Skip to content
086 - Flukes Coincidences and Miracles episode artwork

Jun 23, 2020 1 hr 3 min

086 - Flukes Coincidences and Miracles

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: HELLOFRESH STUFF FROM THIS EPISODE NDQ Tweet - Destin's Pillow Randy Johnson Explosion of Feathers Archduke Ferdinand Assassinated Gavrilo Princip Two Friends Fist Fight - TMBH (Lee is in this video) Jason Statham Robert Fico Spontaneous Human Combustion Coin Toss Lands Right on the Edge Fish Caught with Wedding Ring on Tail Same Birthday Odds Numberphile - 23 and Football Birthdays PBS Prehistoric Road Trip CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

086 - Flukes Coincidences and Miracles

0:00 1:03:17
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Something crazy happened. I'm all yours. I was working with my daughter. She's growing these plants in the Sunroom and She's like dad.

Have you seen the lettuce because we have this new thing called an arrow garden? She's like hey dad come look at this lettuce. I was like, okay, sweetie So I go in I grab a chair I'm gonna put the chair over next to where this arrow garden is and when I pick the chair up There was a pillow in the chair like imagine a pillow that's like a foot and a half to two foot long Maybe 11 inches tall, you know, just a thick pillow. It was like very roundish, you know It's one of those inconvenient pillows that are theoretically there to decorate things up a little bit Maybe be used as a lumbar support in a pinch, but mostly if you were in charge, they wouldn't exist.

You know the one Okay, so that pillow was in the chair didn't see it there because you know that's it's just there to be pretty I pick the chair up The scooted over into the arrow garden the pillow falls out of the chair and lands on its end Like like a domino that you sit up ready to fall and it sits upright like I pick the chair up pillow falls out lands upright Balanced perfectly and I thought that is this pillow. It's not like a domino. It's like a it was very rounded. It looks Okay, let me ask you this because I don't want this to be a you had to be there kind of something to the picture yet I'm in the picture.

Don't do it. Okay. I'm not I'm just gonna tweet Is it the kind of picture is it the kind of pillow that if you hit someone with it real hard in the face? It would be funny or an act of aggression.

It's a really good swing in size Like it's got just enough weight that you could probably take a little kid off their feet with it if he had a hard Enough now that shouldn't stand upright. It did okay now. I'm ready for the picture Show me the picture okay, so if you go to our Twitter account, I forget what the name of our Twitter account is do you remember? What is these questions tonight?

I'm not done. That's no don't use at Okay, here we go. It's at no damn cues. That's what I was about to say here's me the picture Matt It was a total fluke.

It wasn't supposed to happen like when it landed. I immediately looked at my daughter and I was like what just happened What oh whoa whoa that hello? Yes, that makes no sense. All right full disclosure when you describe this to me I was picturing a fat dumpy pillow that's been around way too long.

It's outlived. It's Usefulness, it's like Tampa Bay Buccaneers pillow from 1979 That's kind of lost all of its color and it's that awful creamsicle thing and because it's just so limp and flaccid It just mushes over whatever you drop it on but that that's a tough stout looking pillow It shouldn't happen. It's not it's not the dimensions the thickness of it means that should not physically happen This is not an object that you would expect to stand upright ever and it did ever anything like that happen like a fluke like a Mechanical thing that happens, you know like this should not happen But it just did and I don't know what to do other than look around and see if anybody else saw it Yeah, I've had a few things like that happen the one that stands out is I was in Dylan, Colorado in the parking lot of an A&W restaurant I was there with a bunch of students We were on a ski youth trip thing and one of the other sponsors had my wallet because I had them pay for the food because it's my responsibility And she takes my wallet from across the parking lot and as soon as she hears me say Hey, can you hand me my wallet instead of like walking it over the joke was like haha here comes your wallet stupid And so she just guns it and it's spinning pretty tight and it's not gonna make it to me It's just down by my foot kind of and so I yelled I don't even need my eyes for this I closed my eyes I held up my right hand I stuck my foot forward in a kicking motion and a second later I felt my wallet in my hand and then I opened my eyes and everyone is just dumbstruck I mean this wasn't like a throw from six inches away I had enough time with it in the air to call out what I was going to do and then the joke was going to be look How stupid I look when this thing hits me in the crotch or flies past me or gets all scuffed up and everybody gets a laugh at me Except I looked awesomer than I've ever looked in my entire life doing anything But it's one of those things like did you ever play baseball and you caught something you shouldn't have caught absolutely and it's in your glove And you're like what on earth is that oh, that's the baseball that I was supposed to catch I knew I totally knew because I'm good. I couldn't even play it off I was like we all know dang well that shouldn't have happened and so I don't know I have no explanation for that many aliens That's awesome.

Does that count is that the kind of thing we're talking about? Yeah, I think so. I mean it's even better if there's a witness to see it You know the unit Randy Johnson, right? Absolutely.

You know exactly what I'm about to say. I know it's spring training game Say it he's out there all six foot ten of him and then he throws a pitch and a bird flies by and the baseball hits a bird And just instantly goes he just like cartoon to bird. It just turned into fed yes Yes, yes, and it was like what the odds of that happening are zero how many pitches have been thrown in baseball history? How many times have you heard about a bird getting hit from the pitchers now to home plate and the answer is one and that was with Randy Johnson In a spring training game in Arizona.

Yeah, and the thing about it is I think about how often this happens Especially since then back then it was not really the age of cell phones quite yet now Everybody's rolling a camera on every single baseball game that every eight-year-old kid is playing in every high school division six Who cares game where both teams are already eliminated? They're still mom and dad and grandpa out there with their cell phones if that had happened again It would be all over the internet it has happened exactly once and it is unbelievable still amazing You're making a point with it. What was that point? It's a fluke.

