So I was speaking to the president of the United States. Wow. It's very interesting. And as he turned to leave the room, it was me and a couple of other people there.
He turns around, he says, Hey, what you're doing is important. And by what you're doing, he, of course, was referring to like encouraging people to vote, things of this nature. He said, because whoever gets my job after me is going to have the nuclear codes. I remember the look in his eyes when he said that.
It was very interesting. But you know what I mean by nuclear codes, right? Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it's not just the kind of thing that you punch up and then nuclear weapons happen.
And there's like a double verification in movies. You see some kind of switch, something like this. I mean, it's not easy to fire off a nuke and that's on purpose. Right.
But I remember the look in his eyes when he said this and it wasn't a political moment. It was different. It was like he had been standing in front of something that he had been guarding for a long time and he was worried about what would happen. Like what would happen in the event that, you know, it could just happen whenever.
It was almost like a father protecting a daughter and he knew that he was about to step away from the daughter and should be unprotected. It's hard to explain. Is any of this resonating? Yeah, I think I'm understanding.
And I'm certainly resonating with the father side of what you're saying. And I could see how somebody with that kind of power that they're withholding and trying to figure out how to manage would feel a certain burden with that. And I could see how they would be very concerned that whoever takes their place would not understand the burden. Have you ever thought about launching a nuke and I know many people are anti nukes and many people are pro nuke?
Have you ever thought about the like the decision that a human being has to make in order to execute the firing of a nuclear warhead? Yes, I have absolutely. What kinds of things would you think about in that moment? What I thought about it because I read stuff about Harry Truman, you know, firing a nuke is a little different when you're talking about the technology we have now versus what was being dropped in the mid 1940s.
But still, you know, if you do that, that people who have no stake in the thing, no business being harmed are going to be harmed and people are going to be harmed who aren't even alive yet. It's a monumental decision and I don't have to make it myself. It's unbelievable burden. So I can't imagine the decision, but at the height of the Cold War, there was this guy that I want to tell you about.
And this guy, his name is Roger Fisher. He was at Harvard Law School and he was the guy that came up with something called the Harvard Negotiation Project. Have you ever heard of this? No, no, I got nothing.
The Harvard Negotiation Project is something that was set up to analyze and study how people negotiate between each other and what it takes to get to yes is what they say. There was actually a publication written called Getting to Yes, Interest-Based Negotiation, like what is the other party interested in and how can I give them that in order for us to go both ways? Sure. Okay.
That sounds thoughtful. So this guy wrote a document way back in the day. It's in the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists. He wrote a document about a proposal for what should happen to prevent nuclear war because at the height of the Cold War tensions were high.
There was this new policy that was being laid out right before Reagan took took office. It was a policy by Jimmy Carter. It was called Nuclear Determinants Policy 59 or something like that. Let me get right.
Okay. Sure. Are you familiar with that? I'm familiar with Carter doing work in that arena.
What do you know about that? That he was interested in de-escalation, that he was interested in opening lines of communication that he thought if there was some sort of, if there was some sort of easy and accessible way to communicate before making cataclysmic decisions, it would make things better. Carter was accused of a lot of naivete because of the let's just talk it out sort of stance that he tried to take on things that he tried to implement with policy. But I like a lot of what he thought.
There's actually a really weird controversial thing that Carter did called the Presidential Directive 59, a nuclear weapons employment policy. And the thought was instead of having large nuclear weapons that could be activated over large populated cities and things like that, it was a move towards strategic use of nuclear weapons in smaller areas. So take out a so-called military target and things like that. OK, what are your thoughts on that?
I mean, is this what we call a tactical nuclear strike? Pretty much. We're trying to reduce collateral damage. You just hit the thing you want disabled.
We can't you do that without splitting the atom? You couldn't at the time. Back in 1981, when these discussions were going on by Roger Fisher, this thing I'm about to tell you about that he wrote about in this bulletin that's unbelievable. At that point in time, the Cold War was raging and there was this new missile called the Pershing Two that was being carted out into Germany.
And the idea was they could put it in West Germany and it could hit Moscow with precision. They could hit exactly what they want. And so this is the sort of thing that led towards the demise of the Cold War, or at least back in the day. But anyway, let's get back to Roger Fisher.
OK, so Roger Fisher was interested in how to de-escalate nuclear armed conflict. And he said there are many different ways that armed conflict comes about and policymakers tend to focus on the machines involved, like the mechanisms, the things that are designed, the weapons themselves. He said, but there's another thing that could get you to armed conflict. And do you have any thoughts on what that might be?
