Skip to content
096 - What Are Marshmallows? episode artwork

Oct 29, 2020 1 hr 11 min

096 - What Are Marshmallows?

from No Dumb Questions Hosted by Matt Whitman and Destin Sandlin

SPONSORED BY: THE PATRONS! You can support the program if you'd like at patreon.com/nodumbquestions RAYCON To get 15% off your order, go to buyraycon.com/ndq. STUFF FROM THIS EPISODE Marshmallows Althaea Hippocrates PaRappa the Rapper Viscoelasticity Dioscorides Francis Bacon Gum Arabic Pâte de Guimauve Fluffernutter Gelatin PETA - What is gelatin made of? S'mores Archibald Query Stay Puft Marshmallow Man Althaiophobia CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

096 - What Are Marshmallows?

0:00 1:11:57
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I don't think you can beat me at this. I'm pretty confident I can. What gives you that confidence? Let's be clear.

What size do you have? Massive. Like, shocking. These are big.

I'm not going to lie. Mine are pretty big. Mmm. I'm skeptical of that.

OK. I'm putting the first one in. You ready? I'm ready.

Go ahead. Get ready to shame yourself. OK. Go.

Chubby Bunnies. All right, my turn. No swallowing. Chubby bunny.

Over to you. Chubby bunny. Over to you. Whirl.

Just plural. Number two. Chubby bunny. Three.

Stop the bunnies. Three. Hold on. Don't chew.

Chubby bunny. I'll know. Number four. Chubby bunny.

Four. Huh? You do the chubby technique where it's off to the side. Chubby bunny.

I'm putting in number five and number six. Oh. Chubby bunny. Eat a sand line.

All five times. That's it. That's it. I'm just fighting first.

That won't work. I'm clapping. I'm clapping. Chubby bunny.

OK, you win. You win. I had seven. I had seven.

Oh, golly. Do you drool of yourself? I've got a stream of drool down the front of my jacket. Do we have this time out with the clumps?

I'm going to go with the clumps. Oh, I brought napkins. What are you doing? I'm confident my marshmallows were bigger than yours.

I'm confident they were of equal size because I sent you a photograph of my marshmallows with an SD card next to them so you would know exactly what size to get. I did my best and the lady at the supermarket was insistent that we buy this certain. All right. I got to go watch my hands.

I'll be right back. Oh, man. I look like I had been shaving and missed a bunch of spots. My face was shaving cream.

It was marshmallow slime. It's gross. All right. It's got a massive drool circle with like the little bit of white evaporates still left in it.

Oh, yeah. I don't know if that's ever going to be right. All right. I'm going to go with marshmallows.

It is. Yeah. It's what I want to do. We hinted at it the other day when we were talking with Dailin and I was like marshmallows and Dailin's working on the folk drink.

Thanks. I want to talk to you about marshmallows. Let's do it. Let's do the thing where we started out by you telling me what you already know about marshmallows.

Go. Okay. So it's my understanding that marshmallows originally came from Egypt and there's some type of plant in Egypt that is called the mallow or something like that and they grow in the marsh. That's the marsh.

I see what you did. That's what I got. I think you're right. Are you serious?

Okay. So obviously I don't know a whole lot of things about marshmallows off the top of my head, buddy. So there was some, there was some thought and work here to give you like some stuff to think about with marshmallows. So just understand what I knew about marshmallows coming in was less than that.

I didn't actually know they were a plant. I didn't know anything about where marshmallows came from. So you win this round. I win Shubby Bunnies.

The name, the Latin name of the plant is the Althea Ophissianalis. Ophissianalis. I don't know if I'm saying that quite right. And you're right.

It was, it's this marshy plant. I actually tried to find one and I was going to mail it to you, but I couldn't get one in time. So just imagine that I sent you one of these plants, but they'll grow wherever people grow them in their herb gardens where you live and where I live. Really?

Yeah. Yeah. It's, I read one entry as kind of an old book, but it said that no English herb garden is complete without a marshmallow. Look at this.

Althea Ophissianalis at A-L-T-H-A-E-A. So these plants are more common than, than I thought. So they're not just like some ancient thing that died off, you know, with mummies or whatever. Like this is a thing today.

