Skip to content
088 - The Dead Sea Scrolls episode artwork

Jul 10, 2020 1 hr 31 min

088 - The Dead Sea Scrolls

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: THE PATRONS You can support the podcast at patreon.com/nodumbquestions It is also totally cool if you don't. STUFF FROM THIS EPISODE TMBH - What Are the Dead Sea Scrolls Dead Sea Scrolls The Dead Sea Monty Python and the Holy Grail Official Trailer Khirbet Qumran Hellenistic Period Alexander the Great Antiochus Epiphanes Maccabees Pompey Essenes Caligula Nero Titus Vespasian Arbel Cliffs Masada The Bar-Kokhba Revolt Indiana Jones - "That belongs in a museum." Hebrew University - Eliezer Sukenik Dead Sea Scrolls - Wikipedia Purim Lunar Calendar Dead Sea Copper Scroll Masoretic Text CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

088 - The Dead Sea Scrolls

0:00 1:31:14
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

All right, so this is the podcast called No Dumb Questions, where I, Destin, I have a YouTube channel called Smarter Every Day, but I like to learn about science and technology and learn things of that nature. But I also like to tip toe into other areas. And Matt, you're the history guy. What kind of stuff do you like to study?

I like history, philosophy, theology. The thing that I really, really like trying to wrap my brain around is how we went from thinking whatever it was we used to think to think in whatever it is we think now. I like the history of ideas. Awesome.

So we do this thing on No Dumb Questions every once in a while where, I don't know how to say this, it's usually we're having a conversation and we're going back and forth and we're both adding things to the pile that we're learning about. This is a very different style that we're going to do today. This is one of these moments where you've learned the thing and you've done the research. And I've stayed over here and I'm pretty dumb on the topic.

I'm going to be the absorber of information and you're going to be the giver of information. Is that a good way to describe this? Well, yeah, I mean to a certain extent, but you're a smart guy and you think about things and you pay attention to what's going on around you. So yeah, feel free to slow me down at any point.

Let's game the thing out a little bit more than just a data dump for me, if you know what I mean. Okay, cool. So in the spirit of the name of the podcast, no dumb questions, I'm going to ask you questions and I guess you're going to teach me and I'm just going to sit here and learn stuff about the Dead Sea Scrolls. Let's do it.

But if I think any of those questions are born out of ignorance or offend me, I'm going to berate you. Sounds great. Okay, buddy. I know you've heard of the Dead Sea Scrolls because everybody's at least heard of the Dead Sea Scrolls.

But what do you know about them? I know that the Dead Sea Scrolls, they were found in clay pots somewhere in the desert. I'm guessing near the Dead Sea. Very good.

And my understanding is that it wasn't like an archeology team that found them. It was like a shepherd or something like that. Like a young person found these scrolls. And when we pulled the scrolls out and put them in like a big room in my mind, it's like a bunch of old school, Indiana Jones style archeologists.

They all started looking at these things and reading them in some kind of ancient language. It ended up being really important for the Bible. My understanding is there's something about these scrolls, these Dead Sea Scrolls, that lends credibility to the Bible. And so Christians and Jews are very interested in these things and other people are like, oh, that's an interesting archaeological thing.

But what I don't know is when they were written, who did them, why? I just don't know what it is. Is it like an early copy of the Bible? I just don't know.

That's where I'm at. That's really good. The Dead Sea Scrolls are a collection of ancient documents that date all the way back to about 250 years before the time of Jesus. So what is that 2002?

Before the time of Jesus? Before. So like BC. Yeah, this is before there's a Roman Empire.

Okay, so right off the bat, you just told me that the New Testament, which is after Jesus, the New Testament is not part of the Dead Sea Scrolls. Is that the first thing I just learned now? That is correct. Okay.

Yep. There are a couple of things about the Dead Sea Scrolls that maybe shed a little bit of light or insight on the New Testament. But the people who wrote it, they wouldn't have been into the Christian New Testament things. They were into the Jewish Old Testament things.

So there's no reason for them to keep New Testament documents as we know them hanging around. And let me just start a disclaimer here, buddy. I know that anytime we have a conversation like this and we invite the third chair to hang out with us. There's a huge variety of people who do so.

And I know third chair that there are some of you who are like, oh, awesome. Something having to do with the Bible. I think the Bible is a really important book and I believe some of what's in there. Maybe all of what's in there.

And that's really exciting for me. And I know there are others who are like, I don't really care for that book very much. And I don't care for the religions that it is produced and I don't think there's anything to it. I totally get and respect where people are coming from on that.

What I think is fascinating about this is that it really isn't first and foremost a topic or debate about whether the Bible is true or somebody believes in God or not. It's just fascinating archeology about a thing that has huge cultural implications and historical implications. And so I think this will be a fun one to unpack regardless of where people are coming from. Is that fair enough?

Yeah, totally. But I've already learned things. First of all, you mentioned that they were discovered in the 1940s. I didn't know that.

Yes. When I think 1940s, I think World War II. So does that mean that these things were found in the middle of World War II? Or like what year were we talking here?

No, they were found just after World War II. So World War II wraps up in the mid 1940s. This is getting into the later 1940s. Okay.

So we're talking about a really rugged, bad land kind of area near the Dead Sea about 20 miles away from Jerusalem to the east and way down hills. Jerusalem is above sea level. The Dead Sea, is it the lowest place on earth? Do you know?

I don't, but you've actually been there, right? I have. And it's crazy. I've never seen anything like this place.

