All right, I am Destin Sandlin. This is a podcast called No Dumb Questions, where I talk about interesting things with my buddy, Matt Whitman, how's it going, Matt? Things are super, thank you for the warm introduction, my friend. Oh, you're welcome.
This is one of my favorite types of episodes, Matt, where we go both listen to the same book on Audible. In this case, it's Getting to Yes, Negotiating Agreement Without Giving In by Roger Fisher and William Urey, or Urey. How do you say his last name? I guess I would say Urey, Urey, yeah, I'm going with that.
Okay, cool. This is part of the Harvard Negotiation Project. This particular edition was edited by Bruce Patton. I think he just basically went through and updated everything, because this is a pretty old book, and people have used this.
But this was my book. I got to select the book this time around on our little audio book episode. But what did you think? Just overall, getting to Yes, Negotiation Agreement Without Giving In.
What's your overall reaction to the book? Thank you for listening to it, by the way. Oh, great recommendation. This was a ton of fun to listen to.
It made me think about things that I don't normally think about. It confirmed some things that I already do intuitively, and it embarrassed me on a bunch of other things that I do that I guess were intuitive, but not nearly as constructive. So I would say from a, help me get better at life, and help me observe the patterns of communication better point of view, it was wonderful from a cynicism point of view. I don't know that I like the way the book made me feel.
What do you mean? The jury's still out. This conversation is going to help shape how I feel about the book. Huh.
Well, right in the introduction, they say this thing about, well, you know, we, this is the third edition or whatever, and early on we made the case 20 some years ago when we first put this book out, that everything is a negotiation. And immediately I started off on the wrong foot with them. Like, oh, it's not. Come on.
Don't be like that. That's what power brokers say. That's how people who wear ties with horizontal stripes think about the world. I know people who look at others and look at the world that way, and I don't like it.
I find it off putting. And they went on to make the case that even things that aren't a negotiation are, I don't know. I feel like the premise bastardizes human relationships a little bit, but they softened me as the book went along. And whether I entirely am prepared to agree with the premise or not, the content therein was wildly useful, very well written, loaded with rich examples, and very, very helpful.
For me, my only hang up part is the entire premise. Oh, no. Okay. That is interesting to me, because this was my book.
I chose it. And maybe this comes down to like how I look at the world because for example, there's one thing that every organism does, and that's the oodle loop thing that we described earlier, right? Observe, orient, decide, act. If you're an organism in a physical world, you have to like observe the world around you, whether that be through chemical signals or through optics with your eyes or whatever.
And then you observe the world, then you orient yourself to that. Like, oh, well, my, let's say if you're a single-celled organism, like an amoeba or something, you're like, oh, well, there is a gradient of salinity between here and there. I need to move towards that. Or there's more light on this side, I need to move.
So every organism can be boiled down to like how their actions work in the world to an oodle loop. And I find that useful. It's like factoring polynomials down to their base levels. You know, you get things down to the atomic level almost.
I find that useful myself. So when they started the book saying everything is a negotiation, I thought about that. And I was like, well, I mean, everything from where I'm going to eat for lunch. I mean, that's even an internal negotiation.
Well, hey, do I want to eat lunch? What are my alternatives? All these types of things. And if you get another person involved in that, then some type of dare I say the word compromise or agreement has to be made.
I looked at that and accepted it. And I actually agree with the premise of the book. I think it makes sense that everything you do, at some point you're going to make a decision and you're going to act on something and unless you have total accord with everybody else around you, unless you're acting in a completely solitary fashion, you have to reach some type of agreement with other people in order to do the thing. Am I wrong at that?
Maybe you might be. You might be right too. I'm still thinking about it. I genuinely am not coming to this conversation with my ultimate conclusion set in stone.
I've waited to solidify my thoughts on this until I talk with you because I knew this would be a read and I knew you'd be able to articulate it effectively. And you already are. That said, I felt like the book didn't take into account and even often poo-pooed the idea of altruism. No, I'm just going to sabotage this negotiation because I don't want to win.
I'm running a completely different equation here. It did a great job of accounting for. I need to win. It did a great job of accounting for.
Equitability is found through each side taking a stance and then figuring out each other's needs and trying to do it. But at the very end, they make the remark about, this book is not making a moral judgment. Now moral judgments might be something to factor in. And here's ways that you should maybe consider factoring that in.
But I think you can do an end run around negotiation if you do the truly selfless thing, which I wouldn't recommend all the time. I don't think that's equitable or always healthy. But I can think of situations where it isn't a negotiation and a decision is made because maybe you have already had an internal negotiation and you're like, everything about this decision is about the other person and it needs to be and I want it to be. No, I think that's the premise of the book, right?
I think a person can negotiate with another person for their own good. I mean, you know me well enough to know. Like sometimes I will go try to convince a person to do something that only benefits them. I get made fun of a lot for doing this at times because of the way I come about it.
But I think it is possible that that's the whole premise. It's principle based negotiation, not positional bargaining. That's the strongest point of the book and it's the thrust of the book and I don't take any exception to that. Well, my point is principle negotiation, like you don't have to reveal the principles upon what you're negotiating.
So for example, if the principle that I have and I'm holding to be my North Star in my, whatever, let's say you have a young person, right? And they work at a certain location and you know that young person will stay in that job until they die, you know, I'm using hyperbole here. But let's say you see a person and you're like, hey, I would like you to go to school to learn this particular skill or trade. It's not in the best interest of you to spend time to invest in that person, to get them to do that.
