the wrong stuff about Jesus. So you know, they really, you can't. Yeah. I'm directly descended from the last guy to be burned at the stake for religious offense in the UK.

Oh, wow. But the last name was pronounced white men and spelled white men. And so I don't know if it was at Ellis Island that that change actually happened, but I know a whole lot of people effectively received a new name as they passed through that place. And I mean, that's almost biblical at that point.

Like you receive this new name and you're this new person for all of eternity, moving forward as just how many stories got rewritten as they waited in that whole that you're describing. It's a fascinating place. Oh, yeah. The hall was interesting, man.

I really, I don't know. I spent a lot of time there. We, we as a family, we went to it and we just like separated there. We're like, okay, cool.

I could tell that my daughter was bothered a little bit by being there. She was on edge and I didn't really understand why. And I think she'd read a lot of books. I'm not privy to.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 39 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on January 17, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.