Have you seen the videos and stuff on the Internet of people swimming in the Dead Sea and like they float weird and everything? Yeah, it's my understanding because it's so salty. You're like super buoyant. And so it's you can't dive down or at least it's very difficult to see without weights.

Have you done it? Yeah. Oh, it's off the charts. You can't drown.

Even when I would try to go on my belly when I was swimming in the Dead Sea and just put my face down to see if I could drown. I was like, I don't think I can die in this. There's got to be a way. It's like putting the same pole on a magnet up against another same pole on a magnet.

It just will not work. I can't beef that enough to sink in this. Yeah, it's bizarre. But is it like super duper salty?

I mean, does it burn your eyes like crazy? Oh, heck yeah. Yeah, you can smell it. It's not like being at the ocean where you kind of just have a little bit of that saline feel in the air.

It is pungent. It's everywhere. It smells like wet salt where we were at was a particularly muddy area. Some of the Dead Sea is more blue and beautiful as well.

But we got down in the water with a boatload of other tourists and my kids get in the water and you know how you normally have the dad restrictions on how far the kids can be from you when you're swimming and all that. Absolutely. Yeah. I immediately revoked it all.

I was like, never mind kids. It's impossible to drown. Just go. I swim to Jordan.

I don't care. See what happens. Really? Oh, yeah.

It's crazy. It's really fun too because it's like this mud concoction at the bottom at the north end of the Dead Sea. You can grab this full of people like rubbing it around on their nipples and stuff and like, oh, this is good for the nipples and it gets rid of back knee. And I don't know what people thought they were accomplishing, but everybody's getting themselves.

Throttle back. Throttle back a little bit. So I can't tell what satire here and I can't tell what's real. Nothing is satire.

Oh, this is really satire. Yeah, this is all real. Yeah. Yeah.

So people literally think, OK, OK. Yeah, they think there's some kind of healing quality to that mud. I mean, there's all kinds of makeup products and stuff that are rooted in the elements of the Dead Sea and the mud from the Dead Sea, like Dead Sea mud baths or thing that they sell all over the world. This is a real thing.

OK. All right. And I'm not kidding. Like the old dudes were just taking handfuls and like massaging it on their chests in ways that were really creepy and Eastern European.

They didn't really know what to do with it. OK. All the more reason to send the kids far, far out to see. So the Dead Sea is weird, man.

Have you ever been to any bad lands or like really rugged Mars-like terrain anywhere? Absolutely. Yeah. I've been way off in the desert to places you normally can't go.

There was this one missile range I worked on one time. Where you have to get briefed on turtles before you go out into like you're going to go hundreds of miles out there or maybe not hundreds dozens and dozens of miles out in the middle of nowhere. And if you see a turtle, you have to stop all operations because if the turtle sees you and gets aired and peas like in defense, like it's, oh, God, and it just peas and runs away. That's like all the water that turtle has for the entire last number of months.

They literally have a government appointed turtle hydration specialist that you will radio and you're like, Oh, Tango whiskey. We got a turtle that's just dehydrated itself and water XYZ and he's like, we're all the way in the light come out there and they'll hydrate the turtle because water is so precious in those environments. Okay. Okay.

Okay. You got a throttle back here. I can't tell what is satire and what is not. It's all real.

Yeah, that's all real. Okay. Anyway, the point is yes, I've been to places that are very, very dry. Okay.

And why would someone go out and live there next to the turtles that shouldn't be? They wouldn't. There's no reason to live there. This is a point of transit.

Like you go through this place to get somewhere else. And to like learn things about yourself, metaphorically. Yeah. You don't go to the desert for any reason other than like some sort of emotional, personal, existential, spiritual journey.

It's just the only reason you'd end up there is if you had some very unique opportunity to make a buck or if there were social pressures from elsewhere that pushed you into a place nowhere else would want to be, right? But what's it? Yes, absolutely. But there's other things I can feel you pulling me in the right direction here.

So for example, out in Arizona, or maybe I don't know where it is, maybe it's Nevada. I don't know. There are aircraft graveyards out there because the environment, the climate locally is so dry and airy that things get preserved for a really long amount of time. And so are you kind of walking in that direction or you about to tell me that the dead sea scrolls are where they are because it was so dry in that area that they would be preserved for a long amount of time?

Is that what you're taking me? Yeah. There are three factors and that's good anticipation. Factor number one for why we were able to recover scrolls that got put in caves over 2,000 years ago that are still intact enough to read today.

Reason number one that they're still there is because the people who put them there didn't live in a more populous place where they would have been discovered. They lived somewhere that was crazy remote, so people just weren't rifling through the caves for 2,000 years looking for anything of value. If they had done the same thing in like downtown Jerusalem, like how many times has that been built up and built over and conquered and people going through with the fine-tooth column because they want religious artifacts? Well, not the case when you're talking about really inaccessible caves halfway up the side of a cliff face that nobody accepted random shepherd once every couple thousand years would ever bother to go into.

So yeah, that is one factor, the remoteness. But another factor, and you would understand this way better than me, is that obviously certain types of soil contain certain microorganisms that work more quickly on organic material than other types of soil. Is that a fair statement? Yeah, I would have seen so.

It sounds right. Just intuitively, if we took a wadded up piece of tissue paper and we threw it out in like a really black thick potting soil kind of composty mixture out in the backyard, we would expect that to dissolve and go away much more quickly than if we set the same thing in an alkaline or very arid cave where there are no elements that it's being exposed to. And it's getting shelter, right? Like one's going to get eaten quicker than the other.

