Skip to content
101. Carry on Trekking episode artwork

Jun 20, 2022 1 hr 31 min

101. Carry on Trekking

from Retrospection Hosted by Colin and Paul

In celebration of our 100th episode we continue with part two of our look at Star Trek: The Next Generation's pilot, Encounter at Farpoint. Along the way Paul wonders about the fish, Colin works out the secret of Troi's empathic ability, and we discuss how the holodeck works... or doesn't. Music is the opening theme by Jerry Goldsmith. You can email us at [email protected], visit the website at www.retrospectionpodcast.com. And please rate and review us wherever you download your pods.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

101. Carry on Trekking

0:00 1:31:01
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Space the final frontier These are the voyagers of the Starship Enterprise It's continuing mission to explore strange new worlds To seek out new life and new civilizations To boldly go where no one has gone before hello and welcome to part two of our Star Trek the next generation episode of retrospective Join our continuing voyage as we resume a look at the pilot episode encounter at Fairpoint My name is Colin and what the hell children are not allowed on the bridge And my name is Paul and I can't see as well as Jordi. What so far the material seems rather ordinary. Oh, it's your script Thank you, yes, yes, but a lot of working previously on Star Trek the next generation I'll pick out first days captain of the Enterprise he meets the omnipotent alien Q Who places a Montreal for the past crimes of humanity Q sets up a challenge to prove the human race has changed by dealing with a mystery A fairpoint station. Meanwhile Tasha.

Yeah, I was frozen and defrosted Riker ate an apple a commander Beverly Crusher bought some fabric and now the conclusion Oh, I would love it. We did it like that every week every time I was a two part So that would be amazing. It's better than I'm about the major Barrett when she used to do it. You remember that?

Yeah Before we continue do you want to talk about the current state of Star Trek do we have to? Well, I guess what we don't have to know there are no rules Paul There obviously to be any rules in the current state of Star Trek. I might have thought No, what's going on with it? It's less of a less of a science fiction show now and more of a fantasy show isn't that's what I was the Star Trek?

Yeah, I mean, we've got we've got things like magic crystals. We've got like second talk to planets, you know, right? There's no chain of command. No, yeah, no everyone does what they want and if someone tells them to do something.

It's like whatever I find it quite sad and upsetting that this is where we are with Star Trek because Star Trek I think you feel the same way means a lot to be Star Trek It's something that's been with me for a long time I've ever since I can remember probably of the ages six or seven I've been talking about this before that I saw Star Trek and To see it through all the highs that it went through for the original series and next generation and the movies and then Voyager And then back up with enterprise and in the middle of that we got the S9 which I didn't like at first But you talked me around and I came to love It's just it's not the show it was is it? No, and in some ways it's frustrating because the production value is everything you would have wanted Star Trek to have Oh, yeah, every episode looks like a movie doesn't it? Yeah, but scripts are just terrible and they they they just So Intense I'm not moving on. Yeah, why do we always have to go back?

Why do we always have to I mean we've had the Kelvin movies that were certainly original series And now we've got strange new worlds and we had Discovery which they kind of tried to fix by taking it forward into the far future But why can't we just have something that continues the story on from where the point where we were with the next generation? Yeah, yeah, and then they They borrow from Canon but then on the other hand they ignore Canon when they feel like it I think though like we said last time that comes down to the fact that the people writing in Star Trek now the most that they probably look into Star Trek is they watch Star Trek 2 they watch a handful of original episodes They watch a few they watch best of both worlds parts one and two Rapa car and then um they would compete the rest of it really if it can be bothered. Yeah, yeah Yeah, but it's also it feels like the writers don't even like science fiction Well, no because it's not science fiction anymore. No, they don't like science.

Give me an example. I know you've got one Well, there's that one we've with pick ad where they use a electro-broglatic charge to stop I think it's to stop the cars moving the Boston movie. Oh, yeah And then she uses the same device to stun somebody with yeah in the new season of pick out season two. Yeah But it's also the stakes like to the scene in pick ad where they say we don't don't take phases Back because it upset the timeline, but then they've all got phases.

Yeah, there's a massive Shootout towards the end of the series with phases flying everywhere So it's like not only I did not pay attention to the world of Star Trek. They're not even paying attention to what they're writing Well, I think what they need and what they're lacking now is and I said this before firm hand at the helm and as much as people like june robin re and then After him rick berman have been maligned a little bit over the years It misses those kind of people. I think Yeah, someone who just keeps check of everything. Yeah, it's almost like you could get a writer come in and write a story Right and then they pass it over to a star trek writer who knows star trek and then shapes the story to fit in with the star trek world That's what it needs and I think that's that's kind of what they always did before, isn't it with people like bran and braga?

Yeah But I think there's a certain I don't know this or a fact, but I kind of get the feeling that there's certain arrogance now They don't need that anymore. They yeah that they know better than the people out there We know we know what should be done and you're gonna like it. If you don't like it. We don't want your watch it Yeah, well solve that one Boggles the mind doesn't it because how how can you produce a show and then turn around to 50 60% of your audience and say you don't like it don't watch it.

It's not for you Yeah, it's it's a weird thing. You wouldn't get that in any other industry. You wouldn't No, it's only this one now We said they bring up a show that fans love and then they change it so much to fans hate it then complain that the fans hate it So don't don't make that show makes something different. I often wonder what State snap trek would be in now whether we would feel different about it if Someone like um, saff mccvallen had got the job to show run it which he wanted But and he didn't get it and that's why we've got the allville Yeah, which the allville has changed over the three seasons like the first Season it was supposed to be almost a parody of star trek but they've really dropped that and now it is almost like star trek And he said he said multiple times that he wanted to do star trek properly.

Yeah I mean it couldn't be any worse than what we've got now. No, that's true. Oh, well But but a lot of people like it we have to say that a lot of people do like what they're doing now They're like those have its friends. Oh seems to It could just be it's not for us.

Yep. Yep. There you go. That should be that should be that should be a catchphrase We've been saying all the top and calling It's not for us.

That's how we'd lead out. If we did anything current, that's how we'd lead it out All right, it's just it's just sad. I find it quite sad. Yeah I mean, I rewatched recently star trek raffa khan with my son and And we're rewatching the original series and he's enjoying it every second of it And he's got no desire to watch strange new worlds of discovery or And is that your influence or is it just I never well for years.

He wasn't interested in static at all and then and then one day he just said I'm not trying some statrix. Okay, where do you want to start? Oh, no, no, this is how it went George And you forgot one person who was that the co-host or the main host I would say of junior retrospective j Wait, what junior what It's a it's a podcast we do once in a blue moon about my younger aimed shows. Yeah Um, well, all I can say is um, that's all we got time for so let's move on when you feel threatened you You tend to be defensive calling me.

I'm talking about you All right. Yeah, it's like wait. What was this coming from? He's better at it than me.

Oh, all right. I have said I'm gonna replace you No, I genuinely did forget my own son. So j thank you and further of the year goes to you Not you By the way, let's just say rafakan Excellent film Is guilty though of shaping every sturtric film since then? Oh Absolutely, absolutely.

They all try and follow that template, don't they? The revenge plot the worst one is um The most obvious in is sturtric nemesis Oh, that's because it's inter darkness Yeah, inter darkness is is kind of a remake of sturtic too, isn't it? Yeah, but badly badly badly very badly But sturtic nemesis takes the template of sturtic too and tries to try to move it into the next generation And it doesn't work. Maybe you just can't catch that lightning twice in a bottle, you know, it's impossible.