It's a fluke and it's like like it's not a glitch in the matrix Which somebody you use the you use the term I was exactly about to you It's not what I'm gonna back like glitch in the matrix thing Why is it not because it can happen like in terms of probability this thing will happen like at some point if people do this thing enough It's going to happen Can you think of famous moments like that have happened like I don't know this you're gonna understand this better night My I think it was 10th grade history teacher taught me that the beginning of World War one started with an assassination Art Stuke Franz Ferdinand and Saria Okay, I'm over my head here. I'm about to tell you everything I know about that all I know is there were two assassins if I'm not mistaken one guy had a pistol and he ran up to a car and tried To fire the pistol and it didn't work, right? Yes, that's what happened Yep, and then he had poison and he tried to like kill himself Eventually, yes, and he tried to jump off a bridge and so what yes My history teacher taught me was this assassin came up tried to fire gun didn't work something happened I don't know tried to poison himself jumps off the bridge was gonna kill himself But the tide was low and he lands like in the water and he's like he ends up having failed his attempt to assassinate this guy in Mud pukin is guts out because of the poison that didn't work is that true getting beaten by a mob who absolutely loved the archduke I think the guy's name was gavrilo Princeps the mob they hated him because arts the arts to France Ferdinand if I recall correctly had Four-fitted power because of love and this is happening right at the end of the romantic era And so it was much more than just a failed assassination attempt that later became a successful assassination attempt because as they fled That they were fine They got away and then I think Princeps was a guy who was like well nuts our assassination didn't work out And then the arts Duke just drives up in the like an alley and he was like oh I guess I could still redeem the day and shoot this guy real quick and then he did I think that's how it worked out But whatever the case yes ludicrously long odds on how botched that assassination attempt was and all that had to align for that To go that wrong and then still somehow to work out the end I mean the primer didn't work on the specific bullet he was firing or maybe it didn't get hard enough whatever By the way, I had a primer did something weird one time tell me I fired a lot of bullets in my life I was with some people and I aimed at the weapon and I fired it click and there's several different failure modes for bullets There's you know failure to fire failure to eject, you know failure to feed There's a lot of different things that can happen I fired it didn't go and I looked at the person next to me And I was gonna say huh miss fire and when I looked over towards them then it fired Which means the primer struck led stifenate or whatever was in that primer and it smoldered a little bit didn't go And then went and let the powder and went but I fired this a really good way to accidentally shoot somebody else if you don't have Incredibly good range discipline and training nice job not shooting your friend. Thank you What other flicks have you had happened?

I had one the other day, you know We've been working on building our house back. We had the ice dams and all this snow 29 feet of snow That's what we got in our house this year crazy 29 not inches. That's feet We got a hoth style ice dam that closed in like a monster's mouth around our garage trapping our SUV in there for the whole winter We ended up with like two feet of ice in front of the garage that was part of the ice cave and we had a jackhammer Out in the spring to free the vehicle. I'm not kidding.

That's what I so all this ice happened and our roof failed in one part of our House we've been building this thing back not that interesting story But it's kind of fun to share so we're gonna jackhammer. We rented it down at the heavy machinery rental place That's awesome. Okay, Adam And I just traded off for a few hours banging out ice That's cool The contractors you know finally land on a bunch contractors come up and fix a thing build it all back and they come up and get started and Camilla comes over to the other side of the house one morning and she's like hey I think Lee is here not the lead that you and I know who apologizes to my puddles But my friend Lee from land or Wyoming. It's great dude wonderful dude very distinctive looking duties from North Dakota and now attends the University of Wyoming I'm like I talked to him like two days ago There's no way he would be at the house and not have told me and so I just go out to investigate because that seems pretty weird I know this guy really well by the way really well I walk out and I'm like Lee is here and I kind of do the familiar eye contact like hey We put basketball together hang out.

What's up, dude? And the guy just looks at me blankly and socially that was enough for me to realize in the moment. That's not Lee But I'm sure that's Lee this is crazy. So you know I walk up I introduced myself and introduce himself as a mason I mean just feel this out a little bit like hey, we're from Mason.

He's like I'm from Eastern North Dakota That's where Lee's from and he sounds like Lee. I'll sorry big a boot that kind of stuff. Mm-hmm. He's talking I'm like well, we're just gonna school.

No, I went to Laramie University of Wyoming This is bizarre is that where he went? That's where Lee goes to college now. What he's doing his grad work there Right, and so I'm like all right here in your in South Dakota Yes, I'm in the Black Hills of South Dakota when we're doing all this okay cool So I'm like dude Here's the deal straight up like it's hard for me not to treat you as a really good friend right off the bat because you look Exactly like a really good friend not like every now And then people say I look a tiny bit like Jason Statham when they're not paying attention and everything's dark and shadowy like oh You kind of remind me of so-and-so like oh Dustin reminds me that guy from Serbia or wherever Robert's not like that Nice job. No, it was like you are Lee.

How is this possible? So I slipped around and I snapped a picture of the guy and you know what I'm gonna pull it up I'm gonna show it to you in just a minute And I sat picture of the two of us hanging out and I sent it to Lee and Lee replied saying oh, that's fun. When was that? He didn't know it wasn't a picture of himself and so I explained it to him like dude That's not you and he's like no It's not you check the date on the file and he had to convince himself to believe that it wasn't actually him So then I'm like show it to your wife now.

These are friends of the family We've done all kinds of church stuff together all kinds of adventures and she's like oh cool. What was that? She's married to him So I'm just trying to establish how this is not like oh that guy kind of reminds me of that guy I'm trying to establish like this guy is my friend in every way and I'll send you the pictures here in a minute So I said it's a like three people who know it's very well in common all of them said the same thing like oh, that's fun Cam and Lear out there like no, that's not him Nobody could believe it so I showed this guy Mason pictures of Lee and he couldn't believe it either like everyone has met somebody who looks Like somebody and reminds you of somebody and then afterwards you said your buddy or your wife or whatever like oh Then I can't remind you. Oh, yeah, that's fun But I've never met somebody who could just fool everybody.

I've just never seen anything like that now Here's what's really amazing to me about this. What are the odds of meeting both of those people? What are the odds of that guy showing up to work on my house? How many people have I met in my life in passing here there or some other way?

