Okay, dude, we've been covering all different types of topics here. Some of my favorite topics are when I get to wait off into your territory. We talked about the Siege of Vienna, we talked about Monfer and Von Richthofen, the Red Baron, all these things. Antikytherm mechanism.
Yeah, Antikytherm mechanism. None of them, all these things. That's all your area. Sure.
That's all history, stuff like that. Today, we're going to play in my sandbox. Awesome. Yeah, this is something you've been wanting to do for a while ever since you knew I took the class.
Would you like to set it up and then I'll tell you who we're going to talk to? Yeah. You hit me up with some really creative exam questions probably a year ago. And there was a lot going on.
We were both busy and stuff. You'd be like, no, no, you need to read this. You send me like a maybe a screenshot or you read a question to me, what is this class? You know, this is my nuclear propulsion class.
I don't know. Was that what it's called? Fusion propulsion. Fusion propulsion.
Yeah. And naturally that melted my brain because I don't know that stuff works. But it was fun to listen to you talk about it and describe it. And then we talked to Don Pettit at length a couple years back when he was in town.
It was kind of fun to hear his musings about propulsion. I just never really thought about a bunch of the stuff that you kept bringing up as you were going through the class. And you were clearly having your mind opened and it was really fun. I kind of went in.
Can we do an episode where we talk about fusion propulsion? I try to learn a little bit too. Yes. And so that's what I've arranged today.
So to be clear, when you look at the academic calendar or all the course selections that are possible on your course of study, we're on the very, very far right side of my stuff. So this is a 795 class. So like you're a freshman, you're taking the 101 classes, you move on through. Like when you're graduating undergrad, you're taking the 400 level.
This is 795. It's like one of the last things in the book you've taught in school before. So you know, like when you're in that class, there's fewer people and the rules are a little bit different, right? I would say they're more relaxed and the focus is more on understanding and you are this like wizard of a professor and you're trying to like train other professors or something like that.
That's kind of the impression I get. Yeah. The wizard trying to make more wizards. Wizards trying to make more wizards.
Yes. My graduate advisor told me at one point that, you know, at this level, once you get into this place in this program, you aren't out in the world being a professional yet, but you are a professional in this particular discipline or course of study. And so he's like, look, I'm not going to do anything moving forward to get you to do things. Just nothing.
I assume you're here because you're curious and this is what you want to do and you can't help it be here. And if that turns out not to be the case, you will know to move on. And so yeah, it's very, very different than the early goings of undergrad. Now I wouldn't say Dr.
Casabri did that. So it's Dr. Jason Casabri at the University of Alabama in Huntsville, which is known for the propulsion classes that they teach at the school is where I go. And Dr.
Casabri is a really interesting guy. He is well versed in all these things. He holds a lot of very high positions of standing in the field. So other people from other universities, if I said the name of the universities, you would recognize them, they all talk with Dr.
Casabri. Like there's this community and he's well respected in that community. And it's one of those weird things where I'm in the smaller town of Huntsville. Alabama, but because of our proximity to Marshall Space Flight Center, where they're doing all kinds of research on things you wouldn't believe.
If I told you we had some of these things in Alabama, you'd be like, yeah, right. But we do. Dr. Casabri works here because he has access to all those type of research projects.
So today what I'd like to do is I'm going to call Dr. Casabri. I'm going to patch him into this call. And I just want to start from ground zero and see if we can take you to fusion propulsion by the end of the episode.
You game? I'm more than game. I'm super excited. So, you know, the name of podcast, no dim questions.
You just trust me. Dr. Casabri, you don't have to like act like you know anything around him. He is the coolest dude.
But he's also wicked smart. And so he'll talk to you at whatever level you're at and he'll get you to the next level. So I'm going to call Dr. Casabri, get him on here and let's give the shot.
We say can't wait. Let's get him on the horn. Okay, Matt, you there? Yeah, you got me.
Okay. Dr. Casabri, you there? Yeah, Matt.
How are you? Hey, nice to meet you, Dr. Casabri. I'm doing great.
Yeah. Oh, yeah. Likewise. Likewise.
So I hear you were spear fishing today. That is my style. I don't know. They call I mean the town is called Spearfish, but I think you might actually get in trouble if you spearfish.
Right here, like literally a foot from my right hand, but I've never inflicted it on a fish. Yeah, I tend to do the fly ride thing. He's in Spearfish, South Dakota. That's a misledgy there.
No, I probably just quickly read it when I was here, okay? Yeah. I thought we were all playing along. That's awesome.
You believe that that's something I do regularly. So let me do a couple of intros real quick because I'm the common touch point between the three of us here. So, so Matt, this is Dr. Jason Casabri and I'll do a little bit more intro for him in just a second.
But Dr. Casabri, this is Matt Whitman. I've been a pastor for several years out in Wyoming recently moved over to South Dakota and Matt and I, we talked about all kinds of stuff under the sun. He's the humanities guy.
I'm the, I don't know if you'd say I'm the science guy, but we kind of bounce ideas off of each other, but we're really, we're really good friends and we connect on several different levels. And so I wanted to introduce you to because Matt has been wanting to learn about nuclear propulsion or fusion propulsion. But Matt, I want to tell you more about Dr. Casabri real quick.
So please, just so you understand the kind of person you're talking to here. Don't let how open and friendly Dr. Casabri is fool you. He's one of these guys that will quickly make you feel like a peer, but rest assured, we are not peers.
You know what I mean? I know the type. Yeah, I'm not going to agree with that statement, but that's very kind of you to say. So Dr.
Casabri and I have a really interesting history. So he and I first met when he was on the committee for my master's thesis and you know how you've got several, several people on the panel and you've got like, you know, your advisor and you've got the guy that, you know, it's his discipline and then you got this other person that's kind of like a, like a referee maybe? I don't know. So, like a third reader?