Yeah, I did Before we we crack on with um, what are we doing? Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah sturtic no, sure. Um, I did hear an interesting theory the other day about why Modern Trek doesn't fit with the original series anymore Why why it looks different? You know, because strangely was supposed to be a prequel to the original series, but obviously everything looks more um From enterprise onwards everything looks more modern, doesn't it?

Yeah, I mean I should put out that I don't care about that but neither do I neither do I but it was an interesting theory So I thought I'd run it by you. Okay, so There's a there's a few people that I didn't write the name zone Um So this is not my theory. This is other people's theory on the internet that Star Trek was actually Soft rebooted all the way back at the end of first contact So so first contact happens where we all know that the story of first contact enterprise goes back in time T.S. We can't go back in time to stop the board from taking over and stopping first contact and taking over the earth So that happens The earth is a word of the fact that there were these cybernetic creatures that were foiled by people from the future Which in an episode of enterprise Archer mentions that he that the Cochrane used to talk about these cybernetic creatures that were beaten by these people from the future.

Right. So that didn't happen before in the original timeline. Yeah, got it. Yeah, so that Changed the whole development of Starfleet and the Federation they up the game They created the all the technology got improved because they got this threat out there That might change things and and that had an effect to Other races like the Klingons developed poking technology sooner than they did in the original series That's why the Romulans ended up bumping into the Federation in enterprise Whereas they weren't supposed to bump into the Federation until the original series or that kind of so it kind of all changed it I thought it was interesting theory.

I mean, it's bullshit. Yeah, it's desperate But yeah, but it kind of works if you if you keep that in your head when you watch it It kind of works. So that's why the enterprise in strangely was looks a little bit different than what we get in the original series Okay, well, there's so many surfric timelines going around now that you just don't worry about it. No, no And the JJ Abrams's static they didn't even seem to understand what a splinter timeline was All right, shall we get back to encounter a fair point?

Yes, let's let's do some decent soundtrack or is it who knows? We see the enterprise an orbit alongside the USS hood the hood separates and moves away Picker had walks onto the bridge and that's riker if his message was said bon voyage mon amis because you know he's French I thought maybe you just gave him the finger in a low raspberry out the window Oh the wind down the window we don't want to stash it Please always stand in at that window, isn't it? Yeah, just stirring out. Yeah Yeah Just carry on to the trick.

Oh, are we gonna cast it? We Oh, that's easy captive because Kenny Williams really I would have thought you said sidjay. No sidjay will be riker with me Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, paddy jakes is uh, turoy Yes, yes, uh data Charles or tree. Oh nice good car.

Yes. Tashia would be uh, perhaps yep and wolf He's a tricky one. Oh Yeah, you could I like a with a twig. Oh god I forgot the actors now.

Yeah, that'd be a great security. He keeps going off every titties Yeah, I like that um and um what about o'briene or con as he is in this I don't know who we got. Yeah, who have we got left? Oh, I know winds are davis.

Oh, yeah. All right. Yeah. Yeah.

Okay. There you go We're carrying on to the earth strain very dangerously close to a porn parody which there are many Oh, yeah, I'm sure there are not nothing at all You've been in them Um, they they pretty much knock up uh knock on the head the old french thing, don't they? You don't really hear him speaking french. I think he squirs in what episode of me.

Yeah, that's my last outpost But they kind of stuff it don't they bring it back a lot in season two of the car though I wouldn't know very enough Q appears on the view screen stop wasting time at which point waft springs into action and raises his phaser pick our chalts Lieutenant do you intend to blast a hole for the viewer? I mean that's a first question and one that would have you wondering about this guy's ability for the future I know let's make the guy should almost shot the tv the head of security Well, he does promise to do better Well, he couldn't do worse than that. Could you? This is how I uh conducted myself in all lines of work calling.

I promise I'll do better Oh, right. I first I thought he was gonna say the quick reaction, but it's like that That's the way for it calling. Yeah, I'm still waiting for his respond to things from 1987 Okay, they're eventually um, no what all right This goes back to what we said in our last episode about i think really think because i need to check the CVs of his uh staff doesn't he? Yeah, that'll come up again in a later.

All right, okay Picard says oh for this to be fair, they should be allowed to do it at their own pace q tells them that they have 24 hours Well, I've apologized it rico gives him points for acting fast. It's all a bit weird, isn't it? Yeah, well done. You need to blue a hole in the starship I like the way that Picard actually dressed him down slightly and that kind of Snotty, I know he's supposed to be French, but it's a very snotty British way, isn't it?

It's very passive aggressive of him, isn't it? It was yeah Picard tells rico that they're going to carry on as normal but they are to be damned, let's be damned for what we really are He says amato you live by I can't have him down for a long time You have We see the enterprise and hypocrites latest log entry personal logs sturdate 4 1 1 5 3.8 I've had 24 hours cure lotter just to prove ourselves 11 have now passed without incident And yet I cannot forget to choose prediction that we will face some critical test on another matter I've blocked the toilet again You never hear logs like that Cold and sick went back to bed In the red room rikers explained to pick out that all the planet has to offer is an abundance of geothermal energy And yet was able to build a base to stir fleet standards using material that cannot be created on that world Pickard seems skeptical about rico's reports of almost magical moments when objects that are fought suddenly appear And then pick out things well there's nothing threatening about a race trying to please them But rico thinks there's more to it could it be cute trying to trick them? Do you think this is a bit weird that Picard's kind of like brushing it all off? I guess I don't mind it here because he doesn't know who riker is or anything about riker But if they were doing it like six years from now and he's like going ah riker No you're like you're like no usually it's pretty straightforward It plays that like he's kind of going you know do you know the day I've had you know you're here giving me more shit I don't think so I can really count on this Yeah, did you notice that?

Did you notice on Picard's desk that we don't have data tablets yet? Those weird laptop type things that they have will spin around Oh I thought that was something that commander data was taking Data's tablets Sorry For his own designer No so he maintains that he's fully functional Oh yeah there's little blue ones you know those very well collared Yeah, you know make your time up your side Yeah, yeah I know he does Yeah they don't have those yet He's got weird sort of plastic sort of see through things that he's got on his desk Right they also don't appear to be able to make tea Because he has a kettle at one point away A teapot or something It's like oh shit it's not right we forgot about those What are they called those things that generate food and drink and stuff in the walls What are they called? What are they called? I can't remember that's why I'm acting you can't let me know I can't remember replicators Replicators there we go Maybe that was an authentic reproduction of the conversation that the writers had I really thought that's what we're doing Well it may be replicated at teapot because he wanted to build a tradition with his tea making Well then the week after you just bought our pocket Yeah, he's got like a dozen teapots Because once you do smash them and replicate them What you've got it once you've got a teapot then That's true that's true He doesn't have his fish in this episode Those are actually He's a little fish tank I often wonder what happened to those fish when that shit crashed in generations Oh you know I bothered about the hundreds of crew that were killed Just the fish I wouldn't know what happened to the fish I mean they're a price fish Shouldn't he have the same fish as the whole of like the series No but he doesn't know he didn't data keeps changing They die and they don't tell Captain Picker that he's fishing dead Oh they don't die you know what happens to them Spot that's what happens to them Oh Spot what are you doing in my red room to tell the data Nothing Why Spot so he wet Well he's been swimming in the holiday Bit like Wesley later Yeah Yeah They step out onto the bridge I pick out reveals that he's invited councilor Troy to join them on their away mission to the planet But it seems the two already know each other Troy telepathically communicates with Riker asking if he remembers what she taught him She walks towards Riker Can you still sense my thoughts?

