Skip to content
098 - Supersonic Baseball Canon episode artwork

Nov 20, 2020 1 hr 22 min

098 - Supersonic Baseball Canon

from No Dumb Questions

SPONSORED BY: RAYCON For a limited time you can get 20% off your purchase by going to https://buyraycon.com/ndq. In the unlikely event you aren't satisfied with your purchase, Raycon has a 45 day free return policy. TRY OUT LOCKDOWN AT GETLOCKDOWN.COM STUFF FROM THIS EPISODE Smarter Every Day 242 - World's Fastest Pitch - Supersonic Baseball Cannon Stuff Made Here - Explosive Bat: crushing MLB records CONNECT WITH NO DUMB QUESTIONS: Support No Dumb Questions on Patreon if that sounds good to you Discuss this episode here NDQ Subreddit Our podcast YouTube channel Our website is nodumbquestions.fm No Dumb Questions Twitter Matt's Twitter Destin's Twitter SUBSCRIBE LINKS: Subscribe on iTunes Subscribe on Android OUR YOUTUBE CHANNELS ARE ALSO FUN: Matt's YouTube Channel (The Ten Minute Bible Hour) Destin's YouTube Channel (Smarter Every Day)

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

098 - Supersonic Baseball Canon

0:00 1:22:12
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hey, I'm Destin, this is Neddam Questions, and Matt, how you doing? Things are super, and Matt and this is also no question. I never know what to do. It always throws me off when you start like that.

What? It's all just... It's formal, I'm afraid. Say hello, I think it's important to say our names occasionally.

You never know when people are going to jump in. I think you're right. So you are Destin. I'm Matt.

And we make things on YouTube and the internet you do a show called Smarter Every Day on the YouTubes. I do a thing called The Timing of Bible Hour on the YouTubes. And we're friends, and from time to time we like to get together and put your engineering brain together with my humanity's brain and talk about things that we find interesting. How was that?

That was excellent. I thought that was actually really good. It's cool. Yeah.

So to everyone who always listens, who's nickname we have affectionately dubbed as the third chair. Welcome. And to everybody who's hanging out in the first time here. I am so sorry you had to see us like this, but it gets better.

I hope. We'll see. We'll see. So we shot the supersonic baseball cannon.

And that's what you want to talk about, right? That is what I want to talk about. I want the inside scoop on how everything's going with the supersonic baseball cannon. And to be clear, I have met the supersonic baseball cannon in your garage when I was out there last time.

And I believe I was there for the first dry fire with you and David and Jeremy and Trent. Yes. And what I've seen since then is violence and destruction that you've achieved with the supersonic baseball cannon on YouTube. This is the problem with building a supersonic baseball cannon.

The reason I want to build a supersonic baseball cannon is it's the triple-vin diagram of fluid dynamics and mechanics of my love of air cannons and just engineering and things that are hard to achieve and ballistics and stuff like that. And baseball, I guess baseball was one of those. So maybe it's quadruple. But I love baseball.

I love seeing how fast I can throw something. And just the idea of a supersonic baseball cannon had to happen. But the one thing I'm struggling with on the internet, like you can communicate the sheer power of the thing. But what I cannot communicate is the noise.

I cannot describe that on the internet because it rails every microphone. Does it sound different than the dry fire that I heard? No, it's about the same. It's a little louder.

I mean, it's a lot louder. But do you remember what it sounded like? Boom, boom, boom. It sounded like that.

Oh, really? Okay, no. It sounds way different. Yeah.

No, there's like this. It's like an incredibly exaggerated sound that you get when you open a tightly sealed board game box. Yeah. And then this weird hiss and pulse that is unlike anything I've ever heard before.

So you feel it and you hear it. Yeah, you feel it in your chest. But it sounds like a branosaurus screaming in either pain or ecstasy. I don't know which one it is, but it's like, that's exactly the sound I just made.

Yeah. Why are you like this? I don't know. But it's, I don't know.

Everybody that's seen this thing fire, like in person, they just quit talking. And their mouth just opens up and they're like, what on earth? What is this? So anyway, it works.

And it's awesome. It's unbelievable power. So I saw a dry fire. And I wasn't going to go stand in front of it.

But in my brain, I was like, well, it's a dry fire. I bet you could stand 20 feet down range from it and just get blasted, like, you know, shooting the kids with the leaf blower. And you're like, whoa, that's pretty intense. But no, I think it would, I think would liquify your heart if you stood in front of it, even dry firing.