Pride painting yourself into a corner verbally. I mean, how do you or I get into conflict with somebody else? Sometimes it's because of a business deal or something mechanical to liken it to the military terms. But more often it has to do with something that scrambles my normal sense of morality, my normal view that I normally carry around of other people as being valuable.
And if I feel that pressure start to mount, I find myself kind of forgetting about those things in the moment, that kind of adrenaline rush, maybe we're gonna have some real conflict here. And so the normal moral things that make me tick seem to not quite fire on all cylinders in that moment leading up to conflict. And so I would say there's a very human element to conflict as well. Exactly.
Those are the two things that Roger Fisher says lead to conflict. And he said, we as a society tend to focus on the mechanisms, the weapons, the infrastructure of the military itself and those types of things. And we send a message to the rest of the world like, Hey, if if we can't get what we want, then we're just going to use force and we're going to move in just like we did with Hitler in World War II. And we're going to take land acre by acre until we come literally right up to your doorstep and we get what we want.
But there was a proposal in this document that he wrote in the bulletin to atomic scientists and he said, that is no longer possible. And he said, the reason that is no longer possible is because even if you were to take over another country, you still have the problem of this disagreement because the mind of the other person remains unchanged and you're still going to live with that person unless you totally destroy them. So really the only thing that could happen in order for you to quote unquote win is for you to physically destroy the other person. That's the only way to quote win or time.
Tremendous amounts of time get that done as well. So you think of 1066 AD that dates famous because it's the last time a land invasion of Britain succeeded. William Duke of Normandy came over and famously at the Battle of Hastings. He defeated the forces of Britain and consolidated his own brand new kingdom there and it took a long time for that rivalry between the Saxons and the Normans to gradually go away.
But if you go to the UK today, not a lot of people are yelling about who Saxon and who's Norman. So the way William decided to play it was to just let this thing be a generations long conflict that would carry on for centuries. But eventually I guess die out. The way some other conquerors have chosen to play it is to allow a degree of self governance.
That's what the Romans tried to do with their client king system. It's what the Persians famously tried to do. Cyrus the Great was famous for just saying, govern yourself, pace and taxes. Don't revolt will be cool.
And then the third way that you do this is while what you were just talking about, you kill everyone who doesn't agree and you move forward, wiping their memory from the earth. And that creates, I guess, some warped sense of peace. Yeah, that's true. Someone asked Roger Fisher, a very specific question.
They said, how would you prevent nuclear war? In this article that he wrote, he reveals that he's a pessimist and he explains all the things that are leading up to nuclear war, the fact that there are many countries that have nuclear weapons, they're obtaining nuclear weapons, they're ready to test. Remember, this is 1981. And he's, he's very pessimistic about the future.
In fact, he makes a prediction that a nuclear war will happen before the year 2000. He said that in 1981. What's interesting is he had a proposal. There's a lot of discussion back and forth.
I'll give you a link to this article so you can read it. It's fascinating and he's a really, really good thinker, but he had a proposal at the end of this article that I'd like to read to you about how to prevent nuclear war and it doesn't address the military mechanism part of it. It addresses the human part of it. Is that cool?
Okay. Yeah, please. He says in this paper, my favorite activity is inventing an early arms control proposal dealt with the problem of distancing that the president would have in the circumstances of facing a decision about nuclear war. There's a young man, probably a Navy officer who accompanies the president.
This young man has a black attache case, which contains the codes that are needed to fire nuclear weapons. I can see the president at a staff meeting considering nuclear war as an abstract question. He might conclude on SIAQ plan one, the decision is affirmative, communicate the Alpha Line XYZ in such jargon holds what is involved at a distance. So this is me talking now.
You can imagine, you know, what do you think happens when they launch a nuclear weapon, maybe two keys in a book or something? I picture the two keys. Yeah. Is that how they did it hunt for red October?
Like, yeah, I picture there being some like little glass case that you have to snap open and then you get the key out of there and there's maybe key as a big handle and you got to count and turn it at the same. I have no idea. I'm making things up. That's what I've always considered too.
And so what Fisher is saying here is the activity of getting a key out and saying, you know, the codes are zero, zero, zero, zero, which is probably what it would be for me. One, two, three, four, five. One, two, three, four, five. And so the statement here is that involves distancing the president from what's actually happening.