But if you are negotiating with them about their own time, like, hey, you know, maybe you should do this. You've done this, I know you've done this. Like I've seen you do this. Of course I have, I'm letting you spell this out.
But that was a negotiation. You have to give you my concluding point, which is, well, of course, it's just that's not the only way. Of course, you can negotiate with someone else entirely for their best interest as you perceive it and you're masterful at that. I have watched you without any credit ever help so many people in so many ways that probably won't even occur to them until well after the fact.
I love the way you craft and scheme for the benefit of others and you know full well, nobody's ever gonna see it. And I just happen to be in close enough proximity to you as a friend that I see some of them. I've seen you do it too. Yeah.
I'm not gonna take away your, you know, ethereal reward for doing good by even being specific about it. But of course that's a negotiation. I'm not arguing that. What I am arguing is that I can imagine a human interaction meant for the good of someone else that isn't a negotiation.
Not that I can't imagine one that is. Absolutely, you're absolutely right. I can just imagine stuff that isn't. I can imagine things where there aren't particularly strongly held bargaining positions or really any bargaining positions.
And just some sort of altruism happens. Help me understand. What do you mean by that? Can you give me an example?
Yes, I can give you an example. When it's the only time I've been on the receiving end of a homelessness gesture. I was poor, I was in college, I was hungry. I didn't dress like somebody who was poor or hungry.
But I was at a restaurant near the college that I went to, whoever was there could tell that I looked like a poor college kid, didn't know him, they didn't want credit, I just got a meal. And that was it. And they came over and they're like, hey, this one's on me. There was no negotiation.
They didn't need to scheme to get me to accept it or anything. I just announced I'd like to pay for your meal. And that was it. Now, if you want to go super hard and be like, well, but you could have said, no, I could that point, I think we're just deteriorating into semantics.
I think when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail. And when the thing you think about all the time is negotiation, one might make the mistake of forcing all human interaction into the categories of negotiation when the more, when the healthier, more accurate thing to do might be to say many human interactions involve negotiation. But maybe not all. Wow.
So that one word in the book turned you off at the beginning. Well, I think I'm being a little more level than that. I wouldn't say it turned me off. It's the thing that gave me pause.
Yeah, but it's fun for me to jab you with a stick when I get the opportunity. All right, you can continue to do so. It'll make this episode way more fun too. No, yes, but yes, Destin Wilson Sandlin.
That word was too much and I won't have it. Table pound. Yeah, I mean, but you could also say things like, well, in that case, when you were hungry, or you may or may not have been hungry. In that case, your batma, your best alternative to negotiate agreement was not eat.
Or you may have wanted to preserve your pride or whatever it is. I've been in situations like that as well. I mean, you can always reject it. Yeah, I probably would take that position.
OK, so will you indulge a touch of dorky philosophical talk for just a second? Bring it. Yeah, I mean, I've already described myself as an amoeba across a salinity gradient. So go ahead.
OK, that's true. I'm out. So the premise of modernism. And by modern, when we talk about philosophy, we don't mean nowism.
We mean an era that started roughly with the Protestant Reformation, 1517, and included the scientific revolution. Francis Bacon, Descartes, that crowd, the Enlightenment, Rousseau, Thomas Jefferson, that crowd, and industrialization. So 19th century up to, most people would say, that modernism dies or begins its death or goes into hospice right after World War II in the concentration camps, so discovered. In that period of time, both theologically and scientifically, everyone agreed on one premise.
We can do better. We can answer the physical and abstract mysteries and questions of the world, and humanity is improving. And this increased theological governmental scientific knowledge will only make us better. And then two World Wars happened, and then the concentration camps happened.
And then the communist gulags and all of the death from the Soviet Union and China happened, and the Americans dropped the bomb. And I know some people think that was the right call. I have hesitations about that. But you look at all of that death and chaos that it looks like our technology and progress only made us more equipped to do.
And whether it's fair or not, global attitudes shift from one of 400 years of optimism to something much more skeptical about the human proposition. Now oddly, more than ever now, people think humans are inherently good, whereas during modernism, people thought humans were inherently bad. I mean, I don't know why the modernist mind would be surprised that we would do horrible things to each other. And I don't know why the postmodern mind, the now mind, we think we wouldn't do horrible things to each other.
But that's a question for another day. That issue of the meta-narrative, the big story that explains everything is one that modernists were very concerned with. If we understand relativity, that explains everything. That explains how everything fits together.
You remember 3-2-1 contact on PBS? Contact is the reason it's why everything happens. Contact, well, that's a modernist notion of a single narrative being the explanation for all things. Religious people have these, science people have these.
Religious people have these. This was a very modernist idea. The heart of postmodernism has to do with the rejection, not of a meta-narrative, but of meta-narratives. There is not a single thing, says the postmodern mind, that explains all the things.
That may be true. People can lean whichever way they want to lean on this particular question. But what struck me about this book is that it was very modernist in saying, here is the reason the things happen. Negotiation makes the world go around.
And it's weird. I'm usually very sympathetic to modernist notions. But in this case, it sort of triggered my postmodernist skepticism. And I heard that.
And I was like, I think there are 10 other meta-narratives that we could throw out that would have just as good a claim to explaining everything as negotiation. Contact being one. So maybe that is where my hesitation comes in. So did you read it that way?
Did it feel like they were saying that negotiation is the explanation for what makes the world go around and how people work? Or do you think I'm overstating that? I think you're overstating that. I mean, basically, it's like the software that describes how two organisms interact.