The more organics that are present, the more moisture so that these organic processes can do their thing. Yeah, totally. Makes sense. Okay.

So there's two factors then as to why these things were still sitting around and were still legible two thousand years after the fact. One, they were in a remote place. Two, they were in a very dry place. And then three, it has to be something having to do with the climate itself because it's not humid because maybe you've got this salinity in the air.

I don't know. It just created this perfect environment for preservation. Have you ever seen any of the peat bog people like the humans that got stuck in some peat bog somewhere in Europe and then we find them a thousand years later? And they still look like a person?

Yeah, I have. In Germany, there's this whole peat bog area and there's this whole archaeology thing associated with it. It's fascinating, which seems like the opposite of the Dead Sea, right? Real dry in area.

This is like real moist. And so you would think that if you fell into a bog, you would rot immediately, but that doesn't seem to be the case. I don't understand the chemistry, but something's going on there. Yeah, I saw this as ironic because I saw a display about the bog people at the Denver Natural History Museum.

And I also saw the Dead Sea Scrolls for the first time at the Denver Natural History Museum. And so it really is opposite ends of the spectrum where two very different environments preserved something really, really well. So whatever the case, normally, if you write something down on a sheet of paper in the era of Alexander the Great or just after Alexander the Great, you would expect that to be gone by now. You're just not going to be able to go and pull that up.

But in this particular situation, not only were we able to find one or two things that were written down, we were able to find like a thousand fragments or partially complete or even almost fully complete scrolls documenting a whole bunch of different stuff, including a bunch of what we call the Old Testament. What would be the holy grail in your discipline? Fusion propulsion, perpetual energy machine? Like what would be the thing that if you found it, it would change everything?

Oh dude, yeah, it'd be fusion. Like, figuring fusion out is a big deal. Fusion where you have a gain of more than one so that you could sustain fusion to the point where you could extract energy from it and power out. That would be the holy grail at this point.

Do you know why I understood what you just said? Because our previous episode where you learned about fusion propulsion? Yeah, because Dr. Cassey taught me things and now I understand how that all works.

Not all of it, but I understood well enough to at least get what you were saying. So thank you for that. Yeah, thank you. So are you about to tell me that the Dead Sea Scrolls were the holy grail for your discipline?

Well, no, it's not a lot of ways. The holy grail is the holy grail of discipline. If you can find that, that would be the winner, right? I've never understood why the holy grail was so important to be honest with you.

It's important because of medieval legends. It's mythology is where it's at. Like the holy grail, I don't know, to be honest with you, I mean, the Monty Python is the holy grail is my favorite. It's one of the best of it, but it's ever.

But you know what, I need to expose my children to that. Anyway, that's a rabbit trail. So I'm going to follow it for about rabbit trail, Monty Python. I see what you did there.

I'm going to follow it for like 10 more seconds because it really is an interesting question that you just asked on that. We're putting a pin in it. We're coming right back to Dead Sea Scrolls. The holy grail thing is something that was really interesting because Joseph of Averimathea, supposedly it was maybe the cup that caught the blood of Jesus.

Can we just stop and you just do a whole episode on that in a future episode? Because I really want to know all that stuff and I don't want to just do lip service to it. I want to learn stuff. Yeah.

I was doing some kind of like verbal handshake agreement that we're going to do a holy grail episode someday. Yes. Rod that. I'm putting my hand behind your thigh right now virtually.

Oh, that's covenant. Well, deeper in there than you need to be pal, even over the internet. Dead Sea Scrolls. We're going to have to get into the holy grail thing deeper in a minute because this really is the holy grail or one of the holy grails of studying ancient texts and manuscripts.

But we haven't done enough to explain why and have you be dazzled by it. I don't want you to be not dazzled. So we're going to come back to white matters in just a minute. Pin is in that.

Dazzle me, Matt. Dazzle me. So you find all these texts and the big question that people are going to be asking is first of all, you know, where do they come from and second of all, what do they say, right? The question of what's in them gets answered by the fact that this discovery happens near this ancient settlement called Kerbet Kumran.

Kumran is what it typically gets called. It's not a big community. Can you spell that please? The first one starts with a K and it has like an H and a T in it somewhere and then Kumran is Q, U, M, R, A, N.

Kumran. Is that an Arabic term? You know what? Yeah, it must be.

Yeah, it must be because this is technically in Palestine, right? What most people without making any political statement whatsoever would define as part of Palestine right now. Okay. This area is in a historically disputed territory over the last half century, 70 years.

And generally speaking, there hasn't been a whole lot of hostility over this particular archaeological site because everybody appreciates the gravity of the thing. It was found by Bedouin Shepherds. So those would be, I assume, Muslims. And it's held in a Palestinian area that is largely associated with Islam, but Palestine has a ton of Christians in it as well.

And it's right next to, well, it is historical Israel. So obviously there's a lot of interest in it from that perspective as well. How did I do a thread in the needle there? I'm trying to thread a needle.

Yeah. I'm less interested in anything that trying to couch what you're saying to make sure people are happy. I'm more interested in the topic itself. So by understanding correctly, you're saying that the reason the Dead Sea Scrolls were even discovered in the first place is because they were put in a specific location on the Dead Sea that was A in a very low population density.