What are the odds of me meeting two people in the course of my lifetime who are indistinguishable yet not related in any way? I think that's nuts You could actually calculate those odds you could do the math of bouncing a baseball bat on the ground and figuring out How many what are the odds of it landing on its end? You could do a physics model a Monte Carlo simulation you could figure that out. That's interesting Have you ever met somebody that reminded you of someone else with that much not that much?

No, never quite to that extent like I've met people and I've made myself look an idiot because I'm a snake I'll call them something else, but not never to that extent Do you ever meet somebody who you knew somewhere that you shouldn't run into them? No, please tell me your story No, like you've never been just like out in the far reaches of the world and you're like oh hey Oh, I thought you were gonna be like, you know, you're one time Yeah, you're on the road for long work church week and yeah, you know, I had a couple extra hours No, no gross not like that No, I just mean like to somebody who did just how under today in this part of the world at the same time You are you ever had that happen? I have had that happen as a matter of fact I flew to Detroit for a meeting a work meeting and I met the luggage counter and Amos Kennedy the Yeah, yeah, he was at the luggage thing really like just like hey, what's up? I was like Amos what are you doing here?

I was like, oh I'm moving here. I was like what and then I mean Because if he didn't live in Detroit yet because I met him he lived in Detroit Maybe he did at this point He still lived in the south and he was moving up there I don't know what his status was that point but this did happen. This was last year. There's this pastor in Australia His name is John North and Steve is real good friends with John North and John has come to our church at both on Contranum, what do you mean?

Contranum? What does that mean? I think we decided that would be the term we would use for last names That don't fit with who you are where you're from or what you do for a living. Oh, yeah Oh, yeah, you should be John South if he's in Australia.

That's right. Yeah, I'm down number So John I really like John. I've had some conversations with him They were very meaningful for me in the past and so when we were in Australia a few years ago We tear and I drove out of Sydney to try to go find his church And we went and listen to him preach and the outskirts of Sydney And so I was in Atlanta and I got stranded in Atlanta And I had to stay the night I couldn't get home and I'm just walking walking to go find the hotel And I look over at the luggage claim and from the back like I can see the back of this individual I see his hair and I just see his build and everything I was like that's John North didn't see his face didn't hear him talk anything I was like I can that's just who that is and I just walked up and I'd like walk all the way up total confidence I was like what are you doing here John? And he turns and goes oh hey Destin how are you doing?

And it just like a lovely conversation totally unexpected like I was I think it was mind-boggling too though Yeah, he did for all I knew he was in Australia So it was pretty that was a much better Australian accent than the one that you broke out in the red baron episode But it was pretty bad. Yeah, he has an interesting accent because he yeah, John's got a really cool accent I like him so I don't know what the deal is but those fluke things man. I like them. They're kind of fun.

I do too Hey Destin guess what what Matt hello freshers up again That's awesome. I love hello fresh more importantly other people love hello fresh and they send me emails telling me Thank you for telling me about hello fresh that literally happens to yeah Yeah, do you get that in person ever yeah? I do people tell me what they like and they'll like hey I cooked for the wife the other night Thanks, man. I was like you're welcome.

It's kind of become oddly synonymous with the program when I run into people who listen It's like the stuff they want to talk about sleep paralysis some kind of barnacles and testicles thing and hello fresh Apparently that's what's made in impression. So that's good. No, it's good Okay, we need to talk about like a bunch of stuff about hello fresh But literally here a couple minutes ago when we stepped away I had a fluke happened and I need to tell you about it like literally right now. Did you really yeah?

This shouldn't have happened. Okay, wait, I'm not just saying let me say the promo code and then we'll okay We'll do here story. Okay, so if you want to try hello fresh Which is america's number one meal kit delivery service you can do that by going to hello fresh comm slash 60 indie q and use the code 60 indie q At checkout that's six zero November delta quavec and get $60 off your first three weeks including free shipping on your first box Additional restrictions apply please visit hellofresh.com for more details. Tell me about this fluke.

What's up? Okay, it's only gonna take a second bit. I suck a dream if I don't tell you right now Forget about it, you know, we've been fixing up stuff. I got damage at our house from all the snow in the ice and everything We're down to the finishing touches.

Yeah, I'm to the point now where you take the little plates and you put them over your light switches and your outlets I'm looking at one right now when you do that. Do you align all the screw heads in the same direction? Ideally? Yes, but never mind.

That's an OCD engineer thing. Go ahead. Forget me. Go ahead.

No, I was literally just thinking about that So here's the deal I had one on the ground face up empty I was screwing one into the wall with a butter knife because I always use butter knives for those I don't like the flathead screwdriver feels better with a butter knife So this thing is four feet up the wall something like that and screwing this thing into the wall I miss the little bolt falls out onto the carpet and I watch it bounce and bounce again and then land perfectly Straight down into the plate that was sitting on the ground. That makes me happy is a fluke We were talking about flukes and then a fluke happened. I mean, what do you make of that? It sounds like it fluke like the fact that the fluke happened then is a fluke Yes, thank you.

That's exactly what I was hoping you would say We were in the middle of an ad, Matt. We need to talk about the sponsor. We need to finish this Yeah, I totally know. Did we say the thing that we say about Hello Fresh because they phrased that really well I don't think we did you don't say that.

Did you say it or did you sing it? No, I just said it, but I told her by the promo code. Go to hello fresh calm slash 60 in dq and use 60 in dq at check out I get 60 bucks off. I said that I'm feeling a jingle and I'm feeling like it's gonna come from you All you have to do is just sing the opening line.

How hard is it go to hello fresh calm slash 60 in dq and get 60 bucks off the first three weeks It's bad. What about that shipping? It's free Sometimes you're a good podcast partner and sometimes you're really bad podcast partner You're right now you're really dead. I'm wonderful Can we come back and talk about flukes?

No, okay. No, that's my turn I'm gonna do a jingle and it's gonna be great ready. I'm gonna do the opening part You ask me what hello fresh is and I'm just gonna sing it to you. Hey Matt What's hello fresh get fresh pre-measured ingredients and mouthwater seasonal recipes delivered right here door with hello fresh Americas number one meal kit.

