Hello, welcome. I'm Uri. And I'm Rifki. And this is Talking Tachlis. Uri, what's Tachlis? Rifki, that's a great question. Thank you. Tachlis, or Tachlit, is the Hebrew slash Yiddish word for the bottom line. And that's what we're going to try to get at here in this podcast. What's the bottom line? We don't talk about people. We don't talk about faces. We don't talk about fangers. We don't talk about faces. We don't talk about fangs pertaining to you and you and you and you and you. You too, not you, but you and you. All right, sounds good. I'm excited.
Okay, well, let's get into it. Okay, let's try the first one. Two thought-provoking and controversial articles were published in the last few weeks. In the Times of Israel, Eitan Gross, a staunchly modern Orthodox high school senior, published a blistering attack on the education system from which he's about to graduate. He argues that, and I quote, Modern Orthodox teenagers can tell you who Kobe, Jay-Z, or even Shakespeare is. Even Shakespeare like that. But very few will know Rav Chaim Kenevsky or Rav Herschel Schechter. We'll know how to solve complex math equations, but wouldn't be able to read a simple Mishnah. We care about world values and neglect our own. We care more about Western morals than the true morals of the Torah. Andrew Altman is a self-described yeshivish high school senior who attends City College High School, a magnet school in Baltimore.
Writing in the forward, Andrew has only positive things to say about his academic experience, saying, Very harsh line. Though coming from two perspectives, the arguments seem to work in tandem. Eitan says the modern Orthodox landscape is doomed, with kids groomed to play basketball and earn money. Well, I'll start by saying that I was very impressed by both articles. I thought both of these boys were very thoughtful and got their point across in a very interesting way. Brave. Yeah, very brave, definitely. But talkless, I thought the Eitan Gross article was pretty much just saying...
We can be better. We're doing a good job, but our education system can be better. I think it's very hard, it seems very hard to disagree with that. And I was actually very surprised by the amount of pushback that I saw online to this article. And he says, you know, we don't know who Chaim Kanievsky and Rav Schefter are, and people were criticizing, like, oh, if you're modern Orthodox, why are you saying Rav Kanievsky? He's not modern Orthodox. And I think that's so silly, because obviously he didn't, I don't think that he meant him specifically. He meant rabbis or whatever important figures in Judaism. And yeah, I mean, I think it's very hard to disagree with somebody saying, we can be better, we can be closer to our ideals, both our secular ideals and our religious ideals. I don't think Eitan was saying, we can be better. I think he was worse than that. I think he was saying, this is broken. This is an absolute disaster. This place is a mess.
looking at it optimistically, which is, I think it's a good thing. Okay, so he's saying it's broken and therefore what? I assume he doesn't want, he doesn't regret going to Yeshiva High School. I think he's saying we can make Yeshiva High School better. It seemed to me that the implication he was making is that we need to make Yeshiva High School or modern orthodox Yeshiva High School better by cutting out the secular influences in school. It's a problem that we know so much about basketball players or musicians. I think he was saying that stuff is a distraction and instead it's a travesty that they do not, like, the fact that we can't read a simple Mishnah is...
is critical. Right. So I think what was a little bit unclear in his message, and maybe we interpret it slightly different ways, is he's saying, I interpreted it as, we need to build up and enforce the Jewish values. And you're saying, you read it more as, we need to tone down the secular and cultural influences here. Obviously, it could be a little bit of both. Right. I imagine somewhere in between. But those are very different types of endeavors. Even that's how he says the sentences, right? We care about world values and neglect their own. They know who Kobe, Jay-Z, and even Shakespeare is, but very few know. Okay, so obviously he wants us to know Rav Kanievsky and Rav Schechter.
or whoever the stand-ins for those would be. But in the first part of all of those statements, is there a value judgment there of should we or should we not? Or he's just saying, I mean, he presented as this is just what we know. But I'm asking, was he saying we shouldn't be so familiar with who Kobe is and that kind of thing? Well, and let's jump over to the other article. I thought that the Andrew Altman article, also very interesting, very brave, because he was saying something a lot more off the beaten path, especially coming from yeshivish community or background, as opposed to the Etan Gross. So right off the bat, anything he says that's going to be slightly different is going to be more controversial coming from where he's coming from. But I thought...