Yeah. It's a thing today. I'm not understanding is it not just in Egypt, but all around the Mediterranean world. But the Egyptians, the reason it gets associated with Egypt, what I found is this.

The Egyptians apparently had some kind of upper crust dessert treat that they made. It was like, it sounded like a bar kind of dessert treat where you take nuts and oats and honey and stuff and you put it all in there and it kind of forms like a hardened toffee bar. Toffee is not really the right word. But can you picture the kind of candy?

It's kind of skinny and it's got all kinds of goodies and chunks in there. Like trail mix, but in hardened marshmallow goo. Can you picture that? It sounds like a fruit roll up with a bunch of nuts and stuff in it, like somewhere between granola and chu kind of thing.

Yeah. That's so much better than how I described it. Yeah. And apparently the fancy people could have the marshmallows, but your common people, they don't get the marshmallows.

Really? I wasn't actually able to independently verify that. I only saw that on a whole bunch of secondary sources. So I don't know if that's true or a myth that gets put over the top.

But we know that the Egyptians ate marshmallows and they ate them as a dessert treat. And so this would be our first use of marshmallows as a dessert treat. Like most things in a nurb garden, you can assume that the alfella of fish and alice was used more often medically. What would be your guess for what marshmallows would treat?

I would assume it had something to do with like getting to sleep at night or like an aphrodisiac, you know, everything in the ancient world in my mind, medicinally was about aphrodisiac powers or whatever. So I don't really know. What was it? What was it used for?

Well, this is where it got really interesting. It was legit medical stuff. Because five or six uses that date back to the first century AD or earlier that all have to do with different ways to harvest and prepare the different parts of the marshmallow to legitimately fix things. And okay, so when you think of ancient medicine, who's the rock star of ancient medicine, like the most legitimizing name we could put next to ancient marshmallows, who would it be?

I have no idea. Am I supposed to like literally give you name? I mean, am I supposed to know an answer to that? Yeah, I would think so.

There's a pretty famous oath named after him. No. Oh, they have a crowd of code? Yeah, Hippocrates.

Okay. Hippocrates is a fifth, fourth century, probably fourth century medical doctor who is the father of western medicine. Was he? Yeah, he was Greek.

Well, modern day Turkish. She's from a little bit south of Ephesus. He lived on an island. He's from coast.

So yes, he's culturally Greek, linguistically Greek would have been a contemporary roughly with Plato and Aristotle, Socrates, that crowd somewhere in there. Okay. Got it? Excuse me.

I'm still trying to clear my throat of marshmallow. Yeah. We did not think that through very carefully. No, we didn't.

So Hippocrates, we have some of what he wrote, and I would like to read it to you with your blessing regarding the marshmallow. No way. You have like an ancient document about marshmallows? I do.

And everybody's expecting a barnacle. He's a testically thing right now, but it's not that we actually have it. So here we go. Okay.

All right. We're going to start here overdo it. Okay. These are to be used raw and the leaves of the mellow pounded with wine and the leaves of root.

Don't know what that is. And those of the green origami don't know what that is with all these linseed and what that is is to be boiled up and mixed by pounding it as a very fine powder. When there is danger of, whoa, a word I don't understand, seizing the ulcers, the leaves of woad are to be, oh, whoa, that's like the blue stuff from Braveheart, the blue paint that the barbarian's use. Really?

The leaves of woad are to be pounded and applied raw in a catapalism. I don't know what that means, either along with linseed or the linseed is to be moistened with the juice of strychnus or of woad and applied as a catapalism. When the ulcer is clean, blah, blah, blah, blah, he thought marshmallows would fix ulcers if you mix them up with some wine. Really?

That's crazy. Yeah. Ulcers, not an aphrodisiac. And ulcer here, the father of western medicine wrote that down and recommended it to people who followed his teachings.

How about that? Okay, but I've got to believe that the marshmallows that we have in these bags here, and we just played chubby bunny with, and good job eating by the way. I have to believe these have no, I'm sorry, what's the name of it again? Althea, Althea, Althea, and Alice?

They have none of that in it, right? I was just checking ingredients. Okay. All right.

What brand is yours that you have there? We saved some money. Great value. It's the store brand.