How was that that was excellent job? I'm not even joking. That was really good Thank you for supporting the sponsors when you did that you're supporting the program and you make me sit through this with Matt So, thank you Twice month rainer shine. Okay.

Awesome things about hello fresh. It tastes good It's some of my favorite food that we have other awesome things about hello fresh go It's easy to cook the recipe cards really awesome. You can save those you'll love it another cool thing about hello fresh sustainability If you're one of these people who's into this whole thing where we don't wreck the only planet that can sustain human life that we're aware of in the universe Hello fresh is really good at not wrecking planet earth It is actually more sustainable to do food this way than it is to do it the way most of us do it run to the store and all of that business There's a university of Michigan study that demonstrates that dastin. What else is awesome about hello fresh I just found out that they have donated over two and a half million meals to charity in 2019 and they're stepping that up in 2020 I'm excited about that 2020 is a good year to step that up in I'm glad they are reading the situation well and doing stuff to help people right now Totally every interaction that I've had by proxy or as a customer with hello fresh makes me think they're actually cool and good And so I'm not surprised here.

They do something like that rock and roll hello fresh. Thank you for doing that Thank you to you third chair for supporting the podcast by purchasing hello fresh Which also supports people in your communities who could use a bite to eat and hello fresh is looking out for them One last time with the promo code so right now is how to get it Yep, hello fresh calm slash 60 and dq and then use the code 60 and dq and you get 60 bucks off your first three weeks Including free shipping on your first box and additional instructions apply you can visit hello fresh calm for more details It's awesome. You're gonna love it. Let's go talk about flukes again So it's fun to think about glitches in the matrix and coincidences and flukes and we haven't even talked about deja vu yet But I want to pick your brain about that sometime too But yeah before I take it just a tiny bit deeper any other goofy flukes or anything that came to mind over the break Yeah, actually there was I did the test engineer thing for years And we have this saying that murphy lives if you ever heard of murphy's law if you can go wrong at Murphy.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes on a test range all the test engineers all the technicians We all say murphy lives like we have all seen things that there's no way that should happen But it did like these three relays should not have failed in series on this specific day But they did you know this i remember one specific test I had i'll just generally describe what was happening There was an explosive at one location and there were two things in another location We were trying to sequentially do things in a really strange way And we did this super like it's insane to explain how complex this test was and you know It's kind of thing that you plan for weeks and you finally, you know You spend literally hundreds of hours planning for something that lasts less than three seconds And so we were doing it all and I set it up and it was like a really big deal and people came to watch And five four three two one and it was supposed to do something in a specific order like let's just say boom boom boom boom Well, it was five four three two one boom boom boom instead of boom boom boom boom And I was like what that's not no You know instantly like something's odd, right?

And so we go out and sure enough we're reviewing the high speed footage and we're like wait a second That second thing happened at the wrong time And I know this because of things right for four days. I'm sitting there trying to figure it out I'm going through all the the schematics. I'm looking at the electronics. Nothing's wrong I programmed things a certain way.

I told things to do a certain thing and just wasn't adding up And then it was in the rain and I was like I just gotta go look at everything I just gotta go like smell things and I went down there and I took the tarp off of something And I looked at it and I was like no freaking way No, not in a million years an explosion that happened at one location created this fragmentation And one little bitty fragment from that event over there We call this study spatial fragment distribution So like you're measuring where all the fragments go in three-dimensional space, right? Right, so that's not what we were doing on this particular test But it factors in one fragment went a very long ways and went to another place And did something mechanically at the other place to trigger it at a different time Like these are electronic systems But this fragment got to a place it shouldn't have been in a certain way To hit hit the exact combination of things that had to hit in order to make it go X amount of time before it was supposed to like it was how far did it have to go? How far did that thing travel along ways? Not crazy.

I mean like 20 yards 60 feet. Yeah. Yeah 20 inch meters Yeah, I'm just thinking about how many other places that could have gone. Oh, yeah Expanding space emanating from a single point.

I mean that's growing exponentially with each millimeter It goes out. I mean it's a crazy exponential growth curve in every direction. You take that out to 60 feet The odds are very small. It's like a trillion to one.

I mean it's just it went it when I told somebody it could happen I got in my truck and I drove back up top and I was like hey, dude You remember that thing so how could I forget you know how long we planned for that? I was like this is what happened. He just said bull crap. It's like getting the truck right now We went down there and I was like look at that.

He's like no way man. There's no way that happened I was like you're looking at it. I know I'm looking at it, but it didn't happen obviously it did anyway Okay, wait wait wait wait wait so just to be clear that this really was the kind of fluke you're talking about two Ballistics experts who test this stuff for a living went and looked at it and you both beyond the shadow of it out confirmed that that's what happened Yeah, this wasn't something you were reading into it to create a coincidence to offer an explanation to make something that you couldn't explain that made you uncomfortable Go away that you genuinely data driven believe that's what happened Yeah, there was something called a witness mark. That's what we called it like if two things touch each other in a certain way It's like if two cars hit they'll leave the paint They're you know red paint on my white vehicle because a red car must be me That's like tennis if you're not quite sure if the ball was in you can look and if the ball still fuzzy It'll leave a mark in the green right next to the white line and you can gauge it witness mark That's the witness mark.

Yeah, so there was a witness mark and we were like okay that mark on that object bears witness to it It actually was I mean damage. It wasn't just a witness market was like bent broken metal and there's no other way that could have got there Absolutely. Yeah, that's what happened. And of course you have footage and images of it being set up You know it wasn't there before what was so cool is once we understood that we could go back and we could replay the high speed and we could be like It did.

Yeah, exactly. Yeah, exactly. So back to your Murphy's law thing Murphy a lot of times you hear Murphy's law You think it's just like a your kind of attitude about life Oh, if anything can go wrong, it probably will always me But really it's kind of like the infinite number of monkeys on an infinite number of typewriters with an infinite amount of time theorem They can't go wrong. Yeah, it'll produce everything an infinite number of monkeys on an infinite number of typewriters over an infinite number of time Will produce the complete history to the finest detail of every possible permutation that could ever exist in all of conceivable existence Not just Shakespeare.