It's unbelievable power and pressure exchange. It is. It's not. It's like, if a little piece of dirt or a little rock got in there on accident, you'd have a supersonic rock being fired at you if you stood in front of it.

So we never get in front of the thing ever. No, no, no. Okay, let's reset this just a little bit here. So the supersonic baseball can.

What are the dimensions on this thing? The barrel's 20 feet long. The chamber in the back. I don't know the exact dimension.

It's like eight somewhere, six to eight feet long. It's probably about two foot in diameter. The big tank in the back. The barrel itself is the diameter of a baseball.

It was a little over two and three quarter inches. So, yeah, so we're about 20,000 over the actual size of a baseball because the threads on a baseball or the seams, I guess I should say, the seams poke up just a little bit. And so you have to be able to clear the seams. So yeah, about two and three quarter inches.

Okay. So this is a vacuum pressure powered baseball cannon. So because of that, it has to be a muzzle loader. It couldn't be a breech loader because you couldn't create a vacuum.

So you're loading this from the front with a rod, correct? Right. So we basically put a baseball down the barrel, all the 20 feet down, push it all the way in. And then we cover the outside with tape, the end of the barrel is covered with tape.

We then pull a vacuum. Literally shipping tape. Yeah, exactly. Packing tape.

And that holds it. It does. It's just one atmosphere. So we pull the vacuum.

And the reason we pull the vacuum is we want the baseball to be able to accelerate with no drag. Because the drag equation is a function of how much air is in front of the thing that's fine. And a square of the velocity. So for every 10 meters, well, it's hard to explain.

Long story short is... Keep explaining though. I think I'm tracking. So you're saying drag is a function of the air in front of it.

So you've got 20 feet of air in the barrel and then all the air that's out in front of the barrel. Right. So the ball has to cut its way through that. Exactly.

And it's also a function of the velocity. So if you double the velocity of the baseball, the drag goes up quadruple. Sure. So if my hand is in water and I'm just gently moving it through the water, I can tell there's resistance.

But not as vigorously as if I try to throw a punch through the water. The acceleration of my punch makes the drag perceptibly more pronounced. Exactly. Exactly.

Yeah. 100%. And the reason it's important to take all that air out of it is you can accelerate and you don't have to worry about the drag. So the way that baseball cannon works is in the back.

You can think of the back of the barrel. We have this big pressurized volume. And we have a rod running all the way through that pressurized volume that's touching the back of the barrel. And we just pull that rod out like we're popping the cork.

Like when we do that, all the air that's in that pressurized volume rushes straight into the barrel right into the back of the baseball and shoots it straight down that vacuum chamber. Okay. Sorry. I got another question.

I want to make sure I understand. Yeah. So the barrel is depressurized. You're creating a vacuum there to eliminate drag as a variable completely correct.

Correct. And the tank, it's pressurized. Yes. It's got hundreds of pounds of pressure in it.

Yes. Hundreds of PSI. How many pounds of pressure are you are using? We've been able to get supersonic velocities with only about 400 PSI.

Give me a context for 400 PSI. Okay. So how do I do this? So one atmosphere, like what you're sitting in right now is 14.7 pounds per square inch.

A little bit different because I'm at higher elevation than you, right? It's not much different. But yeah, I mean, it's very, very close. They're 29.9, whatever, 29.9 to millimeters or inches of mercury is I think it's out.

Okay. Yeah. That's a familiar figure because of barometric measurements. Right.

So 400 PSI is not quite 30 times as much pressure as you're in right now. So it's a lot. It's a lot of pressure. And so when you release all that air to go in behind that baseball, two things happen.

It tries to rush into that vacuum at the speed of sound. Like it goes supersonic. But not only that because there's a restriction there, it actually speeds up. We have a flange in there that'll speed it up.

It's the same reason converging diverging nozzles work on rockets. And so it can actually go faster than the speed of sound. But the trick is we're not firing just air. So it's not the speed of sound and air is the speed of sound in nitrogen, which is what we're using.

And the speed of sound and nitrogen is higher than the speed of sound in air. So the ultimate shot, which we haven't done yet, which we're going to do, is do this with helium, where we fire a baseball with helium. And we think we can easily get Mach 2 or Mach 2 and a half, maybe even Mach 3 with helium, because the speed of sound and helium is way, way, way faster. How fast does an SR-71 go?

It's like Mach 7. I don't know. You're going to get me lying. I won't say Mach 6.