You know, you're having to remember the code that you wrote down on a piece of paper in your wallet or you have to go get the key from a Navy officer. So if I'm hearing you right, what you're describing is the status quo at the time? Yes. And I believe we're not into the proposal yet.
We're not into the proposal. Let me ask you a question. How much of a hurdle does that status quo sound like to you for the people who are pulling the trigger on this launch to actually have to clear? I don't know.
I don't know. I think I think it's good that there is a hurdle. I think they've spent some time to think about something has to be put into place. And once that something is put into place, you know, at least we have some kind of check and balance here.
I've always wondered, like, shouldn't there be a coordinate of where you want to drop a bomb that needs to happen? I've always thought about that. But I don't know. There is a hurdle.
OK. My wheels are turning. I have more thoughts, but I want to hear the proposal. So here's Fisher's proposal.
He says, my suggestion was quite simple. Put that needed code number in a little capsule and then implant that capsule right next to the heart of a volunteer. The volunteer would carry with him a big heavy butcher knife as he accompanied the president. If ever the president wanted to fire nuclear weapons, the only way he could do so would be for him first with his own hands to kill one human being.
The president says, George, I'm sorry, but tens of millions must die. He has to look at someone and realize what death is, what an innocent death is. Blood on the White House carpet. It's a reality brought home.
What are your thoughts about that? I'm thinking. My objection to the status quo is that there's no moral hurdle built in. The only hurdle that's built in is logistical.
Like the key slots are 10 feet apart, so humans can't reach that far. So you need two people. So right now the hurdle is you got to get somebody else to agree to do it. There's no moral question you have to wrestle with there.
That doesn't get you closer to the reality of what you're about to turn that key to do. This is a pretty elaborate plan that's being proposed here by Mr. Fisher, but it certainly would achieve the desired outcome. I don't want to push a butcher knife into somebody's heart.
That sounds horrible. That's the stuff of nightmares. So I guess if I were president, there just wouldn't be any nukes. I think that's his goal.
I think this is his proposal to stop nuclear war. Listen to what reaction he got from people at the Pentagon. Fisher says, when I suggested this to friends in the Pentagon, they said, my God, that's terrible. Having to kill someone with the store, the president's judgment.
He might not ever push the button. He might not. He might never push the button again for the second time in a row. I'm buffering a little bit here.
Why are we so eager to push the button? I think that's his point because we spent a lot of money on it and we got, I mean, we might get some use out of that. We have a button. Look at it's right there.
Yeah, somebody I got enough of works. Yeah. What are your thoughts on this? Uh, without getting political in any way, I'm, I'm very troubled by that response.
I would have to believe that someone else he talked to in the Pentagon was like, you know, that's not such a bad idea. Or, you know, we're all trying to avert this kind of thing over here. I have to think he picked the most outlandish response to drive home the point of this article, but I feel like you are setting up enormous philosophical ethical policy related questions. And can you just, like you prepared for this and you're bringing me into your world and into these questions here.
Can we just enumerate what the questions are? Yeah. I mean, the question is quite generally, I mean, the overarching question is all a concept of nuclear conflict. That's the overarching question that I don't think we need to get into right now.
Okay. I think what we need to get into is the mind of an individual that has the power to kill, let's say at least thousands of people with a stroke of a button. That power exists. What types of questions have to go into the mind of a person like that before something like that would happen?
It's kind of a bizarre thing that we've made as people. And to be clear, not just one country has made this. A lot of countries have made this and more countries want to make this. Everybody who hasn't made it wants to.
Well, that's not exactly true. Maybe Costa Rica, South Africa, South Africa had this ability and then they gave it up, right? Yeah, South Africa is the only country to have built nuclear weapons and then voluntarily dismantled them in the 80s. Yeah.
It was the plot like Superman for or something like that. It was, I mean, this, the point is this nuclear thing feels like a very different question for us. I mean, given the last 20 years of life that we've grown up and done early adulthood in terrorism and domestic social stuff, those are the kind of things we've been worried about, but a generation before us, the nuclear threat is all anybody thought about. This was the existential threat to humanity.
It was in all of the movies and TV shows and rock songs and protest songs and poetry and art. This is what everybody was worried about. And I vaguely remember as a kid the Cold War and the idea of nuclear annihilation. And I remember going on car rides with my dad and when everything would get quiet and everybody else was maybe sleeping or whatever.
Late at night, we had a couple conversations where I asked him what it would feel like if we had noot, who would win? Would it be us or would it be Russia? Do you think we'd win dad? I wanted to know because it seemed like the whole world could end.