Yeah. So Murphy's law actually came from a test range My understanding is there was a test that was happening and the guy that was being a human test subject This was out west. I want to say holliman air force base. I may be wrong about that But he was about to do the test and Murphy forget what his rank was and he said oh well These technicians over here are gonna wire this thing up if it can be done wrong that guy will do it wrong The way we say it colloquially or whatever that word is, you know, if it can't go really Yeah, colloquially if it can't go wrong it will it's kind of a variation of what Murphy originally said But on a test range Murphy lives.

Yeah, well, it's absolutely true if it can go wrong and you do it enough times It will yeah that flaw in the system will eventually be exposed. Yeah, huh glitch in the matrix So there isn't really such a thing as a fluke because there's always a reason And so if something was really a literal absolute Impossible thing that just happened for no reason with no meaning attached to it it accomplished nothing That would be more like a meaningless miracle to find the laws of time and space But when we say fluke what we're talking about is something that is so freakishly unlikely statistically Improbable see it in your lifetime, but you saw it once yeah, like I think of spontaneous combustion like a human body You know like I've heard that happened. I've heard that it happens too You gotta think there's all kinds of thermodynamic events happening in a body and so you would think statistically Maybe it would happen, you know, and so it's been proven to be real right? I believe it has but you get used to things not happening enough that the flukes they really do stand out and they really are weird You really think spontaneous combustion would be called on camera but at this point right because we have so many cameras now Well, how many times does it happen?

I don't know like I'm of the impression that we're talking like once or there has to be a White there's gotta be a Wikipedia spontaneous Combustion. There is I've seen it. I just don't remember what it says really even in 2000 years of Eastern and Western Christian history where there are lots of expressions of Christianity that believe in the miraculous still today I tend to be pretty skeptical of that stuff myself, but even with all of that there are only Two or three really difficult to explain away public break the laws of time and space kind of flukes even over that period of time With that people looking for it. I'm sorry.

I know you're taking me to the deep water, but I have to read this This isn't even the deep water. Okay. You just wait it says human spontaneous combustion There have been unconfirmed anecdotal reports of people spontaneously combusting This alleged phenomenon is not considered true spontaneous combustion as supported as opposed to cases have been largely attributed to the wick effect Whereby an external source of fire nearby flammable materials and human bat or other sources. Oh, dear gross I bet that yeah, it's not just a visual that people will never forget who experience it I bet it is also an olfactory experience they never move on from if you click through it takes you to it The next series of Wikipedia pages on paranormal and I just make a habit to not go near that stuff That point gets ridiculous.

Yeah, that's tenetiful hat territory So fascinating because of what it says about the minds of the people who write about it But yeah, okay, all right. That's good to know not a historical example My parents are pretty fun this way because they my mom at least has got a phenomenal fluke story Okay, and she's told it to me a couple of times I still have a rat my brain around it I want to see if I can get her on the phone here and let her run it by you Oh really you can explain it away or make sense of it. Oh, we're gonna talk to your mom You're gonna call her. Yeah, it's a cool if I patch her in here.

Yeah, I love talking to your mom Your big fluke story is maybe the most mind-boggling one I've ever heard and I want to put it in front of Destin and see if you can crack the code I was very young and we were dating and I was home for spring break And your dad was gonna come up and visit me and being a pal I live way out in the middle of nowhere by the otokoban A blizzard hit which was not hitting where your dad was living But it did hit really bad in South Dakota on the prairie My mom got snowed in Rapid City because you couldn't get on from work And my dad put the same on the pick up and went looking for Nancy who was trying to get home from school on the base And he was afraid he had gotten in a bit somewhere So he headed out and got stranded in on the base after he found Nancy the two of them were stuck on the base And I was really concerned that your dad would try to come and get caught in this really dad blizzard That left me a home alone for like two or three days because there was no travel And we had a really awesome phone that had a party line We were too long range the lines went down all the time. Anyway, I prayed about it I picked up the phone and tried to call your dad to say don't come I got through and I didn't talk to him. I left the message And said tell them not to come the weather is really bad And then I hung him up and I picked it up immediately to try and call my mom to find out if dad had made it to the base And if he found Nancy and there was no dial phone and there wasn't a dial phone for the next oh for three days I think maybe even a week it was a long time So I really believe that the phone only worked long enough for me to leave them after to tell your dad don't come And then it was gone again. That's awesome And I had tried to use it prior to that to find out if mom and her turn dad But as it was I just sat out in the lures that didn't like for quite a few days and waited for somebody to come home So that's one of those things that like in the moment, you know from your perspective That was a little tiny miracle for you.

Yeah, I believe it was is is use a present tense verb there Yes, I would have worried a lot There's a lot of open space between during the Wyoming and rapid city, South Dakota Not some place you want to get branded out in a storm, especially in the 1970s Well, yeah back in the 1970s that would have been about 73 maybe 72 or 3. I didn't leave a method because we had okay really funny story with your head not been a You might need to get on the door. Never mind We'll cover that one another day It was a pleasure talking to you as always I love you so much mom. Thank you.

I love you both and always in any way love you too mom Okay, bye bye. She just said she loves you. She I heard that she loves you. She does That feels special a wonderful lady Something I would like to process through with you more maybe later on is in what ways do we assign meaning to those crazy glitches in the matrix The flukes and how would you ever know if it wasn't a glitch in the matrix?

Like if something weird actually happened, right? I'm not sure I could tell the difference Yeah, I've got one of those flukes. I've shared the story with you. Yep.

It's gonna remain personal But yeah, I've experienced those things. I don't want to talk you into telling it. You shouldn't tell it It's just it should be a personal story, but can you just explain why you don't want to? Yeah, because people don't understand where my heart was in the moment and they don't understand the seriousness with which Like it was a very emotional time in my life and you know a lot of people be like, oh, yeah, motion So you're gonna ascribe meaning to anything but it was it was more than that like I had a very specific question that I was wrestling with in a very intense way And the question was literally answered literally like there was a word that was Yeah, I don't want to tell the story, but it and I did the math like I straight up did the math much like your mom says She believes that was a miracle for her.