Yeah. Yeah, I guess so. I don't know how you do it in the sciences if it's the same way as we do it. So, you were not his first reader.
You were not his advisor. You were the extra guy that's in the room. Oh, I'm sorry. You were talking to me.
I thought you guys were going back and forth. Yeah. Yeah, basically. Yes, yes, yes.
Okay. So you were my, you were my doctor Peter Chah. I can track with that. Okay.
So there's more to Dr. Casabri that you need to know. So if you, like in the nuclear, like fusion world, and when it comes to propulsion, he's the guy and here at the University of Alabama in Huntsville, he has a whole device set up on a military installation. It's called Charger One, but he has a huge device that's an experimental fusion unit that he can use to test things.
And more than that, like if you were to write a paper in the history world, you would have like the people you take it to and they get it reviewed and all that stuff, right? Yep. So Dr. Casabri is that person for fusion propulsion.
There's an organization in the engineering world called AIAAA, the American Institute of, oh, help me, Dr. Casabri. American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics. Yep.
I'm supposed to know that I'm a member. And so, as long as you pay your dues, they don't care. They don't care. He's over the committee for nuclear and future flight stuff.
I mean, it's a big deal. Wow. So just recently, he was put in charge of that group and it's just a really big deal to talk to Dr. Casabri.
But the other thing about Dr. Casabri is, you know, last semester in the fall, I had an option of taking several different classes. And I decided to go with fusion propulsion because I like how he teaches and he's a reasonable professor. And, but he also doesn't cut you slack.
So, yeah, that's what a reasonable professor does. Yeah. Yeah, it's a definition. Yeah, it's a really interesting dynamic.
But I don't know, how was that Dr. Casabri? Was that acceptable? Oh, I thought that was a really great description.
Yeah, thank you. Yeah. So, I feel pretty honored to have you jump on with us, Dr. Casabri.
I feel more honored now. It's an amazing resume. Congratulations on an incredible lineup of accomplishments. That's fantastic.
I appreciate it. And likewise, it's an honor to get invited to do this podcast with you guys. Well, it's appreciated. Yeah.
Let me ask you guys, can you hear that goalie washer that is rolling over my house right now? Can you hear the rain? No. Okay.
Well, for the third chair, it's rain. What are you going to do? There you go. So, what I think is really fun about this exercise is I like science.
I was right on the fence between going humanities or sciences when I went into undergrad. I mean, I really went to major in baseball. So what I studied was less consequential. And I decided to go with history because I liked the guy who I met who taught history classes.
And that ended up being kind of a fateful decision. But I continue to be really, really intrigued by your world, even if I don't speak the language and don't understand everything. And what I thought would be fun about this exercise would be to see if you guys can make sense of nuclear propulsion for a guy who knows literally nothing, just some schmoe off the street. I thought it'd be kind of a fun contest to see if I can understand anything at the end of this exercise.
I accept your challenge. And if it's not successful, then I'll own the failure. How about this? You do not yet understand the depths of my ineptitude.
Let's see how that goes. Yeah. So let me set this up here. So just to give you an idea of the way Dr.
Casper normally talks here, I'm looking at my final exam here. This is a question he wrote. And I'll just read it to you. Construct a Lindel Weidner diagram for magnetic fields of 0110 100 and 1000 Tesla for a DD plasma with a, I guess it's ROW RG basically with all these different parameters.
It's a long sentence that it's going to be hard to read in English. So I'm able to contours appropriately and explain the lower left bounds and how and why the magnetic fields and liner affects the results. So that's like question two of four. And so he's used the talking at that level.
But at the same time, what I enjoyed about the class is we can back it up and we can speak more top level broad. And I guess we could start with this map. What do you know about rockets? So we give Dr.
Casper a baseline here. Okay. Well, the rockets are normally fueled chemically, like I guess kind of the more complex version of what an engine, well, it's not an internal combustion engine because rockets move differently. It's the expulsion factor, right?
You are condensing down the release of energy to create thrust. Am I in the zip code? Yeah. Yeah, that's in the right ballpark.
Okay. That's the end. And they're shaped like hot dogs with fins on the end. They're, I think I've exhausted my knowledge.
Yeah. So I'll fill in just a little bit a bit and then I'll get out of the way. So like any vehicle, you have gas mileage, right? So you have the distance that you can travel with a certain amount of fuel.
And the problem with a rocket is that you can't refuel it once it leaves your planet. An ideal rocket would, you would leave the planet and you would constantly accelerate until you get it halfway and then you start decelerating. Like if you had infinite fuel and resources, that's what you would do. And you'd go faster and faster and faster.
And then you'd hit the brakes about halfway and start slowing down depending on if you were going to do a rendezvous or fly by or things like that. What's interesting about fusion propulsion is that it isn't real right now. Is that sick to say, Dr. Casabry?
We are fresh out of working fusion reactors. Yes. Okay. So Matt, do you know what fusion is?
Sure. Well, I mean, that's one of two processes, right? You got fusion and fission. These are both nuclear processes.
One puts together the other cuts in half at the level of the, well, it's nuclear. So at the level of the nucleus, is that a fair assumption? That's a pretty good description. Yeah.
I thought you said you didn't know anything. That's not bad. I'm just guessing based on what the words sound like so far. Oh, yeah.
Yeah. We have, I guess, three types of reactions that are common in, well, chemical is the common one for propulsion and we're working towards being able to do fusion. And fission is one that I think is going to see application in space in the next 10 years if we ever come out of this pandemic. Okay.
So chemical reactions are the things that you're used to your car, that's internal combustion and aircraft also does combustion and soda rockets. And that's the one that we deal with on a day to day basis. In fission, you use uranium or another heavy isotope, but usually uranium and it gets hit by a neutron and then it goes unstable and splits and that releases a lot of energy, a nuclear energy. And then in fusion, the fuels would be deuterium or tritium or proton and eleven boron and helium three.