I had a problem with it. I don't, I think he was building somewhat of a straw person. And, you know, I'm not going to come and say I don't believe him when he says that this is working for him and everything's great. If he says that, I'll take him at his word for it. But I do know that thinking back to my own yeshiva high school experience, which for me was very positive. And I, you know, obviously going along eight-ton girl signs, it could have been better for sure. But I did, I did learn a lot. I did gain a lot. It was a very positive experience for me. I don't, I can't imagine going to public school and coming out with as strong of a Jewish identity.
and a Jewish background as I did coming out of Yeshiva High School. I don't know how that kind of kid, unless you have so much, you know... I don't know what, moxie, to be able to have that confidence. Well, it's a combination, right? I'm sure there definitely is some moxie there. Great word. But I think it's also, I mean, he grew up in the yeshivish community. He still has a lot of friends there. That's still where he is. He spends a full Shabbat, you know, in a different social situation entirely. So he might not have the same FOMO on Friday night because he's with his friends, his other friends. Well, I wonder, what if his friends are having a party on Friday night or Saturday? What if it's nearby walking distance? It's a good question. Where does he draw that line? The truth is, I feel like reading that article, I was almost wavering. I was going back and forth between feeling that same thing of like, oh, I don't know if I could have done this in high school, but also thinking, but if I had been tested that way, if I
temptations and too often we are tempted to fall you know into the thing that's easier it's more fun to go to a jay-z concert than to go to mishmar but at the same time if you're in public school you're being forced to think critically and to make choices and when you can emerge with the conviction that andrew altman clearly comes out with it is so much stronger than the conviction of someone who kind of just coasted through you know we i went to frisch and i coasted through i don't think i walked out anywhere near with either the sort of conviction that andrew altman clearly has or with the answers to some of these fundamental questions that he was clearly, you know, approached. He was the only Jew these people know. So when they ask him either philosophical questions or they ask him practical questions, he has to be able to answer things. I don't think I would have been able to answer these things. I mean, I totally agree with that. And something that he talked about a lot that he stressed, as you're saying, was the, you know, encountering all kinds of different people from different backgrounds, different religions, different philosophies. And I do see a value. It's a very American value, but I share that value.
What I was thinking when I was reading the article was, I don't know, maybe there's a way to incorporate some of that into a yeshiva education. Maybe you could have a yeshivish or a modern orthodox high school, but there could be some extracurricular activities where you're interacting with a public school, with other private schools that aren't Jewish. I could see value in that, and I can see that as a potential solution of having some of those elements of meeting other kinds of kids and even building friendships and relationships with them without being in a school with them. I don't know. I feel cynical because I think it doesn't seem like you can really get to a depth of a relationship.
with just some sort of extracurriculars. And if you could, then you're going to get the challenges. So meaning with depth comes the possibility of someone saying, hey, I have a real friendship and now I want to go to that party. I have a real friendship and now I don't feel as convinced by Judaism because these people are clearly good moral people and they're not from it all. So I'm not sure. And the flip side to that is somebody coming and saying, I don't think you can really get a Jewish education being in public school and then having a chavrisa, you know, a couple days a week after school or on Shabbos. That's not going to give you the foundational education that you need. Well, that's a different conversation. Then it's a conversation about skills versus the philosophy, right? Like he's walking out. I'm talking about the skills or the philosophy, both.
All right. And now what's topic number two? Well, topic number two is a little bit meta, which obviously I love. But I want to talk about social media, specifically the concept of oversharing. How much is too much? No such thing. In my mind, this kind of falls into two categories, maybe more. But when I look at my Facebook feed, I see people posting very political, divisive kind of opinions about issues. And on the other side, you have people posting very personal things about themselves, whether they're going through depression or an eating disorder or a divorce or infertility and things like that.
Also positive things, right? People talking about how in love they are. Or what they have for breakfast. So I'm kind of rubbed the wrong way when I see people posting such personal things. At the same time, I see the value in it, especially when it comes to, you know, talking about things that are taboo but are also very important for mental health and for communal health that people are scared to talk about by having people normalize that conversation and put it out in the open. I definitely understand the argument that would say that this is going to help a lot of people who are going through similar things, both in terms of feeling more comfortable with their situation and also having solutions to problems that they wouldn't otherwise have. I see some of these political posts that wind up having 150, 200 comments within a matter of hours like,
Don't people have jobs? Are they just sitting at their computer? And how do they see that as a productive use of their time? I mean, that's sort of how I think about it sometimes. At the same time, I'm the one reading it and benefiting from these conversations. There's that XKCD comic, I think it's XKCD, where you see it's like 3 o'clock, 4 o'clock, and someone screams, like, what are you doing? Go to bed. He's like, I can't. There's something wrong on the internet. Yeah, I mean, I think we can all relate to that kind of thinking. And, you know, just to throw one more wrench into it, you know, it's hard to draw the line sometimes between sharing your own personal...