I genuinely believe it was Genuinely like all the way I've done the math. I know the math and I put them in the calculator Number one the fact that I got an answer to the question Number two it wasn't like a yes or no question I was asking a question about something complex and the answer was a very strange one and number three The way it was answered like literally something came from the sky and fell at my feet and answered the questions craziest thing ever And the other thing was that I received an answer on the day I did So there are a bunch of factors that are a little bit vague for an outsider But what you're saying is there were just multiple layers of glitch in the matrix coincidence fluke that for you in that moment Just felt like that's just too much. There's something to this. Yeah, there's no way you can say Oh, yeah, well, I mean infinite number of monkeys infinite number of typewriters I get that but you still had to be standing in the right place at the right moment I had to be standing in the right place at the right moment and I had to be worried Like when I say worried about the answer to this question like it was I was losing sleep over it and there was like a two day period of time where it would have been really nice to have been given an answer or Some form of reassurance and I was in that period of time And oh by the way, it happened in the middle of a gigantic field You know that I just happened to be standing in and I was the only person literally within a mile and a half I know that for a fact it was a most bizarre thing ever I think one of the things that gets weird when you start talking about fluke's glitches in the matrix coincidences or even I mean to me it was it let's just say it to me it was an answer prayer.

That's what it was Yeah, yeah Or answered prayer or a miracle or any of those things is that no, let me phrase that a different way When you start to wonder if there's a supernatural element a spiritual element to stuff like that I find that it's not very effective when you try to lay that out for other people It's like it's not it just doesn't work that way. It can't work that way I find those things to be very unsatisfactory. I gotta be honest The math on it for me with your story is shocking and startling as well But if anybody less credible told me that I'd say I like they're cooking the books on that story to impress me or make me think stuff The fact that I've seen you in a billion positions to cook the books to make something look better Or be more credible and I've never seen you do it Give me a lot more pause about your story than it does about I mean Your story is about the most credible thing from about the most credible person I've ever met And it's still hard for me to accept the gravity of it for you Because just with me, I wasn't there But I got a few stories that I'm not going to talk about here Because to me they are at the very least An unbelievable series of coincidences that involve life and death and time And again, the math just doesn't work. I'm not good at that like you are, but I can generalize I mean, I can tell when something's freakish and it shouldn't happen But a couple of times I've tried to explain that story even to people who I really really trust There's no way for me to bottle up the effect that had on me and have it have the same meaning or implications as somebody else And further, I think it's kind of unfair for me to expect that So I've just sort of moved on from that as like an evidence or an argument for something greater than us or Miracles or prayer or any of that, but it's something that privately I got a couple things that I find to be pretty compelling Yeah, that's where I'm at with it And another thing I realized is if someone's demanding evidence the same person that's saying give me evidence I'm not saying you shouldn't do that because I certainly do that in my life Yeah, I'm kind of a fan I've often experienced people when they come to a situation like that and they want to have a discussion about that stuff If you kind of lay all the cards on the table and you say look if you just look at this at face value I can't tell you in a deterministic fashion.

It's a one or zero. I can't say that But what I can say is if we look at this probabilistically This is the question I was asking at that time and this is how it was answered We're in the six sigma range of this. No, we're way we're like seven eight sigmas And for me that was enough different people have different thresholds of belief You know at some point you tip over from okay I'll accept that as an interesting glitch in the matrix or not a glitch in the matrix as an interesting thing that was bound to happen In the course of human history, but why did it happen to me in that moment, you know It's almost like I felt like I was meant to have the experience. I don't know.

Yeah, I don't know I think I just have to live with that. It's a lot easier when you see a bird explode There you go Probability fascinates me think about this if you were to be at that game randy johnson winds up He throws the ball and a bird explodes and you just happen to be watching this baseball game in 1890 And you go home and you're like mom you'll never believe what happened, you know dorkman michamans chhire was pitching Against the you know the grisoo graysocks and through the ball and he hit a bird and it exploded She's gonna be like yeah, right. No. No, no, no really it happened the fact that there's a video That's pretty awesome sure and paul bunyan walks around with the blue ox Have you ever watched these one in a million one in a billion videos on youtube with sports stuff?

It's my favorite. I love it. There was a football like how they referred to swab on south america Soccer game they go to flip the coin at the beginning of the game They flip it lands on the ground lands on its edge stands upright in the grass And it was like smooth grass. It just lands upright and they look at like uh In the ref instead just telling the camera to zoom in he's like uh He just picks up and flips it again and they're like what what just happened it's pretty cool I guess statistically that's bound to happen at some point if you flip a nickel It's like the good version of murphy's law.

Yeah, it's interesting when something happens to you And you know that if you tried to you know like bill mary walks up to people in a restaurant who grab their french fries and eat one Look at him and say no one will believe you and he walks away. That's pretty cool. That's a gotta go That's a gotta get it and so I think it's interesting that we all have those things There's just thing that happened to me as a kid. I still think about it today Granddaddy had kind of a driveway out front that was gravel and he used to get the walnuts that would fall from the tree And he would go put the walnuts he'd gather them in a five gallon bucket and he'd pour them out or a pail actually the old metal pail And he would pour them out on the gravel driveway So that when he would drive his old Cadillac around in the driveway, it would crack the walnuts and he'd go pick him up And eat him it's just the thing he did So that this gravel driveway was out there and I used to have an old wrist rocket You know a little elastic tube slingshot and I used to go out into his yard for hours I pick up a rock one day and my dad had this old ham radio It was a vertically polarized ham radio antenna and it was I'd say 25 30 yards away, which is a long long long shot I'm shooting trees, you know, but I have two foot diameter and I look at that antenna and I was like I'm getting pretty good with this thing.