Those are some of the more common fuels. And yes, they basically combine together and form heavier isotopes in general, but not always. And then they release a lot of energy as well. In the fusion scenario you described, why does that electron destabilize the uranium?
If I said electron, I misspoke, it's a neutron. I may have miss heard the neutron. Okay. And why does it do that?
That's a bit out of my area of expertise, but basically a nucleus has certain, I guess, configurations that provide a stable nucleus and it has to do with a mixture of the way the protons and the neutrons bond together individually and then in pairs and groups. Kind of like in chemistry, there are, I think, certain rules that sort of allow configurations to assemble together. And then if you throw a neutron in, depending on the isotope, it kind of messes up the configuration and then it just kind of falls apart. And why does that?
I don't know. The specific details I'm not sure of, but it has something to do with that. So I really can't answer your question in a very quantitative way, but... No, that's okay.
That's okay. I'm digging all the way back to like 11th grade here. So I'm sorry. There's going to be a lot of idiot questions, which according to the name of the podcast, there aren't.
So just to make sure I'm picturing everything properly, the electrons orbit the nucleus, right? But the protons are in the nucleus. So yeah, you have protons and neutrons in the nucleus. And a neutron has no charge.
Yeah. The neutron has no charge to it. The proton has a charge of plus one and then the electrons have a charge of minus one. So an ion is when it's not balanced.
Is that right? Yeah, that's correct. If it loses an electron, then it becomes a positively charged ion. Okay.
And uranium, that's like way up there on the periodic scales. There's a bunch of goofy stuff going on with those kind of elements, right? Oh, yeah. All the really high winds seem to have the name with EM in the end.
You bring up an interesting point, Matt, because when I started taking the class, I heard the word nuclear and I thought two things. I thought uranium and plutonium. Those are the two things I thought. Yeah.
When we started into the effort in the class, I noticed that all the math we were doing were for hydrogen and helium and deuterium and it's the small element. So it's the other side of the periodic table, which makes sense if you think about what you're doing. You following that? Well, help it makes sense to me.
Yeah. It stood out to me as well as we were just kind of running through that quick rundown on the fusion and fission side. But yeah, I thought it was all the elements as well. I don't understand why there would be advantage to working on the low end of the periodic table.
Oh, well, it's not obvious the answer to that question, but both into the periodic table sort of work in terms of having fuels for nuclear energy. And it has to do with how the isotopes are stable. And so iron, I think, is among the most stable species. And then if you go in either direction from iron on the periodic table, you start to have an opportunity for doing fission or fusion and releasing energy.
But it's only certain ones that actually are worthwhile because they're easier to induce those reactions, like deuterium and tritium on one end of the periodic table or uranium or plutonium on the other end. But your question as to why should we bother with fusion if fission works? Is that kind of the question you were asking? Well, yeah, I'm certainly curious about that.
And which one does the sun do? Is that fission? Yeah, the sun does fusion. So, fusion.
It fuses hydrogen and maybe to some lesser degree deuterium. I think it goes off of something called the carbon cycle. And different stars will have different fusion cycles and fuels depending on how big they are and what state they are in terms of their lifespan. But fission of the two nuclear reactions tends to be easier to do because if you have enough of U-235, that's the isotope that will undergo fission by itself, you have enough of it and then stir in some water and put it in a barrel.
It'll heat up, so it'll start undergoing reactions because it naturally decays and the neutrons that get kicked off will slow down from the water and they get reabsorbed by more uranium. And then the process will continue. If you have the right materials, making a reactor out of uranium is not hard. But the reason that we might want to go to fusion is because it kind of helps with the nuclear waste cleanup after the fact, at least in principle.
So, like with fission, you have fuel rods that you have to dispose of somewhere and then you get all of these activated components that you have to bury in concrete or do something with. And so, it becomes a very expensive hassle to deal with. Now, having said that, I'm not poo-pooing fission at all because fission produces a whole lot of energy and it's woefully underutilized. I think it has a better environmentally friendly footprint than a lot of other things.
We just have to continue working on the management of it. But fusion doesn't have spent fuel rods to deal with. It'll still have some activation issues that you'll have to manage, but it doesn't have the fuel rods that just sit somewhere in either a buried or have to be managed somehow. And it's harder to proliferate fusion than it is with fission.
So there's that sort of a homeland security issue, I suppose, that might go with it. Can I jump in real quick and ask you a couple more incredibly simple questions? Sure. Okay.
So, sun is fusion. What about the bombs from World War II? Were those fission bombs? So, in World War II, those were both fission bombs.
The first one was uranium based and then the second one, I think, was plutonium. Okay. And then the plants that have gone wrong, Chernobyl, Three Mile Island, are those fission reactors or fusion reactors? We don't have any fusion reactors.
So, those are all fission reactors. Yeah, Chernobyl was based on an old reactor design and we've since made a lot of improvements and all the ones in America are made in a way that they can't fail in the way that Chernobyl didn't have them melt down. Okay. Fukushima is a modern reactor, but they had a nine plus scale, you know, richer scale earthquake in a 30-foot tsunami hit it.
So, I kind of feel like they should be given a pass for that. I mean, it was a bad disaster, but I mean, come on. I mean, you know. This is why I like Dr.
Casabry's classes because he's like, okay, yeah. So, I'm going to give you the answer, but then I'm going to give you the engineering anecdotes that you need to know from a more experienced engineer. But to be clear, nuclear energy is safe and it is by far the way to go in my mind. Like, right now everybody's talking about a green future or zero waste energy production or low carbon footprint.
Nuclear is the answer. Nuclear is the bridge to a clean energy future. I strongly build that. And you're suggesting that fusion would be the even better bridge over fission.