Yes, sir. B, the soil was specifically set up so that microorganisms wouldn't jump on and bacteria destroy the scrolls themselves. And C, the climate itself was arid and there wasn't a certain amount of moisture that would kill stuff. Is that mind-shaining of why they were discovered at all after thousands of years?

Yeah. Okay. Yes, that would be my read on it. That's a very succinct way to put it.

So big, big picture here. 2300-ish years ago, there's a group of people who are a part of Judaism and they don't like the way Judaism is going. There's a liberal component to Judaism. There's a more conservative component.

And this division within Judaism becomes more pronounced after Alexander the Great comes through Israel and bloodlessly, according to Alexander, at least, liberates Jerusalem. From who? Jerusalem does not resist. From themselves.

Oh, okay. That kind of liberation. Okay. Yeah.

Okay. It's a tough one because I don't want to go to the beginning of time to explain this. But the quick version is in the 6th century BC, the Babylonians conquered the Jewish people, the Israelites, the southern kingdom of Judah. And they took them into captivity in Babylon.

And then a generation later, the Persians came along and defeated the Babylonians under the leadership of Cyrus the Great. Then Cyrus the Great was like, you know what? We're going to do things different than Babylon. Instead of relocating everybody, we're going to let people go home and do a little bit of self-governance.

The Persians were pretty enlightened, pretty progressive. They get portrayed negatively in 300, but really pretty good empires, ancient empires go. So the Jews go back and are able to govern themselves using their law as something of a constitution and a civil law, which creates some challenges because it wasn't really built for that. And they do this for the course of a couple hundred years, but then of course, the Greeks and the Persians, again, this is your Sparta and Leonidas and all of this.

In the background of the Hebrew, the Jewish, the Israelite people trying to rebuild their people under the distant authority of Persia. Persia and the Greeks are fighting and fighting and fighting. And eventually, Alexander the Great comes along. He's like, enough of this Persia thing.

We're just doing a big march of conquest. And he gets in a big fight with Darius III, Emperor of Persia, battles his way all around this giant march of conquest. And establishes himself as effectively king of everything. It's the largest empire of the world that ever seen at that point.

And along the way, the Jewish people were like, yeah, this is a runaway train. We're just going to roll with this. And so Alexander takes possession of Jerusalem and it is absorbed into this larger Alexandrian Empire. Well, then Alexander dies a few years after that.

His generals divide up the empire and the Seleucid Empire is born out of one of those generals, and it rules over modern day Israel, Palestine, Lebanon, that part of the world. This goes okay for a while, but the thing about Alexander, he was smart. He knew that the key to making this work was not to crush people. It was to integrate with people.

So he spreads the Greek language and Greek culture and Greek writing and Greek wives all over his new empire. And Greek overnight becomes the lingua franca of the whole world. This is called Hellenism, the Hellenistic era. It's the Greek-ish era when Greek culture integrated with everything, including Jerusalem.

You know how the Jewish people felt about other religions mingling with their religion, right? Yeah, it was no bueno. They didn't like it. Increasingly, the relationship between the very traditional Jewish people and their Greek overlords becomes more and more contentious until eventually, one dude, a Greek king named Antiochus Epiphanes, goes so far as to profane the temple and sacrifice a pig, or he threatens to do so, counts of differs to whether it actually happened in the temple of God.

It's unfathomable. I don't even know what horrible taboo I could liken it to today. It was unfathomably evil and revolting and awful in the eyes of the Jewish people at that time. So they're like, yeah, we're done here.

And they have a great big revolt, and the revolt is led by the Maccadese family. This is what Hanukkah is a celebration of, and they establish a new kingdom called the Hasmonean dynasty. And that is ultimately conquered by Julius Caesar's buddy Pompeii in the middle of the first century BC, about 60 years before Jesus. In the middle of all of that time, there are Jewish people who are like, look, I think we just need to play nice with our Greek overlords and adopt their culture and language.

We can synthesize our belief in God with Greek beliefs. And there are other Jews at the time who are like, heck no, we cannot. There's nothing in common between the two. We need to get rid of these people.

And then there are others yet who say, we're retreating from the whole debate. We're going to make a compound. We're going to focus on spiritual things and personal good behavior and right pure living. And we are going to live in harsh conditions, but we divorce ourselves from all of this.

These people are called the Essenes, and we believe those are the people who founded Qumran. So all of that history is meant to explain how these people went out into the desert in the first place, all of the social and political pressures that they faced that caused them to go out there. And then ultimately how this one big, final straw event was the thing that caused them to say, hey, we got to get out of here, cause them to stash these scrolls and these caves and disappear to wherever they went. That was a lot of information.

Did that make sense? Yes, and well done, by the way, applause for reviewing that. Thanks, buddy. It was like, how much 600 years of antiquity you covered right there?

We covered a lot. So you're saying that these scrolls were put in this cave by the Essenes just before Christ? When did this happen? Okay, yeah.

So that's the next question. The first question is who were these people and where did they come from? We've covered that. They live in this unique community that's almost like a monastic community where monks live with all these rules and different times of day.

They have to do different chores. We know they had incredibly short life spans and we know they really liked the written word and were really into prophecy and what Christians call the Old Testament, what Jews call the scriptures. One second. How did we know they had short life spans, meaning them as a people?

Like collectively, they had a short run of their little micro culture or like each individual human had a short run. They died young. Yeah, in part without access to even what we've been now called very primitive medical care, but without access to society, it was to harsher life in harsher conditions. We also know this is really interesting.