I bet I could hit it And I just pulled it back and I still remember how I held it I held it at about a 45 degree angle Not up in the air, but like my wrist was tilted to the right 45 degree angle and I shot it and it went And I hit it and I thought no one will ever believe me No one will ever believe me that I just one shot that antenna And you know for a 11 year old boy in Alabama to be able to master the weapon that you've trained to be the squirrel slayers Your entire life with, you know, that's like the biggest of deals. Yeah, I was just a really interesting thing No one will ever believe me. I could do that now. I took a friend out golfing She not only had never played golf She never really played sports at all Healthy, smart, charming, well adjusted lady, but not an athlete, just not her thing We went after this golf course in Montana again on a trip with some youth group kids And she'd never held a golf club before she'd never hit a ball We walk out and she, you know, comes up to the green with me and I'm like, all right, this is how you hit a golf ball And I hit a pretty nice shot like I'm gonna have a shot at par Really, hit the ball very well And the kids all go through and we're all just playing in a big clump because the course is totally empty And the kids all go through and you know golf balls all over the place And she's all nervous.

It's like I'm not sure I'm gonna hit it Aced it. She aced her first golf hole A hole in one Aced her first golf hole Her first golf swing was something that professional golfers never accomplished in their entire careers And you were there? Yes, she was in the newspaper for it. You got a hole in one How many people saw it?

A dozen? 10? Something like that? But that seems like it would be not true, doesn't it?

That seems very not true Yeah, she just said a hole in one first time ever playing golf first time ever holding a club And every hit she had after that was hot trash I mean awful. I think she finished dead last by a wide wide margin But she was in first after that hole I've seen some stories like this in really old newspapers Like this person caught a fish and it had somebody's wedding ring in it You've seen stuff like that? Yeah, I mean there's a Bible story about that too with coins and stuff A man fishing in a tournament in Lake Michigan on Friday Caught a fish that had a wedding band zip tied to its tail The Chicago Sun Times report The fishermen and the owner of the ring both say the ring is cursed What? Yeah, that kind of stuff Cursed wedding ring found zip tied to steelheads tail Okay, this was 2019.

This was last year But on Monday the former owner of the wedding band came forward to explain why he released the cursed ring into the water nearly seven weeks ago That his decade-long marriage ended four years ago And he finally decided in a poetic way to discard of the symbol of their ill-fated union I'm a fishing guide She was always against me following my dream and hated how much I fished he said So he attached the wedding ring which had a little diamond and an inscription S.D.H. Steel to the tail of the steelhead and released it across the lake Oh wow, there's a picture There's a picture now, I believe it Picture didn't happen Yeah, just imagine how much stuff like that happened that's been lost to history Yeah, and those stories are fun If you want to get to know somebody That's a great question to ask I think Tell me about the goofy stuff that ever happened to you Without any concern about whether or not I'll believe you Just tell me the crazy stuff you've seen Cause everybody's seen something That's a really good conversation starter Tell me the craziest thing that's ever happened to you You know, I went on that nuclear submarine Most people's craziest thing isn't that crazy Well, I went on this submarine, right in the middle of the Arctic Get on it Interviewing people, I sleep there I learn about how to cook on there, how to use a bathroom All these things I learned And then it's about time to get off the boat And they're like, hey, if you wouldn't talk to vote yet I'm like what? Vote I'm sorry, what word are you saying? It's his last name, vote, V-O-G-T Dude really wants to talk to you You need to go say something to him I was like, why?

He's like, he just really wants to talk to you He's like, sure, yeah, happy to, you know Okay And then finally they're like, okay, go in there Go in there, he's in there, he wants to see you I was like, okay, I walk in there I was like, hey man, what's going on? You don't know what to say I'm like, they're telling me that you want to talk What's going on? He's like, hey man, you're from Alabama, right? I was like, yeah, you're from Hartzle, right?

Yeah, you know a guy named Cape Sandlin? I was like, yeah, that's cool Yeah, he's like, yeah, I graduated with him I was like, what? I was like, dude, we were under the Arctic Ocean I was like, what are you talking about? He's like, yeah man, I went to the same high school you did He's like, no, you didn't But I mean, statistically it's bound to happen, right?

Have you heard the statistic about birthdays That, yeah, it only takes a much smaller amount of people in a room To have pretty much guarantee of a matching birthday than you would figure Yeah, I still don't understand the math on that I don't either Brady or somebody do a video about that I think he did That sounds like a video number file would have Yeah, fascinating, too complex for me Hey, can I merge you with Matt? Yeah, that guy, no, I'm kidding Yeah, here it goes Alright, Matt, got Emily Grassley on the line Hey, Emily, how are you doing? Hey, Matt, how are you? I think it's wonderful, just wonderful We just recorded an episode, we want to do a second ad slot for your TV show No, we thought it'd be cool to just let you talk about it real quick Just tell everybody why they should go watch it on PBS I don't even know how to feel right now I'm so excited, I'm like, super nervous The pre-tower road trip is a three-part new series for PBS It starts coming out June 17th on PBS stations around the country And you can stream it from anywhere in the world on PBS.org But anyway, the show is a personal journey of mine I grew up in Western South Dakota And I kept growing up here, I kind of stopped there Never anything really unique about this part of the country It's just like where I was from, you know?

Yeah And it really wasn't until I moved away And moved not just to Montana, but my job in Chicago That I started thinking a lot more about the place where I come from And learning more about it From the perspective of a natural history museum employee Because all of a sudden, for the first time in my life, working at the Field Museum I'm surrounded by all the EGO's and Pay-Leo nerds And they're like, oh, you're from that part of the country? Like, you're from the heart of fossil country And I wanted to explore this idea and manage to get PBS on board with it And we brought a film crew along And made this travel series that explores about 2 billion years of Earth history By driving on about a 2,000 mile road trip through Five States Beautiful I love the fact that as a fellow small town Intermountain West person We both went to big cities like Chicago Except when I went there, I was still the small town person That nobody was jealous of except when you went there Everybody was like, wait, you're from there And then all of a sudden the tables were turned And you were the awesome one Yeah, it was strange, you know, it gave me a different perspective About this part of the country But I kind of took for granted while I grew up here But it was really awesome Like, I gotta come back, I gotta interview my dad on our ranch Oh, that's cool Talk with him about like, you know, so growing up like my grandpa with a farmer ranch Got in your face and he would just dig up dinosaur bones when he was telling his farm field And he didn't know what they were, he just kind of shoved him in a shed And over 70 years accumulated a huge number of dinosaur bones It's like old grandpa's old marble collection Or grandpa's old collection of, you know, 66 million-fold haggisor long bones That's awesome Yeah, and you know, like the famous T-Rex bottle I recubated with found five miles off my dad's ranch Oh, that's amazing Yeah, that's true, that's true to the T-Rex But I want to slay at the Field Museum that I look at every day I go to work So this show is like a homecoming for you Yeah, it's a journey of rediscovery Yeah, it's been a wild ride So we even then did come back with like this new perspective as a science communicator To think about geology and like why it matters that we think about the world in terms of 10,000,000,000 civilians a billion years Like why do that? It's such a mental exercise, right? And it's an exhausted one To try and thousand that amount of time But geologists do it all the time, it was like a superpower I wanted to figure out how to unlock on my own Like how did they do that?