Am I hearing you right? I would not say that. I think there's a portfolio of energy methods that are really good. So you've got hydroelectric dams, but we've kind of exhausted our potential for doing that.
We've got dams in all the rivers and places. Fission is hopefully underutilized because there are lots of things like fast breeder reactors and things that can make use of the spent fuel rods and make a lot more use of the potential energy available. And then fusion and then solar, especially in remote places like deserts where there's lots of land and lots of sunlight. So I think we're better off if we have a good portfolio of different energy options to basically be robust against single point failures of one thing or another.
So to be clear, earlier when you said we are fresh out of fusion reactors, you mean like we're not fresh out. You mean like we fresh never figured it out. We can't do that. Yes, that's right.
But if anyone's listening, if you just send me a half million dollar contract, I've got all problems worked out in a notebook. I would love it if that's what made this all come together. So you actually, Matt, you actually did touch on something that was very interesting. So when you're creating an energy source, I mean, the ultimate idea, correct me if I'm wrong, Dr.
Cassey, is you want to heat up water, turn it into steam and then turn a turbine with that. Is that correct? That's probably the most practical way to do it. There's this thing called gain in engineering and it's like, how much energy do I put in versus how much energy do I get out?
Or you'll hear, okay, we're going for a gain of one or better. So basically we want to get more energy out than we put in. So we call that the break even point. And so right now, if you imagine what we're doing, we're trying to squish these isotopes together in a really fancy way so that this huge energetic event happens.
So what do you need to do that? You need intense pressure. You need a super high temperature, would you say Dr. Casseybury?
Yes. Yeah. So we have to squeeze things together really, really hard. When I say really, really hard, I'm saying to the point where traditional methods to measure pressure and temperature, that physics starts to break down.
And so when I walked into the classroom, I had never heard of an electron volt. Have you ever heard of an electron volt, Matt? No, I mean, I've heard of both of those words separately. So an electron volt is a unit of temperature, you could say.
Is that fair to say? Sure. Yeah, yeah. And it's basically ridiculous levels.
So like you have the normal engineering units that you deal with, which is like Kelvin, Celsius, Pascal, gigapascal. Sure. And then you have the stupid level. Everything we did in this class, you only use stupid units.
I mean, it's insane. So can you please explain in the electron volt, Dr. Casseybury? Sure.
Well, it is used as both a unit of energy and as a unit of temperature. And when we talk about the context of temperature, it is equal to 11,605 Kelvin. Units are always a pain in engineering. Like when I teach undergrad courses, one of the first things I do is apologize for English units and then we learn them.
And when people gripe, I ask them, what is their height and centimeters? And when they give me that cold blank stare, I explain that the reason that we have mixed your sets of units is because people in different groups and cultures get comfortable with using a certain set of units because the numbers are convenient. And so plasma physicists like to use an EV because when you calculate that it's 11,605 Kelvin from its energy definition, it is very easy to talk in terms of temperatures of the plasma in terms of either EV or KEV because people like to deal with numbers of ones and tens and hundreds. So one EV is about like 10,000 Kelvin and 10 EV is 100,000 and 100 EV is a million.
Then when you talk about fusion, you talk about KEV temperature. So a kilo electron volt. And so that is a thousand times hotter. So one EV is 11,605 Kelvin and one KEV would be 11,605 Kelvin.
And then to burn the plasma to actually do fusion, you need around 10 KEV, roughly minimum. And so that's about a hundred million Kelvin. Crazy high temperatures. I don't even know.
I mean, I don't have a context for that, obviously. Yeah. So we're just seeing a problem. So we're seeing a problem.
So we're seeing a problem. Fit into that. Is an electron volt like a way to just have a next unit to quantify something that big or is it measuring something different? Well, so I'm going to flunk the pop quiz on this one because it's been a long time since this week, whenever this, but an electron volt has to do with the definition that an electron being pulled out of a potential well.
And what I mean is literally like a voltage. So if you pull an electron through so much voltage from a point source out, it's equal to 1 EV and it's connected back to the charge. And that all ties in with the SI units. And so when you back out what that energy is, the potential energy, once you know what the energy is, you can connect that to the equivalent random thermal energy of a system.
And when you equate those two and back out, then what its temperature would be by that definition, you find that 1 EV corresponds to 11,605 Kelvin. It comes back to what's the charge on electron and how much energy does it take on when you move it through. I think a 1 volt potential if I remember correctly, but it's been a while. This episode of Nodum Questions is sponsored by HelloFresh, which as you know, we love Matt.
What is HelloFresh? It's America's number one meal, get delivery service where they take really, really smart people and they have them think about food people would like to eat and then what it would take for those normal people to make that food. And they go and find all the ingredients and they pre-measure them and they send them to your house all fresh and ready to go. And then you or any normal person can just follow the recipe card and make awesome food and learn things about cooking and eat things that taste good.
How did I do? Yeah, that was excellent. I'm going to make one of these meals with my kids. I've done that a few times.
I've done it a couple of times myself. My wife can make these so incredibly fast and everyone's a while say, I'm kind of hungry and she'll be like, boom, hello, it's like waving a magic wand or something and it just happens. You look away for a second. It happens.
It's incredible. And my favorite one by far is the Tusken sausage spaghetti. It's absolutely unbelievable. Anyway, HelloFresh has all kinds of other things that I'm sure you care about.
I do, but the food is the main attractor to me, but there's things like the fact that they are prepared sustainably, they kind of minimize packaging, the fact that it's flexible for your lifestyle, you can pause it if you're going out of town, things like that. They give back. They're donated over two and a half million meals to charity last year and they're ramping that up here this year because of the coronavirus crisis. So it's great company.
So if you want to get HelloFresh and I certainly hope that you'll want to get HelloFresh, you can go to hellofresh.com slash 60NDQ. That's a new promo code. So again, it's HelloFresh.com slash 60NDQ and use the code 60NDQ. That's 60NDQ which gets you 60 bucks off your first three weeks including free shipping on your first box.