And that's because the whole world could end. But now it almost feels odd talking about the nuclear threat. Because I think we've just accepted the whole idea of mutually assured destruction for so long that it just feels like, well, that's probably never going to happen. We worry about other things, but those are still sitting there.
That's what you're telling me. Yeah, it's my understanding. So we're going to get down to the heavy topic again here in a second, but Raycon really is great. How do we do this?
How do we tell people to buy Raycon to support? Just doing it. You're doing it exactly right. Raycon is great.
It's a product we both like. And because they exist and they're behind what we're doing here, we get to have conversations like this. Sometimes they're goofy and sometimes they're incredibly challenging, like the one you've chosen for us today. I think this is an interesting topic.
I think it's worth our time. I really like to support the podcast, which I would appreciate if you did, you can go get yourself some everyday E25 earbuds by going to by raycon.com slash in DQ and getting 15% off your order. It's going to be really hard to just explain to you how important it is that you support the sponsor on the podcast, but you know, because we're in that kind of mental place, but I think you get it. Like I listened to stuff like this while I'm out on the tractor while I'm mowing and things like that.
And the Raycon's do a good job of both knocking down the really loud noises that are going around me, which isn't a selling point. Might I add they don't advertise that it's just what I use it for. But that just works. It just works.
The deep sounds on the earbuds are great. Yeah, you're definitely not getting the tinny thing. And honestly, as weird as it is to do a heavyweight episode like this and talk about a sponsor like Raycon, I'm really glad that Raycon is up for this conversation because what I have found is that having great equipment like this that's little, that is ergonomic, that I can drag around with me, that keeps a great charge and I can just pop in my ears no matter where I'm at or what I'm doing. It allows me to take the deep water stuff that I really do like to think about from time to time.
It allows me to take that from like a once a year conversation that I might get into with someone I really trust over a long meal. It allows me to instead go out and find people who are having conversations like that and take it with me all over the place and be in the deep water as much as I want. So it's kind of changed my world to have such a convenient, easy way to do that. Absolutely.
For that reason, it's part of my everyday carry. Like I carry it in my pocket all the time. You're just not stressing on this. You can listen to your favorite podcast, which I hope is this program, no questions, or you can listen to books, just all kinds of heavy, thinky stuff anywhere.
And music sounds phenomenal. It does, too. It's very hard to promote an audio product without letting you hear it, but it sounds phenomenal. It's my favorite earbud for listening to music by a wide margin.
Oh, yeah, sounds just as good as other premium audio brands. I was listening to Prince today as I was working and operating a nail gun. And it was great. Windoves Cry, Purple Rain, you name it.
All of them. Yeah. There's a instrumental called, I want to be your lover. I think it was fantastic.
But anyway, we're getting too light and we need to get back into the deep water here. So let's go back. Fair enough. Thanks, Raycon for sponsoring the program.
Thanks, Raycon also for making a great product that I use every day and that I love. And thank you to all of you in the third chair who support the sponsors. Cause that makes this whole thing work for 15% off your order. You can go to by Raycon.com slash ndq.
I want to ask you a question about what you asked your dad. You said, would we win? What does winning look like in the mind of me when I asked that? And I'm six or seven years old or now.
Both. When I was a kid, they're faceless enemy invaders who speak a language. I don't understand. They're like stormtroopers and star wars that they're faceless, voiceless, nonsense characters that are almost external to me, like video game NPCs.
And the question is, is the game going to beat me or am I going to beat the game? I didn't think of the Russians as humans with values and objectives and dreams and governmental ideals and philosophy and all of that. I thought of them as NPCs. Now I don't think that way.
I mean, you live long enough and you realize everybody's a person and everybody has complex set of motives for why they're doing what they're doing and complex historical motives that people bear together as society or a culture and those stories get woven into the DNA to the mind of each new generation and that factors into. So back then, winning just meant, you know, complete and total annihilation. Maybe we take over Russia and it becomes the 51st state and put a bunch of McDonald's there or something. Now there is no winning.
I guess winning would be not death. Can I read from the article again that Fisher wrote? Please. So Fisher says, yet this concept of winning, that there is such a thing and that it is our dominant objective is one of our fundamental beliefs.
In fact, like a poker player, we have three kinds of objectives. One is to win the hand, whatever it is that we think we want, we want it now. We want victory. The second is that we want to be in a good position for future hands.