The excavations at Coonron have revealed that the way they set up their latrine area, their toilets, a few hundred feet from the settlement. We went back and we were able to, not we, I had nothing to do with this. People way way way smarter than me who are good at these things in the place where science and history meet. When did some digging around and discovered that there were massive, very harmful to human bacterial colonies that were being tracked back in from the latrines to the places where food prep happened and where people lived.

And it's estimated from, I couldn't tell you the whole process, but it's estimated that the average lifespan in Coonron was something in the mid 40s, which was much lower than what people were experiencing, say in Jerusalem or any of the other major Roman hubs. How can you know that? Like, how can archaeologists know that? I'm skeptical that you can find that information from things in the dirt.

Unless one guy wrote it down like, man, really stinks that we only live about 40 years old. That's unfortunate. Meanwhile, I'll go die later, you know, unless there was something like that written down, how can you know that? I think there may be written records on this and I'm shooting from the hip entirely because this isn't specialized in this stuff at all.

If I recall correctly, there's stuff written down that give clues suggesting it was a shorter lifespan here. Additionally, they buried people. And when you go and look at burials, you can kind of figure out how old somebody was based on features of bones and jaw and teeth and all of that stuff. And it looks like there aren't really a lot of old people that were getting buried.

I think that's part of how they reasoned to this estimated lifespan. Okay. And then corroborating that with the latrine data that they got, that seemed to support it and offer an explanation. Again, could be way off.

I'm just going to be honest with you. Like, I feel like the latrine data, I feel like that is a solution looking for a problem is kind of what that feels like to me. That sounds like somebody's PhD researcher like, oh, well, we know this thing is true. So let's make up something that makes it sound true.

That's just what it sounds like to me. I remember, and this is why I say that because it's not, I'm not throwing stones at your discipline. I specifically remember one test a long time ago on the rocket range. We fired a thing and I called on the radio and I was like, hey, person that's running the radar, what range did that thing land at?

And I will never forget the response. It was what range was it supposed to land at? You know what I mean? I was talking about like housing appraisals.

Yeah, exactly. Like what is it supposed to be? What's the contract for? It's worth that much then.

Yeah, I'll say $500 now, please. Exactly. And so the latrine data thing just I don't know. I'm not throwing stones at I just I think it's a really really weird thing.

Yeah, and I have done a terrible job of presenting that. It's just not my primary area of interest or knowledge on this at all. So I would guess that the data on that is much, much more convincing than what I've presented, but I would also readily concede that in all disciplines, there are PhD dissertations that get written to answer a legitimate question and others that get written because you have to write one. Absolutely.

I don't know poop. That sounds interesting. Let's write about that. And I don't know which this is.

So I know doubt have done a poor job of representing it. Whatever the case. No, no, you've taught me many things. You taught me about why we were able to find them.

You know, the population density, the types of soil and the climate itself. You've taught me where they were found, which is in Coomeron. And you taught me the name of the people that put them there, which are the Essene people. And even what those people were all about.

Like they had this little compound and the purpose of the compound was just try to like go out and like do your own little thing. Am I tracking? What you're saying? Yeah, very rigorous, conservative, religious discipline.

That's the kind of stuff they were into. Okay. And they thought the world was going to end. They had an apocalyptic view of the reasonably near future.

And they spent a lot of time writing and thinking about what their role would be when all of this prophecy came to fruition and stuff got crazy and went down, even possibly militarily. So it's not hard to liken them to their preppers. Yeah, yeah, very well said. And I apologize for not being more clear on some of the excavation questions, like the latrine thing, which I think is super interesting, but I just don't know that that well.

So you were asking the question though, about when they actually hid the scrolls. And what's interesting about that is that initially they had no reason to hide the scrolls. Nobody was going out there to bother them 250 years before Jesus during the early part of the Seleucid that's the Greek overlord empire that was going on there. But these people just sat out in the desert and watched that come and go.

And then they sat out in the desert and watched this massive Jewish rebellion that put an end to the Seleucid Empire, the Greek occupation. And then they watched the Hasmonean, the Jewish dynasty, come and go. They watched Pompeii come and enter the holy of holies in the temple in Jerusalem. They watched or got the news, maybe the Julius Caesar got assassinated.

They maybe heard rumors about different messianic claimants coming and going like Jesus of Nazareth. They lived in the same zip code as John the Baptist. They no doubt knew who John the Baptist was. A lot of people think John the Baptist might have hung out there and even swapped the influence with this particular community of Qumran.

They have a lot in common. But then what happened is there's a really pivotal incident under the Roman authority that starts to change the political climate for the people in Qumran and starts to make them feel like they can't hide out here much longer. So the Romans did a thing that we call the the client king model. Let me ask you this, who is in charge of things in Judea during the time of Jesus?

You mean specifically, so you're going to say Pontius Pilate? Sure. That's one, but then where does Herod fit? Above it.

So Herod is like the governor and Pontius Pilate was like the mayor is how I think of it. Is that right? That's a good guess. It's not quite right.

The way it actually worked is they were corresponding authorities. So the governor was appointed by Rome and this was usually someone who was decidedly Italian in descent. Pontius Pilate was as you remember I was talking about from just right down the road from Rome. He was there to represent the interests of Rome to maneuver things around militarily, keep order and collect taxes.

He is the supreme authority when it comes to Rome's representation there. So he is the governor. Herod and eventually Herod's descendants have different roles in what is often called an ethnarchy. They're an ethnic local ruler whose job it is to cooperate with the governor, the actual Roman governor, to keep order collect taxes, but also to be a little bit more aware of and sensitive to the cultural needs of the local area.

