Skip to content
102. Psychology is overrated episode artwork

Jan 11, 2021 46 min

102. Psychology is overrated

from Education Bookcast

I endeavour to understand and explain the field of education through many disciplines, including neuroscience, cognitive science, psychology, anthropology, economics, and evolutionary biology. Over the course of this podcast's history, I have changed in my reading habits and focus across these disciplines, and in my attitude as to how useful they can be, and where they are best applied. Psychology stands out as a case in point. At first, I thought that psychology would hold all the secrets to knowing how to improve education, by revealing what motivates people, how they think, and how they learn, and showing behavioural "laws" or tendencies that explain the framework from which we should approach understanding ourselves and others. Since then, I have realised that the psychological subfield of cognitive science has profound implications for learning, but the rest of psychology has been a disappointment. Firstly, it suffers from sampling bias. Almost all those who have been tested in psychological experiments are Western university undergraduates. This introduces a cultural bias to the data, and so rather than explaining universal features of humanity (as it supposes), it actually uncovers peculiarities of Western culture. This is dramatically less useful than what I had hoped for, and is no foundation on which to build an understanding of humanity as a whole. Secondly, it has frequent replication issues. There are numerous studies which become famous and frequently cited, only to be shown down the line not to replicate, invalidating their apparently tremendous insight. One high-profile example of this is mindset research, popularised by Carol Dweck, which I mistakenly lauded again and again on this podcast, only to find out down the line that replication studies have shown it not to be such a big deal. In place of psychology, I argue that anthropology and economics are powerful fields that can bring a lot to the table. Anthropology is like psychology but with proper sampling, and economics is like psychology but with much simplified models, which are flawed but also more powerful than many people realise (myself included, until recently). Bringing these two fields in essentially says that culture matters, and we can only understand human universals by looking cross-culturally; that we "fish in water", blind to the forces that shape us all, and we can only see these with outsider's spectacles; that value is a fundamental thing that everyone seeks, and that needs elucidating; and that people more often than not behave in a way that is in line with their own desires. In the episode, I discuss all these, plus also a range of other disciplines that have appeared or will appear on the podcast. Enjoy the episode.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

102. Psychology is overrated

0:00 46:22

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

AnointedEDU Jermaine Whiteside The AnointedEDU Podcast explores the intersection of research, leadership, governance, education, artificial intelligence, and institutional innovation. Hosted by Jermaine E. Whiteside, doctoral researcher and founder of AnointedEDU, each episode translates scholarly research into practical insights for educators, ministry leaders, nonprofit executives, public-sector professionals, and organizational decision-makers. Through conference presentations, research conversations, working papers, NotebookLM discussions, and executive education, the podcast examines governance science, adaptive leadership, Faithful Intelligence, AI ethics, implementation science, institutional trust, organizational resilience, and evidence-based leadership. Whether you are leading a church, nonprofit, educational institution, business, or government organization, The AnointedEDU Podcast provides research-informed ideas designed to help leaders build resilient, ethical, Texas Hemp Coalition Podcast Texas Hemp Coalition Welcome to the Texas Hemp Coalition Podcast! This is a place where we will hear from industry experts dealing with advocacy, education and networking in the Texas hemp industry. Join the Texas Hemp Coalition at www.texashempcoalition.org. The Graduate Ishan Singh The Graduate is a college preparation podcast that is passionately committed to assisting all students, with a special focus on those from minority backgrounds, in their journey towards securing spots in the nation’s top universities. This podcast delves into not only the academic aspects of college life but also uncovers the vibrant social dynamics within it. The primary mission of The Graduate is to serve as a mentor to students, offering valuable insights on navigating the challenges of college life. The podcast covers a wide array of topics, ranging from practical guidance on tasks such as filling out the FAFSA application to interviewing students hailing from diverse colleges and discussing campus-specific topics like the best coffee spots to explore. The Graduate is dedicated to helping students realize their dreams and nurture their interests, ultimately equipping them to pursue their true callings in higher education. This podcast is a valuable resource for any student looking

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Education Bookcast?

This episode is 46 minutes long.

When was this Education Bookcast episode published?

This episode was published on January 11, 2021.

Can I download this Education Bookcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.