We want a reputation and chips on the table so that we can influence future events. In other words, we want power. And our third objective is to not have the table kicked over the house burned down or our opponent pull a gun on us. We want peace.
So we want victory. We want power and we want peace. Same article. It's fascinating that he was able to put that to words, isn't it?
It's beautifully concise. Yeah. So it's a weird version of peace though, isn't it? Well, I mean, he's not saying that it's all in the same.
He's saying those are the three things that people want. We want victory. You know, we want to like be the person that overcame the other person. The second thing he's saying that we want is power, the ability to influence things in the future.
And the third thing that we want, and these can be independent, the third thing that we want is peace. You can independently want peace. You can independently want power. You can independently want victory.
And he goes on in this article to say like as a person who wants to deescalate the use of force in the world, he said he often would talk to people about denuclearization or things like that. And he would say things like, look, you have to be able to blah, blah, blah. And he would say, can't you see that you idiots? And he says the fact that I was using the term idiots on them meant I want to power over them.
You know, and he it's pretty self aware. He did a really good job of explaining this. You know, he was he was upset with other people for wanting to retain power at the same time he wanted power over them. It's a fascinating read.
And I highly recommend that you read this. So let me ask you this, how do nukes fit into those three pursuits, victory, power, and peace that just explain to me like I'm five. We're talking about nuclear weapons, not just the general mindset of humanity. How do they fit into the equation?
They don't. They don't give you any, either one of those three things, because if you were to go for victory to be the other person, you also would be destroyed. So that's the mutually assured destruction part of it. The second part of it, we want power over other people.
Well, there are no people. There's no power over and you don't want to go to that land because you just nuked it. You know, it's dirty at that point in peace. That's the third thing.
You might eventually get peace because there's nothing left, but his argument is sound. He's saying that nuclear weapons don't achieve any of these objectives. Well, so then why did people come up with them? What objective do they achieve?
I don't know. I don't know. It's a really good question. OK, so let's look for a second that war has broke out in Europe and it's a hot war shooting war.
You got tanks from the east tanks from the west and they're going at it. So Mr. Fisher in this in this article, he says, hey, last spring, I gave officers at the NATO Defense College in Rome, a hypothetical war in Europe and asked them to work out NATO's war aims. The war was presumed to have grown out in a general strike in East Germany with Soviet and West German tanks fighting on both sides of the border.
Deterrence has failed. I told the officers, you were in charge of the hotline message to Moscow. What is the purpose of this war? What are you trying to do?
OK, so what are you trying to do as a soldier? And you're on the NATO side. You're on the NATO side. You have a soldier.
What are you trying to do in the war? As a soldier, not die. No, no, no, you're in charge of NATO at this point in time. OK, so I'm not a soldier.
I am the Supreme Commander of the Allied NATO forces. No, this is what he says in the paper. You are in charge of the hotline message to Moscow. What is the purpose of this war?
That's what he says. What are you trying to do? So I'm not trying to breed peace. I'm not understanding the scenario.
I mean, the purpose of the war once we're at this point and de-escalation techniques have failed is make sure you're still standing when it's over. Yeah, at this point, it's on, right? It's like when you wrestled with somebody as a kid and they didn't get it socially. And then you're goofing around, everybody's having a good time.
And all of a sudden you feel an uppercut to your chin and you're like, what the heck? And you kind of push back and you make eye contact and you see it in his eyes. Oh, oh, we're doing this. And all of a sudden it goes from we're having fun to I need to make sure I'm intact when this is over.
And then the whole tone of everything changes. And then maybe everybody lands a couple of good punches and you see it go even beyond it's on and into it's completely on total war. I'll kill you if I can. Not only seeing that once in a scruff that I got into.
It was crazy seeing that in the other person's eyes. Unfortunately, he didn't have the ability to really do anything about it. But it was still terrifying to realize if the checks were gone, this guy right now in that state of mind, he would rip my chest cavity open, pull everything out and leave me for dead in the most violent way imaginable. I've never been across from that except for one time in high school.
I didn't go anywhere from there. So that's basically what's happened in this scenario that you're describing. It's gone from, OK, there's some nobility here. We've got some rules of war.
We drew some red lines. We built up troops. Escalation happened. Mutually assured destruction maybe kept us at peace.
But then someone wrong, somebody crossed a line. We maybe too aggressively drew a line in the sand and you're like, I'm not going to let you do that. And you stepped across the line and now I have to respond. We're also like weak to my own people and I lose power.