It's awesome. If you can get the Tusken sausage spaghetti, I highly recommend it. You can go online and pick whatever meals you like. Of course, the steak and sass is like an all time favorite.
Go get those. Check them out. You can go to hellofresh.com slash 60NDQ and use the code 60NDQ, 60NDQ to get 60 bucks off your first three weeks including free shipping on your first box. Additional restrictions apply.
Please visit hellofresh.com for more details. Yeah, you should totally do this. Go to hellofresh.com slash 60NDQ and use the code 60NDQ to get 60 bucks off your first three weeks including free shipping on your first box. Additional restrictions apply.
Visit hellofresh.com for more details. Should we learn more about Fusion Propulsion, Matt? Absolutely. This is humbling and good and I want more.
Let's go. I'm going to pull you back top level, Matt. So basically we have this concept of we have to do things with materials that we don't normally use. We have to create ridiculous pressures and ridiculous temperatures that humans don't even know how to talk about.
And we have to do all this and we have to make that happen. So that requires an incredible amount of energy to make that happen. And then after it happens, you have to somehow figure out how to harvest the energy from that. So this is a very, very interesting method that you mentioned.
I mean, the typical one is the turbine in the steam. Yeah, we'll talk about that later. Don't worry about that. I can worry about that.
I'll worry about it. Are you worried about it? Not at all. So these are the engineering challenges that Dr.
Casabri is thinking about. So the interesting thing is humans are working on Fusion. So Dr. Casabri has positioned himself and a team of other researchers.
They're looking at, okay, we're just going to assume that humans figure this out. Once they figure it out, we need to figure out how to create this into a propulsion device. To put it on the back of a rocket. And the reason we do this is why would you think that?
Why would we care about fusion propulsion over a normal rocket? Okay. Let me list my guesses. Don't tell me if I'm way off on any of these real screw up my further guesses.
One, I'm guessing that fusion propulsion would be more powerful and more efficient. I'm two, guessing that you wouldn't have to have a gigantic reservoir of chemical fuel. And that would increase payloads and then just make everything more efficient in terms of actually accomplishing objectives in space. I would think that, I don't want to put this.
I would think that the fusion option in space would, I don't know the terminology. I picture, I can draw it like a picture in a cartoon. I would picture it being more effective for making maneuvers in space, including, I don't know the term, but like firing backwards in order to slow your progress. It would enable you to not have to do the, just accelerate to a certain distance and then slow down thing because I would guess that if you're traveling in space, you assume that's a clear path, but what if it weren't?
You'd want to have the options to make changes and this would provide you with that. And also it would help to address the problem you brought up fourth at the beginning of the inability to refuel in space. If you have a nearly limitless fuel supply like this, that kind of renders that point moot. Any of those useful?
Well, that was darn near a perfect. So I can't approve on that. You guys have been a great audience. Thank you.
Yeah, that was excellent. That was a really good job, Matt. That was a really good job. Thanks.
I thought you said this guy didn't know anything about the technical aspects of space travel. He just nailed it. Yeah, he did. I mean, it's a lot of Matt's very good at abstract thought.
And fusion propulsion is very abstract, but it's also very hard. I mean, it's a real science too. So don't take it as a dig, Dr. Kasper.
So basically all that's right. But I had an aha moment sitting in the classroom and that aha moment was when you pencil whipped on the board and you said, hey, let's go to this moon of Neptune. We're setting up again, by the way. Oh, gosh.
Seta has a highly elliptical orbit. I think it's around like maybe 50 AU out right now, but it goes way out there like maybe 300 or 3000 AU. I can't remember which one of those off the top of my head. Sorry, I hear AU.
I think gold. What is AU? It's a astronomical unit. That's 1.15 times 10 to the 11 meters.
Good heavens. Yeah, it's a big number. It's basically the distance. One AU is the distance between here and the sun.
And that's a convenient measure for solar system travel because everything is a number like half or one or 10 or 20 or something like that. Yeah. Oh, okay. I have mental health.
You were up there pencil whipping on the board and you were going to send Brock Blastoff out to Sedna or something like that. And you said, hey, how big of a ship do we need to build in order to get there? And how many years does it take to get there with this method of propulsion and this method of propulsion? And every time we did the math, assuming fusion propulsion is something that humans can figure out, it's like an order of magnitude faster and it makes things possible.
Like for example, with chemical rockets right now, we're just not going to leave the solar system. It's just not going to happen. Would you agree with that? Because of time.
It's really hard to do. And if you do it, so we do have a couple of things. We have four satellites that I can think of leaving the solar system and we're still talking to you. So, Voyager 1 and 2 is still awake.
And then we have Pioneer. Was it, I forget the numbers for those 10 and 11 maybe? I don't remember. The way you do it with chemical is you do planetary swing bias to get an extra delta V and kick it out of the solar system.
So it's doable, but you can't get those fast burnout speeds that you can with nuclear based propulsion systems. Recently found, so last fall I had to give this talk on interstellar travel using nuclear technology, say, is infusion and antimatter. And I was asked to do this and you do these things and agree to it because, well, if I don't then somebody else will do it and then they'll get the credit and the bullet on the resume, so I better do it. And I had to go off and study antimatter especially because I don't know squat about it other than some of the basic reactions and how much energy comes out.
But I learned a lot. I found this old, it was an AIAAA short course that was taught by Bob Frisbee who once a while you'll see commenting on one of those weird alien shows on Discovery Channel or something like that. But he was a really good serious scientist and before him there was this guy Bob Ford and they did a lot of work on this kind of stuff. And Frisbee had come up with this ingenious way of capturing all the propulsion technologies and laying them out against any destination you could think of to show which ones make sense to do where.
