Skip to content
091 - Unwritten Rules episode artwork

Aug 15, 2020 1 hr 15 min

091 - Unwritten Rules

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: HELLOFRESH Additional restrictions may apply, visit hellofresh.com for more details. STUFF FROM THIS EPISODE Auburn University Daniel Murphy, Colorado Rockies Jose Bautista bat flip Jose Bautista gets punched George H.W. Bush Vomits on Japanese Prime Minister Adam Gilchrist, Cricketer Mankad Australia/New Zealand Underarm Bowling Incident of 1981 Mankading in Cricket Compilation Paolo DiCanio catch A-Rod calls 3rd base ball The Unmade Podcast The Unmade Podcast on Twitter The Unmade Podcast on Facebook CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

091 - Unwritten Rules

0:00 1:15:47
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

So you've been up in my neck of the woods a couple of times. I mean, you've traveled to Colorado. You've been to Wyoming once. You've been around the American West a little bit.

I've been your way quite a bit. I really like Alabama. But one of the things that I notice going between the two, and I'm curious if you notice too, is that there's a slightly different set of unwritten rules about just how to be cool to people. And what this means versus what that means in one place or the other, have you noticed that the unwritten rules are there and that they change a little bit, depending on where you're standing?

Absolutely, not just between where I live and where you live, but like anywhere. For example, you know the okay sign, like, hey, how you doing? You doing okay? And you make a circle with your thumb and your index finger and then you have your three fingers, you know, the okay sign.

Do you want to talk about? Yeah, of course. Yeah, so here in the United States, you're like, you doing okay buddy? And you hold that up?

Apparently in Peru, it doesn't mean that. What did you find out that it means? I don't really know. I still don't know.

Describe it in detail what you think it means. I think it involves an orifice. I think it involves an orifice. That's all I know.

I guess that might be it. And so when you're somewhere else and you just don't know the unwritten rules, there's many different types of unwritten rules, right? There's the cultural norms that signals to another person. Like, oh, this person is a part of the subculture.

For example, I made a video about the F-16 with the Air Force. And I was going through and making sure that I said everything correctly in the episode. And before you publish something that important, you want to just make sure that an F-16 pilot sees it. So I showed it to an F-16 pilot.

And I was like, yeah, what did you think? They're like, well, first of all, this is awesome. I was like, well, thanks very much. I was feeling kind of proud of myself.

Secondly, you cannot call it the Fighting Falcon. Because in there, I'd say like the F-16 Fighting Falcon is like, look dude, if you say that, that is the quickest way to signal to the entire Air Force that you don't know what the heck you're talking about. Because nobody calls it the Fighting Falcon. It's the Viper.

Well, what is it? It's the Viper. We're the Viper drivers, man. If you fly in that scene, you're a Viper driver.

Yeah, nobody says Fighting Falcon in the Air Force. Now, if you go look at like the budgetary charts or whatever, or the Wikipedia page, yeah, it's the Fighting Falcon. But the quickest way to show other people that you don't know you're not on the inside is to say, oh yeah, well, I got to ride in a Fighting Falcon one time. Like, okay, whatever, noob.

You know what I mean? Huh. So it's just like this thing you do. And there's all kinds of stuff like that.

Like when I got on the submarine, I mean, there were certain hallways you didn't walk down at certain times unless you were of a certain rank. Nobody knows that. It's not written anywhere. But if you do it, oh, they call you out.

It's just interesting. So anyway, you've got stuff like that as well? Well, so if I'm hearing you right, you're suggesting that unwritten rules, which can range, I suppose, from things that are quirky little nuance and details of subculture or a sport or how you interact with somebody in public, all the way up to things that maybe have serious implications, like who walks in this place on a vessel of war. If I'm hearing you right, and if I am, I think I'm agreeing with you, it's a form of in language.

It's a form of demonstrating, hey, I'm reliable. I'm part of the same group here. I can be trusted because I know these same batch of unwritten rules. Maybe that's why you have to have unwritten rules.

Is it going to serve some viable purpose in society? Yeah, it's all about subculture, right? So you can go somewhere else and function completely, you know, in an acceptable way. And you can survive and you can buy food and you can have shelter.

But if you do it in a way where you follow the unwritten rules or you signal to other people that you know the things that they know, wink, wink, or you respect their culture, it's a whole different level of existence. And if you understand these rules and you have the ability to read them in that subculture, then you can learn things about people that can't be said. Like it's things that you know about the integrity of another individual, for example. I don't know, it's a, you're right.

And sorry, I just blasted you with so many words, but that's the way I feel about it. No, no, that's helping me nail it down. And I really haven't thought this through at all until we started talking. I figured I would just jump on with this topic and we talk about a bunch of goofy things, which I still want to do.

But we got right into the deep water here with what unwritten rules mean and why did they exist. So let me frame the question a little bit differently for you. If abiding by the unwritten rules in a subculture, a team, a job, in a school, in a family, in a culture, wherever, if abiding by those shows respect and investment in other people and it makes society work better, why wouldn't those rules just be written? Oh, that's a wonderful question.

Well, I guess it's, I don't know. It's not something you want to formalize to the point where you make it enforceable. It's just like, you know that guy gets it or you know that guy doesn't, right? And so we can choose to associate with that person based on their level of getting it.

You know, if we made everybody do the thing, then it wouldn't really have its value. What about line unwritten rules? Have you observed rules that again, not written down but just about how you conduct yourselves when you're setting up a line, when you're getting in line, when you're waiting in line? Yeah.