That was the way I read that statement. And if you recall, the reason I picked this book is because of the article by Roger Fisher, one of the authors of this book, that was about how to prevent nuclear war by embedding the nuclear codes in the chest of a young naval officer. And the president would have to. It was a great discussion.
Yeah. And so that was the same guy that wrote this book. And so he is interested in arriving at complex creative solutions to very interesting problems. And so I did not read it anywhere close to the way you read that premise of the book.
Because to me, this is just a good way to describe everyday interactions between two people or organizations that have principles that they like to adhere to, but also want to move forward. And I would say, so our Ben diagrams hugely overlap here. I would just allow a little more wiggle room. And I would say, this is a great guide for discussing something that often, maybe even most of the time, shapes human interaction but is not the only defining aspect of human interaction.
And I am forced to reject that because of my position. And we will not move forward on this discussion anymore. See? I really like what you did there.
I'm taking an artful segue. I'm taking my position and going home. Sorry. All right.
So obviously, this is a book episode. And I think it's only appropriate to mention how we listen to the book, which also happens to be the sponsor for this episode, which is Audible. You can get a trial of Audible by going to audible.com slash in DQ or texting in DQ to 500 500. Just on your phone, you pick up a phone, create a new text message, just to the number 500 500 text and then letters in DQ and a little link will pop up on your phone.
And that's it. You're in. It's that easy. I listen to Audible all the time.
What about you, Matt? Yeah, likewise. And so does my whole family now. We burn through credits.
We're constantly getting new stuff. My kids are all powering through audio books left and right now, too. It's kind of fun that we have this shared account and I have to sift through things and I'm like, dang, the rest of my family, they are consuming audio books. They are growing.
They are being exposed to new ideas and bigger words and bigger concepts. And so first, it was just me. And now it's really become a family thing that we discuss. Yeah, I kind of like logging into my audible app.
And I just look in there and the library is huge because our little family library is just like, whoa, I didn't download that. And it's a book about the Civil War. What? What are my kids reading?
It's really, really cool. So please consider going to check it out, audible.com slash in DQ. They have this thing called the plus catalog. So you get one credit a month and you can use that credit on whatever book you want.
And there's just tons of audible titles to choose from. I have a ton of things that I listen to. But they also have this thing called the plus catalog. And if you go to the audible plus catalog, you can get any of those books at any time for free.
And they also have periodicals. They have podcasts. They have all kinds of stuff. Stories.
Audible has anything you would ever want to list to. And it's going to help you cram stuff into your brain while you're doing other things, like driving or running or working in the yard. You get to reclaim that time. It makes you even look forward to mundane things that otherwise make you sad.
You picture them on the horizon and you're like, I have to do the thing. But when you are working through an audio book that you are enjoying and that makes your mind thrive, it's amazing. At least for me, my attitude flips too. Yeah, I get to go do the thing.
I get to go, clean out and organize the garage because I'm going to power through a whole bunch more of Ready Player Two, which is what I'm listening to now that we just finished up how to get to you. Is it really? That's awesome. I just listened to a 37 hour audio book, dude.
Let me see what's it called. Making of the Atomic Bomb by Richard Rhodes. What's it about? Well, it's about this thing called the Atomic Bomb.
Oh. But what's so crazy about it is it starts you way back in 1904 and it tells you where all the scientists were and what they were researching and how it led up to this ultimate thought. Like the atomic bomb existed in a person's brain and then how it went from that one thought to actual physical reality to ultimately being employed in war and the effects it had on the people that it was used on. It's an amazing book.
The Making of the Atomic Bomb by Richard Rhodes. I loved it. But if you haven't listened to Getting to Yes, which is what this episode is about, I would highly recommend that because this is a very easy listen, I mean, it just, it goes down so smooth as you said. Well, and the two of the things that I love about the audio book presentation is one, the dude who reads it really gets the book and the way it's read underscores the principles that are being communicated.
Listening to this as an audio book will help you understand how to use it because the guy reading it illustrates it just in his tone of voice and his delivery. So that's very helpful. Yeah, the guy's name is Dennis Boots Secaris, I think is his name. He did a fantastic job on the reading performance.
The other thing I really liked about it is the spatial organization. I was able to track with the outline so beautifully. They clearly crafted this book with the audio book in mind and what that would be like for a user consuming it the way I did. I was able to keep track of where we were in the flow of thought and argument very neatly.
And so I feel like I can picture the structure of the book in my brain, which is very, very helpful. Another thing that I use on the app, because the audible app is amazing. I now have an Apple Watch for running and you can download the books to your Apple Watch. Yeah, you can just run with the watch.
You don't have to have a phone on you. It's amazing. But I use the backwards 30 second feature all the time because if there's a really deep concept that I didn't quite understand, I'll just go tap, tap, go back and I'll just that whole thought. Again, that's a really handy tool.
Or if you get distracted for a second, tap, tap, and then you get to read digest like how they discovered, what was the gain on the first nuclear reactor that happened in Chicago, that kind of stuff. You're making me think here. Everybody knows what it's like to look at a traditional bound paper book and to go on to autopilot mentally for a page or two pages. And you get to the end of that and you do the, what just happened.
And I will get caught in some kind of brain loop at times where I'll read the same text on a page four or five times and then I have to look at something else for a minute to just reset the mechanism. Because I'm not getting it. I just can't think about that page. But if I get distracted and I tap tap to go back with an audio book, that does not happen.
I get it on the next pass every time. And that had not occurred to me until you said that. Another thing you can do on the app is there's a clip feature where if there's just like a deep, deep thing where you're like, man, that was heavy. At the bottom right on the iPhone app, there's a little thing that says plus clip.