I have big, and fluffy marshmallows from Publix, a fat, free food. I don't believe that. So we've got. So we've got some quenchenery.

It says no fat. Total fat, zero grams, saturated fat, zero grams, trans fat, zero grams. This is good for you. Yeah.

This is what moms, when their kids eat. So I'm not going to recommend it. My wife, she has a bag of marshmallows at all times in the pantry, and she'll just walk by and show this snatch one. It's like her guilty pleasure.

She's like, ah, marshmallows. She likes marshmallows. It's a pretty innocent guilty pleasure. Yeah, it's pretty good.

Dude, I like the marshmallows and Lucky Charms. You know, you can buy. Why do you two? Are those actually, are those something else or are, is that just named marshmallows?

Because this seems like a completely different texture and flavor. Crunch is like, like, airy chalk, doesn't it? Okay. So ingredients.

Yeah. Yeah. Like candy cigarettes were fluffier. Yeah.

Okay. Here we go. Ingredients. Corn syrup.

Sugar. Modified corn starch. Modified food starch slash corn. Gelatin.

Water. Dextrose. Natural and artificial flavors. Tetra sodium pyrophosphate.

What about your? That is exactly the same list of ingredients I have. I suspect all the marshmallows might get made in the same place. We're expecting many.

One or two marshmallow factories and that everybody pays like a leasing fee or something to buy their marshmallows. Dude, you just, I don't know for sure. You just took me back, man. I just realized.

So come back and where? I just realized you took me back to 2001 when I was a mechanical engineering intern at the Little Debbie Snack Cake Factory. And my job was, I was a production engineer on the Rice Krispie cake line. And we've talked about this in the past, but the binder that you use to stick the Rice Krispies together is like marshmallow stuff.

Sure. Yeah. I just now realized. But it's like marshmallow fluff, like the goop.

Yeah, it's kind of the goop. But I mean, I just now realize that I dealt with this material on an industrial scale. Isn't that weird too? I feel like we've lived a lot of lives.

So life of chapters, brother. That's a pretty notable one right there. That's weird. Okay.

The thing that I was dealing with is imagine a five foot wide assembly line of just Rice Krispie treats just coming straight straight at you, but they weren't cut in any way. So my job was to cut those and then divide, divide them up into individual bars. And so the way that was accomplished was with Pete, imagine you have this rectangular conveyor belt covered in Rice Krispie cakes, you know, about an inch and a half thick and you had a series of pizza rollers that they would go in between and that would divide them up into like two and a half inches wide or whatever. Wait, wait, wait, wait, like pizza rollers like that you cut a pizza with or that you would roll dough with that you would cut that you would cut a pizza with.

So pizza cutter, that's a pizza roller. I don't know what you call it. I don't know either one sounds like a pizza roller. Yeah.

It was a pizza cutter roller. I see the like a compact yesterday. The whole, the whole conveyor belt will go right up to that. And there was this little transfer moment where you go from one conveyor belt to the next and you have to jump the gap like pitfall, except the whole thing has jumped the gap and it was fascinating.

You had to make sure that the product, they wouldn't say Rice Krispie cakes, they would always say product. They'd use all these engineering terms and you had to make sure that, you know, this thing's coming along pretty dang fast. And so you had pizza cut them up and then you'd have like 10 strips and then those strips had to be chopped and you would do that with a guillotine cutter with a guillotine cutter had to come down and strike the Rice Krispie cakes and then move with the conveyor belt. Does that make sense?

Okay. So, okay. So the guillotine cutter smashes down, but then it has to advance with the conveyor belt in order to keep up. Yeah.

Yeah. So, so with your, with your arm right now karate chop motion. So I, yeah, you're going to believe me. I'm already doing it.

You don't need to tell me to be karate chopping. Okay. So the Rice Krispie cakes are moving from your left to your right and your karate chopping with your right hand down at about, you know, the left side of your body, but then you're kind of moving your hand to the right after you do the karate chop. So chop, move to the right.

Chop, move to the right. It sounds like a parabola wrap up. Oh, it sounds like a kick chop move to the right. Nothing.

Just, it doesn't matter. Do you remember that video game? The PlayStation game for wrap up where you had to like get in rhythm and push up. Never mind.