So for some reason, I think that, I don't know, I like to stand in lines with younger generation people better, I think. What? I think they're more considerate. Oh, and it's not, they're not fighting for position.

Have you ever watched the traffic flow on the streets of India? I've never been to India, but I've watched a lot of video from it. You know, you've been to South America and you've been in a car there. There's something about some cultures where they will queue an align no matter what, the UK's like that.

There are other cultures like down in South America where the deal is you try to get in front of other people as much as you can. Yes. And it's more self-centered. And I think those little indicators, like how people stand in line, which you bring up a great point, I think that speaks to the broader culture in that area.

I don't know, it's fascinating. It's not better, or I mean, look, for my money, I like lines better. I get frustrated when I travel to certain parts of the world and it feels like, and now the gate is lifted and everyone just battle. It's like the Oklahoma land rush.

I don't like that, it stresses me out. I don't want to battle other people, but also I would like to get some land somewhere. Like I do need a seat on this plane. So it puts you in a really awkward spot.

I do like the approach that happens in my own culture the best. I'm sure it's because it's what I'm used to. And when I go outside that, I feel stress. I feel like I have to be a jerk to other people to make this work.

But what I notice that when people from other parts of the world are mingling with me in my home state or my culture, I notice the same body language discomfort from them about trying to jump in with the way that we do it. And we both have a way that works for how we think about stuff culturally. But if you mix them and you're not thinking very consciously about that, it feels personal. It feels personal for me to tell somebody from another part of the world to get in this line with my body language.

And this is your place in the line, be in this place. And it feels personal to me when I go and try and get into a ticket line in Nicaragua and it's a chaotic mess. And if I look down for one second, somebody's going to wedge in front of me and I'm just supposed to be cool with that. Let me put it this way.

Stuff means stuff. And if you and I agree that the same thing means the same thing, then it's really a slight if you don't do it. I know it was on purpose. You know it was on purpose.

That meant something. It's enough yours. But if somebody who doesn't know the rules does it, is it a slight? I mean, at that point, it's just not knowing, right?

Yeah, ignorance is bliss. I don't know. For this reason, I want to go to Japan, because I'm trying to think of a more foreign culture or I would be the most uncomfortable in Japan. But at the same time, their culture has a reputation for like cleaning up after themselves.

Have you ever seen these pictures of after a music festival in Japan versus at other, you know, in other places in the world? No, but I'm curious. It looks like a garden afterwards. Like every piece of litter is put where it needs to go.

It looks as it should be. It is. I know. It just looks fantastic.

So yeah, the thing I'm about to tell you about, which is an unwritten rule, only happens in the male restroom. And that is urinals. Please continue. OK, you walk into the restroom.

There's five urinals in front of you. If you are the first person to enter the restroom, which urinal do you go to? Far end, every time no brainer. That is correct.

And why is that correct? Because what you're doing is you're not being around anyone else while they have their pants down and urine is coming out of them. You just give people room to just do their thing. Yeah, there's a peripheral vision radius that occurs when you're being at a urinal.

And you have to be as far away from other people as possible. So if you walk in the restroom, you're on the far right of the five urinals. I walk in. What is the correct place for me to go?

Far left no brainer. Obviously. Although if the urinals have partitions between them, the little dignity dividers, which were great for somebody my height, a taller person, I don't know if they actually thwart the peripheral awkwardness. So if you are of average to low tall height, then you could go to the middle one of the five if there are partitions.

And that's absolutely fine. You still left a buffer and there are partitions. You can't see anything. Everything's cool.

But you understand the rules apply differently to a tall person, even though you're not tall, you're average height, then you understand that without actually experiencing that. So yeah, I guess what I'm trying to say is everybody knows how this works. It's line of sight to the penis. That's what that's exactly.

That's how this works. Like a missile tester. Everybody understands exactly how this unspoken rule works. Have you ever been in a restroom and you've done your job correctly?

You're at the far end urinal. Somebody walks in and they walk directly up and get to the urinal right next to you. I don't know that that has ever happened, but I wrote that in a screenplay. I did.

I wrote a comedy a while back and that's what I had a guy who wanted to dominate others do. He would throw right up to people next to their urinal. That's such an inappropriate behavior that I wrote that detail in to help the audience know things about this character's weird alpha controlling intimidation techniques. Yeah.

So anyway, it's just interesting that all this stuff exists and you either know the culture or you don't or you know it and you choose to actively go against it. Cause like you said, stuff means stuff. But for me, most of the stuff, I don't know why these unwritten rules seem to manifest themselves in the sub subcultures, which I think has to do with individual sports teams or even sports themselves. For example, I went to the University of Alabama.

It is an unwritten rule, unspoken rule, in fact, that you do not wear orange and blue. You just don't even if you're a Denver Broncos fan. Yeah, you just don't really do it. Well, I mean, I guess you could in Tuscaloosa, but like orange and blue, those are the the colors of Auburn University, which I happen to think is an amazing university.

And I have no problem saying war Eagle. Like some people would say, oh, you can't say war Eagle. If you went to Alabama, you have to say roll time. I have no problem saying because I really respect that university.

It's a great academic institution. It's just that our sports are better. And it's just that we're superior in every way, except for like forestry and agriculture. I will concede.

They have a fantastic aerospace engineering program. But they're really good for that program or something to like veterinary sciences in Auburn. It's very good. It's very, very good.