It'd be like the governor of Illinois interacting with the mayor of Chicago. So I got it backwards. Yeah, maybe just a little bit. So Herod was below Pontius Pilate.

Herod might not have agreed with you, but I think history bears out that Roman governors had the trump card over client kings. Okay, so yes, I would say Pilate was above Herod. Okay. So what happens then is that at times this system works and at times it doesn't work very well.

And there's this big faction within the Jewish people even during the time of Jesus. You remember this? We want Jesus to be a military messiah who will kill the Romans and give us another Jewish dynasty. We want the occupiers gone and there were still other people are like, no, I'm only concerned with spiritual matters and still others who are trying to be sophisticated and buddy up to the Roman occupation.

That was the political moment there. Well, Jesus comes and goes around 30 AD and then things get really hot by the time you get into the 60s AD. You get worse emperors who come along, guys like Caligula and Nero, guys who are just absolute nightmares as leaders. And finally, the Jewish people get enough momentum to say we're rebelling and they do throw a rebellion and it goes pretty well at first.

The fighting range is all over, but Rome, you just can't trifle with Rome as the biggest nastiest military in the history of ever. And Titus and Bespasian, father and son, take turns punishing the Jewish people. They ultimately corner them in a bunch of cliffs around the Sea of Galilee. That's where one of the famous last stands occurs.

And the other very famous last stand of the Jewish people happens right down around Qumran, just a little further south on the Dead Sea in a place called Masada. Do you remember what happened there when the Romans finally breached the walls? It's basically the Alamo, right? Except if people with the Alamo killed themselves instead of the King killed.

Yeah, it's an amazing fortress. I've been there, I've taken it in. The Romans built this huge siege ramp to come and destroy it. The point is it was a really good rebellion and the Jewish people fought really hard and dug in really hard.

But Rome always won at this point in history. And they punished the rebels very violently. They increased restrictions on the Jewish people. Well, another generation goes by after that with the poor people of Qumran sitting out here going, we're just trying to do religion out in the desert, please leave us alone.

But the more we fight, the more scrutiny comes down on us. We don't like this, so they're more and more wary. But then in the 130s, there's another revolt. And this one is called the Barcocca revolt.

And for a moment, there's an independent Jewish state that gets established. But ultimately it gets crushed even more violently than the one that resulted in the destruction of the Jewish temple in 70 AD. And after this, the Jewish state idea is just over. It's gone.

It doesn't happen again until the 1940s. It is at this point that the writing stops at Qumran. It's at this point that the people who study this believe that the Qumranians don't even know which column, the Essenes at Qumran, we're like, we got to stash all of our stuff and get out of here. We got to clear out.

And so apparently they take at least a thousand, maybe much more. Who knows how many we haven't found yet of these precious scrolls. I mean, their library, the written word was their most treasured possession. And they stash them and it's super hard to see hard to get to caves within about a five mile radius of their settlement.

And they flee. They take off. Now surely the idea was when this stuff simmers down and Rome clears out and things get back to normal, maybe we can return and resume things. But as best as we can tell, they never came back.

And the site is abandoned from that moment forward. And then these documents just hide in caves and go dormant for a couple thousand years. That's the stuff of treasure hunt, right? Yeah, it's amazing.

You look a lot thinner than the last time I saw you, buddy. Yeah, no. I mean, we haven't been able to scavenge like normal. No, we haven't.

Ever since the nuclear winter, we're here in the back catalog, obviously replacing an ad that's no longer relevant with knowledge from the future. And I mean, I don't know what to say, man. I haven't been able to scavenge like normal. I'm assuming.

Well, you're 40% robot now, so you don't need as much food. That's at least positive. I am. I am.

And the unfortunate thing is that my appendages that are now robotic are hydraulic. I got the old model. I didn't get the electro-mechanical ones. Like you have, which I'm frankly jealous of.

Well, you were an early adopter. I waited for improvement in the technology. I know I thought it was cool and futuristic and stuff like that. But dude, it's just not working like I wanted to.

And sometimes I'll be walking in a straight line. And then all of a sudden, I get cavitation in my hydraulic line, like a little air bubble, I guess. And then I lose compression and I fall over and I look more on in front of all my other cyborgs. And I don't know what to do.

You think you're going to get bumped down another level in the underground silo this year? I think so. But I've worried about that. I'm trying to remain optimistic.

You dropped four more levels and you're just going to become a crate-mover, man. I understand. We need to scavenge more because if we can upgrade your parts, then maybe you can at least stay in the middle levels of the underground post-apocalyptic silo. And we can still hang out.

But I fear that if we can't afford the oxygen rations to go out and keep scavenging, we won't be able to find you those parts. And we'll be separated forever as friends. I understand this, Matt. Where are we to find the resources to afford the oxygen credits to go and do the necessary scavenging to build back the rest of your non-organic cyborg parts well enough that you can remain useful to society here in the underground silo.

And we can continue to live on the same level and be friends. Well, I do have an idea. Okay. It's crazy.

It's crazy. I mean, I don't know that this will work. So crazy times. If we were able to get a message back in time to the earlier parts of the podcast, maybe we replaced ads or something back there.

I don't know. I see. If we were able to do that, maybe we could tell people to support at patreon.com slash notem questions, which as you know, if we get enough supporters on patreon.com slash notem questions, we get to go beyond the mushroom level and we get to go up into the, I don't even know, I mean, there's sunlight up there. We get to go beyond the fungicide, whatever.