Let me see. Okay. And as an 80s kid, that's the fastest thing that humans could ever conceive of. Oh, there's a rock SR-71, obviously.

SR-71 is even more awesome. Okay. So it says here it is. Mach 3 plus 2,200 miles per hour.

It's said by that by 740, 2,200. Yeah. So I feel so stupid. I said Mach 6.

That's hypervelocity. Mach 6 is the reason I confuse our hypervelocity missiles are like in the Mach 6. I was asking you to pepper you with questions and putting you under all kinds of pressure. You don't use the microphones and that kind of thing.

Don't worry about it, man. What's the muzzle velocity of an AR-15? Oh, goodness. I don't know.

I have no idea. I would guess 2,000 feet per second. I don't know. No, I guess 1,500.

The muzzle velocity of 5, 5, 6. I'm guessing 1,500, too. Yes. Because you can get an air gun in a 17 that'll shoot 1,250, but it's just such a light round that it's terribly damaging.

It's close to 2,200. I would get 2,200. Close to 3,000 feet per second. That's what it's saying here.

Seriously? Yeah. That's fast. Ouch.

Yeah. So you think you can get a baseball to move almost at the velocity of a super aerodynamic 223 rifle round? Yes. Yes.

I think that's possible. Okay. So what would the difference be in terms of the actual force, the jewels behind that tiny little rifle round versus a freaking baseball? It goes from a lot to a stupid amount.

A lot from to Death Star. Yeah. I mean, well, baseball is like half a pound. It's a lot, dude.

It's incredible. So we fired this thing. So the question was, can we stop it? Like, can we catch this thing?

And let's be honest. I just wanted to see what it would do to gloves. I just wanted to know. And so we bought this boxing dummy and we put it out in front of it.

And it was insane, dude. It just blew straight through this thing. It blew straight through the rubber boxing dummy, through the plastic mount that it was mounted to, through the backside of the plastic mount, through the back of the boxing dummy, all the way to the target, bounced off the target and came all the way back to us behind the gun. It was nuts, dude.

Wow. Yeah. So it ripped through that boxing dummy, like it wasn't even there, had a significant collision with the back plate and then came all the way back and barely stayed intact. It's just jaw dropping power, dude.

It's unbelievable. As a quick side note, I'm very sorry, but the thing that happens whenever I record a podcast with you is happening right now. And so that's just going to be part of the fun, part of the ambient soundscape that we enjoy together is my neighbor mowing the lawn. Always, always happens.

You know, as soon as he's done, your neighbor's going to fire it up. So it works. My neighbor mows the yard like 20 times a week. It feels like it's crazy, but only you don't want to get out of control.

I mean, it's growing season. The other day I went and got a tripod, set it up in the yard. And like the moment I set the tripod down, the mowercrant. And it's like, well, that's how it works.

That's how it works. So honestly, what do you think? Every third time, fourth time we turn on mics together? Yeah, easily, easily.

It's a lot. Okay. I will just roll with it. Yeah.

Okay. So imagine a red dawn scenario where the Canadians come to take over America and everybody's scrambling around and having trouble getting their things together. And the young scrappy American rebels have to find a way to fight back against their neighbors to the north. And you've just got the baseball cannon in the garage.

We have this shot where it's like, wait, guys, I have an idea. It's just so crazy. It might work. And then everybody looks over at the baseball cannon.

Do you think your baseball cannon could be functional in any way against a lightly armored vehicle? If it was like a Toyota pickup truck, yeah. Yeah. What would it do to a Toyota pickup truck?

There's one way to find out. I need to know. Please, please, please, please. Yes.

I need to know. Yeah. I think we know that it won't go through an inch and a half of armor. We know that.

We know it will go through like seven layers of leather. Well, it's not seven. It's like four layers of leather and a lot of layers of felt. And well, no, because there's leather on both sides.

You got to double. Yeah, you have to double the amount of leather. Because it went straight through a catcher's mitt into the boxing dummy. It's an incredible amount of energy, dude.

It's like we built it. We shot it and then we immediately thought, what have we done? Like I knew all the physics. I immediately thought what I'd done.

I knew the physics would work. But there's something about when they do. It's like, wow, that's exactly what I thought would happen because of math and stuff. But just to see an app.

It's not quite an upper moment, but it was definitely a wood on earth is going on. I don't know. It's really cool. I'm just very thankful to be able to do this.

It's something I wanted to know. And, you know, is this possible? And yes, it's possible. That was great.