Out loud she says pleasure Commander Riker replies likewise Counselor Picker asks ever But you two you know Met before he doesn't say like that Thus Thus right there he shows more and profitability than Troy does in the entire episode Don't know why he needs a bait as I like when he considers what's going on Yes Yeah he's bigger than that hasn't he This is just um decorating I think you're over again isn't it? Yeah I never thought about that I guess it is yeah Yep Oh yeah Is that seen in the corridor isn't it? You know when she says to him something like you never said goodbye or something Right right Ah it's just the most profound thought I've ever experienced you have for 100 episodes Geez make the most of it I'm glad I was here We get another 100 before we get to this again Oh you visibly sag their column on our side I was just making every listener that you know Altairva down loud out podcast just sighing with despair It's niche It's niche Now does Troy lose this to everything later Because I don't recall it being a thing No she doesn't use it much doesn't she? No I don't remember I think she doesn't with her mum Doesn't she in an episode in the first season Yes they don't Actually I know why she doesn't use it I'll tell you Okay you're gonna make me wait So the end of the turbo lift And Pickett says I considered him Part of my key officers to know each other's abilities Oh we do sir We do who replies Troy But telepathically to Riker she says I too can never say goodbye Now I take you back what I just said about Pickett It seems he is oblivious I mean It's a bit of Troy wasn't telepathic Just a ventiliquist A pick-out was like You know I can hear you when you do that voice right She's like no I'm only inside Riker's head I can still hear you Waff can you hear her?

Yes sir Should I face a little voice I think she could have been thinking she had this ability And then a mum told that all beta sides can do it And nobody ever explained to her it was real So they don't really have this No beta sort has this ability No no has it No That would be an interesting turn I'd like that more Yeah but that's why you don't see it later Because at some point someone tells her It would make her a more interesting character It would but you know They make a bit weird one It would work You know it would work in What? Carry on next generation Oh yeah it worked Carry on tracking sorry Yes that's about it Yeah it would work It would work in that Usually efficient time It would work in that Yeah there you go We should write this Add it to the list I mean carry on movies every right now I call it Right seven Oh yeah why not It's so many yeah It's a general day Oh keep it like I do know Jim Dale still live Oh we forgot about Jim Dale Who would he be? Who did we say was data? Charles Orchard I think Charles Orchard would make a Yeah So now you would make Jim Dale Would be Riker But then it's funnier if Sir James is Riker Plus Sir James is Riker You can still do the same thing When he ends his car Don't look sort of passing crew Bob's bull The Riker does in every episode But he'd go Whoa Maybe Jim Dale could play the bad guy Cue Yes Excellent work Yeah We've got a way we did Because we were just doing the crew You know But yeah Yeah Jim Dale's cue It all photos This episode did forget about Cue as well for a while So yeah We'll talk about that Mm-hmm Okay So the beam down to Zarn's office Pick out tells him that they need more information Before they can make recommendations to Starfleet Zarn has no objections But he is concerned about her Beta side being at the meeting Troi reveals that she has a half Beta side and can only sense strong emotions Wouldn't you want to fool Beta side other flagship of Starfleet?

You never go full Beta side Really? Did you think Pick out only realizing it now He didn't know He's like hold on You mean my Beta side is faulty Can I swap this one? Can I take you back? I've still got the receipt Actually she says something odd Here She says I'm only half Beta side My father was a Starfleet officer That's not a race That's true Because He could be any race if he's a Starfleet officer She's Beta side She's a Starfleet officer Exactly So Yeah Does she mean that he's Hubert?

I think that's what she's getting at I think that's An instance of ill thought right in It strikes me like something That they would have said in the original series In very early season one episodes Where they're still kind of trying to find their feet a little bit You know because There's that kind of Idea in the original series Isn't that all that kind of inference Where Everybody human and Starfleet And swaps like the anomaly kind of thing Because you never see any other any races on the enterprise Other than Spock That's true That's true But I guess for me I always felt Obviously that's not true But I always felt that it was the early days of Starfleet When it was original Star Trek Which now we say it's not But it always felt like Yes Yeah that was the way to make it work in your head Wasn't it? Yeah Now Zaun says he has nothing to hide Picard tells Zaun that Starfleet Is interested in building Starbase's El Swipots on He's not interested in that He doesn't want to get into the Starbase building business Riker interrupts the suggested trade Items that they need in return for architects and designers Who can show them their techniques But Zaun says his people do not like leaving their home world And his staff leads cannot accept that small weakness Then they will have to seek an alliance with somebody like Oh you know They're for Engi Suddenly Troy Sets his pain Loneliness Terrible loneliness Ah Ah Despair She said to my life 35 years ago It's amazing college Yeah Troy could tell it's not the people on the planet But something else Pick her out of Zaun What the source of this is But Zaun says no And then Gets angry They build a base Look seriously standards that cater for their every need Picard replies yes Whilst avoiding our simplest questions They get up to leave Zaun tries one last tactic The Ferengi will be very interested In a base like this Fine says Picard Let's hope they find you as tasty as the last associates Ferengi people We haven't met the Ferengi yet We don't meet them until a couple of episodes Into the first season do we I like to think that maybe because Isn't there a When they meet the Ferengi in that episode That's coming They don't know much about them do they? No No And I know where you're going I like to think this is some kind of Ferengi propaganda Or it's Picard Just trying to put the wind up Groupler a little bit The Eaf Yeah if we don't know a lot about the Ferengi You probably don't know either So I could say anything It could be But this idea of your enemy eating you Is common Yes It is The Argentinians In the Falklands War Thought that's what the Gurkers did Really? Yeah they had that fear I wonder what it is When it comes from in this then When you don't know But Well it happens in every war Like when you don't know the enemy There's this propaganda about them That you either build up yourself Or they build up to create You know to scare you basically That's a really good line isn't it?

Yes Yeah We got to a shot at the Enterprise orbit in the planet Right? We're looking for Commander Data He asks an Ensign on how to find data She sells him out to use the control panel on the side of the corridor walls Couldn't he just use his communicator? Data Where are you? Oh I'm on the Aladek Cheers mate Well There's lots of instances of Communicator usage in this that are problematic In this second half Yeah And figured it out also They don't really use the walls In other episodes that much No and they certainly don't use those weird pointy arrow things That tell him where to go What if Data was walking around But the arrows keep trying to follow him He's got left No no he's got right He's got right Quicker Pick up the pace Come on He's getting away from him He's going to get that turbo left Oh he's made it A big punching glove comes out Smack's day through the face We can't keep walking Is that officer that Riker talks to A Hobbit or is Riker just huge?

Because she looks like about three foot tall He is a tall man though isn't he Jonathan Frakes? He looks massive compared to her Yeah he is like 12 foot tall 12 foot tall Yeah at least You know that she's going on his to-do list For later Don't you know the way that he looks at Everybody is on that list Do you think in that how many seasons do we get six, seven? Of the TNG Seven Do you think he worked his way through the entire crew? Yes You do I often suspect as much as with Riker Not just crew visiting dignitaries Maybe his idol was Kirk But then again Kirk That's a fallacy that Kirk did that Trust me Riker was an idol Yeah Kirk wasn't Kirk wasn't as much as a ladies man As the myth would have you believe And certainly not like those Kelvin movie The Tragmen Right Yeah But then that's not the Kirk as it is No No and that's because that's the writers Just didn't just wicked it Yeah Kirk, Kirk, Kirk Snobber Greenwom and every week Which he didn't No No So it turns out Dator is in the holodeck As a seed of a forest and Riker steps in He's amazed So only Galaxy Class Persians are holodecks?