I don't know what happens. All the psychology occurs. Pretty soon we start killing each other. The second there's blood on the dirt.
Now you can't have those people having been killed for nothing. We have to avenge the fallen and it's on. And then somebody's going to do something that somebody else culturally feels like is just too far. And when you do that, that means everything is fair game.
And it sounds like the scenario that I'm being presented with in this war game is that we are there, which means either you better be the best negotiator ever and immediately be able to pump the brakes for both sides or you better win. Am I reading it wrong? He said at first the officer saw they knew what to do, win. Very simple.
But what does that mean? What is the purpose of the war? I'm reading now. They begin to realize that NATO did not plan to conquer the Soviet Union acre by acre as the allies of conquered Germany in World War II.
They didn't plan to physically impose their will in the Soviet Union. They were seeking a Soviet decision. Like they're like, Hey, we want you to stop. I'm not reading now.
That was the only way they could have a successful outcome because unless you decide I'm going to go all in and I'm going to take over your country. And that's not what they want. So what they're really looking for is the other person to make a decision. What kind of decision?
What do you mean by that? They're looking for the Soviets to say, Hey, are you going to stop? Are you going to keep going? Because if you're going to stop and basically we want this back to where it started, that's what we want.
They started to try to game out what they were going to say. And they said, Well, I guess the first thing to do is to create a ceasefire, right? Let's stop the killing and then we'll get to the point where we can. And so.
And so the officer said this. They found it hard to draft a fair ceasefire that didn't sound like a unilateral Western ultimatum. It might say stop firing at 0 100 hours tomorrow, promise to withdraw, promise to restore the status quo within 48 hours and then we'll meet the Vienna and we'll sort all this out. Yeah, that's not going to work.
Yeah. But the NATO draftsman didn't know whether the Soviets would prefer Geneva or Vienna or whether they wanted to see started happening at 0 200 hours and stuff like that. So people started saying, Well, what if we worked with the Russians right now before war and we agreed on what our ceasefire terms would be before war started. You're just, you're just agreeing to have a war later.
Yeah. Isn't that interesting? Anyway, I read this paper and it was fascinating to me. And he said, The best proposal I have is for it to never start to begin with.
And the proposal that Fisher comes up with is to plant the nuclear codes in the chest of a human that must be carved out and that human must die in order to put inhibitions in place so that the war would never start to begin with. I thought this was fascinating and I wanted to run this by you and just see what your take on it was. You think it's crazy? No, maybe the whole thing is crazy and maybe you need crazy to restrain crazy.
It's really hard for me to think about this just in terms of the thing and the guys heart and then you got to stab them with the butcher knife and you got to take this back 100 levels. Why haven't we thought about this at some other point in history? Why didn't Julius Caesar have some kind of thing like this where he's fighting against some alamani tribesmen that if he wants to call in the reserve cavalry and wipe them out on the right flank that first he has to stab Lucius Claudius right through his chest and pull out the scroll that gives him the access code to activate his reserve cavalry. I mean, why wasn't that there?
Honest question. Why isn't this coming up until 1981? I think the reason it's coming up in 1981 is because it was harder to kill people back then. You know, it took a lot of time to mobilize your infantry.
It took a lot of time to have the blacksmiths make the weaponry all this stuff. And at this point, everything's in place and we've made it extremely effective and we've made it super easy to just do it to literally push a button. And so I think that's what's so interesting. We have a very unique moment in history.
So scale. I don't know. Julius Caesar's cavalry wiping out a whole bunch of people who signed up to be in a war anyway, fighting on the battlefields in Germany or whatever in 60 BC, the scale of destruction there, it's going to be a real disappointment for those wives back home and for that tribe to recover is going to be hard. But it's not like the environment is going to collapse or central Europe will suddenly become uninhabitable.
I mean, you're talking about such a localized scale, whereas the stuff that we're talking about in the 20th and 21st century, maybe it's just a scale question that if we do this stuff, I mean, with the technology we had a hundred years ago, we wrecked a swath through Central Europe fighting World War I, the technology we had in World War II, escalated that destruction to an even greater scale. If we did it again, who knows if there's even anything left? And that's what makes me think maybe the heart stabbing thing is an okay idea. Because if we do total global war again, it's going to change us as a species in an evolutionary sense.
We will become something fundamentally different if we do it again, I believe. And the planet will become something fundamentally different. So stabbing one dude who signed up for it voluntarily, I'm talking myself into it, stabbing one dude who signed up for this voluntarily to take one for planet Earth in the heart and physically having to reach in there as president and remove that capsule. Maybe it's as good an idea as any.