So you have not even come close to maxing out the potential. You're using nitrogen, which is lighter than oxygen. But you have yet to trichyllium, which is significantly lighter than oxygen. Well, I'll tell you.

So the way it works is you have to do the it's nitrogen. The speed of sound and nitrogen is faster than the speed of sound in air, which is a mixture of nitrogen and oxygen carbon, all those things. So yeah, yeah, you got it. You're on it.

Go ahead. So my question is, if you are using helium, which is the ultimate destination here, right? Yeah, I'm not going to do hydrogen because of the Hennenberg. Thank you for understanding.

Yeah, exactly. But you're going to use helium in the pressurized tank. I understand that correctly. Correct.

Okay. Why will that make the ball go faster? So think of it like this. Imagine you have a fish tank right next to another fish tank and there's a little pipe between the fish tanks.

Okay. And you have a vacuum in the fish tank on your right and you have pressure in the fish tank on your left, right? I'm sorry for those fish. Yeah.

Exactly. So if you were to have this little door or a little valve in between the two and you could open it up, if you were to open it up and it had pressurized air on the left, it would do what's called effusion. It would say it's like leak over, right? Well, the way I think about it, which isn't a really good way of thinking about it, but it's just the way I think about it is those helium molecules are smaller and so they can squeeze in there faster and they can get over to the other side quicker.

Now that is imperfect and that is not accurate. The actual thing is called the sound speed equation and it's a function of the molecular weight of the molecule. But just to put it moving from the high pressure to the low pressure. Correct.

Yeah. Or just the speed of sound in a material is a function of what's called the sound. It's not the speed of sound. It's called the sound speed equation.

And depending on who you talk to, they'll say, oh, well, it's actually a function of the temperature of the gas. The sound speed equation gets complicated. Okay. Even though it's super, super simple.

Like I've talked to a aerodynamicist at the Air Force Research Labs in the Air Force Research Labs in standing in front of the super computers that used to do aerodynamic calculations. I've been in that setting and I asked this question and he's like, oh, what's actually a function of the temperature? And I was like, temperature is not even in the equation. And he's like, well, density is.

And I mean, yeah, but it's just really, really, it's a point of contention amongst a lot of people. I just don't want to even get in the fight. I don't even want to have a conversation where people, you know, so basically the way to do it. So the, I don't know, it's hard to explain, but it has to do with the density of the fluid to calculate the Mach number.

That's the easiest way to come up with it. All I'm sorry, sure. I think of these little fish tanks and I think, oh, that's a smaller molecule. It goes faster and I'm happy with that.

So the speed of sound is what 300, no, 300 meters per second? Yeah, it's about three. It depends on everything. Like here we are.

It's mid 300s. Okay. So when you, this is what I'm trying to get to. When you are talking about Mach, when you're talking about your baseball being fired relative to the speed of sound, what I'm getting confused on is, are you talking about once the ball is out in the wild and it's flight in the air?

Yes. Are you talking about barrel velocity? That's a great question. So I'm talking about once it breaks into open air, the velocity of the baseball in the working fluid, which in this case is air in the atmosphere.

So the speed of sound in air is about 343 meters per second. Okay. And so we did the math and said, oh, holy cow. I, you know, I mix units, how it feels good at the time.

You know, so like a thousand and fifty miles per hour is roughly 1.3 Mach. So, I mean, I can work in whatever units you're most comfortable in. Some people are comfortable in metrics and people are comfortable in for, for a long, for a long, for a long time. I just mentally factor of three.

That's how I was getting to around 300 meters per second. Obviously, I was off by a lot, but that's, yeah, that's how I'm doing it. But the upshot is it's crazy fast. And the problem is once you have something moving crazy fast, how does it stop?

The traditional way that things stop is slowly over time drag takes over and they reach what's called the terminal velocity and they slow down and then, you know, you can catch them at a reasonable, reasonable speed. But if you catch it on the front side before drag has had an opportunity to take effect, then you can just have an incredibly fast moving baseball that does incredible destruction. And that's what I wanted. I just wanted to see that, to be honest.

I wanted to see what it would do to a boxing dummy. I wanted to see what it would do to a stack of gloves. We shot through nine gloves. It was nuts.

This is probably one of the most free-booted videos I've uploaded. It's all over the end. Really? Oh, that doesn't surprise me at all.

I want to see what it does to a rolling Geo Metro. Yeah, that'd be awesome. I just want to know. I mean, that's recycled cans.