I guess so I read that this is something Another thing that they wanted to put into the original But they couldn't quite work out how to do that I think it'd be easy to do Just build a set I suppose I mean As a story telling the vites, holodecks are a great idea Yeah but they're also a crotch Yeah I was going to say They start off as a great idea But then they tend to get overused don't they? Yeah Yeah because you could go anywhere in it Can you explain to me how they would work? Oh certainly So why don't you eventually run into a war? Ah because the environment moves with you But Alright maybe I'm being a bit a little bit thick Yeah probably But how can the environment move with you?

You're not on a treadmill You're actually physically walking across the room That's what you're thinking Maybe the floor moves Actually I mean this episode does have a wall in it That's what I'm saying We never see that again No No I don't quite understand it Alright well done But you don't understand it No don't understand it No you're falling into the trap of what modern Star Trek writers want you to do Oh that's right don't think about it Don't think about it Don't think about it Magic crystals Magic time crystals don't think about it Yeah don't think about getting the Ad bawl out from the bomb by beaming the route Don't do that Just let it die Anyway Yeah So there's real trees in a river Riker calls out He runs across some steppie stones One of them is a bit loose And then he clambers over a hill He hears whistling Data is sat in a tree He's having trouble finishing the song Riker completes it for him Data jumps down as Riker explains The sun puzzles down on the planet that the captain needs answering He suggests I take you on the way team I'll be leading They make the way through the trees And Riker reveals that he looked up Data's record He asks if his rank is honorary Because he's a machine Data says no They graduated sturfully But as he's being a machine bawl as Riker Riker says yes a little Data puts his this down to the prejudice That humans have Now Riker's bothered that Data thinks he's superior to humans Data points out that it's a matter of fact that he is But he would gladly give it up to be human Riker smiles Nice to meet you Pinocchio Data stirs them and Riker says Chuck Ah intriguing Sated data Carving Riker's reply You are going to be an interesting companion Commander Data Um there's a few things in this thing Brent's minus playing Data like he would eventually play lore isn't he? You're not quite Worked at what he's meant to be doing Yeah Or the limitations that he's character Let's say Yes, let's say Data hasn't learned everything that he's going to learn Exactly I mean there's um When this series started there was a six issue Next generation DC comic And they are data data They didn't actually they had data losing his temper one minute And then saying he has no emotions the next at what in one issue In the six issue run jordy dies And uh data is crying So nobody kind of knew what they were doing At all with any of this Right But the other thing is it feels like they're setting up a friendship between Riker and Data But it ends up being jordy In the end, doesn't it? Well, what's also interesting is apparently This was not supposed to be played the way that Jonathan Rakes Freaks played it Oh right, go on He was supposed to be like aggressive and distrustful of data But Freaks delivered the lines in a totally different way From what the writers thought was going to happen And they were like, okay And I like the way he plays it So do I Yeah And I think if he played it the way the writers intended Don't you think it would have made you feel different towards Riker? You would have felt Yes Yeah What a dick But I assume the point was he was going to learn over time Yeah Yeah But it does feel like the setting of friendship, doesn't it?

Yeah, it does Although And they do have like Is it The episode where they Go and find themselves in a hotel Was stuck inside a hotel Season 2 the Royale Yes, that has like a data and Riker together most of the time It does, it does Although, you know, modern track would have us believe that Picard and Data were besties In an almost sort of Kirk Spock way, really weren't they? Probably that isn't it? Yeah, yeah, that's the films did that Yes, I think it started in first contact, didn't it? No, it actually no, it started in generations What?

You know when he's They're in the stellar cartography room and Data So I'd have a panic attack And Picard talking about it That's right, yeah Yeah Seven years, not a jot of that Not really No No Data explains how the holodec can seem so real by using Transporter technology After all, they convert matter to an NGB Mac back again Data shows Riker the real wall Of the deck, as you said They hear Wesley and see him crossing the stones He steps on the loose one and falls in the river Data runs over and picks Wesley up with one hand Laying ground That's all I'm saying I wonder why you shared your head Let him drown, we would never hear sir, okay? Yeah That's a die The exit of the holodec to find Picard walking past his stairs at Wesley dripping on the floor Later is sick by Wesley's mob to get a look at the bridge Where it's against standing orders Crusher reveals that her husband and Picard were friends But Wesley wants to see it from the turbo lift And she says she'll see what she can do She says it, but she's got that look that says Just shut up Doesn't she? Yeah, stop pacing I know that look well Yes Yes So all you do? You get it or give it?

Like a button? personal? On the planet Riker Tasha Deanna Jardin data being down Tasha suggested they begin by examining the underside of the station Deanna tells him that sensors did reveal some passages She suggests that Riker and her take a look But he dismisses this and tells Tasha and Jardin to go over Data and Riker will search topside Is she just looking for an excuse sir? You know Reacquaint herself with Riker Yeah, well she just wants to talk to make sure everything's all right I guess Need rather not For some reason Jardin just points And then they walk off screen It's a weird shot, isn't it?

I think it's like you know you were talking about dragging shots out Just to keep the time You know That's what they're doing here, isn't it? There's no Yeah because no one's saying anything They're just stood there Jardin just points at the hour And then they walk off screen There's no reason to just linger on that, is there? No, as soon as Data and Riker make their way to the off screen That's when you got Yeah Data finds nothing odd about the materials around them It's exactly what Staphley uses Tasha then calls using the R-term team leader Yeah that doesn't happen again, does it? No They found something interesting in the tunnels They're in a passage way directly underneath Jardin now joins in the party line Apparently you could just cut into someone else's conversation It's uh yeah this is the whole communicator thing, isn't it?

I mean people are just slapping those communicators left right and center in this in this moment, aren't they? Yeah Oh he saves the materials of these walls It's nothing they've ever seen before Riker then asks the blind guy Uh, how are you examining them? Are you implying that perhaps Jordi is uh You know, not exactly being above board with what he's talking about here? Well no it's because Jordi says I've never seen this material before Riker's like uh, how are you uh examining these?

Because you know, I wanted to throw the obvious here, mate So and then Jordi replies every way Riker's scopically, thermally, electromagnetically, none of it's familiar Riker's try, she says she's avoided opening her mind because earlier it's been so uncomfortable That's her one job Yeah the one time where it actually would be useful to actually have these powers She doesn't really want to do it Because yeah it might hurt Also, aren't they just walking around not to be a spoiler or anything But aren't they just walking around a gigantic space creature's guts at this point? Ain't us I have to say that it does look good And the the lighting and the sound effects really do give it a bit of atmosphere This whole bit in the corridor Not the aliens guts, I'm sure it looks fine I believe I believe commando we're in an aliens canal Ah, how do you work that out data? Elementary? They should have used that game to show like Holmes episode That they do later, yeah I'm not sure you'd work it in No it would have been a waste Oh, we're not, are we doing that now are we?

No we're not, no, no Or I could say is they need more information So Troy opens her mind Kane, such pain Riker others that dated himself beamed over to Troy's location And when he said he apologizes to her Pain Unhappiness Terrible, despair Riker asks, are you watching Snaretrick Pickard? Yeah I was thinking come on the script's not that bad is it She says it's no life form like this Riker's jolly again about what he could see And he says it's no material he knows They work down a car, he's like, nah I kind of like the creepiness of it all Oh yeah, it feels great It's all bit Well jolly's kind of adding to the useless crew compliment at this point now, didn't they? Well he's, well he doesn't help but Riker's asking the same question Exactly Yeah Back on the bridge Pickard hears the Terrible lift open and sees Wesley What the hell? Children are not allowed on the bridge Doctor Crusher steps out, permission to report to the captain She also points out that Wesley is technically not on the bridge as he's in the Terrible lift Your son, Pickard replies?