How did they put this on to perspective By the time like we filmed the show and we wrapped it up Like it's just an awe-inspiring way to view the way that you walk through the world It's a really changed my entire perspective on everything Did you go to places that you'd been a lot already? Did you hit like the highlight places that locals might think of as like this is where you go for dinosaur stuff? Are you finding things that nobody's ever heard of? Both, so like one of the first sites that we visit in the first episode is Silden Lake in the Black Hills, South Dakota in country I was there this week What kind of a, what have you been there?

So like the beautiful boulders that you know 10 like thousands of people come and visit every summer Those boulders are 2 billion years old And the reason that like we have the oldest rocks in the western part of South Dakota at the highest point of the elevation Is just like a byproduct of how the Rocky Mountains were formed 66 million years ago And because the Rocky Mountains pushed out the Black Hills Which pushed out this basement rock of super ancient rocks That you can start from the Black Hills from like Hudson State Park from Silden Lake And you drive their west to the Badlands of South Dakota And you are literally driving through hundreds of millions of years of our history And you can talk along the way at so many different points And find different fossils that represent exactly different periods of the time Emily Grassley, I was just there hiking around the lake Talking with my friends and my kids about how these rocks happened And I was literally like I have friends like a call They would know how these rocks happened Because these rocks aren't like the rocks in Deadwood Just a little bit further north And literally I was like Sometimes when Emily like when I talk with her next she's gonna know the answer to that And then without any prompting You go right there in our conversation That literally you already answered one of the questions I have About all of this and so if the whole show is like that this is gonna be phenomenal Oh yeah, yeah buckle up But like we're getting in the car, we're driving 30 times Get on board So this is you being this Frizzle and the Magic School Bus is what this is A little bit like I'm not gonna lie There is definitely a medical bus like in the show With just a dash of Blanche For the Golden Girls So this is PBS.org And what are people looking for on PBS.org to find it? No, we have a prehistoric road trip That's the name of the show Alright, go support our friend Emily Grassley, PBS.org Prehistoric Road Trip Thank you guys Awesome And so I really am content with that being something that for me as an individual I see something that doesn't make sense I think in terms of narrative I can imagine what it would be like to assign meaning to something arbitrarily And when I find myself doing that it's easy for me to be like I saw something really unique and cool and crazy It doesn't happen very often I was standing in the right place at the right time That's really cool And I'm maybe trying to assign meaning to this right now And I can usually catch it and move on Like I said, there have been a couple of times where Five layers of impossible add up And the sixth layer is that instead of the particles that make up me being spaced us Somewhere far far away There's a me And I'm alive right now And I'm standing here right now And there isn't everybody else This is the odds of all of these things converging And the fact that it seems to specifically address or point to something Or bring clarity to something I don't know, it's almost hard to believe there's nothing to that Then it is to believe there's something to that And I'm talking about like two times in my whole life Maybe one and a half So this is not something I see behind every bush And behind every action You know, I get a good parking spot Because I need to run into Walmart quickly I'm not like that's a miracle I'm not that guy But yeah, I got a couple things too Maybe it's not the right thing to say But I'm not totally sure even what to do with that as we talk about it now Hmm How do we end this episode, man? This has just been the most random whatever Well isn't that what the episode's about though? Kind of It's just the most random whatever And how the heck did that happen?

Yeah, just like the fact that the person listening right now Is passing a mile marker 247 Right as I'm saying this That is mind boggling And the other guy who's got the two kids in the back seat And they're both asleep And he's trying to sneak through the Burger King drive-through Right before they close breakfast Because he doesn't want their stupid lunch But he does want a crescent which but it's like 10-31 And he's just hoping that they'll actually play along Good luck, man Yeah, good luck on that one I hope they still have the croissant which Or the other guy that's driving the old red Chevy pickup truck And his left front wheel is a little flat And he's just trying to limp along And hopefully he doesn't wear the tire out Because of the low pressure that guy Imagine how it feels to be that guy I'm trying to imagine that Or Mike who works at the DMV And they told him to quit listening to podcasts But he keeps sneaking it in anyway And right now he's like, oh no Did they call my supervisor? We did, Mike Oh man, I really hope one of those is right They're all right It's all going to happen Come on infinite number of monkeys deliver Hey, this was fun buddy Thanks for talking about a weird subject And the larger inherent question of Is there meaning to the seeming randomness Of the universe in our existence And well, you and I are both of the persuasion That yeah, in one way or another we think there is And also there's a lot of people I'd like in respect To might answer that question differently To be clear, I think the pillow hitting and landing the way it did Was just completely random, obviously I think so too That's going to happen like one and every few hundred times Right? But there is a threshold where it gets beyond just a coincidence I don't know Some people might have a totally different view of everything and say like Oh no, everything's a coincidence always Yeah, I don't know No, we have slightly different thresholds of belief as you said earlier That makes life interesting And makes it fun to talk with other people about how they see this stuff Which is why you gotta leave with the question What's the craziest crap you ever seen? Who thinks you come from that?

Yeah, call it a fish with a wedding band zip tied to its tail one time See, that's pretty good

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 3 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on June 23, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.