I don't. I'm sorry. You just sung lyrics from it on accident. Forgive me.

Anyway, that's what, uh, that's what I would do. And the whole deal was you would, you would pick up. This was the key. You wanted the marshmallow to be mixed just enough where it was a suitable binder.

And so occasionally we would do quality checks where we would go grab a Rice Krispie cake that had just been guillotine chopped. We would pick it up and we would pull it apart. You'd take your index finger and your thumb and each hand and you'd grab the sides of it and you'd pull it apart and you would figure out how far it would stretch before it would fall. And was there a prescribed amount that it needed to stretch to?

There was. I don't remember what it was, but I remember thinking things like, oh, this mixture is too long. This mixture is too short. And you had to, you had to like dial it.

It was a function of temperature and it was a function of, uh, you know, the ratio of marshmallow to rice. Man, dude, I have forgotten. This is insane. Dude, I told you I want to talk about marshmallows and you were like, uh, I got nothing.

Okay, whatever. And then we started the thing and I'm like, what do you know about marshmallows? Like, uh, I heard a rumor. There was a plant and then we get into it.

You're like, Oh, no, actually I was an engineer on a marshmallow line. Here's how all the things work. Here's the viscosity factor for the renal instigator. You have to get the matriculation.

Co-opision. I legitimately forgot all this stuff. Now that's really all I got. I legitimately forgotten all this about my life, but there you go.

That's where I'm at. Okay. Okay. deeper into marshmallow.

Yeah, we have more history of marshmallows that I want to get to, but is there a physics? Is there, is there a, I don't want to say this. Is there a term? Is there an explanation in physics for stickiness quotient?

Is it a thing or is it just something that I ball in science doesn't know how to explain? That's a hard one, dude. So I've heard, I've heard people use visco elasticity to try to describe it, but I don't really know. I don't, I can't claim that I understand this because there's two things you want to happen with a sticky substance.

You want it to, first of all, you want to be able to flow, like you want it to be able to move and suitably, like imagine a coastline of a continent or whatever. It's not a line like it is on the map. There's a bunch of like inlets and outlets and things like that. And the closer you look, the more rough the edges are, right?

Like if you go into the pebble level, you can go around a rock and then back out into the sea and then around another rock. And so like the more, the more coarse or the more jagged the edges are, the more you can affix yourself to a surface if you're able to flow into those little crags, kind of like a jigsaw puzzle. Does that make sense? Yeah, sure.

But at the same time you want to be able to bind it in there. So, so if you can, the ideal sticky substance would be a substance that could flow into all those little cracks on an uneven surface and then freeze and be very difficult to move. So, so imagine something very slow to move, very, you know, very viscous, but then once it's in those little cracks, it doesn't want to let go. So that's why like honey and molaskas are very sticky.

Yeah, I don't know. What does marshmallows have to do with that? Right. But temperature can accomplish that.

I mean, you can, you can make that binding agent really flowy at one temperature. Yeah. And then move it to another temperature and then you get the results you want, right? Yeah, absolutely.

That makes sense to me. But when you're talking about what you call it viscoelasticity? Yeah. Okay.

When you're talking about that, when I look at a kneaded eraser, do you remember those from art class in eighth grade? A long time ago. Yeah. When you sit there and goof with a kneaded eraser and you pull it apart, it has some disco elasticity to it.

But if you look close, it's not gooping apart. It doesn't disintegrate the weight of the arc created by pulling it apart. Doesn't cause it to droop apart. You really are ripping it and you can see just because of the nature of that texture, a gazillion little micro tears as you pull it apart.

If you held it 18 inches away from your face, you wouldn't see all those little micro tears happening. It would feel like pulling apart a marshmallow or something like that. So is the reality of the situation that when anything gets pulled apart that has this kind of texture at the most basic level, it really is ripping, even if it doesn't look to the eye like it is? Okay.

I've got a marshmallow and I'm pulling it apart. Oh, it's very much ripping. Like you can see, oh, that's interesting. You can, it starts off with like tinsel breaks.

But then as it rips down through the marshmallow, it kind of turns into sheer. Oh, that's very interesting. Oh. So, you're giving me of what those two terms of meaning.