It's like putting a bookmark in a physical book. And you can just make a little note to yourself. Like for example, I can make one that says, hey, tell Matt about the story about the land when I'm making actual notes about the book getting the yes. It's amazing.
And there are your notes. You get to go back in your library and review those actual notes. And it'll play the clip for you. And then you can read what you wrote.
It's really cool. Matt, you want to say the URL one more time and just make sure the offer is very clear? Yep. You go to audible.com slash ndq or, since you're probably setting this up on a device at some point, you can just text to the number 500 500, just text to the letters ndq.
And then you're going to get your first audio book and full access to this whole plus catalog that Destin was talking about for free for 30 days. That's awesome. Thank you very much to Audible for supporting the podcast. And let's get back to negotiating about negotiating.
Okay. So that little thing I did right before the ad break there where I took my ball and went home. Yeah, I missed you. That's like what it looks like when a negotiation breaks down.
So how do you want to tackle it? Let's actually go through some of the things that went through the book if you're cool with that. Absolutely. I'm excited to.
And again, let me just make sure you understand. This book benefited me and I think it's good and I'm glad everybody read it and I'm glad I read it. Great. Wonderful.
Yeah. Okay. So don't take my pushback on the premise to be a rejection of everything we're about to discuss. It's not.
No, your feelings are valued and you have been heard. Oh, oh, wow. This had been going well. Oh, no, no, it's absolutely good.
So how would you like to go through this book? Would you like to just go? I'm sure you took notes. I listened to it twice.
Likewise. Would you like to just point by point or how do you want to go through this? I think it'd be fun to talk about specific points in our lives and we've negotiated things. I'm sure you have notes on that.
Yeah, they will come up as we go along. I'm sure. And I think that's one of the real strengths of the book is every time I was like, wait, I think I understand. But what would that look like?
For example, like, oh, hey, that was great. Thank you. Yeah, I thought that was very powerful. I got so lulled into a rhythm by the narrator and I don't think these guys read it.
I think they had somebody else read it for them. But the person who read the book sounds exactly like the kind of person who should read this book. Oh, yeah. And it made me feel so chill as I listened to all the examples.
It was like that is reasonable. The other party is reasonable. It was so neutral and calm. Even the way the reader read the book demonstrates that he understood it very deeply.
And if he'd used all kinds of inflection that tipped his hand toward which side he thought made more sense in these examples, it would erect it. So there's an artistry to the reading that really made this thing go, I think. Yeah. And I actually thought that was an interesting point that was made later in the book that sometimes when you're doing a negotiation, well, let's just start here, for example, we can go back to the positional bargaining versus the principal negotiation.
But I thought an interesting point that was made toward the end of the book was just the fact that people that negotiate face to face tend to arrive at an agreement that's more acceptable to both parties. Wasn't that something as opposed to like a phone call or texts or something like that? Just that fact alone. I knew that.
And I felt that, but like having the data just thrown at you and being like, Oh, yeah, of course. And so that made me realize if I ever wanted to negotiate something, if I can physically get there or do some kind of video chat, we're actually looking at the person in the eye, I think that fact alone was immensely powerful. I think so too. And the fact that they had done their own research, I assume they were citing themselves to put numbers on it to give you actual data.
That is so helpful to be able to visualize that a little bit. I was watching a video about trucks that do the automatic shut off at stoplights the other day. You know what I'm talking about? You pull up and your vehicle is still on, but the engine quits running to save fuel.
And dude was talking about the advantage of somebody's like, Oh, people like to turn this off. It makes them nervous, makes them feel weird. And then he looks right here, the cameras are like, don't turn it off. 90 seconds at a stoplight costs this much fuel and he holds up a little water bottle that's about one eighth, one sixth full, something like that.
And I was like, dang, really? That's like just dumping that much gas on the ground. Oh, I don't want to do that. Yeah, I'm definitely leaving that auto shut off in the on position so I can use it.
And I had the same kind of epiphany moment as they're walking through the percentages of how effective these negotiations are depending on what medium you use to communicate. I mean, it kind of swears with my experience, but you put data to it. Now I really believe it. Yeah, absolutely.
I thought that was cool. So let's do this at the beginning. Let's just talk about positional bargaining versus principal negotiation. So I'm assuming that you do the thing I do.
Like when you're in another country and you're learning the language, whether it be for me, Spanish or very poorly in German, I like to negotiate at an open air market. And it looks something like this. You walk up, you see a thing on the table, whether it's some type of, I don't know, pastry or if it's a pot or something like that, like something you want to take home to the ****. Yeah, exactly.
If it's something like that. Yeah. So let's go with your thing though. Like some sort of freshly baked bread.
Yeah, exactly. So you have the thing there and you start and you know, in Spanish, you'd say how much? And then they give you a price and you say, no, that's too expensive. How about this much?
And then you go back and forth and it takes a lot of time and you eventually meet somewhere in the middle or as you get better, they meet more towards your side or as you learn the market in the area, you learn that, oh, well, there's a guy a mile that way that sells them for a third of that. And so then you kind of understand the underpinning of the market and you can get to a much cheaper price. But the seller knows that you have to go to that mile away market to get it at that price. So there is value for them having it here.
And so there's something about that that happens. It's really interesting. It gets it to where you can learn the inflection of the language that you're working in. You've done this, right?