I don't even know what you call that place. I've never been since the nuclear winter. So if we could get enough support on patreon, I think they'll let us go above and our foraging would be more effective. What do you think?

If we had enough oxygen credits, we could rove even further and theoretically find what we need to preserve your aging cyborg body and our friendship. Yes. It sounds like this. What did you call it again?

Patreon. I particularly want to try to find the parts that are failing in your memory sockets. Yes. I was like, what am I talking about my cyborg appendages or my talking of?

Yes. Patreon, of course. And then maybe we could afford a quart of skydraw, which as you know, is the only working hydraulic fluid, which is also caustic. And it damages some of my seals.

So yeah, I would be down for it. If we could get the people of the past to support on patreon.com slash Node-Am Questions, I think that's our only hope. It's a long shot. And if this is our best plan, things aren't looking very good.

But it's the best we've got. And I say we just make the ask. I think we use our best. If you like to help our friendship survive the apocalypse and help us have the ability to purchase oxygen credits sufficient to rove beyond our underground bunker's normal roving range to try to find the parts we need to maintain Destin's ailing cyborg body.

Yeah, simply go to patreon.com slash Node-Am Questions and select your preferred support level. Thanks, man. That means a lot that you would be willing to use the last few drops of time travel internet on this. Thank you.

This is my greatest honor. Okay, got it. So I understand why the swirls were preserved because of the environment they were preserved in. I understand where it's at, Kumran.

I understand the people and why they did it. But what I don't understand is who found them and how. Like, it's 1940s, as you said earlier. So if it's the 1940s, we should know the exact name of the person that found these or like group of boys or whatever.

Do we know that information? We do. And I'm not using any notes or anything here, but I did have to look this one up and just make a note of it. So the two guys have found it were Bedouin goat herders named Juma and Muhammad Edib.

And I did not know that off the top of my head. That's a hard name to remember. These sound like Islamic names. Yeah.

And that's one of the incredibly interesting ironies of the whole thing is two good Muslim boys discovered something that proved to be hugely helpful and important, not just to the history of the world, but very specifically to the history of Christianity and Judaism. Interesting. Okay. And how did they find them?

So story goes and I've heard some people refute this, but there's no good reason to refute it. We only have their version of the story. So I'll go with it. They were kids.

They were hurting goats up on these rugged cliff sides and they're throwing rocks into caves and they heard something break and it freaked them out and they ran away and then later they got less freaked out and they came back and they went in there and literally they found these clay jars cracked open with dirt, dust and visible, large scrolls sticking out of them. And one of those scrolls turned out to be an almost completely intact copy of the book of Isaiah. So still the first discovery in all of this is probably the most significant. That scroll is kind of the big deal.

That's interesting. Like, first of all, it's a weird story. I don't know. I've been a kid in the woods and I have found weird things.

I remember finding a six pack of beer out by the way. I was young and I tried to be a good little boy and I was like, oh man, we found beer. We should pour it out. That's a really nice gesture.

That's what I did. It's what I did. I poured it out, but the problem is I went back to anyone's mouth. They're just like under the ground.

Under the ground for a dead person. But the problem is I went back to my mom and I smelled like beer. It's just like what's going on. But I remember that what we did and I remember going back and explaining it and not making any sense.

And I also remember going and seeing a bunch of icicles and telling my mom, hey, we saw a bunch of icicles and not telling her the part about us throwing rocks at the icicles that were like 10 feet tall and we broke them off. Didn't tell her that part. So this story kind of sounds interesting to me. It sounds like they went into a cave.

They found some jars and then they threw rocks at it, broke it. And they're like, hmm, we probably shouldn't have done that. We'll leave that part out. That's kind of what that sounds like to me.

But regardless, they found a good thing. So these two boys found this. What do they do? They go tell somebody they found it?

I don't exactly know how they made the connection, but somebody who heard from the boys sold them to Antiquities Dealers. And this was a huge deal for about 100 years from the mid 19th century to the mid 20th where people could just go and buy like mommies. It was a common trait. Did this go by somebody's dead body from a couple thousand years earlier and just have it in your estate in England or whatever.

People bought and traded and swapped mommies. This was a thing. Okay, got it. So you can just buy things back in the day.

Yeah. And so when people first found the scrolls, they're like, oh, it's not like we found this massive cultural important thing. They saw money. Yes.

I mean, that was just part of the trade, part of the business at this time. And it's both a pity that that was part of the deal. And it's also kind of awesome because a lot of things got preserved that might otherwise not have because they were worth something and they were valuable to collect. You know, when Indiana Jones is having the fight and he's like, that belongs in a museum.

You know, they're all bickering about that stuff. Yeah. That really was pretty accurate. It was a reflection of the debate that was going on in the 1930s and 40s about how archaeology should be handled in the British Museum is way in and on that.

Whatever the case, the initial cave gets lost. They can't remember which cave it was or they couldn't figure out who the boys were who found it. Maybe the boys kind of went underground with this a little bit and didn't want people to know. Oh, for whatever reason, it took another year or so to just figure out who found the cave and to be shown where the cave was.

And there's pretty quick confirmation that they found the right cave, which they called Cave One, the first one to be discovered because there's more stuff in there that hadn't been unearthed. Over the course of the next 10 years, all of these researchers show up and they're just pouring through every little nook and cranny in this very pockmarked cliff base looking for anywhere else that these ancient, vanishing, almost cult members would have stashed their writings. As they poke around, they end up finding 10 more of these caves. You gotta just picture this for a minute because this is where you get into the really legitimate mystery and wonder of the whole thing.