Really ought to go through. It's awesome. You might be able to shoot that through a Geo Metro engine block. I want to see that.

Hey, this episode of Notive Questions is brought to you by Raycon. They make fantastic earbuds that we both use a whole bunch. And because if we talk with the brand and we just, there's nicer than it talked to us, but we don't like their stuff. We don't work with them.

If we talk with the brand and we really do like their stuff, we do work with them. That means that we really like this. What do you like about Raycon Destin? There's two things.

Number one, the price point. I like the fact that if I lose my Raycon earbuds, it's not the end of the world. I've got friends that have lost some other brands and it literally upset their entire week. It's like, holy cow, that was a significant portion of the budget.

You can use them in the shop. I don't know if they're advertised like this, but this is what I do. I use them in the shop as hearing protection. Am I allowed to say that?

I don't think they say that they're hearing protection, but I use them the same way. I'm mowing them. I use them on the tractor. We're not allowed to say that, I'm sure, but I also use them in the shower to listen to podcast books, which are also not allowed to say because it's just what I do, man.

That's the truth. That's what we're going for is what we actually use these things for. I do the exact same stuff. I work on stuff.

I wear these and listen to podcasts and I can hear what I'm doing clearly over the stuff I'm working on. I take them into places where they might occasionally get exposed to water as they did while I was fishing the other day. They work great. Buddy Mine called me the other day.

This actually happened. He said, look, I'm going to tell you something so that you can say this on the MDQ during the Raycon ad because it actually happened. I was in the washing machine. He got him out of the washing machine.

He said he threw him in some rice and then he charged them up and they were good to go. Look, they're not saying you can run up to the washing machine. They're not saying any of this stuff. I'm just telling you, this is a data point.

A buddy of mine did this. Number one, it wasn't the end of the world because they're reasonably priced. Number two, the fact that they did survive anyway. That's awesome.

There's two different types that I recommend. There's the Everyday E25s and you don't have these, but I did get a pair of these. They're called the Performer E55s. Have you seen these?

Well, I can't kill my every days despite numerous mishaps. So I haven't gone to get the other ones yet, but maybe I need to give them a try. What's better about them? I like them better because of the way they fit.

They have a different mechanical form factor that will go into your ear. I have the electric blue color. I like the blue color. There's several different color issues from you.

You've got black, blue, white, red, and rose gold. I like the way they fit. It's better. And also they have a larger case that's charged with a USB-C connector.

I love it because it's the right charger that works with all my stuff. It's fantastic. The Everyday E25, you get 24 hours of charging with the little case. On the Performer, the E55, you get 36 hours.

So I'll charge these before a trip and just forget about it. It doesn't matter anymore because you know your earbuds are going to work the entire time. Yeah, well, obviously that is all good stuff and it sounds like I need to try these out at the same time. I cannot complain about the Everyday's.

I mean, how long have I had these now? It's been a better part of a year. And I cannot tell you how much abuse I've subjected them to. Clearly, I'm going to go out and thrash around in streams, fly fishing, and in inclement weather because it's just stuff I like to do.

And these have been a great companion for all of that. I can't believe I've got this much use out of them given what I've done to them. And there's no sign of them quitting at this point. So every time we talk about Raycon, I am more pleased with my Raycon's because we've got that many more miles on the tires and they're still going strong.

Okay, so this is what I would like you to try, Matt, if you don't mind. Okay. By the E55, they're the performers, what they're called, the E55, try those. I would be curious to know how you feel about the mechanical form factor between the two.

Of course, both of them come with different little ear hole adapters as well, but ear port hookups or whatever, the little rubber things that go into your ear. I've run five Ks with these things. There's no issues whatsoever, but I like the E55 better. I don't know why.

I'd be curious to see what you think by trying the E55s and their prices just as reasonable. So I mean, I think you're going to dig those. All right, right. Yeah.

Bye Raycon.com slash N.DQ. All right, I'm going to do it. Yeah, here's the deal. If you want to try this out, for a limited time, you can get 20% off by going to by Raycon.com slash N.DQ.

That's B-U-Y-R-A-Y-C-O-N as in November dot com slash N.DQ for no dumb questions. That'll get you 20% off for a limited time and I recommend the performer. Of course, you get the everyday E25s as well. Is the sound is the same?

Because I'm very, very happy with the sound on the the every days. What's the performer like? It's very rich and full and the bass is awesome. I don't know.