Africa, I assume? Yeah, well, almost everywhere I've negotiated in Africa has been in English except for Equatorial Guinea, which is more of a Spanish, Spanish, so for the most part, my negotiations on that continent have been pretty easy because we're all speaking the same language. But in Latin America or in Italy, yeah, I'm at a big disadvantage and I have to reduce all of this down to its rudimentary negotiating parts. Yeah.
And so the book makes the claim that this positional bargaining where I'm going to establish myself here, I'm going to set an anchor at one side of the number line and they're going to set an anchor at the other side of the number line. And then we're just going to like move back and forth verbally until we arrive at somewhere that we can both, you know, we span that chasm in between us. That is one way to negotiate and it's effective. Like it works, but I don't know, it lends to mistrust because if I want to quote, win, one thing I'm going to do is I'm going to anchor really low if I want to get this thing for a good price and it makes the seller anchor really high.
I actually did this. There was a URL that I'm interested in and it said, Hey, click here to make an offer. And so I made an offer for the URL. I was like, Hey, I think it's be worth like 500 bucks.
No joke. This is the exact response I got from the little web service or whatever. It's like, Hey, this is Albert. Yeah.
So you're off. So at this time we are entertained. I'm just going to read it to you. Respond to counter offer, confirm your offer.
Let's see. You don't have this URL yet. No, I do not have the URL open. I was just, I was just interested in it.
So here we go. Okay. So this is the one you were telling about. This is Destin smoking hot.
Yeah, that's the one. That's the exact one. And so this guy says, Hey, thanks for your offer. $500 at this time, we are only entertaining offers at $48,888.
And I said, the response to that is I said, Oh, well, thank you very much. The highest I would be willing to give is $2,000. And they came back like, Oh, okay. Well, thank you for leaving the lines of communication open.
You know, I will match your willingness to increase your price by my willingness to decrease my price to the very low price of $33,400 or paid over a year, $2,700 a month. You know, at this point, I'm just kind of entertained, right? I'm just like, Wow, there's a very, very deep chasm in between us. And I don't think this will be spanned in any reasonable way.
And so I was listening to this book at that moment, like when I was doing this, I'm like, Oh, wow, we are in positional bargaining right now. This is just not going to work. And I'm certainly not going to come out ahead. Okay.
So the principle negotiation that the authors of the book put forward has really opened my eyes to many different things that are possible. Like you can be creative with an agreement and stuff like that. Can you give me an example of a time in your life where somebody's wanting to get into a positional bargaining situation, but you took them to a principle based negotiation? Yes, absolutely.
But before we do, let's make sure the third chair is with us on this, because this is the thesis of the book, their whole technique that was celebrated at a couple points in the book with massive negotiating breakthroughs, some of which I'd even heard of. Those breakthroughs were credited to making this mental pivot on how you negotiate and this exact school of thought on negotiations. So this is a big deal. What is held out in this book, the thesis of the book is your run of the mill lazy normal negotiating approach is competitive.
It usually involves two anchored positions like you just described over gathering this URL and the two sides just fire back only one dimensional arguments. I want this while I want this while I want this while I want this. Well, I want this I could go this far. I could go that far.
And the book opens with an example of somebody trying to buy a pot or a brass bowl or something in an antique shop and it never even gets to resolution. And the example you can just imagine this would go on ad nauseam with both sides blustering and posturing about, well, I could never know look at the engraving. It just has too much. So they hold this out and do a good job of characterizing it as being ineffective, but also the default setting of most human negotiation, unless you think critically about it and willfully and intentionally abandon this position based bargaining and move to principle based bargaining, which looks like what?
Now, basically you figure out what the other side wants. Like if you can put yourself in the position of the other person, I mean, the trick is essentially empathy, but if you also know what you want, probably the best example in the book that I felt really characterized the whole principle negotiation thing was the example of the construction company that had really fast trucks moving up and down the streets. The people that lived in the neighborhood did not want these trucks moving up and down the streets because their children were in danger when the children would play outside. And so instead of saying, hey, I need you to stop your trucks moving up and down the street, the person that was negotiating on behalf of the neighborhood said something along the lines of, well, you have children, don't you?
You know, you open with something like that. Or does your company adhere to the OSHA safety standards that are accepted by industry? You know, they said a couple of things along those lines and it implied like, hey, this person on the other side of the table is of goodwill and they're intelligent and they want to solve the problem too, because if one of the trucks hits one of our children, I mean, that's bad for everybody, especially the child, obviously, but like that could be horrible for the company. And so that very act in itself, empathizing with the other person and one very real way to do this that I thought was very interesting.
And I've actually used this since reading the book is if you're trying to work a problem out, physically sit on the same side of the table with the person that you're trying to work this out with and look at the problem, like you have a whiteboard in front of you and say, hey, this is our problem. We're trying to figure this problem out and you write it down in some way. How can we together work on that? And so it removes that, well, this, I'm on this side of the table and that side of the table and we are clearly in conflict.
If you can remove the conflict and just get down to the principle that you're each trying to adhere to and work together on that solution, it sounds simple, but that was groundbreaking, right? Yeah. So the thesis makes a ton of sense. You have position number one is positional bargaining and that is we each pick an anchor point.
We focus on what we each want to get and then without ever considering what the other one wants to get, we just negotiate, which makes the other person the problem instead of making getting to yes, the problem. We need to get to yes together. Let's figure out how to do it. Whereas what you are describing the principal bargaining approach being it makes the other person the ally and the question before us is the problem and we're going to workshop it and see if we can figure that out.