And it all comes back to the energy density and the fuel. And that kind of tells you which propulsion concepts are good candidates for different missions and you can kind of see clearly that for Earth and maybe Mars that it's certainly the moon, it's hard to be chemical. When you get to Mars nuclear thermal really trades off nicely nuclear electric if you can make some assumptions about improvements in that technology. And then when you start to push out farther like say Jupiter and Saturn and so on then it's fusion and fusion hybrids or let's call it like exotic gas core vision where you're creating explosions or plasmas that blast out in nozzle rather than a reactor that you use heat transfer to heat up a gas.
And those things really look good for pretty much anything within our solar system. Then when you go interstellar it's really a stretch to use anything other than antimatter and even then it's hard. I thought antimatter was science fiction. I didn't even know that was a thing.
Oh no there's an antimatter chamber here in Alabama. Yep. Oh yeah. Well that's what I get for reading history.
Well actually lightning makes anti-matter. Yeah lightning makes anti-matter. Yeah it's really. Yeah that was actually discovered by a professor at UAH in the I think in the atmospheric sciences department it might be the space physics.
And I apologize for not remembering exactly who it was but yeah they found out that it's such a high voltage differential between the cloud to ground during a storm, a thunderstorm and they started taking measurements across the spectrum and they found you know any matter it gets produced. And it's basically just a linear particle accelerator. Maybe an inefficient one but still. Michael Briggs.
Oh yeah. Yep that's him. So just listen to these descriptions of different types of propulsion that would be needed for each of these different ranges. So if you were leaving Earth to go to the farthest reaches of the interstellar travel you're not getting off Earth with antimatter right.
You'd use chemical to get into orbit and then you'd switch or would you just go with whatever from the get go. No you have to use different propulsion systems for different parts of the trip based on the convenience of it. That's an excellent question by the way. That is an excellent question.
Yes it is. Yes it is. To get off the ground you really need chemical propulsion you need rockets because it all comes down to thrust away. You got to get over the Earth's gravity well to get out.
We don't really have anything better than that at the moment. But once you're in orbit in your space then you can kind of take your time and use something that has less thrust but higher exhaust velocity and the propellant to get you where you want to go and that's where your fuel efficiency comes into play and if you can burn for a really long time like say for a month or a couple of months then you can get up to really high velocities. And coming back to the point that you made earlier Matt about why we would want to do this essentially you want to have the ability to speed up to really high velocities and then turn the ship backwards and fire the rockets again for a while to slow back down to get to your destination. So that's one thing I learned in this class Matt.
So there are different types of rendezvous things that have happened. For example Dr. Cassie, correct me when I get it wrong please forgive me for not remembering exactly but it's called the beta factor correct. Yeah you're talking about Wolfgang Moekles model in which beta basically weights the trip time and the distance into the calculation.
Exactly so if I want to go just out. Let me pull up your grades I can make a change of grades in case you get some problems. There you go. So basically I'm going to do a rendezvous with a planet and I'm going to land there.
I have to hit the gas all the way and half way I'm going to flip around and hit the brakes. Right? Yep. That's the way.
If I want to do just a well I guess that would be a rendezvous correct. Yes that's correct. Then I would do a return I could just hit the gas and go and I'd have to slow down and then I'd have to hit the gas when I leave there and hit the brakes on the way back. So there's all these different modes that you have to use these propulsion systems and so as I'm sitting there in class and I'm looking at this graph and it was a big paper written by Frisbee and what was the other guy's name?
Bob Forward. So they wrote this big PDF and it was like they kind of packaged up all of their knowledge in their career and they handed it off to the next generation and they were like hey next generation you're going to have to figure this out. And what it felt like to me is some kind of Viking culture that said something like hey we figured out a way to make bigger boats and if you make these big boats you can go to different places you know. That's what it felt like.
It's just really interesting to read it because you know if you were going to the library you know two blocks away you might take a little scooter. If you're going across ten blocks away you might take a motorcycle across town you take a car you could get pretty far on a car but at some point you get on an airplane. And so it's really interesting the point you brought up Matt about needing different propulsion systems for different applications. So I remember I was in West Africa and we had to get on a taxi and we went to this one place into car Senegal and that's where all the taxis were and if you wanted to go to a different country you had to get on one of those taxis but you all went to one central location to find your taxi and say hey are you going to the Gambia?
Hey are you going to Cameroon? Wherever they were going. And so I can imagine a place in space where we park all these taxis and the big fusion blaster 3000 or whatever we call these things I can imagine you go get up and you link up with a tugboat and you get on board and you go to wherever you're supposed to go. This is really far out there stuff that we're thinking about but it's all physically possible.
And yet a guy who made a TV show in the 60s had the same idea. I mean isn't that Ron Barry's vision that you would have a spaceport that there would be some sort of tug that maneuver these great big vessels that they use this burst impulse power for short range travel and then obviously I have no idea what the warp drive concept is even supposed to be. I just know it's very very very fast and they put numbers next to it and I have no idea if the science of Rod and Mary holds up at all but it seems like he was at least asking the same question you are. Oh yeah.
Yeah and a lot of what influences a number of us that work in this area is Star Trek or Star Wars or pick your other favorite sci-fi for me it was those two. So they make up a lot of stuff obviously and sometimes that's a convenient you know plot you know technology and science or plot armor against you know whatever's going on to the protagonist that episode. There's a lot of thought put in and I think they consult with a lot of scientists in order to put those shows together so yeah. The impulse engine on Star Trek I think is fusion propulsion combined with some sort of I don't know inertial damper or mass reduction system so that you know whatever you scored out the exhaust your F is equal to MA and M is somehow magically tiny and so that gets some very high sub light speeds makes efficient use of the exhaust.
We're working on half of the technology for the impulse engine or. Okay you wrote four sequels mass times acceleration is that the F equals MA? Yes. So at the end that my beloved Star Trek episodes from the 60s with Bill Shatner running around that they didn't totally have that formula balanced?