I just thought it was a very interesting thought experiment. And to think about myself in the moment, so let's say their chair, a couple of cities just got hit and you're the president and you know exactly who did it. And there's no question in your mind who did it because they sent a person in person to tell you they were going to do it and immediately after the person uttered the words, Hey, we're going to do this. It happened.
So there's no question who did it. Okay. So you're now in control and you have the ability to retaliate. First of all, do you do it if there's a button?
And that's a question in and of itself. And then secondly, how much more of a hurdle is there if you have to kill a person in order to do it? It's just a really fascinating question. And I just want to ask you and just see what you thought and just and just take you there mentally and just see what was going on in your head.
That's kind of what I was thinking. Let me say this. It is a fascinating thought experiment. You presented it really well.
That article is fascinating, but I feel like sometimes the existence of a question or the validity of a question can demonstrate the absurdity of the context that would make such a question valid. And the problem is your question is valid. You're asking me if it would be a cool idea to put some kind of capsule in a guy's heart, give somebody else a giant steak knife and tell them that before you make this particular executive order, you have to run him through yourself and then pick through what's left to find the capsule. And that makes sense.
It's an indictment of the moment we're in. And so I guess the bigger question that I ask is, OK, that's a bandaid. I mean, that's one way to add a moral hurdle that goes along with the put the keys 10 feet apart, physical hurdle, logistical hurdle. But another great question would be, how do we back down from this?
Not just throw a bunch of weapons into space and not have them anymore. You can't forget the technology. It's a human problem. How do we get to a place where no one wants to harness the power of the atom to destroy other people anymore?
Let me ask you this. Today, we don't think about nuclear war quite as much as our parents did. Sure. But today we do think about other people inflicting harm on societies using social media, for example.
And the question is, why? What is a person trying to achieve by harnessing the power of social media to try to inflict pain or disorder or chaos or whatever on other people? What are the goals? What does victory look like?
And why would you put energy into doing that? I can think of a handful of answers. Is it rhetorical or do you want me to bounce a few off you? Do it.
OK. One, some people just want to see the world burn. They want to flip over the table. They feel like they're so far behind the game that they're losing so hard that their objective will never be achieved, that what they have left to play is chaos.
We used to play risk finals week, every semester in college. And there was this one player who, as soon as he realized he wasn't going to win, he wouldn't bow out or hunker down and try to hold on to where he was at, like a person dealing with actual humans in their own actual country where they feel pride and collegiality and their family lives there. These are just little plastic pieces to him. And so he would just throw them at something and try to create as much chaos as possible.
That's one reason people would try to make a mess of the world via social media. Because they know they're not going to obtain the ultimate objectives they would want in a utopia. So they said, well, forget it. I can't do it.
I'm just going to mess everything up for everybody. It's like the old villain would do in the desperation moment at the end of the old action movies. If I can't have it, nobody can. And they go to the nuclear option.
I think a second reason that people would make an attack like that is because they have to disrupt what they perceive as a status quo to get the thing that they want. If there's too much unity or agreement on a certain approach to life or a certain set of values, you have to wreck that. You got to get people to not like each other first. Because if you got a situation where you have a political left and a political right, you more or less still agree on morality and we like each other.
We can have a beer after, but we have different visions for how we're going to solve some of these problems. There's not enough there to drive a wedge between and get a radically different version of existence. There's too much unity there and you're going to make those people hate each other so that there's a wide open gap to make that wedge, that gap even bigger. And then you have the chance to achieve something that otherwise you just couldn't.
There would be no gap to exploit. I think that's some of what goes on. Can I give you an example of that? Please.
I had a coworker one time and we were really, really good friends and I walked in one day and he was on his computer and he had a really mean look on his face, looking at me and I said, what's wrong, man? How's it going? And I was just bebop and in, you know, good times. He's like, I'm just really upset.
And I said, I'm sorry. I don't, I don't know what's going on. And he said, I heard what you said. I said, I'm sorry.
I, I honestly do not know what you're talking about right now. Can you just go to straight to the front door is possible and just tell me exactly what you're talking about. He said, yes, this person said, and it was a lie. Someone had told my really good friend a lie about me.
It was a categorical lie. He said, I said something derogatory about this person like, oh, well, he would help us if he wasn't in there playing solitaire on the computer, something that simple. Okay. And I said, I don't know.