I'm sorry. Like a tinsel break is just pulling straight apart and a sheer break is something that's like cut like with scissors, but it's like tear sideways. It's interesting. Got it.

So yeah, I don't know where we're going with this, but there's, I mean, this is a very, very deep well. And I'm thinking that what you have to say about marshmallows is probably more interested about than than like more circle and how principal stresses act on different substances. Well, I don't know about that, man. I think this is one of those cool places with our Venn diagram because why do marshmallows have staying power?

They taste good, but lots of things taste good. It's because they're fun, right? Yeah. They are enjoyable to chew and chop and mess within your mouth and you can change the temperature with them and their behavior changes.

I mean, you change the temperature and I don't know why sugar likes fire so much, but even a slight temperature change results in, I guess what you would call a pronounced chemical change, right? Yeah, caramelization. I'm eating a marshmallow now, by the way. Yeah, I was going to do another one, but I'm afraid of what I'll do to my mouth.

Hey, we're sitting here right now. Back at a log listeners, it's Matt and Dustin from the Future. We're sitting here right now. Yeah.

Right. So, we're going to talk about the questions of spots using every time travel and future dystopian folks that we can think of to beg the listeners of the past to support us on Patreon. Well, not necessarily the listeners of the past. It's people that are going back for the back catalog like explorers mining through the archeology that is no dumb questions, lore.

And so thank you. If you're listening to the back catalog, I think you might actually care about us or like, I don't know, maybe you're fishing for things to cancel us over who knows. Good luck. Yeah.

Good luck. Yeah. We cancel ourselves every day. And you can do that at patreon.com slash no dumb questions.

It's a big deal. And we have learned that being free from external forces is really, really important. We don't want to play the algorithm game with anything we do. So if you'd be willing to support, that'd be great.

What should we do next? We haven't done like a dystopian young adult novel thing yet, like Hunger Games or something. Okay. Let's do that.

Yeah. Let's do one more. We're on a raft to hear all a raft. Yeah, like we're going to have an ocean on a raft because of the waters rising.

Yeah. Well, I've seen it put waves and sound. Yeah, of course. Yeah.

We had to scorch the sky. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Here's a deal. I'm not telling everybody where we're putting all of these. I'm just burying these little nuggets throughout the back catalog, kind of like one of those time traveler parties that Stephen Hawking tried to throw a while back and nobody showed up for.

I'm just putting them all back there. And it's going to be one of those things like when the professor or when the student writes some kind of note to the professor in the exam to prove that the professor doesn't read the exam. It's like that they're just all going to be back there somewhere. I don't even know where.

Did you get the book? No, I didn't because I didn't find it. That analogy doesn't work totally though because in this situation we're kind of hoping for the book. Oh, yeah, it doesn't work.

Patreon.com slash no-dim questions. Thank you. Thank you from the future. Bye.

They are fun, aren't they? They're fun. That's kind of a thing. It's fun to eat a marshmallow.

Mm-hmm. Yeah, soda is awful for you, but it's fun to drink. And marshmallows are awful for you, but they're really fun to goof around with and fun to chew. And I think if they were just a little jolly rancher bricks of flavorless sugar, it wouldn't be interesting.

I mean, the flavor isn't special. The texture is what makes the thing go. And to your point about there being more to the story, there is the ancient marshmallow stuff, it's a flavor brick, dude. It's a hard bar that would make a crunching sound when you broke it off on your side teeth as you took a bite of that Egyptian marshmallow dessert bar.

It was not gooey though. It was gooey when you treated the root and took it out of the ground in the first place. It's kind of sappy and oozy is my understanding. Like, this is in the literature.

Like, like, this is in the literature. Well, I mean, like, Egyptians, please forgive my ignorance. They wrote with hieroglyphics, et cetera. Yeah, you're right.

So I mean, eventually they wrote in Greek or derivatives thereof, but the old school stuff is hieroglyphics. Should you tell me there's like a wall somewhere with like a recipe for all that stuff you just read? Granted, that was Hippocrates. You know what?