So I have a lot of respect for university. In fact, I've talked to my daughter. I was like, you know, you really should consider Auburn, you know, for the kinds of things that you're into in life. They're really good for that.

But all that to say, there are people that have allegiances to Alabama that transcend logic and reason. And these type of allegiances, you just don't wear orange and blue on game day. You just don't do it unless you clearly don't get it. And if you do, we're going to ridicule you in a fun, Joe, you'll kind of way.

That's just the way it works. Have you ever been to like a sports match where you weren't a fan of one of the teams? And so you didn't even really know what to wear and you didn't know what the cheers were and all that stuff? Oh, yeah, yeah, tons of those.

It is kind of awkward. I especially noticed it at minor league hockey games. If a town has a minor league hockey team, I like to go. Don't know any of the kids minor league hockey is like 15 year olds, dude.

Kids get drafted really young to play traveling league hockey. Then they go and they stay in people's homes. They're host families. It's almost like a foreign exchange student program.

Really? But yeah, they play professional hockey at like 16, maybe other kids. But hockey is weird, dude, because you can be amazing at age 15. And you can also be amazing at age 55.

It's because of the friction that we're the lack thereof and moving around on the ice means you can be really effective at a wider variety of ages than in other sports. So minor league hockey is fascinating because you get children out there just dominating and flying with no restraint. All they're thinking about is their invincible 15 or 16 year old body and how much they don't care about taking the abuse. It's really fun to watch.

But local minor league hockey, there's all these weird cheers and chants and tradition that you run into when you go. And I don't know any of it for any of them. And so you just kind of look at what everybody else is doing and clap along and do the thing and you hope nobody notices that you're an outsider. So yes, vividly, yes, I have been to such sporting events and know the feeling of not understanding the culture at all.

But what do you do when you go to an event like that? Do you play along or do you kind of watch and observe coldly from a distance? I go and just kind of decide as I'm there who I'm going to root for, but I get really worked up about what I wear to the event because that's an outward way of signaling it, right? You can keep your mouth shut.

Yeah, you can keep your mouth shut and people will be like, oh, okay, well, it's just another human, right? But if you outwardly wear the wrong plumage, if we were birds, right? You're you're you're signaling very clearly certain things. And so I kind of worry about that at times.

I think that's why a lot of people get concerned about what they wear to a wedding or to a party or to church or something like that, because it's like I don't want people to immediately know I don't know what I'm doing. I don't know why, but it seems like these little subcultural unspoken, unwritten rules seem to show up in sports more than anywhere else, at least for me. Yeah. Okay.

My favorite sport is baseball and the unwritten rules sometimes are called the unwritten rules and other times they're just called baseball etiquette. I think it is important that some of the rules of baseball aren't written down because I think it's important that the players have a degree of ownership. For example, there is an amount of time that it is acceptable after hitting a home run to look at the home run. And if you look at the home run for too long, you're going to get hit with fastball next time you're at the plate.

That's just too long. One of my players from one of my, well, I like the Colorado Rockies, Daniel Murphy hit a home run. Daniel Murphy is this goofy Irish dude who carries a little extra weight with him and he's jovial and he laughs and he goofs around in the field. I just love the way he plays, but he hit a home run against the Giants and I watched it go out and I watched his behavior.

And I was like, Oh, he's got a beef. He didn't like something about what the pitcher did or what happened last inning because he watched the home run for three seconds instead of two seconds. And it got past two and I was like, I don't know why that's just too long. You need to be running, son.

You need to get going. And I don't know if there was a beef there or if there's going to be an issue next time I face each other, but even something that detailed, there's just this unwritten rule. You don't show up the pitcher. You don't do that.

There's another unwritten rule about how far you can throw your bat. You remember as a little eager, like if you threw your bat, the umpire would call you out. Absolutely. Cause I mean, your kid, you freak out.

Like I actually had something you take that metal snake and you just went in the 30 or 40 feet. You're going to murder somebody. And so the police said they would call you out back. Well, there's no like, don't throw your bat rule that I'm aware of in the bigs, but there is an unwritten rule that you don't flip your bat after a home run.

So if you hit a home run, you discard your bat. You do not spin it or flip it. And Daniel Murphy, not only watched for three seconds, he flipped that bat a little bit. And there's a famous incident where a guy named Jose Bautista for the Toronto Blue Jays hits this big home run in the postseason against the Texas Rangers and did the J like he threw the bat from his left hand to his right hand and it chucks the bat with his right hand across his body and does the he man gesture and then he rounds the bases and it was just clear.

I don't know when I don't know when, but you're going to get it, man. You can't be doing that. But next time they face each other, the next season, he gets a fastball in the back. He goes sliding aggressively into the second base and the Rangers, it gets up shoves the Rangers shortstop or second baseman, maybe, I don't know, infielder and do just punches him directly in the face.

And I'm sending you a picture. You need to see this actually just just Google Jose Bautista punch and hit images. Look at this guy's crunched up face. This is amazing.

Oh, wow. Oh, yeah. You find it with his squish, his glasses flying off. Yeah.

That's a street brawl, man. And here's why it happened. I can't ever pronounce a guy's first name. It's like Runed Odor.

He drilled him and all of this is over the fact that Bautista grabbed his bat, flipped it from one hand to the other through it aside and watched his home run a little too long the year before. I mean, you can make fun of it, but this stuff is real. The unwritten rules are real in sports, not just for the fans, but for the players. Do you like those unwritten rules or does that attract for you?