And in order to work well with your ally, you need to understand your ally's interests as you both come out of the problem together and they need to understand yours. Is that a decent summary of what you just said? No, well, I want to modify one thing you said. So this is a specific strategy within principal negotiation.
You can engage in principal negotiation with a hostile party. You can have a principal negotiation technique with someone who is angry, for example. Sure. And capitalists can try to defeat Hitler with communists.
Yes. I mean, yes, we have huge examples of that happening, but we agreed the problem was Hitler, right? Well, I'm thinking on a much smaller level than you. I mean, you're thinking in much bigger terms than I am, but I can remember a specific meeting I was in and the individual that we were negotiating with.
This was a big contract having to do with military vehicles and putting a specific type of hardware on all these vehicles. And this individual worked at that company. I remember this individual clutching their fist and physically hitting the table and saying a thing really loud like, I don't blah, blah, blah, blah. So you are talking about the communism thing.
You're talking about Chris, Jeff. No, I'm not. You didn't have a meeting with Chris. No, no, no, this individual, this was like, you know, we were all Americans and we were all having this discussion, but this person had this thing that they were really, really mad about.
And I remember looking at the person screaming and pounding, literally pounding your fist on the table. And I remember cutting my eyes to my friend in the room and we both like kind of giggled with our eyes, if that makes any sense. And we realized like what he said just then doesn't matter. Like he may have well said, I want to smash my hand on the table because I'm angry.
He may have well said that, but in the moment we realized that we're like, okay, cool. That was just emotion that had nothing to do with anything. What matters is this? And we got back to the principal and we figured out how to turn that into a real thing.
How to turn that around. But we didn't dismiss what he was feeling. He had that feeling and there were reasons he had that feeling. And we didn't say, Hey, you're stupid calm down.
We didn't say that. We were like, yeah, Mr. X. I understand you feel that way.
So how do you think we can get to this position? You know what I mean? How do you think we can get around to this solution? And so there were other techniques in the book like that like listen to emotional outburst, just the fact that you listen to the emotional outburst and you don't interrupt the person.
That's amazing. The fact that you can not affirm what they're saying is true, but affirm the way they feel. That was interesting. That lets the other side know that they've been heard, but you don't have to agree with them.
You can let them say their thing and it costs you nothing. I thought those little tips like that were super, super powerful because that makes the people feel like they can trust you because they can because they can be vulnerable and they can tell you how they feel and it might boil down to something not going great at home. You know, they might be having a hard time at the house and this is the one thing they feel like they have control over. And if you can somehow break through that hard outer shell and get to the actual human beneath and as the book puts it separate the people from the problem and just give the person what they need, not what they're asking you for, but like figure out what they truly need, which is, Hey, I need to look powerful in front of my constituents.
You know, I need to make rent. Whatever it is. I thought that was powerful. I thought so too.
And I think you said that really well. I'm not understanding how that's different than how I characterized it. And so I think I maybe derailed you and you didn't have a chance to get to the point of distinction you wanted to make. So the only thing I was clarifying is that principled negotiation could take many forms.
It doesn't have to take the one form where you're both on the same side of the table. There was a slip of the tongue in there somewhere. I was just saying that you can also have principled negotiation with a hostile party. Sure.
Yeah. And I think you can also sit on the same side of the table as a hostile party. It's weird. Yeah, but it's disarming.
I would agree. It's also kind of fun. Well, it's such a different gesture or set of gestures. You have at your disposal when you're sitting next to the person who doesn't like you, then you have at your disposal when you're sitting across from the person who doesn't like you.
The same exact open hand gesture directed across the table feels like a four-fingered point. Whereas if you just open that to your right, just here, actually try it. You open that to your right. It feels like you're being differential.
Right. You need to. Well, my friend here makes the point. It's the same exact hand motion.
It's just whether you thrust it forward or open it to the side. Those things are subtle. You get the Marine Corps drill sergeant knife hand in one direction and then you have like this gesture of openness in the other. Yes.
Yeah. It's just like international negotiation like, Hey. No, I have actually. I've been an ambassador for the country before.
I've done that. I was a member of a group for a long time called international test operational procedures, and I top as what was called. And it was an agreement, a memorandum of understanding written in 1985 between the nations of the US, Germany, UK and France. Basically, it went like this.
Hey, we're going to test these rockets. And let's say, for example, France made some rockets and America wanted to buy them. Well, America has certain test standards and France has certain test standards and often those standards are different. For example, America might have to test the rocket down to minus 40 degrees Fahrenheit and plus 140 degrees Fahrenheit where France might want to test them only down to minus 25 C or something like that.
And so this group I was a part of. I did it for 15 years. We would meet in a different country. I hosted the meeting twice.
We would all go together twice a year and we would sit at a table and we would negotiate on how to test certain things. And we would argue for hours over the word will versus shall or may versus will. All of those things we would work out together. And we did some pretty big things.
Like I authored about five international agreements between specifically the US, the UK and Germany. It's pretty cool because at the end, there's a document that's got the nation's flags on the top and you wrote it and diplomats sign it and you're like, wow, that was interesting. You know, and it it pertains to a very specific net, noid level thing like it's a very small sliver of agreement between two countries, but you learn that the fewer people that are at the table, the easier it is to arrive in an agreement. For example, the UK didn't send diplomats for a while and France had some people out for different reasons.
The UK, you know, lacked funding for whatever reason. And so when it was just the US and Germany at the table, we had so many documents that were written because the area of the Vindigram was a little bit bigger. But our sister organization, what's called Stainag standard NATO agreements that had all of the nations of NATO in there, their agreements were so broad because there were so many cooks in the kitchen that you couldn't actually create a meaningful document. Because by the time it was something everyone would accept, the document basically meant nothing.