I would like to think that somewhere out there buried in the sands of time is a marshmallow recipe in hieroglyphics with pyramids and eyeballs and people doing that Egyptian dance and crocodiles and stuff like that. But most of the stuff that we have from the ancient world in terms of sources is, well, you call it, a pseudo primary source. So a whole lot of what we have of Hippocrates, for example, is secondary. He was so famous that we can almost reconstruct all of his works.

I think this is true of Hippocrates. I could be mistaken. But a bunch of the church fathers that I study, the Latin philosophers and theologians of the first few centuries, we don't have much of their work. But you can piece back together everything that was in there by looking at quotes from 50 or 100 years after they were alive, because their work was so influential and got quoted so much.

So while we might not have a copy of the book, we can piece it together. Likewise, I don't think there's a wall that we know of that has the marshmallow recipe on it. But we've got a whole bunch of secondary sources that talk about the mallo being used in food and the mallo being used in medicine. And the really famous one in terms of the medicine side is by a guy named Dioskorides.

Have you ever heard of him? I'm sorry. You're gonna have to spell that. It sounded like he sneezed or something.

Or said something about a corgi dog or something. Dioskorides? That's pretty good. We can just go with that.

Dioskorides is the guy's name. He is a contemporary of Paul of Tarsus and his traveling companion, Luke of New Testament. Bible fame. And the interesting thing is that he was a pharmacist from Tarsus.

So it's kind of fun that Dioskorides and the biblical character Luke, if they were in Tarsus at the same time, is a decent chance they would have been talking shop. Because there were doctors. Yeah, about the world of medicine. Well, doctors kind of fun to imagine.

Anyway, there's no evidence they actually chatted, but my brain goes there. So this guy put together a massive work called on medical material or day material, Medica. I'm looking at it. And this could be right now.

Oh, you already found it. Right. Yeah. What jumps off the page either?

Let's see. It's like Barry, it looks really well done. It's been reproduced several times. It appears.

But man, that's amazing. This was and again, I don't know much about medical history, but from my homework, this was like the compendium of the field guide of everything you could use in nature to make people feel better that dominated the minds of the medical world for 1500 years. It wasn't until the age of bacon, the scientific revolution, Francis bacon, not the food, the scientific revolution that this starts to go out of vogue as more early modern expressions of medicine start to catch on. So I mean, talk about staying power, man.

So this day, material, Medica has 1500 years worth of staying power. What do you think people are writing right now that's going to have 1500 years of staying power? Oh, wow. 1500 years of staying power.

So it'll still be cool or relevant or useful in some way in 3500 plus 80 in space. Bitcoin hashes. I don't know. I don't know.

I don't know. I don't know what people are. Right now, I'm listening to a book about nuclear physics. And I don't know.

I think a lot of discoveries are happening now. I mean, what I say now, I mean, like within the last 100 years, there's a lot that's been discovered in the last 100 years. So a lot of science textbooks, I would think could be, but won't those just get updated in 50 years? No, no genetics genetics.

We are just now understanding the human genome. And I think as we learn more about specific genes and we write those down, those will matter in the future. That's my question. Even if we change, maybe we decide that we want to change who we are to make a stronger combat disease, whatever, that would be a slightly different genome.

And it would make the 2000 dish version of our genome an important point of reference. I think so. I wonder if someday they'll Jurassic Park this version of us. Not better back then.

Not me. Not me. No, I'm not. I'm on the same place.

No, no, no. Go with a big negative story on that. I understand. Yeah.

I don't know that I have a better answer to that question. Whatever the case, it looks like the authorities was telling people that this wouldn't help get intestinal worms out and that you could mix it up with honey and resin and use it to bind up a wound in battle. We do it super glue. Now what?

Yeah. What? Honey and resin and marshmallow alania aficionellis to bind up a wound in battle. Yeah, I don't know if that would actually work or not, but there's record.

I mean, how do you learn something like that? I don't know, man. That's bizarre. Like somebody learned it and it made them alive.

So mine just said they wrote it down. They're like, Hey, next time you get cut real bad in battle by a sword, get some marshmallow do fix and just, yeah. I mean, what's interesting about that is, you know, we're using the super glue suitor techniques these days. Right.

That's fascinating. It makes me wonder how many like ancient remedies and stuff like that are legit and work great. And we just, we just haven't taken the time to go back and read. There's got to be a ton of that, man.