I like it, but what you're making you realize is, you know, this is a physical altercation that happened as a result of someone not doing the unwritten rules like they were supposed to be done, so to speak. So this kind of stuff could lead to war. I wonder if it has. Oh, wow.

You use. Yeah, there's one in the isn't the one in the Bible where some guy shows up and like uses the wrong plates or something like that. He uses plates from the temple. That's a written rule.

I don't know that that that's a written rule. Yeah. I mean, certainly there have been slides and there have been slides that have been ignored. Like I think of George Bush barfing on the Japanese Prime Minister.

I mean, that didn't lead to war. I think it's an unwritten rule that you don't barf on your head of state counterparts as they serve the feed, but sorry. I don't know. And there are there are slides.

There are things I could gesture or say or do at you right now that could, if you didn't know the exercise we're going through, that could cause you to feel hurt or like, wow, okay, that isn't in itself a big deal, but we both know what that gesture means. We both know in our friendship what that phrase meant. And it's unwritten that you kind of don't hit somebody for that. And if I were to, you would handle it well because you're a mature, healthy adult, but it would stay more than some other joke or some other rib.

So I don't think unwritten rules are just macro things. I think all it takes 700 in rules, even two people where you both really know that stuff means stuff and that gesture, that word, that action, that lack of consideration. Whoa, that meant something pal. And I think that's what happens in baseball and different sports is like that we've all agreed somehow isn't showing up or insulting your opponent, but that doing it 20% more.

That is insulting your opponent and we won't tolerate that. Oh, yeah. Without a doubt, you know who thinks about this sort of stuff a lot? Tell me Brady.

He's got this whole like he is ultra dialed on subculture nuance. He is. I don't know. I remember this one day he took me to see Hamilton in London and we let's just get him on.

Do you talk to him yesterday, right? Yep, I did. See if you can get him on. Yeah, pretty good for it.

Let's do it. This episode of Notum Questions is sponsored by HelloFresh. America's number one meal kit delivery service. They send you pre-measured ingredients where you can cook a delicious meal at your house with your families, how we do it.

Sit down, enjoy a meal. It's fantastic. You're going to like this service. We highly recommend it.

Part of what I like about the HelloFresh thing is that I had not done this before we started with the whole Notum Questions thing. And for those of you who've been around the podcast for a while, you know, we've talked about HelloFresh for a long time, but also you have been witness to me learning things about cooking and food and nutrition and whole bunch of stuff. I just honestly did not know hardly anything about and it's because of the relationship with HelloFresh and I know a bunch of you have gone and tried it out as well and you're experiencing the same thing. So it's like we're evolving and it makes them an even better partner because there's actually growth involved in the thing.

And the way it works is that you jump on, you make an account, you order stuff, and then it just shows up very quickly when it's supposed to. And there are instructions that even if you don't understand things about kitchens or cooking, you can't screw up. They're so abundantly crystal clear. And each time you do it, you know, a little bit more of the verbage and a little bit more about how the things work and it just keeps getting smoother and smoother.

And the growth part has been huge for me. And I think HelloFresh themselves have actually grown. Like last year as HelloFresh has become more and more successful because people realize how great it is, they've done things as a company that I think is really interesting. Like they make a lot of moves towards sustainability.

They also give back to the community in a huge way. Last year, they donated over two and a half million meals to charity. And this year, they're stepping it up. So I just really like seeing a company that does something I like and enjoy as a product using that success to help other people as well.

So they are growing as a company and I'm proud to be a part of that. So they do things in a way that is sustainable. They do things in a way that saves me money and makes me better. They do things in a way that benefit people who are completely external to my relationship with HelloFresh.

They just me going through the natural paces of wanting to eat good food. I somehow get to feel like this tiny percentage of ownership that I get to be a drop in the bucket of helping all the people who they've helped as a process as well. It really is just a win-win relationship across the board. But that doesn't speak to the one thing that is the most natural question about food and that is does it taste good?

Destin, does it taste good? It does. It really, really does. I have eaten every bite of every HelloFresh mill that's ever been put on my plate, not because I'm trying to do it.

So I can tell you that. I literally like it. So here's the deal. If you want to try this, go to HelloFresh.com slash 80 in DQ and use the code 80 in DQ to get a total of $80 off, including free shipping on your first box.

Additional restrictions apply. Please visit hellofresh.com for more details with that's the promo code. HelloFresh.com slash 80 in DQ and use the code 80 in DQ. This HelloFresh thing has been a gigantic success story in terms of the relationship between a third chair podcast audience and the podcasters and sponsor because you keep using the product and you tell other people about the product and we just cannot thank you enough for the way that supports us.

And hopefully the way it's making your lives better as well. So again, if you want to get HelloFresh, you go to hellofresh.com slash 80 in DQ, use the code 80 in DQ and get a total of 80 bucks off, including free shipping on your first box. It's great. You're going to love it.

One of the unwritten rules here at Notum Questions is when you get your first HelloFresh mill, you tweet a picture of you cooking it to HelloFresh and to us at No Dumb Cues because we really like to see you making your own food. I see a lot of those. I like getting those. Keep them coming.

Let's get back to the conversation. How are you Brady? Very well. Thank you very well.

It's excellent. We need an authority in all things, unwritten rules and I mean, who better to talk to than Dr. Brady Heron? Well, oh, gosh, you do need a ton of time to drop the camera by the way.

You do need a ton of money. You do need a ton of money. You do yourself on her by getting a PhD. I didn't get a PhD.