I haven't actually thought to compare the two. I'm just pleased across the board. I have no complaints right on. You see that button on the performer that are?

Yes. Like that's the pause button. You can stop and start music and books and stuff like that. That's great, man.

I dig it. I'm sorry, dude. I'm trying to engage, but I'm picking colors for my earbuds and I'm actually making this purchase right now. And so here, I'm just going to let you get the end of this.

I'm going to go finish buying these. Sure. Yeah. If you want to try this, it's this easy.

For a limited time, you can get 20% off by going to by Raycon.com slash N.DQ. These things make a great gift for the holiday season. If you want to check it out, I recommend the E55s, but you can also get the E25s. Just whatever works best for the gift that you're trying to give.

They get you a great set of earbuds and it supports us and we are grateful. So what's the end game? I mean, what's next that you haven't done with it yet? Are you withholding that information?

Well, I mean, the obvious thing is we have the Mad Batter, which is the extremely terrifying bat swinging device that can swing bats at hundreds of miles an hour. And the idea is to fire the supersonic baseball cannon versus the Mad Batter. I'm almost positive that the supersonic baseball cannon will overpower the Mad Batter and destroy it instantly. Am I going mad or did the word almost escape you?

Seriously? Almost? Of course it's going to win. The Mad Batter has no chance.

I'm concerned for where the pieces of the Mad Batter are going to end up. Yeah, we're seriously talking about digging a hole. We did the original Mad Batter out on a baseball field and we hit what we feel is the longest baseball, you know, 700-something feet. However, we're like, we're quickly getting up against the limits of the baseball.

So the baseball fired against a steel target destroys itself. It just goes away. But at some point in that there's an elastic collision that happens. And so there's a point at which you can recover the strain energy that you put into a baseball during a collision.

You can recover that by it bouncing off. And then you can go too far and you have a plastic deformation of the baseball and it won't recover. Do you remember going out with those cheap Tony the Tiger baseballs that you got when you saved up four proofs of purchase and mailed them in? And you go out and you take your first swing with your buddies and somebody catches the ball in the outfield and it's an egg.

Exactly. It's just a lousy baseball. Exactly. So my question for you is this.

What if you change to the projectile? Is there, I mean, a baseball is optimized for the limits of velocity that a human arm can generate. It's optimized for 60 feet, six inches from the mound to home plate. It's optimized for contact, well, originally on wood now on metal.

Is it though? Is it optimized for those things? I think it is. Yeah.

There's unbelievable science that goes into that. What makes you say it's optimized? Well, part of it is just all of the science and study that goes into how a baseball works that my team has put into understanding the physics of that. So I refer the Colorado Rockies.

They play it out to too. There's literally a purple row at Coors Field. Oh, yeah. Everybody gets home runs records there.

Well, yes, ish. So there's literally a purple row at Coors Field in downtown Denver. That's about three quarters of the way up the stadium and that is 5,280 feet right where that purple row of chairs is the rest of the chairs are green. So it's a pretty cool thing.

But the problem they have is well, one dimensionally, Coors Field is a little bit tricky. Baseball fields aren't all the same shape. And so you have some big, what's called power alleys. That's part of the issue.

But the other issue. I'm sorry. What's a power alley? I don't know what a power alley is where you hit doubles.

I hit where you arrive safely and comfortably at second base. You have a left center field power alley and a right center field power alley and a left handed hitter will tend to drive the ball with power. If you think of the diamond as 90 degrees and 45 degrees being dead center field, a left handed hitter will hit with tremendous power at about 30 degrees. A right handed hitter will hit with tremendous power at like 65 degrees.

So left center field for a right handed hitter, right center field for a left handed hitter. It's just where the bat speed maximizes in a normal swing. If you contact the ball in the right place, you're going to hit at the hardest, usually right there, most consistently. So you get a lot of doubles there and stadium designers make their fences deeper in the power alleys or else it would just be a home run fast.

So part of it's the arrangement of the field. But the two big factors at Coors Field are this. One, the air is thinner. So theoretically the ball does travel a little bit farther.

But it's not as much as people might imagine or be superstitious about imagining that the ball is just on a launching pad. It's a little bit farther. I don't remember the exact ratio on that. But the other issue, and I know this very well being a breaking ball, that curve ball, knuckle ball, slider, balls that spin and curve.

I was that kind of pitcher in high school. And I pitched every other game for my high school. I just burned through my arm. And then I went to college in Chicago, which is very humid, thick, heavy, low altitude air.