Yes, last during years ago when she trails off Pickard agrees to lay him on the bridge scene as you know he's already there Pickard tells him that he knew he's fiver and that he could look around But don't touch anything I knew your father Wesley, oh I've banged your mommy But we don't talk about that He did Maybe, you're fiver You think he did? Yeah Well now I don't fix it I don't know, I often wonder whether that's what you just said then about Whether they were kind of always hinting at that maybe Pickard was his real dad It's amazing they haven't done that instead so pickard, don't know Oh we've got another season, yeah, you're never there Oh well, yeah we do don't know right This is the reunion one right? Oh yes We're all gonna hobble Oh yes Oh yes I did hear that apparently Brent's find it is not playing data Well it doesn't matter he plays everyone He's everyone and he was it Which ancestor that looks like data is he going to be now? Can you know Dr what's the names?

Soon Soon, excuse me Soon, yeah I didn't like it when he did it in enterprise But I put up with it I liked it even less in Pickard Yeah, that's funny Apparently in the world of modern Star Trek All ancestors and descendants look exactly the same Don't get me started You know there's a scene in Pickard where Nunean sung when he's when he's Nunean sung Junior every year Junior Junior When his plans get foiled He pulls out a file from his drawer and he says The Khan Project Let it go Just let it go people Move on Pickard lets him sit in the captain's chair He describes some of the equipment that Wesley knows all about already A beeping sound occurs and Wesley presses a button It's a perimeter alert Pickard orders him off the bridge as Walf confirms that yes it is a perimeter alert Ship sensors have detected an unknown vessel approaching It's not the hood returning Pickard orders to the away team to beam up The ship appears on the view screen It looks like a flying saucer of a purple circle underneath And it's not returning their hails Pickard raises shields and ready as the phasers The ship approaches Pickard calls on and tells him about the vessel Zaun says no ship is due to arrive And Pickard asks him about the frangie But Zaun emits their no dealings with them It was just an empty threat The ship is larger than the Enterprise They always are, aren't they? Ship feel good bigger ships They do tend to be Yeah It's got a bit of a close encounters vibe too The ship as well doesn't it? Do do do do do do do Wow That was perfect Perfect Says If it was well to trek it, it would play the beastie boys Oh yeah, unless said about that the better Um I did like Wil Wheaton's Like Wil Wheaton's look of amazement as he was walking around the bridge Apparently that was real Did you not get out much? Well, no he's a stetric fan Yeah, yeah, oh yes we know don't we Because he tells that we can shut the story Every five seconds doesn't he?

Yeah, so what I'm saying is it wasn't good acting It was real Yeah, shit that wasn't it Yeah, give one me over Yes I always say that everyone on stetric They're acting got better Because they learned the skills and they got settled into the crew Except for one Who got worse, it's time we're not But he disappears eventually Yeah that's true Yeah So the ship fires a beam of white to the enterprise And stops, it's her scan of some kind Back in her tunnels, Diana's still trying to sense the life on She feels close to an answer of some kind Data tells her that it's something she's shielding the communicators And they can't contact the enterprise Diana says oh yeah, that's exactly the feeling I've been having You know that somebody doesn't want us communicating with the ship That's something, you know She just coasting at this point, isn't she? I gotta say I feel bad for Diana at this point Because I've been ripping out of her for the entire episode She gets better, the character does get better Oh, I don't think it's not her fault It's the writing's not very good That's what I'm saying, the character gets better when they They lose that thing, don't they? Of her sensing something in two seconds Yeah, yeah Yeah, right cos he's, come on Let's get to the surface Did you see that Jordi was looking directly into the camera As he walks off-screen, arms as if the actor can't actually see where he's going And he doesn't want to walk into the camera Well he's blind, he doesn't know what this camera's uh What are you talking about? He can't see I forget Kolev, it's real, isn't it?

Yes Yeah, he doesn't matter, he's not camera, he can't see He doesn't even know he's in Star Trek Yeah, I mean you could put Jordi in a holodeck It'd be alright, wouldn't keep himself halfway He'd never find a wall, would he? No Wanderer over days Yeah, hmm I don't like that Yeah, would you stuck in a holodeck just wandering around? It'd be amazing, wouldn't it? Ah, just the fact that you could create whatever you wanted No What'd you say?

Oh, well, I won't want to be one of the Enterprise cleaners Yeah, that is another thing, where does it go? Everywhere Yeah Uh, clean up in holodeck six And if you clean up in holodeck six If you have, so like Deep Space Nine They had the club, didn't they, where they were always going You know, with the singer and everything Remember that? You know, with James Dant Great Jazz club, oh, do I want the comedian? That's the right No, Deep Space Nine That's the end, J That's the end, J Oh, a real club Yeah, no, it was a holodeck club, wasn't it?

Run by that Singer from the 60s Play by James DARRON Why would you have a holodeck club on a station that hasn't, oh, bear Because didn't somebody made it, and they wanted it? Anyway, anyway, my point is that if you eat or drink something in the holodeck Does it just disappear inside you? Once you walk out of the holode No, it's real, data explains that it's energy converted to actual matter So some of it's real, some of it isn't It's all real But in the, okay, but in that episode, were they in the first season Were the holodeck characters walk out of the holodeck? They disappear Yeah, they can't exist outside of the holodeck So how does food and drink exist outside the holodeck inside your tummy?

Tummy? When you have a burger, as you do every day No, not every day, but it's like Can you see it in your belly? No, but I know it's there And I see it later That's interesting, like so you're saying like maybe it doesn't affect you like calories? Yeah So basically it works like you think beer works for you, right?

That's how it works, isn't it? Yeah, yeah, well you think you're in a calorie controlled diet But beer's not included because that doesn't count That's right, yeah, isn't that? So holographic food is the same as beer to you Oh, a graphic beer A holographic beer? You drink as much as you want Amazing Yeah, right, so I'm here Did you get drunk?

Would you get drunk or a holographic beer? Maybe you're only drunk in the holodeck As soon as you walk out of the holodeck, you're not drunk anymore Would you, no hangover, even Exactly, I'd be amazing, you could roll into work two seconds after you've just finished Boom, it's over Well, how would your life be different than what it is in reality, Paul? Back on the ship, Worf tells Picard that they still can't identify the avian vessel and that they aren't responding to any hails Picard orders a scan, but their signal is just bouncing off Suddenly the alien ship begins firing at the planet But not the station, just the old city Suspicious You said he liked Boris Kalloff and Frankenstein You know what he was doing? Drink good Well then Oh, it's funny you went there, I went drink Yeah, it shows where, you know, what kind of people we are, right?

Yeah Right when company find a passageway to the surface Witnessing the destruction of the old city This set looks a lot like something from TOS, doesn't it? Yeah, it's just Because of the backgrounds are very boring Yeah, it's just a red sky, isn't it? It's a lot, isn't it? Yeah, it's just kind of ruins You think they would have done like a long shot?

You know, maybe a model shot I mean, because they've done model shots, I mean, fair point stations are model shot Right, at least it's a CGI shot Well, they're using CGI now, don't they? No, it was models, yeah Right, orders Troy, yeah, and Jordi back to the enterprise While he and Dator are going to check out what's happening Not taking care of security chief, you know, maybe could be useful Uh huh No? Maybe he's not taking anybody that he's had issues with, like, you know, relationships with That's right, I'm talking about, yeah Oh, you're saying he's been there as well? Oh, yeah, I'm saying he's been there as well It's like taking the under-eyed because it's the only person Yet So do you have an interface part?