And so one technique that we would do is we would go meet as an ITOP group, we would negotiate this stuff. And then after we arrived at an agreement, sometimes the state and people would be like, hey, do you guys want to cover sheet the ITOP agreement? Meaning, hey, they did the hard work of coming up with agreement. And if this is good enough for the US and Germany, do we want to do it as well?
Sure. Let's put our cover page on it and let's all sign it. Whoever, whatever nation wants to ratify this, they can. But what I learned more than anything is the personal relationships with my counterpart in Germany was the most important thing, period.
Once we could trust each other, it was amazing because we could actually have super complex discussions on how do we test a laser at a test facility without shooting it into space on accident? You know, the Germans, they liked the deterministic versus the probabilistic approach, you know, and how do you test a flight termination device in a way that would be accepted by the German safety guys? So once we arrived at, hey, your name is Klaus and I'm going to go to your house and we're going to play ping pong after the meeting tonight, which happened, you're just in a completely different place. You trust each other.
And it's amazing. That's kind of like the example of the Russian diplomat and the diplomat from the UK that the book included where the Russian diplomat asked for more time. The guy from the UK balked and the Russian diplomat said, you're not understanding me. I'm asking you personally to give me more time.
And then the guy from the UK in the example in the book was like, oh, oh, I get it. And so he granted more time. And the result was a wonderful outcome for everyone. I saw that happen many, many times.
Like we would do silly things like, hey, we're going to meet for four days and on the fifth day, we're going to go on a tour of a local facility together. And then we're going to go eat at this restaurant that this guy likes. It seemed like it was a goof off day, but it was not a goof off day because that was the day I met this person's children. Or this is the day they came to my house and we shot guns together.
You know what I mean? It was amazing. It was fantastic. I remember sitting at a German guys house and he had such command of the English language.
The only word we had to look up that day was pomegranate because he didn't know how to say pomegranate in English. I was very impressed. I don't know what I'm showing. I thought it was amazing.
It was a huge, I matured a tremendous amount in the world grew for me by meeting those people, my counterparts in the UK and all that. It was such a formative thing for me. And I'm so very blessed to have had the opportunity to do that at such a young age. Hearing you tell that story and connecting the dots with how I've seen you negotiate and we've negotiated together, I've seen us do things intuitively while we are in the same room that are recommended by this book.
I've seen us do things that are not condemned as being immoral or unethical, but that just aren't like, no, that might not be the most effective. I've seen us get things right. I've seen us fumble a little bit and trying to say what we meant to say as well as we could have said it. But we've had several just little rather inconsequential negotiations.
You and I were becoming away and we're like, hey, cool, that went well. And what those all have in common is what you're describing. You learned at a young age doing these negotiations internationally. That being there was some kind of banked equity to draw on that we were able to bring to the conversation or that the other party was able to bring to the conversation.
And that banked equity is huge. See it in church, you asked, for examples, I don't know, a while back here of times that I have engaged in negotiations. I can think of a couple. One is not so much a negotiation, but just a way of thinking through or wrestling through ideas together early on in my time doing church.
I noticed that the orientation of a church sanctuary with wise versus lengthwise means something different and seems to accomplish different things. Really? Sure. The higher the church, the more vertical or long the orientation of the church itself.
I mean, think about it. When you picture a Catholic cathedral, which is an expression of Christianity that is very top down, is it wide or is it long? It's long. Meaning there's more chairs further away from the pulpit.
Yes. Whoever is speaking is on the short leg of the rectangle, not on the long leg. Now you picture your very low church bedazzled jeans, worship band, smoking lasers, kind of like very low non-denominational church. Is it longer?
Is it wide? It's wide. And sometimes it's even like an amphitheater feel where it's around the center. What does that mean?
You want people to be able to see each other. So I've been a part of multiple church building projects very early in the game. I became convinced that stuff means stuff. This was maybe my first ever life epiphany, my first ever tautology as a person who's trying to think about stuff and make sense of the world.
And this idea that everything means something, stuff means stuff, is something that started to become important to me as I went and looked at churches as a young man. I figured out really quickly the orientation of a church means something. It communicates theology. And it should.
And so if you have a Catholic church that's incredibly wide and there are exceptions, you see that every now and then, great, give it a try. It could be cool. I bet you that that Catholic church, though, is going to feel more low churchy than a traditionally oriented Catholic church. So then when I do these building projects, one of the big questions that I've encouraged my teams to think through with me is who are we theologically?
What kind of organization are we and how could the orientation of our church communicate and help our theology instead of be something that we have to work against? And so every project I've been a part of has been wide instead of long in terms of the way the orientation works. Why? Because I want to reduce the authority of the person up front, me, and I want to increase the sense of we do this as a community.
We put all of our processors on this. We can see the other half of the room as we sit and worship and participate in this stuff together. And because I wanted to give the impression that we have a problem, maybe problem is overstating it. I'm trying to use the language of this book.
And the problem is that we all suspect that there is some divinity behind all of this. There is something transcendent and profound about human existence, about existence in general, and that there's a starting point for all of this. That being a God. I know not everybody in the third chair sees it the same way as me.
I have total respect. You don't have to come at the same way as me, but I think you're understanding where I'm coming from here. And that is that's a very big question. And so should I as a 35 year old last time I worked on a building project, whatever I was, should we build the whole thing around how smart I am and how much I know in my infinite wisdom, having been a full fledged adult for 14 whole years now?