And I could not believe my first day on a mound in Chicago at 18 years old, what I could do with a baseball. It was unbelievable. I'm picking up inches on my slider. I'm like, I'm dominant.

What is going on? And so these pitchers go back and forth from altitude in Colorado and dry air in Colorado to wet air and low altitude, heavy air in other places. And where you really notice it is in the pitchers ability to make the ball unhittable. And so consequently, there's a higher rate of quality contact at Coors Field at 5,280 feet in Denver, Colorado.

And you tag on that little bonus that you get from the thin air on the ball's travel. You project that out over a sample size of 81 games. That's how many home games you play every season. And it's going to result in an uptick in offense.

So in about 2000 days, give or take a few years. I don't remember exactly the brass for the Colorado Rockies brought in some specialists, people who do the kind of stuff you do. And like, what do we do? How do we make the ball behave more like it does everywhere else so that our players can compete and we don't have this crazy lopsided home versus road record and statistical anomalies or splits between the home and the road that are so different?

And what they came up with was a cigar style humidor. And they built a humidor. I think it's maybe out in right field. I remember exactly where it is.

They built this humidor and they store with the permission of Major League Baseball, all of the baseballs in the humidor so that they are being exposed to the same kind of damp, dance air that baseballs everywhere else are aged in and exposed to. And it did result in a reduction of offensive numbers and a slight narrowing of the difference in performance in the 81 games that happen every season at home versus the 81 games that happen on the road. All of this is the same, my friend, that yes, I think the baseball is optimized to a certain extent. It has been refined.

The baseball has been altered over the years of the sport. I think the baseball has been optimized for those distances and those human limitations. And so what I'm asking you is what if you optimized a different baseball in a different way to handle the stresses you're putting on it a little better to see if you might be able to see what you're putting on it. It's better to see if you might be able to get more out of it.

Okay, so first of all, didn't know any of that and that's fascinating. But this is what I want to pull that thread a little bit when you say optimize. So there's two things that happen with a baseball. Number one, it flies through the air.

And when it flies through the air, the things that affect it in terms of drag deceleration, like the parabola that you throw a ball in, in Denver, is going to be different than a parabola you throw a ball in Huntsville, Alabama. And that's because of the drag coefficient. And the force needed drag is equal to one half times the velocity squared times the cross sectional area of the thing you're throwing times the drag coefficient and the row, the density of the area. Let me get that right.

I'm not looking. I'm trying to do this memory. Force needed drag is equal to row one half of E squared a rose density. I think that's right.

I'm just trying to do it for me. Anyway, long story short, you got to fly through the air factor in this one decelerate. But what you're talking about sounds like the collision mechanics of a baseball. The moment the ball hits a bat.

So that has to do with something called the coefficient of restitution. And the coefficient of restitution, to hand wave it a little bit, talks about the amount of energy you get out of a collision. So if you were to measure the kinetic energy going into the collision and measure the kinetic energy coming out of the collision, then they should. If it's a perfect collision, they should equal, right?

Well, okay. Let me make sure I'm understanding because if I'm not tracking, maybe not everybody else's either. So let's go with tennis. Somebody hits a serve aggressively at me and the ball is traveling in the air.

Right now, all the energy in the equation that we're concerned with is in that tennis ball. Correct? Yes. Okay.

Then that ball bounces once in the service box. So now we've got an equation that we can run there on the coefficient of restitution. All the energy of the ball hits the ground. Somehow there, the angle of impact, the consistency of the ball, the consistency of the strike surface, you're telling me there's some kind of formula, some kind of way you can figure up how much of that energy is lost on that impact or how much energy could even theoretically, I guess not be gained.

But the ball could accelerate off of that surface too, right? If it were the right kind of conditions? I don't think it could accelerate. It's only going to decelerate.

Well, I mean, why do super balls bounce higher? So let's simplify the problem. Okay, all right. Go ahead.

Simplify the problem. You're standing above a tennis court with a ball. Yep. And you drop it and you drop it from a certain height.

That's the amount of potential energy in the system. And it falls, falls, falls right before it impacts all of that potential energy, which is the mass times the gravity, 9.8 meters, 10 squared times the height. Okay. All of that is going to be converted to kinetic energy, one half in B squared, right?

Okay. The impact occurs and a collision happens. The ground doesn't move, but the ball is going to move after impact. And so the coefficient of restitution is the ratio of the relative velocity after the collision versus the relative velocity before the collision.