Yeah, I've heard you're fully functional We've got lots of sockets That's true, yeah Troy becomes emotional, saying that she couldn't bear it if something happened to Riker He reminds her that she's under-orders And she regains her composure and they've been back up with the others Yeah, I like it, it's like, it happens, it's done Yeah, I mean this scene would go on for a lot longer now, wouldn't it? Really the whole episode, I think, I would have tried Yeah, it would, wouldn't it? It would It would be what the show was about, actually It would be, yeah I actually used to hate this moment, you know But considering, like you said, our emotional-sturture characters get no This is nothing, is it? No, no, she's stoic It's subtle, actually, comparison, you know It's it, yeah In his office, Rockler, he's not that name, Rockler Rockler is begging enterprise for help And back on the ship, because I just ordered him turned down, doesn't he?

Yeah Do you do that to me? Do I do what to you? Turn me down Sorry, sorry, I'll come to you all in a second Picard contact her anchor Ah, that's better Ah, thank you Picard contact her anchor, and after phasing his way through a gate Weird that bit, isn't it? Because it doesn't look like that case connected to anything No, he just likes using his phaser Sorry, I've heard, yes Yeah, he's just gotta get it out, occasionally, wave it around He tells Picard that the old city has been destroyed But oddly, there's no damage at all to Firepoint Station Picard tells her anchor about the Indian ship, and Picard orders, Rockler's own brought up Yeah Picard turns to Troy for help Things must be desperate As he's concerned about being put into a difficult position regarding the Prime Directive But she's actually useful for once here And she reminds him that Singers of Bandai are in the midst of diplomatic discussions with the Federation That gives him a little bit wiggle room, doesn't it?

Didn't they make the Tamaguchi ties? Sorry, Bandai can't pull, didn't they make the Tamaguchi? When the whole Firepoint Station fell through, I mean, they had to get into other things, didn't they? So that's what they went into, okay Did you ever have one of those?

No, I never saw the point, didn't I? You just kill them, don't you? Yeah, well, it's not even like, it's just done in real graphics It's not like a little computer person, I've got a couple of... 64 Oh, you have to bring a couple of 64 ones, didn't you?

Remember a little computer person? Yes, I do, yes You play cards with him, feed him Yeah, the cassette was rubbish, the disc was horrible, the disc version was okay You fed him, you played cards with him, and you could put music on him, he would dance And he would get sick, and you'd have to make sure he was okay And if you forgot to feed him or anything, he'd die Did he die and call him? He died I'm not surprised I watched him die You watched him die, didn't you? Slowly, every day Far away from the screen where you when you watch him die Close, very close Don't know anything like that, don't like that Picard orders phasers locked onto the alien vessel When Q, do you remember Q?

Uh, alien I'm not a pittance, yes, yeah, yeah Suddenly appears, he still needs Judge Robes, and he mocks Picard calling him a savage And his voice is echoing again in this bit Wow, he's got the old reverb turned on Q says go on, use your weapons Not quite like that, but Oh, good, good, good, good Your weapons, yeah, give it a go And he points out that humans never seem to follow their own rules It's true, you never follow your own rules What rules? But Picard tells him that his order was purely precautionary Q then reminds him of all the Bandai casualties mounting up on the surface Oh yeah All that's the scared of Tamaqachi That's exactly what I'm pointing to my head as well But Picard shows him that the order to send medical teams to the surface has already been given So, you know, jog on Isn't that what he refers to as a CMO? And that's the only time that we ever hear that expression as well Which I really liked Oh, because it's like a really professional in there Like, you know, the card accused is Q of uncivilized conduct And then orders the Enterprise moved in between the alien and the planet The warff informs him that the ship control is gone Uh oh Can you imagine if that was Picard's reaction? He just does Captain, we've lost control of the ship and we're plummeting to the Earth Into the Earth, stop it Oh no, oh no Well, that's a crisis Why don't you just phaser it mate?

That seems to be your answer, doesn't it? Yeah On the planet, there has been an explosion A rychron data flat out on the ground covered in dirt Now, why did they stay there? Why did they get further away? Well, they're trying to get into getting grappler, aren't they?

He's off isn't he? Yeah, okay Yeah, okay Alright Data sits bolt upright and rychron comes too Are you undamaged? That's the rychron? Data performs a quick diagnostic and tells him Go on Well, you say quick Data says the rychron you're okay, rychron is like, yeah, yeah, I'm fine straight away Rychron says are you undamaged the data And data spent half an hour going, yeah Hold on, yep, check in everything Why does it take longer for data to work out his okay than it does for Rychron?

I think it's because it gives the impression of his machine, doesn't it? If he does a kind of like, you know, that's what it's about. It's like data, are you okay? Hold on, I have to do a self-dramastic It was the 80s Yeah, he's got a dial in Click Yeah It was all done, I don't say round to put it on the other side Yeah, I think it's there for our benefit rather than actually making any sense Yeah But he says all systems are operating And he kind of smirks as he else rychron to his feet as well, doesn't he?

He's a little bit, he's expression, he's kind of... All right Well he's superior, isn't he? Yeah, yeah, but we lose all that, don't we eventually? Takes a few episodes I think, but we eventually lose it, don't we?

Yeah Heading into Grappler's office, they find him covering under his desk He begs them to send it away Whose day? Ask Grappler, please ignorance Data believes Grappler's lack of knowledge to be unlikely as he supervises to bandized contacts with all other worlds Raika turns to leave when suddenly Grappler screams in pain as a transporter beam of some guy snatches him away on the ship, Q mocks them for not even knowing who has taken Zorn Raika wonders if it's Q at first, but trying for him to Picard that now she's sensing great satisfaction Make Jaggers on the ship Oh that'd be amazing Oh, what? Racking his lips around Yeah, yeah, doing that weird dance skills And Q refers to Picard as a dullad, don't you use me? Rasking if the sensation is coming from the same place as before Troy tells him no, this is much closer Oh Riker and Data arrive back on the bridge as Picard orders Q to either leave or finish us There's not a lot to this second half of this episode, it's just occurred to me We've had a really strong first half and there's not much to this second half, is there?

Yeah, you mean the first half that I had to do, all the detail and characterisation and dialogue and then the second half which is nothing I like it that way Why do you think you always do the first half of everything gone? Oh, I know, well it were Q agrees as long as Raika beams over to the ship and investigates Picard is reluctant to send any of his people over, but Raika replies that he wants to go and Q looks at Raika, using the E-Show's promise That's a hint at what's to come isn't it, in another episode? Yeah, yeah Raika then rails on Q telling him that haven't they proven by now that humanity is no longer a savage race But Q tells them that they must still prove that and disappears Yeah, puffer smoke What? I can't just disappear puffer smoke It damn is, doesn't it?

As Picard heads with a turbo lift, Raika asks what he will do, they can't prove they're worth to Q I'll attend to my duty To the bitter end, as Shriker, Picard smiles I see nothing so bitter about that That's a great moment, that's the best moment in the episode It is, yeah, yeah, I tend to ask you to, he's locked the toilet again Oh, in fact, that's it, he's like, he just goes, lift up, open and then they open up again slightly and he goes, ah, Tylot, Raika, I'm not sure You get more from that though, wouldn't you really? You watch, yeah, yeah You attack that Hu-Ben with his brush like Faeze it Yes, he shoots everything You've got to say, and we have said it multiple times at this point now But this is Picard, isn't it? This is the version of Picard we get now, he's not the same person Alright, he's older Ah, no, no, no, no, I think this isn't exactly Picard I think season, season three of far is Picard I think this is still early prototype Picard for me But it's still He's still too uptight and shout, he thinks he's on a Victorian sailing ship We have to yell at everybody in a shout commands Because on a sailing ship you do, because you've got a lot of noise You don't have to shout when you're in a hosted carpeted bridge So he's still got that too uptight, but it meadows a little later on Not too much, just a little You'd take it though, wouldn't you? Capoe but what you've got now Oh yeah, yeah, it's a thousand times better than what we end up with Picard goes to see Crusher and apologizes for his behaviour earlier And even prays his worst for his abilities, for that hurt Yeah, but it did But he then goes on to basically try to get a Twitter job So that he doesn't have to put up with her and her annoying kid Or was I reading that wrong?