No I would say that I think the concept for the enterprise and other you know ships like that the idea behind the impulse engine was a sub light capability in which they had some device on board that would effectively reduce the mass of the ship and then their exhaust is a fusion exhaust so it's pushing on what might feel like a postage stamp so that their acceleration is really high even though they've got this giant ship that they're actually pushing. I think that's what the impulse engine was supposed to be. It took two runs at the explanation but I got it on the second one. Okay yeah.
So Matt let me say one other thing real quick so you casually mentioned warp drive in this flipping kind of I'm going to just say warp drive because that sounds fun and fancy and then you kept moving on. If you have a question about warp drive you're talking to one of the people in the world that know about it. Well I thought that was science fiction too. I mean isn't it like I think that's supposed to fold space or something and it seems ridiculous.
Well it's theoretically possible but really hard to do. I had a student Joseph Agnew he was an undergraduate student he's not going to be a grad student with us. He coached me I had just given a talk on fusion and I tried to after these things are over make a mad dash to my vehicle to avoid picking up another student or something you know because I just get so spread out and he intercepted me he's tall he's got a big stride you know and he tracked me down and he said he wanted to work on warp drive and I said well maybe what you could do is a review paper on the technology to kind of find out what the current thinking is and who's doing you know what effort and all that and he did an amazing job on this he was his paper was ten times better as an undergrad paper than some of the professionals that speak on the subject so it was excellent it was a standing room only crowd when he gave his talk. Wow.
Last summer it was really really good but now we get contacted once or twice a week by people all over asking us about our warp drive lab and nobody's building warp drive at the propulsion research center but yeah so back to your your real question you know the idea behind one way to do this is to distort space time somehow and the first calculation that was done was by this guy I'll be curious if I'm pronouncing it correctly and he needed the mass equivalent energy of like Jupiter or even higher in order to be able to do it and people have subsequently figured out how to fold space time without violating known physics to get this down something smaller and smaller and so theoretically they're making progress on figuring out how to do this in an energy efficient way and I'm gonna go out on a limb and say somebody is gonna figure this out we're gonna have flying cars and warp drive someday I don't personally know of what the tricks would be to get there but I just like to think that the universe or guide or whoever's in your heart that governs all of these things intends for us to not socially distance across the galaxy universe ever what's and what I like about sitting in Dr. Cassey's class math is a lot of people you hear something you're like well what about this and the instant oh no that's not possible and the place he starts every time is list well let's look at the math okay well in order for this equation to work we have to figure out how to make this number bigger or this number smaller it's never just no I mean maybe it is you know after you do the math but in the process of learning and discovering it always starts with let's look at the math and it's amazing how close you can get by back of the envelope estimations when you hear warp drive you're like whatever yeah like Boba Fett and all that you know you think about that and a lot of that happens when you know these serious scientists they sit down and they dream and they actually apply logic and reason to the problem and they take it seriously and what I found having sat in those classrooms and hear the seriousness with which they're discussed a lot of it gets lost once it goes to media and someone writes an article about it once an article gets written in some kind of you know wired magazine or something like that it's almost always wrong in how they present the information maybe you have different experiences Dr. Cassey but it's a really weird thing it is like one time I was asked some questions about propulsion concept just so they could you know propulsion engineer Jason Cassey at the University of Alabama in Huntsville said blah blah so they gave me this paper and I really hedged on it because I didn't think that what they were working on was going to get anywhere near the goal that they had I said it's going to take a tremendous amount of work and but they totally changed what I said to Dr. Cassey says this is going to be the next greatest propulsion system and it's going to replace gas turbine it's and and I just read that went oh my god I didn't say that and I emailed and they you know they don't care they got their quote they're moving on.
Exactly wow it's not like a teaching style that's like good parenting instead of just saying no maybe the answer for now will turn out to be no but let's work through all the variables to understand why yeah and that way instead of students or kids in a household learning that well what I learned from this experience is dad said no what they learned to do is think and run the calculations for themselves I really respect that. Yeah it's really cool can I ask one question about warp drives before we move on I'm sorry yeah it's not a question okay when I watch that happen they're like okay we're entering the calculations now well we've got to get out of here but the calculations aren't ready the calculations they're running is is there something that I'm to believe that is happening in those calculations that will keep them from going through like baseball sized rocks while they're in warp drive because it's like a baseball sized rock would be enough at that speed to do an incredible amount of damage to a spaceship but what's the answer for that yeah let's see so I'm thinking the calculations are a combination of navigation so you don't fly through a planet and also some gibberish about not reversing your polar on beams and mixing in too high of a you know a tacky on production rate because that could create some sort of gravitational anomaly and result in a doomsday machine creation or you know some that was really good that was really good that was me barfing whatever random star trek you know words came to mind that worked on me it totally worked so but I mean I'm just in general any kind of space travel yeah what do you do about ramming stuff that wouldn't be on a map well yeah I mean just kinetically if you do the calculation you're going like say a good fraction of speed to light let's say 0.5 c and you hit a rock I mean it's like an atomic bomb explosion you know the kinetic energy in that impact and so how do you survive such a thing like that and I don't think that's a question that we have a good answer to I think for now like a lot of our satellites that we we send out into free space space is so open that the odds of a collision are really low and then the collisions that you do have are micro meteoroids and you're dealing with speeds of like 10 to 20 or 30 kilometers a second if you're talking about deep space and it's bad but they just create little craters and you can kind of engineer for that but yeah if you're going 0.5 c you get hit by probably even a green of sand would be pretty bad so I don't know how you do it there's actually at UH there's a light gas gun and for the specific problem that you're talking about the micrometeor right impacts they had to answer that for the space station and for the phd topics when I was starting to sniff around to see what I wanted to do that was an option it was this guy named Joel Williamson Dr. Joel Williamson used to teach their UH he did a lot of impact studies and they developed this multi-layer armor for the space station for satellites and so part of the strategy is instead of having one thick piece of material if you get an impact on one side it comes out the other right because you get that shockwave that goes through part of the strategy is to have multiple very thin layers at distances to slow it down over time you can stop some pretty heavy stuff and by heavy I think like smaller than a BB but you know at these velocities that's significant yeah that's a really big problem you're getting a lot of this stuff Matt like just intuitively you're figuring it all out it's really interesting I don't know if you watch the TV shows and there are questions that stack up in your brain but then the next plot thing happens and you forget and now I've got both of you here and they're all coming back to mind. So this is the big question I had in the class and I'm just going to let Dr.