There has to be, I saw a meme today. I don't even remember what the meme was, but basically it was a historians meme grieving the burning down of the library in Alexandria. How much stuff did people figure out the hard way, not the easy way, the way where people die and get hurt while you experiment and figure out how much stuff did people figure out the hard way and it all went to ash. That just is infinitely tragic.

Dude, I'm scared to death that most of the stuff in my life is digital. I'm scared to death of that. And I know we're talking about marshmallows, but, but I'm still taking this place so far. Don't quit.

Yeah. Yeah. I'm just really terrified that you know, I've got all this stuff I've done and, you know, just learning stuff and trying to, I mean, just all of smarter every day, all these lessons that I learned in the hard way. I mean, I've got them on a hard drive.

YouTube has them, but I don't know. It could all go away. Yeah, I think about that too. Yeah, for a while I started to do the digital library thing.

It was buying all my resources on Kindle. And I still do because I want to have them in duplicate so I can have them with me wherever it's just my phone. If I got 10 minutes, I can work, but I'm buying hard copies of everything now too. I want to physically have that.

I'm taking film photos now. They look good, man. You're going to nice touch. It looks good.

Thanks. It's really interesting. But I don't know. There's this company that I'm, I think I'm going to start working with them to try to bring film back.

So anyway, Marshmallows get cut in a battle. You goop it up with some honey and some, some, what was the other stuff that you goop in there? Resin. And marshmallow.

Money in a resin marshmallow battle wound cure. Yeah, there you go. Hmm. Interesting.

What else you got? This is interesting. Well, I kind of thought so too. You know, you got such disparate functions and we're only to the first century AD, but then it looks like things kind of go dormant.

The Romans ate marshmallows. We don't know or at least I wasn't able to find how exactly they treated them and what they did with them. It looks like the big jump with marshmallows happened in France in the early 1800s. I don't know who, but they came up with a fresh combination where they added another thickener agent to gum Arabic.

You heard this, right? It's in everything. I've heard of it. I have no idea what it is.

Ooh, it's from an acacia tree, I think the stuff that giraffe seed. Yeah, the thorn entries. Yeah, with the little tiny leaves and I think if you hack at the bark, it just barfs out gum Arabic. But it's, it's a massive thing.

I mean, it's like palm oil. It's one of those deals where you vaguely heard of it maybe because you got bored once and read a label on something. And then as soon as you see it, you know, dang, this is in everything. And so gum Arabic is used in maybe cosmetic and stuff and paints and actual gummy foods.

So I don't know much more about it than that other than I know it's in everything. I had no idea. So you cut the bark of an acacia tree and this stuff oozes out kind of like when you, you see a sap coming out of it. So this is a specific sap specifically for this tree.

And then somebody could have looked up. Yeah, I did. So I figured out how to combine this with marshmallow stuff. And that was the breakthrough.

And people are crazy. Yeah. Well, I mean, it's pretty cool what came out of it because this version of marshmallows that was called pete de guimav. I don't know if the gui in guimav is an automobile or not, but it sounds like it has gui in the name.

So sugar, water, egg whites, gum Arabic and marshmallow root. And it looks like from what I found online, I looked at some YouTube videos and stuff, it's like marshmallow ingot, like a brick of marshmallow. That's how it comes out. Like the kind of thing that if you jabbed it or flicked it, it would jiggle back and forth for maybe, I don't know, five or six cycles and then settle down and go back to looking like a brick sitting there.

Is there a name in physics for that jiggle factor? Yeah, it's called thick. THICC. Wait, nothing.

I just googled marshmallow bricks. This is taking away places with me. Do that. That's a.

Sorry. Yeah, I don't know. What? Yeah.

I just googled marshmallow brick. This is what am I, what am I, what do I need to Google to find this thing that you're telling me about? Like P-A-T-E, like duck pate, pate, de, guimab, G-E-Y, M-A-U-V-E. So like gooey and then mob, like the color.

And so it turns out that a bunch of like homeschool moms and stuff make pate, dig guamav, still. No way. Hold on. Hold on.

Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. Hold on.