Yeah, it's also weird that again I complained about this in Modern Trek, but it appears to go back to this as well Like wouldn't he know who his chief medical officer is? So first of all, okay, maybe she was chief medical officer before the enterprise before he came aboard, but then she said she chose that aside That's right, yeah So it's like, how does he not know who is, is that how it works? I don't ship, you don't know who your doctor is I find that really hard to believe That seems weird, right? Yeah, I think it's a You don't know who your nurse is at, you know, you're cadets, you don't care about that But you know who all your chief of staffs were, wouldn't you?

At least, yeah, you would Yeah, I think it's a contrivance for the dramatic purposes Well, the conflict, yeah But tells him finally that if she had any issues regarding Picard And her husband's death, she wouldn't have requested the job as you said He shakes her hand, welcomes her aboard, wants her something about being friends And then gets the hell out of there Yeah, he's done So Riker Yartroy and Data beam over to the alien ship Into an identical corridor to the one underneath Fairpoint Station But without any signs of power Troy then feels anger and hate directed towards the Bandai city, at least it wasn't me Oh, makes it change, don't it? He does, he does So which data starts to just comment on things that everybody already knows To which Riker tells him, don't stop, my friend Yeah So does that hint that there's gonna be some kind of relationship between the two Right And that's about you say, he's just looking to plug him later Terrible, turn of race, okay Well, I say plug because he's a machine, isn't he? Yeah It wasn't being rude, I mean Oh, he went for you It would be like plugging something in, wouldn't it? We've got sockets Alright, can we move on?

I'm... You don't want to talk about that in this whole pocket? Alright, no Riker is giving a live commentary to Picard telling him he sees no controls or read-os of any kind And Troy tells him that Grupple is just ahead They hear Grupple scream That's not true, there's a body, he's got an arms He's just a head, it's on He can't do it if she did that Sign is a head Because like, holy Christ, he's just a head Be my back, quick, but chopping bodies off No, wait, wait, wait, you can't get up to it, sorry It's a good phrase It would be quite, it would be better than this Yeah They hear Grupple screaming Full-body scream, not just ahead And find him suspended in mid-earth surrounded by a force field that seems to be torturing him Troy suddenly realizes that he's only sensing one alien presence I mean Grupple screams that he doesn't know what the alien wants Troy says he's lying Isn't Grupple technically an alien? Yeah, yeah, yes, he has an alien But she's only sensing one alien presence Well, I mean, I seem to already know who's on it She means she's sensing an alien presence other than her son She'd be clear at Troy, that's all I'm saying Wow, we really pick on her, don't we?

I was going to do something with a pick-a joke then, but I couldn't actually make it work with my head so I won't do it Yes, we do, and it's unfair And we're very naughty, and we shouldn't do it No, although we did pick on Yur quite a bit as well Well, that's even worse, that means we're just picking on the female character Do you want... Oh yeah, yeah, you are The only reason we've not picked on her in the second half is because she's got nothing to do That is true, Yur does nothing in the second half, doesn't she? No, all this stuff's in the first half And you wonder why she quit? That's true, we picked on Wolf Quite a bit Yeah That evens it, it's got a big head Yeah, it's true, it's a bumbling form Yeah, that's interesting, that changes as well, isn't it?

Yeah Too many people on the bridge, that's all I'm saying Yes, definitely Riker and Data Phaser the Force Field releasing Groppler And I like the little moment that they take to compare phasers settings before firing There's no sort of phasers to fall or something like that, they just a little look at each other's phasers and compare it before they fire Right, yeah Because you would, I mean why would you have to say like these people are professionals, aren't they? That's true, yep Groppler is released, which seems to anger the alien And on the bridge they see the pulsing lines of the ship begins to change Q reappears, now I mean I start for the uniform And he informs them that their time is up The car tries to beam his team back, but he can't even contact the transporter chief So is this O'Brien? He's still sat in the battle bridge going on, isn't he? Where is everyone?

Where'd they go again? No one told me he weren't done with this Oh well Either that or from previous evidence, he probably wouldn't have even noticed that he's alone, really He's just still sat there going to do it, but do you press the buttons and I'm flying the ship Gotta see if he gets Spotify and his consoles Yeah Yeah So he's got a new view that his people are in trouble Q smiles and sits in the captain's chair Which causes a reaction on the bridge Like a rush? Well everyone kind of jumps up like, I dare you sit in that chair Well at least sat in it For a second I kicked him off didn't anybody could sit in that chair I've sat in it You were having you? Yes Very jealous Picard orders everyone of these and asks Q for permission to get his people back And this is really well played by Patrick Stewart isn't it?

Yeah It's like again he's showing what a captain he is Because you know that he wants them to just kick you off his ship But he's doing what he needs he has to do Even going as far as telling him that he'll do whatever he says That's right Yeah He wouldn't say that to Q in the card Yeah it depends on whether he's playing Yeah Yeah I see the fight Yeah Suddenly the away team along with Grappler material lies on the bridge As Q reminds Picard of his last few words But Troy and Riker tell Picard that the agreement doesn't stand As it was the alien that returned them not Q Troy then goes on to say that it isn't a vessel But it's alive And in the background Q is trying to get Picard just a fire on the alien and I've done with it Yeah it's same like Just shoot it Fire all faces It's not like just a collating He needs to get out of the war because you know he's warping on that console He'd be like Yeah he talks to the wrong guy You're right He is Yeah Grappler also wants Picard to fire Saying that the alien was killing his people Was there a reason? Picard asks And Q points out that it's an unknown isn't that enough To which Picard replies that if he earned that uniform he's wearing He'd know that the unknown is what brings them out there This all feels so different to the explosions and bloodshed of modern trek Doesn't it? Yeah they would be punching each other at this point Oh I mean We've got Igojins We've got God knows what going on in modern trek Ever way Frontal punches we've got neck holds And if you want Roll up roll up two four on two four on Doesn't it doesn't have to I mean this is this is Gene Roblin's influence All over this isn't it? Yeah it is Yeah It reminds me a lot of the the end of the cage Ah yes okay It's all you know we need to understand what's going on Rather than just react to it Yeah Yep They then discuss the identical tunnels and why Grappler was being punished Perhaps with some wrong he's inflicted on another creature At this point Grappler blurts out that all they did was help the thing Whoops And yeah I've got a fool You know what I said I don't load I thought it was just in my head Yeah Worst villain ever Yeah Because I figured it out that the ship and Fairpoint Station are creatures That can convert energy into matter And the orders are being of energy directed at the station The ship then grows tentacles and becomes a gigantic space jellyfish So the Fairpoint Station disappears right?

And turns into Yeah What happened to all the people in the Fairpoint Station? Dead Oh Alright Maybe they evacuated it Couldn't hear that didn't see that No no I'm reading between the lines Yeah Or maybe they just ate them They're in its guts at the end of the day, aren't they? That's true That boy doesn't eat to eat and then they're ordered, do Instant absorption That sounds good, doesn't it? Sounds like a Tissue advert, but yeah It turns out that the Bandai captured one of these creatures It's mate And fed it just enough energy to keep it alive And able to do whatever the Bandai required of it Two points out that he sees neither This was too simple a puzzle And that generosity was always his weakness Yeah Yeah I'm like you But really Go on, this should be good, go on Oh I've just said generosity is my weakness I keep you You want some kind of stuff?