Well, no, I don't think so. I like the idea of communicating the optimism of people sincerely pursuing this are going to sit on the same side of the table and look at the question together and workshop it together. When we got to that part about principle bargaining that involves sitting on the same side of the table, I know it's not exactly a negotiation per se, but that's what it made me think of in terms of things that I've observed and tried to implement along the way. I think in many, in many ways what you're doing in that situation is far more difficult.
Like I know several pastors or community leaders, things of that nature, and the stress that they feel because they are trying to please so many people. And you'll see a pastor, if you get to know him and you talk to him, they'll say, Hey, man, I want to do this, but I can't because that'll offend this group of people or I want to do that because it'll offend that group of people. You see this play out like at schools, you see all this. So in many ways, if you ever get to the place where it's just like two people have to agree on a thing, it gets really, really easy.
But the more people you have to negotiate with, that's horrible. That's hard. But then the buy-in is off the charts. What do you mean?
Well, let's say we're having a disagreement between the congregation as a whole and the leadership team of the church, something I've never experienced, but let's say that was happening. That's pretty bad. That's a big deal. That means that the entire future of the institution is in jeopardy.
Well, let's say that we're having that disagreement and I sit down as the leader of the leadership of the church with one representative of the whole congregation who disagrees about which way we should go, and we begin to engage in negotiations. Let's say we finally come to some sort of conclusion. Is that very broad congregation going to accept what that one individual comes back and says, well, we worked it out, we did this. Well, no, that's not as likely because there are a whole lot of reasons that different people have for coming to the position that might bring them together in name, but they all got there in different ways.
And I don't think there is likely to feel like their reason for how they got there was addressed or considered if the negotiations happened behind closed doors. Plus, it's going to be very difficult for me to go back and sell that to my entire leadership team. Whereas in an institution like a church, there is some advantage in certain circumstances to putting everybody in a room and setting some ground rules for how we talk to each other and what we're doing. I've been a part of a meeting like that that I did not lead as a lower ranking, well, very low ranking pastor on staff.
The ground rules weren't put in place. The thing melted down into a Jerry Springer episode. One half of the room says something. Half of the room cheers.
The other half of the room says something. That half cheers. The other one boos. I mean, it was ugly and that church struggled after that meeting.
So I've seen it go wrong, but I've also seen leaders put down parameters for how we're going to talk to each other, how we're going to do this thing. Yes. Remember, here's the goal. Here's the objective.
The people sitting around you. Like you give the reasons first. Yes. This is what they talked about in the book.
They said you want to give your interest in reasoning first before suggesting the fixes. So they said like, Hey, we know that we want to be unified at the end of this. And we also want these things to happen, whatever it is. Like we have this problem that we need to address together.
If you agree on the ground rules before you start the negotiation, it's much more likely to turn out. Well, I'm assuming you think. Yeah, and it exposes manipulation to everyone. I mean, in that kind of setting, if there's an nefarious actor who is using flowery religious language, well, I just want to do the right thing.
And I'm concerned that some folks around here are just not taking the Bible seriously enough. Well, that sounds really righteous and holy. But if you all agree together, all sides on what we're going for as a group as a congregation and everybody's like, yep, that is what we're doing. And we have two different views for how to achieve it.
And then somebody comes out and is a bad actor and they've been a driving force and the whole thing. Everybody gets to see really quickly, Oh, well, those aren't the agreed upon goals. You have a different set of goals than everybody else on both sides. You're doing your own thing.
You're the crapster right there. It's you. And so one other advantage in this kind of big group decision making setup of patiently expressing the value of all parties and then working through the values of all parties and what we're going for is that it becomes much easier to detect the person who really is doing their own thing and isn't going for the agreed upon point of what the institution is driving at. I don't know, man.
I've let a ton of meetings and churches when they go well, it just feels incredible. And when they don't, I can tell you whose fault it is mine. I'm the one leading this negotiation. If somebody acts like a turd and I can't figure out how to steer that or make something good come out of it, it's on me.
It's not high pressure thing. It's not international trade negotiations or weapons testing or defense systems testing negotiations by any stretch of the imagination. But I think I can understand it a tiny bit of what you're talking about. Oh, but I mean, all of these principles apply whether you're talking about weapons that kill people or, you know, scripture that heals people.
Like if you're if you're a group of people working on a certain thing, all of these negotiation things apply, which is why I found this so interesting. Yeah. Can I tell you a couple of specific things that happened in my life and now looking back to you kind of what I got right and what I got wrong? Is that cool?
Yeah, let's swap a few of those. Go for it. Okay, I'll start with the first one. I was a very young man.
I did not have a tremendous amount of discretionary income coming into the family. I had to drive back and forth over two hours on the road every day. My wife was doing the same thing. We live between two cities really far away and we kind of split the difference in terms of distance and we had to have a reliable vehicle.
At the time I had a V8 truck that was just burning the gas and just burning all of our money away. And so I needed a vehicle that was smaller that would get better gas mileage. Okay. So I had two options.
I found one that was a like a 1994 escort that was kept by an engineer and he had every receipt for every oil change he'd ever made in four years. It was a four-cylinder. It was an automatic. It was a fantastic purchase to say.
But it was a four-descort. Yeah, I mean, it was the right choice looking back with my adult brain. However, that's funny is that name made sense as something you would want to call your vehicle in 1990. So the second option was a 1987 Toyota Supra with a six-cylinder with a stick shift and a little decal in the back that says turbo.