I just imagine being somebody in the 1940s whose job it is to go see if any of those caves have priceless artifacts maybe sitting in there. Oh, yeah. We've already found three or four caves that do. Maybe you'll be the one who finds the next one and then you actually do dig down in there.

You get deep in, you pull back dust, whatever it actually looked like to find it, and you see one of those little bits of parchment scroll sticking out of the ground. I mean, what must that have been like? Yeah. So if I'm shank correctly, this is what the way it's set up in my mind.

There's this village where the Essings used to live, but now fast forward 2000 years, this is where the Bedouin culture lives in this particular area. Some kids are out goat herding and however they get into this cave, they find these things. They take them back, they're worth money, and then people go back looking for more and they find this whole other cave system like a cave network. Am I understanding correctly?

I don't think it's a network. Okay. I think these caves are caused by weathering from the outside in, not from pockets and internal forces. Like sometimes you get those like mammoth cave isn't caused because a bunch of wind and rain hit the side of a cliff face and carve something out.

It's caused by pockets of internal turmoil and the development of big chunks of rock. This is not a network. I don't believe these are pockmarks, indentations in the cliff face. I don't mean to say this in a derogatory way towards the Bedouin.

Obviously understood there was value there, but who was the first expert in the topic? Shout up on the same. It was like, oh my goodness, this is what this is. We did it change from an interesting thing we found to the most important thing in the history of this whole field of study.

There's a guy from Hebrew University whose first name I don't remember, but his last name is Suganik. And he finds out that this stuff has been floating around and really wants to nail down where this was found, who had it, when they had it. And he seems to lead the impulse toward getting to the bottom of the thing. But the stuff is getting sold quicker than he can track it back down.

And so if I recall correctly, a few years after the fact, a handful of these scrolls went up for sale like in a New York newspaper or something, an American newspaper at least. And that really gets people's attention. And at that point, you've got some religious folks in the area. I think an Orthodox Christian monastery or leader comes into possession of a few of the early copies of this.

And they're trying to protect that during an era of turmoil. You've got antiquities dealers who have them, and then you've got this guy from the Hebrew University trying to track it all back down and put the toothpaste back in the tube. By this point, we're into the mid 1950s. And now people are really starting to look.

And this is when the big era of discovery of the additional caves, which end up being 10 additional caves. I think 11 are discovered in this initial run. That's when all of this unfolds. I've got the Wikipedia page pulled up here, and I'm going through and I'm trying to back check you as I go.

And it's a mess, man. You'll say a name and I'll search for it and it'll be in some really weird place. Like, so it's very clear that you're having to give me a very compressed version of events here. Like they're trying to track down where all these fragments were and all this kind of stuff.

It looks like it got really weird. Well, it did get really weird. And you think about it. That is a function of geography and religion.

I mean, the Dead Sea, Jerusalem, is at the intersection of three continents and the three biggest historical world religions. Everybody has an interest. And everybody's there. And you throw money into the equation.

And you throw military turmoil into the equation because this is when Israel is becoming a nation. And yeah, it's going to get a little bit weird. I'm just going to read random sentences from what I'm seeing here. Damp conditions from temporary storage of the scrolls in the Ottoman bank vault from 1956 to the spring of 1957 led to a more rapid rate of deterioration.

And then you just scroll a little bit. It's like, until the 1970s, the scrolls continued to deteriorate because of the poor storage arrangements, exposure to different adhesives and being trapped in moist environments. And like, apparently these things changed hands so many times. At what point were they studied?

They're being studied from the beginning, but just not all at once. And even now, I don't think anybody owns all of the Dead Sea Scrolls. I mean, very recently, the Bible Museum in Washington, DC tried to buy a handful of copies. And it ended up being a bunch of frauds that they spent a ton of money on.

And they got duped. So there are recent forgeries even now if the Dead Sea Scrolls still floating around. The shrine of the book in Jerusalem has got a huge collection of these things, including a display of the Great Scroll of the Prophet Isaiah. I've never seen that actual scroll, but I've seen a facsimile of it at the Vatican.

And it's amazing how intact that thing is. There's a picture that I put in a YouTube video. I did about this of President Obama standing there, just marveling at the Great Scroll of the Prophet Isaiah. So I guess your question is tough to answer because, well, which Dead Sea Scrolls?

Which fragments? Lots of different people have had access to lots of different expressions of this thing. And the study of them isn't even really a uniform thing. If you're looking at the Great Scroll of the Prophet Isaiah, that's over 20 feet long and it's almost entirely intact.

And it reads just like the Isaiah that was in people's Bibles in the 1940s. Amazingly accurate. But the study you're going to do on that is not going to be so much trying to cobble back together the words that part's already done. What you're going to be doing is trying to do a textual study to compare that to the other manuscripts of Isaiah that have survived the centuries, to figure out how accurate these copies all are.

Whereas if you go and get one of the gazillions of teeny tiny little slivers of Dead Sea Scroll that have been found, you're trying to cobble back together a jigsaw puzzle from history. You don't know if you're looking at a piece that dates to 200 BC or 180. That's very painstaking. And so I think a lot of people from the outside looking in imagine that you just go with a shovel and you dig some crap out of the ground.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 31 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on July 10, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.