I just got a piece of paper. So here's the deal, Matt. So I was in London a while back and I asked Brady if he would teach me cricket. And we went to a pub near Trafalgar Square.

We sat down as I recall the fries and the hamburger was great. Excuse me, the chips were amazing as I recall. We're just a couple of minutes from Buckingham Palace. We're right next to the Victoria Theatre.

Oh, OK. Yeah, it was awesome. So Brady sat me down and just went through cricket. It started off.

It was very clumsy, very difficult. But by the end of the thing, I was being like, oh, no, he can't do that. Obviously he shouldn't do that. Right.

Wow. How did you perceive it, Brady? I thought I was getting it by the end of it. I'd I think you, uh, your memory of it might be slightly different to mine.

I think asking. I think asking someone to explain cricket to them over a hamburger and fries is like me saying, while we're here, Dustin, could you please teach me all the rocket science? Like you cannot learn all the cricket over a burger and fries, but I did my best with the limited time we had. It was great.

I think you did a wonderful job and I feel like I'm an authority in the topic now. You were a willing student. The first time I went to the UK, I think I told you this before, buddy, but we we came upon a cricket match. I don't know where we were.

We just went around London for no good reason and looked at stuff. My wife and I and this was the first time I was there. It's the first time I went there with her and we came upon this cricket match and we just sat there and we took in an hour of it. It was wonderful.

And I was like, I'm going to go home and learn how to do this. I think my baseball skillset would translate at least a little bit. I'm going to Google the rules. I'm going to recruit people and we're going to have a cricket match.

Is it called a match? Yeah, a match. OK, so that worked out. And so I did.

I got a whole bunch of people together. I don't know how many people you need to play cricket, but I got them together. I told them that 11, 11, a side. Oh, well, that's memorable.

That's how American football works. I told them that they all had to wear white because this was a classy sport. And so we all wore white and we went out to the softball fields. There's a big soccer field next to softball fields in Nebraska where I lived.

And we played cricket. I took a hockey goalie stick and cut it off to make a cricket bat, which is completely wrong and unofficial and we were playing with the wrong kind of ball. And we all had a really good time. But by the end, we had unwritten rules where we would be calling each other like, Hey, hey, dude, that's too much.

You can't do that. But I think they were all the wrong, unwritten rules. I don't even remember what we were. But I'm sure I'm sure you have right, unwritten rules where it's just like offensive.

Yeah, but you don't really know why it's offensive in cricket. Do any of those come to mind? I mean, cricket is very much called a gentleman's game to the extent that it transcends the sport. And if someone does something incorrect just in general life, you will say to them, Hey, hey, that's not cricket.

That's just not cricket. So cricket has almost become a synonym for the right thing and doing things politely and in a gentlemanly way. I'm stealing. Yeah.

Whoa. There are two examples from the world of cricket I wanted to share with you that I think might fit into where you guys are going with this episode. I'm not sure. But one is something in cricket called walking.

Now in cricket, there are numerous ways for a batsman to get out to be dismissed. Your innings, your batting innings could last anywhere from minutes to potentially days. So getting a batsman out is the only way you can stop him scoring runs. So it's a big deal.

Getting a batsman out is a big deal. But the thing is some of the ways a batsman can get out can be very subtle and sometimes can be known only to the batsman. For example, if the bowl ascends down the ball and the ball just almost imperceptibly touches the bat, just feathers past the bat and then is caught by the wicket keeper who is like a catcher of cricket. You are out.

But the problem is sometimes it's not entirely clear whether you feather the ball. And so all the fielding team, the defensive team, as you would call them, could all jump in the air and celebrate because they think the batsman has feathered the ball. But the umpire may not have perceived it. He may not have heard it or seen it.

He may think, no, no, no, no, he missed and give the batsman not out. And the batsman can then chuckle to himself and think, well, I got away with that one and continue his innings. But the gentlemanly thing to do, the cricketing thing to do would be to walk, would be to admit to what happened. Yes, I felt it because a batsman always knows whether or not the ball has touched the bat and say, yeah, you're right.

I was out and walk off the field, like to give themselves out almost like calling a strike on yourself. And professional sport, this is quite a thing to do. And in the olden days, in the days of black and white, black and white television, most batsman would walk if they knew they were out as the game became more professional through the 70s, 80s and whatnot. I think the attitude became, well, it's the umpire's call.

If the umpire thinks I'm out, I'm out and if they don't, they don't, sometimes they're going to give me out when I'm not out. So I might as well take the advantages I get. But in recent times, there was an Australian player called Adam Gilchrist, who was a very sportsman like a very decent guy. He decided to bring back walking and he was one of the best, most destructive batsman in the sport, getting him out was like a coveted thing.

And he would just start walking sometimes, even when the other team weren't entirely sure if he was out or not, he started giving himself out because he thought that was the right thing to do, the sportsman like thing to do. It created a huge debate amongst cricket because everyone started saying to all the players, well, are you going to walk? Are you going to start walking now when you know you're out? And most of the players were like, well, of course I'm not.

It's the umpire's decision. But Adam Gilchrist brought it into Vogue for a while and it sort of became almost the trendy thing to do again to bring cricket back to decency. I have to say over the light, Adam Gilchrist is retired now, he no longer plays. And also, there's been a few innovations in recent years using microphones and new technology to tell whether or not the ball has been feathered, has been edged.

And now a lot of the time it can be reviewed by technology and television. So walking has become less of an even talking point in the sport. But back in the sort of early 2000s, mid 2000s, again became a big thing. Should have batsman walk.