information and sharing other people's personal information for example I've been at events I'm specifically thinking of I was at an event on Purim when things are a little bit you know crazy and somebody was live streaming at the party and I saw the video afterwards and I was in it and I didn't really like the way I looked I didn't want myself you know publicly presented to the world in that way and I wasn't asked permission if that could be posted but that because that was that person's live stream not mine I just happened to be in it like what are my rights in that situation how do you read the Dave Eggers book The Circle yes nightmares for weeks very very powerful book I didn't see the movie though I didn't see it either it looked interesting The book was so good, but it freaked me out so much that I don't think I would want to see the movie. Yeah, I mean, I don't want to talk too much about the book if people haven't read it, but it felt very sci-fi and crazy. But when you really think about it, it seems to be where we're heading. Just this world where everything is in the cloud and public and they have politicians who wear cameras. So every single one of their meetings is publicized. In the book. In the book, yeah. And once the first politician does that, everyone else who isn't doing it, it's like, what are they hiding? Exactly. And that's how our brains now work.
I'm scared by it, and we're putting this podcast out there, and I don't know what people are going to think about it, but we're sort of maybe part of the problem. But what do you think? It's interesting. I was thinking specifically about the first thing you said about the people posting constant sort of like strong political arguments and this sort of being – you and I were speaking informally last week, just a stomp conversation, and we were talking about last week was the anniversary of the Balfour Declaration. And I told you at the time that I felt like there's something wrong with me that I don't have a strong opinion about the Balfour Declaration. I don't think that I'm sort of –
educationally equipped enough to make an argument, but I also feel like we're living in this time where everyone has to have opinions. And if you don't have an opinion, then it's like, are you not thinking? What are you doing? I also find it very funny, exactly kind of what I think you're saying is, you know, it's always been the case when a big event happens in the news, you know, the president and other public figures are expected to make a statement. And now when you look at your Facebook feed, it's almost like every single person is expected to make their own statement about what they feel about the situation.
You know, sometimes it's heartfelt and it's real, but at the same time, sometimes it feels a little silly. I've heard people, you know, obviously criticizing the over-curated social media accounts, and I guess kind of towards the extreme of that attitude is I've heard people say, like, when you post something, you can never take it down, even if it's embarrassing to you, because that's your persona, that's your online thing, and by taking it down and editing your social media, you're part of the problem. And, like, that mentality, I sort of understand it, but it's kind of weird. And also what concerns me in this whole issue is, like, especially when, you know, we talked about in the previous segment about these high school kids who are writing these articles. You know, I mean, they're young and they have ideas and they have strong ideas and they're writing about it. What if in two, three years, they no longer agree with those ideas? It's out there. They can't take it back. And it's attached to their name. And that's a pretty heavy thing to have on your shoulders. So Rivki Tachlis, what do you have to say about the social media discussion?
I mean, I think it's an ongoing conversation as it is social media. The landscape is changing every year, every two years. There are new social media. People are using it different ways. The major conversation that I've been having recently and reading about recently is advertising and how we are the product and how we're being – we think that we're consumers, but really we are the ones being consumed. But there's a lot to think about there as well. But I think it's a really interesting conversation, and I'm definitely uneasy about it and yet an avid consumer. Are you recording me? Oh. I can't hear the snare.
Count me on Twitter Where do I go when I don't have a friend? Where do I go at another's day's end? Nobody loves me, somebody loves me on Twitter. I think I'm a big, big loser. Then I go to my computer, turn it on. I feel grand all because of Twitter. All right. And that wraps up our first episode of Talking Talkless. Thank you, Ari. Thank you, Rivki. That was a lot of fun. We'll see if we actually decide to post this. And if we do, hopefully we'll get better in the future. And we're looking forward to that. Should we get like an email address? Yeah, I was thinking we should start a Gmail. We'd love to hear feedback. If you guys listen and you hate it, you love it, you want to hear more of something, you want to hear less of something, email us at TalkingTalklessPodcast at gmail.com. Talkless is spelled with a C-H.
Okay, fine. So don't use that. Bye.