I didn't realise you were my cura Colin Oh Pop, pop, we're all your cura Yeah that's what we're curating to They feed the station creature and energy beam It comes alive and turns into a creature that skips off into space holding tentacles with its friend Yeah It's also a bit That's just Skips Well they could if they would They would if they could But that's the way around Oh It's also a bit of a Staff at the motion picture moment as well as well Feels like Yeah You know the whole I've both been telling you It's not new intelligence but it is to them Yeah This bit always makes me laugh though When Troy describes the feeling of great joy and gratitude I don't know what it is about the way that she delivers that line It just makes me chuckle No he's just signed to seven year contracts That's true Picard turns to Q and he basically tells him to get the hell off his ship Q agrees to go But before he finally disappears he tells Picard That he will not promise never to appear again Resuming on Picard He gives a rise smile to his crew Yeah we'll see him again I think we won't And again And again He's later and we see the enterprise still in orbit Captain's log start at 4.1.1.74.2 It was a bit too chatenorous now isn't it? It was very aggressive It was like an angry log An angry we won't let an angry log college Come on away That's true we have yes yeah The agreement for the rebuilding of Fairpoint Station has been completed Permine Structions It's a very short log entry We've just got places to go Yes And we got to the bridge with everyone at the stations Reporting ready Did you notice as well that there's a very severe lack of O'Brien in this second half It's just a bit of Todgy still it's still a battle bridge He's still on there isn't he? Yes It's a terrible thing he stayed there before he realised Better go really Well when did he first appear in the transporter in the first half? Season two Season two isn't it?

Yeah well there you go Yeah when did he make Kako? I can't remember now Yeah I don't remember that either He just appears doesn't he? Yeah at some point yeah Riker hopes that this adventure isn't the way that the missions will always go Oh no no no one smiles because I'm sure most will be much more interesting And leaning forward he whispers Let's see what's out there Engage And they warp off And many more seasons of enjoyable quality Star Trek I remember those days Colin Remember those? I do I do yeah Yeah Fun memories And that's the end of the pilot episode of Star Trek the next generation Nice so Paul what did you think of the pilot episode?

If I'm looking at this as a two-parter which we have Then it's first to say that this second half is the week and half I think Yeah The first half the introduction of a new ship a new crew new everything Which can't help but be more interesting than what's to come in the second half You have the trial You have the source of separation You got the McCoy cameo Right This I've got to talk in a space jellyfish Yeah Yeah But having said that There are still some nice little moments between the characters Particularly right from Picard They seem to settle a bit more into the roles in the second half than they did in the first half I think Um It's interesting because it's probably not filmed in that art Probably isn't but it feels like it when you watch it And the stuff in anything Corridus was good On the planet Yeah So As a whole It's very flawed in places It's a pilot And you can see that people are feeling their way into what this new Star Trek is going to be Yeah But I do think it's a much stronger pilot episode than I ever gave it credit for back in the day Um And there's no doubt whatsoever that this is 100% gene-for-all of his vision of Star Trek More so than the original series was His fingerprints are all over this Yeah How can I miss that? Oh Makes me quite sad watching it really Oh, don't cry It's crying Everyone's crying To his right without his face But Is it a hit? You know That's the question I think I'm going to say yes Because It is the episode that launched Seven seasons of good Star Trek And it sets it all up nicely So yeah, I'm going to say so here All right Where about you? Um I agree with everything you said so far Um You could tell though that it's two different stories that's been slapped together Oh, you can see that the Q thing's just just tagged onto it Yeah, oddly because you know the Q thing is what people remember and goes forwards into the series But yeah Uh Do you think that might be that nobody cares about giant space jellyfish?

I know I think we need to start voicing support for space jellyfish I think they need more people to speak up for them Do you need to start a movement? Yes, I do You heard it here first? Yeah, don't don't give them the welly Support the space jelly I like it Okay Think it's coming soon Everybody should wish to be a space jellyfish Okay Um What's that in the sky? It's a space octopi I think you have to also Give it credit for being The first new Star Trek since the original series in that It's got a lot of problems because it's exploring something brand new Every pilot that's come since then in Star Trek Whether it be Voyager DS9 Enterprise It's built from the mistakes made in this pilot Oh, yeah, yeah, I can see that So I think you have to remember that but And some of the acting's a bit hard The Anna Choice character is not very well written But again, it all seems to be because they weren't sure about the characters I don't know whether it was a rush to get it written and produced We should say shouldn't we that some we have poked fun at Troy quite a lot in this episode But it is purely down to the way it's written Yeah, yeah, it's got nothing to do with the actor No, not at all Yeah, so and of course you read that the actors didn't really know I'll have the time to develop the characters But it's funny because I don't think we'll be saying this about any other pilot These kind of defense for it Oh, no It's just Star Trek Well, no, but is it because it's Star Trek Or is it because we have such a nostalgic view of this Because there's been Star Trek pilots since this Which would have been less Understanding about it Which ones don't you like compared to this one?

Oh, you rate lower than this one The Voyager pilot, I think it's terrible Oh, you do? Mm-hmm Because oh, it's done Okay The deep space nine pilots Again, I find that top heavy as well All the good stuffs in the first half of it, I think So I think and I think you might agree with me this I surprisingly think the end surprise pilot is the best pilot And don't you think that comes from like you said that they've learned from Mistake? Yeah, yeah They've learned from Voyager Yeah, and it's a lot of the same creative team that worked on all these Star Trek series Yeah, I completely agree with you I mean, Enterprise is on a whole I think it's a show that's getting more traction and recognition now Oddly all those years later than it got at the time Yeah, it seems to be I'd take another season of Enterprise anything over what we're getting now Yeah, I agree with you I would too Yeah I wasn't necessarily talking about old pilots I was talking about modern Star Trek pilots They are Star Trek At the end of it, it is Star Trek name on it Oh, yeah, I think the discovery pilot is terrible The strange new world's one is Ira but it's very forgettable I was going to say the exact same thing about both Yeah The pick-out one I can't even remember Nope, I think I've erased it from my mind Yeah Yeah, I haven't got a clue that one was like Uh, that's it So Is the catch with Fairpoint to hit? Yeah, I think so Again, I'm like you You've got to burn behind everything that's created and that's come from it Yeah, it's a hit Is it And just to wrap it up, is it more of a hit than the cage?

Well, the cage is a failed pilot Okay, so is it more of a hit than Is it more of a hit than when No Man has gone before? I think it's more It's got more values of Star Trek than when No Man has gone before because that was made to please a studio or a network I should say So that's why it has the action sequence Yeah Is it more but when No Man has gone before it's entertaining Yeah, it's an adventure story, isn't it? Yeah And it's got William Shatter, the rip and shirt which we'll see many times in the future Yeah, that's true which you love Well, you know, William Shatter than I wouldn't like to see doing that Which you would I would have Yeah, I agree with everything that you said Alright, so there you go That's it for two-parter I'm finished off 100 episodes And now into the next 100 episodes And beyond You know what? Yeah Yeah, but yeah, let's leave it there You know what they say in Star Trek And if human adventure continues You know what they say in Star Trek?

Be me up So thank you to our Patreon supporters And don't forget, you can email us at info at RetrospectionPodcast.com You can visit the site at RetrospectionPodcast.com And you can still message us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram Please rate and review us Wherever you download the podcast Remember, half a beta side is better than no beta side at all Goodbye Bye

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Retrospection?

This episode is 1 hour and 31 minutes long.

When was this Retrospection episode published?

This episode was published on June 20, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Retrospection episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.