Can you imagine a baseball, a really, really close call at first base and the umpire saying safe and the runner then saying, no, actually, I was out by a heartbeat and just walking off into the dugout of his own volition. It's kind of that's what walking people would be like. I can't imagine that in professional baseball. I've never seen that.

I can imagine it in Fort Collins, eighth grade summer league baseball in Colorado. Oh, yes. Because I had recently watched a set of Christian videos called the buttercream gang that my mom made me watch about telling the truth, even when it hurts. Yes.

And I knew I was out at first base. And so I got called safe and I called myself out and walked to the dugout. And my coach went nuclear on me. Our relationship never recovered.

My standing with the team never recovered. And so I think it's safe to say that the Fort Collins, eighth grade city, league baseball Yankees believe that you should leave that call to the umpire. Yes. Yes.

I mean, at amateur level, it's different because the standard of umpiring and the level of umpiring is completely different as well. And I think there's an expectation at the amateur level that you need to be a bit more honest. But yeah, but this was at the highest level of the sport that I'm talking about. Adam Gilchrist, this was the highest stakes you could have sometimes when games were in the balance and he would walk and it became it became quite a thing.

Well, I've got to know Brady. Do you walk? Although, I mean, obviously I have only played at the lowest levels of cricket. And I have to tell you doesn't matter.

I need to know. I can think of one time when I didn't walk that still shames me to this day. That's so not cricket. It's not cricket.

But I had a reason, but it was a terrible reason. For those who understand cricket, I will explain it was in the first innings of the match, I'd gotten out for a duck. That's zero. If you make no runs and you get out, that's getting out for a duck.

That's a very shameful thing in cricket. You don't want to get a duck. And then in the second innings, I went out to bat again. I had a second chance to bat.

If you get two ducks in innings, that's called a pair. And that's like, that's the ultimate bad thing in cricket. Oh, my goodness, I got a pair. And the first ball I faced, the ball tickled my bat and went onto my pad.

And it was caught by a close infielder and they all jumped up and appealed. And because it was at such a low amateur level, the umpire was actually one of my teammates. You have your teammates when they're not batting to come to the umpires. And he gave I don't know if he knew or not, but he gave me not out either.

You know, you always err on the side of your teammate. I don't know whether he was saving me or he just didn't know, but he gave me not out. And I didn't walk because there was no way I wanted to get a pair. So I just stood my ground.

But that's about it. And you still think about this? I do. I remember it vividly.

I remember it vividly. And I would have been in my, you know, it must have been 20 years ago. I think we are qualified to actually absolve you of this cricket sense. Since, you know, we're talking about unwritten rules, but Matt, you're already into something, right?

You'd better believe it. I think you're confession. I think everything's good now. It balances out.

It balances out and balances out and life because I once got a guy out in a game of cricket when he was on zero, he was clearly out and he got given not out by his teammate. And we all kicked up a fuss and said, you should walk mate. He's like, I'm not walking. So he stood his ground despite clearly being out much more clearly than me.

And he went on to make us huge hundred runs and won the game for his team. And I remember that to this day as well. So even in the end, it does even out. But I know you still drag that guilt with you in my version of Protestantism.

We don't really have any gestures we make when we install absolve people. So I'm just going to do one. Just clapping stuff. That means you're absolved.

It's not totally official with all expressions of religion. All right. I'll take it. But it's going to count for my goodness.

I did that one time in a tennis match. It was tight. I didn't feel like losing. I felt like some chintzy things that happened during the game where I was like, I should be up by a lot.

That's that's garbage. And then what happens is a little mental justifier in my brain started spinning like the one that was spinning in your brain. Yeah. And then it's amazing how quickly those moral calculations happened when that deep lob touched the back of baseline ever so slightly and without hesitation.

Out. I called it out. It was in. It's the only time I've ever done that.

And I knew and then what do you do immediately come back and be like, well, actually, I had a moral thing going on. Yeah. And I made some decisions like, no, you just roll with it. I lost anyway.

I deserved it. I'm a bad person. That wasn't great. Yeah.

And you know what? I'm not going to absorb you for that one. I'm so you. That was your co.

You know, the depth of the unwritten rules are incredible. Like they get right to the matters of the heart very quickly. What are some other cricket, or it doesn't even have to be cricket. Well, what's another example of an unknown?

I'll give you one more cricket one. And then I'll give you a couple from other spheres of life that I thought about. A very famous cricket one, which was an unwritten rule for so long. And it divided the sport for so long.

They actually finally have written rules for it. And even though they now have written a rule for it's still like this partisan debate and cricket on whether it's right or wrong and whether you're willing to practice this thing or not. And it's called a man cad. It's named after an Indian cricketer, whose surname is man cad.

And I'll try. I'll kind of put it into baseball language a bit to help you guys understand, but it's not entirely the same thing. But in cricket, there were two batsman out on the field at a time. There's the person who is facing who's striking, who's trying to hit the bowl.

And then there's a teammate at the other end who's kind of kind of like a base runner, I guess they were at the other end of the pitch and they'll run back and forward and share time striking the bowl. So if you're the non-striker, you're the runner at the other end of the pitch, you're standing next to where the bowler is, to where the equivalent of the picture is. And as soon as the bowl leaves the bowlers hand, you're allowed to start walking or running towards the other end. So a really common thing in cricket.