So it is, dude, this is the rabbit trail topic that keeps giving. So this is fluff. Fluff. Fluff.

Kind of. Have you ever heard of fluffinutters? Oh, wait, fluffin what? Fluffinutters.

I have a free desk. When I was young, when I was young, I went up to, I guess it was Massachusetts. There's just, I think it was Massachusetts, but we were talking about peanut butter and banana sandwiches. And they're like, oh, no, no, you haven't lived until you've had a fluffinutter.

I was like, what on earth? Can you spell fluffinutter? FLUFF, apostrophe N, N-U-T-T-E-R. Fluff.

Nutter. Nutter. And so up in the northeast, they have this stuff you can buy in a jar called fluff. Have you heard of marshmallow fluff?

Sure. Oh, yeah, we're going to talk about fluff. Okay. I'm sorry.

I'm jumping ahead. No, no, no, this is your running track. Okay. So fluffinutter is a sandwich that is part peanut butter and part marshmallow fluff.

That's it. I did that. Yeah. It's just like Wonder Bread?

Yeah. Yeah, that's it. Seems like it'd be good on graham crackers. I'm sorry, I've heard it wrong in my whole life.

It's a fluffer nutter. F, no flutter nutter. I don't know. I have no idea what's going on.

Yeah. I'm seeing it. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. It's pretty good. It's a new England. They do that.

No, this is new to me, but I'm inspired. I'll try it. Yeah. No, the paté de guimav is not yet marshmallow fluff.

It's a forerunner to marshmallow fluff, but it's a breakier version of marshmallows and it's coming back in vogue and people are apparently making it. I have not had any yet, but I look forward to it. Really? This is fascinating.

I'm telling you, that's pretty dang fun. So the next gigantic leap forward in marshmallow technology was the middle of the 19th century when a guy named Peter Cooper and then another guy named Charles Knox figured out how to mass produce gelatin. Have you ever cooked a gelatin or read anything about gelatin and know what gelatin is? Dude, I'm about to show my ignorance.

I was thinking about this today. My kids have these little vitamins. Now when we were kids, it was Flintstone vitamins, right? Little hard candy like that.

Oh, okay. Yeah. Yeah. We all at some point almost overdosed on, you know, but the new thing is gummy vitamins for kids.

Like if you're vitamin C or whatever. So I was thinking like this is gelatin. Please forgive me. I've always thought that gelatin is some kind of derivative from like hooves or something.

You're right. Is it really? Yes, it is. I remember my grandma telling me this in the kitchen when she was showing me how to cook something.

We were making a jello. I think we were just making jello near the base in South Dakota one time. And grandma was like, you know what? This is actually made of.

And she used a bunch of choice words to describe it to really gross me out. It's like, it's not grandma's disgusting. And I asked your grandpa and I asked my grandpa and he said the same thing. I was like, no, I mean, grandpa called food.

He would make up dishes and then he'd call it stuff like mulligan guts to and it was probably a perfectly good food, but he was trying to gross us out. So I didn't believe him either. And then my mom confirmed it. No, gelatin is all the undesirable bits of unprocessed animals and he just dump it into a giant cauldron and you boil it.

You boil it until it is pulverized into liquid hair, teeth, bones, lips. I don't know. Okay. I'm reading it right now.

So I'm on Snopes fact check gelatin is made from the bones, hides and other parts of animals, including horses rating true. Holy cow. Boom, there you go. It's saying it might not be hooves, but bones and hides.

I'm looking at hooves. It's just a major. Maybe it is, dude. We are popular belief is that gelatin comes from horses, cows, hooves, craft, the maker of jello, a search that hooves do not contain the necessary collagen and therefore are not used in the production of jello brand gelatin products.

My homework says that it was used in gelatin back in the day. I have no idea if it's used in gelatin. I thought gelatin today was way more synthetic, but I don't know. I don't know, man.

Why do we do that? Well, because of the thing that you were doing when you were working at the little Debbie's place, you need that base or that additive, or I guess they call gelatin is technically a thickener. You add it to stuff that otherwise would be edible and would be useful, but it's too liquid. When you dump it into the cracks to build on your analogy, it runs through and there's no time to harden it up and take advantage of those certain cooking materials.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 11 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on October 29, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.