Casser explain the answer to this so let's say you are able to create fusion in the back of your spacecraft then what you have to do is you have to direct the beam of whatever that energy is you have to direct it away from your spacecraft you have to deflect it right and if this reaction is happening at multiple times the temperature of the Sun and we have no known material that can actually withstand those temperatures how do you keep the back of your spacecraft from melting off. Well that is a very good question. There's two flavors of fusion propulsion or kind of collectively fusion and fission fusion concepts in which you burn a plasma and then send it out. So you have steady state versions like tokamax or spherical torus or stellarators and then they have this thing called a diverter that scrapes off the products that come off and then they sort of flow continuously through some sort of nozzle and that would look a whole lot like a rocket or a gas turbine engine.
That'd be like a really smooth continuous stream of flow and how they do it the plasma is fairly low density and so I think the heat flux to the surface is something that probably could be manageable. Maybe you circulate some kind of coolant and then pass it through radiators and keep it cool like that. I'm not an expert on that particular area but I think that's kind of how that would work. With the pulsed versions that we're looking at there's a whole class of magneto inertial fusion and then there's inertial confinement fusion and all of those collectively together I consider them sort of like the two cycle weedyter of fusion because of the way they work.
Like a two cycle engine you know just has like those two strokes you put fuel and gas in and you compress it explodes it blasts out and then it exhausts kind of like immediately and that's kind of how these inertial concepts would have to work and how do they actually keep cool enough. Before you move to that step can I kind of slow that down for a minute? Sure yeah. Thank you.
So imagine you create this plasma cloud. It's literally what it sounds like just a cloud of plasma and you were able to use a huge magnetic field because plasma and magnetic fields they interact. And you shape that magnetic field in a really fast way and you squeeze the cloud down really really small really fast. Can you imagine that?
I mean this never would have occurred to me in a billion years left my own thought but yes I can picture it. So you squeeze that cloud down to a very very small point and we're talking about over the span of where we at. Fimto seconds Dr. Casabary what time is it?
It's not that short. Implosions would vary from maybe 10 microseconds that's on the long end. Okay. Down to maybe 100 nanoseconds the compression part of it.
Let's say between say 10 nanoseconds in 10 microseconds that's about the right order of magnitude. In high speed physics and stuff Matt that's a really long time. So like the high speed camera that I use to capture bullets flying in the field of you. If I can take a picture that's two microseconds in exposure time then I can make the bullet look like it stopped.
But if I take a picture that's 10 microseconds of exposure time then you'll get a little bit of motion blur on that bullet. You got a feel for that? Yep. I actually think about time in terms of bullet blur that's how my brain works.
And so he's talking about just at the point of bullet blur to well below that a couple orders of magnitude below that. So that's the time scale we're talking about. So you take this plasma cloud and you squeeze it really hard really fast down to the smallest point you can imagine like you try to make it take it down to a single point and then because all of that plasma is moving in that direction. Am I getting this right Dr.
Cassie? That's the mega dose. Yeah, sounds good. Inertial fusion.
The inertia is the speed at which I'm throwing it all together into a singular point. And then once it gets there at that very, very small central core the little bitty tiny grain of a compressed plasma cloud that's when the boom happens. Right? Or wrong.
Okay question. I can picture the shape of the magnetic field. I can picture the plasma cloud. I'm tracking with all of that.
I think I can even I can't picture it but I'm tracking with what you mean about the rate of time. But where is this all happening? Is this in an apparatus? Is this outside an apparatus?
This reaction would take place effectively inside the nozzle near the focal point. Let's say if it's a paraboloid it would kind of be close to the focus of that paraboloid. So you would create this implosion which would compress the fuel down and heat it up and then it explodes and then it expands out very quickly either against a physical nozzle or against a magnetic nozzle and then gets redirected out the exhaust. So the magnetic nozzle then would solve the melting off the back of your ship problem.
It helps. You still have radiation which is going to couple into the material. So you have that issue. But you kind of get rid of that.
Let's give him that when Dr. Casabry that was a stretch for him. He did a good job. Yes.
We got a giving that. So just so you know man. I'll take an F plus or a D. No, no, no.
I'm sorry. Dr. Casabry is talking to you like a student in the classroom now. I'm honored.
You're hanging. You sound just like a graduate engineering student. So you're doing a great job. Let me ask you another question.
I'm trying to. Wait before you go to that question, before you go to that question because we have this mental model. I was just trying to give you an attaboy before we move forward. So you use a magnetic field like a paraboloid magnetic field and you squeeze that thing down and you make a little boom and then the boom comes back out.
And so before you use the magnetic field to squeeze the plasma, right? That's one concept. But the field is actually just there to produce thrust and maybe extract power. Okay.
Yeah. That's what I was going to say. You can kind of get some power off the explosion as it comes out against the magnetic field, right? So it's kind of like a regenerative breaking on a car.
So as you use the magnetic field to squeeze the plasma down as it goes boom, you can kind of get some of that energy back by using it in reverse. If that makes any sense. Yes. Okay.
Good. Okay. Yeah. Okay.