It's a bit like giving yourself a bit of a lead in baseball, but it's not quite so such an obvious thing is as the bowler bowls the bowl, you will just gently start walking in the direction that you might run in case you need to run. And this is an accepted part of the sport. It's called backing up. You're supposed to still be like in your crease behind the line or the equivalent of on base as the bowl is released.

But naturally, as the bowl is released, you'll just start this walk. Of course, if the bowler doesn't bowl it, which doesn't happen in cricket, you don't get like it's not like in baseball where the pitcher will be a bit cagey and pretend they're going to pitch the bowlers always bowls it. But if the bowlers was to not bowl it, you would naturally just be walking in that direction and you will walk out of your crease. So what man can did was he pretended to bowl and the batsman just gently innocently just started walking like looking for the bowl.

And at that point, the bowler broke the stumps, which of these things in cricket and got this guy out. And that's for years for 50, 60, 70 years that was considered a really unspotsman-like thing to do. It was almost considered cheating. If you look, if you interpreted the rules of the sport, it was out, it was a way to get someone out.

But if you did it, you were an absolute pariah practicing a man-cat. And you would never see it. It was like it was just like a sin of cricket. And then sort of in the last 20 years or so, as the stakes got higher in cricket and the desperation to win and get people out increased, you started getting more and more man-cats.

And it split the sport. You would have interviews with people saying, what do you think? Is a man-cat sportsman-like? Is a man-cat part of cricket?

And half of people would say, yes, you should be allowed to do it. That batsman is gaining an advantage. And the other half would say, well, they're not really gaining an advantage unless you change the way the game is played and don't bowl the bowl. And you shouldn't be doing that.

So you shouldn't be getting people out that way. It became the accepted practice to warn the batsman to say, I think you're stealing an advantage. If you keep doing it, I'm going to man-cat you. And then kind of all bets were off and you could man-cat them.

But doing it by surprise was still considered a bad thing. And they recently just had to change the rules of the sport. They basically said man-catting is all right. But still people are divided about it.

Still, there are some people who think it's right and some people think it's wrong. And if it ever happens in a game, it's like this big international incident. Does it break down along some kind of ideological lines? Like if you meet somebody who likes cricket in a certain environment, you just kind of look at them and you listen to them talk about some other things, like what movies they like, whatever.

Can you just be like, that guy's a man-catter? Or is it just completely random? I don't think I would be able to do it. I don't think I would be able to break it down.

I just remembered another incident, though, that I must tell you guys about. That you will love. And everyone who's not Australian will be saying, I bet Brady's not going to mention that incident, but I will mention it. And it was one of the biggest disgracees in Australian history.

It was a really big deal. And it involved a cricket match between... And this is again was breaking an unwritten role. There was a famous cricket match between Australia and New Zealand.

And I think you guys are aware that in cricket, unlike baseball where you have to throw the ball to the bat on the full, in cricket, the ball will usually bounce once before it reaches the batter. So there was this famous game of cricket between Australia and New Zealand. And it came down to the final ball of the match. And in the final ball of the match to win the match, New Zealand had to hit six runs.

And to hit six runs, you have to hit the ball over the fence on the full, like a home run. It's not as rare as a home run, but it's quite rare and difficult feat. It was unlikely it was going to happen, but it was possible. And the Australian bowler at the time, under instruction from his captain, did a very shameful thing.

But it was technically legal under the rings of cricket, although you would never ever do it. He walked up and instead of bowling a normal ball, he underarmed the ball and rolled it along the grass. Just rolled it all the way along the grass like bowls, or like 10 pin bowling or something, which made it impossible to sort of leverage under the ball and hit it for six. It's impossible to hit a ball for six if it's rolling along the grass.

It's the equivalent of walking someone in baseball and it's like an intentional walk. It was like an intentional walk, except with an intentional walk, at least another batter has to come up. Whereas this was the only opportunity to hit a six. This was the one ball.

There was no more cricket after this ball. So it was hit this one ball for a home run and win or don't hit it for a home run and lose. And to make sure it didn't get hit for a home run at all, he rolled it along the ground. So I mean, I don't like intentional walking anyway, but it wasn't like, at least if it was an intentional walk, another batter would come in and have a chance to hit the six, but here that wasn't the case.

It just made it impossible to win the game. And that was like an... No, I'm completely tracking. I had that scenario happen in a baseball game.

We had a player get ejected. No, he didn't get ejected. He just got hurt. And he couldn't finish the game.

And we only had nine people show up. And so we had a hole in our batting order that was just an out every time through. You don't have to forfeit the game. If you can't field a full team, but you have to take an out in that position.

So we were playing with two outfielders and a stripped down team. We had runners on base. We were down a run. It was the last inning.

And we only had one batter left to drive in those runners, because if the next batter came up, we would take our third out and the game was over. And of course, they just naturally intentionally walked the last remaining hitter we had. And then we took the automatic out next and took the loss. And it was an incident for us.

Everybody was mad about it afterwards. It felt personal. And I knew kids on that other team. And it carried over.

This cricket stuff carry over from what happens in the game. That under-arm incident between Australia and New Zealand, I think it was in the 1980s, still comes up all the time. It's a deep, deep fracture between the two countries. But it's an international incident.

If somebody defends that, though, do you think a little bit less of their integrity? No one defends it. There's no, there's no, like, the Australian captain who asked the bowl to do it, which, funnily enough, they were brothers. The captain and the bowl who were bowling were brothers.