And so a really easy way to think about it is if it comes off of the ground, 90% of the speed of that it impacted the ground with, then your coefficient of restitution is 0.9. You with me? Okay. So the way you measure it is what comes out of it, not what is lost.

Correct. That makes sense, given the term. Okay, I'm tracking. You can do both.

I mean, you can get the math either way. So that's the coefficient of restitution. So that's a one-dimensional problem. It's going down and it's coming back up.

Okay. So now let's- Because we're assuming even though the ground does move a little bit, we're treating it as though it isn't a completely immovable surface. Yes. It's a boundary condition.

Exactly. Yeah. I mean, you're going to have a little bit of flex on like a tennis court or something, but I think I'm getting it. So think about what happens at the point of collision.

So the tennis ball is physically going to warm up, right? Some of that collision is going to be turned into heat. Some of it will be turned into sound. You know, that's energy.

That has to go somewhere. I just haven't thought of it this way. Yeah. It's actually going to heat up the ground.

Like the ground will actually get hotter. In fact, in cricket, that's one of the ways they tell if content is going to be. They tell if contact actually happens with a bat, as you can see the little warm spot on the bat. And so all these things, the energy losses go somewhere.

And so that rolls into what's called the coefficient of restitution. So that's the one-dimensional version. The two-dimensional version would be now the ball has bounced up. And out.

At a 45-degree angle. I'm going back to the example of the serve now. So the ball has cleared the net. It hits in the service box and bounces up toward the returner.

Well, hold on. Let's back up. Let's do another more complex one-dimensional analysis. Okay.

I didn't know there was one. Let's hear it. So the ball is coming straight down. It's falling from the sky and you have your tennis racket down on the ground.

And as the ball is coming down, you swing your tennis racket up straight up and you hit the ball. And so what that means is before the collision, you have the velocity of the ball moving in one direction and the velocity of the tennis racket moving in the other direction. Right? So after the collision, they're both moving.

The tennis racket is moving in the same direction. You swing it. Sure. And the ball is moving in the direction that you swing it.

And so what happens is some of the velocity of the tennis racket was taken away and it got imparted into the ball. Yes, that makes perfect sense. Yeah. There's a way to compensate for that energy loss with the elasticity of the strings or even the racket.

Well, that's what they give and rebound on contact to compensate for that energy loss. Right? That's the principle. What you're doing when you tune a racket is you're tuning the coefficient of restitution of that collision.

That's what you're doing. I'm going to say that at the tennis center. You're going to be a smart comradour dinner party. You know what I mean though?

Like you're tuning those tennis strings just like you're tuning a guitar so that it has an optimum collision. That's what you're doing. And so that's an interesting thing. So if you think about a baseball, somebody throws a baseball at you and you're doing a baseball.

You're swinging really, really hard. But the bat is way heavier than the ball. And so when they collide at the exact moment, the bat touches the ball. The bat slows down and you're taking some of that energy out of the bat and you're putting it into the ball.

But you're doing it through a squish. And when you're doing that, that squish is an elastic compression and it relaxes and that relaxation is what shoots it off of the bat. That's what's going on. Like you are, yes, you're swinging the bat way slower than the exit velocity of the ball.

Right? Because you're not swinging the bat faster than the ball comes off the bat. Right? So in our heads, contact with a baseball in real time sounds like a crack, a solid contact.

But if you slow it down, it's actually a begoing. Right? There's recoil in spring. Right, to this.

Exactly. And so all this is happening. And so what I'm learning from you, which I did not know, is that in Mile High Stadium there in Denver, they... Course field.

Course field. Excuse me. Which happens to be in Mile High. Yeah, it's tricky.

Got it. So they are tuning that elastic collision of the baseball by putting the balls in a... So are they adding humidity to the ball? Is that what they're doing?

Yes. Adding humidity. So do you know... So I'm assuming by adding humidity to the ball, this is back of the envelope swag here, I'm assuming they are reducing the rebound off the bat.

It kind of dampens the blow just a little bit. So they're adding humidity to the ball, which means it's not that they're adding mass, but it's just that they are tuning that collision. It's almost like they're dampening the collision a little bit. It'd be about loosening the strings on your tennis racket.

Is that right? Yeah. That is my intuition. That's always what my brain has told me, but I've never put actual thought into it like this.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of No Dumb Questions?

This episode is 1 hour and 22 minutes long.

When was this No Dumb Questions episode published?

This episode was published on November 20, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this No Dumb Questions episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.