I said the person's name. I said, friend, I did not say that. Who told you that? And before you tell me who told you that, I promised they're lying.
Who was the person? And he told me the name of the person that said it and he goes, you're right, aren't you? He did lie to me. I said, he did.
He said, I should have considered the source. Please forgive me. I was like, we're good, man. Nothing ever happened.
So this external person tried to get between this professional relationship I had with this person. And so in order to do that, they manufactured a lie. What did they want? They wanted the relationship with this person.
There you go. Yeah, there's an angle that couldn't happen if you guys were tight. No gap to exploit. Okay.
So what were the first two real quick and I'm going to recap them. Okay. So reason number one, someone might do that that I'm suggesting is they just want to see the world burn. They're so far behind the game.
They just want to flip over the table. Reason number two is the really exact opposite end of the spectrum. They do think they can win. They have a thing that they want, but if they just go through the front door and say, Hey, let's do this.
People aren't going to sign up for it. They're too unified against them. You've got to create chaos between people. I think a third reason, and maybe this one is a bit more on the individual level, but it does happen corporately as well.
That is hurt people hurt people. When people get banged up, it's hard to know what to do with that. Even the most healthy functional people I've ever met. When you're hurt, it feels weird.
And what was the Mike Tyson quote about getting punched? Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the mouth. Right. Yeah.
Yes. And when that happens, all the things that used to make sense, you're mad, you want to fire back, but you also don't want to feel that pain again. And it can take us to a place where we just do and say things that aren't very calculated that don't have a clear objective. We don't want to see the world burn.
We're not nihilists. We're hurt and we want some kind of recourse for that hurt. I feel like what I just said is 90% of the ugly that I see happening on social media. It's not some grand conspiracy or plan.
It's overwhelmingly people either real or imagined are dealing with slights and they feel crappy and they want other people to feel crappy too. I think you just you just hit the whole thing right on the head. What does winning look like? If winning involves me getting something I don't have, how do you get it?
I don't think attacking another person is the answer. We should run that by the Vikings. Yeah. Cause it was the answer for them.
But my people built a civilization out of that, right? Like for some way, you said my people. Well, that's who I am. I'm a Viking.
That's where I come from. That's my cultural history. I'm on the receiving end of the Vikings because the other part of me Scottish and I'm on the giving end with the Raiders. I mean, that was just the dynamic for a period of time.
And there's always been groups historically. We're like, we do not so. We're just going to go take it. It is one viable way to achieve a certain set of ends to let other people do the work and then through cunning or sheer force to just go take it from them.
I'm not saying it's moral or good or sustainable, but people have made a living on it for a while. So weapons are going to happen because weapons are necessary to prevent the Vikings from coming. Yes. And so the trick is once the weapons exist, how do you limit their usage?
Ideas for a long time. I think people thought, well, we need one shared religious vision. And that's a, that's a nice idea, but theology is hard and people are going to bring their experiences to the table. They're not going to just not going to land at the same conclusions on something as big as God and the finer details of ethics.
That's where the genius, I think of the enlightenment and the liberal revolutions of the French, the Americans, Latin America in the 18th century and 19th century, the idea was we got to boil this down to a very limited set of things we can agree on. Like it's good to be free. It's good to not kill other people. It's good to own things, cause you need to own things and consume some things in order to stay alive.
We're going to try to build some kind of homeostasis where we build into the structure of society and agreement on a very select few ethical things that you could arrive at from any religious system. You don't have to think this person's thing about God or not God or anything. We can all reason to this and then maybe we have the swords just in case somebody decides they want to do things differently, but theoretically that tiny bit of self restraint, we can disagree on everything else, but we're just going to agree on these few core things could keep us from doing that to each other. Now people might disagree about how effective that was, but that was the whole point.
It was to make a society that wouldn't keep doing stuff like this. Yeah. This took us to a lot of places, man. There's so many directions we could go right now.
Yes. Most of them take hours. They do. And I think my wife has cooked dinner for me or I'm supposed to pick it up from the Chinese restaurant.
I don't know the answer yet. You deserve one crack at this. What's the answer? Give me your singular number one.
If we were going to solve this problem that humans have really struggled to solve through the years, what's your answer? I think this proposal is fascinating because ultimately the problem lies within the human heart. And that's where he that's where he takes it. He takes it literally to the human heart.
He said, you have to get right down. You have to cut right down to the heart of the problem and that is the human heart. And that's the way he designed his solution. And I find that fascinating.