And the older brother told his younger brother to do this thing. They're called the chapel brothers. No, you know, he had to make like a hit forlorn sword in this kind of national apology. It was not a good moment in Australian cricket history.

Literally a national apology. Oh, it was a big deal. It was a very big deal. Would you man-cat somebody if you were bowling in your head?

Well, funnily enough in the game of indoor cricket, which is almost a completely different sport. Man-cating is legal. And I was very good at man-cating, actually. It was one of my favourite moves, but it's completely legal.

You would be good at man-cat. It's a bit of a poker move, you know. It's a bit like, you know, the baseball, the pitcher, you know, catching the runner. That's awesome.

I'm sitting here looking at a man-cating compilation on YouTube. Oh, yeah. It's like instant emotion. One guy shatters his bat.

He gets caught and he just, it's so angry. He shatters his bat. It's a big deal, man. Yeah, it's kind of a big deal.

I'll give you a couple of good soccer unwritten rules. Laughter. So one of my favourite. And again, a lot of these things are changing as the sports become more professional.

And you can no longer trust people to follow unwritten rules. So again, this has changed in recent times, but it's still a grey area. This is when a soccer player gets injured, there's an unwritten rule that whoever has possession of the ball, whichever team has possession of the ball, you'll kick it out of bounds, not take advantage of your numerical superiority, let someone come onto the field and treat the injury. And then when play regimes with a throw-in, the team that has the throw-in will throw the ball back to the other team and give them back the possession they had.

So if the, you know, if the Destin Sandlands had the ball and a Matt Whitman player got injured, the Sandlands would kick the ball out of bounds, you'd fix up your Whitman, and then the Whitman's will take their throw-in and throw the ball back to the Sandlands. But this becomes difficult because as I'm sure you're aware, soccer is notorious for players feigning injury to try and win free kicks and things like that. So quite often in the professional game now, someone will be rolling around on the ground pretending they're in agony, and the other team's like, oh, piss off, you're not injured. And they'll just keep playing.

Get up, get on with the game. And it's up to the player who's feigning injury to decide whether they're going to stick with their pretending or they can just get up and keep playing. There's been incidents where someone's been injured, another team has rushed forward with their numerical advantage and scored a goal, which is considered a terrible travesty to have done that and not kick the ball out of bounds. Because it's an unwritten rule among professionals if one of the other guys is injured, kick it out and let's get him some treatment as soon as possible.

Soccer in the US has, or at least European football, has the reputation to be a lot of, how do I say this? It's just very deceptive. Like, all these unwritten rules don't mean a thing. Like, we make fun of people that, you know, act like they're hurt and things that they're making.

Oh, yeah, yeah. I can't imagine that a soccer unwritten rule carries near as much weight as it does with cricket, because it seems like deception is part of the game. But it's fun, you're right. And there are some things that, like, diving to win a penalty or pretending to be hurt is almost, is an accepted part of the game, although increasingly frowned upon, whereas this, when someone is genuinely injured, not kicking the ball out of bounds is considered a poor thing to do.

There's a very famous incident that people can go and look at online. It's one of the great moments of sportsmanship in sport. It's very famous in England. It's famous around the world, where Everton, the team from Liverpool were playing against West Ham, a team from London.

And the score was one all, and it was right at the very, very end of the game. Both teams were desperate to win, and West Ham went streaming forward, and the goalkeeper for Everton came running out to try and block the ball, and injured himself in doing so, and quite a long way from the goal. And West Ham retained possession of the ball, while the Everton keeper was stricken, injured on the ground, obviously not guarding his goal anymore. And a West Ham player crossed the ball, like, across the face of the goal, to this very, very good football called Paolo DiCanyo, an Italian player, but he played for West Ham.

And he was a fantastic finisher. So as the ball drifted through the air towards DiCanyo, with his empty gaping goal, it was almost a fair complete that DiCanyo was going to do something spectacular and score a goal in the final second, and win the game for West Ham. But DiCanyo had seen the injured goalkeeper and knew it was wrong to keep playing, with the player injured and with the goal open. And instead of heading the ball or kicking the ball towards the goal, he just caught up with his hands and then turned to the referee and said that guy over there's injured, that's getting treated, and rolled the ball away and didn't try and score a goal.

And it was like one of the great moments of sportsmanship in sport. This would be like, you know, in an American football match running towards the touchdown line and noticing the guy chasing you to tackle you, pulls a hamstring and stopping your run to the touchdown line and turning around to check he's okay. What was the score on the scoreboard? That matters.

It was 1-0, it was 1-0, this would have won the game. And it was like, it was in stoppage time. The game was seconds from ending. The game ended 1-0, I believe.

It cost them victory. But it's not like that in American football. It's not analogous because we have no such unwritten rule that people get hurt on every single play, at least a little. Yeah, I was drawing an analogy to help you understand the stakes, you know, how close it was to a score and how it was.

Yeah, of course. But there's so much with that one though, because it matters who the player is, because if that's like a player and it's his first time to play, and he does that, everybody's going to hate it. Yeah. But because it's this, you know, this huge and the person that's larger than life.

I mean, everybody praises him. And the player had been injured only moments before. You could even have argued it was still the same motion of play. And there was no responsibility to the injured player.

Like normally, it's very rare that that situation of putting the ball out of bounds comes about. It's such a moment where a goal is so gaping and so possible. Normally the ball's just in the midfield and tapping it out of bounds isn't that big a sacrifice. But this involved sacrifice, which was what was so amazing about it.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 15 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on August 15, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.